P Chidambaram's Remarks | Discussion on Union Budget 2020-21 in Rajya Sabha
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- P Chidambaram's Remarks | Discussion on Union Budget 2020-21 in Rajya Sabha
Declaration:
This video is an intellectual property belonging to the Indian National Congress. Please seek prior permission before using any part of this video in any form.
For more videos, subscribe to Congress Party channel: / indiacongress
Follow Indian National Congress!
Follow the Indian National Congress on
Facebook: / indiannationalcongress
Twitter: / incindia
Instagram: / incindia
RUclips: / indiacongress
Follow Rahul Gandhi on
RUclips: / rahulgandhi
Facebook: / rahulgandhi
Twitter: / rahulgandhi
Instagram: / rahulgandhi
Please listen to this man just once, set aside your ego and address the points raised by the former FM if your love for the nation is genuine.
Well Said
@Adam LB , FM replied to the queries and observations made by PC. She says economy is great and all that the nation is facing now is inherited. This is not a new song. This administration has been repeating like a broken record. Thanks for acknowledging nothing will be done to set the issues right. Hate messages are what you guys are capable of. Will have to suffer for another 4+ years which we will gladly do.
@RKA , and are they saying anything different about our GDP, Unemployment, NPAs et al?
@RKA , so you don't believe government data and you are convinced data given by other agencies are credible and unbiased.
@RKA , government data themselves are depressing.
Mr. Chidambaram, You are 100 times more sincere and Concerned about the Indian economy compare to PM Modi.
One of the best parliamentarian, none to match him in the ruling party, there are many like him in opposition, but ironically none in govt.
This is painful tragedy of Indian politics that incompetent leaders with cheap communal brutal sickly unreliable, gundan type fanatically prejudiced to Hindutwa (which is 100% vote politics based upon psephology of sentiments ) that ultimately has nothing to do with genuine Hinduism...These RSS born greedy religious bigots BJP'S are cancer to Mother India's well being.
Ultimately the responsibility lies with the people to cast their vote against psycho Gvnt.
उतर गया ना फिर जातिवाद और धर्मवाद पर।
वो जमाना गुजरने के बाद भी,, अगर मौका मिले तो हर मौके पर धर्मिक सहिष्णुता पर पुरजोर समर्थन काम करो और ऐसा ही होना चाहिए होगा।
do you want to recreat History.. or even if immense other possibilities are there in current Democratic system ...... और तो और सबसे बड़ी बात अगर आप ऐसी मानसिकता धर्म जात को लेकर सोचते , रिएक्ट, और एक्ट करते रहोगे तो तुम अव्वल दर्जे के नक्कर क़िस्म वाला बेवकूफ़ घटिया इंसान हो।
अगर वाकई में दिमाग वाले बनते हो तो देश के तमाम CORE ISSUES पर अपना दिमाग लगवोना मेरे साथी भाई साहब!!!! कब तक इन वोट की raajniki करनेवाले लालची गलीज़ नेताओं के तलवे चाटने की आदत से सेवा करते रहोगे।
बात करो:
रोजगार की।
अर्थव्यवस्था की।
ग़रीबी की।
स्वस्थ्य की।
और अगर अब भी समझ ना आए तो बिना दिमाग का कॉमेंट मत किया करो।
कया बोलता है लोल!!!! अगर ऐसी बात है तो नब्बाक नेताओं की पैदाइश वाला FEELING हटा दो अपने अंदर से।
@RKA if you don't know how to debate then rather just shut up.
@RKA says a supreme Court judge
@RKA answer the question idiot, u r the kind shaming BJP
If i was government, i would have hired chidambaram in the economic council on whatever conditions he demanded :P
I believe it's not a wise choice... there are many with good knowledge than him..
This is a what a speech should be like, fact based and civilised not mud slinging ones like a certain someone.
Well done Mr. Chidambaram
Modi ji speaks like comedian
Well said brother
Real fact is he and his family is worth thousands of crores and of course that doesn't matter in this context,also bjp is staunchly following britishraj like congress n allies.Its only IT Payers and taxation that is running the economy
Absolutely !!! numbers speak for themselves. Don't need any extension to numbers. It's straight and substantial for one to analyse.
He's so professional... Compared to FM or subramaniam swami.. They don't sound credible Neither convincing. Only arrogance.
He's a great PM candidate material. He has some premium class.
Just simply he delivered good english and statistics...is that what u mean PM candidate ☺️☺️
@@sarathikrishna1523 He delivered facts through the medium of a language called English with statistical data. 💯👏
Always been a benchmark Parliamentarian..Hats off Mr. P Chiddambaram Sir✌✌
What a choice of words and what an excellent delivery! Thank you Chidambaram saheb.
Good speech every aspect of economy explained very well ,our economy is in doldrums very sad
Where is the Dr. to treat the patient kept out side the ICU. He is on the way coming from USA. His name is Donald Trump. 7 million people of Gujarat will be standing both sides of airport road to the venue of mega event organised for Dr. Modi and Dr. Trump. All Indians will get mesmerized by the grand event and forget what is happening to economy and jobs.
@RKA This is the chela of WhatsApp University..
@RKA you should study history and understand in what state the British left us and how we turned the table!! We need to give Congress some credit but the main credit goes to those who have worked and are working sincerely in the government and we people who slog every day to improve our nation and our lives. And if you want to debate on political parties, debate on facts and then your eye's might open up on what's actually happening!!
Ha.. May Be.
@RKA No boss!! You can't say that they weekend the country completely. If that was the case, India would be in a worst state than what the British had left us with. I'll tell you the fact, the congress did a brilliant job for a few decades to get our motherland on track but then greed took over and they kept on getting into deeper corruption after 1970-75 and the effects can be seen. Or else we would've been on par or even more developed than China.
Brilliant. Subtly sarcastic. But to know that you must be educated. Not just literate.
He is one of my frv8 economist. Modi should ask their expertise for better future.
You are correct. But Dear, they don't need anybody's advice. They are very intelligent.
@@arvinderkaur4128 they are super duper 💩💩💩intelligent .
@@arvinderkaur4128 I've been watching their intelligence for about 6 years & I know the 2 things they are excellent at are spreading communal violence & hate & giving fake & empty promises...!
He is lawyer not economist.
Chidambaram great speech. How elaborated details given but no use of telling in the blind and deaf government who needs CAA and NRC urgent than of economy or progress of the citizens of the nation. Mera Bharat Mahan.
Super lecture, study this modi take another ten years.
manoj chirayath but what was the use ??? Congress was never doing any development?!!! Only speech !
itna bhimat hasao bhai.pet me dard hone laga
@@smkrishna2781 ye India dekh raha hai na jo vo Congress Party ne hi banaya hai
@@angryman5517 people of india and great imdustrialist like tatas ambanis built this country.not politicians
@@smkrishna2781 bhai pehli baat jake thoda search karo ki congress ne kia kha hai..sirf negatives search karte ho toh negatives h dikhega..phir apna priority set karna..aur sochna ki upa ne kia kya hai!!achi life style cahiye ya bharat mata ki jaye bolke khus ho khud h decide kar lena..
Funny no one dares to intervene... They just don't understand him.. Lol
Agree100%§§§
Agree 100%
True. Because he speaks the truth and FM knows that
ITS CORRECT they are thinking ..chidambaram.....better to join oxford or Stanford as a visiting professor for economics...so that students will understand and they will get good Mark's.😃😂.
@@shivamr4725 Coxt
Best Speech Mr PC sir, I think the whole Bjp MP's Including PM...Must get tutors at home about this speech and economic technicals which Mr. PC has explained. Literate is Literate always......Superb Mr. PC.
Even an irdinary person can understand his speech.Speech to be translated in all Indian languages so as to know the real picture of state of economy by the people of all states.
People are just sleeping. And busy wth religions mentality.
@@Ksm47 Especially follwers of stinking fanatic cult called PISSLAM 🤧
Nothing wrong in learning english.
Deeply insight and enlightened analysis regarding the current state of Economy.
Salute to Honourable M.P, Mr. P. Chidambaram.
I have been seeing for past 5years all bjp mps are banging on every budget presentation including our PM if these budgets are so good why is economy in slowdown people are loosing jobs
so true man!
I think next time onwards all members should be present in Rajya Sabha so that they could learn economics and it's crysis... whenever Chidambaram is giving a speech in RS
Excellent assessment , where is the doctor? Modi bhai MBBS.
FOOD RELIGION MBBS ?
Great explanation regarding economy India need more people like P. Chidambaram Hats off to this man
Who is watching after Delhi assembly Result🙏
This was main reason y Chidambaram was put away in jail. He brings out the incompetence of the government.
@RKA why are you joining everything with Muslims? I saw your other replies as well. All were about either Pakistan , Muslims etc. Gobar bhakth open your eyes and stop this prejudice. Ever heard of Khan Abdul gaffar Khan? Go read about him
Excellent speech, Sir. An honest and sincere FM should have resigned by now. Hope better sense prevail.
..center is drunk on power.. there are in no mood to listen to anyone..
Correct.modi speech nothing but jokar
Chidambaramji best finance minister we had during UPA government
Second best first one is always Dr manmohan singh
This is the aura of a statesman
Pure class
Very impressive talk! Knowledge ore. Carried all the facts to debate ..
Swamy left before the speech even start.. He can't listen to a smarter person..
SS and his false ego
Ha ha..
woh asaram bapu se ashirwadh lene chala gyaa.. lol.. bakwas jitna marzi karwalo Subramanyam Swamy se... dang ki baat kabi nahi karega.. Sachai se bagne wala kaayar.. Jawab tha nhi . Jhand ho jati. pehle hi bhaag gya kambakth.,.. Isko Tamil Nadu se bahar nikal do bhaiyon.. Modi se desh nhai sambhal thaa. aur saala Rajiv Gandhi Ji ko chor bolta hai. My foot
@Adam LB Ur dd 2 :)
Oh please. He is well versed in self gratification
This is how a finance minister should talk.
Bhai.... 🙋♂
@@ananddave7191 bhai aap idhar😂😜
@Adam LB Yes, I agree. But how can you be very sure If nirmla sitharaman is not doing the same ?? how would you know?? They hide everything. They have suppressed all stasticial reports which are puplished by their own officials (nso, nsso, cso). Please enlighten me if everything is fine corruption has gone, farmerms income has doubled then why data of growth and gdp seems to be negative?? Atleast government must publish unemployment data like it has published figures under sawach Bharat mission and took credit of ODF.
@@Nonjudgemental 😉
@Adam LB , yet not a single charge filed.
It is a treat to listen to someone like P Chidambaram.. Intelligence and eloquence personified.. 👍🙏
Sir p.m. chidambaram deserve to be praised... We need leaders like him to become the prime minister of India. Hats off 😍😍😍
Look at the parliamentarians, they Look blank having no idea what he is talking about.If the discussion was about gobar and cow they would have understood.
😅
hahahaahah
Lol
Truly said
Lol 😂
Modiji and Ms. Sitraman should take tuition from PC on economics and Dr. Manmohan Singh
This is gujrat model of devolopment.
I am waiting for bhakts to say chidambaram is corrupt in this comment section.
What chidambaram doesn't understand is that the youth wants hindu identity not development.
suheil pinto Chidambaram is corrupt
@@reetajain6463 thank you. You made my day.
Excellent speech with very authentic figures and facts.
@@reetajain6463 lol Bhakt
@@suheilpinto6964 😀😀
This is what i call a hard hitting speech with facts and no rhetoric. PC is quoting your official data and seriously the govt seems clueless. God save India’s economy for the next 4 years of this govt. we need educated and subject experts to handle our economy and so long as this govt stays, we will get only more of India pakistan, hindu muslim!
Well talking about Rhetoric .. you must listen to Dr. Shashi Tharoor who is a well educated man whose speech is always premised upon the facts and rhetoric . However I do appreciate the way Mr. Chidambaram speaks , presenting the facts in highly mediocre way .
Listening to this speech reminds me of an issue by The Economist in 2010, How India's growth will outpace China's, when Pranab Mukherjee was the Finance Minister.
16:55 : face of finance minister .."He is talking too technical😟... I do not understand.🤔. .... I told the officials to massage the numbers to look positive😧"
😂😂😂😂
Nailed it
Lol🤣🤣
Exactly!!!🤣🤣
🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
Such a great approach to navigate through current situation. Hats off.
/// Superb speech . GOD bless you Mr. Chidamram .///
Indian economy is tired as was Indian Finance Minister.
I don't know when our people will realise the value of these people: manmohan, chidambaram, and like.
Ruling party need to take ideas and suggestions apart from politics from such a wonderful asset Mr.PC of our country.
I could listen to Mr. Chidambaram All day and these idiots want to shut him off after 30 mins.
Government is lacking a think tank who have full authority to advise the corrective steps based on dynamic macro and micro changes taking place locally and globally
Govt lacks the conviction and intention to do the right thing
Anshul Sharma insecure modi believes in implementing half cooked policies and doesn’t believe in expert advise.
The way country was put for experiments without serious considerations it’s paying now
Anil Mehta more interested in big events and announcements to keep the impression that lot of progress is being made.
Vishnu kumar Dikhawati Sarkar
He doesn’t know anything just rhyme two sentence and get cheap publicity.
Problem is the unemployed and uneducated youngsters falling everyday in a new trap of false nationalism.
I am scared about the future
Nirmala tai is looking as if she has no clue what is being said
Modi and Nirmala sitaraman don't understand what PC is talking about.
A Dog Doctor is treating Manu Rogi,
This is a big SHAME to our Indian voters because we didn't elect a working knowledgeable government but a barking government with venum
Jacintha Fernandes we got fooled by these illiterates.
I appreciate the analysis by the former finance minister....
Advisable to understand dress scientist how to escape frm economic crisis fm let lison n remove the blunders frm budget
Unemployment 45 years old high
--- so back to 1975
(that's bad, we dreamed of becoming super power by 2020)
Year-Year Corporate Tax, import, export are low --- so ppl n corporate r not making money, Less happening in market.
Demand for electricity only 55%, credit to farmer n corporate growing less --- So no increase n production that will generate money also no sign of increase n consumption
food consumption reduced 10% --- obviously no work, no money
People of india dont like strong economy. They just need religious fights, so they voted.
Dr P Chidambaram
Dr sashi tharoor
The two gentleman u cannot win them in anyway
venkatesh sana very true
Well not a single BJP politician able to understand all these except spreading hatred
Great.leader.congres
P CHIDAMBARAM SIR JINDBAAD JINDABAAD ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,JAI DESH KA SAVIDHAN ,,,,,,,,,,,,JAI DESH KI EKTA,,,,,,,,,,,,JAI HIND,,,,,,,,,,,
Expert of economics
We have the best finance minister who doesn't understand what is economy? Why let someone who doesn't have any economy knowledge run our economy....she deserves to be sack or resign immediately
Again this Year also the FM
Ms. Nirmala Seetharaman
was sitting in this Debate
like a Beaten School Girl
by her Teacher. She has "No
Answers" to any of the
Questions raised by Mr. P.
Chidambaram. Congress
must Dub this Speech in Hindi
and put in Circulation in their
Net Work. The People in
Hindi Belt must know what
the condition of Economy is
under Modi's 6 years Rule.
They must know the Economy Is in ICU.
Jai congress
Modiji & Nirmalaji to attend coaching class on economy conducted by former FM honorable Chidambaramji instead of finding fault with earlier Govt as if nothing done/achieved.
Excellent speech by PC
Being an UPSC aspirant its a best idea to grab some good economics its structure and facts thr such intellectual debates by mr chitambaram. No need of any books reqd his expressions makes it all . Can hear it for hours and hours
I am going to respect this person more and more...day by days...he explains every terms of economy and situation of indian economy..
we Indian are fortunate to have him
If you're give to them good advise then they are put in jail again this is the Modi jumla and jhoot rolling bakwas party
Extraordinary analyses.
Excellent speech Sir
Chaiwala has left the chat
Sir you are absolutely right sir
proud of u sir ... respect!!
மிக மிக மிக அருமை awesome speech
29:30 epic
Excellent, eloquent ,informative speech ,we unfortunate that such people are not in power .
We need a great hindi speaking person who has equal authority on economics like PC. Jm scindia is good option.
Owais Peer why Hindi ?
@@bsethura because Congress has chidambaram who is excellent English and tamil speaker ,they have others who are great english and regional language speakers. But there is no one who is erudite like chidambaram in economics and speaks fluent hindi.
We dont need hindi since english is the language of the world. 🖐
One of the Best Parliamentarian from Our State of TN,an intellectual par excellence, Indeed,PC opened the yes of BJP who are in deep coma?
Qualified quality gentleman.
Bakths are Waiting for ambani and adani to rule this country .
No wonder they kept him in jail 😂😂😂
No survey, no observation, no implementation....icu patient is to be wheel into ici but patient is out of icu.....waaoooaa.....!!haa...30. 35 to 30.38 time.....speech is superb...
Is anyone from the BJP understanding anything....?
Aapk budget ki Watt laga di, by factual truth...
@RKA Ofcourse we aren't like those illiterate goons who treat animals as thier god
Who is that incompetent doctor..
He should have mentioned..
We don't have a doctor anymore. We only an RMP called Modi and Nirmala Sitaraman.
@@asrini4u rmp( registered medical practitioner- a doc who has registered in MCI/ SMC) is a doctor too, i guess you were about to say quacks. Am i right ?
@@madhankumar1356 yes
@@asrini4u 😀😀
Dr. Pakoda modi
This is one of the best ways to articulate the way our economy is doing today - factual contents! Modi and Sitaraman may have not understood 60% of this statistical figures at all - considering that both of them understand JOOMLO-NOMICS, which doesn't need facts or figures!
It's really not required to understand figures....seriously not required...
At the way, the Indian economy is reeling in the last 6 years, it is evident - that none of the Parliamentarians (sadly including our current "Yes Boss" RBI Guv and the Finance Min) really understand FIGURES at all, nor any way to resurrect the economy at all! And this is just the beginning - trust me!
huge respect to p.chidambaram sir
See the face of the person who came at sat down behind PC at 18:21 ...he is like main MC hoon jo yaha a gaya... 😆😅
Outstanding
Current FM sitting like a failed student to Mr. Chidambaram
Excellent.. high quality ..
Legend's only knows the delivers perfectness how to mantain the economy. sir good sign of perfect.
Might be really this govt may not possible to learn your accuracy and experience.
Really you are great sir
Super sir another great speech 🔥
Inflation is gallapibg,COI inflation is high,Mr Chidambaram is right.
Careful Chidambaram Sir, they may get angry and put you in TIHAR again... Love you from Northeast.
Congress in 2024. I seriously regretting my decision to vote for this sekhchilli pm
Don't degrade shakechilli
I couldn't find a single comment opposing these facts or even arguing with his speech . That's how bad our economy is doing ☹️
overall i apreciate former ministers speech pushing economy by jobs markets puting money short term lending increase one way good to push.
Sitharaman be like" Hum ko kuch nahi pata"
This is called one sided debate! Where u r discussing with half wits !! Hats off Mr. Chidambaram!
Best speech
🔥🔥🔥 The Master! Time to Lead🔥🔥🔥
There is no capable people in the current government quite unfortunate we still have to bare 4 more years. BJP should look at from the legendary leaders from the opposition and don’t hesitate to ask the solution from then end of the day india is our country.
It is shame that the govt is not even 50% present under such critical debate. It clearly states they are running out of their responsibilities