Definitely agree with the boring voices in the lower category, Mandarin dubs have a lot of those. I agree with the comment on Putonghua Mulan so much, she's fitting because she's not just a typical girly voice, she sounds so emotionally invested in the song, I absolutely love it. Hahaha, "heh, bullshit", that was funny! Definitely feeling your top 8, especially your number 6, she wasn't that high in your Anna ranking and I wasn't expecting her to get so high :D When I think about it, I feel like the gloriousness in the Chinese Mulans was sort of recreated in their Elsa's. Cantonese once again brought a solemn voice that isn't technically that powerful but still brought a lot of emotions to the table, Mandarin brought us a great-sounding voice that may not fit as well as much as she just kicks ass in singing the song, and Putonghua brought a deep, mature, sophisticated voice that is also one of the best fits for the character. What a coincidence! Miriam was very surprising, but a very emotional and good one! And yeah, I was expecting Wei Na to be first, she's among the likes of Arabic and Czech that would get so much more credit in my new Elsa ranking. Sucks that you don't have access to the internet, hopefully it'll be okay soon!
+Leonardo Ayala Wow you actually dropped a bomb on that comparison... the three Mulans and Three Elsas! The strange, soft one, the suiting, simple one, and the pop-styled one who owns the song.
Even though Liu has a very sleepy sound in her voice, I think that's a characteristic of her performance, her voice still sounds a'ight on Ariel's face. As for Li Xiao, I almost doubt she's the same singer as Ariel....there must be some confusion, it's impossible for me to believe that a voice can transform that much....same for Liu XiaoYun, Belle & Ariel are poles apart. And can I attempt to guess what bothers you in Shennio? Because, maybe its the same thing that bothers me, and that is the autotune, the high treble used in the mixing, it ends up sounding too robotic, ignoring that, I think Shennio's version is amazing. Nice top 3... :)
+rishabhrox1 Nah I love Shennio's voice in general but really it just doesn't sound IN THE ZONE you know like.... Coco Lee, Gisela, Marsha Milan, Rita, it's all those pop-type voices that might not make the transition so well into being the character, and for Shennio it's not a matter of emotion but just the fact she doesn't have the broadway belter style that the character usually has, even tho some of those like Idina and Mona Moor aren't so well-loved.
Liú Xiao-Yún ??? Ma Yù-Fen Chia Alyssa Yáng Kun Wáng Huá-Yí Yè Bei Li Xiao-Xiao Màn Xuan Xiao Chén Xiù-Zhu Liú Xiao-Yún Shin Winnie Li Xiao-Xiao Liu Ray Lin Shennio Wáng Lì-Huà Lee Coco Jiang Du-Huì Hú Wéi-Nà
Oh, glad to see your opinion on Mandarin voices, though I already feel I'm gonna disagree since nobody likes Mandarin voices and that you don't like young voices that much. Last place, first disagreement x) Well, the whole ranking is a disagreement, except for one or two voices lol x)
+charguigou I kinda had 'sorry charguigou' on my mind as I made this lol because I know you really like my bottom two! I'm not sure if we agree on much other than Shennio, I enjoy her performance.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
In memory of Coco Lee, her voice of Mulan in Mandarin Chinese will still be remembered for her impressive voice and performance. 🕯🙏❤️🎤😭🕊
yes RIP she was a hit and way young to die :(
@@raneemacintosh6842 Didn’t expect at all for hearing those tragic news. I’m going to really miss her. 😢
Definitely agree with the boring voices in the lower category, Mandarin dubs have a lot of those. I agree with the comment on Putonghua Mulan so much, she's fitting because she's not just a typical girly voice, she sounds so emotionally invested in the song, I absolutely love it. Hahaha, "heh, bullshit", that was funny! Definitely feeling your top 8, especially your number 6, she wasn't that high in your Anna ranking and I wasn't expecting her to get so high :D When I think about it, I feel like the gloriousness in the Chinese Mulans was sort of recreated in their Elsa's. Cantonese once again brought a solemn voice that isn't technically that powerful but still brought a lot of emotions to the table, Mandarin brought us a great-sounding voice that may not fit as well as much as she just kicks ass in singing the song, and Putonghua brought a deep, mature, sophisticated voice that is also one of the best fits for the character. What a coincidence! Miriam was very surprising, but a very emotional and good one! And yeah, I was expecting Wei Na to be first, she's among the likes of Arabic and Czech that would get so much more credit in my new Elsa ranking. Sucks that you don't have access to the internet, hopefully it'll be okay soon!
+Leonardo Ayala Wow you actually dropped a bomb on that comparison... the three Mulans and Three Elsas! The strange, soft one, the suiting, simple one, and the pop-styled one who owns the song.
Even though Liu has a very sleepy sound in her voice, I think that's a characteristic of her performance, her voice still sounds a'ight on Ariel's face. As for Li Xiao, I almost doubt she's the same singer as Ariel....there must be some confusion, it's impossible for me to believe that a voice can transform that much....same for Liu XiaoYun, Belle & Ariel are poles apart. And can I attempt to guess what bothers you in Shennio? Because, maybe its the same thing that bothers me, and that is the autotune, the high treble used in the mixing, it ends up sounding too robotic, ignoring that, I think Shennio's version is amazing. Nice top 3... :)
+rishabhrox1 Nah I love Shennio's voice in general but really it just doesn't sound IN THE ZONE you know like.... Coco Lee, Gisela, Marsha Milan, Rita, it's all those pop-type voices that might not make the transition so well into being the character, and for Shennio it's not a matter of emotion but just the fact she doesn't have the broadway belter style that the character usually has, even tho some of those like Idina and Mona Moor aren't so well-loved.
Liú Xiao-Yún
???
Ma Yù-Fen
Chia Alyssa
Yáng Kun
Wáng Huá-Yí
Yè Bei
Li Xiao-Xiao
Màn Xuan Xiao
Chén Xiù-Zhu
Liú Xiao-Yún
Shin Winnie
Li Xiao-Xiao
Liu Ray
Lin Shennio
Wáng Lì-Huà
Lee Coco
Jiang Du-Huì
Hú Wéi-Nà
Oh, glad to see your opinion on Mandarin voices, though I already feel I'm gonna disagree since nobody likes Mandarin voices and that you don't like young voices that much.
Last place, first disagreement x) Well, the whole ranking is a disagreement, except for one or two voices lol x)
+charguigou I kinda had 'sorry charguigou' on my mind as I made this lol because I know you really like my bottom two! I'm not sure if we agree on much other than Shennio, I enjoy her performance.
+Ranee L MacIntosh (Roro) Haha don't worry I understand ^^
Mulan 1998.🇳🇱
Love
Elsa
Mulan
Pocahontas
The new Ariel
Cinderella
Rapunzel
Tiana
Anna
Both Belle's