That's because: Except for NH, state highway contracts are still with benamis of State chief minister and road transport ministers... 200% commission, then how come quality roads will be built??
instead of focusing on increasing exports, increasing defense and space budget, increasing budget allocation for government and important things like that, finance ministry is focused on differentiating between salted and caramel popcorn
So according to u Mr. Economist. Highly processed items and regular items should have same taxation 😂.. c'mon use some brain . Aajkal sabhi experts ban gye hai .😂
@@My23789 bruh when did i say that they should have same tax? i was pointing out how that work is done very quickly but impactful work in other sectors takes them a very long time despite having the ability to make it happen much sooner
@@Aditya-op1ql because other sectors have other people working with their own style and dealing with all other issues...but i pointed out the unnecessary targeting of finance minister..it is wrong
Ranveer should know this. NHAI raises money from institutional investors (mostly foreign) to build roads. These investors earn a return on their investment from the tolls that are charged. Swami ji is right that taxes are just going into the pockets of the politicians.
The road cost is mostly recovered through high toll tax. There is very least money going from government's pocket. It's all a big scam. Where middleclass only suffers and all other are celebrating.
Ghante ka best, hamare himachal mein national highway bana hai abhi aao dekho zara yahan gadkari ke kaam ki quality, bewakoof bana rahe hain logon ko yeh aur kuchh ni@@Toofun_TV
This is 100% true. A friend of mine is the contractor for National green movement . She support the government by planting, landscaping trees and lawns on NH and in City parks. Not being paid till now for multiple projects poor lady. She hired local poverty struck people to get the job done. We need a solution for this. 😊😅
Even the opposition have nothing against Gadkari. He should have been the PM. Atleast in the next term Modi should step down and bring in the man who can rebuild the national infrastructure.
Ha ha That makes sense, so it will never happen. The masses need a showman like Amitabh Bachhan, Modi,. Indira Gandhi, Obama, etc. who are good only at speaking powerfully. This is an inherent flaw in democracy which relies on votes, and votes are emotional. If you have a 1000 Crore company you will never hire Modi to run it. Yet, people hire him to run a $4 Trillion country. Ronald Reagan was a fllm star, like Rekha and Sunil Dutt. Or like Sachin Tendulkar, Imran Khan or Arnold Schwarznegger. They get elected. No one cares that they are incompetent. They get the votes as votes are emotional. And this is why criminals also get votes.
Sir is speaking 100% Truth. Roads r build by public & private funds & after been built we r charges Toll charges even after paying Income Tax, GST on products.
What happened to Mr Subbramanium.... 😮 We all know what our honourable minister , Shri Gatkari ji has been doing with solid road networks and connecting all remote areas so well for our country ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉 Far better in last 75 years ❤❤❤
Yes, even Gadkari was in 1970's he would be building roads. TAX economy even doesn't have 10% contribution in building road infrastructure. Gadkari economy model of road building is very unique. Gadkari model of road infrastructure is investment model more than expenditure model.
Income tax, Toll for roads, water tax, Tax on property, GST for everything we purchase, service tax, Swacha Bharat Tax.. :) We are squished, where billionaires don't pay any taxes 😂
Billionaires don't pay tax really 80 cr people get free food from money falling out of sky or the middle class that pay 2-3 lakhs pays for it The collection from gst is 122 billion dollars in a quarter and only the oil import is of 125 billion dollar for that quarter. Only 15 cr people pays income tax 120 cr people are just complaining. In that u r saying billionaires not paying tax is hilarious. Think in terms of economics. India has one of the largest corporate taxing in this planet. Any billionaire buying rolls Royce pays 1.5 cr just in tax. Do middle class buy that?
We pay taxes and the govt gets richer. Modi gets to roam around the world, and talk big in those meetings when in actuality he doesn't do anything for the nations progress. India's farmers are struggling, many people don't have jobs, the value of rupee is nothing compared to what it was before 2016, South Indian states aren't getting the share they deserve for he development and are just being given less than the bare minimum. This govt is all talk on the outside, but on the inside, its horrible. All it has ever done is change names and build temples which does nothing for the country's economy. For a developing country, things like economy, literacy and as a doctor myself I would say medical tech and medical system matters a lot.
@@mangoman-vx4pz Just calculate the amount of tax paid by an billionaires, calculate the tax being collected from Middle class people. Even for electricity and water we are paying after 70+ years of independence. The highest tax paid by any celebrity is Akshay Kumar! What about others? Nobody pays tax because they know the loops in the system, that's why CAs are appointed! The amount of tax taken from middle class is out of proportion, no matter which government gets formed, they'll always suck the blood of middle class working people!
India and China had a similar start …. He explains the difference between the two nations which is also the reason for the differences in the two economies
so are taxes only allocated for new infrastructure? Maintenance of existing infrastructure doesn’t come under tax paid and additional toll is required? Why?
@@swethanidumukkula9848 the debate is not whether it is easy or tough, the debate is when tax is being paid, why isn’t it covered in the same? Do you have any specific answer?
Stupid response on the money going to pockets of people. The infrastructure and the govt run schemes for the less privileged is being funded by the tax. Hatred can make you speak illogical stuff
The highways and flyovers they make, the cost is recovered after the roads are built....this is correct The govt. offers tenders to private companies and the private companies make the roads from their own pocket and then govt tells the companies to recover the cost and profit by collecting toll from that road for the next 10-15-20-30 years and after that the govt. takes over the road. That's called BOT system, that is Building Operate Transfer. Build from your money, Operate the road and collect Toll and then after a certain period, say 10-20 years, Transfer back to Govt. Sometimes, government pays the cost first like say 50-50 percent , but mostly the BOT system prevails. The Income Tax money has nothing to do with the roads that are built because the common man pays Toll, so basically you are paying twice, once Income Tax and secondly Tolls. If they used our money to build roads then why they charging tolls again So just to prove the point that Sir said, the Payment will made after it is build is Correct
Not blaming the Finance Minister but her boss obviously aaj kal meeting sirf GST ke naam pe hoti hai bas. Koi aur kuch aur baat karta nhi hai. As a CS myself 8 years se kissi Government ke Minister ne ICSI aur ICAI mai dhayn nhi diya hai. 😊
Roads arent good at all. Newly built highways have potholes and irregularly placed unmarked speed breakers which is dangerous to lives. Work has been done on humongous scale but of poor quality. Corruption, use of sub standard material, poor labour care and wages are worsening further.
If it was taxes for development, still India’s debt have increased, taxes have increased, government subsidies are all gone govt sectors are privatised. Isn’t it a strange calculation.
I asking One Simple question : Does India is Growing Better than Dubai on Economic level. Dubai doesn't tax like India... there are people who are going beyond That's why Big Business People or Entrepreneur are going to Dubai, America India needs better, who are actually educated...
I hope the govt. Stops any incentive and advantages for the tax office (popcorn haters)... They should be taxed to even talk per min..... F-in greedy pockets
All the people saying that Govt. does not spend anything on roads, PLEASE GOOGLE. Budget gives 2.78 lakh crores for roads, a huge amount. Stop talking without knowing anything, otherwise you look foolish.
But where does the money collected from high taxes go and how one can prove that no development of any sort in the country is not done by the tax money.
I dont know when ranveer calls people like dr swamy arundhati roy and all i doubt him also if he gets funding from any Soros cabal and anti india companies
You can call me anti-national if you want, but the truth is, you haven’t gone through what I’m experiencing. Before the BJP came to power, my salary was more than enough to live a comfortable life, and my primary mode of travel was by air. However, with rising inflation and increased taxes, the cost of living has skyrocketed. While my salary has increased, it hasn’t kept up with these soaring expenses. Despite studying hard and securing a well-respected job, I still can't afford to get married and can barely cover my rent and basic needs. You haven’t faced these struggles, so it’s easy for you to judge
@@amalksuresh286 what truth. No one speaks about how GDP grew from 1.8 to 4 trillion in just 10 years of BJP rule per capita doubled. While INC ruled for 54 years what they did? Giving lands to waqf and made them third largest land owner. Just build 2 AIIMS. BJP build more than them in 10 years. No one talks this. INC banned gurukuls but not madarsas. Why so called secular country has polygamy for muslims sharia based laws for muslims. Do you have any answer. Why Scamgress didn't even build a one expressway all expressways we are seeing almost all of them are build by BJP. Petrol was 33 rs in 2004 and it went to 75 rs in 2014 see the gap see the change. Rising inflation my foot
Honestly speaking, I have huge respect for Gadkari
But roads in India are still not up to the mark
That's because:
Except for NH, state highway contracts are still with benamis of State chief minister and road transport ministers... 200% commission, then how come quality roads will be built??
Gadkari is a central govt minister...roads in state is a state subject
Maybe because you are not voting for right local candidates
So you take it up and improvise honestly 😂😂😂😂
Ask your state governments! Majority of roads around you are theirs.
One nation one election
One popcorn 3 taxes
That is Vishwaguru for you
What a comment haha w
Hilarious 😂😂
No one one nation one medical health facility 😂😂😂
LOL so true
instead of focusing on increasing exports, increasing defense and space budget, increasing budget allocation for government and important things like that, finance ministry is focused on differentiating between salted and caramel popcorn
Don't blame FM. She has to do what her boss tells her. Decisions are made by him.
And he appointed her and continues with her.
popcorn was already taxed but andhnamazis hate bjp so cant do anything about their brainrot
So according to u Mr. Economist. Highly processed items and regular items should have same taxation 😂.. c'mon use some brain . Aajkal sabhi experts ban gye hai .😂
@@My23789 bruh when did i say that they should have same tax? i was pointing out how that work is done very quickly but impactful work in other sectors takes them a very long time despite having the ability to make it happen much sooner
@@Aditya-op1ql because other sectors have other people working with their own style and dealing with all other issues...but i pointed out the unnecessary targeting of finance minister..it is wrong
Ranveer should know this. NHAI raises money from institutional investors (mostly foreign) to build roads. These investors earn a return on their investment from the tolls that are charged. Swami ji is right that taxes are just going into the pockets of the politicians.
India needs its own institutional investors
I dont think all income tax is going to pockets of someone. This statement is bs
@@harshvardhansinghchouhan6697he means the money collected is not being used for the right purposes
The road cost is mostly recovered through high toll tax. There is very least money going from government's pocket. It's all a big scam. Where middleclass only suffers and all other are celebrating.
Poor ?
@@mr.jacker3951poor people don’t buy cars and hence don’t pay toll taxes
But middle class does and that's who suffers
Itna easy nahi hai. Apna FM duniya ka worst hai. Par Nitin Gadkari is the best minister second to none.
Ghante ka best, hamare himachal mein national highway bana hai abhi aao dekho zara yahan gadkari ke kaam ki quality, bewakoof bana rahe hain logon ko yeh aur kuchh ni@@Toofun_TV
Honest and brave man speaking truths.respect.
This is 100% true. A friend of mine is the contractor for National green movement . She support the government by planting, landscaping trees and lawns on NH and in City parks. Not being paid till now for multiple projects poor lady. She hired local poverty struck people to get the job done. We need a solution for this. 😊😅
Even the opposition have nothing against Gadkari. He should have been the PM. Atleast in the next term Modi should step down and bring in the man who can rebuild the national infrastructure.
Ha ha That makes sense, so it will never happen. The masses need a showman like Amitabh Bachhan, Modi,. Indira Gandhi, Obama, etc. who are good only at speaking powerfully. This is an inherent flaw in democracy which relies on votes, and votes are emotional. If you have a 1000 Crore company you will never hire Modi to run it. Yet, people hire him to run a $4 Trillion country. Ronald Reagan was a fllm star, like Rekha and Sunil Dutt. Or like Sachin Tendulkar, Imran Khan or Arnold Schwarznegger. They get elected. No one cares that they are incompetent. They get the votes as votes are emotional. And this is why criminals also get votes.
Why so.Modiji is doing a great job in all aspects.Gadkari or anyone can't match him
Modiji will most probably step down , but I don't think nitin gadkari may be next .
Sir is speaking 100% Truth. Roads r build by public & private funds & after been built we r charges Toll charges even after paying Income Tax, GST on products.
What happened to Mr Subbramanium.... 😮
We all know what our honourable minister , Shri Gatkari ji has been doing with solid road networks and connecting all remote areas so well for our country ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
Far better in last 75 years ❤❤❤
Tender se milta ha road construction usme bhi kaale baazare😂
Ranveer you ask very very value questions Shri Swamyji👌.
Dr.S honest, critical but neverputting forward ' take no prisoners' solutions. Where is Dr S.S now not making noise about Chennai floods.
What flood he should talk about? The water drained within a day and you're calling it a flood
Sometimes Swami Ji talks rationally….😂😂😂😂
Yes sometimes 😂
Always bro. only thing is he rants when he loses limelight.
Sometimes 😂
He is harvard ecomics graduate bruhhh
😅😅
Yes, even Gadkari was in 1970's he would be building roads. TAX economy even doesn't have 10% contribution in building road infrastructure. Gadkari economy model of road building is very unique. Gadkari model of road infrastructure is investment model more than expenditure model.
Bro understood economics better when he said “OKAY” and looked a little concerned 😄 overall, good talk btw….
Income tax, Toll for roads, water tax, Tax on property, GST for everything we purchase, service tax, Swacha Bharat Tax.. :) We are squished, where billionaires don't pay any taxes 😂
Billionaires don't pay tax really 80 cr people get free food from money falling out of sky or the middle class that pay 2-3 lakhs pays for it
The collection from gst is 122 billion dollars in a quarter and only the oil import is of 125 billion dollar for that quarter. Only 15 cr people pays income tax 120 cr people are just complaining. In that u r saying billionaires not paying tax is hilarious. Think in terms of economics. India has one of the largest corporate taxing in this planet. Any billionaire buying rolls Royce pays 1.5 cr just in tax. Do middle class buy that?
We pay taxes and the govt gets richer. Modi gets to roam around the world, and talk big in those meetings when in actuality he doesn't do anything for the nations progress. India's farmers are struggling, many people don't have jobs, the value of rupee is nothing compared to what it was before 2016, South Indian states aren't getting the share they deserve for he development and are just being given less than the bare minimum. This govt is all talk on the outside, but on the inside, its horrible. All it has ever done is change names and build temples which does nothing for the country's economy. For a developing country, things like economy, literacy and as a doctor myself I would say medical tech and medical system matters a lot.
@@mangoman-vx4pz Just calculate the amount of tax paid by an billionaires, calculate the tax being collected from Middle class people. Even for electricity and water we are paying after 70+ years of independence. The highest tax paid by any celebrity is Akshay Kumar! What about others? Nobody pays tax because they know the loops in the system, that's why CAs are appointed! The amount of tax taken from middle class is out of proportion, no matter which government gets formed, they'll always suck the blood of middle class working people!
Tax on child birth
@@VPuffy yeah gandhis used to walk to foreign countries right
Spitting facts 😊
India and China had a similar start …. He explains the difference between the two nations which is also the reason for the differences in the two economies
Swami on Gadkari wow didn't expected that.
Truth Times with Subramanyam Swami .
Dr Swami says the truth.
Lol 😂
If roads are built by taxes then why do they charge a toll?
It's for maintenance of the road which are build and do more development around
so are taxes only allocated for new infrastructure? Maintenance of existing infrastructure doesn’t come under tax paid and additional toll is required? Why?
Road could be maintained by the income tax or even additional gst but can't fill the pockets of all the politicians..@@md1954
@@md1954 boss maintenance requires alot than we assume... talk to a civil engg to understand how tough it is
@@swethanidumukkula9848 the debate is not whether it is easy or tough, the debate is when tax is being paid, why isn’t it covered in the same? Do you have any specific answer?
What is the point of giving income tax and then road tax when we also have to pay toll tax to use those roads?
Corruption= all time high in Indian History 😢
In income tax govt giving example of roads , and for roads they are recovering the cost from toll tax..
This needs a raise
Jaigurudev Dada gurudev
Stupid response on the money going to pockets of people. The infrastructure and the govt run schemes for the less privileged is being funded by the tax.
Hatred can make you speak illogical stuff
Yes you are right but the thing is why development not happened during 72 years if it's not the current leaders
Speaking truth
The highways and flyovers they make, the cost is recovered after the roads are built....this is correct
The govt. offers tenders to private companies and the private companies make the roads from their own pocket and then govt tells the companies to recover the cost and profit by collecting toll from that road for the next 10-15-20-30 years and after that the govt. takes over the road.
That's called BOT system, that is Building Operate Transfer.
Build from your money, Operate the road and collect Toll and then after a certain period, say 10-20 years, Transfer back to Govt.
Sometimes, government pays the cost first like say 50-50 percent , but mostly the BOT system prevails.
The Income Tax money has nothing to do with the roads that are built because the common man pays Toll, so basically you are paying twice, once Income Tax and secondly Tolls.
If they used our money to build roads then why they charging tolls again
So just to prove the point that Sir said, the Payment will made after it is build is Correct
Right Government sell Bonds to make.Roads and pocket Income tax
Gurudev ❤
Not blaming the Finance Minister but her boss obviously aaj kal meeting sirf GST ke naam pe hoti hai bas. Koi aur kuch aur baat karta nhi hai. As a CS myself 8 years se kissi Government ke Minister ne ICSI aur ICAI mai dhayn nhi diya hai. 😊
"Baap ka road" makes sense now
2 billion dollar coastal road project in Mumbai filled with patches due to potholes !
Build a road and keep collecting toll even after the whole expense to build that road is collected. This happens in India
"I'm trying to understand economics better" nice use of words
As the time passing, his thoughts and allegations towards BJP is becoming more prominent.
Roads are built by PPP model... Private companies build roads and the road users pay tolls... IT has nothing to do with roads...
We still have potholes in Bangalore. I don't think tax collected here is less
Government print the money and fund the develpment.
😂😂😂
Roads arent good at all. Newly built highways have potholes and irregularly placed unmarked speed breakers which is dangerous to lives.
Work has been done on humongous scale but of poor quality. Corruption, use of sub standard material, poor labour care and wages are worsening further.
Honestly asking where is all our tax money is going, if the road have been built with our money then what is the reason for toll taxes.
For funding illegal Bangladeshi, Rohingya muslim immigrants, freeloaders.😂😂
Jitna bada gathbandhan jitne bhi log involved hai coalition meh utna tax badhega sab khayenge mil baat kr khayenge. Middleclass 🤡
If it was taxes for development, still India’s debt have increased, taxes have increased, government subsidies are all gone govt sectors are privatised.
Isn’t it a strange calculation.
Then why had you proposed inheritance tax?
Cut right truth
Gadkari doesn't get money from tax he raises bonds and pay by toll
I asking One Simple question : Does India is Growing Better than Dubai on Economic level. Dubai doesn't tax like India... there are people who are going beyond
That's why Big Business People or Entrepreneur are going to Dubai, America
India needs better, who are actually educated...
I hope the govt. Stops any incentive and advantages for the tax office (popcorn haters)... They should be taxed to even talk per min..... F-in greedy pockets
Ranveer didn't understand the meaning of dexterity and replied "ok" 😂😂😂
In all rationality, gadkari deserve to be the pm on India.
Blown..!!
Swamy has some balls😂
All the people saying that Govt. does not spend anything on roads, PLEASE GOOGLE. Budget gives 2.78 lakh crores for roads, a huge amount. Stop talking without knowing anything, otherwise you look foolish.
sir aap please sitaraman pe case daal do, usne band baja rakhi h middle class ki
Income tax is just too much
What is the criteria to join income tax dept?
I wanna become rich 🤑
Give upsc
But where does the money collected from high taxes go and how one can prove that no development of any sort in the country is not done by the tax money.
Very true Nirmala jee is killing our life
He is right btw
Why BJP is afraid of this sincere person into Finance Portfolio.?
It's good that Nirmala knows only three types of popcorns 🌽. Else if knows the variety she will end up making a unending list of taxes on popcorn 🍿
Ambani Adani ke tax ke paise bhi toh maaf krni hai😒
"Not at all" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sad reality of India 😅
Gang of EWS
Nirmala, swant, gadkari,nehru, patel, pvn rao, chidambaram
Isko bhai finance minister banna he or jab tak isko nhi bnaenge ye ese hi 😂 leta rhega sabki
They say, our tax is used to build roads..
Govt pays the company building the road...and then again extort toll taxes ....where is samaj sewa...
It is correct..unfortunately Mr.. swami is FBI agent..
Why the hell people think with Tax money roads are being built. Roads are built by toll fee they charge us and not by tax 😅😅
I dont know when ranveer calls people like dr swamy arundhati roy and all i doubt him also if he gets funding from any Soros cabal and anti india companies
When 2 people who don't understand economics discuss economics
Defense upgradation kaha se hi raha hai chacha se pucho
❤
Road doesn’t built from income taxes it’s built by contractors then he get recovered from toll tax
"Without Gadkari"
Too much tax in India , frustrating
You can call me anti-national if you want, but the truth is, you haven’t gone through what I’m experiencing. Before the BJP came to power, my salary was more than enough to live a comfortable life, and my primary mode of travel was by air. However, with rising inflation and increased taxes, the cost of living has skyrocketed. While my salary has increased, it hasn’t kept up with these soaring expenses. Despite studying hard and securing a well-respected job, I still can't afford to get married and can barely cover my rent and basic needs. You haven’t faced these struggles, so it’s easy for you to judge
lol bot
@@riderchallenge4250 ?? Kya hua bhai
@@riderchallenge4250everyone who speaks the truth is a bot now?
@@amalksuresh286 what truth. No one speaks about how GDP grew from 1.8 to 4 trillion in just 10 years of BJP rule per capita doubled. While INC ruled for 54 years what they did? Giving lands to waqf and made them third largest land owner. Just build 2 AIIMS. BJP build more than them in 10 years. No one talks this. INC banned gurukuls but not madarsas. Why so called secular country has polygamy for muslims sharia based laws for muslims. Do you have any answer. Why Scamgress didn't even build a one expressway all expressways we are seeing almost all of them are build by BJP. Petrol was 33 rs in 2004 and it went to 75 rs in 2014 see the gap see the change. Rising inflation my foot
Ranveer pls try to bring a krishna tantra practitioner so that krishna devotees can see him from a tantra pov 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Please don't bring him!
You seriously think he listens or even see our comments?
@yushaplayer dont give up bro
Productivity khatam h India mai bas tax tax tax jisne desh ko khatam krdia hain ....
Make this guy a finance minister of India and he will tell you how modi government policies are beneficial for Nation
By people's tax money the country gets good infrastructure and development
Wo bacche jinko neighbour toffee de to baap bol dete hain.... Wahi baccha aaj buddha hoke MP bna baitha hai...🙏
💯
Nirmala jaise minister yahi kar rahe hai😮
Bhaiya harek chijh me tax aur majduri utna hi
We still have potholes. Gatkari hasn't done much....😂
Nitin Gadkari is uncorrupt and superb man
We still have potholes
Dr. S S should have been the one in place of "her". The only problem with "him" is that he sometimes become irrational.
He's an unstable genius.
Where does this go? road tax, tax on fuel , tax on insurance, registration fee .. + tons of taxes
If we dont pay taxes how will all the govts give subsidies and freebies, taxes are collected to provide freebies to the vote bank😂
And what about toll taxes??
Bro if they use tax money then why take tolls, if they use tax money why should tax payers pay again
😂 Fun fact : roads are build by tax payer money and again it is looted as toll money 😂
I think we need monarchy
Some one take this seriously done having hike on task
Guess what? We have Gadkari ji and still have potholes.