Finally 240 Su 30MKI engines Ordered | 63% Indian! | हिंदी में

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 169

  • @siddharthsahu7123
    @siddharthsahu7123 Месяц назад +24

    It is not as good as Al 41 does not make it Bad one.
    This engines also makes sukhoi 30mki one of the fastest active fighters( 2120km/hr) in Iaf and in world with a thrust to weight ratio over 1.4 empty weight and around
    0.9 fully loaded.
    Su 30 mki is one of the most maneuverable fighters of all time.

  • @SouravMoitra19
    @SouravMoitra19 Месяц назад +6

    AL31FP should be the engine of choice for our next aircraft and we should develop engine varuants based on AL31.

  • @rajendrapatil1147
    @rajendrapatil1147 Месяц назад +3

    I always recommend to go for super updated SU 30 war plane jets, that are battle tested, experienced. India can have MORE squadrons of super SU 30 to counter our rivals . Better deal done.

  • @islamicsensei
    @islamicsensei Месяц назад +35

    IAF has officially entered panic mode

    • @pvajit1109
      @pvajit1109 Месяц назад +5

      Not Yet in Panic mode. That will be in two years. Besides these engines are not available off the shelf. Russia is busy with Ukraine war. They have to produce these engines for India. Or assemble these in india frim parts supplied by Russia.

    • @suryanshsingh8492
      @suryanshsingh8492 Месяц назад

      😂😂yes and that's not good for you btw seen your bull$hit content just pure hatred for india

  • @sanurawat1651
    @sanurawat1651 Месяц назад +15

    Oh wow i wasn't expecting zero comments

  • @hiteshadhikari
    @hiteshadhikari Месяц назад +5

    Al 41 upgrade would have costed 2 to 3 times the cost of using the ecosystem already in place for the current engine
    Cost benifit analysis was not favouring setting up an Al41 engine line here
    The upgrades done to the al 31 have improved on things quite a bit and the difference would not be sufficient to justify doing it all over with 41 hence this engine was used again.

  • @sigma-sigma1
    @sigma-sigma1 Месяц назад +9

    At least seek the assistance of Russian oems collaboration to upgrade and integrate al-31fp engines with some elements of al-41 engines like fadec control, more fuel efficiency etc.

  • @FalguniSinha2002
    @FalguniSinha2002 Месяц назад +7

    I am feeling glad as well as jealous for my Juniors who will do internship in HAL(KORAPUT) next year😢😢❤

  • @Siddharth_shivshankar
    @Siddharth_shivshankar Месяц назад +4

    Although Sukhoi was inducted in 2002, it is shocking that nobody has thought about a mid-life engine upgrade. Even though we had the opportunity to upgrade our engines, there was no plan for upgrade. this shows how poor our planning was.

  • @kanishkdhanker0280
    @kanishkdhanker0280 Месяц назад +2

    Finally Panic Mode Purchases.

  • @stephenprakash9427
    @stephenprakash9427 Месяц назад +3

    Oh wow I wasn't expecting a single comment

  • @sameer-fk8oy
    @sameer-fk8oy Месяц назад +3

    63 % 🗿🙏

  • @FalguniSinha2002
    @FalguniSinha2002 Месяц назад +10

    Koraput is not only the production hub of AL31 FP engine for sukhoi Or RD33 engine of Mig-29, they too had made gearbox of Kaveri engine,
    Woh baat alag hai ki testing k time pura box hi toot gaya tha😅.

    • @Bibhu99
      @Bibhu99 Месяц назад +1

      We lack experience bro we will definitely do better

  • @jawedmanowar657
    @jawedmanowar657 Месяц назад

    Great Move by GoI and shall give HAL the freedom to go for upgrade

  • @tikki537
    @tikki537 Месяц назад +36

    Highly ill informed video. Why you compared heavy category al31 with f404 engine? Compare it with heavy category f100 engine used in f15 which has MBTO of same 1000 hours and service life of 3200 hours only. But f100 was unreliable with frequent failure leading to f15 crash and now has been replaced by f110 which has service life of 4000 hours. Meanwhile al41 also has service life of 4000 hours and fully FADEC technology. And al31 has zero failure in 20 years of service and is highly reliable. None of the su30mki crash has been because of al31 failure unlike the case when most f15e crash were due to f100 failure. The admin must have factual knowledge.

    • @emotionalIntelligence2078
      @emotionalIntelligence2078 Месяц назад +4

      He compared not based on the category but on what Pakistan will wage a war with in 2035...the last desperate war before civil war kicks in !
      - Similarly Tibet region doesn't allow heavy wt jets to maneuver...so China will also have light wt ones.

    • @cs-ig8qb
      @cs-ig8qb Месяц назад +10

      Its not a wrestling match where you can control you weight category... Enemies can deploy whatever they want against us

    • @skcorpioniner6890
      @skcorpioniner6890 Месяц назад

      Because the Su 30 has two engines mostly one engine has failed and pilots have managed to land with one engine. Ask the question my dear fellow indians why so many engine failures on SU 30. Basically it has bearing problems and chips in oil. Parrikar knew it. But he died. RUclipsrs know next to nothing and keep putting up crap for gullible Bhartiya nagriks😂😂😂😂😂

  • @rahulgawade321
    @rahulgawade321 Месяц назад +1

    Su-30 upgrade demands must higher thrust but still same engine with same power

    • @hiteshadhikari
      @hiteshadhikari Месяц назад +1

      Actually the super sukhoi will not require a new engine. The use of lighter and more power efficient components is enhancing the performance and a new engine is not needed for the planned upgrade

    • @NavratnaGangwar_Trading
      @NavratnaGangwar_Trading Месяц назад +1

      Cost bhi dekhni hai.
      Engine replacement ki jaghah availability and sustainability ke liye sahi step hai.

  • @eliteevildarkness5830
    @eliteevildarkness5830 Месяц назад

    Weren't we gonna add an upgraded version of these engines??

  • @shabbirkhan635
    @shabbirkhan635 Месяц назад

    Bhai i think we should with AL-41F1S fighter engines
    into the long term prospectus our strategy should be always I ahead in the counterpart of China
    When you look into the maintenance cost and MTBO & TEL you will find AL-41F1S fighter engines are quite cheaper in comparison of AL-31FP engines technologies maintenance practice and lifespan cycle hours
    Plus the technology is equipped with AL-41F1S fighter engines technologies optimizations are equipped with Supercruising features capacity and Variable Geometry Digital technologies
    And very special designed digitalized CPU gearbox technology and very special designed materials of the bearings integrated into the AL-41F1S and when you will compare it with the American in the terms of lifespan cycle hours and MTBO you will 100% find it equivalent or more,
    So in Summary going with AL-41F1S fighter engines in the long term strategy it is beneficial as you know as the time changes we have to upgrade the Technologies never remain with the old Technologies because of it is cost effective solutions
    I think and many expertise to believe that we should adopt latest technology

  • @AwaisRana-i7n
    @AwaisRana-i7n Месяц назад +3

    Why not choose AL41 the latest version that used in SU-35

    • @Archway16
      @Archway16 Месяц назад +8

      More expensive + they would come directly from Russia, so no Make In India

    • @abhinavsingh4858
      @abhinavsingh4858 Месяц назад +1

      AL-41 has bigger dimensions than AL-31, hence the airframe would need to be modified to make it fit in the Su-30 MKIs

    • @Vartik-jr4qr
      @Vartik-jr4qr Месяц назад

      ​@@abhinavsingh4858same dimension

    • @K3ppa
      @K3ppa Месяц назад +1

      Cost and not much difference

    • @shabbirkhan635
      @shabbirkhan635 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@abhinavsingh4858
      Russian have successfully completed intigration of AL-41F1S fighter engines into Super Sukhoi SU-30M2 variant, which is currently used by Russian Air-force's
      For your kind information

  • @BharatXtreme
    @BharatXtreme Месяц назад +1

    jai bharat

  • @Chimera_0990tfr
    @Chimera_0990tfr Месяц назад +2

    Defence matrix jara bata do is sal mein kya mk1a ki delivery hogi?

  • @sumitron2k
    @sumitron2k Месяц назад

    defense matrix … what do we do with the scrapped engine .. do we reuse components, is it recyclable etc ? what components go bad after the required 1000 hours overhaul period ? and why we were not able to modernize these components.

    • @pratikpaharia
      @pratikpaharia Месяц назад

      These RUclips Defence channel people don’t know have technical insights. They are simply trying to make money, not much different than unskilled Labour. Don’t expect too much :)

    • @sumitron2k
      @sumitron2k Месяц назад +3

      @@pratikpaharia :) well they are putting in the effort to do research and tell us certain things which i am curious about hence i do like their vids. i don’t watch all defense channels but find defense matrix and alpha defense to do a good job. alpha actually works for one of the defense sector in some capacity so anyways they know more than me. :)

    • @pratikpaharia
      @pratikpaharia Месяц назад

      @@sumitron2k Fair point. I didn't mean to take away from the contribution these YT channels make in informing the crowd, but let us be honest, in days and weeks from now, your questions, or any part of it, will still not have been answered. Not because they wouldn;t have seen the comment, but beause they wouldn't know better to be able to provide an answer :)

    • @sumitron2k
      @sumitron2k Месяц назад

      True… i have gotten response in past when these channels were not that big but maybe now they don’t have time or they don’t have an info. hope yei rehti ki they will cover this topic is a future video.

  • @ashwingupta8621
    @ashwingupta8621 Месяц назад +1

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @Ajay-fl7bl
    @Ajay-fl7bl Месяц назад

    Permission came from Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS). Not Defence Acquisition Council (DAC). Please correct it.

  • @ashisbose6181
    @ashisbose6181 Месяц назад +1

    Drdo announce k5 3stage missile and change range 6000 km to extend 9000 km Official range with two ton warhead. But unofficial range 16000km with mirv because due to sanction fear from USA india announce always half range of original range k5 name daddy missile of k4.
    Drdo😢decide to some c17 globe master to 75 ton weapon load bomber. 50nirvoya 2 missile😮carried to attacked😮whole china 50 town but if carried 10 cruised missile and 60 ton extra oil then even bombed USA and kanada khalistani position.

  • @blankbook9603
    @blankbook9603 Месяц назад

    order kr diya gaya wahi bahut bada baat hai...

  • @chandrachurniyogi8394
    @chandrachurniyogi8394 Месяц назад

    without private sector equity India's indigenous defense aspirations are seriously compromised . . .

  • @SafiWarraich-p6r
    @SafiWarraich-p6r Месяц назад

    We can sense the panic

  • @prashanthb6521
    @prashanthb6521 Месяц назад

    India should add FADEC control on it own. Why arent we doing it ?

  • @Chiku....300
    @Chiku....300 Месяц назад

    Odisha❤

  • @AlphaBeta007
    @AlphaBeta007 Месяц назад

    Is HAL adding fadec , as some articles are reporting?

  • @hrishikeshnagre3280
    @hrishikeshnagre3280 Месяц назад

    Ye engine FADEC ke sath aayenge I think ?

  • @hrishikeshnagre3280
    @hrishikeshnagre3280 Месяц назад +1

    12 su - 30 mki kab order honge ?

    • @K3ppa
      @K3ppa Месяц назад +1

      When all upgrades are ready

  • @pjane9231
    @pjane9231 Месяц назад

    Why does army keep on changing the caliber of its fire arms its rifles? instead it can use upgraded bullets with more lethal projectile!!like the green tip that gives better penitration... This way it is cost effective and efficient...

  • @rajatsinha6607
    @rajatsinha6607 Месяц назад

    Is there a way to increase its thrust even a little bit?

  • @deepfeelings43
    @deepfeelings43 Месяц назад

    2 din phle vali he video lgate ho 😮😮😮

  • @dhavalbhanushali-uh9ve
    @dhavalbhanushali-uh9ve Месяц назад +1

    Tejas ke liye engine le lo

  • @cibertron4860
    @cibertron4860 Месяц назад +1

    ACHA BETA OR MRFA 114 AIRCRAFTS KAB ? 🥸

  • @mayanksoni8465
    @mayanksoni8465 Месяц назад

    63% in haardware term.
    How much in rs. Term...

  • @sadynasty
    @sadynasty Месяц назад

    al 41 brahmos carry karne me jyada helpful hote..higher thrust hone se..heavy brahmos bhi easly equipped ho jati..but chindi chor goverment h...

  • @Godofwar-fw1lu
    @Godofwar-fw1lu Месяц назад

    1.30cr USD per piece is not cheap

  • @maheshshah7570
    @maheshshah7570 Месяц назад

    Why TOT is not 100%

  • @gourabdebnath9449
    @gourabdebnath9449 Месяц назад

    Did the kaveri engine have Fedeck control

  • @insaafkaro009
    @insaafkaro009 Месяц назад

    Worst step by iaf and govt we should have gone with Al41 engines at least if not better

  • @AnkitRaj-0
    @AnkitRaj-0 Месяц назад

    10 mn$ /engine cheap kaise

  • @rajibparida9672
    @rajibparida9672 Месяц назад

    Indian has no other foreign Engine Option other than Russian, We hv no Indigenous Engine. Comparison with Other Engine is valueless.

  • @shabbirkhan635
    @shabbirkhan635 Месяц назад

    AL-41IS fighter engines will come with the solutions of cost effective Fuel consumptions efficiencies improvements and increased significantly more strength and speed controlled substances systems incorporated technologies capabilities provide extra ordinary thrust power producing capacity and supply of electricity power availability required for the enhancement and improved and mor lethal Avonics package in the programme of Super Sukhoi SU-30MKI programme intigrations

    • @kanhyasah6342
      @kanhyasah6342 Месяц назад

      Boss al 41engins is heaver than al 31engine and we have spent more money on tot of engins and spares parts and supply chain management in india with local vanders we have indigation whole al31engine up to 56percent

  • @bhupeshthakur5814
    @bhupeshthakur5814 Месяц назад

    Na 2.3 mach mil ra na fuel efficient kya fayda
    Dikhaya Su 37 terminator aur Mila ye mazak ho gya IAF ke sath. Ab AESA radar lgaake hi pta lgegaa kya hai future iska
    F 15 EX ka EPAWSS ke samne ye kuch b ni na F 18 hornet ke. samne

  • @luckybajwa7212
    @luckybajwa7212 Месяц назад

    By the end of the program, the indigenous rate would be 63 percent. This is being done to increase the average indigenous rate above 54 during the entire program. So what you are saying is incorrect. Dont make videos in a hurry .

  • @utsavgoswami5263
    @utsavgoswami5263 Месяц назад

    Modi hai to mumkin hai, aatmanirbharta hai
    congress hai to chandigarh lobby hai, commission khori hai, defence capability sabotage hai

  • @maheshshah7570
    @maheshshah7570 Месяц назад

    It is old model engine

  • @Yash_15-r2i
    @Yash_15-r2i Месяц назад

    Matalb apna nahi banyege engine 🙂

  • @sunnyverma2567
    @sunnyverma2567 Месяц назад +2

    26000 crore for 240 Engines itne saste kaise 😂😂😂 aadti se le rahe hai kya …. Lutao lutao paisa lutao….. pappu Gandhi kaha ho bhai tum😊😅

    • @K3ppa
      @K3ppa Месяц назад +1

      @@sunnyverma2567 ? I thought engines come free

  • @nishantshrivastava9674
    @nishantshrivastava9674 Месяц назад +3

    Latest deal points out it costs approx 11 million dollars per engine is no where cost effective.
    It is at par the cost of American engine

    • @thepriest8694
      @thepriest8694 Месяц назад +1

      KN thrust class are different .

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 Месяц назад

      @@thepriest8694 GE F414 costs approx 7 million dollars per unit to India.
      And GE F100( F15 EX engine) same class of Al 31 costs approx 11 to 12 million dollars.

    • @hiteshadhikari
      @hiteshadhikari Месяц назад

      The deal does not merely include the engines

    • @thepriest8694
      @thepriest8694 Месяц назад

      @@nishantshrivastava9674Made in India GeF414 cost 90 crores pr engine .

    • @nishantshrivastava9674
      @nishantshrivastava9674 Месяц назад

      @@hiteshadhikari Then enlighten us what else does it include

  • @nocringebruh6967
    @nocringebruh6967 Месяц назад

    Wtf is this BS. They should make it 100% or its just pure copium

  • @junaidahmed1755
    @junaidahmed1755 Месяц назад +1

    "You can buy as many fighter jet engines as you want, but it won't do you any good. Your pilots will flee at the mere mention of the Pakistan Air Force. Remember four years ago, when all your Sukhoi-30s ran away without firing a single missile?"

    • @adarshkumar-ve3fs
      @adarshkumar-ve3fs Месяц назад +2

      😂😂😂 just madarsa chaap knowledge

    • @xpsameer9756
      @xpsameer9756 Месяц назад +1

      You guys are stuck in past ​@@adarshkumar-ve3fs

    • @junaidahmed1755
      @junaidahmed1755 Месяц назад

      @@adarshkumar-ve3fs prove me wrong or just shut your mouth 😂

    • @anubratadas4911
      @anubratadas4911 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@junaidahmed1755 First try to win a war or shut your mouth😂😂

    • @adarshkumar-ve3fs
      @adarshkumar-ve3fs Месяц назад +1

      @@junaidahmed1755 if you think that jf 17 can even touch rafale in bvr then you are most stupid person in Pakistan 😂
      Platform and avionics matter.
      Indian pilots has better skill then Pakistan's air force because of advance avionics and training.
      Till now Pakistan has no answer against rafale 😂 prove me wrong or just shut your mouth.
      Pakistan can't even track 1 brahmos missile forget about intercept it imagine what 400 - 500 brahmos can do ???
      Just saying Pakistan's navy is nothing compared to Indian navy you have to accept it Pakistan doesn't e even have a single destroyer in 2024 !😂 aircraft carrier is still a dream for Pakistan and even commission of 1 nuclear submarine would be biggest achievement for Pakistan in this century. India has 2 made in India nuclear submarine which is over 110m+ in length bigger than any submarine or warship Pakistan ever had and 3rd nuclear submarine would be at sea trials under 6 months.
      NOW IF YOU FEEL AWKWARD ARGUE ME ABOUT ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT DEFENCE SECTOR.
      IF NOT THEN SHUT YOUR MOUTH UP.

  • @asadshah8679
    @asadshah8679 Месяц назад +1

    Crux of the story , India is spending hefty amount to acquire outdated tech (only 63%) over the period of 8 years .

    • @NavratnaGangwar_Trading
      @NavratnaGangwar_Trading Месяц назад

      Itna bhi seekh jaaye toh bhi Kaveri engine ke liye kuch help milegi.

    • @asadshah8679
      @asadshah8679 Месяц назад

      @@NavratnaGangwar_Trading I am from Pakistan but genuinely speaking , this is just a waste of time . Although engine replacement is necessary but acquiring old tech is worthless . If you are putting efforts and money as well , take some pain and go for top notch tech .
      I am making no comparison but Indians say that Pakistan is not contributing to project TFX of turkey . okay accepted , but in the long run Pakistan will have the technology of 5th gen platform by 2035 and AMCA would still be on paper or in its initial stages . JF-17 is a cheap and cost effective solution but it has KLJ-7 , its a big thing as KLJ-7s are being reported to be produced in Pakistan to some extent .. These are used in J-31/35 . With Turkey , Pakistan is producing top notch drones , air to air missiles , investment in air defence . Where is Tejas ? its still in development phase and Pakistan with the experienced gained has started PFX officially , a stop gap between JF-17 and J31& KAAN

  • @muhammadishaq561
    @muhammadishaq561 Месяц назад +1

    So, at a rate of 30 engines per year, it’ll take 8 years to replace 240 engines. That is of course if everything goes as planned.
    Considering the Su-30MKIs entered service in 2001, they’ve already clocked 23 years. Fast forward 8 more years, and voilà-India will have a “new” aircraft after a total of 31 years! Only catch? It’ll still be a 4th generation fighter in an era when everyone else is flying 5th or even 6th generation jets.
    But hey, who needs cutting-edge technology when you can keep refreshing antiques? Maybe by then, they can slap on a few more upgrades and call it the "Su-30MKI Mark Infinity"!

    • @krish2.ogamerz248
      @krish2.ogamerz248 Месяц назад +5

      Don't expect anyone to have large squarden of 6th generation fighter jet before 2040 it's take time for the fighter jet to get mature and usa NGAD programme facing delays other countries 6th generation fighter jets will not take it's first flight before 2036

    • @clashingwithtushar6778
      @clashingwithtushar6778 Месяц назад +1

      Bro the existence of Gen 5 aircraft doesn't make the previous gen aircraft absolute. The 4th ++ gen aircraft are still equally relevant and will be for atleast 2 an half decade. And regarding 6th gen, we are atleast 5 to 10 years far from seeing an actual 6th gen aircraft

    • @krish2.ogamerz248
      @krish2.ogamerz248 Месяц назад

      @@clashingwithtushar6778 we are 15 years behind to see actual 6th generation fighter jet

    • @K3ppa
      @K3ppa Месяц назад +3

      What a stupid comment this was. Let's define 6th generation first what is 6th gen. Even USAF is ordering more 4th generation jets like f16 and f15. They ain't going no where. It's not 4th generation. It's 4.5 gen after cats system comes it will be equivalent to a 5th generation fighter but without the stealth

    • @K3ppa
      @K3ppa Месяц назад +1

      ​@@krish2.ogamerz248let's define 6th generation first then compare how far we are

  • @muhammadishaq561
    @muhammadishaq561 Месяц назад +3

    India could have easily gone for a brand-new aircraft rather than sinking a fortune into upgrading an outdated engine. But hey, why embrace innovation when you can pour billions into tinkering with the past? After all, isn't it more fun to polish an old relic and call it cutting-edge technology? Who needs fresh designs when you can just keep repainting the same old machine? 😂😂😂

    • @krish2.ogamerz248
      @krish2.ogamerz248 Месяц назад +10

      Well than pakistani airforce should stop importing more jf 17 and j10 and it's not about new aircraft it's about the generation and capabilities , sukhoi 30 mki is a 4.5 generation fighter there is nothing wrong to import it more I want indian airforce to have 338 sukhoi 30 mki by 2035 if I calculate it properly

    • @plusultra7258
      @plusultra7258 Месяц назад +5

      Looks like someone does not get that old does not mean it is bad. By that JF 17 should not be used since it is just a cheap copy by China of F-16. Looks like the US should retire F-16s, F-15 already by that 😂

    • @MeenPo786
      @MeenPo786 Месяц назад

      A 🐷 commenting on India like u r rich!😂

    • @a.k4394
      @a.k4394 Месяц назад

      Answer me some simple questions why you people are taught that earth is flat and seasons change as per the wish of Allah 😂😂😂 and also dozens of children are the 'Allah ki deen' and also why you people marry with your sisters ( isn't it shameful and pathetic thing to do ? ) and finally why halala is prevalent in your community ?

    • @a.k4394
      @a.k4394 Месяц назад +7

      @@krish2.ogamerz248 to whom you are educating bro. these madarsa educated won't understand your logic and point of view

  • @kanhyasah6342
    @kanhyasah6342 Месяц назад

    Fedact digital control al 31engine may interduce honna chiya😢😮😮😮

  • @sanjaylalverma7840
    @sanjaylalverma7840 Месяц назад

    Shasta hona chahiya chaha kitna ghatiya ho waha modi

  • @abubakarmujtaba
    @abubakarmujtaba Месяц назад

    Bad decision must go for latest engin

  • @devanshudwivedi5875
    @devanshudwivedi5875 Месяц назад

    Who gives a shit button ->

  • @jogindersagar2629
    @jogindersagar2629 Месяц назад +1

    26000 करोड़ के 240 इंजन मतलब 108 करोड़ का एक
    लूट मची है देश में
    इससे बेहतर है की सीमा विवादो को कुछ give and take करके समाप्त किया जाए
    और ये पैसा पब्लिक ह्यूमन और एजुकेशन के डेवलपमेंट और प्रोग्रेस में लगाया जाए।

  • @stephenprakash9427
    @stephenprakash9427 Месяц назад

    Oh wow I wasn't expecting a single comment