Why Have Ceasefire Negotiations Over Gaza Repeatedly Failed? - Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июн 2024
- What is standing in the way of reaching a ceasefire agreement between Hamas and Israel?
We spoke to author and Palestinian academic, Dr Azzam Tamimi, and Daniel Levy a former Israeli peace negotiator, on why they think ceasefire negotiations over Gaza have failed thus far, and what each side actually wants?
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
US is a spokesperson for Israel. US is not a mediator.
Exactly that is the main Problem
Hamas don't have no choice they don't have no allies except protestors and pity from college kids. Sympathy can only go so far till that turns to hatred from the pariah stubborness
@@DMC1982 the US runs the modern world, even if they ain't the mediator they will have the last word. U can comment all day about Zionist and the US bad, but at the end of the day the funding needs to get to the Palestinians with US dollars 💰
US is a stra-tegic to Is-rael.
Honestly I knew that it was going to happen. I asked how can USA be a mediator when they obviously support Israel, and they will be 100% bias on the negotiation deal.
Stop the genocide
They won't. Don't even think about it.
It's not as easy as that.
US has never been a honest broker in the Israel / Palestine two State Solution.
The US can't simultaneously say they want a two state solution while vetoing full UN membership of PaIestine and not recognizing the state of PaIestine.
Or anywhere else for that matter.
Clinton was though but his time was cut short
Let's not forget how they supported aprtheid here in South Africa, throughout all the years. Only when pressurred did they suddenly preetend to be on our side all along. The US is a deemonnic country.
@@TD1237agree along with the.Uk they are an obnoxious regime 😡
Anthony Blinken lies openly and thinks we don't know that he is lying. That makes him blind to the truth.
Blinken looks fraught with guilt as he literally makes a killing continuing the status quo with his company WestExec
Blinken is like a stupid magician who believes his own magic tricks 😂😂😂 *we see the string, dummy!*
He Knows. He doesn't care...
Free palestine
Which bit isn’t free?
@@martynanstis1620 Westbank East Jerusalem and Gaza genius!
@@DMC1982 wrong. Not been in Gaza since 2005. As for Jordan its joint run by PA and Israel as a result of conflict. Take your tears elsewhere
The big liars in the world
Biggest
@@Eli-dt6fn In all of history!
Who?
Ysraël doesn't want peace they want unconditional surrender...playing the blame game since 1967.
When the world deliberately fails to see who the real villains are.
Then who's
The Israelis. The Palestinians want their freedom and dignity like any other human being would. @@ssekibalahassan1612
Such a shame, U.S. has lost all its credibility during these 8 months. I look at U.S totally different. Very sad indeed.
I never liked them. But this event confirmed all susspicions and sealed the deal. I'll never forrgive them for this.
Sorry, but they had no credibility to lose.
Only eight months ago.
It lost it the moment America was created via the genocide of the Natives.
One colonial state, will ALWAYS assist the other.
oh no what will they do without user I23918 support
Really appreciate Daniel Levi's honest opinion..He seems to be serving humanity
Huge respect for Daniel Levy!
There has never been a possibility for ceasefire..Israel sees an opportunity to cleanse GAZA and repopulate with Israeli settlers..
😂😂😂Nonesense.
Selling gaza real-estate to settlers in the US
Xactly Bibi was offered 2 times but he refuses cuz he wants to demolish Khamas n 🇵🇸he will never achieve his mission 🤨
@@Imaan815Breakthrough News has a video of all the times ceasefire was offered by Hummus. Over 10 offers were rejected. Let's also not forget the 4 UN resolution ceasefires vetoed by the US.
@@MysteryFaceXand the “ceasefire” USA agreed on, was only good for Isr@31 and a temporary one
Hamas wants a permanent ceasefire and Israel totally out of Gaza. Israel/US want a 6 week ceasefire/hostage release and then the continuation of the war/killing and destruction. Which one is more humane? The Hamas proposal.
Shaitabyahu is a psycho!
@@silviehaqiqi-activist9499Yes, Benzion Mileikowsky truly is.
How is permanent ceasefire different from a ceasefire? And how is permanent ceasefire different from a peace deal ending all hostilities.
Israel hasn’t been in Gaza since 2005 so what’s your point. Hamas invited Israel back in after 7th October. As is usual in wars beware you don’t lose what you have.
@@martynanstis1620 repeating a lie does not make it true.
Thanks for another great piece of independent fact based journalism
Why on earth would any Palastinian believe Israel and America ? Belies belief !
I wouldn't and I'm an American. They lie to us about every single thing.
Why on earth should Israel or America believe any Palestinian?
Yes, my dear brothers, my beloved Palestine is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it contains Al-Aqsa, the third holiest place for us Muslims in Palestine. Bethlehem, the cradle of Christ, is a blessed land, and it is the holy land, and it has been our land for tens of thousands of years, and it is the land of the Canaanite Arabs, the original Palestinian people, and they have lived in it since the Islamic conquest in the era. The Umayyad, Abbasid and Ottoman Arabs, Muslims, Christians and Jews are like brothers and neighbors under Palestinian rule to the owners of the land, but the Zionists came and the British occupation brought them to our land as compensation to the Jews for what they did to them Hitler. The question here is that who did the Holocaust, the Germans, why do I, the Palestinian Arab, pay the price? Why not Germany? Why do I, the Muslim, pay the price for crimes? Committed by the Germans and Nazi Europe, fascism is the root of all evil in the world. Our problem is the occupation❤Palestine is an area of more than 27 thousand square kilometers and is on the borders of Egypt and Jordan, which historically is part of Palestine and the people of Jordan, more than 70 percent of whom are of Palestinian origin, but Britain made them a state and brought agents to the Jordanian ruling dynasty in order to rule Jordan and protect the occupation from the Jordanian-Palestinian people Palestine Its capital, Jerusalem, is the land of the Palestinian people for tens of thousands of years. It is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it is the third holiest place for us Muslims. It is a land where most of God’s prophets lived, were born, and died. It is the holy and blessed land and the land of the Palestinian and Arab people. Muslims, Jews, and Christians lived there for thousands of years as neighbors and brothers before the Zionists occupied our land. Britain brought them in the Balfour Declaration to occupy our land. Those who committed the Holocaust against the Jews were the Germans and the West, not me.
How wonderfully & accurately put. My meager observations do not nearly paint the picture. Thank you.
True words spoken. This is all true. Shukran
When its holy land to most of the worlds populatione you should Think that instead of dishonering it by fighting everybody would respectfully live in pease
@@l.s68Vous n'avez pas honte de faire semblant de ne pas comprendre !
Son pays où vivaient des juifs, chrétiens et musulmans d'origine palestinienne est envahi par des européens, des russes, des maghrébins, des américains,...sous pretexte qu'ils sont juifs, par culture!
Les philistins, actuel peuple palestinien est le véritable peuple hébreu par le sang.
Lisez le livre de Shlomo Sand , historien et chercheur israélien " Comment le peuple juif fut inventé ". Vous apprendrez bien des choses...
Sending all my love to Palestinians! Free Palestine! May there be peace, equality and justice! ☮️❤️🇵🇸🇵🇹
Because GAZA HAVE OIL, DUH!
😂😂😂
@@honeyho9890true face? No more whining about oct? So called self defence? Evil creeping out.
....and natural gas
nonsense Gaza has nothing
Apartheid Israel must end. One state , democratic, with equal rights for all. No supremacy allowed!!!
Too late for this, they’ve had since 1948. They have no intention of getting on with their neighbours.
Hamas and Their followers aka palestinians do not want that
@@l.s68says who?
@@l.s68Actually, they've openly said they want this, numerous times.
Democratically, the Palestinians will vote for an arab apartheid over the Jews under your solution.
Blinkin is extremely uncomfortable with this entire situation and it shows. He didn’t sign up for what’s going on. He’s a terrible liar
He is not comfortable not because he has to lye but because his lyes are exposed.
Thank you middle east eye and it's broadcasting .
we have not heard from Netanyahu directly so there is no deal
Extremely informative......
thank you
Because Israel have never wanted peace with the Palestinians and seeing as America is so deeply invested in Israel, nor did they.
That is true on the Palestinian side as well. Both parties wants a single resource which cannot be shared.
Begging them not to murder civilians. Wow. Only when you're not whyte...🤔
Blinken enjoys his fortnightly trips to Israel too much to end this
Strength to the resistance. Love, peace, equality and freedom for all Palestinians ❤😢
what has i brought them look at the 75 years
The ironic issue is that Rabin never had the intention of honoring the treaty or allowing the palestinians any rights. That was just theatre. But even that was too much to accept by israel and that resulted in assassinating Rabin.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Blinkered Blinken is a bad Jew...how he claims to be neutral in these talks is beyond reason
Can you imagine dying with those kinds of crimes on your heart and hands?
Everything they are doing leads to what the world already knows & sees & its coming from them, from their words & actions. Not to mention the fact that they must love what is happening & what they are doing if they recorded themselves mocking their suffering & crimes & war crimes against them. They want us to believe what they are doing is justified when the intent is nefarious & there is an agenda but yet we need to have sympathy for them when they dont have real sympathy for what they are doing to Palestinians. If its not true. Why so much destruction & so many deaths?. Why mostly women & children? Why steal & destroy homes, schools, hospitals, books, places of worship, businesses, contol movement, kill & exucute unarmed children & people, why are there mass graves with signs of people tied up & buried alive?, why arrest children? Why kill journalists, aid workers & UN personnel? Why shut down news agencies? Why destroy land they use to farm & try to make a living? Why put the on "diets"? & control what can come in for them along with water & electricity? If its not true what is it? What is this & what does it mean because people with common sense know what this is.
Well said, thank you
Stop paying taxes.
Thank you for your work
Free Palestine
Which bit isn’t free?
Brilliant talk.
No one is stooping the i$rahellis that why they continue and get away with it time and time again
Because the Arab leaders wants Hamas to be destroyed and don't care how many Palestinians are killed
you cant expect truth out of any of them
Philasteene❤️❤️❤️
"white man speak with forked tongue"
Good one 👍
Thank you gentlemen ! 🙏
U know they make that up completely. The delay helps to keep the destruction going
Criminals aid the Criminals
On this day of arafat I ask for mercy for the Palestinians and success
Netanyahu's pride is taking like pharaoh. Hamas is an idea which is even born with young generation he can't uproot
There have always been organislzations with this idea - that humans are equal and lives cannot be owned. Hams is just another example. As you said, they cannot uproot this. ❤
I don't understand why if Israel sincerely intends to eradicate Hamas in Gaza, civilian innocent people children and women cannot be evacuated to some safety place in Israel? It rather looks like as a collective punishment than a war with Hamas if even no attempts were made to prevent unnecessary casualties.
IDF, Israeli Demonic Force
You realise how stupid your solution sounds?
Did the Soviets evacuate Germans to Russia when fighting the Nazis?
The responsibility to take in Gazan refugees doesn't lie on Israel, it lies on Egypt
@@user-kf8fl5rm3s please explain to me how a someone in Gaza gets to Egypt. Through what path do they take, and how much $$$ is it to cross, im sure Idf just let you go right through to Egypt even if they were taking in refugees
@xIcyStarzz-yz7my the idf has no interest to prevent refugees crossing to Egypt, and it was never proven otherwise
How does anyone know if the people evacuated don't have radicals within the group?
Great analysis
Deceit and dishonesty from Izrahell? Surely not!!
Very well explained. These past Months and the actions of the occupiers have changed everything. Why havent these war criminals been stopped already. It speaks volumes to the World and all humanity. Free Palestine and Return All there land and Property. ☮️❤️🌎🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
When Netanyahu Israeli has accepted cease-fire , where , and how ? Surely , not even when Unied States proposed cease-fire being debated at United Nation Security Council session. Only what the people hear is the same words from Yetanyahu as Blinken : any cease-cease would come only after Hamas defeated ( surrendered ) and lay down their weapons , as simple as that! ' But, remember, as Charles Darwin said : " It's not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but the one most responsive to change ." Dinnosours ( the fittest )could not survived so as conservative ideology and slavery .
Wow fantastic analysis
The Americans always have 2 scripts , 1 for the world as PR exercise , 2 is between itself and its allies ……
Very good coverage. Honest reporting
Hope is just a word , how could US agree with peace which its existence drains on that war , but imperialism doesn’t know that this is the end
Words matter - stop calling this a war!
😮😮😢 🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥Does anyone else find it interesting that you cannot spell Israel without the letters L-I-A-R-S 🤔 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
You can't spell Palestine without the word L-I-E either.
Your point?
@user-kf8fl5rm3s Can U or someone please explain to me again why no European nation including the US wanted these people in their country before during and after WWII????? What did they know that we are now finding out???? 🤔
@The-Man-Right-Chea factually it is incorrect.
But that lie you spread, is irrelevant now, let's focus on the present.
Why does no Muslim country want to take their Gazan brothers??? Can you explain to me why could it be?
@@user-kf8fl5rm3s 😢😢😢😢😢😢 Can we now get interviews from Palestinian Hostages that were kidnapped before October 7th that caused Hamas to launched the rescue mission on October 7th to free them????
In answer to 3 common questions.
1 important to rememberit was zeonists nobody wanted. Jewish people who follow Torah/Talmud are not zeonists as Torah/Talmud say it is only the messiah who can lead Jews into israel and it should not be done by force/war. Jewish people, Rabbis and Holocaust survivors are protesting against zeonists treatment of Palestinians and have been for a long time. zeonist israel are the naazis of today.
2 why should Palestinians be taken in by any other Arab country? Why shouldn't Palestinians stay in their own country = Palestine? Arab countries know that zeonist israel want Palestinians to leave so zeonist israel can steal more land and never let the Palestinians back to Palestine just like what has happened for over the last 70 plus years.
3 before the zeonist israel arrived, Christians, Jews and Muslims lived in peace in Palestine in a thriving society. There is even black and white filmed footage from that time to prove it. zeonists wanted to set up their own state and first thought of Africa, then when that didn't work out they thought Argentina then when that didn't work out zeonists came to Palestine where they have behaved like thieves and robbers ever since. zeonists even made agreements with the naazis in ww2 and have obviously taken the German nazzi playbook as their own. zeonist israel are the naazis of todays world.
Who would have thought that some of the countries who fought against the naazis in ww2 to stop a holocaust would be supporting a Holocaust (as defined by the dictionary) today. I never thought Christians who say they follow Christ's teachings would be standing up to support a Holicaust/genocide which is the opposite to what Christ taught. zeonist israel is slowly corrupting as much of the world as it can and needs to be stopped.
Well said and observed there is no real negotiations turkye russia china brazil should join the peace table . USA is not neutral party .
So what do the honest actors and especially the victims do?
This is the best video I have watched that explains the conflict and the only solution to peace but in the long term and not now due to the people in power!
12:34 الحمدلله
Because negotiations never even took place 😅😅
Never ever let the US become a peace broker in any conflict.
👍🏽 Good comment, however, there is no country called América listed in the Organization of the AMERICAN States ( O A S)
You use the Eurocentric, Anglo centric, misnomer to call "America" to the United States, as is listed in the OAS.
Oh yeah, Israelis want peace. Piece of this land, a piece of that land, and big piece of all of Gaza
Agree. That’s exactly what they want. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
WHEN HAVE THEY...TOLD ANYTHING THAT WAS THE TRUTH.
WHY IS ANYONE BELIEVING ANYTHING THAT THE OPPRESSORS ARE SAYING EVER?????
Great content, great analysis of what is going on.
TLV is making the Strip inhabitable
Some 75% of its population don't want 2 States, side-by-side
❤❤
Excellent analysis of the events.
Thank you for those who bring peace to the world.
In the UNSC the US said Israel accepted the plan. So what are the implications of that?
they have been lying all the time, if not why did the US vetoed numerous times…
*The US said it.
@@edgarvonboltzmann7465 Yes
♥️🙏Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Yeah , is his ceasefire negotiation could have achieved if we could do the same to Tel-Abiv , what's happened to Gaza.
Then they will be more than eager to have a ceasefire.
This is excellent.
No PRIDE in Genocide Pray for Peace for all mankind ❤
Shame
Im going to agree with Hector and Mustache...
Subhanallah
What a mature insightful analysis s if Teo brillant minds ,one an Israeli and a Palestinian .they talk about cease fire and end of the occupation of Palestine !
The Israeli newspapers Jerusalem Post and Haaretz News asked then-Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in 2012 he had said: “Israel will end in ten years.” The question was raised after a 2012 New York Times report quoted former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger as saying that “support for Israel in the United States is waning and Israel will cease to exist in the next ten years.”
thats the problem people are still living in the past
That's easy they both hate each other
Because Blinken and Netanyahu want them to.
THE RESISTANCE NEEDS ONLY PORTIONS OF ITS LAND-1967 BORDERS AND THEY WILL NOT SURRENDER THE THE LOSES ARE GETTING MORE TERRIBLE ON BOTH SIDES
Why? One word and his name begins with B
Excellent dialog, we should practice commonsense.
Better UNO deal negotiation for ceasefire instead of warmongers.
The history of black America does not end
Why was this deleted off instagram
Since when do the losers get to decide the terms of a ceasefire?
Who built Genocide pier ?
MEE, please do stories on Gaza 2035 project and the Red Sea Project.
I can't see why these projects are not major news items anywhere. They all know about it. The names of the projects keep changing to throw off the average person. Putin shakes hands with MBS, Zelensky shakes hands with MBS. These projects take years of planning before they are built. Investment companies, engineering firms, labour and equipment need to be organised, therefore thousands of people are involved. Supply of building materials etc, etc. These are all organised years in advance.
It’s theatre for their own populations and audience. There is no serious intent to bring about peace by Isreal/US. Same for the two state solution which practically would never work I.e. one being a dominating aggressive neighbour and the other being weak and probably not allowed to acquire weapons or military.
🎉
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
No comment, that way I won’t be censored.
“nous avons une ambition sans limites, une cupidité dévorante, nous sommes acharnés à une vengeance impitoyable et brûlante de haine.” »
Because of America
america is as much a mediator for israel as saruman is a mediator for sauron
Because they keep trying to draw all kinds of proposals that guarantees an Israeli victory
I agree with Levy. It's deceitful. It should be a ceasefire period and the US should and can make it happen. Stop the killing of Innocent Palestinians it's not only Hamas it's the Israeli as well.