What if France became Ultranationalist in 1923? | Project Red World - Episode 3

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 160

  • @rewriting-history
    @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +19

    French House Election - forms.gle/Ra6T6EVB8CfMRgEW6
    Also subscribe!

    • @zhcultivator
      @zhcultivator Час назад +3

      What if China became Neo-Fascist after ww2? (Right-Wing Ultranationalist China alt history)
      In this timeline the KMT ( The Kuomintang, also known as the Chinese Nationalist Party) win the civil war and go into a Fascist direction (instead of a Democratic Path like in Taiwan) with a (third positionist) corporatist economy combined with a chauvinistic welfare system and a culturally traditionalist outlook. I expect this China to be highly pronatalist i.e. it would encourage high fertility/birth rates to restore the dead population lost in the conflicts of the 20th century like the chinese civil war/japanese invasion of china/breakup of the Qing dynasty, first sino-japanese war, the taiping rebellion, and opium wars.... This Neo-Fascist KMT-led China is probably Irredentist too.

    • @zhcultivator
      @zhcultivator 57 минут назад +1

      What if India became Fascist during and after WW2? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_National_Army / en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindutva
      Basically, this 'Free Republic of India' or free republic of Bharat is = OTL India + Pakistan + Bangladesh in one country (or just India and Bangladesh combined)
      Fascism in Asia - Wikipedia
      en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
      / en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_Mahasabha / en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akhand_Bharat
      The most viable route here is to declare independence from the British, perhaps with more military aid from Imperial Japan and play the Franco game in order to stay neutral before allying with the U.S. on account of it's probable anti-communism to counter Soviet/Communist influence in Asia going into the Cold war.
      In this Alternate Timeline, the partition of British India (or the British Raj) doesn't happen instead the Indian Subcontinent (excluding Bhutan, Sri Lanka and Nepal) is just one country called the Free Republic of India. And it is a militaristic revolutionary conservative/fascist state run by one authoritarian or totalitarian political party focused on Hindu (ultra)nationalism, Anti-Colonialism and Anti-British sentiment and is Pro-Empire of Japan (or supports the Showa Statist Empire of Japan- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statism_in_Shōwa_Japan ). They're likely economic/influence rivals and mortal enemies with China, especially in the still highly likely event the Communists take over. The two would have each other as the primary security threats, are radically ideologically opposed, and have clashing interest in terms of establishing regional hegemon status, so they are bound to clash frequently and trying to back insurgencies inside each others' countries. With a more Hindu nationalist India, I assume there would be frequent Muslim rebellions in Bangladesh and Pakistan of our timeline. And the government of this Fascist India would develop Nuclear Weapons too like in real life history.
      How would this affect India and South Asia's history, borders, culture, demographics, socioeconomic development, and international relations?
      This isn't very realistic I think, but I think it could be an interesting alt-history scenario to think about and speculate about...

    • @zhcultivator
      @zhcultivator 55 минут назад +3

      What if Brazil became a Distributist democracy in the 20th century and the 1964 Military Coup never happened? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism??

  • @Captain_Griff
    @Captain_Griff 2 часа назад +81

    If i had a dolar for every time France became Ultranationalist in a Rewriting History series, i'd have 2 dolars which isn't much but it's weird that it happened twice

    • @Bartholomew-h9q
      @Bartholomew-h9q 2 часа назад +4

      True dat

    • @brabius2695
      @brabius2695 Час назад +1

      Good reference 😂😂😂😂

    • @Pragmaticlearner98
      @Pragmaticlearner98 47 минут назад

      I bet you Rewriting History will do another project history like the Pax Britanica or The Three Cousins League and France will be communist and in one of these two future and hypotetical projects France will cease to exist

    • @TheRatattat
      @TheRatattat 36 минут назад

      "Which isn't much but weird it happened twice"

  • @Grinibog902
    @Grinibog902 2 часа назад +25

    Lol the Flag of France looks like Batman ngl

  • @indianajones4321
    @indianajones4321 2 часа назад +38

    “Better dead than red”
    -1923 France, probably

  • @unfunny4346
    @unfunny4346 Час назад +4

    France: "I am vengeance, I am the night, I am France!"

  • @ItzKyth123
    @ItzKyth123 2 часа назад +32

    France being ultranationlist everytime is crazy
    also i like your videos alot and i subscribed

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +7

      I appreciate that!

    • @ItzKyth123
      @ItzKyth123 2 часа назад +1

      @@rewriting-history cool🙃
      also what software you use to make your videos and the map?

  • @Prestoninthezone
    @Prestoninthezone 2 часа назад +29

    JUST SUBSCRIBE TO REWRITING HISTORY

  • @SirSloo
    @SirSloo 2 часа назад +25

    France really pulled that uno reverse card

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +7

      They said "Fine, I'll do it myself"

    • @Ey-1w
      @Ey-1w 2 часа назад +1

      I'M IN THE THICK OF IT, EVERYBODY KNOWS🥶🥶🥶

    • @Ștefan_cel_Mare_și_Sfânt
      @Ștefan_cel_Mare_și_Sfânt 2 часа назад

      ​@@Ey-1w the ai recreation is actually good, not like the original

  • @ayyybob
    @ayyybob Час назад +4

    Damn the Bulgarian political situation was just downright insane💀

  • @AydinMete654
    @AydinMete654 2 часа назад +15

    Can you do another series where Russia surrenders to napoleon after France took Moscow, I think it would be very interesting, love your videos

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +4

      I plan to do more Napoleonic Wars videos, but maybe next year

  • @Terr_o_ist
    @Terr_o_ist 2 часа назад +7

    Heart of iron the second you launch it without historical mode.

  • @michealbrennan8107
    @michealbrennan8107 Час назад +2

    9:46 ireland would never accept this seeing as they had just finally gotten independence and were under no threat from either the communists and the ultranationalists

  • @AbhishekMann-bk3ur
    @AbhishekMann-bk3ur 2 часа назад +8

    Idea for your 3rd series.
    Franco Prussian War is won by Francewith help of Ausria. Prussia forms alliance with Russia and Britain and Italy. France allies with Austria-Hungary, Ottomans and Southern German states. A World War starts in Balkans with Russia invading Ottomans. Austria helps Ottomans. Prussia attacks Austria-Hungary leading to France attack Prussia. Britain and Italy waits but joins Prussia side and win.

    • @antodiyo7523
      @antodiyo7523 2 часа назад

      Yes please 🥺🙏

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +4

      I like the idea. I am planning something different for 3rd series, but I can do something similar as to what you wrote for a mega scenario ~40 minutes

    • @AbhishekMann-bk3ur
      @AbhishekMann-bk3ur 2 часа назад +1

      @@rewriting-history Thanks for considering my idea.

  • @itsParkas
    @itsParkas 2 часа назад +5

    I CALLED FOR IT
    Last Red World Episode I literally said that the next country to fall would be France AND HERE WE ARE!

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +1

      Good job! Let us see how the series develops in the future. Feel free to make a prediction about Bulgaria and the Balkans' future

    • @itsParkas
      @itsParkas Час назад

      I have a few assumptions for what would happen next:
      Obviously the obvious first:
      Republic of China; The Communists will simply win the Chinese Civil War. Except maybe this time they annex Taiwan.
      Onto the fun stuff:
      Spain; Spain is already very precarious given their history and the fact that their neighbour of France is literally communist.
      The Spanish Civil War would likely start but it would be the Spanish Government vs the Spanish Communists.
      Turkey; Turkey had just come out of a war that gave it its modern borders and had gone through sweeping reforms under Mustafa Kemal. Given the situation, it would be hard and very unrealistic. I believe that Turkey could be communist if enough political strings were pulled.
      The Balkans; I cannot say how, but I find it likely that Romania, Bulgaria and Greece will fall under Yugoslavia and/or Turkey if it became communist
      British Empire; Maybe the socialists will gain traction over time (like in Kaisertum) but it would be very unlikely. But according to the narrative, the British Communists would eventually take over the country.
      This would be major, it would likely induce the fall of the British Empire with colonies like Malaysia, British Raj, South Africa etc. breaking away.
      Anyways that's all I got

  • @handsomedoor1705
    @handsomedoor1705 2 часа назад +8

    Suggestion: What if Dacia won the first Daco-Roman war
    What if the treaty between Dacia and Rome was not broken by Traian

  • @daniilere
    @daniilere 2 часа назад +5

    Batman France

  • @minestar2247
    @minestar2247 2 часа назад +4

    hell yeah, rif resistance mentioned!
    another sign of spanish incompetance is that they also used areal bombings and toxic phosphate, and yet only won after the riffi left the mountains that made them strong

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад

      I never knew about the Rif war, so I am glad I can learn new stuff while making videos!

  • @FillUserChill
    @FillUserChill Час назад +2

    I rly hope Italy doesn't take the L at the end of this scenario aswel 🙏😭

  • @Zapadoslavwithcrown
    @Zapadoslavwithcrown Час назад +2

    YEAH BABY! NEXT EPISODE!

  • @Ezkhishi
    @Ezkhishi 3 минуты назад

    I'm very happy and excited I get to take part in one of your videos 💙

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 2 часа назад +4

    Love your content! Thanks For this 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @Trollge398
    @Trollge398 2 часа назад +2

    Up with Ultranationalist down with the Reds

  • @Ryanlovedits
    @Ryanlovedits 2 часа назад +3

    Wait..... I think I've seen this happen before

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 2 часа назад +2

    This series is amazing! Thanks For another video😊😊😊😊😊

  • @tony-gp6do
    @tony-gp6do 2 часа назад +3

    Guys, let's get a new napoleon in france

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад +1

      It went well the first 2 times, we will see what the people will vote for :D

    • @dqnkdoggo_
      @dqnkdoggo_ Час назад

      Fourth times the charm!

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator Час назад +1

    What if Yugoslavia was Fascist? Slavic-Fascist Yugoslavia.

  • @splatsquidgereng3789
    @splatsquidgereng3789 Час назад

    I love your videos. You put a lot of time into it and that is very noticeable. And it's very entertaining! Keep up the good work. :)

  • @Em-Theassiate8888-mp3uf
    @Em-Theassiate8888-mp3uf 27 минут назад

    I look forward to this series the most

  • @AlexandreHernandezvaldez
    @AlexandreHernandezvaldez 2 часа назад +2

    Great serier keep it up

  • @GoncaloBall
    @GoncaloBall 2 часа назад +2

    great video just like always this is what youtubers should do also make scenarios

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад

      I appreciate the kind words!

    • @GoncaloBall
      @GoncaloBall 2 часа назад

      and look who is back here from the shorts

    • @GoncaloBall
      @GoncaloBall 2 часа назад

      @rewriting-history no problem realy think i would miss this masterpiece

    • @GoncaloBall
      @GoncaloBall Час назад

      if you know what i mean by that

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator Час назад +1

    What if India became Fascist during and after ww2? Basically a Hindutva-Fascist India that covers all of current-day Bangladesh, India and Pakistan...

  • @markelcuetara5287
    @markelcuetara5287 2 часа назад +1

    Damn your videos make me the day, when I see your notification Im Happy

  • @QasqaZhol
    @QasqaZhol 58 минут назад

    Regular France: ouie, ouie, ouie...
    BatFrance: ouie, ouie, ouie(agressively, with low baatman voice).😂😂😂

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator 54 минуты назад +1

    What if Georgism succeeded in the USA during and after the Great Depression?*

  • @khaledmoslehi1314
    @khaledmoslehi1314 2 часа назад +1

    Have an exam tomorrow but I can't miss the new project red world episode 🔥🔥

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад

      Don't worry, study hard after the episode and you will crush it! Good luck and do your best!

  • @FronteiraAlternativa
    @FronteiraAlternativa 2 часа назад +1

    I've already made my choice

  • @TomFelix
    @TomFelix Час назад +2

    Thanks for wearing my French flag bro

  • @Ștefan_cel_Mare_și_Sfânt
    @Ștefan_cel_Mare_și_Sfânt 2 часа назад +1

    Rh, I have 2 video ideas
    What if Michael the Brave who united the 3 Romanian Principalities wasn't assassinated by german merchants in 1600 (or 1601 I forgor)
    And what if Greater Romania survived WW2 intact (and hopefully not communist or fascist)

  • @markomarkopootis5556
    @markomarkopootis5556 42 минуты назад +1

    If mustache painter was born in southern Belgium.

  • @Ľudovít_g
    @Ľudovít_g Час назад +1

    Can you make at least age of history lll mod?

  • @Kosmochelik
    @Kosmochelik 2 часа назад +3

    Dear RH
    We think you.. don't trust us. Don't believe that we can do something to person who comented last time 3 monts ago. So you can ask anything. Any 5 questions about us
    -Group "A"

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator 59 минут назад +1

    What if the Indo-European Migrations/Invasions never occurred?*

  • @bluefame2966
    @bluefame2966 2 часа назад +1

    Please make a what if germany went accelerationist after ww1 video

  • @ayyybob
    @ayyybob 2 часа назад

    The Bonapartes were quite liberal, left-leaning, powerhungry and were overthrown just 50 years prior, while the Bourbons were still unpopular for their corruption and incompetency, so i voted for Orleans

  • @b.r508
    @b.r508 Час назад

    That Ultranationalist France Flag Kinda Looks Like The United Federation Flag From Sonic Lol

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator Час назад +1

    What if Turkey became a Fascist country in the Interwar Period?? What would happen next???

  • @ZukiTheMapper
    @ZukiTheMapper 2 часа назад +2

    tutorial to create amazing videos like this when

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад

      I will make something similar either in December or next year

  • @polish_productions
    @polish_productions Час назад

    Can you do series like that but the episodes will be in timeline format for example frist video 1936-1939 second 1940-1943 and thrid 1943-1945?

  • @dqnkdoggo_
    @dqnkdoggo_ Час назад

    This is truly a red flood

  • @vansglitches1192
    @vansglitches1192 Час назад

    This will be the timeline where people on the internet will not make fun of french people
    (Not a french nationalist)

  • @MacedonianBulgarian
    @MacedonianBulgarian 2 часа назад +2

    New video 🎉

  • @REV-PN7
    @REV-PN7 Час назад

    French Ultranationalist:Surely I'll beat the Germans this time
    right?

  • @fuzzyduck3171
    @fuzzyduck3171 22 минуты назад

    Where did project kaisertum go in hoi4? That mid looked very good

  • @JesusOrDestruction
    @JesusOrDestruction 2 часа назад

    If the Austrian painter was born in western Switzerland

  • @liviapavel316
    @liviapavel316 Час назад

    Is it red world or ultrenationalist and monarchist world?

  • @rainballanimates2116
    @rainballanimates2116 Час назад +1

    The thumbnail reminds me of oversimplified😅

  • @UnYoutuber._.
    @UnYoutuber._. Час назад

    Ok so now my best bet is that maybe in thia timeline Sanchez Cerro will have slightly more support from the peruvians itself due to the rise of communism in the world itself... At least MAYBE managing to reach 1936 alive.

  • @blahajgaeming
    @blahajgaeming 2 часа назад

    Imagine if bonaparte house came to power

  • @bladefeather2293
    @bladefeather2293 2 часа назад

    I can't vote , but Bonaparte for the win

  • @RougeTsunami
    @RougeTsunami 15 минут назад

    We're away from the French?!? GET IN!

  • @DAK_12
    @DAK_12 2 часа назад +1

    Time to have a god day 😀😀😀😀😀

  • @divertedpreon
    @divertedpreon 2 часа назад

    What is your poolitical stance on the rise of the for right in Europe?

  • @Prussiankingdom1871
    @Prussiankingdom1871 2 часа назад

    5:23 it fucking napoleon

  • @reachvidurmurali
    @reachvidurmurali Час назад

    Vote Bonaparte or the monster under your bed will attack you tonight

  • @thedetective4742
    @thedetective4742 Час назад

    i think greece would see comunist uprisings no matter who wins but nothing too great but i also think that they could just invade bulgaria just to gain eastern romelia

  • @Nalabear_2020
    @Nalabear_2020 27 минут назад

    Oman was part of the British empire but it’s not colored in ?

  • @niueworldorder
    @niueworldorder 2 часа назад

    alt history try not to make france super radical challenge (impossible)

    • @rewriting-history
      @rewriting-history  2 часа назад

      It makes for more entertaining content. If all were peaceful democracies that's great, but for alternate history it's boring. Obviously these are not my views, but I did state that I will abandon realism and focus on entertainment

  • @thatgermandaniel
    @thatgermandaniel Час назад

    Do I smell another hoi4 mod

  • @Arabmapperguy
    @Arabmapperguy Час назад

    WHO ALSO WANFS HOUSE OF BONAPARTE TO WIN

  • @minestar2247
    @minestar2247 2 часа назад +1

    damn? france going ultra nationalist again?
    well, at least here it wasn't because of popular votes

  • @MrBlitz-em7kd
    @MrBlitz-em7kd 59 минут назад +1

    Neznaeh che si bulgarin !

  • @SNCY29
    @SNCY29 42 минуты назад +1

    0:54 commie France, where flag from?

  • @JelyBeanCrusher
    @JelyBeanCrusher 2 часа назад

    I have gave up you will never do a benin empire video

  • @rexhepspecialforcesgrup2la961
    @rexhepspecialforcesgrup2la961 45 минут назад +1

    Hi bro im back❤😂😊❤

  • @is_idk
    @is_idk 2 часа назад

    What if instead of british, netherlands colonized malaya?

  • @Smokrylio
    @Smokrylio Час назад

    Imagain a 3 napoleon beat a communist world

  • @Leatly
    @Leatly Час назад

    Hello

  • @ChandrabhaRawat
    @ChandrabhaRawat 2 часа назад

    What if the Anarchists won in Ukraine during Russian civil war

  • @gio253
    @gio253 Час назад

    is this a red world serie or a fascist one?

  • @javediqbal1038
    @javediqbal1038 2 часа назад

    Fun fact: this comment was created before the video has ended for anyone.

  • @rauhau_
    @rauhau_ 2 часа назад +1

    :)

  • @psrgaming5509
    @psrgaming5509 2 часа назад

    Last (My internet suck so I am late)

  • @QUEfrang
    @QUEfrang 2 часа назад +1

    🟥🌍

  • @TeodorSpasojevic
    @TeodorSpasojevic 2 часа назад +2

    First

  • @zhcultivator
    @zhcultivator 52 минуты назад +1

    What if Brazil became a Distributist democracy in the 20th century and the 1964 Military Coup never happened at all? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism??