These are the kind of discussions why I'm a paid subscriber of The Print! Dr Chipman not only gave a macro view of the geo politics , but also with great specificity. Seemed like he was willing to double click on any topic Mr Gupta brought up These are the kind of men you want in your government or at least advising the government Thank you for this The Print Team.
Excellent interview , i couldn't stop watching and listening till the end. I agree with everything they said except the last part about next prime minister for England which i don't know much about.
I have a feel that Russia has taken advantage of the Ukraine war to offload or dispose of its aging stockpile of Soviet era weapons of mass destruction simultaneously testing its striking capabilities. And the Americans doing a similar exercise on their side. The non participant in this war also have important learnings to draw from. The true victim is Ukraine.
stupid as always lol. To get ride of their stockpile. They would recycle it, not reapir it for billion of dollars and use it in a war. At that price they would get new and better stuff.
To say that Russia didn’t think of having air superiority in parallel with its inland thrust by its land forces is very difficult to digest. From the advent of the air age we have seen air dominance as key part of any war. From the First World War to recent afghan and Iraq war. I doubt Russia has deficiency of air assets to put on this offensive. There is more reason to this question as to why Russia isn’t having air superiority over Ukrainian air space. Or at least over Donbas and Luhansk region. Only time will tell.
what are u smoking? air superiority is key to giving a crushing blow; the US established air superiority pretty quickly in Iraq, and in the early stages of Barbarossa, the Germans had the air superiority and were able to dole out crushing blows cause of that. And air power just wasn't that relevant during ww1.
This OTC was Gold! Honestly I was going to skip this until you mentioned it in your CTC today. It’ll be a good idea to provide such reference about your guest in a prior/post CTC episode every week.
Always love to hear the “gora” log speak. They are so pragmatic, have depth, lateral thinkers, dynamic analysis and most imp bereft of personal emotions.
Hi Harish, May we request you to send a screenshot of the error message on contributions@theprint.in, so that we may understand the issue and help you out at the earliest.
Old Chinese saying . If you want do a business build a road. Land locked northwest now will connect with Eurasia . Plus the minerals metal ores gas. Gold what it discovers on the way is pure bonus for its industrial revolution
China praises Ukraine mediator Macron as Beijing hopes to renew EU ties In a call with the French president’s diplomatic counsellor, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi says mediation efforts are appreciated
There is an easy way against AI, do things that you have never done before. Be unpredictable and AI will have no clue that you would do something like that
I was thinking exactly the same thing. Never presents a balanced view. @ThePrint - why should the west think they can get involved in spreading "democracy" and "freedom" in Ukraine and not in Saudi Arabia? Did you ever bother to ask that? That is what caused the coup in 2014 and the conflict now. If that wasn't done, they wouldn't have had to think bout seizing Russian assets to feed the rest of the world, would they? @ThePrint - Are you trying to spin a narrative? Do your job and present both sides to inform, not to rally opinion. It is getting really annoying.
@@shahrukhkotwal7125 till today I was not able to watch him not more than 10min. But there is a thing called listening to both sides. SG is not even the most neutral journalist either like everyone he has his biases. Do you think listening to only one side makes you wiser. Calling out names does not help. Western speakers said Russians are short of ammunition after one month, I am waiting for Russians to run out of ammunition. They claimed lysychansk is difficult to capture because it is on elevation. Russia took it in just a week. Wait for a month or two and you will see more cities falling to Russians. We all knew it was impossible to roll over ukraine or any country in 3 days. It will take almost a week for Russian tanks to reach kiev even if it is left open and unguarded
@@shahrukhkotwal7125 just by listening to this you think that you are the most well informed and you think you will be on higher intellect, but it is not the case sad to inform you.
@@hanniballecter1734 west thinks they are flag bearers of democracy and freedom, but in reality they have carried worst genocide, military coups, wars, racial abuses, invasions, overthrowing governments of sovereign nations and what not. They have set a very good template of how to remain in power
This "guru" of yours probably is the worst expert on the topic - his narrow minded approach, heavily biased, Russophobic, and well, basically he is one of those who wants to see west as the center of power. His appearance on your programme seems like he is pushing the "western" narrative to this part of the world. So far this has been the worst guest I heard and definitely not worth the title of "guru", at least by me.
Nobody cares about his views and definitely not common Indians and government itself has refused to condemns,we can't openly support Russia owing to our own dependency on west and gulf for energy imports...but we definitely don't support zelensky who is responsible for pushing his public into this war...
Maybe he is biased towards Ukraine, majority of left media are against Russia but majority of common Indian support Russian stance and especially those who know history of NATO and USA war crimes in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan know that Russian stance is totally justified.. it's American fault who used zelensky as guinea 🐖🐖
These are the kind of discussions why I'm a paid subscriber of The Print! Dr Chipman not only gave a macro view of the geo politics , but also with great specificity. Seemed like he was willing to double click on any topic Mr Gupta brought up These are the kind of men you want in your government or at least advising the government Thank you for this The Print Team.
Hi Purvayian, we are glad to have an audience like you, stay tuned.
State-of-art journalism and strategic analysis!!Jus Brilliant!!
Hi Lumbini, glad for your response.
@@ThePrintIndia Thanks to you actually 😊
Excellent interview , i couldn't stop watching and listening till the end. I agree with everything they said except the last part about next prime minister for England which i don't know much about.
Hi Homayun, thanks for writing in.
Please call Prof. John Mershimer to the show as well to hear the counter perspective.
They won't dare!!
I have a feel that Russia has taken advantage of the Ukraine war to offload or dispose of its aging stockpile of Soviet era weapons of mass destruction simultaneously testing its striking capabilities. And the Americans doing a similar exercise on their side. The non participant in this war also have important learnings to draw from. The true victim is Ukraine.
stupid as always lol. To get ride of their stockpile. They would recycle it, not reapir it for billion of dollars and use it in a war. At that price they would get new and better stuff.
Excellent, classy, extremely insightful and informative!
Thank you so much Shekhar Gupta Sir, The Print, and Sir John Chipman!
That question on Turkey was the best one...I have been wondering about that for a long while...
To say that Russia didn’t think of having air superiority in parallel with its inland thrust by its land forces is very difficult to digest. From the advent of the air age we have seen air dominance as key part of any war. From the First World War to recent afghan and Iraq war. I doubt Russia has deficiency of air assets to put on this offensive. There is more reason to this question as to why Russia isn’t having air superiority over Ukrainian air space. Or at least over Donbas and Luhansk region. Only time will tell.
what are u smoking? air superiority is key to giving a crushing blow; the US established air superiority pretty quickly in Iraq, and in the early stages of Barbarossa, the Germans had the air superiority and were able to dole out crushing blows cause of that. And air power just wasn't that relevant during ww1.
Russian Air superiority was not tried or has not worked ..we will never know which one !!
Wow, he aged a lot since the thumbnail was made. Lol
Thank you Shekar Gupta ji
This OTC was Gold! Honestly I was going to skip this until you mentioned it in your CTC today. It’ll be a good idea to provide such reference about your guest in a prior/post CTC episode every week.
Dr Chipman is clearly a western hawk. I did not hear much about the Russian perspective.
I don't think any so called 🤔 strategic thinker of western mould can afford not to be a hawk !!... they would be sanctioned out !!..
great presentation 👏, ty
Beautiful, see you again soon
Thanks
Masterclass
Excellent talk. Thank you very much!
Always love to hear the “gora” log speak. They are so pragmatic, have depth, lateral thinkers, dynamic analysis and most imp bereft of personal emotions.
Lol . Except his criticising logistics his analysis is wrong about Russia.
Great conversation
Interesting insights
@The Print You should also have an Off The Cuff episode with Peter Zeihan
Upsc aspirant
GS Paper-2: international Relations
Not able to renew the membership. Saved card., which is active, is not working. Neither it's allowing to add new card.
Hi Harish,
May we request you to send a screenshot of the error message on contributions@theprint.in, so that we may understand the issue and help you out at the earliest.
@@ThePrintIndia you will respond only to money related messages.. cheap propaganda media eager to join with west to malign the country.
Interesting talk!
As always, it was very interesting to listen to.
Hi Kevin, thanks for tuning in.
🙏🏻
Russia should rebuild it's relationship with Afghanistan.
Old Chinese saying . If you want do a business build a road. Land locked northwest now will connect with Eurasia . Plus the minerals metal ores gas. Gold what it discovers on the way is pure bonus for its industrial revolution
Shekhar ji one ctc on data please.
China praises Ukraine mediator Macron as Beijing hopes to renew EU ties
In a call with the French president’s diplomatic counsellor, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi says mediation efforts are appreciated
👌👌👌👍👍👍🥂🥂
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🤩
There is an easy way against AI, do things that you have never done before. Be unpredictable and AI will have no clue that you would do something like that
🙏👏👍👌❤🇮🇳 the best next new Prime Minister of UK Shri Rishi sunak congratulations
गप्टा
I like that
Why does he bring only pro-west speakers? This is not neutral journalism. This is kinda propaganda
Bhai tu arnab dekh
I was thinking exactly the same thing. Never presents a balanced view. @ThePrint - why should the west think they can get involved in spreading "democracy" and "freedom" in Ukraine and not in Saudi Arabia? Did you ever bother to ask that? That is what caused the coup in 2014 and the conflict now. If that wasn't done, they wouldn't have had to think bout seizing Russian assets to feed the rest of the world, would they? @ThePrint - Are you trying to spin a narrative? Do your job and present both sides to inform, not to rally opinion. It is getting really annoying.
@@shahrukhkotwal7125 till today I was not able to watch him not more than 10min. But there is a thing called listening to both sides. SG is not even the most neutral journalist either like everyone he has his biases. Do you think listening to only one side makes you wiser. Calling out names does not help. Western speakers said Russians are short of ammunition after one month, I am waiting for Russians to run out of ammunition. They claimed lysychansk is difficult to capture because it is on elevation. Russia took it in just a week. Wait for a month or two and you will see more cities falling to Russians. We all knew it was impossible to roll over ukraine or any country in 3 days. It will take almost a week for Russian tanks to reach kiev even if it is left open and unguarded
@@shahrukhkotwal7125 just by listening to this you think that you are the most well informed and you think you will be on higher intellect, but it is not the case sad to inform you.
@@hanniballecter1734 west thinks they are flag bearers of democracy and freedom, but in reality they have carried worst genocide, military coups, wars, racial abuses, invasions, overthrowing governments of sovereign nations and what not. They have set a very good template of how to remain in power
This "guru" of yours probably is the worst expert on the topic - his narrow minded approach, heavily biased, Russophobic, and well, basically he is one of those who wants to see west as the center of power. His appearance on your programme seems like he is pushing the "western" narrative to this part of the world. So far this has been the worst guest I heard and definitely not worth the title of "guru", at least by me.
Nobody cares about his views and definitely not common Indians and government itself has refused to condemns,we can't openly support Russia owing to our own dependency on west and gulf for energy imports...but we definitely don't support zelensky who is responsible for pushing his public into this war...
Why doesn't Shekhar Gupta brings any Russian guy on this show? It can't be any bigger propoganda than what this particular Guest is spewing.
which statements are propaganda?
What will a Russian say to justify their war on Ukraine?
The USSR doesn’t exist anymore.
You should watch Russian RUclips channels for their views
@@mdaalishanraza3928 every sentences specially "Russia is desperate for ceasefire "!
Maybe he is biased towards Ukraine, majority of left media are against Russia but majority of common Indian support Russian stance and especially those who know history of NATO and USA war crimes in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan know that Russian stance is totally justified.. it's American fault who used zelensky as guinea 🐖🐖
If Trump was president today instead Jo biden what would have been the situation with respect to Russian and Ukraine war.
Nothing different 🇺🇸 foreign policy stay the same. If you really look it hard it just continue through one administration to another administration.
He is some kind of astrologer
two western stooges talking to each other!!
Cope hard, lol.
Thanks
Dear Arun,
Thank you for supporting ThePrint.