Wow, I would have never guessed that Seohyun's grandma, who took care of her for most of her childhood, had passed away the very morning of this debut stage based on her stage performance. Years later she would say that she regretted not listening to her heart... Her innate professionalism and ability to grow and self reflect. Just another reason I love this woman!
The era when auto-tune was not yet a thing! The era when artists sounds like human... Nowadays, most music shows feature production numbers wherein artists sounds 'too good to be true', to the extent that you wouldn't even hear minor natural (but acceptable) flaws. You wouldn't even hear them breathe in between their lines. Most of them sound too mechanical, too robotic. I miss REAL music shows 😭😭😭💔💔💔
😊😊🔎 tanggal-4-11-2020.. hari rabu.. aku melihat youtube, menyimpan video & menulis komentar tentang girls' generation twinkle.. pada jam=22.05.. dengan baterai=25%.. didalam kamarku.. didalam rumahku.. do'aku hari ini adalah: ya allah subhanahu wa ta'ala.. aku ingin melihat konser girls' generation twinkle di korea.. amin ya rabbal alamin.. jusni lovely: girls 'generation twinkle..
5331 butterfly well I don’t wanna be rude and say they were lipsynking, but it really looks like Taeyeon was expecting her ad lib in this part to be on the MR... Cause the mic wouldn’t just stop exactly while her ad lib should be going on and then back to work perfectly right after.
They didn't. Tiffany is still promoting but in America (however she's still going to Korea. Proof is whenever she make appearance in tv shows that features the gg or other k-idol friends like Jessi.) Meanwhile, Seohyun is focusing in acting and I think she's still doing musical. They are still in the korean industry but in different fields.
this one... hmmm, i think much better if they chose jessica instead of seohyun.. just my opinion.. jessica's voice is really amazing and it blends well with taeyeon...
Same and they are the same size. I always think seohyun is so awkward. Makes me cringe a little looking at her. She doesn't look natural with her stage facials :(
At this time, Jessica was already busy in the fashion side for her clothing brand which is Blanc and Eclare to launch but the original subunit was TaeJessSeo which consists of her, Taeyeon and Seohyun.
During this time snsd had their own individual schedules. Jessica was busy doing the legally blonde musical and acting in a drama. The other members were busy in variety shows and dramas. Taetiseo specially wanted to work with music.
@@shawnnicolo7445 she didn’t focus on her brand till later. During this time Jessica was busy with a musical and drama. The unit was originally gonna be taeyeon and Tiffany because of the good response from their lady marmalade performance from their concert and they wanted to do something with music while others focused on acting and variety shows. They later added seohyun because she was the only snsd member who didn’t have any schedule.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
![SNSD - TWINKLE+ENDING [GIRLS & PEACE] in SEOUL](/img/1.gif)
To think SeoHyun stood there and sang her heart out and did great while grieving for her grandma that died that morning is heart breaking
my heart is breaking too
She's good compartmentalizing
they really never lipsynced
+Brendo Joya where's the lie?
uhmmm........ good joke tho
Ppanya Kim it's not u are tho 😶
They ever lypsinc but 95% of them all are live
they do. but in this vid, no they're not lipsyncing. You can see taeyeon trying to smile despite the high notes
의상 진짜 너무 잘 어울린다. 보석이라는 말이랑 딱 맞음. 우리 애들이 보석이잖아.
SEOHYUN IS AMAZING
😍😍😊
So true!
TIFFANY!!!! where's tiffany stan?
Ella Adnan right here!
taeyeon is a perfection.She had gorgeous look and legend voice
SEOHYUN U SUCH A STRONG GIRL :')
My God. The things that happen behind the camera. She's so strong.
라이브 진짜 개살벌하다... 특히 후반부 태연 고음몰빵 미친듯;;
SeoHyun
Tiffany is beautiful and cuteee
OMG Seohyun is stunning
I love the tiffany most... OMG her voice... I love her the ONE...!!!
tiffany...❤❤❤❤
Tiff 💖
서현이 트윙클 첫방때 할머니 돌아가셔서
엄청 슬펐는데 무대 해야해서 감정 숨기고
노래하는건데 ㅠㅠ 너무 잘한다
슬픔이 조금 보이는 것 같기도하고 😔
우째 지금봐도 세련되고 이쁜지
Tiffany's singing skill tho
Seohyun😘😘😘😘
Wow, I would have never guessed that Seohyun's grandma, who took care of her for most of her childhood, had passed away the very morning of this debut stage based on her stage performance.
Years later she would say that she regretted not listening to her heart... Her innate professionalism and ability to grow and self reflect. Just another reason I love this woman!
tiffany why so pretty?
taeyeon😚
I love tiffany 💜 cute and pretty 😍
❤️ TaeTiSeo
Seohyun and taeyeon like a sisters
My baby is so strong and professional, once again Soshi's pride indeed
Seohyun
i love taeyeon♡♡♡♡♡
TAEYEON I LOVE YOUR VOICE AND I LOVE YOU TOO!!!
Tiffany 😍 😍
I still can't believe that live performance.
01:06-01:15 when tayeon's mic suddenly was cut off and came back. u can tell she did not like it AT ALL
PS: watching this again after 4 yrs
Damn right!!
haha she smirked!! taeyeon's that bitch y'all!!
I can't believe Taeyeon invented singing
Seohyun~♡So beautiful~pretty~
Seohyun slaying even if her grandma died that morning...she is the moment
Tiffany
Taeyeon ❤
서주현 개미쳣다
i love taeyeon
it's 2021! I'm still falling luv with this song.
Oh my god!!!! Taeyeon give me goosebumps!!!!!
I'M SO SORRY MY MAKNAE. WE HAVE NO IDEA. ILOVEYOU SO MUCH
태티서는 거의 라이브네. 노래 실력이 뛰어나도 이런저런 사정으로 라이브 못할 수도 있긴한데, 태티서는 라이브 비율은 역대 아이돌 그룹중 최고일듯
2:04 GO OFF SEOHYUN
Love taeyeon unnie
Coming from Yooquiz. Is this the debut stage when Seo's grandma died? Maknae!!!!!
I laugh at everyone who said SM artists don't sing live the first week... you can clearly hear they perfect vocals
i love you snsd tts
Omg my heart is melting I remember when I danced to this song when I was 6 or something
Taeyeon is my queennn
No, she's mine ;)
I love watching less viewed snsd vids bc I can actually see old comments lol
Revisiting my queens here✨ I miss them so much
taeyeonnnnn🔥🔥🔥🔥😍😍💗💗💗
The era when auto-tune was not yet a thing! The era when artists sounds like human...
Nowadays, most music shows feature production numbers wherein artists sounds 'too good to be true', to the extent that you wouldn't even hear minor natural (but acceptable) flaws. You wouldn't even hear them breathe in between their lines. Most of them sound too mechanical, too robotic.
I miss REAL music shows 😭😭😭💔💔💔
Totally agree.
So true
Well Blackpink can still sing live tho
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@@dandx67895 Blackpink barely sings live, they always used backtrack
Eonnie, Miss You❤
2024년에 온사람? 👍
I cant pick.. theyre all good
Someone needs to watch this.. I mean singing live
Seohyun :(
Legend never end.
My Taeyeon!!!
Sitsiritsit alibangbang 🎶🎶
Still watching
was this the first stage that seohyun mentioned in yoo quiz?
That's my question, too.
Probably mnet's stage because she said first music broadcast. Looking at description it says this aired on 5th May while mnet aired on 3rd May.
super
Is this the performance that Seohyun mentioned?? :(
0:30. 2:15
1:05. 1:22
1:57
There's something wrong with Taeyeon's mic from 1:07 to 1:09, damn!!!
I miss them
😊😊🔎 tanggal-4-11-2020.. hari rabu.. aku melihat youtube, menyimpan video & menulis komentar tentang girls' generation twinkle.. pada jam=22.05.. dengan baterai=25%.. didalam kamarku.. didalam rumahku.. do'aku hari ini adalah: ya allah subhanahu wa ta'ala.. aku ingin melihat konser girls' generation twinkle di korea.. amin ya rabbal alamin.. jusni lovely: girls 'generation twinkle..
who’s here after crossroads?
OMGGSKJSJS I LOVE THEM FIRST KPOP SONG I EVER LISTENED TOOO
Girls who say I don’t sparkle 😏
2021😳
태연❤
2:50 may i ask, this part should be shouting/screaming or with technique you can achieve this high notes?
🦋🦋🦋
Who is still here 2022?
2020🎉
2020?
Miss then so much
2022 Love
看看現在的音樂節目誰有唱現場
Something happened to Taeyeon’s microphone at 1:07-1:09.
5331 butterfly well I don’t wanna be rude and say they were lipsynking, but it really looks like Taeyeon was expecting her ad lib in this part to be on the MR... Cause the mic wouldn’t just stop exactly while her ad lib should be going on and then back to work perfectly right after.
Gabriela Gariglio they never did lypsinc, fyi. its real something happened to Taeyeon's microphone. and that adlib never to part on MR...
2020 become to 2021 ???
Legendary
7tahun lalu suram
5人の少女時代なんて考えられない(´；ω；｀)
OK GG.22:40 Bangkok Thailand
What's wrong with taeyeon's mic 😑
SITSIRISIT ALI BANG BANG~~~
Tangina hahaha
Hahahahaha huy Notre Dame represent 😭🤣🤣🤣
2019
I feel bad for Taeyeon because Seohyun and Tiffany retired. 😢😢
They didn't. Tiffany is still promoting but in America (however she's still going to Korea. Proof is whenever she make appearance in tv shows that features the gg or other k-idol friends like Jessi.) Meanwhile, Seohyun is focusing in acting and I think she's still doing musical. They are still in the korean industry but in different fields.
@@babyflame3814 What I meant was they both left SNSD to pursue their own career.
@@Van-gg7go they never did.
@@Van-gg7go they left SM not SNSD..they still snsd and forever snsd
Do not feel bad! They just released Forever1 album in 2022 for us
I still think their sub-unit would have been better called TST and not TTS.
sitsiritsit alibangbang
Hu
石字未睡嗎
lipsync what????
Are they forgotten the other members singing like they are alone.
this one... hmmm, i think much better if they chose jessica instead of seohyun.. just my opinion.. jessica's voice is really amazing and it blends well with taeyeon...
Livy Darling Diestro then go ahead and make your visionary ttj instead of tts.
Same and they are the same size.
I always think seohyun is so awkward. Makes me cringe a little looking at her. She doesn't look natural with her stage facials :(
@@_GunpowdertheGabite she is always been like that. Innocent maknae. But her voice suit this song much better.
@@_GunpowdertheGabite who are you to say that? Hahaha Jessica deserves to be blacklisted after all.
LoL, but her and Taeyeon is not on good terms tbh. Why would Taeyeon like to sing with Jess 😭
I wonder why jessica is not included?
At this time, Jessica was already busy in the fashion side for her clothing brand which is Blanc and Eclare to launch but the original subunit was TaeJessSeo which consists of her, Taeyeon and Seohyun.
During this time snsd had their own individual schedules. Jessica was busy doing the legally blonde musical and acting in a drama. The other members were busy in variety shows and dramas. Taetiseo specially wanted to work with music.
@@shawnnicolo7445 she didn’t focus on her brand till later. During this time Jessica was busy with a musical and drama. The unit was originally gonna be taeyeon and Tiffany because of the good response from their lady marmalade performance from their concert and they wanted to do something with music while others focused on acting and variety shows. They later added seohyun because she was the only snsd member who didn’t have any schedule.
Tiffany 😍
Taeyeon 💜