We from Borneo, Sabah and Sarawak are watching this very closely. If the Malay Muslims in Peninsular Malaysia reject the Rukun Negara, this will make us question our participation in forming Malaysia in the first place.
Islam not the monster, but the wrong teaching are the cause of the issue, “Islam reform” can be better future or worse. Freedom of humanity are the basic.
Dear Prof, for the sake and survival of our beloved country, please continue to actively share and instill your well-balanced thinking and values here and on other widely-accessed platforms.
Yes, some rohingyas refugees here even claimed Malaya is part of Rakine, Nyammar & belonged to their ancestors who were in it before any other creeds came & settled in Malaya.
To be honest... Look like malays in peninsular moving toward extreme belief. This country should be religion Free. This is what happen when one is mixed up with political system.
The original aim of Rukun Negara is good. It's just that those who have a twist n turn of the meaning of the wording to suit the needs of extreme religious requirements for their political gains. The view of the Prof. is very precise n clear from a Muslim point of view of the religion. A very thank you for your open minded view of the Rukun Negara for the country😮😊
But to some fanatics who have been brainwashed & Indoctrinated since young, that their abrahamic religions of the middle east desert is the most supreme, its God is all almighty and only it can save them. Non-believers are outcasts, sinners, infidels, heretics, zombies, etc.
Yes pls, it should not be who's born in this land but who can do better in embodying the core spirit of Malaysia. If they are born here but cannot contribute to the society's core values, then please leave, or make it simple just go to the north Islamic States.
KJ is good to be the front and role model for all, prof is good for behind the scene work if he is truly what he preach, by changing the system behind Islamic education from the ground up.
Can I ask what the present YDPA will do about it for his majesty is the head of Islam in this country. I remember very clearly when his majesty was installed as the YDPA he mentioned very sternly that he has his own ways of governing this country. Therefore surely his majesty can do something about extremism and Muslim extremists in this country can't he?
If you think about it, it is almost like a problem left behind by British for us to solve. If that fail in Malaysia, it means it fail on global stage where the world are split into Muslim vs Non-Muslim. If we succeed then the world has found an alternative.
Perfectly true, all you say. There many of us older people who share your values. Unfortunately the decay has progressed far and words only won't suffice. Do you have any thoughts on how to nudge the society in the direction of Rukunegara.
Its quite sad that in 2024 that certain segment of society is destroying all that is good in this nation?. This notion that "we are the majority and you need to respect us (our wishes)" is very very dangerous because it goes against the whole concept of the formation of the federation. Malaysia does not include only Malaya or the Malays, no? It includes Sabah and Sarawak peoples.
Yes, they are the majority, if whatever their overzealous selves to impose their tyrannical majority on others, then they regress themselves to be the minority, because the Truth is the majority as it is the Truth.
@@apaichuat167 ketuanan are necessary for the political elites and career politicians to enrich themselves. It's based on Marxist theory that the subordination of one group of people to benefit another group, and continue the growth of one's social status.
Well said. Please stand for election as the 3rd force and the people will strongly voice that you be given the ministerial position for religious affairs
When we gain independence from the British, the Rukunegara is drafted by the government to enable all of us to follow. I remember when I was in school during assembly, we recite the Rukunegara & also sing the National Anthem " Negara Ku". The politicians of today must ensure that the Rukunegara is followed & do not go astray from the Rukunegara to benefit themselves. The religion especially Islam do not go against the Rukunegara.
Prof....you can suggest many thing which is good for the country but political party will break the law and the Government afraid to take serious action 😂😂
Not so true. Because some religions teach that believe in its Him or Deity, god to Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'good' to yearn for. Don't believe in Him, go to Hell ie punishment by fear terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life. Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity to suffer.
Not so true. Because some religions teach that believe in Him or its Godhead, go to Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'godly' they so yearn for. Don't believe, go to Hell ie punishment by fear for terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life. Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity into various groups to fight & suffer.
WE TALKED ABOUT RUKUN NEGARA WHY U DIVERT THE ISSUE TO PMX AND PALASTINE ARE U ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF WALAUN DIE HARD FAN WHO ALWAYS KNOCKED AT TOILET DOOR
The Islamic Reform is the main reason that many Malays have become extremists today. The term extremists are more accurate than conservatives for these people. Because there are many conservatives who are not extremists. So we need an alternative to the Islamic Reform because obviously it didn't work to make PAS and fans happy. Why should we bow to them anyway? We need the majority of the population to have a critical, independent thinking as well as courageous like you, Prof. This needs to start from public education.
Undang- undang Malaysia ikut darjat contoh orang biasa Hina sultan dapat hukuman cepat kalau pemimpin atau orang berpangkat mengambil masa yang lama pergi mahkamah di tangguh - tangguh sampai lebih kurang setahun. Kalau ada sosiomedia mereka keluar8 kenyataan terus dakwa tak tinggil reman terus dakwa di mahkamah seperti orang biasa
Perhaps it is now time for Jakim to go learn from department Agama Indonesia how to administer and run a multi religious country. Jakim despite its large budget allocation does not appear competent to discharge their duty and responsibilities. Time to learn.
Indonesia are also merely tapping in the dark like us, there are simply no symbolic role model for a progressive Islamic country as of yet, we are touted to be one but we only adhere to live & let live status quo mantra, meaning many problems are simply sweep under the rug. Indonesia itself have try to ban hijab again & again but fail while Tajikistan a Muslim majority country is able to do it.
After explaining the Rukun Negara in the islamic way I'm sure they will look at it from the islamic lense and makes things worse that it is already is currently. Being the dominant race doenst give you the pass to "demand" respect, it is Earned.
To insist they are the majority & could do what they want without basing on the Federal Constitution of the Federation is tyranny of the majority. Hence their majority is in fact a minority.
Exactly why “Malay hero” brought up by Prof Is not gona work because the more you pander to Muslim, the more they double down on the illusion of “Islam is beautiful” which will only lead us down a tunnel vision. Islam does not teach them the value of introspection or gratitude. Remember when the Malay goalkeeper in Singapore somehow help China stay in the World Cup qualifying match? So the Chinese netizen & people from China started showering the Malay goalkeeper with love, affection, money, fame then in return you see many Malay netizen commenting thanking Allah for rezekit. So whatever good deeds you did for them, it doesn’t go into the Malay “Trust fund”, it only make their Allah stronger then after that it come back and bite you by forcing you to be Islamic.
Rukun Negara Malaysia adalah satu2 ringkasan yg tepat pemikiran noble & falsafah dari cara hidup yg murni, budaya, tradisi, pusaka dan tamaddun bangsa2 Nusantara khas nya, dan Kemanusiaan pada am nya. Amat di-kesali jikalau ia nya di-abaikan olih mana2 pihak yg mereka adalah berbagai warganegara2 Malaya, Sabah dan Sarawak ie Satu Malaysia yg maju, progresif dan gemilang. 😊
Very insightful! I wonder why the governments then and now, as well as the _authorities_ allowed certain sections of the country to keep on tearing the social fabric, and thus weakened the nation building...
Those who wrote and approved even before merdeka in the way that we still know is because of the multi races in the country back then and its still multi races today. Not everything can be Islamise. Its selfish to not be sensitive to all other races in the country.
No good enough, some Muslim fanatics asserted to believe only in their Islam & Allah, and only these can save people to Paradise, otherwise shall go to Hell hereafter life. What these treacherous teachings, and to believe, worship & idolise someone else's creeds invented religion which is from an outside & far away middle east desert primitive civilization.
I have high respect for not only Islam, but also other religions. When l was eating with my Malay neighbours in their house, in the sixties, l always ate with my fingers, although l was offered with folk n spoon.I believe, every religion, including Islam, teaches us to respect other religions or races, not bad mouthing or hating each other. But now, l m confused that one Mufti saying one thing n the other saying the reverse : who to follow ? We elect law makers to talk about politics, such as how to improve the economy, progress n uplifting the peoples livelihood : not capitalising only on religion. It’s very sad n frustrating to hear this sort of argument or attire restrictions every day instead of talking something constructive. Take a stick from some Islamic countries in the Middle East, such as UAE, Saudi Arabia, Turkey n see how open minded n progressive they r. Let’s move forward for the sake of the country n our future generations. Happy 67th. Merdeka.
But then do most Muslims (not all) respect you? Because to them, those who are NOT believers or followers of Islam are considered as outcasts, sinners, infidels, heretics, zombies, etc, right?
The Rukunegara is preceded by an ikhrar/pledge. In this pledge is the intention to create a modern liberal and progressive country. Only after the pledge is followed the 5 tenets of the Rukunegara. Why is it now the ikhrar/pledge is no longer mentioned and we only hear the 5 tenets of the Rukunegara?
i agree fully. through my interactions with muslims in tiktok, certain muslims will use only rukun negara to thier convenience only and will reject totally if it is against them. when Hadi ridiculed the dressing of none muslims, they will say please follow kesopanan dan kesusilaan. when the gambling companies were favored by the court over the ban of gambling in kedah, they forget about keluhuran perlembangan and kedaulatan undang undang and insisted that the court has made a mistake. 😅😅😅
Rukun Negara was written for ALL Malaysians and was unquestioned. Why now create a controversy about it. Islamic extremism by PAS was rejected by ALL Malaysians- including Malay Muslims. Why pander to PAS extremism?
Prof…it already started…example national flag is not raise with national anthem played…or rather foreign flag is raised with Malaysian Anthem…& no action is being taken
When will a Muslim convey a message to Muslim majority that they are not the only one capable of being conservative. Look at the West, the only demographic left supporting Palestinian are LGBTQ or liberal type. Without liberal, there is only conservative West & touch wood, not a Nazi type. Extremism will only lead to extremism but Muslim love to take advantage as if the world owes it to them. Like I have always emphasis, Islam has a systematic problem therefor moderate Muslim always lose but somehow the non-Muslim has to be the one responsible in fixing it?
Opium war, British allow the destruction of their asset so that they can fight legitimately. World war 2, British sacrifice their whole naval fleet even though they have crack the German Enigma encryption knowing the Nazi Germany would be launching an attack, just so they can win the overall war. Pearl Harbor, despite many early warning by their own inteligence or their counterpart from China on the impending Japanese attack, US chose to ignore it and let the attack happen. “Coincidently”, they only move their carrier away from the island before the attack. 🤔 Oct 7, Israel intelligence are known to be one of the best and is aware of Hamas attack but they let it happen, why? So they have legitimate reason to escalate the conflict now. The UK riot against Muslim is 20 years in the making, not a coincidence. Why do Muslim like to take people for granted and believe the West only have idiot left? When Nazi were bombing the brits, they were still hanging out at pub as if nothing happen but when they fight, they will fight hard. Lastly since Prof Tajudin like to explain everything from Islamic way then I will do it from a very theology point of view. Muslim believe in the zaman akhir right? So why does the Muslim fear that Zaman akhir is approaching when Muslim is the fastest growing religion & world largest religion now? If one is to corrrelate, doesn’t it mean Islam is like agama sesat, the more they grow the faster our world end? Finally the infamous biblical revelation 9:16 spoke of 200million mounted troops coming from the East. Many associate it with China but even they may have the largest army in the world, it is still not enough to fit the biblical description of 200million…unless they incorporate AI, Drone, & robotic warfare. From the Ukrainian war we can already see human are like cannon fodder, relic of the past when drone are utilize heavily to turn the tide of the war. Now we all know the smartphone we use are the biggest spy device on earth but what we do not know is they are capable of detonating it by overheating the battery through remote malicious or built-in code, or it is simply a locking device that triangulate our gps location. US is already capable of taking out Iraq within 3 days 20 years ago. Now when we utilize AI, Drone, robotic, and many other new tech in modern warfare, things would happen so fast we won’t even know what happens as all the attack can happened pre-programmed to target all the pre-mapped hostile target while sitting at home, in mosque. In office, etc. 200million troops from the East is no longer a fairy tale but a possibility that one can make it a reality. If believer already believe in end of days, non-believer always have the option to make it happen for them since we ran out of choice to co-exist.
Nasihat utk Prof.: Prof. kena memiliki kedudukan dalam Gov. ex Menteri level so apa falsafah atau teori atau pemikiran positif yg pernah dibincangkan dalam youtube menjadi realisasi. Kalau tidak semua akan menjadi seperti “masuk telinga kiri keluar telinga kanan”. Sy penyokong kuat Prof.
The current ISTAC is no longer the original institution of what it was aspired to be by its founder, Professor Dr. Syed Naquib al-Attas. Some politicians have hijacked it and even removed the professor from ISTAC many years ago. Please consult with his son, Datuk Dr. Syed Ali Tawfik al-Attas on this matter.
If you prof Tajuddin can think of this farsighted view to safe our dear country, then i seriously think that our minister of religious affair need to resign as they are what you call "makan gaji buta" saje!!!
Wake up, it is time to acknowledge that the years of Arabisation of Malaysia has failed the country. When I was a high school student, I questioned my niqab fashioned Malay Teacher from Kelantan that the first principle of RK should be the least important as religion is a personal individual matter, rather the last Principle , courteous respect of one another and moral discipline are the top priority. She could not argue with convincing facts but continued to be deluded in Arab fantacy. The RK is actually a product of cold war, after the second world war, The religious Catholics Nazi alliance lost to the Soviet Union Communist block, the WASP ( White Anglo Saxon Protestant) led by US UK lauches massive scale of anti communist propaganda against the communist block. The right wing Catholics are stauch supporters of the Spanish Franco regime and the Ngo Dim Diem Catholic government of South Vietnam. With the geopolitical conflict, the US CIA masterminded a coup to topple the Indonesian Sukarno government .The coup was bloody with the religious group in alliance with the right wing group massacred the left wing group in Indonesia.Half a million of Indonesian were massacred . The Malaysian RK is faulty in comparison to the Indonesian Pancasila for the Pancasila fortunately included the Buddhist priciple of Bhineka Tunggal Eka from Kekawin Sutasoma. The Malaysian history book teaches the student that RK was formed after May 13 to curb communism . The communist phobia has been successfully implanted by US during the cold war. One should understand that the first principle of RK is fallacious as monotheism is inherently intolerant, the UN Israel Ambassador demonstrated it blatantly in his speech, Israel is the most Moral country in the world. Monotheism is self evidently a humanitarian disaster as demonstrated by the purest form of monotheism, Zionism. You can call it Nazism .
The problem is never the people its the politicians who creat all these problems for their benefit.All we need is a dynamic leader with integriti and will power but so far non.
Why every little thing in Msia has be explained in the Islamic way ? Why everything is centred on religion ? Isn't religion supposed to be personal ? Between u n God ?
Bukan jenis calang2 rasanya nak ubah nusantara kepada islam. Jenis2 tertentu makin ramai akan terpesong jauh. Tadi apa? Pengedar dadah apa? Jenis anda.
Malays are the majority. Being the majority they already have all the rights they want. They don't need to ask for more. It is the minority that needs support. Being majority doesnt mean you take everything. If you are 60%, you take only 60%. That's all. You don't take 100%. If the minority is 25%, they deserve 25%. 60% does not equal 100%. Malays must remember this. Saying they are the majority and must be respected is merely stating the obvious. It does not mean they have the right to decide everything to their satisfaction. It means the majority has to take into account the rights of the minority. This idea of taking everything stems from greed. The political elites of the past have taken everything that can be taken. Now the present political elites want something. Where to get it? From the non Malays. That is the political basis of "the majority must take everything". This idea must be resisted. Malays can take 60% of what the govt can offer. Not those belonging to the non Malays. That's it.
Rukun Negara amat penting bagi setiap rakyat yg berbilang kaum di Malaysia,ia termasuk sistem perlembagaan dan raja2 melayu juga.Yg kata x penting tu cuba nak bawa agenda sendiri apa yg parti pembangkang sebut sila lihat cermin dahulu sbb cakap lain buat lain.
Why does the PANCASILA work for Indonesian Muslims and the RUKUN NEGARA does not for Malaysian muslims ? Perhaps it is the way Islam is practiced in each of the countries.
Many still do not have understanding on the subject of Civil Rights...its somewhat of equality except that other races respect the bumiputra status of Malay rights and privelege. As for non malays...some rights and equality should be applied with fairness. Equality has some limits for other races here. To be fair...be Just and Fair.
So sorry professor ur UMAT UMAT is more to religion than their country, any where in the world your umat UMAT love more their religion than their country even in non Muslims countries or Muslim country they are not patriotic
What you say is true. They are not patriotic. They are willing to forsake this country for the sake of their religion. Their religion goes number one. Country and the rest is not important. Or worse, they want this country all for themselves. They want others to become slaves or ousted from this country.
@@faizanuar850 so you are saying after we follow Allah teaching we will reach wawasan 2020? That means east side of Malaysia is more developed than West side, like the incredible water infrastructure in Kelantan? Or the same pattern with all Islamic countries where they all rely on petroleum money, basically haram money paid by the West? Petrodollar, ring a bell?
Dear Prof Tajuddin, I always thought (1) Race supremacy was unconstitutional. (2) Freedom of religion was enshrined in our constitution. Can we just run our nation constitutionally?
That is the cunning part about British (they are known for it), our constitution is pretty much about race supremacy and they know how well it blends with Islamic teaching where Quran focus on Muslim vs non-Muslim like Bumiputera vs non-Bumiputera, the like of Jizya is like Quota system or alibaba business mantra to tax non-Muslim. The reason British did it this way as a mean for us to solve (or scapegoat), or they know it is the next problem after 20th-21st century because Islamic philosophy is unlike Chinese one, there is no flexibility, only fight fire with fire, this would put Islam on direct crash course with Western civilisation
Not all Religions teach good. There are some religions which teach that believe in Him or its Godhead, go to eternal Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'divine' to they so yearn for. Don't believe, go to eternal Hell ie punishment by fear for terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life. Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity into various groups to fight & suffer.
Oh, prof, Jakim and Pmx/Jkom should lead the charge and counterpropaganda/narrative by fed govt based on your suggestions among others to that of the oppo, not unity or education ministry. They wont listen to a nonm. Someone accused others as dajjal. NGOs like Abim, Ikram etc should intensify their reach.
Hang tak payah cakap rukun negara culture kita juga pon kita buang jauh kerana ada ahli agama dalam Malaysia kata itu haram, syiriklah, padahal kalau hang kaji betoi² tidak ada kaitan dengan bertentangan islam, kita lani lebih pentingkan budaya Arab daripada budaya sendiri, padahal islam tidak pernah suruh jadi seperti arab untuk jadi muslim yang baik, kita di ambang kritikal sekarang, edukasi harus di update guru² harus berkelayakan tinggi untuk mengajar, kita menuju ke ambang menjadi seperti iran, Afghanistan sekarang, pasanglah seat belt kuat²
![MISSING: SLIM SHADY [Expanded Mourner’s Edition Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xh8qgHrOO1g/mqdefault.jpg)
SAY NO TO PASuai. SAY NO TO KHAWARIJ. SAY NO TO EXTREMISM. SELAMATKAN MALAYSIA TERCINTA.
We from Borneo, Sabah and Sarawak are watching this very closely. If the Malay Muslims in Peninsular Malaysia reject the Rukun Negara, this will make us question our participation in forming Malaysia in the first place.
Rukun negara comes after Malaysia was formed.😊
Borneo agama bebas
@@nadaiduit Don't bull.
Islam not the monster, but the wrong teaching are the cause of the issue, “Islam reform” can be better future or worse. Freedom of humanity are the basic.
MA63 reigns supreme.
Dear Prof, for the sake and survival of our beloved country, please continue to actively share and instill your well-balanced thinking and values here and on other widely-accessed platforms.
Thank You My Good Sir,for Your Wonderful And Courageous Masterpiece Presentation.This Is What We Call,Person With A Reformist Appeal,Replica Tak Mahu.
And they accuse the non-Malays for not being loyal to the country.
Now they are saying non malay are not part of malaysia already
What about the org Asli
Yes, some rohingyas refugees here even claimed Malaya is part of Rakine, Nyammar & belonged to their ancestors who were in it before any other creeds came & settled in Malaya.
As for me, i'm not bothered what those type say . My birth cert & I.C. is officially recognised.
To be honest... Look like malays in peninsular moving toward extreme belief. This country should be religion Free. This is what happen when one is mixed up with political system.
Those who cannot accept Rukun Negara should have their citizenship stripped.
Why?
I do think so
The original aim of Rukun Negara is good. It's just that those who have a twist n turn of the meaning of the wording to suit the needs of extreme religious requirements for their political gains. The view of the Prof. is very precise n clear from a Muslim point of view of the religion. A very thank you for your open minded view of the Rukun Negara for the country😮😊
But to some fanatics who have been brainwashed & Indoctrinated since young, that their abrahamic religions of the middle east desert is the most supreme, its God is all almighty and only it can save them. Non-believers are outcasts, sinners, infidels, heretics, zombies, etc.
Yes pls, it should not be who's born in this land but who can do better in embodying the core spirit of Malaysia. If they are born here but cannot contribute to the society's core values, then please leave, or make it simple just go to the north Islamic States.
Very practical solutions - thanks Prof, hopefully PMX or someone of authority will take notice and consider your proposal.
We need less of KJ and more of you
KJ is good to be the front and role model for all, prof is good for behind the scene work if he is truly what he preach, by changing the system behind Islamic education from the ground up.
Can I ask what the present YDPA will do about it for his majesty is the head of Islam in this country. I remember very clearly when his majesty was installed as the YDPA he mentioned very sternly that he has his own ways of governing this country. Therefore surely his majesty can do something about extremism and Muslim extremists in this country can't he?
If Rukun Negara cannot be accepted by Malayans then Malaysia has failed, then lets dissolve the federaion.
If you think about it, it is almost like a problem left behind by British for us to solve. If that fail in Malaysia, it means it fail on global stage where the world are split into Muslim vs Non-Muslim. If we succeed then the world has found an alternative.
When you finally understood why RN was drafted, congrat. you have reached the enlightenment. I am not at liberty to tell.
Perfectly true, all you say. There many of us older people who share your values.
Unfortunately the decay has progressed far and words only won't suffice.
Do you have any thoughts on how to nudge the society in the direction of Rukunegara.
Its quite sad that in 2024 that certain segment of society is destroying all that is good in this nation?. This notion that "we are the majority and you need to respect us (our wishes)" is very very dangerous because it goes against the whole concept of the formation of the federation. Malaysia does not include only Malaya or the Malays, no? It includes Sabah and Sarawak peoples.
Yes, they are the majority, if whatever their overzealous selves to impose their tyrannical majority on others, then they regress themselves to be the minority, because the Truth is the majority as it is the Truth.
Malay muslims all has the same "entitled" mentality. Truth. Period. Bitter pill to swallow but thats the reality
I have to apologize professor
Rukun negara meaningless if those people claim that they are greater and above than others
Which is basically why secular society find them to be a threat be it in the West or the East.
@@kokwuilennonchong1116nobody like others taking advantage of your hospitality, stay in your house rent free and eat free.
Who is paying most the taxes and bringing fame to Malaysia thru sports , invention and businesses @@nadaiduit
We should not had ketuanan in the first place.
@@apaichuat167 ketuanan are necessary for the political elites and career politicians to enrich themselves. It's based on Marxist theory that the subordination of one group of people to benefit another group, and continue the growth of one's social status.
Excellent talk. Everyone should understood and respect Rukun Negara.
Well said. Please stand for election as the 3rd force and the people will strongly voice that you be given the ministerial position for religious affairs
Thank you for your intuitive information 🙏 I could learn a lot from you.
When we gain independence from the British, the Rukunegara is drafted by the government to enable all of us to follow. I remember when I was in school during assembly, we recite the Rukunegara & also sing the National Anthem " Negara Ku". The politicians of today must ensure that the Rukunegara is followed & do not go astray from the Rukunegara to benefit themselves. The religion especially Islam do not go against the Rukunegara.
Dr is a real Malaysian for the progression of the nation.
Prof....you can suggest many thing which is good for the country but political party will break the law and the Government afraid to take serious action 😂😂
Give respect and take respect.Not only theory practical is more important. Action speak louder than words
All religion teaches.postive side.GOD IS LOVE.
Not so true. Because some religions teach that believe in its Him or Deity, god to Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'good' to yearn for.
Don't believe in Him, go to Hell ie punishment by fear terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life.
Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity to suffer.
Not so true. Because some religions teach that believe in Him or its Godhead, go to Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'godly' they so yearn for.
Don't believe, go to Hell ie punishment by fear for terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life.
Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity into various groups to fight & suffer.
I cannot disagree. Above all your passion for truthful expression is anchored in your courage.
We are moving into a Fanatic Malaysia
Professor, today I am told pmx son in law is a palistanian , no wonder pmx is so concerned of palistanian problems.
WE TALKED ABOUT RUKUN NEGARA WHY U DIVERT THE ISSUE TO PMX AND PALASTINE ARE U ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF WALAUN DIE HARD FAN WHO ALWAYS KNOCKED AT TOILET DOOR
No true
The programe is "Live. Presence worship on the streets of Zwolle the Netherlands"
The Islamic Reform is the main reason that many Malays have become extremists today. The term extremists are more accurate than conservatives for these people. Because there are many conservatives who are not extremists.
So we need an alternative to the Islamic Reform because obviously it didn't work to make PAS and fans happy. Why should we bow to them anyway?
We need the majority of the population to have a critical, independent thinking as well as courageous like you, Prof. This needs to start from public education.
Undang- undang Malaysia ikut darjat contoh orang biasa Hina sultan dapat hukuman cepat kalau pemimpin atau orang berpangkat mengambil masa yang lama pergi mahkamah di tangguh - tangguh sampai lebih kurang setahun. Kalau ada sosiomedia mereka keluar8 kenyataan terus dakwa tak tinggil reman terus dakwa di mahkamah seperti orang biasa
I salute you Sir.
Rukun Negara is for all malaysian.
Dearest Professor Tajuddin
Well said, agreed 💯
Perhaps it is now time for Jakim to go learn from department Agama Indonesia how to administer and run a multi religious country.
Jakim despite its large budget allocation does not appear competent to discharge their duty and responsibilities.
Time to learn.
Indonesia are also merely tapping in the dark like us, there are simply no symbolic role model for a progressive Islamic country as of yet, we are touted to be one but we only adhere to live & let live status quo mantra, meaning many problems are simply sweep under the rug. Indonesia itself have try to ban hijab again & again but fail while Tajikistan a Muslim majority country is able to do it.
Cerminkan diri sendiri.Noone is perfect to condem.
True PROF 😊
After explaining the Rukun Negara in the islamic way I'm sure they will look at it from the islamic lense and makes things worse that it is already is currently.
Being the dominant race doenst give you the pass to "demand" respect, it is Earned.
To insist they are the majority & could do what they want without basing on the Federal Constitution of the Federation is tyranny of the majority. Hence their majority is in fact a minority.
Exactly why “Malay hero” brought up by Prof Is not gona work because the more you pander to Muslim, the more they double down on the illusion of “Islam is beautiful” which will only lead us down a tunnel vision. Islam does not teach them the value of introspection or gratitude. Remember when the Malay goalkeeper in Singapore somehow help China stay in the World Cup qualifying match? So the Chinese netizen & people from China started showering the Malay goalkeeper with love, affection, money, fame then in return you see many Malay netizen commenting thanking Allah for rezekit. So whatever good deeds you did for them, it doesn’t go into the Malay “Trust fund”, it only make their Allah stronger then after that it come back and bite you by forcing you to be Islamic.
Rukun Negara Malaysia adalah satu2 ringkasan yg tepat pemikiran noble & falsafah dari cara hidup yg murni, budaya, tradisi, pusaka dan tamaddun bangsa2 Nusantara khas nya, dan Kemanusiaan pada am nya.
Amat di-kesali jikalau ia nya di-abaikan olih mana2 pihak yg mereka adalah berbagai warganegara2 Malaya, Sabah dan Sarawak ie Satu Malaysia yg maju, progresif dan gemilang. 😊
Saya tak pasti sek kebangsaan Dan sek agama ada ajar topik Rukun Negara.Semasa 1119,nampak ramai tak tau ,tertanya-tanya apa itu Rukun Negara.
Very insightful!
I wonder why the governments then and now, as well as the _authorities_ allowed certain sections of the country to keep on tearing the social fabric, and thus weakened the nation building...
Those who wrote and approved even before merdeka in the way that we still know is because of the multi races in the country back then and its still multi races today. Not everything can be Islamise. Its selfish to not be sensitive to all other races in the country.
To all Malaysian to be Reminded Rukun negara first line is
Kepercayaan kepada Tuhan.......
Tuhan siapa?
@@hiiwei80tuhan alam ini
No good enough, some Muslim fanatics asserted to believe only in their Islam & Allah, and only these can save people to Paradise, otherwise shall go to Hell hereafter life.
What these treacherous teachings, and to believe, worship & idolise someone else's creeds invented religion which is from an outside & far away middle east desert primitive civilization.
Kau warga china pasaipa sibuk dengan negara orang, pergi berambuslah kau
I have high respect for not only Islam, but also other religions. When l was eating with my Malay neighbours in their house, in the sixties, l always ate with my fingers, although l was offered with folk n spoon.I believe, every religion, including Islam, teaches us to respect other religions or races, not bad mouthing or hating each other. But now, l m confused that one Mufti saying one thing n the other saying the reverse : who to follow ? We elect law makers to talk about politics, such as how to improve the economy, progress n uplifting the peoples livelihood : not capitalising only on religion. It’s very sad n frustrating to hear this sort of argument or attire restrictions every day instead of talking something constructive. Take a stick from some Islamic countries in the Middle East, such as UAE, Saudi Arabia, Turkey n see how open minded n progressive they r. Let’s move forward for the sake of the country n our future generations. Happy 67th. Merdeka.
But then do most Muslims (not all) respect you?
Because to them, those who are NOT believers or followers of Islam are considered as outcasts, sinners, infidels, heretics, zombies, etc, right?
Religion is someting personal between YOU & GOD..SELF RELIAZATION.Relationship between.you & GOD.Why jugdge others.You are not GOD to judge others.
The Malays are minority in the worldwide population. How do Malays want to be treated on the world stage?
Yes, by creeds, only the Hindus & Chinese are the 2 biggest majorities in the World.
@@aeronhong4998 many operate on the premise that if you can't take on from without, then take on from within. Typical Ah Q-ism.
The Rukunegara is preceded by an ikhrar/pledge. In this pledge is the intention to create a modern liberal and progressive country. Only after the pledge is followed the 5 tenets of the Rukunegara. Why is it now the ikhrar/pledge is no longer mentioned and we only hear the 5 tenets of the Rukunegara?
i agree fully. through my interactions with muslims in tiktok, certain muslims will use only rukun negara to thier convenience only and will reject totally if it is against them. when Hadi ridiculed the dressing of none muslims, they will say please follow kesopanan dan kesusilaan. when the gambling companies were favored by the court over the ban of gambling in kedah, they forget about keluhuran perlembangan and kedaulatan undang undang and insisted that the court has made a mistake. 😅😅😅
Is the School of Islamic teachings espoused in Malaysia considered fundamental, deviant, or extremist in the view of the global Islamic community?
Rukun Negara was written for ALL Malaysians and was unquestioned. Why now create a controversy about it. Islamic extremism by PAS was rejected by ALL Malaysians- including Malay Muslims. Why pander to PAS extremism?
This is where they are not taught..
Prof, it's already at the point of no return.
Prof…it already started…example national flag is not raise with national anthem played…or rather foreign flag is raised with Malaysian Anthem…& no action is being taken
Finally prof thanks for stating facts
When will a Muslim convey a message to Muslim majority that they are not the only one capable of being conservative. Look at the West, the only demographic left supporting Palestinian are LGBTQ or liberal type. Without liberal, there is only conservative West & touch wood, not a Nazi type. Extremism will only lead to extremism but Muslim love to take advantage as if the world owes it to them. Like I have always emphasis, Islam has a systematic problem therefor moderate Muslim always lose but somehow the non-Muslim has to be the one responsible in fixing it?
Opium war, British allow the destruction of their asset so that they can fight legitimately.
World war 2, British sacrifice their whole naval fleet even though they have crack the German Enigma encryption knowing the Nazi Germany would be launching an attack, just so they can win the overall war.
Pearl Harbor, despite many early warning by their own inteligence or their counterpart from China on the impending Japanese attack, US chose to ignore it and let the attack happen. “Coincidently”, they only move their carrier away from the island before the attack. 🤔
Oct 7, Israel intelligence are known to be one of the best and is aware of Hamas attack but they let it happen, why? So they have legitimate reason to escalate the conflict now. The UK riot against Muslim is 20 years in the making, not a coincidence.
Why do Muslim like to take people for granted and believe the West only have idiot left? When Nazi were bombing the brits, they were still hanging out at pub as if nothing happen but when they fight, they will fight hard.
Lastly since Prof Tajudin like to explain everything from Islamic way then I will do it from a very theology point of view. Muslim believe in the zaman akhir right? So why does the Muslim fear that Zaman akhir is approaching when Muslim is the fastest growing religion & world largest religion now? If one is to corrrelate, doesn’t it mean Islam is like agama sesat, the more they grow the faster our world end?
Finally the infamous biblical revelation 9:16 spoke of 200million mounted troops coming from the East. Many associate it with China but even they may have the largest army in the world, it is still not enough to fit the biblical description of 200million…unless they incorporate AI, Drone, & robotic warfare.
From the Ukrainian war we can already see human are like cannon fodder, relic of the past when drone are utilize heavily to turn the tide of the war. Now we all know the smartphone we use are the biggest spy device on earth but what we do not know is they are capable of detonating it by overheating the battery through remote malicious or built-in code, or it is simply a locking device that triangulate our gps location.
US is already capable of taking out Iraq within 3 days 20 years ago. Now when we utilize AI, Drone, robotic, and many other new tech in modern warfare, things would happen so fast we won’t even know what happens as all the attack can happened pre-programmed to target all the pre-mapped hostile target while sitting at home, in mosque. In office, etc.
200million troops from the East is no longer a fairy tale but a possibility that one can make it a reality. If believer already believe in end of days, non-believer always have the option to make it happen for them since we ran out of choice to co-exist.
Give me the faith that I see in Palestinians. True Islam.
Sad...sad...sad...😰
In the present day, which Islamic country that Malaysia could emulate?
Malays are now more Arab than Malay?
Nasihat utk Prof.: Prof. kena memiliki kedudukan dalam Gov. ex Menteri level so apa falsafah atau teori atau pemikiran positif yg pernah dibincangkan dalam youtube menjadi realisasi. Kalau tidak semua akan menjadi seperti “masuk telinga kiri keluar telinga kanan”. Sy penyokong kuat Prof.
Kepercayaan kepada Tuhan. This applicanle for all Malaysian including non Muslim.
Non Muslim believe there is a Creator too
The current ISTAC is no longer the original institution of what it was aspired to be by its founder, Professor Dr. Syed Naquib al-Attas. Some politicians have hijacked it and even removed the professor from ISTAC many years ago.
Please consult with his son, Datuk Dr. Syed Ali Tawfik al-Attas on this matter.
❤❤❤
If you prof Tajuddin can think of this farsighted view to safe our dear country, then i seriously think that our minister of religious affair need to resign as they are what you call "makan gaji buta" saje!!!
Wake up, it is time to acknowledge that the years of Arabisation of Malaysia has failed the country. When I was a high school student, I questioned my niqab fashioned Malay Teacher from Kelantan that the first principle of RK should be the least important as religion is a personal individual matter, rather the last Principle , courteous respect of one another and moral discipline are the top priority. She could not argue with convincing facts but continued to be deluded in Arab fantacy.
The RK is actually a product of cold war, after the second world war, The religious Catholics Nazi alliance lost to the Soviet Union Communist block, the WASP ( White Anglo Saxon Protestant) led by US UK lauches massive scale of anti communist propaganda against the communist block.
The right wing Catholics are stauch supporters of the Spanish Franco regime and the Ngo Dim Diem Catholic government of South Vietnam.
With the geopolitical conflict, the US CIA masterminded a coup to topple the Indonesian Sukarno government .The coup was bloody with the religious group in alliance with the right wing group massacred the left wing group in Indonesia.Half a million of Indonesian were massacred .
The Malaysian RK is faulty in comparison to the Indonesian Pancasila for the Pancasila fortunately included the Buddhist priciple of Bhineka Tunggal Eka from Kekawin Sutasoma.
The Malaysian history book teaches the student that RK was formed after May 13 to curb communism . The communist phobia has been successfully implanted by US during the cold war.
One should understand that the first principle of RK is fallacious as monotheism is inherently intolerant, the UN Israel Ambassador demonstrated it blatantly in his speech, Israel is the most Moral country in the world. Monotheism is self evidently a humanitarian disaster as demonstrated by the purest form of monotheism, Zionism. You can call it Nazism .
How many years only realize?
The problem is never the people its the politicians who creat all these problems for their benefit.All we need is a dynamic leader with integriti and will power but so far non.
Malay Muslims must change . Too much of negative though in the mind & heart . PAS is a insane party . Liked wat TSVELU said . Byk org giler skrg . 😁🤭
The personnel giving out the tauliah are themselves not competent in Islamic teachings.
If Rukun Negara must explained in the framework of Islam, perhaps Malay Muslims must look toward hijrah to Saudi Arabia
Pas paling baik,pas paling jujur,pas paling jaga rakyat,pas ialah pilihan paling baik untuk semua rakyat malaysia.We choise pas to be gov.
Why every little thing in Msia has be explained in the Islamic way ? Why everything is centred on religion ? Isn't religion supposed to be personal ? Between u n God ?
Bukan jenis calang2 rasanya nak ubah nusantara kepada islam. Jenis2 tertentu makin ramai akan terpesong jauh. Tadi apa? Pengedar dadah apa? Jenis anda.
Malays are the majority. Being the majority they already have all the rights they want. They don't need to ask for more. It is the minority that needs support. Being majority doesnt mean you take everything. If you are 60%, you take only 60%. That's all. You don't take 100%. If the minority is 25%, they deserve 25%. 60% does not equal 100%. Malays must remember this. Saying they are the majority and must be respected is merely stating the obvious. It does not mean they have the right to decide everything to their satisfaction. It means the majority has to take into account the rights of the minority. This idea of taking everything stems from greed. The political elites of the past have taken everything that can be taken. Now the present political elites want something. Where to get it? From the non Malays. That is the political basis of "the majority must take everything". This idea must be resisted. Malays can take 60% of what the govt can offer. Not those belonging to the non Malays. That's it.
The govt even refuses to pay in full the 40% owed to Sabah. Where is the sincerity?
The nation was not founded by one racial group. Who fought for it.
Rukun Negara amat penting bagi setiap rakyat yg berbilang kaum di Malaysia,ia termasuk sistem perlembagaan dan raja2 melayu juga.Yg kata x penting tu cuba nak bawa agenda sendiri apa yg parti pembangkang sebut sila lihat cermin dahulu sbb cakap lain buat lain.
Pasberg. Now everyone can drink. Take beer.
Toddy is better😊
Why does the PANCASILA work for Indonesian Muslims and the RUKUN NEGARA does not for Malaysian muslims ? Perhaps it is the way Islam is practiced in each of the countries.
Many still do not have understanding on the subject of Civil Rights...its somewhat of equality except that other races respect the bumiputra status of Malay rights and privelege. As for non malays...some rights and equality should be applied with fairness. Equality has some limits for other races here. To be fair...be Just and Fair.
❤❤❤❤
🎉🎉🎉🎉
Ramai nama yg sokong aku x kenai.
.
Kepetcayaan kepada TUHAN.
So sorry professor ur UMAT UMAT is more to religion than their country, any where in the world your umat UMAT love more their religion than their country even in non Muslims countries or Muslim country they are not patriotic
What you say is true. They are not patriotic. They are willing to forsake this country for the sake of their religion. Their religion goes number one. Country and the rest is not important. Or worse, they want this country all for themselves. They want others to become slaves or ousted from this country.
Allah wants us to govern using Islamic teachings
What is Allah answer to wawasan 2020 which we have fail to achieve?
@@RetiredOrangUtan we didn’t follow his teachings so don’t expect much, alcohol and gambling is still not being banned
@@faizanuar850 so you are saying after we follow Allah teaching we will reach wawasan 2020? That means east side of Malaysia is more developed than West side, like the incredible water infrastructure in Kelantan? Or the same pattern with all Islamic countries where they all rely on petroleum money, basically haram money paid by the West? Petrodollar, ring a bell?
Politics and religion must be separated - if we speak of loyalty to country, which comes first- religion or country?
Dear Prof Tajuddin,
I always thought
(1) Race supremacy was unconstitutional.
(2) Freedom of religion was enshrined in our constitution.
Can we just run our nation constitutionally?
That is the cunning part about British (they are known for it), our constitution is pretty much about race supremacy and they know how well it blends with Islamic teaching where Quran focus on Muslim vs non-Muslim like Bumiputera vs non-Bumiputera, the like of Jizya is like Quota system or alibaba business mantra to tax non-Muslim. The reason British did it this way as a mean for us to solve (or scapegoat), or they know it is the next problem after 20th-21st century because Islamic philosophy is unlike Chinese one, there is no flexibility, only fight fire with fire, this would put Islam on direct crash course with Western civilisation
There seem to be a lot of hatred for other ppl. by some segment of society. Probably cooped up for too long and don't know how to interact anymore.
A saga constructed by ummo??
Not all Religions teach good. There are some religions which teach that believe in Him or its Godhead, go to eternal Paradise ie reward by greed for something 'divine' to they so yearn for.
Don't believe, go to eternal Hell ie punishment by fear for terrible things will happen to themselves, hereafter life.
Such toxic religious ideology based on greed & fear by 'carrot & stick' narrative breaks up & divides Humanity into various groups to fight & suffer.
Oh, prof, Jakim and Pmx/Jkom should lead the charge and counterpropaganda/narrative by fed govt based on your suggestions among others to that of the oppo, not unity or education ministry. They wont listen to a nonm. Someone accused others as dajjal. NGOs like Abim, Ikram etc should intensify their reach.
But corruption is always halal???
Hang tak payah cakap rukun negara culture kita juga pon kita buang jauh kerana ada ahli agama dalam Malaysia kata itu haram, syiriklah, padahal kalau hang kaji betoi² tidak ada kaitan dengan bertentangan islam, kita lani lebih pentingkan budaya Arab daripada budaya sendiri, padahal islam tidak pernah suruh jadi seperti arab untuk jadi muslim yang baik, kita di ambang kritikal sekarang, edukasi harus di update guru² harus berkelayakan tinggi untuk mengajar, kita menuju ke ambang menjadi seperti iran, Afghanistan sekarang, pasanglah seat belt kuat²
Satanic thought will bring great disasters, ask yourself do you see God with your religion, do your behaviour closer to God or closer to Satan.
Atuk A/L Mamak claimed that he was born a Malay Muslim....
But when he applied for university he put his race as Mamak
🤔🤔🤔
Only the religion of Islam is accepted by Allah
Another PROF NATO KANGKUNG statement 😮
Stupid is Stupid does.