@@farahhni it's rose even gd mentioned it during his concert lee hi sang roses part even chaesoo vlive they mentioned she changed her vocal technique coz bp wanted a lighter tone member as well jennie,jisoo,lisa voices are already has a strong tone
Is it wrong to point out, that as a Singer, Y'all are irritating because You have no knowledge of what Voice means... yet everyone has that, insect in tummy, to appear knowledgeable...? Rosé had Old Technique and Tonality in GD song... Now Rosé has different Technique( mainly due to nasality and Twang ) and Tonality( due to aging )...
@@roohisitharaabdulwahab9025 But bro have you heard this voice? Why the hell did yg need a Contrast tone From rosé only her vocals were so amazing then
rosés register back then wasnt deep. it was on the lower side but not deep. she’s always had a pretty middle toned talking voice so when she sings and does high notes it’ll ofc go higher that’s how singing is! she bettered her technique over the years so she can sing longer durations. :)
The vocal tone she has now is something that you have to be blessed to discover. The actual vocal coaches ( not the fake ones who act like professionals when it comes to Rosé) had reacted to her pre debut vocals and had said that she had found her own unique vocal tone which takes tears of training to discover. Don't downgrade her hardwork with your fake knowledge
@@NickiBora dude , do u understand English at all. I just said I liked her old voice and wanted to hear it again in her new songs , did I by any means commented any hate about her. You toxic blinks are always like this, this is the reason we r not allowed to even give our opinions also .
@@NickiBora And who gets to decide who are the real coaches? You? That's a fucking weak ass argument. Vocal coaches know she is achieving this thinner timbre by raising her larynx which is never healthy. Good tone is when you sound closest to your natural voice with proper technique. It is fine to screw with technique every now and then, stylistically, but she sings like this 100% of the time, that will have consequences. Coaches that deny this are pandering to the fandom to avoid getting targeted. Edit: just want to point out that Rosé is a good singer. She has talent and she works hard. The fault is within YG, just like they messed up Bom's voice over the years.
I honestly think it's the opposite. In order to produce the sound that people want to hear, YG has made her strain when she uses her current tone. Her pre debut voice sounds natural and less strained.
that deep voice was angelic +heavenly ! BUT STILL THE CURRENT ROSIE IS MORE CONFIDENT AND STILL HER THIS VOICE IS ALSO DAMMN ANGELIC ! LIKE IF U BELIEVE SHE IS THE GOLDEN VOCALIST OF KOREA!!❤ roses_r_rosie #blink # rosiee
Her deep voice is strong and powerful, and nostalgic, whereas her sweet angelic voice is soothing to the ears. I love Rose a lot❤ now she gives off pop rock vibe and it really suits her.
It's so soothing and less nasally. I know it's easier for her to sing nasally since it's much easier to lean that way for most people but man her predebut vocals went so hard. I wish YG didn't try to model her after Park Bom
G drangon's without you ft rosè was amazingg!!! I love rosè's old voice/tone from her pre debut to now her recent abums and solos (hard to love was 🤌🤌🤌💯💯) she really grew in her vocal and is much more comfortable now im so proud of her!! Edit: thanks yal for the likess 🤍
Fun fact: Black pink used to be called pink punk and had 9 members but they started leaving as YG were making their debut way too long so that left Jisoo Jennie Lisa and Rosè 👍
her old voice was so precious and unique it also hit hard cuz it sounded so mature and ima not lie even without getting her voice restrained she would've been amazing and not "golden" vocal she would've been an Angelic vocalist, YG sucks for this, I hope Rose gets her old voice back because it's really good, her restrained voice wouldn't even allow her to reach those notes of old days; she is rated as a decent vocalist, however, if she didn't have her vocal restrained then she could've been a soprano level vocalist or even as good as Taeyeon.
She already has a beautiful voice but with her old vocals it's like just amazing and her high notes. She would definitely be more praised like taeyeon and iu if she was aloud to sing like this.
Stfu The vocal tone she has now is something that you have to be blessed to discover. The actual vocal coaches ( not the fake ones who act like professionals when it comes to Rosé) had reacted to her pre debut vocals and had said that she had found her own unique vocal tone which takes tears of training to discover. Don't downgrade her hardwork with your fake knowledge
her pre debut voice was DEFINITELY her naturally comfort vocal pitch SHE WAS 16 WHEN SHE STARTED BELTING NOTES LIKE THAT WHATT!! that's raw talent right there
I can’t deny...it sounds much more relaxed than her current voice. I often do find her singing in her deeper voice during live performances coz it comes naturally when she’s singing for long on stage and using a lot of stamina on the voice and it actually sounds real good.
Yes, both voices are good but PLS stop saying that she's using fake voice. She just change her technique and she found the right colour for her voice. She NEVER change her voice for YGE
bruh it has nothing to do with yg he is not controlling everythink like you think. rose found her own technique and it’s obvious that she is more comfortable with singing now
@@sorryformybedengland575 actually no cause if she already had a original natural voice it wouldn’t change this much Yg definitely told her to use different voice
@@moiz9907 Why would YG do that? I‘m sorry but it’s really lame to blame YG for literally everything. Just as the person already said, Rosé grew up and eventually found her own voice
@@winterwinter1840 why would yg do that??? Cause they like to force Idol to do everything!!! I forgot her name but she used to be in yg as a kpop idol and everyone knows how yg forced her to change her voice And right now rosè’s voice kinda sounds like her
Her voice is so angelic!! She really deserves so much fame and praises from the people and fans around the world. Rosie is really a great musician and I am very proud of her. I love you, rosie❤❤❤❤
For those wondering, the first song is “Gone”By Rosé. The 2nd song is “Without you”By G-Dragon & Rosé. She was featured in it, BEFORE debuting, because G-Dragon liked her voice. Jennie, also did a song with him, BEFORE debuting.
Without you is one of my favourite kpop songs it makes me feel warm inside and it makes me think of love. Like if i was in love i would expect it to feel like that song its such a good song just too underrated. G dragon is a lyrical and musical genius and roses deep voice in contrast to his sweet smooth high pitched slightly autotuned for effect voice just makes it all the more better.
@@CLee-qv4ej what technique? Roseanne enter 7 years of her career and keep getting better. If she follow "bom technique", rosé would lose her voice probably 4 years ago and regressed but she doesnt 🤷
@@Random_Channel000force? Did rosé tell it to you? Duh bp need higher voice and rosé has wide range can do both low and high so stop being stupid and spread lies
Her voice is much more unique now but her voice sounds much healthier and supported then. But hopefully, her voice now is something she loves and is healthy for her to use her beautiful instrument for a long time.
Did she personally told you this??? Why you guys always make your opinion as fact it can be she is for comfortable now untill she say anything about it we are on one to blame anyone
@@princesskatebella2594 just by this you are thinking they forced her I think you forget she sung this song when she was a teenager and peoples voice changes after they become adult and it can be that she learned to sing with her head voice and feel more comfortable we are on one to judge before knowing anything
Her old deep voice was so powerful and unique, I miss it a lot. She has grown so much in her vocals since then, I'm proud of her.
You ever where 😭
Why do you have to be everywhere and write comments on one video hundreds of time
WHY ARE U EVERYWHERE
Bro this guy is a part of every single fandom of games, singers etc ever💀 respect
Hi Chicken
Her old voice make me want to cry😢 her voice very best
HER OLD VOICE SOUNDS UNRECOGNIZABLE-
Fr
Song name?
@@anushreenair3186 the first one is "gone" by rosè and the other one is "without you" by g-dragon and rosè.
@@farahhni pretty sure it is rosé the live video with leehi didn’t sound like the same voice in the song
@@farahhni it's rose even gd mentioned it during his concert lee hi sang roses part even chaesoo vlive they mentioned she changed her vocal technique coz bp wanted a lighter tone member as well jennie,jisoo,lisa voices are already has a strong tone
She was 15 years old at that time when her pre debut comes with g dragon ✨♥️
She was so extremely lucky
@@Hayoonie3yeah ofc
Gd 😊😊
Now voice and past voice both beautiful
True
True🖤💗
Is it wrong to point out, that as a Singer, Y'all are irritating because You have no knowledge of what Voice means... yet everyone has that, insect in tummy, to appear knowledgeable...?
Rosé had Old Technique and Tonality in GD song...
Now Rosé has different Technique( mainly due to nasality and Twang ) and Tonality( due to aging )...
Yass✨
🥵🥵🥵 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 roses. Voice. Is. Diffrent
Her natural voice is Healing my ears i hate yg for this
Bro they needed a contrast tone in the group coz the other 3 members already have a strong tone
@@roohisitharaabdulwahab9025 But bro have you heard this voice? Why the hell did yg need a Contrast tone From rosé only her vocals were so amazing then
@Jimin's long lost Jam but that's her strained voice it took some efforts That this was Her natural voice
@Jimin's long lost Jam natural means you sing without straining your throat. This is what she does now to sound lighter and younger.
@Jimin's long lost Jam 💀Lmfao
I miss her deep voice tone
rosés register back then wasnt deep. it was on the lower side but not deep. she’s always had a pretty middle toned talking voice so when she sings and does high notes it’ll ofc go higher that’s how singing is! she bettered her technique over the years so she can sing longer durations. :)
girl she still has it she just uses a softer voice
She still has it, she strains her voice when she sings
I’m sorry but it’s not even close to being deep
@@crystalflake6888 that was 6 years ago, she obviously still has it
Woww her voice was so powerful and seems like she doesn't drag while singing. I hope she sings like that in her new songs
She won’t yg want her to change her tone that why she sing like that now
The vocal tone she has now is something that you have to be blessed to discover. The actual vocal coaches ( not the fake ones who act like professionals when it comes to Rosé) had reacted to her pre debut vocals and had said that she had found her own unique vocal tone which takes tears of training to discover. Don't downgrade her hardwork with your fake knowledge
@@NickiBora dude , do u understand English at all. I just said I liked her old voice and wanted to hear it again in her new songs , did I by any means commented any hate about her. You toxic blinks are always like this, this is the reason we r not allowed to even give our opinions also .
@@NickiBora And who gets to decide who are the real coaches? You? That's a fucking weak ass argument. Vocal coaches know she is achieving this thinner timbre by raising her larynx which is never healthy. Good tone is when you sound closest to your natural voice with proper technique. It is fine to screw with technique every now and then, stylistically, but she sings like this 100% of the time, that will have consequences.
Coaches that deny this are pandering to the fandom to avoid getting targeted.
Edit: just want to point out that Rosé is a good singer. She has talent and she works hard. The fault is within YG, just like they messed up Bom's voice over the years.
The second clip was Lee Hi, a solo artist who was under yg
I miss her pre debut voice that was just so deep and beautiful. And that high note really hits different
She did sound very good I’m the past but she’s way more comfortable in her tone now and her voice sounds so much more unique to me now.
I honestly think it's the opposite. In order to produce the sound that people want to hear, YG has made her strain when she uses her current tone. Her pre debut voice sounds natural and less strained.
Her pre debut song name?
@@eren....yeager without you it was with g dragon tho idk if tht rlly was her prefebut song
She doesn’t seem comfortable at all. She’s straining it too much because she’s forced to. And she has to be comfortable because she has no choice
Same but she was forced to change her voice
Her voice is just like an angel ❤❤😊
that deep voice was angelic +heavenly ! BUT STILL THE CURRENT ROSIE IS MORE CONFIDENT AND STILL HER THIS VOICE IS ALSO DAMMN ANGELIC !
LIKE IF U BELIEVE SHE IS THE GOLDEN VOCALIST OF KOREA!!❤ roses_r_rosie
#blink
# rosiee
She could hit high notes with her real voice. Imagine if she kept going like that she could of been better. But her voice rn is still good I love it
I swear when I first heard her pre debut voice I didn't have a clue it was rose's!!
Queen slaying even before her debut! 🤌🫶
Beautiful and talented woman ❤!
Her deep voice is strong and powerful, and nostalgic, whereas her sweet angelic voice is soothing to the ears. I love Rose a lot❤ now she gives off pop rock vibe and it really suits her.
It's so soothing and less nasally. I know it's easier for her to sing nasally since it's much easier to lean that way for most people but man her predebut vocals went so hard. I wish YG didn't try to model her after Park Bom
Neither are nasally?
@@_suika_ Just accept the fact that her current voice is nasal bruh 😭
@@adellianaura7910that not true, just your opinion
@@rainejones4434 It's not JUST my opinion tho 💀
A lot of people also have the same thoughts
yg k bắt Rosé thay đổi để giống Park bom chỉ là chị đã lớn hơn nên giọng cũng thay đổi và cách hát bây giờ sẽ tốt hơn vì có kĩ thuật
Her pre debut voice that song I didn't know it was Rose's voice
G drangon's without you ft rosè was amazingg!!! I love rosè's old voice/tone from her pre debut to now her recent abums and solos (hard to love was 🤌🤌🤌💯💯) she really grew in her vocal and is much more comfortable now im so proud of her!!
Edit: thanks yal for the likess 🤍
It's one of my fav song
Her voice it’s like gold I always listen all her song especially gone it’s soooo touching
Her voice is like an angel❤
Seriously... Her voice is beautiful now too.. but pre debut voice gives me chills everytime I hear this song
I showed that song to my older sister when I found out about her pre debut voice and she was like "That is not your Rosé!!!!"
What is the song she were singing.?pls tell me
@@PONYA_SHIKU without you. It's by Gdragon, but he featured a yg trainee in it and Rosé was the trainee who was picked
@@Caro.Covers ok thank you so much dear 😍😍
Honestly she improved so much like she can put more emotions on her voice
Nice defend but people are not child they know bp is worst only use autotune
@@ManojKumar-hb6ee maa ke lode uncle Jake pdle aajta nangi lafkiya dekhne aur hilane
@@Bajwa-ht8ow oh god, another anti. Shut up and go to sleep
@@Bajwa-ht8owYes That's why Rose's vocals sound more better In Non Autotune version
But her pre-debut voice is much better bruh 😭
When I listen to hear her voice I feel like I am in heaven
omg!she pretty girl,i love you so rosie,rosé queen
I wish she will sing with her debut voice after becoming a soloist cause it ain't possible until she is in yg
그녀의 모든 목소리는 좋다
Her voice is just magic
Your voice is so sweet I love your voice😊❤🎉❤❤❤
Rose voice is like gold
She is just love❤ sweeetiee😊
Her voice is much more unique now though ❤
Her voice is very soft and i think no one can say that she is not best.❤❤
Fun fact:
Black pink used to be called pink punk and had 9 members but they started leaving as YG were making their debut way too long so that left Jisoo Jennie Lisa and Rosè 👍
Another fun fact: Jennie was supposed to be the leader but declined the offer of being it
Her voice gave me goosebumps 😮
Aahhh!! Her voice😩💖 A girl with prettiest face and Angelic voice - Rosè💖
I like both of Rosè's voices, but we can't deny that it's her current voice that has earned her the nickname "golden voice of Korea"
Heart touching voice 💘💋
her old voice was so precious and unique it also hit hard cuz it sounded so mature and ima not lie even without getting her voice restrained she would've been amazing and not "golden" vocal she would've been an Angelic vocalist, YG sucks for this, I hope Rose gets her old voice back because it's really good, her restrained voice wouldn't even allow her to reach those notes of old days; she is rated as a decent vocalist, however, if she didn't have her vocal restrained then she could've been a soprano level vocalist or even as good as Taeyeon.
With his deep voice she can easily hit highnotes
Her sound all ways butifull ❤
her old voice gave me literal goosebumps I have never really been a fan of her pitchy tone but damn she's got deep voice
her voice now is levels better than her pre-debut voice. There is more tone to it now.
She already has a beautiful voice but with her old vocals it's like just amazing and her high notes. She would definitely be more praised like taeyeon and iu if she was aloud to sing like this.
Stfu The vocal tone she has now is something that you have to be blessed to discover. The actual vocal coaches ( not the fake ones who act like professionals when it comes to Rosé) had reacted to her pre debut vocals and had said that she had found her own unique vocal tone which takes tears of training to discover. Don't downgrade her hardwork with your fake knowledge
@@NickiBora why are you so triggered I'm not hating I meant her pre debut sounds like taeyeon and iu vocals her vocals are beautiful
@@STRAWBERHEE sorry not really
Golden voice?😭😭 yikes
She's not the golden voice of Korea. Blinks are the one that gave her that title.
I miss her old voice but luv her new one cuz its so calm and shes comfortable with it❤❤❤❤❤❤
DEEP VOICE ROSÉ LITERALLY HITS DIFFERENT
I didn’t know that was her old voice wow 🤩💜
her pre debut voice was DEFINITELY her naturally comfort vocal pitch
SHE WAS 16 WHEN SHE STARTED BELTING NOTES LIKE THAT WHATT!! that's raw talent right there
Im literally melting because it's way too good to listen ❤❤❤
I like her every voice
What? She still has a Angel 's voice. What are you saying. She is really blessed
Rosé is talented so she can sing in various styles
Her old voice is her
Her current voice is also her
Both are her and original
Yasss
I can’t deny...it sounds much more relaxed than her current voice. I often do find her singing in her deeper voice during live performances coz it comes naturally when she’s singing for long on stage and using a lot of stamina on the voice and it actually sounds real good.
We still didn't didn't a Gd x Rosè performance, god we were robbed:*
Yes, both voices are good but PLS stop saying that she's using fake voice. She just change her technique and she found the right colour for her voice. She NEVER change her voice for YGE
True! I wish we can hear more of her pre-debut voices, not just Rosé's
This isn’t actually her
@@h4ileyy this is her bruh
@@h4ileyywdym the deep voice was her and G Dragon
Her voice is something else 😌💖
Yahh .YG should not strain them
bruh it has nothing to do with yg he is not controlling everythink like you think. rose found her own technique and it’s obvious that she is more comfortable with singing now
@@sorryformybedengland575 actually no cause if she already had a original natural voice it wouldn’t change this much
Yg definitely told her to use different voice
@@moiz9907 Why would YG do that? I‘m sorry but it’s really lame to blame YG for literally everything. Just as the person already said, Rosé grew up and eventually found her own voice
@@winterwinter1840 why would yg do that???
Cause they like to force Idol to do everything!!!
I forgot her name but she used to be in yg as a kpop idol and everyone knows how yg forced her to change her voice
And right now rosè’s voice kinda sounds like her
@@winterwinter1840 girl this is kpop-
Her voice is so angelic!!
She really deserves so much fame and praises from the people and fans around the world. Rosie is really a great musician and I am very proud of her.
I love you, rosie❤❤❤❤
The deep voice ahhhhh 😫 so good
YES EXACTLY i wish she could sing with her pre-debut voice too🥲
“Without you” is always my jam 😫❤️. I love that song like mehnn
I will never believe it's her voice ❣️
For those wondering, the first song is “Gone”By Rosé. The 2nd song is “Without you”By G-Dragon & Rosé. She was featured in it, BEFORE debuting, because G-Dragon liked her voice. Jennie, also did a song with him, BEFORE debuting.
She is so good at everything
Really my rose hits different
Nice message for rose haters see rose also hits high note
Her voice is unique in pre debut time even now too
Yasssssss🤩
Love Blackpink
Stream On the ground, Gone and Born Pink
She can still sing like the 'old' her, it's just that her song 'Gone' requires a different vocal tone.
Without you is one of my favourite kpop songs it makes me feel warm inside and it makes me think of love. Like if i was in love i would expect it to feel like that song its such a good song just too underrated. G dragon is a lyrical and musical genius and roses deep voice in contrast to his sweet smooth high pitched slightly autotuned for effect voice just makes it all the more better.
I love Rose black pink
I really like Rose
Rose golden voice in the world❤
Pov: you are in living room and your family wont let you listen🥀
Dude same situation
Hey BBROTHER WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN CHUCKIE
Yeah
And if i will sing infront of my parents when they say don't sing i will sing but sound in squeaky high pitched voice Straining so bad
i love her voice so much❤❤❤❤❤
She is my bias
Her pre debut voice was so good it gave me goosebumps❤❤❤❤❤ love u Rosie and will love Blackpink forever❤
Park Bom's impact on her is crazy
Bom wishes she could sing as good as rosé's 6 years into her career 🤷
@@fisontherun6655 calm down lmao. They just use(d) the same technique in yg which bom used first n now rose
@@CLee-qv4ej what technique? Roseanne enter 7 years of her career and keep getting better. If she follow "bom technique", rosé would lose her voice probably 4 years ago and regressed but she doesnt 🤷
@@fisontherun6655 i gave no hate comment to rose but go off lol dunno why u mad
@@fisontherun6655 but good for her. She maintained her voice well
Yoo that vocal climb was amazing! 🫠🫠🩷🩷
She was forced to change her voice 😢
Both beautiful
Her voice and Her personality is priceless
That high notes 🙀💘💘💘
That was rosé’s voice?? HOW DID IT CHANGE?? 😭
I think YG didn’t like her deep voice and forced her to sing with a high pitched voice.
@@Random_Channel000force? Did rosé tell it to you? Duh bp need higher voice and rosé has wide range can do both low and high so stop being stupid and spread lies
That high note at the end-
I love high notes like that and knowing that its rosè who is singing it makes me love them even more 🥺💜
this is just shows that Rosè can control her voice/pitch...from low to high
She was forced to by YG
Rose ovozi hammanikidan zo'r❤❤
Uning eski ovozi ham yangi ovozi ham chiroyli va yoqimtoy❤❤❤
Rose's old voice holds so much power.. I wish she use it in her solo's
it's not "old voice" it's lower notes
Wow very nice voice you have❤❤
They said rose to change her tone so she had to change it but I swear to God her old voice is incredible u know "old is gold"
Her voice is much more unique now but her voice sounds much healthier and supported then. But hopefully, her voice now is something she loves and is healthy for her to use her beautiful instrument for a long time.
I miss her deep voice ! It hits different 😢❤
I notice her voice in both. An angel blowing
The only actual artist in BP with love for music
I love you so much 💗
Её голос звучит как ангельский в душу заходят мне очень нравится её прежний голос ❤❤
Ham aapke Naam khubsurat rakhna chahte Hain 🌹🌈💯🌧️🌧️🔥🔥🔥 ROSE ...
She was actually forced by YG to change her tone
So sad that many idols have to go through this shit 😔😔
Did she personally told you this??? Why you guys always make your opinion as fact it can be she is for comfortable now untill she say anything about it we are on one to blame anyone
@@kirtitiwari8907 they actually did force her since jisoo and jennie already had a deep voice they needed someone with a unique/different voice
@@princesskatebella2594 just by this you are thinking they forced her I think you forget she sung this song when she was a teenager and peoples voice changes after they become adult and it can be that she learned to sing with her head voice and feel more comfortable we are on one to judge before knowing anything
Istg y’all always love to victimize them for everything
@@DD-fh6uj yess
That's why her natural voive is not shaking