Urdu is essentially Khari Boli language which got mainly persianized, later sanskrit words were heavily added to create Manak Hindi (standard Hindi), but its essentially Khari boli , and the most popular writing in it is probably Ameer Khusro using Khari Boli, maybe he mixed some other words of other Hindi belt languages too like Braj Bhasha, Awadhi etc, i dont know. And when it went south it became Dakhani, but again its essentially is khari boli. Urdu Hindi Dakhani all are Khari Boli.
The most popular 1 langauge of Medieval India, in which so much literature is written was Braj Bhasha, no other come very close, other was Awadhi but still Braj was most popular especially in middle era of Hindi Literature, it was not Urdu. And the early desi (modern languages) starts from Apabhramsha, and then comes Avhatt, Pingal Dingal, Maithili, Khari boli, Braj , Awadhi, modern Rajasthani languages, etc and other north indian langauge family, and Urdu.
Aadab and the hand gesture was invented by Lucknowi Nawab Wajid Ali Shah. And lot of Indian culture also went outside in Iran, Arab icentral asia etc: spices, herbs, sugar, rice, our fabrics etc, our literature panchtantra, kathasaritsagar, and influenced them, chess, our mathematics sciences medicine, damascus steel, infact the famous arab numerals which are actually Indian numerals, in fact a famous musalman scholar came to india and wrote many things Al-Biruni. and muslim world also got to know our might in early years of our north western and northers kings: lalitaditya muktapida ,bappa rawal, prithviraj chauhan, maharana pratap, rana sanga, rana kumbha, shivaji, and there was this literature also in apabrahmsha language about indian king and alauddin khalji : Kanhadade Prabandha
tumlogo ka anthem persian ya Urdu (joh ki hamari bhasha hai) usmein nahi honi chahiye, par local langauge jaise most spoken punjabi, ya mixture of all ur languages mein honi chahiye, or some minority language
@@user-hq8wm8giyujcg language hamari ya tumhari kab se honay lgi . Language kisi ki property toh nhi hoti. Aur jahan tak Urdu ki baat hai toh last 200 years mein Urdu literature mein sab se zyada kaam Punjab mein hua hai
@@sam-239-. Haan haan bhai japani bhasha bhi tumhari bhasha hai japani logo ko nahi. Samurai toh tumhare purwaj the na. Jaise arab persian turki tumhare purwaj the
Ameer Khusro didnt kewn Urdu, because that language was not there only, there was Khari boli and still today Urdu and standard Hindi are essentially Khari boli only. And other than foreign languages, Ameer Khusro knew local langauges: Khari Boli , Braj , Awadhi, Bhojpuri. Even Akbar made local language peotry not in Urdu but Braj, he once wrote a poem for Birbal, and wrote other short poems also in Braj, he also knew Hindi gali too. Poet Bhushan, who was Hindi region person, but also wrote in Braj mainly poetries on Shivaji Maharaj who was a Marathi.
Happy Independence Day Pakistan. But dont forget that all of us are Bharatiya, and part of Bharat Mata that is Akhand Bharat (Indian subcontinent), with many sub Indian cultures. Pakistan is just a national identity unlike India
Baqi sab toh theek hai Lekin hum zameen ko khuda nhi maante aur na hi iss ki ibaadat kartay hain . Ye saari zameen khuda ki makhlooq ke liye hai Cheen o Arab hamara , hindusitaan hamara Muslim hain hum watan hai saara jahan hamara
@@sam-239-. In our ancient culture we already have the idea of: 'Vasudhaiva-Kutumbakam' , which means The world is one family. Aur jo apne culture apne desh ka nahi ho sakta woh kisi ka nahi ho sakta. Woh aaj humme dikh raha hai, apne desh aur Bangladesh ka haal dekho. Aur arab desho ne toh khud tumlogo ka saath chhod diya hai.
Another fascinating conversation! Thank you both so much. Looking forward to future episodes with you both.
What an informative and educational podcast! Kudos to Ali Raj for always bringing such insights and knowledge. Always a joy to listen to him.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Urdu is essentially Khari Boli language which got mainly persianized, later sanskrit words were heavily added to create Manak Hindi (standard Hindi), but its essentially Khari boli , and the most popular writing in it is probably Ameer Khusro using Khari Boli, maybe he mixed some other words of other Hindi belt languages too like Braj Bhasha, Awadhi etc, i dont know. And when it went south it became Dakhani, but again its essentially is khari boli. Urdu Hindi Dakhani all are Khari Boli.
The most popular 1 langauge of Medieval India, in which so much literature is written was Braj Bhasha, no other come very close, other was Awadhi but still Braj was most popular especially in middle era of Hindi Literature, it was not Urdu. And the early desi (modern languages) starts from Apabhramsha, and then comes Avhatt, Pingal Dingal, Maithili, Khari boli, Braj , Awadhi, modern Rajasthani languages, etc and other north indian langauge family, and Urdu.
Aadab and the hand gesture was invented by Lucknowi Nawab Wajid Ali Shah. And lot of Indian culture also went outside in Iran, Arab icentral asia etc: spices, herbs, sugar, rice, our fabrics etc, our literature panchtantra, kathasaritsagar, and influenced them, chess, our mathematics sciences medicine, damascus steel, infact the famous arab numerals which are actually Indian numerals, in fact a famous musalman scholar came to india and wrote many things Al-Biruni. and muslim world also got to know our might in early years of our north western and northers kings: lalitaditya muktapida ,bappa rawal, prithviraj chauhan, maharana pratap, rana sanga, rana kumbha, shivaji, and there was this literature also in apabrahmsha language about indian king and alauddin khalji : Kanhadade Prabandha
tumlogo ka anthem persian ya Urdu (joh ki hamari bhasha hai) usmein nahi honi chahiye, par local langauge jaise most spoken punjabi, ya mixture of all ur languages mein honi chahiye, or some minority language
@@user-hq8wm8giyujcg language hamari ya tumhari kab se honay lgi .
Language kisi ki property toh nhi hoti.
Aur jahan tak Urdu ki baat hai toh last 200 years mein Urdu literature mein sab se zyada kaam Punjab mein hua hai
@@sam-239-. Haan haan bhai japani bhasha bhi tumhari bhasha hai japani logo ko nahi. Samurai toh tumhare purwaj the na. Jaise arab persian turki tumhare purwaj the
@@user-hq8wm8giyujcg ap dalits ko apnay purwaj ki trha q nh izzat dety
Our national anthem is in Sanskritized Bengla , and is part of a poem by Great Rabindranath Thakur ji .
tamil m q nh//tamil sanskrit sa ziada purani language h
accha hai ki video speed up karne ki zarurat nahi, bhai sahab khud kitni speed mein bolte hain
Ameer Khusro didnt kewn Urdu, because that language was not there only, there was Khari boli and still today Urdu and standard Hindi are essentially Khari boli only. And other than foreign languages, Ameer Khusro knew local langauges: Khari Boli , Braj , Awadhi, Bhojpuri. Even Akbar made local language peotry not in Urdu but Braj, he once wrote a poem for Birbal, and wrote other short poems also in Braj, he also knew Hindi gali too. Poet Bhushan, who was Hindi region person, but also wrote in Braj mainly poetries on Shivaji Maharaj who was a Marathi.
Great podcast. But Dr Ali Raj talks sooooo fast! Oh yaar, thorra easy ho jao 🤣
Happy Independence Day Pakistan. But dont forget that all of us are Bharatiya, and part of Bharat Mata that is Akhand Bharat (Indian subcontinent), with many sub Indian cultures. Pakistan is just a national identity unlike India
Baqi sab toh theek hai
Lekin hum zameen ko khuda nhi maante aur na hi iss ki ibaadat kartay hain .
Ye saari zameen khuda ki makhlooq ke liye hai
Cheen o Arab hamara , hindusitaan hamara
Muslim hain hum watan hai saara jahan hamara
@@sam-239-. In our ancient culture we already have the idea of: 'Vasudhaiva-Kutumbakam' , which means The world is one family. Aur jo apne culture apne desh ka nahi ho sakta woh kisi ka nahi ho sakta. Woh aaj humme dikh raha hai, apne desh aur Bangladesh ka haal dekho. Aur arab desho ne toh khud tumlogo ka saath chhod diya hai.
@@user-hq8wm8giyujcgBhai jab next ap Yaha ao tu apna yeh hbharati desh bhakti ek side Rakh ana ok
Ha ha , your guest had all illogical explanation to support Pakistani anthem.
pre partition north india😂😂 even after partition north india is here only, and its not ganges its Ganga, Ganga Maiyya (mother Ganga)