Problems in Periodisation of James Mill | How,When and Where | Class 8 History

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 янв 2025

Комментарии • 2,2 тыс.

  • @MagnetBrainsEducation
    @MagnetBrainsEducation  2 года назад +10

    ✔️📚👉 Grab Notes by Expert Teachers Here: www.pabbly.com/out/magnet-brains
    ✔️📚👉Get any subject playlist here:- www.magnetbrains.com/get-subject-wise-playlist
    ✔️📚👉Get any class & subject's topic Video here:- www.magnetbrains.com/get-topic-wise-video
    ✔️📚👉 Watch Full Free Course: www.magnetbrains.com

  • @MagnetBrainsEducation
    @MagnetBrainsEducation  4 года назад +103

    Previous Video: Chapter 1.4 - How Do We Periodise:
    ruclips.net/video/27KnouxyE8Q/видео.html
    Next Video: Chapter 1.6 - What is Colonial:
    ruclips.net/video/yIzVacf_gMI/видео.html

  • @SakshiSingh-pc4lv
    @SakshiSingh-pc4lv 3 года назад +18

    I have a trick to remember when did James Mill wrote 'A history of British India' . As we know, in James Mill's perspective India had "pichdapan", so, this year was also going "aghe to peeche" like, 18>17. So, 1817 is the year

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +8

      Sakshi Singh, Thanks for being active on the channel. Do recommend us to your friends.

    • @wayweofficial
      @wayweofficial 2 года назад +5

      Itna yaad karne ki jarurat hi nahi he . 5 - 6 baar padho automatically yaad ho jaaega

    • @wayweofficial
      @wayweofficial 2 года назад +3

      Itna yaad karne ki jarurat hi nahi he . 5 - 6 baar padho automatically yaad ho jaaega

    • @wayweofficial
      @wayweofficial 2 года назад +3

      Itna yaad karne ki jarurat hi nahi he . 5 - 6 baar padho automatically yaad ho jaaega

    • @doba4561
      @doba4561 7 месяцев назад

      ​sab ke comment padh ne se hinyaad ho na6e ga 😅

  • @vedikalodhi1926
    @vedikalodhi1926 3 года назад +21

    Sir, the answer of ir question is the "History of British India" and it was written by James Mill in 1817...🙃

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +9

      Vedíka Lodhi, Thanks for the reply. Wherever possible, please recommend us to your friends.

    • @abdussalamkhan6523
      @abdussalamkhan6523 Год назад

      A history of British india

    • @Anisha-sx9om
      @Anisha-sx9om 6 месяцев назад +1

      A history of British India

  • @musicalgallery2270
    @musicalgallery2270 Год назад +2

    The name of the book is:-
    ''The History Of British India'' by James Mill in year 1817.

  • @rohitrram2119
    @rohitrram2119 4 года назад +9

    Sir , the book written by James Mill is 'The History Of British India'.....

  • @diyabtsarmy7014
    @diyabtsarmy7014 4 года назад +6

    You really taught good. Everything is understood very well 👍

  • @priya-kk1lg
    @priya-kk1lg 4 года назад +84

    A history of British India 😊book published by James mill in 1817😃

  • @ParinitaSrivastava-jl9ih
    @ParinitaSrivastava-jl9ih Год назад +1

    good evening sir. the answer is " A history of british India" by james mill.
    so grateful to have u as teacher🙏🙏

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  Год назад

      Thank you for your positive feedback! We're glad you're enjoying the videos and learning from them.

  • @vaishnavitiwari7521
    @vaishnavitiwari7521 3 года назад +7

    In 1817, James Mill , is Scottish economist and political philosopher , published a massive 3 volume work , "A History of British India".

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +3

      Shailja Arts, Thanks for the reply. Wherever possible, please recommend us to your friends.

    • @musicalgallery2270
      @musicalgallery2270 Год назад

      Google baba ki jay😂😂😂😂

  • @IshmeetSinghBaweja
    @IshmeetSinghBaweja 4 года назад +4

    Sir, the answer of your question is "The name of the book written by James Mill was 'A History of British India' "
    Lov u sir ❤ Your Teaching Style is so good

  • @satyanarayansharma3104
    @satyanarayansharma3104 4 года назад +7

    James mill a Scottish economist and political philosopher written a book a history of British India and divided Indian history into three periods Hindu Muslim and British

  • @Kpopeditz11
    @Kpopeditz11 4 года назад +10

    Sir, the book name was "A History of British India" written by James Mill.

  • @ishaanmishra3681
    @ishaanmishra3681 3 года назад +1

    What are problems in the perodiastion of james mill?
    Please answer the question

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад

      Ishaan Mishra, Thanks a lot for checking out the video and replying back. Do recommend Magnet Brains to your friends. Also do checkout the Magnet Brains website, all video lectures are organized on the site for easy access.

  • @lalita81
    @lalita81 Год назад +2

    The name of the book written by James Mill is A book of British India

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  Год назад

      Thank you for your positive review of our educational video on James Mill's A book of British India. We are India's No.1 Online Education Platform and we are committed to providing the best quality educational videos to school students.

  • @rajeshkumargupta7987
    @rajeshkumargupta7987 4 года назад +15

    The book written by James mill is a history of British India

  • @mansii2
    @mansii2 4 года назад +5

    Answer of ques
    "The history of British India was the book" which was written by james Mill.

  • @studyteach3380
    @studyteach3380 3 года назад +2

    Thanks for great explanation..
    Answer of the question History of British India.

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +1

      Study Teach, Thanks for being active on the channel. Do recommend us to your friends.

    • @balupatil5006
      @balupatil5006 3 года назад +1

      @@MagnetBrainsEducation ok sir

  • @zeenatashiq1522
    @zeenatashiq1522 2 года назад +1

    Thank you sir❤️You clear all my doubt✨

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  2 года назад

      Thank you for your kind words! We're glad that our videos have been helpful for you. We want to make sure that students get the help they need to succeed, and we're so happy that we could provide that to you. Keep up the good work!

  • @kislaykumar3000
    @kislaykumar3000 4 года назад +4

    I understand this video's topics very well. Sir

  • @Mrsahil1296
    @Mrsahil1296 4 года назад +7

    Very nice explanation sir. Really its very helpful to me to understand it properly

  • @Arcane2818
    @Arcane2818 4 года назад +7

    "The history of British India" is the book written by James mill perioidising the history of India into three parts - Hindu,Muslims and British(christian).It has many drawbacks and problem.
    Thank you sir for your lecture which help a lot in my studies.

  • @SuccessBrain-s3u
    @SuccessBrain-s3u 9 месяцев назад +1

    The book name was written by James mill A History of British India❤

  • @somraj5364
    @somraj5364 2 года назад +2

    James Mill book name is 👉A history of british India

  • @kaushalkishor4721
    @kaushalkishor4721 4 года назад +19

    A history of british india is the book writen by james mill

  • @r.kmishra4164
    @r.kmishra4164 4 года назад +8

    Sir ,james mill ke book ka name tha - A history of british india 😊

  • @Sheknowsmeh
    @Sheknowsmeh 4 года назад +4

    Home work:- A history of British India, was written by James mill

  • @anshikagangrade4147
    @anshikagangrade4147 3 года назад +1

    😄 explanation is good and we can understand it very clearly.😉

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад

      Anshika Gangrade, Thanks for the reply. Wherever possible, please recommend us to your friends.

  • @dharmeshchoudhary2004
    @dharmeshchoudhary2004 9 месяцев назад +1

    Sir, book name a history of British India written by James Mill a Scottish economist and political philosopher. Who periodise the Indian history into 3 periods hindu, Muslim, and British. The periodisation came to the widely accepted.
    Thank you sir for explaining this chapter you are the best teacher

  • @RaviPandey-tp9yj
    @RaviPandey-tp9yj 4 года назад +4

    The name of the book written by James Mill is ' A history of British India

  • @dhritisman6822
    @dhritisman6822 4 года назад +7

    In 1817 James Mill a Scottish economists and philosopher who periodise history into 3 parts- hindu muslim and british. The book he wrote was 'The history of British India. '

  • @dssschool9558
    @dssschool9558 3 года назад +9

    "The history of British India" written by James Mill in 1817

  • @jagratimehta8725
    @jagratimehta8725 2 года назад +2

    James Mill was a philosopher Scottish economist political he divided Indian history into three period Hindu muslim and British he wrote the books the massive three volume word and the history of British India in 1817

  • @Mousumi.Officials
    @Mousumi.Officials 3 года назад +2

    The name of the book written by James Mill was A History of British India...
    In this classified India into three parts -:
    1. Hindu (Ancient period)
    2. Muslim (Mediaeval period)
    3. British (Modern period)
    Sir please tell if I am right.

  • @vivakkhera7071
    @vivakkhera7071 4 года назад +9

    Sir, the book written by James mill is "The history of British India "

  • @Hand142
    @Hand142 4 года назад +6

    Sir the name of James mill's book is ''the history of British India"

  • @madhurikumari2366
    @madhurikumari2366 4 года назад +4

    The name of the book is written by James mill is The history of british India
    It is divided into three periods Hindu,Muslim and British 👍

  • @Kawishraza_750
    @Kawishraza_750 Год назад

    Sir please explain the meaning of these following words " Regional intelogrance, ignorance,caste hierarchy and orthodoxy " ...

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  Год назад

      Thanks for your comment! We appreciate your interest in learning more about these terms. Regional intelogrance is the idea that one region is more intelligent than another, while ignorance is simply lack of knowledge. Caste hierarchy is the social ranking of different castes, and orthodoxy is a strict adherence to established beliefs or customs. Hopefully this explanation helps!

  • @neelamsharma9552
    @neelamsharma9552 8 месяцев назад +1

    Sir, today's homework: The Book of James Mill A History of British India😊 We Write this book in 1817..😊🎉..❤..😊

  • @nihi5009
    @nihi5009 4 года назад +11

    The name of the book was ' HISTORY Of BRITISH INDIA' and was written by James mill ...

  • @subhangishreya6801
    @subhangishreya6801 4 года назад +4

    Sir kya aap online class bhi krata h

  • @poojasawhney6005
    @poojasawhney6005 4 года назад +4

    A history of british India was the book name written by james mill

  • @prat_uhh
    @prat_uhh 3 года назад +2

    A history of British India
    In western side of India there were Marathas In South there were Cholas, Vijayanagara empire etc.
    Also according to the modern period, we learn these things from them too.

  • @sameeha1984
    @sameeha1984 2 года назад +2

    Sir, the answer of question is the"the history of british india" and it was witten by James Mill in 1817...☺

  • @artaleart
    @artaleart 4 года назад +9

    The name of the book which is written by James mill is " THE HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA"

  • @Army-ru7ve
    @Army-ru7ve 4 года назад +6

    " A history of British India " is the book written by James mill . It was published in 1817.

  • @shrutirohilla2548
    @shrutirohilla2548 4 года назад +4

    The name of the book "The history of British India"

  • @Kriya-l4t
    @Kriya-l4t Месяц назад +1

    History of British India is book written by Mr James mill

  • @lacuna_01
    @lacuna_01 Год назад +1

    The book written by James mill was " HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA " and he divided it into 3 parts - Hindu , Muslim and British.

  • @piyushrai5771
    @piyushrai5771 4 года назад +7

    Home work "A history of British India"

  • @amrendrajha8311
    @amrendrajha8311 4 года назад +4

    The name of the book is 'A HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA'.

  • @mayankthaker1321
    @mayankthaker1321 4 года назад +7

    Sir name of book written by James Mill is 'HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA'.

  • @sureshpattanaik7594
    @sureshpattanaik7594 3 года назад +2

    Sir the name of the book written by James Mill is A History Of British India.

  • @abdaniftikhar8625
    @abdaniftikhar8625 3 года назад +3

    'The History of British India' written by Scottish economist and political philosopher James Mill in 1817.

  • @StudywithRadha886
    @StudywithRadha886 4 года назад +5

    The history of British India the book written by James mill

  • @farihatuba1539
    @farihatuba1539 3 года назад +4

    "the history of British india" was the book written by James mill

  • @onamutsav2493
    @onamutsav2493 4 года назад +4

    Sir please organise live classes

  • @kavitadansana7128
    @kavitadansana7128 3 года назад +1

    A history if British India was the name of book written by James Mill

  • @pinkiyadav1617
    @pinkiyadav1617 3 года назад +1

    Name of the book which is written by James Mill is A HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA. In which he has divided Indian history into three periods :- Hindu, Muslim and British.

  • @madhumithas7823
    @madhumithas7823 4 года назад +5

    Sir the name of the book which was written by James mill was "A HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA".

  • @sarthaktiwari2523
    @sarthaktiwari2523 4 года назад +4

    Sir the book name is
    The history of British India

  • @kunal1005
    @kunal1005 4 года назад +6

    Thank you sir
    Very interesting video.

  • @creativeworld9606
    @creativeworld9606 3 года назад +1

    Book 📕 published by James Mill:-
    A history of british india 🇮🇳😊

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +1

      Ritu Sharma, Thanks for being active on the channel. Do recommend us to your friends.

  • @ImranbhT0707
    @ImranbhT0707 3 года назад +1

    A History of British India was the book that James Mill published.....🤗

  • @diyabtsarmy7014
    @diyabtsarmy7014 4 года назад +7

    'A history of British India' was the book written by James Mill in 1817

  • @nsgangwar4015
    @nsgangwar4015 4 года назад +11

    History of british india

  • @anaykr1978
    @anaykr1978 3 года назад +3

    SIR , THE BOOK PUBLISHED BY JAMES MILL IS---- "A HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA.

  • @Sunshine-uo3vo
    @Sunshine-uo3vo Год назад +1

    A history of british india the book written by James mill

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  Год назад

      Thank you for taking the time to watch our videos and for writing a comment. We're glad you found our videos helpful and we hope you continue to enjoy learning from them.

  • @rajinderkhajuria5677
    @rajinderkhajuria5677 3 года назад +1

    I have a question sir what were the limitations of James Mill periodization

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад

      RAJINDER KHAJURIA, Thanks a lot for checking out the video and replying back. Do recommend Magnet Brains to your friends. Also do checkout the Magnet Brains website, all video lectures are organized on the site for easy access.

  • @shreyaraj3577
    @shreyaraj3577 4 года назад +5

    The name of the book written by James Mill is "A History of British India".

  • @rohininetam1419
    @rohininetam1419 3 года назад +5

    "The history of British India"
    Book name

  • @mohammadaltafnajar9432
    @mohammadaltafnajar9432 3 года назад +4

    "The history of British India"
    was the name of book

  • @dupinderkaurvirdi5942
    @dupinderkaurvirdi5942 5 месяцев назад

    The book's name in which James Mill periodised British India is named"A History of British India (hw done sir 👍)

  • @rossegirigaming9095
    @rossegirigaming9095 2 года назад +2

    A history of british india in 1817 by james mill 😍

  • @Smart__woman__
    @Smart__woman__ 4 года назад +7

    A History of British India written by James Mill

  • @MukeshSingh-zl4pd
    @MukeshSingh-zl4pd 4 года назад +4

    'The history of British India ' is the book written by James Mill

  • @vedikad4869
    @vedikad4869 4 года назад +7

    Tq so much sir through this vedio I can easily write my tomorrow social test

  • @Mr_Gamer.42
    @Mr_Gamer.42 3 года назад +1

    The history of British India was written by James mill

  • @unknowngaming1575
    @unknowngaming1575 2 года назад +2

    The name of the book published by James Mill was "A History of British India" in 1817

  • @ddkycx
    @ddkycx 4 года назад +7

    who who came in the comment section to know the books name written by James Mill 😂😂😂
    like me😂

  • @kushgarg5500
    @kushgarg5500 4 года назад +4

    उत्तर: ब्रिटिश भारत का इतिहास) जेम्स मिल द्वारा लिखी गई पुस्तक।

  • @archanasharma62625
    @archanasharma62625 3 года назад +4

    " A history of British India " was the book written by James Mill in " 1817 ".

  • @sadaquatstokes7996
    @sadaquatstokes7996 3 года назад +1

    According to Me , James Mill's periodisation is absolutely right.
    Because in Hindu time period, Hindu rulers were rule, in Muslim time period, Muslim rulers were rule and in British time period, British rulers were rule.
    Because in ancient history related to rulers's fight and big events only
    When rulers born, rule over the state,his ruling time period,his sons/daughters born and when he died.

    • @Niteshcroco
      @Niteshcroco 3 года назад

      What if Akbar is ruling and all the subjects were Hindu's, you can't divide History on the basis of the religion of the ruler

    • @sadaquatstokes7996
      @sadaquatstokes7996 3 года назад

      @@Niteshcroco No
      I know , we can't divide history on the basis of the religion.
      But James Mill's periodisation absolutely right because his thought was that his periodisation according to development of India by the ruling time.

    • @khadimhussain1388
      @khadimhussain1388 3 года назад

      No, the periodization is not right offered by James mill because there were Hindi rular also in the mughul period.

    • @shreyamishra3449
      @shreyamishra3449 2 года назад

      @sadaquat stokes in the time of Muslim every ruler was not muslim some small ruler of states were hindu .every ruler in akbar time period was not muslim

  • @Kawishraza_750
    @Kawishraza_750 Год назад

    1st q. Ans -The name of the book which is published by James Miller was " the history of British India" ..

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  Год назад

      Thanks for your comment! We are glad that our video was able to help you. We strive to provide free educational videos to students to help them in their studies. We hope you find our other videos equally helpful.

    • @Kawishraza_750
      @Kawishraza_750 Год назад

      ​@@MagnetBrainsEducation 🎉thank u so much sir..

  • @anupamkumari5011
    @anupamkumari5011 4 года назад +7

    Name of the book is the history of British india

  • @nitudevi810
    @nitudevi810 4 года назад +9

    A history of British India .homework completed

  • @prernabish4201
    @prernabish4201 4 года назад +5

    The name of the book written by James mill is A history of British India.

  • @gayatrikumari5453
    @gayatrikumari5453 3 года назад +1

    The history of British India book is written by James Mill.

  • @Gajanandnagar6622
    @Gajanandnagar6622 3 года назад +1

    Sir hamare online class chal rahe ha par hum aapke class le rahe ha👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

  • @knowledge_dot_virat
    @knowledge_dot_virat 3 года назад +2

    Book "A HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA"
    WRITTER " JAMES MILL"
    YEAR IN WHICH IT WAS PUBLISHED " 1817"
    🙂🙂

  • @lipikakanwarshekhawat6638
    @lipikakanwarshekhawat6638 4 года назад +14

    " A history of British India"
    That was the book

  • @RAJNISHKUMAR-bt6yn
    @RAJNISHKUMAR-bt6yn 4 года назад +11

    A history of british India 🇮🇳

  • @ayantikasingh6323
    @ayantikasingh6323 3 года назад

    The problem with the periodisation of Indian history by James Mill is that he divided the Indian history into Hindu, Muslim and the British period. It has been argued by many historians that it is not correct to periodise the Indian history on the basis of religion of the rulers.

    • @ayantikasingh6323
      @ayantikasingh6323 3 года назад

      And your questions answer is a history of British India published by James mill in 1817 he was a Scottish economist and political philosopher

  • @ammusicmasti8250
    @ammusicmasti8250 3 года назад +2

    The book was written by James mill are a history of British India 🙏👍💯

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад +1

      abha kumari, Thank you for your comment. Do recommend Magnet Brains to your friends.

  • @vardaanpanchal5976
    @vardaanpanchal5976 4 года назад +6

    Ans: The history of British India

  • @trlegend3805
    @trlegend3805 3 года назад +11

    "THE HISTORY OF BRITISH INDIA".

  • @deepakmanchanda88
    @deepakmanchanda88 3 года назад

    Sir... The book written by James Mill was.. " A history of British India "

    • @MagnetBrainsEducation
      @MagnetBrainsEducation  3 года назад

      Deepak Manchanda, Thanks for the reply. Wherever possible, please recommend us to your friends.

  • @suryanshu9682
    @suryanshu9682 3 года назад +1

    History of British India is written by a Scottish economist and political philosopher in 1817

  • @shuklagamer2420
    @shuklagamer2420 4 года назад +8

    The name of book "The history of British India "

  • @virendrasinghchouhan2573
    @virendrasinghchouhan2573 3 года назад +3

    the book written by James mill was the "History Of British India"