This look amazing, very well done for a 2D animation, The theory looks accurate, but I suggest to remove the buckling when the 2nd funnel falls, the forward tower should stay intact, the 4th funnel should fall to port or shouldn't fall at all, If you want a time later than 2:15, I would suggest 2:16 and around 45-50 seconds before 2:17, and the officer shooting himself should be at 2:14.
I will say my theory has changed for example I’ve replaced the buckling with the ship slowly bending over time i will take some of this in to account although the officer shooting i still think would make sense to have it take place just a couple seconds before the 1st funnel collapses thanks for the feedback.
@@SyAnimates I do see what you mean on why you make the officer shoot himself, it would make sense because during the final plunge, a lot of things are happening at once, I'm sorry, the officer shooting himself is supposed to happen at 2:14, however this may change at anytime because, research.
The animation is very good but i have a few problems with this theory, 1. 2:17AM is too late for the ship to start plunging at, If this happened Boat A would of cleared the ship and Boat B would never get to the starboard side. 2. She cant buckle and continue to rise, once she buckles she will fail. 3. The FT coming off at the surface, Ive explainned this before but if it comes off at the surface it will never go far east and will end up in the hypocenter. 4. The even keel wasnt caused by flooding of a boiler room, It was the collapse of a bulkhead inside the ship. This can aslo be linked to the deep exlosions heard from Titanic at her plunge. 5. 2 minutes is too long for the stern to settle for, If this happpened peoples eyes would adjust and they would see that she had broken in two. 6. There is far too many sparks on the 2nd funnel, and it never exploded.# No hate is intened in this comment, just cunstructive critisism.
The plunge doesn’t start at 2:17 but late in to 2:16 personal i see as far more likely then 2:15. And one big thing the forward tower stays connected to the bow and during the dissent of the bow the bow swings to the right throwing the forward Tower a much less distance then if it was thrown off the stern I plan to go in more detail in a different video. And the stern starts rising 40 seconds after the break just at a low angle as some did see Titanic not rise for 2 minutes. And they still are able to see the break. Also if Titanic dosen’t buckle how can people like Jack Thayer who saw titanic buckle before the break. Thank you for the feedback I will use some of this advice.
@@SyAnimates Okay so, the bow cannot throw the FT, try bow never spun or would’ve had enough momentum to through it at all. And Jack Thayer saying she buckled was most likely him saying she broke. When you look into how she was built and designed she cannot buckle and still rise. And the plunge doesn’t start at 2:15 it starts at 2:16 and it happening at late 2:16 doesn’t make sense tbh from my analysis and research.
@@DannyDraws1912 I don’t think the bow spun i plan to talk more that in a later video but to try to explain it now the bow head towards the sea floor with bow swinging left to right a about 5-10° a couple time first to the left making the forward tower weak then swinging to the right throwing the forward Tower off. Back to Jack Thayer i beleave he says he sees the ship “bow and buckle” before mentioning the fall of the 2nd funnel all through i may be wrong.
@@SyAnimates Jack Thayer seen the “buckling” after the 2nd funnel collapse and no matter if the bow is rocking or not it cannot throw the FT away. Also btw do u have discord? I have a lot of diagrams and papers bout this thing and I could explain it better there
I love watching your videos!
Thank you so much!
This look amazing, very well done for a 2D animation, The theory looks accurate, but I suggest to remove the buckling when the 2nd funnel falls, the forward tower should stay intact, the 4th funnel should fall to port or shouldn't fall at all, If you want a time later than 2:15, I would suggest 2:16 and around 45-50 seconds before 2:17, and the officer shooting himself should be at 2:14.
I will say my theory has changed for example I’ve replaced the buckling with the ship slowly bending over time i will take some of this in to account although the officer shooting i still think would make sense to have it take place just a couple seconds before the 1st funnel collapses thanks for the feedback.
@@SyAnimates I do see what you mean on why you make the officer shoot himself, it would make sense because during the final plunge, a lot of things are happening at once, I'm sorry, the officer shooting himself is supposed to happen at 2:14, however this may change at anytime because, research.
The animation is very good but i have a few problems with this theory,
1. 2:17AM is too late for the ship to start plunging at, If this happened Boat A would of cleared the ship and Boat B would never get to the starboard side.
2. She cant buckle and continue to rise, once she buckles she will fail.
3. The FT coming off at the surface, Ive explainned this before but if it comes off at the surface it will never go far east and will end up in the hypocenter.
4. The even keel wasnt caused by flooding of a boiler room, It was the collapse of a bulkhead inside the ship. This can aslo be linked to the deep exlosions heard from Titanic at her plunge.
5. 2 minutes is too long for the stern to settle for, If this happpened peoples eyes would adjust and they would see that she had broken in two.
6. There is far too many sparks on the 2nd funnel, and it never exploded.#
No hate is intened in this comment, just cunstructive critisism.
The plunge doesn’t start at 2:17 but late in to 2:16 personal i see as far more likely then 2:15. And one big thing the forward tower stays connected to the bow and during the dissent of the bow the bow swings to the right throwing the forward Tower a much less distance then if it was thrown off the stern I plan to go in more detail in a different video. And the stern starts rising 40 seconds after the break just at a low angle as some did see Titanic not rise for 2 minutes. And they still are able to see the break. Also if Titanic dosen’t buckle how can people like Jack Thayer who saw titanic buckle before the break.
Thank you for the feedback I will use some of this advice.
Also sorry for replying so late
@@SyAnimates Okay so, the bow cannot throw the FT, try bow never spun or would’ve had enough momentum to through it at all. And Jack Thayer saying she buckled was most likely him saying she broke. When you look into how she was built and designed she cannot buckle and still rise. And the plunge doesn’t start at 2:15 it starts at 2:16 and it happening at late 2:16 doesn’t make sense tbh from my analysis and research.
@@DannyDraws1912 I don’t think the bow spun i plan to talk more that in a later video but to try to explain it now the bow head towards the sea floor with bow swinging left to right a about 5-10° a couple time first to the left making the forward tower weak then swinging to the right throwing the forward Tower off. Back to Jack Thayer i beleave he says he sees the ship “bow and buckle” before mentioning the fall of the 2nd funnel all through i may be wrong.
@@SyAnimates Jack Thayer seen the “buckling” after the 2nd funnel collapse and no matter if the bow is rocking or not it cannot throw the FT away. Also btw do u have discord? I have a lot of diagrams and papers bout this thing and I could explain it better there
The sounds credits to 1997 film Titanic
I mean other then the prayers sounds I didn’t use the movie sound effects but I will credit them now that I realize I didn’t