I love that its mostly Shuhua who covers her parts, but I kinda wish that in Moon they would've given that line literally to anyone else except for Minnie considering her line distribution in that song is practically already a minute long
I agree! I was quite surprised to see that but still Minnie did a really great job for this part. They probably chose her because she has a similar part in the song and her voice suits it. Still, they could've chosen Soyeon because she has a similar part too, and she has like 6 seconds of lines in that song so I really don't know why...
@@borachic Well, in Soyeon's case I actually understand why they didn't choose her. And that's because she most likely won't agree to it. Soyeon wrote Moon as her way of saying that sometimes she just wants to disappear and hide away from the world. So she purposely chose that her ONLY line in that song is at the very end. It's actually a somewhat genius move from Soyeon. And of course I completely agree that Minnie completely rocked those parts. It just would've been nice to hear the other members' voices more in that song.
Shuhua in Hann (Alone) actualy gave me goosebumps. Taking up extra lines in that song after she got so much hate, as well as finally having lines in Senorita which she originaly was afraid of due to the HANN backlash, this girl is so brave! She has come so far!
Soyeon pernah mengatakan hanya suara miyeon yang tidak bisa dia tiru dengan benar.. karena miyeon memiliki ciri khas yang sangat kuat (power vocal)..itu artinya suara yang lain memang terdengar mirip apalagi shuhua.. dulu sewaktu ot6 ketika aku hanya mendengar audio aku sering salah aku kira soojin ternyata pas di konser atau stage performance itu adalah shuhua seperti intro lagu luv u
I love how they all cover the parts, But Literally something feels missing, No one can do it like Soojin,her charisma,her grace,her voice. It just hits difficult
what I noticed in the line redistributions: 1. if the line is naturally sexy, Shuhua gets it 2. if the line is partnered heavily with dance, it goes to Yuqi 3. if the line has to be fierce, Soyeon sings it 4. if the line must be a killer moment, minnie gets it 5. Miyeon is yet to receive lines from Soojin's old parts.
You know, it might be because Soojin used to sing verses, while Miyeon is queen of pre-chorus, chorus and have some bridges, but not verses at all. Or her parts are more close to Soojin's, and that's why she can't sing them
Ot5 did a great job covering soojin part and I am happy that they atleast gave more to shuhua cuz she deserves these lines. But honestly no one will ever do it like Soojin did, she was fabulous on stage and I hope that she will continue solo or even go back with Idle
I can't believe the Main Vocalist: Miyeon, didn't get more line. She is probably the only main Vocalist in any girl group who isn't number one in line distribution. You never see Wendy from Red Velvet, Siyeon from Dreamcatcher, Swan from PURPLE KISS, Ella from PIXY ever in middle or last in their songs, overall. Like I know their is a difference between Main & Lead but I mean, come on, Minnie or Soyeon is always #1.
I don’t agree, it’s pretty common for main vocalist get less lines. Examples: Lia from itzy, jihyo from twice, ningning form aespa. They all get less lines even though they are main vocalists
Miyeon and Minnie are both main vocal with different tones. One will always have more lines than the other + Miyeon's voice is not that suitable for Soojin's parts they have such a different tone that's why they chose someone else for those parts.
thats cause soyeon is smart and knows her members voices, she picked those who can fit the lines best, thats why shuhua got most since her voice is almost identical to soojin.
Soojin always will be in my heart like on of my most loved bias, but i will never end supporting (g)i-idle as 5. And if Soojin will come back to continue her carier, or just to say good bye to us, then that day will be always in my heart, just like her. We love you Soojin and we will love idle too till the end
If I ever meet Shuhua I will just tell her that by covering Shuhua's part she's proving that she's good at singing live along with dancing, like I want her to be confident and satisfied with her work, she's amazing and Im sure Soojin is very proud of her. I really like Shuhua and I realized that her hair are beautiful
Love the girls all 6 of them! Bit cube when u take soojin out of lion and senorita its not the same- Of course ALL the girls nailed it but soonin had that touch ❤️
I would have liked to see Yuqi with Soojin's part in Hann. Her deeper vocal at 0:37. Of course, I will never complain with a Minnie vocal. And Soyeon having the part "I may turn violent" is a YES QUEEN moment. Shuhua did well! Miyeon is a queen even though she didn't get these parts. I wonder what the line distribution looks like now.
Missed opportunity in OT5 5 Lion. Could've had the 5 girls sing the last "Ba Ba Baa. Looks like a lion, I'm a queen like a lion" line. Also Soojin did nothing wrong. OT6 in our hearts.
They always look so sad during her parts and it breaks my heart, but it also makes me so happy to see how much the members of g(i)-dle love and support one another.
yes i love that shuhua finally has a lot of lines and her voice is oh so pretty but.. it can’t help but feel wrong :( *6 was a perfect number for gidle*
No wonder Miyeon blinked so fast in that one interview with them when their interviewer said "blink if you're getting mistreated", they didn't even give a single part to her 💀
But I think it’s more because their voices are really different and it would be harder for Miyeon to cover Soojin’s lines And she also got Soojin’s part in i’m the trend even if it’s not in this video
How I wish their prod/ mgmt gave them enough “boom/ oomph” effect in their concert. Like there’s not enough stage props and mostly these 5 girls are left on stage which makes it empty or too spacious for them. C’mon cube ent, give these girls a good stage for their tour. Even here in the ph, their rumored concert loc can only hold 2000+ pax. A price for a concert but venue for guestings 😕 Neverland and these girls deserve better.
I’m not saying others are not good ,but soojin’s voice some how feels like a hook to allure you . That feeling is so different and sexy !! I just miss her so much😢😢😢😢
i can imagine miyeon singing soojin's lion parts would be much better along with sharing some with shuhua. i LOVE shuhua's part in uh oh and yuqi's dance break in uh oh
They can't replace Soojin with Miyeon voice cuz she has the exact opposite voice of Soojin which has breathyness and Miyeon has Powerful and Bright Tone~~ i still wish miyeon got more lines tho
雖然她們做的很好 但沒有誰能取代誰 每個人都是獨特的風格與魅力 有誰能穗珍平反 還她一個公道？難道她只能帶著莫名的恥辱度過她的一生… 잘 지내고 있지만 누구도 대신할 수 없는 스타일과 매력은 누구에게나 있다 누가 수진을 갱생시키고 그녀에게 정의를 줄 수 있을까? 그녀는 형언할 수 없는 부끄러움으로 평생을 보낼 수 밖에 없는 걸까... Although they are doing well, no one can replace anyone. Everyone has a unique style and charm. Who can rehabilitate Soojin and give her justice? Could it be that she can only spend her life with inexplicable shame...
They did but I already put those parts in a video cause they had performed them in January ruclips.net/video/sx4NR_kuDGs/видео.html There is also Oh my god and Latata there and at the concert they performed Luv U and I’m the trend but since I couldn’t find clips of both I’ll probably just put them in a part 2 when I find some
i just miss soojin :(( i was going to stan g idle right after i heard hwaa and senorita but it was already too late because soo already left, i mean sure i can still stan the group but i wanted soo to be there so i didn't stan them but they're still on fire tho
you’re right, she was a really good member to the group, but just like you said, they still do great music. if you need to know anything about (g)i-dle, just ask me!
I wish Soojin back in the group we are all disobedient and rebellious during our younger days everyone deserve a second chance I’m sure that soojin had already did some self reflection let’s pray for soojin
The public doesn’t know, but a few weeks ago a friend of hers said that she is doing well That’s unfortunately the only real update we had of Soojin since she left the group, hopefully we’ll know more soon
I cant watch this, I didnt watch this last year because I dont want see a 5 membered gidle. I really hope that CUBE let soojin back. Im gonna cry, can Soojin came back please. 🥺😭😭😭
i don’t want to make you even sadder, but i don’t think she will come back because i personally don’t even know one case of an idol coming back to a group, also because cube is the worst company ever, (i doubt they could make something like that) and because soojin maybe doesn’t want to be an idol anymore. let’s still support them because even without soojin they make great music.
2018 (Girl)I-DLE , 2019 (QUEEN)I-DLE , 2020 (Goddess)I-DLE , 2021 (Legend)I-DLE . to be more , the flame 🔥 must be returned to the Group . only the Great Power ⚡ of the Group , can bring back the Legendary flame 🔥 of the Group. we await . i see the Power ⚡ of Soyeon , i see the Heart ♥ of Minnie , i see the Soul of Yuqi , i see the Charm of Shuhua , i see the Beauty of Miyeon , i Feel the Flame 🔥 and Fire 🔥of Soojin in all the Members Hearts ♥
I love how they gave it shuhua cause honestly I think it’s only her who do soojin Justice (not hating on the others ofccc). But in other songs they should consider who had already have more lines and give soojin’s part to those who have less lines
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Part 1: ruclips.net/video/sx4NR_kuDGs/видео.html
You can comment if you want to make subtitles in another language!
I love that its mostly Shuhua who covers her parts, but I kinda wish that in Moon they would've given that line literally to anyone else except for Minnie considering her line distribution in that song is practically already a minute long
I agree! I was quite surprised to see that but still Minnie did a really great job for this part. They probably chose her because she has a similar part in the song and her voice suits it. Still, they could've chosen Soyeon because she has a similar part too, and she has like 6 seconds of lines in that song so I really don't know why...
@@borachic Well, in Soyeon's case I actually understand why they didn't choose her. And that's because she most likely won't agree to it. Soyeon wrote Moon as her way of saying that sometimes she just wants to disappear and hide away from the world. So she purposely chose that her ONLY line in that song is at the very end. It's actually a somewhat genius move from Soyeon.
And of course I completely agree that Minnie completely rocked those parts. It just would've been nice to hear the other members' voices more in that song.
I hadn’t realized it. I agree
i feel like shuhua or yuqi couldve done it and slayed
Was Minnie closes to her in the choreography? That could also be a reason
I miss Soojin😭
I’m so freaky fishy fishy Kazuna
Me too😭
Its just different without her. Her voice was one of my favorites in the group. I really hope she can redebut as a soloist.
Same.....
Same
I really like how Soyeon sings what used to be Soojin’s part in Lion. She makes it fierce lol
I agree she is the perfect member for this (other than Soojin though)
She already sang this part once (You Heeyeol's sketchbook)
@@its_tomtrn127 do you mean in her solo performance?
@@MidnightBard She did a solo stage of Lion
Shuhua has such an unique voice just like Minnie she can transform her voice to match with the music
✨versatile range✨
No matter how different they sing the songs I always hear soojin in my head especially señorita, soo owns that song.
always 🥺
Forever and always
Always
i miss soojin so much, but the girls especially shuhua did such a good job of covering her
Shuhua in Hann (Alone) actualy gave me goosebumps. Taking up extra lines in that song after she got so much hate, as well as finally having lines in Senorita which she originaly was afraid of due to the HANN backlash, this girl is so brave! She has come so far!
I've never seen Miyeon sing Soojin's line before. all four of them sang. but the most is still Shuhua.
She took Soojin’s part in the second verse of I’m the trend but I couldn’t find clips of this song when I did this video
I think it is because Miyeon and Soojin’s voices are too different. Minnie and Shuhua took the most because they have the same tone
Soyeon pernah mengatakan hanya suara miyeon yang tidak bisa dia tiru dengan benar.. karena miyeon memiliki ciri khas yang sangat kuat (power vocal)..itu artinya suara yang lain memang terdengar mirip apalagi shuhua.. dulu sewaktu ot6 ketika aku hanya mendengar audio aku sering salah aku kira soojin ternyata pas di konser atau stage performance itu adalah shuhua seperti intro lagu luv u
@@borachic ruclips.net/video/V8bh7dxIJzM/видео.html
I’m happy it is shuhua that took over tho
I love how they all cover the parts,
But Literally something feels missing,
No one can do it like Soojin,her charisma,her grace,her voice.
It just hits difficult
what I noticed in the line redistributions:
1. if the line is naturally sexy, Shuhua gets it
2. if the line is partnered heavily with dance, it goes to Yuqi
3. if the line has to be fierce, Soyeon sings it
4. if the line must be a killer moment, minnie gets it
5. Miyeon is yet to receive lines from Soojin's old parts.
Miyeon got Soojin’s part in I’m the trend but this is very true
Miyeon also got Soojin′s part in Luv u
You know, it might be because Soojin used to sing verses, while Miyeon is queen of pre-chorus, chorus and have some bridges, but not verses at all. Or her parts are more close to Soojin's, and that's why she can't sing them
I love Shuhua's voice, she sounds so good ;-;
I will always adore Soojin and I am so proud of the group for continuing strong despite losing a very important member. They are shining.
they did so well, im crying
Me too
2:48 Yuqi's voice in this part gives be goosebumps!
Me too tbh I can’t stop listening to it
Me too! It sounds so good!
Yuqi's deep voice matches the best with Soojin
Ot5 did a great job covering soojin part and I am happy that they atleast gave more to shuhua cuz she deserves these lines. But honestly no one will ever do it like Soojin did, she was fabulous on stage and I hope that she will continue solo or even go back with Idle
I agree 200%
I agree I hope she does so, I really our girl Soojin
Soojin is irreplaceable.
I can't believe the Main Vocalist: Miyeon, didn't get more line. She is probably the only main Vocalist in any girl group who isn't number one in line distribution. You never see Wendy from Red Velvet, Siyeon from Dreamcatcher, Swan from PURPLE KISS, Ella from PIXY ever in middle or last in their songs, overall. Like I know their is a difference between Main & Lead but I mean, come on, Minnie or Soyeon is always #1.
I don’t agree, it’s pretty common for main vocalist get less lines. Examples: Lia from itzy, jihyo from twice, ningning form aespa. They all get less lines even though they are main vocalists
@@joytoken1936 i thought nayeon was the main vocal ahah
She has a pretty different voice from Soojin’s, but I agree she should get more lines in other songs
Miyeon and Minnie are both main vocal with different tones. One will always have more lines than the other + Miyeon's voice is not that suitable for Soojin's parts they have such a different tone that's why they chose someone else for those parts.
thats cause soyeon is smart and knows her members voices, she picked those who can fit the lines best, thats why shuhua got most since her voice is almost identical to soojin.
2:32 we aren’t talking about this enough
So proud of Shuhua she’s doing so well 💜💜💜💜💜
it's so sad that we didn't get to see the ot6 performance of i burn's bsides:(
but the girls slayed
I can't even see them as a group of 5, hearing how they sing the part of soojin hurts 🤧
i kinda wish Yuqi had more of Soojin’s lines but i liked her Senorita cover though🫶
god i miss soojin. i'm so proud of our girls for pulling through and doing so well without a key member.
Minnie covering soojins parts is 🔥 🔥
Hann Alone in the winter sounds more saddest without soojin
so true 😢
Soojin always will be in my heart like on of my most loved bias, but i will never end supporting (g)i-idle as 5. And if Soojin will come back to continue her carier, or just to say good bye to us, then that day will be always in my heart, just like her. We love you Soojin and we will love idle too till the end
So sweet ❤️
I feel the same but couldn’t have wrote it better
omg minnie sounds amazing
Shuhua and Yuqi has lines in Señorita, PERIODT
I reallly want them to perform Maybe live because I want to see how they divide the parts and also because I just want to see it live. 😂😭
They did in I-land
If I ever meet Shuhua I will just tell her that by covering Shuhua's part she's proving that she's good at singing live along with dancing, like I want her to be confident and satisfied with her work, she's amazing and Im sure Soojin is very proud of her. I really like Shuhua and I realized that her hair are beautiful
Love the girls all 6 of them! Bit cube when u take soojin out of lion and senorita its not the same-
Of course ALL the girls nailed it but soonin had that touch ❤️
I would have liked to see Yuqi with Soojin's part in Hann. Her deeper vocal at 0:37.
Of course, I will never complain with a Minnie vocal. And Soyeon having the part "I may turn violent" is a YES QUEEN moment. Shuhua did well! Miyeon is a queen even though she didn't get these parts. I wonder what the line distribution looks like now.
I really like shuhua voice. Its kinda mysterious
Yes I totally get what you say her voice is beautiful and mysterious
Shuhua's English voice is so nice and sultry
no one can do it like her 😭
I miss our girl Soojin, I hope she comes back more stronger
Minnie slay Soojin part in LION😭
when I said that Shuhua should be given more lines, I didn't mean that way...💔
Shuashua smile with soojin:🤣
Shuashua smile without soojin🙂
I miss her so much even though I wasn't here at the time and I can't even imagine how hard is for those who were in the process of her leaving :(
It was hard but here they are, shining!
OMG Minnie - Goddes in Lion. I Need her solo debut so much😍😍😍
Missed opportunity in OT5 5 Lion. Could've had the 5 girls sing the last "Ba Ba Baa. Looks like a lion, I'm a queen like a lion" line.
Also Soojin did nothing wrong. OT6 in our hearts.
They always look so sad during her parts and it breaks my heart, but it also makes me so happy to see how much the members of g(i)-dle love and support one another.
I misss soojin so much i still hear soojin’s voice when shuhua sang her part
yes i love that shuhua finally has a lot of lines and her voice is oh so pretty but.. it can’t help but feel wrong :(
*6 was a perfect number for gidle*
No wonder Miyeon blinked so fast in that one interview with them when their interviewer said "blink if you're getting mistreated", they didn't even give a single part to her 💀
But I think it’s more because their voices are really different and it would be harder for Miyeon to cover Soojin’s lines
And she also got Soojin’s part in i’m the trend even if it’s not in this video
No one can say those parts like Soojin She is fantastic
How I wish their prod/ mgmt gave them enough “boom/ oomph” effect in their concert. Like there’s not enough stage props and mostly these 5 girls are left on stage which makes it empty or too spacious for them. C’mon cube ent, give these girls a good stage for their tour. Even here in the ph, their rumored concert loc can only hold 2000+ pax. A price for a concert but venue for guestings 😕 Neverland and these girls deserve better.
Nobody can replace soojin 😭😭😭❤️❤️💔💔
I love this theme where members with the least lines are getting lines from absent members. Such as Onda from everglow
they have one of the best stylists
this makes me miss soojin:(
I'm crying...
It still breaks my heart
You can tell they’re putting their all in those lines🥲
Of course because it’s (G)I-DLE :)
I’m not saying others are not good ,but soojin’s voice some how feels like a hook to allure you . That feeling is so different and sexy !! I just miss her so much😢😢😢😢
Miss her🥺
I miss soojin so much, it's killing me
this makes me so sad....
Yuqi covering soojin part in senorita she ate it
DAMN IT I MISS SOOJIN 😭😭😭
#justiceforsoojin miss u soojinnie 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
miss her
So sweet that they fit her parts perfectly, so sad they have to cover up the fact that Soojin has ever been part of (G)I-DLE
I really hope she is doing well wherever she is and whatever she is doing
i can imagine miyeon singing soojin's lion parts would be much better along with sharing some with shuhua. i LOVE shuhua's part in uh oh and yuqi's dance break in uh oh
SOOJIIN 😭😭😭
I miss Soojin but the positive side of this whole situation is that Shuhua received a power up and is showing what he is capable of
they did good but none of them possess the same charm soojin had
I'm Crying While Watching All Soojin's Part i wish she's also Here performing her part😭😭😭😥
They can't replace Soojin with Miyeon voice cuz she has the exact opposite voice of Soojin which has breathyness and Miyeon has Powerful and Bright Tone~~ i still wish miyeon got more lines tho
雖然她們做的很好 但沒有誰能取代誰 每個人都是獨特的風格與魅力 有誰能穗珍平反 還她一個公道？難道她只能帶著莫名的恥辱度過她的一生…
잘 지내고 있지만 누구도 대신할 수 없는 스타일과 매력은 누구에게나 있다 누가 수진을 갱생시키고 그녀에게 정의를 줄 수 있을까? 그녀는 형언할 수 없는 부끄러움으로 평생을 보낼 수 밖에 없는 걸까...
Although they are doing well, no one can replace anyone. Everyone has a unique style and charm. Who can rehabilitate Soojin and give her justice? Could it be that she can only spend her life with inexplicable shame...
This maketh me sad.
Minnie is the best option for cover Soojin’s lines
soojin te extraño vuelve porfavor
Crying
Didn't they include Dumdi Dumdi and Hwaa in the setlist?
They did but I already put those parts in a video cause they had performed them in January ruclips.net/video/sx4NR_kuDGs/видео.html
There is also Oh my god and Latata there and at the concert they performed Luv U and I’m the trend but since I couldn’t find clips of both I’ll probably just put them in a part 2 when I find some
I like it but it wont be the same without our queen T_T
i just miss soojin :((
i was going to stan g idle right after i heard hwaa and senorita but it was already too late because soo already left, i mean sure i can still stan the group but i wanted soo to be there so i didn't stan them but they're still on fire tho
you’re right, she was a really good member to the group, but just like you said, they still do great music. if you need to know anything about (g)i-dle, just ask me!
I wish Soojin back in the group we are all disobedient and rebellious during our younger days everyone deserve a second chance I’m sure that soojin had already did some self reflection let’s pray for soojin
You’re right, even if these claims are probably false, if they aren’t, she deserves a chance
I really miss soojin, does anyone know where she is now?
The public doesn’t know, but a few weeks ago a friend of hers said that she is doing well
That’s unfortunately the only real update we had of Soojin since she left the group, hopefully we’ll know more soon
@@borachic Hopefully she comes back to industry and kick cube's ass.
Thank yoU!
Miss soojin😣🥺
I love the Shuhua cover the most bc we know how she was so close to Soojin and have similar voice but this makes me miss Soso so much
I would love if they came to Brazil...
I cant watch this, I didnt watch this last year because I dont want see a 5 membered gidle. I really hope that CUBE let soojin back. Im gonna cry, can Soojin came back please. 🥺😭😭😭
i don’t want to make you even sadder, but i don’t think she will come back because i personally don’t even know one case of an idol coming back to a group, also because cube is the worst company ever, (i doubt they could make something like that) and because soojin maybe doesn’t want to be an idol anymore. let’s still support them because even without soojin they make great music.
@@borachic yes of course ill support them. Just feels sad that soojin is not with them anymore. But i still like them, still my favourite kpop group.
3:20 shuhua empieza a decir seo soojin, soo soojin....... llora¨*
SHE SAID SONG WOGI
It's probably just because of the concept, but they look sad to sing Soojin's lines in some of these
2018 (Girl)I-DLE ,
2019 (QUEEN)I-DLE ,
2020 (Goddess)I-DLE ,
2021 (Legend)I-DLE .
to be more , the flame 🔥 must be returned to the Group .
only the Great Power ⚡ of the Group , can bring back the Legendary flame 🔥 of the Group.
we await .
i see the Power ⚡ of Soyeon ,
i see the Heart ♥ of Minnie ,
i see the Soul of Yuqi ,
i see the Charm of Shuhua ,
i see the Beauty of Miyeon ,
i Feel the Flame 🔥 and Fire 🔥of Soojin in all the Members Hearts ♥
This was a good opportunity for shuhua to get more lines
was she ever proven innocent? 😭
Not like officially but classmates and people found multiple arguments
@@borachic oh ok
كلهم قسمو أدوار سوجين بينهم إلا مييون😭
Ahhhhhh soojin
so basically everyone but miyeon
Okay but Yuqi covering Soojin's parts omg
ຄິດຮອດsoojinແຮງ😭
Original still the best:)
I love how they gave it shuhua cause honestly I think it’s only her who do soojin Justice (not hating on the others ofccc). But in other songs they should consider who had already have more lines and give soojin’s part to those who have less lines
In Moon I found it really strange how they give Soojin’s long part to Minnie who already had a big part of the lines in this song
So I guess Shuhua simply lip syncs to Soojin's lines. Soojin's recorded vocals are very audible when Shuhua performs to them.
Is not the same they can cover her part but is not the same I miss my baby 😔😔😔😭😭😭