Personal Ranking: Live-Action Jasmine

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 янв 2025
  • I didn't think I cared about this character enough to rank, but I got a lot of requests and questions on if I would, so I did it! I'm glad I waited so long - many of these voices were newcomers back then, and have since been seen elsewhere.
    I also appreciated Speechless more when I discovered that meeting Aladdin and going on the carpet ride happened BETWEEN part 1 and 2 - I think the whole 'falling in love as a catalyst for change' is a great development for a character and having a love interest inspire a character to be strong is WAY BETTER than "she's a strong woman, she doesn't NEED a man!"

Комментарии •

  • @AnmoKRSo
    @AnmoKRSo 27 дней назад +1

    *DID SOMEBODY SAY JASMINE??? 😍❤*
    I wouldn't expect a ranking from you about Jasmine, to be honest! However, I agree with some choices, while some not (including the top 1) but I wanna thank you for 7th place! Alexandra really was a great casting choice for Jasmine (tho I love the whole Romanian cast of this movie).
    I'm wondering what's your next video gonna be about.
    Either way, keep it going! 😅

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  27 дней назад

      @AnmoKRSo I am working on a language ranking for a language I have not yet ranked!

  • @poisonivyYT
    @poisonivyYT 4 месяца назад +1

    Brooooo what, I can’t believe I’m seeing a live action Jasmine ranking from you.
    It’s been so long since I paid any mind to these voices so my opinion is extremely vague, but eeeee at Romanian’s placement, she’s still my favourite. I love how my flat out last place is among your top 3, that’s what is so fascinating about rankings - you get new perspectives on voices. Your first place was surprising mostly because I had totally forgotten about her existence and I couldn’t for the life of me figure out which version it was going to be when I was approaching your #1, but I agree it’s a wonderful version

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  4 месяца назад

      @@poisonivyYT yeah in my early brainstorm days I saw your rank which had my 2nd fav right at the bottom so I forgot about her for a bit.... she was SO CLOSE to being #1

  • @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ
    @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ 5 месяцев назад +3

    YOU RANKED HER!! *WHAT* ?!?! I would have never expected this ranking from you, mainly cause I think I remember you saying that you wouldn't 😂
    I always love reading your ingenious and detailed opinions!
    The day the leading female character in a Disney film isn't dubbed by Jasmine Cai in Taiwan, I will be very worried xd
    Even I, a non-native English speaker, have caught the Broadway enunciation thing. It was present until Frozen (Kristen Bell, at least, had it, Idina, she pronounced many things weirdly, so idk), then Auli'i kinda had it in some points, then they forgot about it in all of the following movies (Live actions and animated)... And wish is just insane omggg I kinda die when I try to imagine this pop sounding accent if it was in a Spanish dub, noonononono plz I'm praying it'll never happen 💀
    I love the german singer's voice so much, but I get what you mean, though the only vibrato that bugs me stratospherically is a type of kinda operatic vibrato, that sounds as if you were cutting it? Like metallic... And quite forced. It's actually quite similar to Halle's, it shares this watery characteristic, but I actually really like hers...
    I love the Czech singer so much... She's just so full of passion and strength, she's incredibly emotional whenever she needs to, and she's the one that moves me the most in this song!
    I insanely agree with what you explained about Monali and Shuang... They are my big favourites here just because of the emotional depth of their performances. They sound so tormented yet mentally strong in a way that's indescribable.
    Your top 10 is filled with gems, I love it so so so much, I LOVE all of them, I think I am you, you are me, literally the same top 10, then you add Mandarin, Hindi and Czech as the extra cherry on top and you have it :D
    Thanks for Castilian! People usually don't like her that much, so it's cool to see some appreciation 🥲

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад +2

      @@ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ i think I'm a bit biased on the Spanish dubs bc I first worked on this before and after my Spain trip, but I think they both have character! I see some resemblance in Czech to one of my fav czech voices, Elsa, but a bit less stable so she couldn't end up on top.

    • @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ
      @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ 4 месяца назад

      ​​@@raneemacintosh6842 I agree! They both have more character than the animated ones imo! I also believe that she sounds so alike to Czech Elsa (who I love so much as well)! BY THE WAY, I don't want to pressure you in any way, but in case you'd like to participate, you have until *September 3rd* before the Princess Games close!!!

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  4 месяца назад +1

      @@ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ omg forgot about it this year. I'm actually away from my microphone now until September 1 so it's not looking good LOL

    • @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ
      @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ 4 месяца назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Nooooo 😭 You will be missed :____)

    • @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ
      @ALEX.GARCIA_DUBZ 4 месяца назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Anyways, it's already closed 😂😭 I misread it as 3rd and it said 31st (August) 💀 You can vote now if you want, tho, Felicia has just uploaded the videos with all the auditions 😱

  • @dasn4
    @dasn4 5 месяцев назад +4

    Live-actions rankings are becoming a thing now, nice. Naomi being that low shocks me, but I agree, her voice is quite average, despite her high vocal range. Thanks for Castilian, never saw her high!

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@dasn4 i don't care much for these movies but it does give us a whole new set of voices for songs and characters we already know - quite easy to rank because of that

  • @denkleinriderii8872
    @denkleinriderii8872 5 месяцев назад +4

    Ooooh Miranti Anna wins !! Yeaaah so glad !! And so glad for Ukrainian too. Always a pleasure to read your precize comments !

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@denkleinriderii8872 I had SUCH a hard time choosing between them!! I think both could have been #1

    • @denkleinriderii8872
      @denkleinriderii8872 5 месяцев назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Oh I imagine yes !

  • @rishabhrox1
    @rishabhrox1 5 месяцев назад +1

    yessss! I was actually REALLY waiting for this ranking of yours.
    Okay, agree on most low places, kinda surprised to see Hiba THIS low but then, it is true that her vocal performance was not REALLY up to the mark, the struggle in her voice was real.
    I actually thought Ding Shuang would be your #1 at one point cuz she has several of the same qualities as the Russian 1992 Jasmine had, in terms of vocal quality and even the delivery....
    But my biggest happy moment is seeing Sunitha Sarathy where she is! People often get overly bothered by her timbre but I think she sounds very normal. I'm even surprised you mentioned she has some 'Indian feel', because to me as an actual Indian, she frankly sounds SO western, which probably comes off the fact that she trained in Western Gospel music and her voice developed that way. I guess an Indian will sound 'Indian' anyhow, no matter how they train or use their voice HAHA.
    Romanian and Portuguese in the top 10 are a big yes from my side, and of course, #1 is a MAJOR favorite of mine with those riffs and that rustic, full-sounding voice both complementing each other SO WELL in Speechless. Really interesting ranking actually, glad to see the ups and downs of my faves and plenty of surprisessss

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@rishabhrox1 i think perhaps I only said that because of her resemblance to Hindi Elsa! It made her feel familiar

    • @rishabhrox1
      @rishabhrox1 5 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@raneemacintosh6842 haha, I see. In that case I would love to see (if you ever plan to do) a Nala 2019 ranking, cuz both Sunidhi and Sunitha are going to be in it XD

  • @juliapakarinen7956
    @juliapakarinen7956 5 месяцев назад

    Thank you for this great ranking! I have the soft spot for Anni, but I understand your criticism about her. Your top 5 is amazing. :)

  • @PopRock-gl5ey
    @PopRock-gl5ey 5 месяцев назад +1

    Glad you made ranking of these voices!Thanks for 16th Happy to see her that high usually she is so low so Glad to see Castilian so high,she is REALLY underrated next is Belle 2017 Right?

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey 5 месяцев назад

      Or Nala 2019?

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@PopRock-gl5ey belle will not be happening most likely. Can't stand that one.

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey 5 месяцев назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Okay So as Far as I remember you siad to Meirenyu that you are working on 2 rankings that share at least one voic with Asha so this Is the FIrst one and 2nd one would be?

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@PopRock-gl5ey you'll just need to see! Probably gonna put it out in November. Which is actually a very esoteric hint.

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey 5 месяцев назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Okay

  • @chriskdisney
    @chriskdisney 4 месяца назад +1

    Beautiful video ! We mainly have similar opinions on Jasmine. I just find quite funny your comment about Lara Suleiman, as I personally prefer her Jasmine way more than her Luisa, for exactly the same reasons you prefer her Luisa over Jasmine, lol.
    My biggest disagreements for sure here are French being that low and Ukrainian being that high.
    Mirianti is a treasure!

  • @croserbqueen
    @croserbqueen 5 месяцев назад

    I didn't expect to see your Jasmine Live action ranking. Well, we have some agreements and disagreements. Anyway, congrats to the winner. She is not my favourite one ( she is 29th in my ranking), but I love to see how unique and different our tastes are. I love the comments which are so real and honest. I can't wait your Asha's ranking somewhere in the future, especially to hear your opinion about Tjaša (Slovenian Asha) cuz I love her so much, even though I am not sure if she is my number 1.

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад +1

      @@croserbqueen how do you feel about Croatian and Serbian versions of Jasmine 2019?

    • @croserbqueen
      @croserbqueen 5 месяцев назад +1

      Both are amazing, but I prefer Franka here. Franka is in my second place, while Irina is in eighth. Maybe the lyrics also influenced my opinion. The Croatian version feels more natural; the Serbian translation has some odd lines. For example, "grad nad nama nestaje" translates to "the city is disappearing above us." How can the city disappear above them if it's under them? Or "jer živim grlo kad ruka stegne," which means "because I live when a hand tightens around my neck," which sounds super weird. I also hate how they changed the lyrics of "A Whole New World" in Croatian. I always prefer the original lyrics. The worst case was what they did with "The Little Mermaid."

  • @AntymoneczekPL
    @AntymoneczekPL 5 месяцев назад +1

    I never knew Irina dubbed Jasmine in Serbian, but she sounds amazing as always. Will you do an Asha ranking in the near future?

  • @Meirenyu
    @Meirenyu 5 месяцев назад +1

    Hooray a new ranking from you!
    - I'm so sick of Jasmine Cai too 😅she mentioned once in an interview she got cast as Elsa because she took singing lessons with the dubbing director...
    - Interesting where you rank Naomi Scott, definitely agree it's sad to see Disney move away from the articulate musical-theatre styles to trendy pop styles
    - Swedish, I belong to those for who the era has not ended 😅
    - Couldn't agree more that too many dubs make Speechless sound far too angry & aggressive! sure she's advocating for things, but it almost detracts from Jasmine's character
    - Franka, totally feel the same about her too! she objectively is great, but just keeps getting pushed down when you rack & stack
    - Monali, loved your description on her (those are always more interesting than the number itself)
    - Meshi, very surprised to see her so high (same for Korean)
    - Telugu, haha yes she totally sounds like Hindi Elsa!
    - Our top 10s (arbitrary cutoff) couldn't look more different but I loved watching this video! 🩷

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      Thank you for the long comment! I love hearing opinions of the people whose rankings I watched when making mine ha. I think it was in your comment section where I gave a hint at which characters were coming up - was this one of your guesses?

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      RE: English - my favorite new female voice of the past 5 years has definitely been DIANE as ISABELA, who has the most traditionally princess-style voice of anybody since Frozen.

    • @Meirenyu
      @Meirenyu 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@raneemacintosh6842 This was! But I'm curious who the next character will be as I don't know 🤨 yes Diane as Isabela is the best! haha the priness-style voice I still can't fathom you liking is Slovak Anna - that's the one that comes to mind first

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@Meirenyu I had been thinking lately that all my rankings have a wildcard at about 8th place.

  • @Akin12348A
    @Akin12348A 4 месяца назад +1

    Now that there’s more voices dubbed, are you going to do a separate Serbian and Croatian ranking?

  • @angelyphil
    @angelyphil 5 месяцев назад +1

    Such an unexpected high place for Ukrainian 😍 I was a fan of Olha for years, watched her performances on X-Factor, she is very talented opera singer. So I always was a little upset that she's so underrated in fandom☹

  • @stevie6694
    @stevie6694 5 месяцев назад

    i only watched this movie like.. once back in 2020 LOL so i don't have super strong opinions on live action jasmine's voices. speechless is a good song though and i'm really happy to see chinese and italian so high! i think they're amazing. i can't help but hear "HELL YEEEEAAH" in the finnish version. miranti is also really good and i'm impressed that she fits pretty much every single character she plays, even fei fei.
    watching this and the live action ariel rank is really funny knowing that you're not gonna rank live action belle LMAOOO (i don't blame you though. that movie is ass)

  • @hefraindisnerd
    @hefraindisnerd 5 месяцев назад

    Last place hurt my ears lol.
    Although I'm not a fan of this live action movie, rankings of Disney community made me fall in love with the "Speechless" song.
    Thanks for 15th, 13th, 11th, 6th and 3th.
    My version (8th) seems to not be very popular so I'm happy she's great for you.
    I was scared cause I thought you forgot about Olha but then I saw her in 2nd position! YES!!
    I find her extremely underrated by the fandom although I'm really glad that she has been getting more fans nowadays. Her speechless is so soulful and show-stopping with no doubts. Good job!

  • @PopRock-gl5ey
    @PopRock-gl5ey 3 месяца назад

    Haha Swedish comment made me laugh"If you are Stran,Daniela or Snadra hater"

  • @anonymousofwonderland4850
    @anonymousofwonderland4850 5 месяцев назад

    Thanks 17th place!

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 5 месяцев назад

    Well, this is unexpected.

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 5 месяцев назад

    French shocked me more than English honestly. I definitely prefer Hiba so much more than Karine, even though she has her ups and downs, but I like how she's an improvement to the older French voices in which I'm sick of (specifically the cutesy-fake voices like Marie, Maeva, Emmylou, Karine, and so on). As for English, I have a mixed relationship with her. She sounds emotional in Speechless, but so monotonous in AWNW, the result leaves me torn. I actually like Shehnaza's Jasmine, but I agree, Nazerke would've been a better fit. I think I understand what Finland is going for. Anni's voice reminds me of Ulla, who she's grown on me, and while I think it works as I find her AWNW sounding reminiscent to Ulla's version, her Speechless just doesn't work with me. I keep forgetting Natthaphatson's version so much even though she does the job, but imo she's the most forgettable to me. I agree with Russian, I really miss Anna's version, but Kseniya is very nice, just doesn't stand out much to me. I'm kinda tired with Meshi, her best role will always be Rapunzel. Both Castilian and Latin Spanish in Top 10? Surprising placements even though I don''t like them and are in my bottom spots. I feel like Alexandra and Olha are now your new favorite Romanian and Ukrainian voice. Love Miranti, but didn't expect to be 1st place. Overall, great ranking (my Top 1's gotta be China Mandarin.

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 I actually feel the total opposite about French voices! I like a lot of the mid 90s ones like Karine, Benedicte, and Laura Mayne, but recently they've gotten quite predictable. I find for example Anaïs, Charlotte (sequel Elsa), and Océanne are basically triplets, and Canadian soundly defeated France on the new Ariel dub despite being one of the worst in the animated Ariel dubs.

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 5 месяцев назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Well, I'm not gonna include Benedicte and Laura, coz they're definitely in their own league in the 90's. But yeah, French voices in the recent don't really wow me, but I actually like Oceane. And yuh, Canada did over France, not just in the new Ariel, but also the 2010's dubbings (namely Nancy, Chloe, Veronique, and so on).

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      @@elijahmartinobracia4741 its a shame Canadian French pulled back right when they were getting good. Tiana, Rapunzel, and Anna were all great, and more recently Eléonore (Meechee, 2017) and Audrey (Ariel, 2023) showed they've still got it, but haven't dubbed most Disney characters in singing.

    • @raneemacintosh6842
      @raneemacintosh6842  5 месяцев назад

      I think it's a shame they didn't get someone else for Jasmine instead of Hiba in both versions. Even if I liked Hiba a lot, I would appreciate the variety, since she redubbed the song anyways.

    • @elijahmartinobracia4741
      @elijahmartinobracia4741 5 месяцев назад

      @@raneemacintosh6842 Yuh, and I found out that Sofia (the Canadian speaking voice of Asha) dubbed the songs, but they decided to have Oceane's version altogether, wish we could hear Sofia's version tho. Imagine Canada started dubbing way back in 1938's, they would totally defeat France

  • @XRando78X
    @XRando78X 5 месяцев назад +1

    Prediction: #1 Will be Shrek
    Edit: Lame