DOJ to NAR: “Your days are numbered!”

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024

Комментарии • 126

  • @everlastinglife2500
    @everlastinglife2500 2 месяца назад +20

    NAR 👎 I don't need another form of governance telling me what's best for my business and forcing me to pay them money. We have enough of that already. #FREEDOM

  • @EricSellsMN
    @EricSellsMN 2 месяца назад +32

    Does all of this go away if all brokers leave NAR? Then it's a state level issue with MLS's right? No more Feds? I hate NAR, their attornies are inept, they should have hired major outside litigators. All MLS need to remove the NAR member mandate so we can all escape their ineptitude and run our businesses as we see fit.

    • @abbyynorman2874
      @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад +5

      We 2 million non-members out number 1.5 million members-welcome aboard NEVER have I needed NAR 35yrs con job & ruse on the public -

    • @KaterinaGasset
      @KaterinaGasset 2 месяца назад

      The issue with everyone leaving NAR, is that NAR is the largest lobbying group on Capital Hill. They do protect private property rights daily on Capital Hill and in state legislative bodies.
      They are the lobby that keeps us from having to pay sales tax on our commissions, and to keep us from becoming W-2 employees which government idiots try to pass.
      They protect homeowners’ property rights. We don’t see all behind the scenes because we are working but stupid politicians who never owned a business keep trying to take away our property rights.

    • @joseleiva1331
      @joseleiva1331 2 месяца назад +3

      @EricSellsMN. Wiser words haven’t heard ever in this NAR sellout …

  • @comment_deleted
    @comment_deleted 2 месяца назад +5

    if the DOJ gave a shit about antitrust, they'd investigating facebook, google, blackrock, vanguard etc....

  • @kharithoughts2679
    @kharithoughts2679 2 месяца назад +7

    I'm concerned about the DOJ. I see a problem with their assertions. We are acting like sellers don't actually own their properties. If we take the agent out, then the government is saying sellers do not have a right to creatively market their properties. They can't offer to help with costs, offer a moving truck, offer to move in early before their loan closes, etc. They are saying sellers have to offer a home for a price and that there is nothing else to negotiate. Sometimes price isn't the most important thing. People may buy a property for other reasons from a seller. Buyers want to know which sellers are willing to accommodate unique situations.
    This is a waste of time. Buyers have to look at every property out there and send an offer to everyone just to have sellers reveal that they are willing to help with the concessions they need. Realtors do have the power to influence, but in the end, it isn't their property. Let's stop acting like these terms of the listing are the agents' terms. They are the sellers terms.

    • @KaterinaGasset
      @KaterinaGasset 2 месяца назад +2

      Because this government actually doesn’t believe in private property rights so they don’t think sellers can do what they want to in selling their properties.
      Most people in government don’t have a clue about how real estate transactions work.
      They do the same thing with the internet and apps. They have no experience or knowledge yet make laws regarding these.

  • @mallenvt
    @mallenvt 2 месяца назад +8

    I’m so happy to hear people speaking up about this. I was feeling like NAR was just a bunch of sheep following blindly. God Bless MLS PIN!! I wish more would join them.

  • @patcomo5695
    @patcomo5695 2 месяца назад +11

    Yes, they are!!! Corruption is an understatement. Our government is out of control. Just look around

  • @rmanofmoss
    @rmanofmoss 2 месяца назад +16

    DOJ just wants to make it as difficult as possible for first time homebuyers. #renternation

    • @abbyynorman2874
      @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад

      DOJ wants to make you showing agent for GlobalistZillow for a flat employee fee-cancel memberships you dont HAVE to be a Board office!

    • @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA
      @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA 2 месяца назад +5

      Facts. The only way to “own nothing and be happy” is if you are renting everything

  • @veronicaegidio2374
    @veronicaegidio2374 2 месяца назад +3

    The DOJ wants everyone renting, they must own all of the toothpick built massive apartment buildings in my area? Disgusting, every time they get their in the hands of "Any" entity it turns to shit

  • @veronicaegidio2374
    @veronicaegidio2374 2 месяца назад +4

    So how is that the lawyers setting a 33% to 40% fee isn't illegal, wtf?

  • @samanthahammondsrealtor
    @samanthahammondsrealtor 2 месяца назад +6

    4:55 and now they want to remove all transparency. It is completely backwards.

  • @stanleynowak9325
    @stanleynowak9325 2 месяца назад +6

    Corruption from Joe's administration? Naw, he is an angel.

  • @user-ep2ow1nm2m
    @user-ep2ow1nm2m 2 месяца назад +7

    MLS PIN needs to rep NAR in court. They’re savages.

  • @EricSellsMN
    @EricSellsMN 2 месяца назад +8

    Someone explain to me how commission and how they are promoted or shared falls under Federal Law when each brokerage and MLS is licensed individually state by state? NAR does not set state law regarding commissions and or payouts, each states commerce department does right? The only thing related to Federal Law that my license education taught me or requires me to follow is Federally Protection of Classes.

    • @abbyynorman2874
      @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад

      Federal law also covers lead , steering, discrimination, handicap laws . and many others that fall under civil rights lol Where you get ya license?

    • @abbyynorman2874
      @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад

      Federal law always supersedes state laws-

  • @KaterinaGasset
    @KaterinaGasset 2 месяца назад +4

    This should have gone to the supreme court.

  • @JA-wb5my
    @JA-wb5my 2 месяца назад +3

    This is why our judicial system has higher courts. NAR could have taken this all the way to the Supreme Court, but they decided to lay down and settle for a chance in self preservation.

    • @abbyynorman2874
      @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад

      They took the COVID cash fed govt owns them-now they have the Petto flag on their logo-not a dime would I give NAR not a dime!!!

  • @EspressoAgent
    @EspressoAgent 2 месяца назад +5

    Wow, this video is packed with crucial insights! Excited for the live cold call session next Wednesday! It's going to be great seeing you in action and learning from your techniques. Keep up the great work in keeping us informed and prepared for these industry shifts.

  • @ohiorealestate
    @ohiorealestate 2 месяца назад +9

    Agents are entrepreneurs and will find a way to still get paid. Many people want this situation to ruin “evil” realtors. Sorry to tell them it’s just a road bump and we will keep going.

  • @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA
    @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA 2 месяца назад +37

    If only we had a President in office that has years of experience in Real Estate and makes “mean” tweets 😢

    • @mincollagroup
      @mincollagroup 2 месяца назад +2

      Amen

    • @stanleynowak9325
      @stanleynowak9325 2 месяца назад

      Huh, you got someone in mind? 😊

    • @christinaarcher1712
      @christinaarcher1712 2 месяца назад +11

      TRUMP 2024!!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

    • @rhayder
      @rhayder 2 месяца назад

      @@christinaarcher1712 Trump sucks at real estate and running a business. He's broke now and how many times has he declared bankruptcy? Give me a break.

    • @pier21realty
      @pier21realty 2 месяца назад +3

      Agree. Truth is nothing can save this country from the lines that have been crossed. Stay tuned.

  • @JenniferParliman
    @JenniferParliman 2 месяца назад +2

    It is a shame the DOJ chose to allow havoc in the real estate industry, when a realtor provides a service to the public for betterment. Yet, the loop hole digging attorney, paid hundreds in billable hours, decided to dig deep into our industry, and choke hold the realtor paid pennies in comparison. Huuummmm so who is supposed to have our back and protect us when here is the perfect example of what an attorney does for a living?

  • @TheEblenRealestateTeam
    @TheEblenRealestateTeam 2 месяца назад +4

    Thanks for clarifying why bankruptcy isn't an option.. It's a total money grab.

  • @jamesnickerson8330
    @jamesnickerson8330 2 месяца назад +5

    At least in Florida, unless otherwise engaged, agents are considered transaction agents. There are no fiduciary duties unless single agency is entered into.

  • @melann1111
    @melann1111 Месяц назад

    This isn’t a real estate AGENT issue. This the big brokerages. When are they going to address the unfair commission splits, insane amount of fees and expenses that the AGENT is forced to pay, and the unfair independent contractor agreements between the agent and broker. Seriously. I’ve never worked in an industry where my own broker lies about commissions and doesn’t pay agents for taking on their listings or else saying they can have buy side but not list side if there isn’t a buyers agent. I don’t understand why Agents have to pay monthly fees on top of commission splits and ALL of their other expenses. It’s garbage. I can see what’s going on here because if they didn’t settle there would be LOTS of AGENTS demanding change and answers.

  • @pier21realty
    @pier21realty 2 месяца назад +7

    Great video fellas. Lines have been crossed. We are being led and ruled by misfits.

    • @paroffice
      @paroffice 2 месяца назад

      If you study communism that's exactly what they want. Ruled by incompetent people and criminals. They're easier for a dictator to control.

  • @KatKatz11
    @KatKatz11 2 месяца назад +1

    I've built 18 homes and always list with a flat fee company to get on the MLS ($199 fee), every home with the exception of 3 had consumers contact me directly and make an offer (yay! I paid no commission and wrote the contract and dropped off at title company...no brainer). The other 3 I sold to a buyer with an agent...so offered them 2.5% way better than paying an agent 5-6%. People need to smarten up and cut out the middle man.

  • @nilcivelek3988
    @nilcivelek3988 2 месяца назад +4

    Maybe they want it to become messy so next time they can come up with something bigger! 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

  • @OKCrealtor
    @OKCrealtor 2 месяца назад +4

    Bro you right on that money grab, you called it a while back- ol' Mikey be CATCHIN' THOSE MARKS!

  • @patriciaellinghausen4365
    @patriciaellinghausen4365 2 месяца назад +1

    I think this is the start of dismantling property rights, and Americans' ability to own property at all. The government involvement is not producing clarity. Its not about fairness or transparency. you asked if it is something else- i think this is the underlying concept.

  • @abbyynorman2874
    @abbyynorman2874 2 месяца назад +2

    DOJ end goal wants you showing agent for Zillow be employee pay flat fees - cancel memberships Brokers dont have to be Board offices

  • @bestofUS_90
    @bestofUS_90 Месяц назад

    Transparency should not be used against the sellers so the agents ban low balling sellers via MLS. DOJ is right on it for that matter.

  • @arizonaflatfeemls4142
    @arizonaflatfeemls4142 2 месяца назад +1

    Attorneys has so much damaging info from large real estate companies that it was the only smart thing to do...

  • @paroffice
    @paroffice 2 месяца назад +2

    Consumer will dictate compensation in the end run. Not a bunch if highly motivated psychopaths. Consumers will rule.

  • @SteveSchwab1961
    @SteveSchwab1961 2 месяца назад +1

    The mere fact you and other Realtors use the term “concession” demonstrates this is about the money, not the client. So, just so you can get paid, the buyer will no longer get repair, closing cost or other credits. Hmm. Remember, many other countries dont do the Buyers Agent system and that real estate transacts just fine. Bottom line, its gotten very expensive to sell your home as the commission the seller pays, pays for everything that financially benefits in the real estate world. Things include: splits with your brokerage, splits with your team, coaching, leads, systems, marketing, buyers agents and more. Grab your big boy pants and hold on.

    • @tjcrowleyrealestate3197
      @tjcrowleyrealestate3197 2 месяца назад +2

      This country didn’t have the buyers agent until the 80’s - 90’s but the consumer wanted representation and that’s why we have what we have today.

  • @davidporterrealestate
    @davidporterrealestate 2 месяца назад +2

    Can’t wait for the cold calling together!

  • @kharithoughts2679
    @kharithoughts2679 2 месяца назад +1

    Houses aren't a commodity. Price isn't the only reason someone buys a house. Are we going into a system where we don't market anything in life by anything in price. So my next car then should just say the price, they cant talk about interest rates, trade in bonuses, etc.

  • @mincollagroup
    @mincollagroup 2 месяца назад +1

    Amen. This only hurts the people and the public at large. If they want to help housing they would stop out of control spending, then we could get lower inflation and then lower rates. This would help supply chains and builders confidence which would provide more inventory with lower prices and lower rates. Commissions have nothing to do with helping people. If a buyer is unrepresented they will get hurt.

  • @franklinromine8600
    @franklinromine8600 2 месяца назад

    I like the comment about keeping the bottom agents in, they make you look when you go to the same listing appt.

  • @jasoncarter3572
    @jasoncarter3572 2 месяца назад +1

    6:48 a choice. But they want to take that away. How’s that helping it being a “negotiable” piece? Why can’t a Seller market how they chose? 🤔

  • @KarieJacobs
    @KarieJacobs 2 месяца назад

    How do you negotiate with a buyer you don't have a relationship with at first showing and additionally have no idea how much work or services are required. Are you working for 1 month or 6 months?

  • @KarieJacobs
    @KarieJacobs 2 месяца назад

    In 2018, the Justice Department opened an antitrust investigation concerning “potentially anticompetitive practices in the real estate industry” implemented by the National Association of Realtors (NAR).

  • @daveuygur
    @daveuygur 2 месяца назад

    Love Your Live Call Sessions ! Miss them

    • @RickyCarruth
      @RickyCarruth  2 месяца назад

      Been doing it every Wednesday
      Go watch the last two sessions and watch this week live

  • @youremeraldagent
    @youremeraldagent 2 месяца назад +10

    When Biden came into office he said he was going after real estate commissions.

    • @GoodDaywithRickyRay
      @GoodDaywithRickyRay 2 месяца назад

      FR FR? Where can that be found? Please share.

    • @ThePreferredAgentTeam
      @ThePreferredAgentTeam 2 месяца назад +1

      They are gunning for your commission.
      JB'S words back in March... But here's the deal,
      I'm calling on realtors to follow through on lowering their commissions to protect homebuyers.
      You can read the transcript on C-SPAN or your NAR March newsletter... you can't make this stuff up... totally insane!

    • @angelabrown8729
      @angelabrown8729 2 месяца назад

      @@GoodDaywithRickyRay It can't be found!! Propaganda!!

    • @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA
      @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA 2 месяца назад +5

      If only we had a President in office that has years of experience in Real Estate and makes “mean” tweets 😢

    • @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA
      @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA 2 месяца назад

      @@GoodDaywithRickyRay this all has to do with BlackRock and the 2030 Agenda. It has to do with the WEF agenda that we will “Own nothing and be happy.” The only way we can own nothing is if we are renting everything. BlackRock has a goal to own 60% of the Single Family Homes in America. Builders are now building homes for rent and not to own. Look into it. Also, Wells Fargo was the number one distributor of Home mortgages and stopped in January 2023. Why would they stop when they are number one? It’s because BlackRock is one of their share holders.. there is a push to ban sellers from paying buyers agent commissions because they want to make it hard for low and middle class income families to be able to afford a home. They want to turn us into a renters nation.

  • @paroffice
    @paroffice 2 месяца назад

    People also don't like an agent telling them something that would jeopardize them. They see it as an agent limiting them where we are busting our asses off to make sure they don't get themselves sued ..... Or lose a ton of money

  • @HomeportResidential
    @HomeportResidential 2 месяца назад

    Lead with curiosity. Simple and brilliant at the same time!

  • @OKCrealtor
    @OKCrealtor 2 месяца назад +1

    Ricky the GOAT! 🐐 Fresca on the otherhand....

  • @steveh1460
    @steveh1460 2 месяца назад +1

    Thanks Ricky!

  • @MrHawaiianislands
    @MrHawaiianislands 2 месяца назад +1

    It is totally insane

  • @barttracy88
    @barttracy88 2 месяца назад +2

    Consumers should be able to allow their real estate consultants any and all means to get their home sold for them. As far as steering, new construction offering incentives to use their preferred lender? Is this not steering consumers to a specific lender to receive an incentive? That sounds like steering! And DOJ does not make the laws congress does.

    • @LookyLooRealEstate
      @LookyLooRealEstate 2 месяца назад

      In WA state, both Lennar and D.R. Horton will only use their forms, title, escrow and they push hard through, you guessed it - compensating buyer with closing costs to get the consumer to use their lender. They also have a caveat that the buyer waives their right in a bankruptcy situation to use the Homestead Act to protect their primary residence from being taken. The DOJ doesn't have a problem with that, it seems.

  • @LookyLooRealEstate
    @LookyLooRealEstate 2 месяца назад

    In Washington state, Lennar builders went to 0% buyer compensation back in 2021 in NWMLS

  • @kentuckygreenthumb1
    @kentuckygreenthumb1 2 месяца назад

    Great convo.

  • @KatKatz11
    @KatKatz11 2 месяца назад

    It will make agents work harder for less...which is good, so many do nothing and all are over paid with too high of commissions. I was a realtor in NY and FL...easiest money I ever made.

  • @jessedau
    @jessedau 2 месяца назад

    $1 mandatory clear cooperation rule set this whole thing off. They should’ve always had it at $0. Stating a $1min doesn’t really state “negotiable”. Very idiotic.

  • @jessehepburn
    @jessehepburn 2 месяца назад

    I wish you hit the highlights in under 15 minutes.
    45 minutes is a long video for something like this.

  • @JSCimmo
    @JSCimmo 2 месяца назад +2

    Do you think if trump wins he could change the future of these changes ?

    • @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA
      @LIFEINSOUTHFLORIDA 2 месяца назад +2

      If only we had a President in office that has years of experience in Real Estate and makes “mean” tweets 😢

  • @vickimiller6608
    @vickimiller6608 2 месяца назад +1

    You’re barking up the wrong tree. And most likely confusing people. Pointing fingers the wrong way. This sucks ! With the exceptions of buyers will not be Realtors hopping.

  • @ZNIP3R11
    @ZNIP3R11 2 месяца назад

    I started drinking Fresca too now ha ha

  • @TheEblenRealestateTeam
    @TheEblenRealestateTeam 2 месяца назад +1

    This guy's is thinking on the lines I was seeing this

  • @JenniferParliman
    @JenniferParliman 2 месяца назад

    Shame on the loop hole digging attorney too cowardly (not my choice adjective) to dig up a "loop hole" in his own industry, driven by greed and paid hundreds in billable hours. So why did the DOJ choose to cause havoc on a system that has been working for decades in the real estate industry? Realtors provide a public service for the betterment of society and are paid pennies in comparison to do so. A great example of what attorneys do for a living or not?

  • @priscillabeggs6057
    @priscillabeggs6057 2 месяца назад

    Can't wait until the maritime law our country practices turns back to Common Law. Bye-bye attorneys!!!

  • @californiaproperties1582
    @californiaproperties1582 2 месяца назад

    Agree, something else is going on.

  • @Realtor_Ryan_Hodzic
    @Realtor_Ryan_Hodzic 2 месяца назад

    sponsored by Fresca. 😂

  • @user-sn8me1jr1n
    @user-sn8me1jr1n 2 месяца назад +2

    This guest speaker's tone is very annoying, and he is whinninng more than he is actually providing information.
    Also, what is in that ENDLESS cup of coffee that's got him so hyper?

  • @joegibson6041
    @joegibson6041 2 месяца назад

    Not an agent, but a house seller. It seems the logical thing to do here is the buyer and seller both pay 2.5%.

  • @izzybizzy3650
    @izzybizzy3650 2 месяца назад

    I’m not sure you know enough to be interpreting this correctly. Let’s be honest with ourselves. The amount of “training” videos talking about how to answer commission questions etc is what’s gotten the industry in trouble. I seriously doubt that a change in administration is what triggered them into trying to open the case again. Pretty sure the same people who were part of the case and agreed to the deal in 2020, are still the same people in 2021. Do some people get replaced when there is a change in administration, sure, but everyone who works under the department ? Not likely. Agreements fall apart all the time, most of the time it’s because there are stipulations in the agreement that both parties can’t agree with.
    Is that a conspiracy? No. Are you trying to insinuate that in your video? Yes. Stick to helping agents navigate this new way of business that we’ll all be facing soon. Especially when you’re not privy to all of the back and forth of this investigation/settlement. 😒
    I do have to add, that’s good the MLS’s are pushing back. It was NAR’s ineptitude that has lead us here.

  • @jennodine
    @jennodine 2 месяца назад

    This whole situation is based on a false premise that a real estate transaction is adversarial in nature, when they’re actually cooperative.

    • @jennodine
      @jennodine 2 месяца назад

      I still can’t believe this is happening in America and the DOJ is looking the other way while Wall Street landlords are keeping units empty to create an artificial housing shortage. If they can manipulate the market this much with less than a 10% stake, imagine life in 7 years when they own 40% - which is what they’re on pace to accomplish right now.

  • @theGHSV
    @theGHSV 2 месяца назад +1

    Real estate professionals and/or coaches trying to explain legal principles, civil procedure and/or litigation practices to other real estate professionals is hilariously cringeworthy. It would be like an auto-mechanic watching a video of an accountant coach preaching to other accountants the benefits of Honda’s 2.4L V4 engine vs Toyota’s 2.5L V4 engine with completely inconsistent information and no knowledge base.

    • @RickyCarruth
      @RickyCarruth  2 месяца назад +5

      almost as bad as a lawyer trying to explain how the real estate industry works. I am sure you would agree

    • @theGHSV
      @theGHSV 2 месяца назад +1

      @@RickyCarruth Not really. Real estate professionals are telling lawyers how the real estate industry actually works, and in turn, those lawyers are telling those real estate professionals, associations and MLS affiliates how the real estate industry actually works is in violation of federal law. But thanks for liking my comment Ricky! You will adapt to the new industry practices and be successful no doubt.

    • @RickyCarruth
      @RickyCarruth  2 месяца назад +2

      @theGHSV they have no idea...just a money grab.

  • @nunovurbiznis
    @nunovurbiznis 2 месяца назад +1

    Give it five years and the buyer agent will be no more. Buyers are just going to go directly to the seller with their own offer drafted by an attorney which would cost much, much less than a buyer agent. Services like Showami will become more popular.
    Europe and South America does realty this way.

    • @tjcrowleyrealestate3197
      @tjcrowleyrealestate3197 2 месяца назад +1

      How long will it take for an attorney to put an offer together for you? Likely many days and in many situations that property will be long gone before you even make an offer.

  • @NBAhoops123
    @NBAhoops123 2 месяца назад

    Most real estate agents are crooks. They quote this 6% commission, but when you look at the commission rate with average homeowner equity at 30%, using a 500k sales price, the commission = 6% x 500k=30k and based on homeowners equity at 30% x 500k= 150k. So 30k / 150k= 20% commission!!! This is illegal in almost any industry and it’s literally a wolf of Wall Street style fleecing of customers. The DOJ is going to bring the hammer down on these crooks and real estate agents will be forced to charge fair commissions in the 1-3% range vs 5-6%. And more likely the commission rate will be based on the equity value which is what the homeowner actually owns vs stealing money from the homeowner. It’s about time the chickens came home to roost.

  • @rusilver2
    @rusilver2 2 месяца назад

    man, there are a lot of butt hurt realtors ....