Celestion V type vs 21 other speakers - shootout
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- Celestion V Type vs 21 other speakers shootout, plus Mystery Speaker
We are often asked how the Celestion V type sounds with other speakers.... well here it is. First we blend the V type with other spaekers then we go head to head and see how they compare directly.
The speakers are Celestion Alnico Blue, Vintage 30, Century Vintage, G12-65 (Heritage not classic series), Alnico Cream, V type, H heritage 55Hz, Classic Lead 80, Alnico Gold, H heritage 75Hz, H creamback 75, G12H Redback, M creamback 65, H anniversary, M heritage, G12T-75, Neo Creamback, Alnico Ruby, Mystery Speaker, A Type, WGS Invader 50
www.zillacabs....
Gear list:
Paul Reed Smith Custom 22
Marshall JMP 2203
Tul G12
Zilla Fatbaby 1x12
Two Notes Reload
That last one really popped for me. The warehouse speaker.
0:13 G12 alnico blue
1:47 G12H 70th anniversary
4:59 G12 alnico blue A/B
7:35 G12H 70th A/B
4:52 V-Type
What this tells me is... the V-Type sounds very good by itself! I almost always preferred the V-Type alone clips, save for when you mixed in an Alnico
Yeah the V type with the alnico's seems to be a popular choice here. Thanks for watching.
awesome.
I liked the H creamback mixed with the V-type , they are surprisingly similar.
1:25 mix G12H cream
1:46 mix G12H anni
My Favorites:
V-type Chord 6:56
GB M25 Chord 6:03
CB H75 Chord 7:03
CB M65 Chord 7:26
WGS Invader 9:03
4:53 V-type
5:11 Vintage 30
5:59 Greenback M25
6:13 Greenback H30
6:59 Creamback H75
7:23 Creamback M65
8:11 Neo Creamback
6:53 V-type to Creamback H75
7:18 V-type to Creamback M65
Mixed
0:20 V-type & Vintage 30
1:25 V-type & Creamback H75
That's great, thanks for watching and taking time to put your favourites down.
V Type sounds pretty balanced to me in this demo. Just the right amount of honk and sizzle. I think I still prefer the G12M Greenback. It’s got that classic bark.
You guys are wonderfully nuts!! Such a great resource of knowledge. The V-type really handles the competitors well, it is really well voiced ;-)
Thanks Christian, I'm glad you like the videos!
Lately, after listening to sound comparisons for months I am finding a clear favourite emerge to my ears and it's not what I would have chosen when I began all this listening. But man... I love that G12H-30 anniversary. Not the most popular choice I know, but I think it's the speaker for me.
An underrated speaker is the V Type, and it sounds amazing with the Alincos & Greenbacks. Thanks for putting the video together, love your videos.
Thanks Simon, I'm glad you found it useful.
It has a similar sensitivity ratings as a greenback as well. I'm going to mix these in a 2x12 next week.
@@qua7771 Let me know how it goes, interested in how it would sound in a real world example. I'm sure I'm not the only one interested either :-)
@@GuvnaOnSpotify I will. It won't be here until the beginning of the week.
If I understand correctly the shoot out in this video did not have the speakers mounted in the same cabinet. Having them in the same cabinet always sounds like they are more connected to me.
0:20 - mixed with v30
0:49 - mixed with greenback
1:39 - mixed with creamback
5:04 - compared to v30
5:52 - compared to greenback
7:16 - compared to creamback
i’m really surprised how well the v-type mixed with alnicos. girth and sparkle.
thanks guys!
Yeah I've quite enjoyed the alnico with a few of these videos, especially the ruby, I think that one is turning out to be a good speaker to mix with others.
Edited - The timestamps of each speaker so you can click on individual speakers to A-B compare them
0:14 - Celestion G12 Blue Alnico (Alnico Series) - 15W - 16 Ohms
0:21 - Celestion G12 Vintage 30 (Classic Series) - 60W - 16 Ohms
0:28 - Celestion G12 Century Vintage (Classic Series) - 60W - 16 Ohms
0:35 - Celestion G12-65 (Heritage Series) - 65W - 16 Ohms
0:42 - Celestion G12 Cream Alnico (Alnico Series) - 90W - 16 Ohms
0:49 - Celestion G12M Greenback (Classic Series) - 25 W - 16 Ohms
0:56 - Celestion G12H Heritage 55Hz (Heritage Series) - 30W - 16 Ohms
1:03 - Celestion G12 Classic Lead 80 (Classic Series) - 80W - 16 Ohms
1:11 - Celestion G12 Gold Alnico (Alnico Series) - 50W - 16 Ohms
1:18 - Celestion G12H Heritage 75Hz (heritage Series - 30W - 16 Ohms
1:25 - Celestion G12H Creamback (Classic Series) - 75W - 16 Ohms
1:32 - Celestion G12H Redback (Classic Series) - 150W - 16 Ohms
1:39 - Celestion G12M Creamback (Classic Series) - 65W - 16 Ohms
1:47 - Celestion G12H Anniversary (Classic Series) - 30W - 16 Ohms
1:54 - Celestion G12 M Heritage (Heritage Series) - 20W - 16 Ohms
2:01 - Celestion G12 T-75 (Classic Series) - 75W - 16 Ohms
2:08 - Celestion G12 Neo Creamback (Classic Series) - 60W - 16Ohms
2:15 - Celestion G12 Ruby Alnico (Alnico Series) - 35W - 16 Ohms
2:22 - V-Type Mixed with Mystery Speaker - 50W - 16 Ohms
2:29 - V-Type mixed with Celestion A-Type (Classic Series) - 50W - 16 Ohms
2:37 - V-Type mixed with Warehouse Invader (British Invasion) - 50W - 16 Ohms
Back To Back Section :-
4:53 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series - 70W - 16 Ohms
4:59 - Celestion G12 Blue Alnico (Alnico Series) - 15W - 16 Ohms
5:05 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series - 70W - 16 Ohms
5:10 - Celestion G12 Vintage 30 (Classic Series) - 60W - 16 Ohms
5:16 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
5:23 - Celestion G12 Century Vintage (Classic Series) - 60W - 16 Ohms
5:28 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
5:34 - Celestion G12-65 (Heritage Series) - 65W - 16 Ohms
5:40 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
5:46 - Celestion G12 Cream Alnico (Alnico Series) - 90W - 16 Ohms
5:52 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
5:58 - Celestion G12M Greenback (Classic Series) - 25 W - 16 Ohms
6:05 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
6:10 - Celestion G12H Heritage 55Hz (Heritage Series) - 30W - 16 Ohms
6:16 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
6:22 - Celestion G12 Classic Lead 80 (Classic Series) - 80W - 16 Ohms
6:28 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
6:34 - Celestion G12 Gold Alnico (Alnico Series) - 50W - 16 Ohms
6:40 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
6:46 - Celestion G12H Heritage 75Hz (heritage Series - 30W - 16 Ohms
6:52 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
6:58 - Celestion G12H Creamback (Classic Series) - 75W - 16 Ohms
7:04 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
7:10 - Celestion G12H Redback (Classic Series) - 150W - 16 Ohms
7:17 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
7:22 - Celestion G12M Creamback (Classic Series) - 65W - 16 Ohms
7:29 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
7:35 - Celestion G12H Anniversary (Classic Series) - 30W - 16 Ohms
7:41 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
7:46 - Celestion G12 M Heritage (Heritage Series) - 20W - 16 Ohms
7:53 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
7:58 - Celestion G12 T-75 (Classic Series) - 75W - 16 Ohms
8:04 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
8:10 - Celestion G12 Neo Creamback (Classic Series) - 60W - 16 Ohms
8:16 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
8:22 - Celestion G12 Ruby Alnico (Alnico Series) - 35W - 16 Ohms
8:29 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
8:35 - V-Type Mixed with Mystery Speaker - 50W - 16 Ohms
8:40 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
8:46 - V-Type mixed with Celestion A-Type (Classic Series) - 50W - 16 Ohms
8:52 - Celestion G12 V-Type (Classic Series) - 70W - 16 Ohms
8:58 - V-Type mixed with Warehouse Invader (British Invasion) - 50W - 16 Ohms
HI Jeff, I'm going to try and put the time stamps in later today if I get a minute.
@@ZillaCabs i did it for you :D
I use V type combined with Creamback and it's a amazing thing everytime i play!!! A really great speaker from celestion that people thinks it's a bad product because it's not expensive as the rest of the line. Thanks for do things like this, this really helps a lot!
Which creamback do you pair with it?
@@stratocaster222 creamback 65!
The celestion gold heritage was heavenly..like good god. That ones my fav for sure
Thats really cool. The Vtype has been quite popular with alnico speakers in these videos.
Amazing sound place right here ! Choosing the right speaker in respect to whole equipment is very important. I like those speakers with not too much hi-mids : maybe less definition and hole through the mix but still velvet for my fingers and ears. So, I like V-Type but G12-65 Heritage is my next choice for sure. I like the "resonance" it has. Thanks a lot for your fantastic videos !
The best takeaway from this exercise is how great your JMP and PRS match up- Rock out!
haha, I'm glad you like it. That's not even my best JMP ;)
Awesome video guys 👍 Can’t decide now which one I like, but appreciate the effort you’ve gone to to confuse the hell out of me. 😁
Thanks Danny, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
V Type pairs well with a Greenback they are same sensitivity so they play evenly together.
Your videos is very informative! Bought new Celestion V-Type for 55$. I find my Greenback is to woody on cleans for a VOX-slyle amp. Yea, V-Type sounds closer to V30 or even Blue))
Celestion V type has a balanced tone, using and eq you can get a lot of different tones. I have it on my 1x12 inch combo amp and I see no reason to replace it.
it would be interesting to see a series of videos on how the sound changes in different cabs, so for example, the V-Type in a 1x12 fatbaby and then a Ported cab... you could build a huge library of sounds that show how the cab changes the sound of the speaker. No-one else has done that to my knowledge
We're working on it mate. I think that may be the next run of videos... it just takes a load longer to do ;)
@@ZillaCabs sweet!
It has been done before for acoustics research...
But still not shown on RUclips.
So yes, it would be really interesting and appealing to a large number of people.
If I had to choose only one, I want Greenbacks heritage 20watt ( EVH) . If I pare V-type with another Celestion, I choose V-type + V30.
I love the EVH greenback, its a great speaker.
So true
I prefer the v type with the greenback. It has a nice ac/dc tone to it. I also like the cream backs.
My favourite mixes were the G12H30 (both), the G12M25 and the Classic Lead 80. Most sounded good. I’ve got a Creamback Neo and V Type in a 2x12 now with a JCM800 and it has so much high end. Also, when really cranking it the Neo starts thinning out. I’m looking for something a bit different now which brought me here. 😎
Great, glad you liked the video mate.
Enjoyed the video and thought some of the pairings worked well. Personally I tried mixing a V-Type and a G12M RI Greenback in a closed back 2x12 cab. I found the pair difficult to EQ. Independently, though, each speaker is great and can be complimentary in a two amp setup. I also prefer the V-Type in an open back cab. Thanks the the video!
Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed it. We haven't used the V type that much before but I have been told it works best in an open back too. I see it quite a lot in combos.
Celestion VType sounds fantastic in this comparison....
Thanks Manuel, glad you liked it.
It's so weird how the brain processes sound. I haven't liked the G12 Century in any combinations but alone it sounds pretty good. Meanwhile I haven't liked any Creambacks alone but I think they tend to sound great in almost every combination.
I’ve always preferred the Mystery over all others. My favorite.
I’m wondering if that’s the HempBack judging from the lumpiness of the paper cone. Although it isn’t green sooooo idk
You need a this demo with a DV77!!
I wish I could get my hands on one, I can't get one anywhere.
It seemed like it sounded best with the G1265 and the G12T75. And the mystery monster.
I'm looking forward to revealing the mystery speaker. Thanks as always for watching.
V type sounds like a Greenback with some added beef to me. Great value speaker IMO.
I keep on rewatching old videos to freshen up my memory of some speakers. I think G12H Anniversary plus V Type in 2x12 might be best cheaper option for the classic rock tones. G12H Anniversary brings more top end and is more scooped while V type is all Celestion middle range one can have. Together clean and driven they sound pretty good and do not break the bank.
Trivia moment, PRS Hendrix cabs use V Type.
I'm glad you are enjoying the videos. I think the Vtype came out pretty good in these videos. Thanks for watching.
wow thats a great video! Thanks very much for sharing!
Thanks, I'm glad you like it.
I like the v type and it has worked well with many amps. Right now i have a 4×10 with vt jrs and jensen mod q0 50s
That mystery speaker is an Eminence Screamin' Eagle, found in some Marshall MG 2x12 combos.
Good guess but not right in this case.
Hempback?
Is there gonna be a big reveal?
You can literally see "celestion" stamped into the frame.
Sounds like a great, classic sounding speaker, just the low end seems to be quite on the looser side. I got it in a Laney 112 recently and I'm quite happy with the sound yet. Like it best with the V30 or the classic greenback, which seem to improve the definition clarity.
What I've learned from this video, is that I love the greenback. I don't own one, but I should!!
The greenback is a cool speaker for sure.
thanks for this comparison! the Celestion G12M Greenback (Classic Series) - 25 W - 16 Ohms
gets me somehow :)
I have a couple of V-Types (one in a combo, one in a 112 cab) and have a Greenback on the way. I think that's going to work!
Hi Matt, I think that pairing came out really good in the mix. Let us know how you get on with them. Paul
Classic Vintage 30 Beeeeeeesssss!
0:21 V30
0:57 G12H 55hz
1:18 G12H 75hz
1:54 Heritage G12m
very well done comparison.
thanks, great video - it's funny how a Greenback always sounds 'right' somehow
Could you do, please, a new video with the new Celestion neo V Type comparing with other speakers?
Yeah, we've been meaning to do that one. It shouldn't be long now.
I think the G12H-30W 70th Anniversary was the best sound of all of them. IMHO 7:35
I think those two mix really well together.
This vids are awesome!
Thanks mate.
Very helpful.
Thanks, glad you like it.
I'll be waiting for those dang hempback
Me too Red, I've got 100 on order. We'll definitely be doing a bunch of videos on them as soon as we can.
@@ZillaCabs i still wonder will you ever get high while playing em tho
To tell you the truth I don't hear a lot of difference between them, but I got a vintage neo 16ohm just lately and it sounds great, and its light weight.
4:52
5:59
6:14
Thanks
Guys, why don't you include the K100 in your demos? Not specifically these demos (I know these are all 16 ohm and the K100 only comes in 8 ohm), but I think you never demoed those in the past as well.
Good questions, it is the impedance thing here. I tell you what though, we haven't used the K100 yet so we should definitely do a video on it, you are right.
@@ZillaCabs 4x12 oversized cabs with K100s are god level cabs as far as Im concerned!
It's a very good speaker
I had a 4x12 with Vtypes and K100’s in it and it sounded fucking immense. The bottom end on the K100 and the top and mids on the Vtype blended really well in an X pattern.
V TYPE is the better for me
5:25. 6:01. 6:36
6:59. 4:59. 5:11
7:36. 8:12
I put a v-type in my Dsl40 and hated it. Sounded gutless and weak so replaced it with the v30 and never looked back
It because DSL is sucks itself))
@@mikhail6289 it sucks itself? Lol
Please do double track in next video. Gives a better picture of sound
I really dig the V-type, it kinda sounds in the same vein of a g12m greenback. Could you show the new V-type neo? I’m so curious about that one.
By the way, any idea why Celestion still doesn’t produce a neo version of the g12m greenback?
Ooh that would be a great speaker, a neo greenback, or at least interesting to hear. As soon as we get hold of the Vtype neo then I will get it recorded for sure. Im looking forward to hearing it too.
V type the best speaker of celestion
You really do love the V type don't you Shachar. Thanks for watching the videos.
That V30 that You demo in all videos, is that China or UK made? What year?
It is a standard Chinese V30 and it will be a recent one, so 2020 I should have thought.
Has anyone guessed the mystery speaker correctly? Is it a seventy-80?
Yeah there are a couple of correct guesses... its not the Seventy-80 though.
I think the mystery speaker might be a WGS Reaper HP?
It was something else.
So im guessing the neo v type is newer i cannot find a neo vs ceramic for the v type
It is a newer speaker. We've had a few issues editing new videos (we got super busy over the last few months... not the worst problem to have, but not great for the channel). We've done a few shootouts on that speaker and it is really cool. We'll be putting them up in the next few months for sure.
Question: how does a eminence em12 compare to a Evm12l ? Or a eminence delta pro 12a? Maybe is time for round two with the Thick boy, redback, governor, etc
Yeah we definitely need to get more Eminence speakers in. I need to brush up on their range a little.
@@ZillaCabs i got another idea! High end speakers vs speakers with bad reputation 🤣🤣🤣 for example i got celestion rocket 50. People trash those, i dont love them but i dont think is thaaaat bad like people say it is.
hi, sorry for the imperfect language, I am writing to you from Italy, I have a vintage marshall studio head, with matching 2x12 cabinet with v type cones, honestly I can't please them, they are woody, you who have tried and understand cones, can you recommend a suitable solution for that plexy reissue? I would also like to have some advice on a possible coupling, I have already tried to couple together: g12h 55/75;
2 evh greenback;
2 creambacks; 🤯🤯
Thanks 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Go with greenback reissue
@@OperationEndGame thanks man 🤙🏻
6:47
7:48
5:59
6:11
Is this the same V-Type included in the Marshall DSL-40CR?
Yes
2:08
1:12
0:32
I have a bassbreaker 30r with a v type its very bass heavy with an oversized semi open cab. I really want to but a neo speaker in it but am not sure which one
Any neo will take some bass and low mids off, so will do the job of removing the boominess.
What difference does it make in this vid? None.
What do they sound like clean?
You can't hear the difference? We get complaints when we do clean comparisons as it is harder to tell the difference with low and no gain.
I can hear the difference between them but I can twiddle some knobs and make changes to the material or porting of the cab to make any of them sound similar to any other with a distorted high gain signal. Only a clean signal will let me hear the tone of the speaker and what it can't do . From a cabinet designer of a well respected company.
PS. I came to find out if the VType will deliver the beauty of a vintage 30.
Thanks anyway. Good luck.
@@George.Andrews. alto fantasma
5:54
7:17
8:55
Is the mystery speaker a 70-80?
It was the hempback
7:11
8:05
8:10
so what is the mystery speaker?
We're not allowed to say just yet but will let you know soon.
@@ZillaCabs thanx for the answer and also thanx for creating those videos in the first place. They are really helpful to make better decisions when buying speakers. Also, they make me want to buy a zilla cab :D
Greeeenback G12M25
They all the same with drive. Test them clean. You had one job...
Don't go to 11?........... Well im out then. 😂
Works best with the various M and H variations. Also the lower watt alnico models.
Thanks for watching.