They had a brother - sister relationship. She was in love with her Jackie. she loved Arthur like a big brother, showing her the ropes of being an outlaw with a heart. Plus, he's terrified of her.
Both were broken and empty shells of their former selves. They understood each other like noone but there was not a single change they would develop romantic feelings towards each other. Sadie died with her husband and Artur died with his child and wife. They both were heartbroken beyond repair. Arthur liked being around Mary because she was his first love and reminded him of their previous innocent lives which he missed very much.
I knew something was up with her when a simple shopping trip turned into a bloodbath, but I'll never forget the raid on Shady Bell. Middle of the fight I hear Sadie scream in the distance and I go running over to help her, only to find out that wasn't a scream for help but a bloodthirty war-cry as she stabs several men to death.
The one that stayed with me was in the last chapter I think when they're hunting you-know-who, and she gets stabbed or shot, don't remember, and Arthur goes to help her and she scream "I ain't dying" don't know why
I think if it wasn't for the fact that Sadie is a widow and focused on being a badass and killing odriscalls. Arthur and Sadie would've been amazing together
I like that Arthur doesnt seem interested in anyone, besides maybe considering getting back together with Mary. Some people, like myself, kinda just stop looking for partners and just focus on the day to day. Maybe if someone hits their fancy in just the right way, hed try a relationship, but he seems more focused on surviving the day.
I think mary understood that arthur will not settle down. She let him go a second time. And yes we did see mary visiting arthurs grave in the ending credit.
Arthur were only interested in the girl that got away + He already lost his family, so it's not like he is willing to go about and lose another one especially considering what kind of a girl Sadi turned into. He's attracted to the girl away from this life, the opposite attracts
Am I the only one who greeted a prostitute and John said, "I hope you've got protection," and I thought I was about to sleep with her, and then he said, "There's bad people out there." 😂
Arthur doesn't get involved with Sadie mostly because of what he and her have both gone through in their lives. Arthur losing his family and Sadie losing a chance to ever have hers. Their relationship is one built on respect not carnal desires. Arthur does develop some romantic feelings for Sadie but would never act on them because he knows she simply would never go for it and in a way Arthur sees himself as someone who knows in a lot of ways he's no better then the men that killed her husband and Sadie would never be with someone like that. Most people in the group view Arthur as the big brother, but from day one Sadie never saw him that way. They were equals.
Then again there’s Charlotte who lost her husband and few weeks ago when you meet her and then only knowing Arthur after like 3 encounters is interested in him and even kisses him on the cheek
Arthur was actually always interested about Sadie and deeply cared for her. So did she. But they were both too traumatised and on different paths in their lives. “Romance” wasn’t a possibility because they were always just looking to somehow survive and on the run. Plus, the writers c0ckblocked their potential romance.
If Sadie didnt let John know that Micah was still alive, he’d probably stay alive. Him, Sadie and Charles left such a big mess on the Epilogue Final Mission, and that brought John into Ross’s radar. So in a way, Sadie letting John know that he has the chance to avenge Arthur (something, Arthur wouldnt want John to do) signed his death warrant.
@@tombombadilofficial are you seriously blaming sadie for john's death 😭 john was aware of the risks, he could've easily died DURING THE MISSION, and he still did it to avenge his brother. it made sense for his character
They were definitely interested in each other after a while. Would take a blind person to not see the flirting. It just seems like kind of a “right person, VERY wrong time” type thing. People can still be close friends with eachother while having romantic feelings that are never acted upon.
Exactly also I wonder what it would be like if Molly and Arthur got together me personally I feel like Molly would just turn to Arthur for the attention Dutch wasn't giving her
I always kinda felt like Arthur and Sadie had feelings for each other after a while has passed by. Like i mean how they flirted and talked and acted on each other, that’s not normal friend or whatsoever behavior. But they were both broken and probably that’s the reason why they never confessed their feelings to each other
In my playthrough when we had our party for Sean I was able to dance with Mary Beth while Dutch danced with Molly. After playing the game so many times that was the first encounter like that I seen.
Fun fact: during development Sadie was planned to be a romanceable character similar to Mary. However rockstar removed this as it conflicted with the story and characters. There are still some lines of dialogue in the game files left over from this.
I could understand if it was a brother/sister like relationship, on the other hand I can also understand if it was something more, a part of me hopes it's the latter because I hope they ah "did the deed" and that Arthur at least had a child before his time, because for him to go out like that and not leave a legacy behind is very heartbreaking 💔
A lil out of topic, but if y'all read Arthur's Journal, he seems to fancy Abigail herself. He wrote something along the lines of "Had I married her, etc..." I forgot the exact lines, but it's somewhere between chapter 2 or 3.
Arthur was actually in love with with Mary Linton and ever since the two broke up, he never really found anyone else apart from Eliza whom he had a son with but both of them were killed
even roger clark said he didn’t like people wanting him and sadie together. they’re siblings not lovers. he said arthur only loved mary and sadie only loved jake. they were both too broken to like each other like that
Arthur and Sadie both know in other circumstances they could've been together, but both are still hurting over the death of their partners over petty robbery. They understand each other like nobody else in that camp, for the same reason Arthur and John see each other as brothers due to their upbringing.
@@leahward6790 what you on about!? There’s loads of scenes if your honour is maxed out where it’s identical to broke back mountain. Lenny gives Arthur a bath in one scene. And Arthur’s tells Lenny he always loved him when he died. What game you played?? 🤔
I love this relationship between Arthur and Sadie, so much that I think that Sadie should be the main character in RDR 3. The story would take place after the incident with the mustached rat on that mountain, you know what I mean (I didn't want to say spoilers). There is some potential in this solution, especially if we will be able to play as a female character in GTA VI and here in RDR 3 as well.
claytonhawk8512 pretty much covers it, but I will reiterate why Arthur isn't interested in anyone but Mary. Arthur already had a family once. They got killed when he was away doing outlaw things. The experience hardened him. That's why he won't even consider anything more than a deluxe bath from working girls. Because he fears the responsibility that could come from one simple mishap. Mary makes him dream but not of family, just sweet times, and being free from the gang, being free of responsibility altogether. The only woman, other than Mary, he considers briefly during the events of the game is Abigail, because he wants to be there for Jack, since John is useless, not because he is sweet on Abigail, not anymore anyway.
I don’t think you will find he was much. And even if he was don’t forget that Sadie was still getting over her husband. I mean for Christ sake she even went on that killing spree killing as many odricsals as she can. And why do you think she became a bounty hunter in the end? Think about it. That would of never happened if her husband was still alive. Let alone her being in the gang as well.
For me, they have like a siblings relationship, like Arthur being a big brother to her. And if he even loves her in some point and surpass Mary, he wouldn't even kiss her, thanks to his TB.
Sadies scream sounds less of a "help me! Im a woman in distress!" Type scream and more of a lion or a cougar fighting to the death, like in the shady belle raid behind the barn, I honest to god thought a cougar wandered in while we were shooting until I saw sadie stabbing those guys to death
The real reason why Arthur wasn't interested in Sadie is because Sadie wasn't interested in any other man than her husband that got killed by the O'Driscolls
I think he does like her and she likes him but she was depressed because her husband was killed by the O’driscolls which she wasn’t over yet obviously and Arthur wanted Mary Linton too
The *real* real reason is... "No one would have me" - Arthur Morgan, 1899 Edit: Ignore this bit down here I dont like the channel, please dont like my comment
If you’re drunk and interact with Sadie, in one of the later chapters, he will say “I love you”
he can say that to every member
I think him and Sadie have more of a family relationship like an older brother
@@BenPerez-hr6ixchapter 5 takes place in the south 😏
This is simultaneously one of the most liked and horniest comments I’ve ever written
@@roboticcake6047 🤨🤨🤨
@@roboticcake6047well u got a point there. In final mission of chapter 6, when Sadie asks Arthur to go on the lighthouse she calls him "honey"
Ok but Karen singing farewell to Sean was heartbreaking though.
No it wasn’t
@@Wort-Wort-Wortdude. I felt nothing for Sean.
@@Wort-Wort-WortOh, hey Micah.
@@Wort-Wort-WortYES IT WAS.
Looks like 2.2k people disagree, well, not me including@@Wort-Wort-Wort
They had a brother - sister relationship.
She was in love with her Jackie. she loved Arthur like a big brother, showing her the ropes of being an outlaw with a heart.
Plus, he's terrified of her.
Jackie? His name was jake
@@nedflandersmustache when u help Sadie at Hanging Dog she calls him "her Jackie"
@@damienthetexasian6827No, it's Jakey, his name was Jake.
@@artemis-entity4177 sorry keeps autocorrecitng from JAKIE TO Jackie
that's a perfect way of putting it, just because people have chemistry, doesn't mean they want to bang each other
Both were broken and empty shells of their former selves. They understood each other like noone but there was not a single change they would develop romantic feelings towards each other. Sadie died with her husband and Artur died with his child and wife. They both were heartbroken beyond repair. Arthur liked being around Mary because she was his first love and reminded him of their previous innocent lives which he missed very much.
As he already said to her: "We're more ghost's than people"
Arthur did not have a wife - he had a kid with a waitress and would visit them, until they died.
Like Arthur said there more ghosts than they are people
@naomi-g Mary Linton was his ex-wife. She gives Arthur her wedding ring back in chapter 6.
And yes, he was too with a waitress and had a child.
Artur😭😭😭
I knew something was up with her when a simple shopping trip turned into a bloodbath, but I'll never forget the raid on Shady Bell.
Middle of the fight I hear Sadie scream in the distance and I go running over to help her, only to find out that wasn't a scream for help but a bloodthirty war-cry as she stabs several men to death.
The one that stayed with me was in the last chapter I think when they're hunting you-know-who, and she gets stabbed or shot, don't remember, and Arthur goes to help her and she scream "I ain't dying" don't know why
That's why arthur is scared of her
@@rafaelferfer1332 JM no, this happened at the end of the game with John
@@jefferyheslop5567 I think he was trying to avoid spoiling the game for others. It's like 5 years old by now though so it doesn't really matter.
That’s when I realized Sadie was built different 😂😂
I think if it wasn't for the fact that Sadie is a widow and focused on being a badass and killing odriscalls. Arthur and Sadie would've been amazing together
No
"Затаившийся Ленивец".
focused on being a mary sue
@@lepersonnage371waaaahhh waaaahhh, I hate it when female characters are independent and strong even if that's literally 95% of Rockstar characters
@@dirtydan883 strong and independent (from what btw?) is one thing, and mary sue is another
@@lepersonnage371your gonna attract the simps lol
I like that Arthur doesnt seem interested in anyone, besides maybe considering getting back together with Mary. Some people, like myself, kinda just stop looking for partners and just focus on the day to day. Maybe if someone hits their fancy in just the right way, hed try a relationship, but he seems more focused on surviving the day.
Wdym kinda? He wanted her so bad, did u read his journal? And go on the second mission in Saint Denis
@@edbootay9461 i don't recall seeing anything in the journal about him wanting Sadie
@@edbootay9461nowhere in the journal did it say he was into Sadie let alone wanting her.
@@edbootay9461I think he was referring to Mary guys
I think mary understood that arthur will not settle down. She let him go a second time. And yes we did see mary visiting arthurs grave in the ending credit.
Arthur were only interested in the girl that got away + He already lost his family, so it's not like he is willing to go about and lose another one especially considering what kind of a girl Sadi turned into.
He's attracted to the girl away from this life, the opposite attracts
"Nasty, angry, smelly.... and dumb, just like a real outlaw"
Th is your picture supposed to be trigun or some shit
@@kennykenny5264 Alucard
@@rdr.erasedyou sir, op mods or not, are very good at red dead, or atleast making good videos
Am I the only one who greeted a prostitute and John said, "I hope you've got protection," and I thought I was about to sleep with her, and then he said, "There's bad people out there." 😂
Literally had that happen last night when I was grinding honour... Lemme guess, you were in Valentine?
@xavierwedel4691 Yeah, that's where I was the first time it happened to me.
Yup, same here
*there
YES!! Omg it was so funny and i didn’t think that happened to anyone else
Arthur doesn't get involved with Sadie mostly because of what he and her have both gone through in their lives. Arthur losing his family and Sadie losing a chance to ever have hers. Their relationship is one built on respect not carnal desires. Arthur does develop some romantic feelings for Sadie but would never act on them because he knows she simply would never go for it and in a way Arthur sees himself as someone who knows in a lot of ways he's no better then the men that killed her husband and Sadie would never be with someone like that. Most people in the group view Arthur as the big brother, but from day one Sadie never saw him that way. They were equals.
No, the reason is she lost her husband like few months ago. She's still mourning and is not interested in anyone than Jake!
Then again there’s Charlotte who lost her husband and few weeks ago when you meet her and then only knowing Arthur after like 3 encounters is interested in him and even kisses him on the cheek
@@lemonsquidge3134Different people behave differently
@@NicoGVHis point is that is not impossible for a woman who has lost her husband have interest in another man. But i understand ur point too.
I love sadie
I hate sadie
I hate Sadie
That’s cold dude
She’s 49
@@Adam48374no
bc arthur was still obsessed with mary and sadie was still mourning jake
I belive the word you're looking for is "mourning", Sadie was mourning her dead husband, by way of obliterating the gang that did it.
@@ogcr2008 yes that’s a better word
Arthur was actually always interested about Sadie and deeply cared for her. So did she. But they were both too traumatised and on different paths in their lives. “Romance” wasn’t a possibility because they were always just looking to somehow survive and on the run. Plus, the writers c0ckblocked their potential romance.
I love Sadie. She was basically the one who held the gang together when Dutch and the guys went to the islands.
And Charles too
If Sadie didnt let John know that Micah was still alive, he’d probably stay alive. Him, Sadie and Charles left such a big mess on the Epilogue Final Mission, and that brought John into Ross’s radar. So in a way, Sadie letting John know that he has the chance to avenge Arthur (something, Arthur wouldnt want John to do) signed his death warrant.
@@tombombadilofficial are you seriously blaming sadie for john's death 😭 john was aware of the risks, he could've easily died DURING THE MISSION, and he still did it to avenge his brother. it made sense for his character
@@iamnotemo6306ikr even Abigail was begging John to not go but he still did it
I love sadie
She cool
Edit: as a character
I hate Sadie
She’s stupid
Why?
@@Seth-xh8qs she’s just cool, nothing to explain
@@TooDrizzy1 she’s cool but over the top. Also you did explain
Yeah that fart was so cool
They were definitely interested in each other after a while. Would take a blind person to not see the flirting. It just seems like kind of a “right person, VERY wrong time” type thing. People can still be close friends with eachother while having romantic feelings that are never acted upon.
Exactly also I wonder what it would be like if Molly and Arthur got together me personally I feel like Molly would just turn to Arthur for the attention Dutch wasn't giving her
I always kinda felt like Arthur and Sadie had feelings for each other after a while has passed by. Like i mean how they flirted and talked and acted on each other, that’s not normal friend or whatsoever behavior. But they were both broken and probably that’s the reason why they never confessed their feelings to each other
Can you imagine if they did end up getting together, only for her to lose Arthur too?
We all lost Arthur.
Imagine the offspring top gunslinger that we could play in RD3.... Just imagine....
Sadie: **farted**
Arthur: “okay i'll catch you later then 😷”
😂
0:19 Sadie farting
Arthur : Okay I'll catch you later then 🤠🗿
No, there was some blood on her fingers that she had to wave off
@@M3TAH34DNah, that is farting animation. Npcs does it all the time ingame.
Sadie was still mourning her husband and Arthur is clearly still not over Mary.
A lot of people dont seem to know that sadie and arthurs relationship was cut content
I wish it happened,or at least a little nod,they both could have used it story wise
Arthur ain’t no simp🗿
Being interested in women means you're a simp...? I pity your father
He simped for Mary like hell 🙃
In my playthrough when we had our party for Sean I was able to dance with Mary Beth while Dutch danced with Molly. After playing the game so many times that was the first encounter like that I seen.
Yeah, me too
Fun fact: during development Sadie was planned to be a romanceable character similar to Mary. However rockstar removed this as it conflicted with the story and characters. There are still some lines of dialogue in the game files left over from this.
can't Sadie drop the gas outside the camp or a hidden edge? 🤔
?
Why should she be the only who can’t fart where the mood takes her?
Arthur didn’t love Sadie he did kinda have a crush on black belle tho
Yeah true
Who didn't shes a Cougar with that wink she does on top of that shes also a badass
Who doesn't have a crush on Black Belle?!
If they had more time they absolutely would have fallen in love but neither of them were in that place yet. The sad part is they never would be.
Arthur knew he was damned and didn't bother, instead he tried to get right with the Lord before checking out
Arthur didn’t believe in God, that was not his motivation to do anything.
I could understand if it was a brother/sister like relationship, on the other hand I can also understand if it was something more, a part of me hopes it's the latter because I hope they ah "did the deed" and that Arthur at least had a child before his time, because for him to go out like that and not leave a legacy behind is very heartbreaking 💔
I think it’s because she farted like 3 seconds before he walked over
0:16 Is it just me or did Sadie fart? It didn't make any noise 🥲
Silent but deadly farts.
The attention grabber
I didn't hear a noise, but she was waving her hands around, can't stand the smell of her own farts. I'm lucky 'cause my farts smell like roses.
Rule 34:
A lil out of topic, but if y'all read Arthur's Journal, he seems to fancy Abigail herself. He wrote something along the lines of "Had I married her, etc..." I forgot the exact lines, but it's somewhere between chapter 2 or 3.
That is what is on Arthur's tombstone. "OK I'll catch ya later then"....LOL
Arthur was actually in love with with Mary Linton and ever since the two broke up, he never really found anyone else apart from Eliza whom he had a son with but both of them were killed
even roger clark said he didn’t like people wanting him and sadie together. they’re siblings not lovers.
he said arthur only loved mary and sadie only loved jake. they were both too broken to like each other like that
Sadie was extremely fathful to her husband, she still considered herself as married.
Sadie was the legend gunslinger in south after time skip
because shes low honor
This video didn’t explain nothing
If I was Jake I'd be mad af about dying too
Arthur and Sadie both know in other circumstances they could've been together, but both are still hurting over the death of their partners over petty robbery.
They understand each other like nobody else in that camp, for the same reason Arthur and John see each other as brothers due to their upbringing.
Bro why did they not put them together, Sadie is the baddest in the game
0:17 lmao nobody mentioning that Sadie farts 😂😂
Girls can't fart idiot
Girls don't fart, they poot (Richard Pryor)
Charlotte was the woman he needed. She listened and cared, good head on her shoulders. Mary... She thought he was pretty. But who doesn't?
oh, I think he was plenty "interested"-it just wasn't in the stars
I have played this game for well over 500 hours and there is ALWAYS something I haven’t seen or experienced. Absolutely insane!
I’m missing it. What’s the reason.
Sadie is beautful
Because Arthur had a thing with Lenny, it’s even in some of the hidden dialect
Now that's what I call a reach
LENNY!!!
Arthur ain't gay 💀💀💀💀
Isn’t Lenny like 19????
@@leahward6790 what you on about!? There’s loads of scenes if your honour is maxed out where it’s identical to broke back mountain. Lenny gives Arthur a bath in one scene. And Arthur’s tells Lenny he always loved him when he died.
What game you played?? 🤔
Thumbnail doesn’t match the video. I mean, what am i supposed to be seeing?
She farted. Idk why he missed the actual fart noise.
I mean if someone like Micah call you hellfire
I love Sadie wish i marry a tough girl like her
SIMP
women have germs. ewwwww.
Arthur WAS interested in Sadie. He wrote it in his journal
Simply because they are in love with other people.
Bro I would’ve loved them together
The phrase arthur tells her in beaver hollow "You and me... well we are most ghost than people" makes you realize the main reason for that
I love this relationship between Arthur and Sadie, so much that I think that Sadie should be the main character in RDR 3. The story would take place after the incident with the mustached rat on that mountain, you know what I mean (I didn't want to say spoilers). There is some potential in this solution, especially if we will be able to play as a female character in GTA VI and here in RDR 3 as well.
Stay focus Arthur
Stay focused Arthur. Focus on your damn TB
@@lancematthewrcunanan1785 yeah
The reason is Arthur saw Sadie as more of a step sister than anything else.
I feel like the writers were sort of on the fence about making Sadie and Arthur have a thing at times but ultimately decided not to
claytonhawk8512 pretty much covers it, but I will reiterate why Arthur isn't interested in anyone but Mary. Arthur already had a family once. They got killed when he was away doing outlaw things. The experience hardened him. That's why he won't even consider anything more than a deluxe bath from working girls. Because he fears the responsibility that could come from one simple mishap. Mary makes him dream but not of family, just sweet times, and being free from the gang, being free of responsibility altogether. The only woman, other than Mary, he considers briefly during the events of the game is Abigail, because he wants to be there for Jack, since John is useless, not because he is sweet on Abigail, not anymore anyway.
I don’t get it? The video seems completely irrelevant to its title?¿
Sigma Arthur Morgan doesn't simp
Fix your title. This is your reason into why you think he didnt like Sadie.
He only loves mary
And where's the real reason here?
Don’t know why the idiot that posted this can heart but not reply. She farted that’s why
I mean get you a girl who can be both a badass outlaw and a classy wife
Probably Arthur's still in love with Mary, and he ain't dumb enough to marry a girl 10 years younger than him
Pretty sure they are the same age
@@AinnRubiix of coujrse not
That thumbnail though, with her pouty mouth and semi-closed eyes 😂
bro the thumbnail
gorsh
I don’t think you will find he was much.
And even if he was don’t forget that Sadie was still getting over her husband.
I mean for Christ sake she even went on that killing spree killing as many odricsals as she can.
And why do you think she became a bounty hunter in the end?
Think about it. That would of never happened if her husband was still alive. Let alone her being in the gang as well.
I thought she was gonna fart or something
For me, they have like a siblings relationship, like Arthur being a big brother to her.
And if he even loves her in some point and surpass Mary, he wouldn't even kiss her, thanks to his TB.
He still was in love with his precious Mary
Sooooooo, what's the reason 🤦🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
Just hearts the comment no explanation.
I'm assuming he's trying to imply that her singing is bad.
@@n1ghtst6lker02she farted ☠️
@@n1ghtst6lker02I think that's Karen singing about Sean
Sadies scream sounds less of a "help me! Im a woman in distress!" Type scream and more of a lion or a cougar fighting to the death, like in the shady belle raid behind the barn, I honest to god thought a cougar wandered in while we were shooting until I saw sadie stabbing those guys to death
Sadly Adler
The real reason why Arthur wasn't interested in Sadie is because Sadie wasn't interested in any other man than her husband that got killed by the O'Driscolls
İ played last mission and in the mission sadie cares about arthur and says him honey
Arthur was always a one girl type of man.
Arthur is sigma, he doesn't like women.
He likes men
I think he does like her and she likes him but she was depressed because her husband was killed by the O’driscolls which she wasn’t over yet obviously and Arthur wanted Mary Linton too
You didn't want to play "five finger filet" with Sadie?
ok soooooo whats the reason?????????
this dosnt say why arthur dosnt love sadie
Cute face in thumbnail.
The *real* real reason is...
"No one would have me" - Arthur Morgan, 1899
Edit: Ignore this bit down here
I dont like the channel, please dont like my comment
She looks good in that thumbnail 🥵
what reason?
He liked Sonny better
Arthur wasn't into her but I was lmao
Arthur Is 12 Years Older Than Sadie
I clicked it for the thumbnail
Don't get it
at 0:16 she farts
Didnt hear it but i saw she blew the fart away😂😂
0:24
Best Arthur line in the entire game right there
Bro just don't want to 💀
Because she ahd just lost her husband and still loved him