Not one, or two but three You voices. 😂 I love you Shuka for putting the LL community through this!! 🤣 Your ranking is pretty decent and I can say it seems difficult to rank. Should I try. lol Anyway my You voices ranking would be: 3. Mid 2. Original 1. Current (I love the current one. It's more like Shuka and the balance between the Mid and original fits perfectly for You. imo.)
Honestly this was by fair the most difficult ranking for me. I re-uploaded this video two or three times because I kept swapping people around. Even now I’m not fully happy with it. I feel like many of the pure attribute voices are just so song-dependent as to whether I like them. Like, Ruby in say Daydream Warrior? Amazing. Ruby using her cringe baby voice in Seinaru Hi no Inori? Not so much. And they’re all kind of like that. As for You… UGH SHUKA WHY lol she’s killing me. It only seemed fair to do 3 You voices because her OG voice, peak squeaky voice, and current voice are all noticeably different to my ear. I don’t really like You’s mid voice but I like that as you said she’s kind of found the balance between them now (though I still prefer songs where she leans harder on the OG side of things). You is just kind of really hard to rank 😭
@@mikan_v2 I know! Kanan, Ruby Kotori, Hanayo, Mia, Nozomi like almost all of the pure attribute girls seem to be song dependent. Since the time I saw this video today, I tried to think how I'd rank them and up until now I still keep on swapping them out. No other attribute is like this. Pure attribute is one of a kind. The reason why I don't like You's high pitched voice is because of the auto tunning on it. Like why?! I hate when they ruin voices with auto tuning. And I'm so glad someone finally realized it. You's deep voice is so good. The OG one and the new one both do her a lot more justice. Whenever I hear You's albums on shuffle I love the variety of voices that I get to hear from You in the same shuffle playlist and while listening to the shuffle sometimes I don't mind the high pitched one too.
@yo-soro1416 haha maybe we’ve stumbled upon the true way they categorize who goes in the pure attribute 🤣 I would even say You falls in here too, because her voice varies a lot in songs. Emma and Ayumu too. I like Emma’s voice way better in some songs than others. Pure girls definitely are a challenge. I did not expect at all that they would be the most difficult for me to accurately rank. I think I ended up with like a five way tie because of this 🤦♀️ it’s so hard when so many girls have really strong songs but also really weak songs! Oof yeah you can hear auto tuning on Kotori’s voice a lot too and it just makes me wince. The auto tuning makes it A LOT worse. If I’m going to wince or cringe at a voice 99% of the time it’s from the pure attribute and probably 75% of the reason is staff just trying too hard to compensate. It sucks.
@@mikan_v2 lol. Pure attribute has become a group in which each girl has a different voice for a different type of song. 😅 Any idea who is in the pure attribute from Liella and do those girls also have this changing voice attribute? They also use auto tunning on Kanan and Ruby too. Shizuku's recent songs are also auto tuned. Ironically, one of my favorite vocals from each group has faced this auto tuning problem, :/ sadly.
Mine For voice: 16 Ruby 15 Original You 14 Original Kotori 13 Mei 12 Original Hanayo 11 Kinako 10 Current Kotori 9 Nozomi 8 Ayumu 7 Current Hanayo 6 Kanan 5 Current You 4 Keke 3 Kasumi 2 Mia 1 Emma By favourite 13 Ruby 12 Ayumu 11 Hanayo 10 Kinako 9 Kotori 8 Kanan 7 Mei 6 Nozomi 5 Emma 4 You 3 Mia 2 Keke 1 Kasumi
Not one, or two but three You voices. 😂 I love you Shuka for putting the LL community through this!! 🤣
Your ranking is pretty decent and I can say it seems difficult to rank. Should I try. lol
Anyway my You voices ranking would be:
3. Mid
2. Original
1. Current (I love the current one. It's more like Shuka and the balance between the Mid and original fits perfectly for You. imo.)
Honestly this was by fair the most difficult ranking for me. I re-uploaded this video two or three times because I kept swapping people around. Even now I’m not fully happy with it. I feel like many of the pure attribute voices are just so song-dependent as to whether I like them. Like, Ruby in say Daydream Warrior? Amazing. Ruby using her cringe baby voice in Seinaru Hi no Inori? Not so much. And they’re all kind of like that.
As for You… UGH SHUKA WHY lol she’s killing me. It only seemed fair to do 3 You voices because her OG voice, peak squeaky voice, and current voice are all noticeably different to my ear. I don’t really like You’s mid voice but I like that as you said she’s kind of found the balance between them now (though I still prefer songs where she leans harder on the OG side of things). You is just kind of really hard to rank 😭
@@mikan_v2 I know! Kanan, Ruby Kotori, Hanayo, Mia, Nozomi like almost all of the pure attribute girls seem to be song dependent. Since the time I saw this video today, I tried to think how I'd rank them and up until now I still keep on swapping them out. No other attribute is like this. Pure attribute is one of a kind.
The reason why I don't like You's high pitched voice is because of the auto tunning on it. Like why?! I hate when they ruin voices with auto tuning. And I'm so glad someone finally realized it. You's deep voice is so good. The OG one and the new one both do her a lot more justice.
Whenever I hear You's albums on shuffle I love the variety of voices that I get to hear from You in the same shuffle playlist and while listening to the shuffle sometimes I don't mind the high pitched one too.
@yo-soro1416 haha maybe we’ve stumbled upon the true way they categorize who goes in the pure attribute 🤣 I would even say You falls in here too, because her voice varies a lot in songs. Emma and Ayumu too. I like Emma’s voice way better in some songs than others. Pure girls definitely are a challenge. I did not expect at all that they would be the most difficult for me to accurately rank. I think I ended up with like a five way tie because of this 🤦♀️ it’s so hard when so many girls have really strong songs but also really weak songs!
Oof yeah you can hear auto tuning on Kotori’s voice a lot too and it just makes me wince. The auto tuning makes it A LOT worse. If I’m going to wince or cringe at a voice 99% of the time it’s from the pure attribute and probably 75% of the reason is staff just trying too hard to compensate. It sucks.
@@mikan_v2 lol. Pure attribute has become a group in which each girl has a different voice for a different type of song. 😅
Any idea who is in the pure attribute from Liella and do those girls also have this changing voice attribute?
They also use auto tunning on Kanan and Ruby too. Shizuku's recent songs are also auto tuned. Ironically, one of my favorite vocals from each group has faced this auto tuning problem, :/ sadly.
That is one packed list from you 😅
My ranking would be:
9: kotori
8: hanayo
7: kanan
6: Nozomi
5: ruby
4: You
3: Mia
2: kasumi
1: Emma
I knew Emma would be your number one but I'm happy to see my baby Kasumi in number two!!
@@mikan_v2 I’ve told you before that I like kasumi’s singing voice right 🤨
@Jury01 you have I just didn’t expect her to be that high, that’s all. Makes me happy!
Mine
For voice:
16 Ruby
15 Original You
14 Original Kotori
13 Mei
12 Original Hanayo
11 Kinako
10 Current Kotori
9 Nozomi
8 Ayumu
7 Current Hanayo
6 Kanan
5 Current You
4 Keke
3 Kasumi
2 Mia
1 Emma
By favourite
13 Ruby
12 Ayumu
11 Hanayo
10 Kinako
9 Kotori
8 Kanan
7 Mei
6 Nozomi
5 Emma
4 You
3 Mia
2 Keke
1 Kasumi
It surprised me that I ended up putting the Niji pure voices so high... their voices are nice.
13. Hanayo (Current voice)
12. Kanan
11. Nozomi
10. You (Mid voice)
9. Mia
8. Kotori (Current voice)
7. You (Original & Current)
6. Ayumu
5. Kasumi
4. Ruby
3. Kotori (Original voice)
2. Hanayo (Original voice)
1. Emma
RIP the blissful OG voices of Kotori and Hanayo, you are missed.