@@akbar8309 just wondering why those emojis re Roseanne Chae-young Park growing up in Australia? To be exact, Rosé was born in Auckland, New Zealand in 1997. Parents emigrated to NZ, from Korea, couple decades prior. The family moved to Melbourne, Australia when Rosé was 7. Rosé, at 16, and her mother, initially, moved to Korea, after Rosé auditioned among 700 others at YG Entertainment auditions in Sydney. The rest of the family also moved to Korea several months later.
you can't be serious, Rosé is Australian, her first language is English, by the way, Alicia keys the original singer for this song posted a clip of Rosé while singing this song and expressed her admiration. I know everyone has a different opinion, but this is the first time I've seen a vocal coach who has negative comments about Rosé and for me i found you'r comments rude gys.
i honestly don't understand how rose's ennounciation was off, maybe the first singer but rose literally learned english as her first language. and blackpink are still a four-member group as they have always been, the guy on the right was kinda rude.
Rose’ is Australian (New Zealand born, Australian raised actually), so it wasn’t a vocal trick, it’s her accent (and it’s charming) .. -not even knowing who’s in blackpink kinda means you’re not up on current music at all -if Rose’s voice is screechy to you, I’d recommend not reacting to her anymore .. I’ve watched tons of vocal coaches react to her and you’re the first with all the negative feedback, so, congrats, you’re 1of1 .. best of luck on your journey .. far away from Rose’ and blackpink I hope.
For your kind information, rosé is an Australian with aussie accent and her ennounciation is pretty good And to be honest she has much better accent than 3 of you
Guys this was a Korean TV program aired during the pandemic where famous Korean celebrities ran a free, for the lucky few, outdoor restaurant and bar called sea of hope. This performance was an unplanned encore request by one of the guests. Rosé appeared in 6 of the 12 episodes. The cast all live in a small shack on the beach rehearse and prepare meals and drinks in the morning and perform in the afternoon and evening. The whole show had to fit around the artists regular schedules so some of them pop in and out. If you have a look at some more of the covers I think you'll be impressed.
Y’all are just haters, except for the girl on the left. She’s fine. You people are so overly critical and you take the fun out of everything. Neither of them were bad, they did amazing! But the guy on the right especially just pointing out enunciation is kinda giving me some racist vibes because not everyone can speak English and not everyone has to. Besides, she’s Australian so if anything y’all got it wrong.
This! The guy with the green coat is kinda giving me racist vibes lol, he mock the pronunciation more than their skill is weird like are they just thinking that English only one accent? 💀 they don't give a good solid opinion just trying to pick something random so that they could have an opinion.
Not sure I understand this reaction at all. No research on the artists you're critiquing, no research on the show you're reviewing, criticizing the accent of an artist singing in a second language, not much mention of the positive vocal qualities in what is clearly an incredible performance. I get that you're "vocal coaches" but you come off more as "vocal debbie downers."
that's why appreciate those youtuber reactors do research before reacting to the person. not just someone wants view and it's totally a clout chaser hahahaha
Well in the show they were running a mini beach bar where they also entertain customers by singing to them. I also understand the problems with the enunciation. In their defense, Suhyun is Korean while Rosé is Australian so their pronunciation will not be the same as when an American does it. Even Texans sing differently compared to let us say a New Yorker 😅 But I get it each has his own preference. At least you are honest with your reactions.
@Pau, thanks for the backstory. Was this like an "unplugged" show, or an invitation event (as not huge audience, like normal)? Happening either side of a main gig? (EDIT: eventually found answer). Interestingly, Rosé was born in New Zealand, but grew up in Australia, from the age of 7, until 16 when she moved to Korea. As Rosé was relaxed, maybe she was singing with Aus pronunciation lol. Didn't notice that much (until replayin), but then aussie pronunciation I'm very familiar with lol - & the extended "hanging on" of vowel sounds of at end of words, such as Noooh. So Australia's to blame. Ha. Also, I love anything chilled like that & an ultimate dream to be at a favourite artist's gig if was something like that. Was going to ask if more of BP at this but googled (& translator) & see it's from a TV Series, Sea of Hope (in English) which is part reality series, part no audience performance, & part live gig. For others reading (summarised from Wiki): Sea of Hope is a healing show which combines three themes: sea, bar, & wish. Participants open a bar on the sea-side & offer to the customers various food, drinks & musical acts, so they can escape their daily lives for a moment. (although that doesn't exactly detail some other episodes, I had a brief look at part of)
This song was requested by an audience so it was not practiced or planned. More of a simultaneous trial in casual vibe during the street busking. It’s not for a Live TV stage or studio recording. They just wanted to have some pure fun by getting closer to general publics :)
a lot of comments about this already, most of them touch on what is going on. I will try and spell it out clearly. This show was a variety show, which they got actors and singers to serve dinner, drinks and desert to paying customers on a beach front location during Covid, this is why everyone is spaced out so far apart on the beach front, it is not their parents but random guest. So after the food service was complete, they would ask the artist to go on stage and entertain the guest with a song or two. The first girl is a talented singer from YG, SuHyun from the group AKMU. her english is pretty good for being a second language. The Guy is Onew from the Group Shinee, and then Rose' - who holds a New Zealand passport. she said she obviously learned Korean first, but only at the elementary level. and has picked up the Australian Accent after moving there at the age of 6 until her early teen years. So you could say English is her first/second language. when she moved to Korea to join YG / BlackPink at the age 15, Lisa who is Thai was speaking Korean better then her at first. And the group BlackPink is still together, but they have solo projects they sing when they are not producing music together. At the Beginning of the clip, you see Rose' kind of laughing or shying away like Really... As this song was not planned. someone suggested they sing this song, and SuHyun said yeah, she know this song and started it off. as you could tell, Onew did not really know the song but most people know the chorus, so he was just following along though out the jam. Rose' who knew the song but not well enough was on her phone for lyrics, and you could see it in her eyes for help, or a simple, you are doing great, which she was. and this is when SuHyun joined in for a bit but tapered off again. I will also comment on the manners of the panel, I do not think they are Rude or impolite. They may be un-informed about the group they are talking about, but this does not make them bad, which is why they are asking questions. People, There are no bad questions, so don't be so offended if someone does not know everything you know. and everyone is entitled to there own opinion, it is refreshing to hear someone say what they are feeling and not being obliged to say a nice word when they don't feel it. with that said, when I hear someone singing an english song and it does not sound the way I hear it in my own head, i too do not initially enjoy it, and sometimes it may take a few listens to fully enjoy the performance. everyone has different accents and styles, and this is what makes every artist stand out from the pack. enough said. great reaction.
Rose' is from Australia so honestly her enunciation or pronounciation is correct and this is just a jamming so I don't really get where the boy's are coming from and there's a lot of American singers that really don't show of there voices
I whole heartedly agree with most of these comments. Like critiquing vocal technique is one thing but so much of the "critiquing" was just plain disrespectful and rude commentary plus context matters a great deal in my opinion when you are critiquing and they didn't even try to get a little background prior to their review. Like they don't necessarily have to if they are critiquing vocal technique only but that was not the case here. I have watched many vocal coaches give their reviews on technique but never on their preference for the singers accent. Guy in the green shirt couldnt even find one positive thing to mention. Also, they started off by saying Koreans really know how to sing and then proceed to rudely rip every little thing to shreds. There is constructive criticism but this was not that. Like what was anyone supposed to learn or take away from this?
This song is not in the set list. That why Rosé carry her phone to see the lyrics. They don't practice this song together and this is live performance but they make a good one.
The girl who sang at first is Suhyun, from Akmu, and the man was Onew from SHINee, they r both great vocalists and so talented too. There was another duet between Rose and Onew ini that show, they covered"Lucky", i think that will be so much fun watching or reacting them, the chemistry just so cheef's kiss!!! Here is the link : ruclips.net/video/lqAeYl05V2k/видео.html
@@Itsjinndo you even know what first language means? it doesn’t mean ur really first time learned language but the language that u really mastered lmao Rose is better at english than korean💀
@@Itsjinn uhm but the thing is that she was born in there lmao u were born in Korea and stayed till u graduated preschool but rose went to an australian preschool💀
Omg is this true? This is why I don't believe these people on RUclips who claim to be vocals coach 😅, Rosé was born in New Zealand and at the age of 6 her family moved to Australia and she grew up there, speaking English, with her beautiful Aussie accent and these people talking nonsense, smh
You're not really wrong but its like you listened to this with your engineer hat on instead of your music-lover hat. You totally missed the vibe, the intimacy, the rawness and the warmth of this impromptu performance.
Yes Rose is still in the group they all have there solo stuff and then the group same with BTS and GOT7 Rose singing dancing in the burning room is a good one or lucky from sea of hope
Guys maybe you miss the point. The young lady gets it but the guys seem clueless. I don’t care about vocal technique all I know is that when Rosé sings there’s something that pulls you in. She’s got over 74M followers on IG and their MVs have billions of views. Most of these people will tell you they would rather hear Rosé sing while reading the lyrics off her phone rather than some vocal technique genius. Don’t tell me why she isn’t technically the best singer, tell me why so many love to hear her sing. 😊
@Draxle Lee, yeh, it was an unplanned unrehearsed extra song. More like a "jam" by those performing. I found out, after searching for more vision of the gig. It's from Korean TV series 'Sea of Hope', & not an actual concert. More like watching a local band at a beachside bar or cafe. Sea of Hope series is part Reality-TV, part documentary, & part "low-key" live music performances
Video is from Sea of Hope TV series. Episode 5 (I think). More of the beach-side gig: ruclips.net/video/YA13dYaLT7Y/видео.html From episode 1 of Sea Of Hope TV series: ruclips.net/video/QnOmPzXs2tg/видео.html which helps show more what’s going on & why.
Does having a different accent in singing affects your singing performance?! Does pronouncing the words differently makes you a bad singer now?🤷♀️🤷♀️🤷♀️
Welcome Michael, the new Simon Cowell of the industry. They're obviously just fooling around, but we have to be dead serious in our comments. Oh well, my take was the first girl was a little thin, the guy was pretty good, and Rose was spectacular. And sorry Grace, but I don't know who any of them are either.
its also funny how the middle in the guy along with the reactor I DONT KNOW HIM and NOT INTENDED TO KNOW HIM even they introduce themselves. It's funny how he assumed and concluded Onew's gestures the 'he is sick of it' 'he's asking about the sound when onew go thumbs up' like literally in other perspective the mean of those gestures isn't like that. He just really HATE it so obvious hahaha you can criticize rosie's voice cause its your opinion but concluding and assuming towards onew's gesture he is making onew the bad one. Pft If I were being asked the part Onew is trying to blend with rosie but rosie do have a unique voice so he found it a light difficult and those thumbs up at the last its means 'GOOD JOB' cause they have literally finished singing the song so why bother asking about the condition of the sound.
Ohh noo I'm sorry but I don't enjoy this video at all because this "reaction and review" Video about someone performance aren't really good because you guys lack the research of these singer and the variety show. Please the girl on the left and wearing the orange shirt I do hope you could bring a legit "vocal coach" In here lol and not someone who just blatantly mock the singer accent just because they live in another country like duh. But nonetheless thank you, I like how the girl giving a positive attitude in here. I'm sorry but the dude with the green jacket isn't that nice he gives me racist vibe 💀
if yall want to react to an artiste I think yall should search and get to know them more not start making these rude comments, I mean I understate what yall said about the first girl she is Korean so she has that accent but when it comes to Rose and saying that she is facking/using cursive is not very professional from u to say cause first of all the show was just about having fun!!!
Six months ago you listened Nightwish. The song was written to the voice of second singer Anette Olzon who has more traditional rock singing style. If you haven't listen Nightwish after that I think you would get more out from Ghost Love Score that let Floor Jansen's own voice come out more freely. She has one of the most versatile voices I have ever heard and you need to see many performances to get an idea of her range. ruclips.net/video/JYjIlHWBAVo/видео.html ps. Santa Claus is from Finland just like Nightwish but Floor Jansen is Dutch. ;)
pls reactions to J.Fla - "Before I Met You" Kang Yoo Jung (Gemma) - 꽃이 피고 지듯이 풀버전 I Can See Your Voice 4 ′Think Of Me′ 160629 EP.18 Feng Timo - FALL IN LOVE, Zhou Shen, ...
@SeanyMacStudios Hi guys Because your reaction to Nightwish Storytime was impeded by the problem with the sound on your reaction, would you be willing to give them another listen? Nightwish - 'Ghost Love Score' is one of the three most reacted to songs in RUclips history ruclips.net/video/47e_961OQWE/видео.html It is from the same concert that Storytime was from
So basically you ask a aussie why it has a aussie accent😅dude before wven react do some more research like everyone does..there are people having more follows than you barely speaking english😂 and you are vocal coaches😅tf
Aigh.. I think i'll just stop at 6:23 😂, simply bcuz about half video in i just couldn't bare my straight face pulling out "let them talk first" tolerance expression anymore, like i'm usually quite okay when people being skeptically critical over somebody who they rarely watched in their own time, but then again some comments in this video and judging by what people have been said in the comments are enough to tellin me that some of those who so called vocal coaches can be plainly ignorant, shockingly off within their observation and even fairly lacking in their professionalism Like i get it some people defending these vocal coaches by saying "oh yeah finally something refreshing comes out with such an honesty", "singers could have a bad day or two", " ennounciation blah blah blah", but nahhhh y'all fans of this channel were mad blind over some important details in this video, like as an example these coaches were fully predicting that SEA OF HOPE might just a relaxing jamming session which normally are not that intense/serious when it comes to the whole staging quality and yet these coaches still proceeds to criticize each one of the performer in this video by saying not impressed (which is fine since everyone entitled to their own ego/preference), they also said that ONEW's gesture shows that he might be sick of the performance quality and many more baseless claims 😂 And remember, these statements were coming out from vocal coaches, vocalll coaches with no proper knowledge about BLACKPINK nor LEE SU-HYUN nor ONEW nor SEA OF HOPE evenly, and y'all fans of this channel somehow still not getting something's off from their reaction yet? Sheessh 😂... i guess this is why some vocal coaches would always staying stuck at the same place and some are trully knowledgeable in what they 'bout to say
Fist time watching you guys but from this video it seems Grace is the only one that was on point... By the way the guys are very brave to criticize any of the Black Pink queens As I see from the comments of other BLINKS in the comment section :):):):):):)
Hi..can i suggest a good singer from malaysia..ernie zakri..she is also a vocal coach.. 1. AJL35 title Gundah - she composed the song - won Vocal award - she sang while crying but not affecting her vocal - m.ruclips.net/video/8PhhBcoUtnU/видео.html 2. TV show title Misteri - she had flu this time n sound nasally but still slays - most difficult song - m.ruclips.net/video/oNslg_FqdlE/видео.html Thank you
REACTION video should be "First Hard Experience" ... ? ... YES it should. BUT !!!! .... BUT !!!! .... Not knowing what you are reacting too is TOTALLY DIFFERENT !!! If you take this for granted .... { Ok we do reaction video as hobby when we have some free time. just sit in ... see what people recommend and talk shit and we got views ... enough ..... !!!! ] You are disrespecting your follower , your channel and the artist you are reacting to. SO ... do your homework before making new video ..... be professional please !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Last but not least ..... What kind of DICTION that the guy was shitting about ???? Do Americans and British need to have the same 'Diction' ????? She didn't paint the word that way, she has Australian Accent cuz that's her hometown. PS. Where did you find that guy ? .... I wouldn't judge him, he might be a decent man. However, attitude is very important for doing Reaction video. I was surprise that you could keep his whole head in the video frame. But if you feel your life is too peaceful and feel like having bullet magnet to make your channel gain more excitement like making video in Beirut. Yes !!! you are on the right track. Be my guest !!!
It is very amusing to read the reactions of some people that just because the reviews of the vocal coaches on this video is not the way the fans want it to be that it means they don't know what they are talking about. For me, I like reactions that are real and honest which I believe what they did respectfully. They are vocal coaches so, of course, their focus is more on the voice, techniques and delivery and not more on who the singer/s are. Singers are people, they have good and bad days. They are not always perfect and even in their imperfections they can still be good. So, don't shoot the vocal coaches commenting of what could be done better because they are basing their comments on the current video performance and not about who the singers are, their achievements, nationalities, etc. I love this channel because they actually provide lessons for those who want to learn. Remember, people learn best from their mistakes and I believe that every decent artist will prefer constructive criticisms rather than just saying they are perfect all the time. So, I hope this channel continues to deliver honest reactions and lessons to those who truly appreciate what a true reaction video really means. Bravo!!!
No need for the attitude girl. Black pink might be super popular to YOU and to the general public but you cannot always assume and expect EVERYONE to know them.
Your comment is a fair comment, BUT these people reacting are vocal coaches & singers and should at least know about who their analysing, when the artist is a major world-wide artist. Don't expect them to know it all, but even I not young, & rarely watched/listen to BP, know Black Pink are 4, & are Rose, Jenny, Jishoo & ... that one I'd have to google. Also, Sean who's channel this is has said in other video he goes to Korea couple times of year (tho not past few years of course), & said he's friends with some Korean singers (such as Maytree) when reacting to some vids of some singers; so he really should know that Rosé is in Black Pink. AFIK there's only one Korean now international singer in the world named Rosé. If Michael wasn't listed as a vocal coach in the description and if this channel didn't react to heaps of Korean singers, as they do, I'd be more generously forgiving. I'm an being somewhat lenient as idea of these is first time hearing reacts; but still...
![Olivia Pardede | Drivers License - Vocal Coach Reacts [See you on Wednesday]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BvEWvYIVe1U/mqdefault.jpg)
![ROSÉ SEA OF HOPE COVERS [reaction] - Gone, If I Aint Got You, The Only Exception & SDIABR](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xx-trlbiYeo/mqdefault.jpg)
Rose's pronunciation is not being stylistic, she grew up in Australia. It's her natural accent.
Thats she from australia😭😭😭😭
@@akbar8309 just wondering why those emojis re Roseanne Chae-young Park growing up in Australia?
To be exact, Rosé was born in Auckland, New Zealand in 1997. Parents emigrated to NZ, from Korea, couple decades prior.
The family moved to Melbourne, Australia when Rosé was 7.
Rosé, at 16, and her mother, initially, moved to Korea, after Rosé auditioned among 700 others at YG Entertainment auditions in Sydney. The rest of the family also moved to Korea several months later.
you can't be serious, Rosé is Australian, her first language is English, by the way, Alicia keys the original singer for this song posted a clip of Rosé while singing this song and expressed her admiration. I know everyone has a different opinion, but this is the first time I've seen a vocal coach who has negative comments about Rosé and for me i found you'r comments rude gys.
Omg she's an Aussie , basically her first language is english duh
i honestly don't understand how rose's ennounciation was off, maybe the first singer but rose literally learned english as her first language. and blackpink are still a four-member group as they have always been, the guy on the right was kinda rude.
yeah thats when you realize when people are just asspulling just to sound "pro" lol.
When someone trying to be "smart" Just to have an opinion lol
Rose’ is Australian (New Zealand born, Australian raised actually), so it wasn’t a vocal trick, it’s her accent (and it’s charming) ..
-not even knowing who’s in blackpink kinda means you’re not up on current music at all
-if Rose’s voice is screechy to you, I’d recommend not reacting to her anymore .. I’ve watched tons of vocal coaches react to her and you’re the first with all the negative feedback, so, congrats, you’re 1of1 .. best of luck on your journey .. far away from Rose’ and blackpink I hope.
For your kind information, rosé is an Australian with aussie accent and her ennounciation is pretty good
And to be honest she has much better accent than 3 of you
Guys this was a Korean TV program aired during the pandemic where famous Korean celebrities ran a free, for the lucky few, outdoor restaurant and bar called sea of hope.
This performance was an unplanned encore request by one of the guests.
Rosé appeared in 6 of the 12 episodes.
The cast all live in a small shack on the beach rehearse and prepare meals and drinks in the morning and perform in the afternoon and evening.
The whole show had to fit around the artists regular schedules so some of them pop in and out.
If you have a look at some more of the covers I think you'll be impressed.
Y’all are just haters, except for the girl on the left. She’s fine. You people are so overly critical and you take the fun out of everything. Neither of them were bad, they did amazing! But the guy on the right especially just pointing out enunciation is kinda giving me some racist vibes because not everyone can speak English and not everyone has to. Besides, she’s Australian so if anything y’all got it wrong.
This! The guy with the green coat is kinda giving me racist vibes lol, he mock the pronunciation more than their skill is weird like are they just thinking that English only one accent? 💀 they don't give a good solid opinion just trying to pick something random so that they could have an opinion.
ennounciation comment just doesn't make any sense
Not sure I understand this reaction at all. No research on the artists you're critiquing, no research on the show you're reviewing, criticizing the accent of an artist singing in a second language, not much mention of the positive vocal qualities in what is clearly an incredible performance. I get that you're "vocal coaches" but you come off more as "vocal debbie downers."
Agreed people that want to react should at least do research
literally💀
@@JupiterXin fr, like a quick google search even💀😭
that's why appreciate those youtuber reactors do research before reacting to the person. not just someone wants view and it's totally a clout chaser hahahaha
Well in the show they were running a mini beach bar where they also entertain customers by singing to them. I also understand the problems with the enunciation. In their defense, Suhyun is Korean while Rosé is Australian so their pronunciation will not be the same as when an American does it. Even Texans sing differently compared to let us say a New Yorker 😅 But I get it each has his own preference. At least you are honest with your reactions.
@Pau, thanks for the backstory. Was this like an "unplugged" show, or an invitation event (as not huge audience, like normal)? Happening either side of a main gig? (EDIT: eventually found answer). Interestingly, Rosé was born in New Zealand, but grew up in Australia, from the age of 7, until 16 when she moved to Korea. As Rosé was relaxed, maybe she was singing with Aus pronunciation lol. Didn't notice that much (until replayin), but then aussie pronunciation I'm very familiar with lol - & the extended "hanging on" of vowel sounds of at end of words, such as Noooh. So Australia's to blame. Ha.
Also, I love anything chilled like that & an ultimate dream to be at a favourite artist's gig if was something like that. Was going to ask if more of BP at this but googled (& translator) & see it's from a TV Series, Sea of Hope (in English) which is part reality series, part no audience performance, & part live gig.
For others reading (summarised from Wiki): Sea of Hope is a healing show which combines three themes: sea, bar, & wish. Participants open a bar on the sea-side & offer to the customers various food, drinks & musical acts, so they can escape their daily lives for a moment. (although that doesn't exactly detail some other episodes, I had a brief look at part of)
I love how vocal coaches constantly criticize singers, while not being able to reproduce a sound even close to what their armchair critiques imply.
This song was requested by an audience so it was not practiced or planned. More of a simultaneous trial in casual vibe during the street busking. It’s not for a Live TV stage or studio recording. They just wanted to have some pure fun by getting closer to general publics :)
Rosé is perfect. This guys are vocal coach .. are you sure??? They can't hear accent?
a lot of comments about this already, most of them touch on what is going on. I will try and spell it out clearly.
This show was a variety show, which they got actors and singers to serve dinner, drinks and desert to paying customers on a beach front location during Covid, this is why everyone is spaced out so far apart on the beach front, it is not their parents but random guest. So after the food service was complete, they would ask the artist to go on stage and entertain the guest with a song or two.
The first girl is a talented singer from YG, SuHyun from the group AKMU. her english is pretty good for being a second language. The Guy is Onew from the Group Shinee, and then Rose' - who holds a New Zealand passport. she said she obviously learned Korean first, but only at the elementary level. and has picked up the Australian Accent after moving there at the age of 6 until her early teen years. So you could say English is her first/second language. when she moved to Korea to join YG / BlackPink at the age 15, Lisa who is Thai was speaking Korean better then her at first. And the group BlackPink is still together, but they have solo projects they sing when they are not producing music together.
At the Beginning of the clip, you see Rose' kind of laughing or shying away like Really... As this song was not planned. someone suggested they sing this song, and SuHyun said yeah, she know this song and started it off. as you could tell, Onew did not really know the song but most people know the chorus, so he was just following along though out the jam. Rose' who knew the song but not well enough was on her phone for lyrics, and you could see it in her eyes for help, or a simple, you are doing great, which she was. and this is when SuHyun joined in for a bit but tapered off again.
I will also comment on the manners of the panel, I do not think they are Rude or impolite. They may be un-informed about the group they are talking about, but this does not make them bad, which is why they are asking questions. People, There are no bad questions, so don't be so offended if someone does not know everything you know. and everyone is entitled to there own opinion, it is refreshing to hear someone say what they are feeling and not being obliged to say a nice word when they don't feel it. with that said, when I hear someone singing an english song and it does not sound the way I hear it in my own head, i too do not initially enjoy it, and sometimes it may take a few listens to fully enjoy the performance. everyone has different accents and styles, and this is what makes every artist stand out from the pack. enough said. great reaction.
Rose' is from Australia so honestly her enunciation or pronounciation is correct and this is just a jamming so I don't really get where the boy's are coming from and there's a lot of American singers that really don't show of there voices
Vocal coach? I wouldn't be surprised if none of your students became famous singers based on you judging someone.
Rosé's Australian, that's just her accent...
I whole heartedly agree with most of these comments. Like critiquing vocal technique is one thing but so much of the "critiquing" was just plain disrespectful and rude commentary plus context matters a great deal in my opinion when you are critiquing and they didn't even try to get a little background prior to their review. Like they don't necessarily have to if they are critiquing vocal technique only but that was not the case here. I have watched many vocal coaches give their reviews on technique but never on their preference for the singers accent. Guy in the green shirt couldnt even find one positive thing to mention. Also, they started off by saying Koreans really know how to sing and then proceed to rudely rip every little thing to shreds. There is constructive criticism but this was not that. Like what was anyone supposed to learn or take away from this?
This song is not in the set list. That why Rosé carry her phone to see the lyrics. They don't practice this song together and this is live performance but they make a good one.
It's her accent, australian accent
The girl who sang at first is Suhyun, from Akmu, and the man was Onew from SHINee, they r both great vocalists and so talented too. There was another duet between Rose and Onew ini that show, they covered"Lucky", i think that will be so much fun watching or reacting them, the chemistry just so cheef's kiss!!!
Here is the link :
ruclips.net/video/lqAeYl05V2k/видео.html
But Rosé first language is English...
@@Itsjinn No lol
@@Itsjinndo you even know what first language means? it doesn’t mean ur really first time learned language but the language that u really mastered lmao Rose is better at english than korean💀
@@Itsjinn it is bcs she went to preschool and she learned English there don’t u think🤨 (probably 3-5years) are the age where u go to preschool lol
@@Itsjinn uhm but the thing is that she was born in there lmao u were born in Korea and stayed till u graduated preschool but rose went to an australian preschool💀
@@Itsjinn 그리고 한국인이면 한국말 해라 걍ㅋㅋ 로제 초등학교 이전부터 호주 유치원 다녔는데 한국말보다 더 잘하는게 정상 아님?
I like how rose sings purposefully keeping her accent
rosie cover of this is so good other may think its off because it accent but for me and my ears it was great
Omg is this true? This is why I don't believe these people on RUclips who claim to be vocals coach 😅, Rosé was born in New Zealand and at the age of 6 her family moved to Australia and she grew up there, speaking English, with her beautiful Aussie accent and these people talking nonsense, smh
She’s literally Australian. That’s just her accent you bigots
You're not really wrong but its like you listened to this with your engineer hat on instead of your music-lover hat. You totally missed the vibe, the intimacy, the rawness and the warmth of this impromptu performance.
Rosé ate that cover up 🌹❤
Yes Rose is still in the group they all have there solo stuff and then the group same with BTS and GOT7 Rose singing dancing in the burning room is a good one or lucky from sea of hope
Guys maybe you miss the point. The young lady gets it but the guys seem clueless. I don’t care about vocal technique all I know is that when Rosé sings there’s something that pulls you in. She’s got over 74M followers on IG and their MVs have billions of views. Most of these people will tell you they would rather hear Rosé sing while reading the lyrics off her phone rather than some vocal technique genius. Don’t tell me why she isn’t technically the best singer, tell me why so many love to hear her sing. 😊
Imagine criticizing a voice that makes millions...
It’s called having an accent, idk how you guys call yourselves vocal coaches and don’t realise yikes
Of course it's just a jam session. Did you think the were recording their masters? I'm not sure what you expected. It's not like it's in a studio lol.
There's still more covers and yes they weren't planning to this song
I love ROSÉ ❤️🔥
Very likely it was her first time singing this song and had to read the notes and lyrics from the phone...
@Draxle Lee, yeh, it was an unplanned unrehearsed extra song. More like a "jam" by those performing. I found out, after searching for more vision of the gig.
It's from Korean TV series 'Sea of Hope', & not an actual concert. More like watching a local band at a beachside bar or cafe.
Sea of Hope series is part Reality-TV, part documentary, & part "low-key" live music performances
@@profonde3460 Gee.... thats a lot of details. Thanks.
You need to react to rose gone sea of hope
Don't recommend any other song or cover of rosé since they don't have any interest in vocals but judging
Y'all really claim y'all are 'professionals' IJBOL
Kindly react on Rosé’s song cover of Dancing In The Burning Room and Eyes Closed
Video is from Sea of Hope TV series. Episode 5 (I think). More of the beach-side gig: ruclips.net/video/YA13dYaLT7Y/видео.html
From episode 1 of Sea Of Hope TV series: ruclips.net/video/QnOmPzXs2tg/видео.html which helps show more what’s going on & why.
I LOVED it !!!!!!
Does having a different accent in singing affects your singing performance?!
Does pronouncing the words differently makes you a bad singer now?🤷♀️🤷♀️🤷♀️
Welcome Michael, the new Simon Cowell of the industry. They're obviously just fooling around, but we have to be dead serious in our comments. Oh well, my take was the first girl was a little thin, the guy was pretty good, and Rose was spectacular. And sorry Grace, but I don't know who any of them are either.
its also funny how the middle in the guy along with the reactor I DONT KNOW HIM and NOT INTENDED TO KNOW HIM even they introduce themselves. It's funny how he assumed and concluded Onew's gestures the 'he is sick of it'
'he's asking about the sound when onew go thumbs up' like literally in other perspective the mean of those gestures isn't like that. He just really HATE it so obvious hahaha you can criticize rosie's voice cause its your opinion but concluding and assuming towards onew's gesture he is making onew the bad one. Pft If I were being asked the part Onew is trying to blend with rosie but rosie do have a unique voice so he found it a light difficult and those thumbs up at the last its means 'GOOD JOB' cause they have literally finished singing the song so why bother asking about the condition of the sound.
"my take was the first girl was a little thin" Jfc you must be tone deaf and or just plain stupid. I'm thinking more of the latter smdh.
That's just her accent
I'd like to hear these three try to sing a better interpretation.
Ohh noo I'm sorry but I don't enjoy this video at all because this "reaction and review" Video about someone performance aren't really good because you guys lack the research of these singer and the variety show. Please the girl on the left and wearing the orange shirt I do hope you could bring a legit "vocal coach" In here lol and not someone who just blatantly mock the singer accent just because they live in another country like duh. But nonetheless thank you, I like how the girl giving a positive attitude in here. I'm sorry but the dude with the green jacket isn't that nice he gives me racist vibe 💀
More Sohyang please! You guys have abandoned her, and she is the best in the world! Come on, eh! 💘🛸👽
if yall want to react to an artiste I think yall should search and get to know them more not start making these rude comments, I mean I understate what yall said about the first girl she is Korean so she has that accent but when it comes to Rose and saying that she is facking/using cursive is not very professional from u to say cause first of all the show was just about having fun!!!
Literalmente no están acá para reaccionar. Ni siquiera se informaron de lo que iban a mirar. Sólo criticaron.
What a strange reaction…
I know very disappointed with your reaction. The criticism of both men is terrible, full of prejudice for them.
So Hyang's cover of this is wonderful.
Six months ago you listened Nightwish. The song was written to the voice of second singer Anette Olzon who has more traditional rock singing style. If you haven't listen Nightwish after that I think you would get more out from Ghost Love Score that let Floor Jansen's own voice come out more freely. She has one of the most versatile voices I have ever heard and you need to see many performances to get an idea of her range.
ruclips.net/video/JYjIlHWBAVo/видео.html
ps. Santa Claus is from Finland just like Nightwish but Floor Jansen is Dutch. ;)
pls reactions to J.Fla - "Before I Met You"
Kang Yoo Jung (Gemma) - 꽃이 피고 지듯이 풀버전
I Can See Your Voice 4 ′Think Of Me′ 160629 EP.18
Feng Timo - FALL IN LOVE, Zhou Shen, ...
@SeanyMacStudios
Hi guys
Because your reaction to Nightwish Storytime was impeded by the problem with the sound on your reaction, would you be willing to give them another listen?
Nightwish - 'Ghost Love Score' is one of the three most reacted to songs in RUclips history ruclips.net/video/47e_961OQWE/видео.html
It is from the same concert that Storytime was from
It has been 6 months and still not another Jinjer!!!!!!!
Plsss React to Babymonster performance live performances next....
Should recommend to other people not them 😅
So basically you ask a aussie why it has a aussie accent😅dude before wven react do some more research like everyone does..there are people having more follows than you barely speaking english😂 and you are vocal coaches😅tf
Please react to Zephanie, Janella Salvador and Stell of SB19 in "A Night of Wonder with Disney+.
thanks for the reaction!! i hope you guys could react to her 'the only exception' cover too!!
😍😍😘❤️
Celine Dion hits by the divas of the Queendom.the singer's amazing
Aigh.. I think i'll just stop at 6:23 😂, simply bcuz about half video in i just couldn't bare my straight face pulling out "let them talk first" tolerance expression anymore, like i'm usually quite okay when people being skeptically critical over somebody who they rarely watched in their own time, but then again some comments in this video and judging by what people have been said in the comments are enough to tellin me that some of those who so called vocal coaches can be plainly ignorant, shockingly off within their observation and even fairly lacking in their professionalism
Like i get it some people defending these vocal coaches by saying "oh yeah finally something refreshing comes out with such an honesty", "singers could have a bad day or two", " ennounciation blah blah blah", but nahhhh y'all fans of this channel were mad blind over some important details in this video, like as an example these coaches were fully predicting that SEA OF HOPE might just a relaxing jamming session which normally are not that intense/serious when it comes to the whole staging quality and yet these coaches still proceeds to criticize each one of the performer in this video by saying not impressed (which is fine since everyone entitled to their own ego/preference), they also said that ONEW's gesture shows that he might be sick of the performance quality and many more baseless claims 😂
And remember, these statements were coming out from vocal coaches, vocalll coaches with no proper knowledge about BLACKPINK nor LEE SU-HYUN nor ONEW nor SEA OF HOPE evenly, and y'all fans of this channel somehow still not getting something's off from their reaction yet?
Sheessh 😂... i guess this is why some vocal coaches would always staying stuck at the same place and some are trully knowledgeable in what they 'bout to say
criticizing anyone You should have enough information. But obviously you don't even know anything.
Fist time watching you guys but from this video it seems Grace is the only one that was on point... By the way the guys are very brave to criticize any of the Black Pink queens As I see from the comments of other BLINKS in the comment section :):):):):):)
Please try to react: EM ĐỒNG Ý (I DO) - ĐỨC PHÚC x 911 x KHẮC HƯNG | OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO | VALENTINE 2023
Hi..can i suggest a good singer from malaysia..ernie zakri..she is also a vocal coach..
1. AJL35 title Gundah - she composed the song - won Vocal award - she sang while crying but not affecting her vocal - m.ruclips.net/video/8PhhBcoUtnU/видео.html
2. TV show title Misteri - she had flu this time n sound nasally but still slays - most difficult song - m.ruclips.net/video/oNslg_FqdlE/видео.html
Thank you
REACTION video should be "First Hard Experience" ... ? ... YES it should.
BUT !!!! .... BUT !!!! .... Not knowing what you are reacting too is TOTALLY DIFFERENT !!!
If you take this for granted .... { Ok we do reaction video as hobby when we have some free time.
just sit in ... see what people recommend and talk shit and we got views ... enough ..... !!!! ]
You are disrespecting your follower , your channel and the artist you are reacting to.
SO ... do your homework before making new video ..... be professional please !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Last but not least ..... What kind of DICTION that the guy was shitting about ????
Do Americans and British need to have the same 'Diction' ?????
She didn't paint the word that way, she has Australian Accent cuz that's her hometown.
PS. Where did you find that guy ? .... I wouldn't judge him, he might be a decent man.
However, attitude is very important for doing Reaction video.
I was surprise that you could keep his whole head in the video frame.
But if you feel your life is too peaceful and feel like having bullet magnet
to make your channel gain more excitement like making video in Beirut.
Yes !!! you are on the right track. Be my guest !!!
Hey guys, can you please make a reaction video to MARCELITO POMOY SINGING "THE PRAYER" 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
you cant hear accents lol
Please react to Gigi De Lana version of Unholy 😊🫶
WoW!! Talk about a failed reaction, this is it. Felt sorry for Grace.
pls react to SB19 Mapa and Tilaluha
Please do react a filipino commercial.its jolibee commercial
🤣🤣🤣 I see a hater right here
Please react this cover by agseisa to
This is song reflection by misterwives
Thankyou hope your all blessed
ruclips.net/video/3BQDRGKTA8Q/видео.html
HOW RACIST. SHAME!!!
What a horrible reaction. She's Australian. There is absolutely nothing wrong with her pronunciation or her "style" of singing.
don't watch these clowns all they do is bash singers
It is very amusing to read the reactions of some people that just because the reviews of the vocal coaches on this video is not the way the fans want it to be that it means they don't know what they are talking about. For me, I like reactions that are real and honest which I believe what they did respectfully. They are vocal coaches so, of course, their focus is more on the voice, techniques and delivery and not more on who the singer/s are. Singers are people, they have good and bad days. They are not always perfect and even in their imperfections they can still be good. So, don't shoot the vocal coaches commenting of what could be done better because they are basing their comments on the current video performance and not about who the singers are, their achievements, nationalities, etc. I love this channel because they actually provide lessons for those who want to learn. Remember, people learn best from their mistakes and I believe that every decent artist will prefer constructive criticisms rather than just saying they are perfect all the time. So, I hope this channel continues to deliver honest reactions and lessons to those who truly appreciate what a true reaction video really means. Bravo!!!
Awww it's so sweet that the mom of one of them is taking up for their child. How cute.
No need for the attitude girl. Black pink might be super popular to YOU and to the general public but you cannot always assume and expect EVERYONE to know them.
Your comment is a fair comment, BUT these people reacting are vocal coaches & singers and should at least know about who their analysing, when the artist is a major world-wide artist. Don't expect them to know it all, but even I not young, & rarely watched/listen to BP, know Black Pink are 4, & are Rose, Jenny, Jishoo & ... that one I'd have to google. Also, Sean who's channel this is has said in other video he goes to Korea couple times of year (tho not past few years of course), & said he's friends with some Korean singers (such as Maytree) when reacting to some vids of some singers; so he really should know that Rosé is in Black Pink. AFIK there's only one Korean now international singer in the world named Rosé.
If Michael wasn't listed as a vocal coach in the description and if this channel didn't react to heaps of Korean singers, as they do, I'd be more generously forgiving. I'm an being somewhat lenient as idea of these is first time hearing reacts; but still...
By the way, find the react to Maytree - Colours of the Wind. Worth seeing (or find Maytree's video)
Sounds to me like you're the one with the attitude
@@profonde3460 I agree, and Michael's nitpicking. &... Lisa, and Jisoo
She's right tho