Makhloev vs Stadnichenko M1 Medieval
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 дек 2014
- Makhloev vs Stadnichenko M1 Medieval
Medieval TV
Махлоев vs Стадниченко бой М1 Medieval
Links:
• Makhloev vs Stadnichen...
medievaltv.ru/
medievaltv
/ medievaltv
donjon_magazin
www.donjon.ru/
Donjon shop of medieval things www.donjon.ru. Everything for Medieval Fighting and historical reconstruction.
"Магазин средневековых товаров "Донжон" (www.donjon.ru). Всё для исторических средневековых боёв и реконструкции". 
Спорт
why the fuck isnt this more popular
B M.C. I totally agree...
B M.C. I am mot rly fan of MMA, but id totally watch this lol
B M.C. My guess is that it feels too much like LARPing. If they are going for historical accuracy... why the ring? If they are trying to advance the art of swordfighting, we have developed better armours and swords now, why the medieval...ness? But I'm gonna watch this anyways. Sports always baffled me, why create this roundabout system of establishing dominance with these arbitrary rules involving balls and goals? Why not just beat the fuck out of each other, that's definitive. Which is why fencing, kendo, MMA, kyokushin, boxing, muay thai, and this (apparently) are the only sports I can get into.
MobiusCoin Well, I reckon I might be able to explain sports. First, back to basics; that hot piece of ass only wants the best example of manliness to be her mate, because he has the strongest genes, which means that the children she bears have the best chance of survival and mating. But how will she know who's got the best genes? Well, fighting's an option, the best fighter's more than likely the fittest and thinks quickly on his feet - both are good traits for a hunter gatherer supporting a family, so the winner's the one she wants. But in a serious fight, the winner could be seriously injured, hampering his ability to provide for her and their children, so we need a non lethal competition. Hence sport. The roundabout rules let us see which group is fitter (and hence has generally better genes for this primitive society), and hence which ones the ladyfolk are better served pairing off with, whilst minimising the risk of debilitating injury.
All this from an extremely underweight neckbeard who can't do sport for shit. I was always a brains over brawn kinda guy. I used to do cricket though, that was fun.
B M.C. because it isn't realistic
This needs to be the world's favourite sport. Forget football (any kind), baseball, tennis, cricket, hockey and all those others. M1 Medieval is a sport I would watch fanatically
This only has to be international to be bigger than baseball so it won't be hard to imagine
Watching men flail at each other with metal swords, without any proper stance or technique? No thank you. I think I'll stick with HEMA.
Back in my day, all you got was a bronze sword and a metal loincloth.
Oh so you were a spartan?
Leave it to Russia to produce the best sport I have ever seen.
i swear i thought this was an asian thing XD
@@hyperpengu8722 lmao
Dark souls pvp in real life
Clearly without enough stats to wield the weapon -__- this is pointless
Need more dodge roll
4:42 for start of fight
This is the most stupidly rad thing I've ever seen in my life, I love it.
It's great how the fighters going into the ring show on their faces they are totally aware of how goofy this idea is, but the people in their corners are dead serious.
You don't seem to be aware how much some of these blows hurt, especially the shield bashes on the helmet. It's not just show and flowers.
Hitting someone with the swords when they're wearing armor seems a bit pointless. I think this is why war hammers and maces were invented.
EGarrett01 Except these swords are blunt and for scoring points. And they dont seem to be allowed to jab and stab with them....
It's weird because it's supposed to represent real combat I think, and non-damaging sword strikes don't seem like they'd matter in a real fight.
EGarrett01 there also trying not to kill each other.
EGarrett01 IRL they would use a sword of this size to stab/thrust at weak points, such as under the arms, around the neck and joints. No way knights would flail at each other with these, they're too small to even dent armour.
They'd either wield a two-handed Claymore type weapon that can dent armour or as you mentioned they'd use a mace or hammer.
TG Morgan Actually sword was more of status symbol than a real weapon, especially huge claymore. During mass battles most used weapon was small axe or mid sized dagger so you can grab enemys armor, lift it up and stab under it. Sword was used in duels, tournaments and small intensity fights where you actually have space to wield it. Also it was more suited for cavalary than foot infrantry.
this is fucked up and amazing at the same time
Welcome to Eastern Europe
are you allowed to end them rightly?
the Mylo What, by throwing your pommel?
+Morrigi192 there is no other way.
Bro I hope so
If they have time to unscrew the pommel
Why the ref isn't wearing armor too, they could accidentally stab ref..
+David Chandra I would at least be wearing a mask. Could easily get a swing in the eye.
It's his own responsibility to stay clear.
+David Chandra He IS wearing armour. Well, sort of.
That red thing he's wearing is a gambeson. Historically, knights wear these under the mail and armour. Its pretty padded and can withstand slashes of a fully sharpened longsword full force.
+Shogun Seva And the weapons aren't sharp, either. Would still hurt and possibly cause serious injury to get hit by it without armor, but it wouldn't kill you. Plus no thrusting is allowed in the M-1 combat, so nobody would get "stabbed".
+David Chandra ''accidentally''
Where has this been all my life.
In Russia
R1 R1 R1
I don't get it.
edl411 for honor
Good ol warlord for me
Man I would be happy to try that,wearing a full solaire of astora armor and praise it when the ref call my name
Where has this been all my life?! This is brilliant!
5:57 "STOOOOOP."
lol
Lol! What the fuck is this? Why are they even carrying swords? I mean, they don't use the swords in any meaningful way. No thrusts, no half-swording. they really care little about defending themselves. They are basically just bashing at each other. They could just as well replace the swords with fucking clubs or something. Or with maces or war hammers. That would actually be historically more accurate and would make a lot more sense.
Probus Excogitatoris If they don't care about defending themselves why are they using their shields?
Probus Excogitatoris this reprtesents tournament fights, which was mostly the same, back in medieval times.
Лев Стонт Okay, I see. Well, then it sort of makes sense. Thanks.
Sam West well, actually this armor protects quite well, so there are very rare cases of serious injuries, I dont't remember any recordings of deathes.
Sam West well, not during battle\fight. Some accidents during festivals, of course occured..
This is epic! I really hope this blows up like mma and end up really incorporating every form of hand weapon based combat. Imagine a samurai there, or someone with a warhammer, or sabers, etc.
ive never been more fucking hype for larping
Can someone tell me more abouth this Sport? Im totaly new here (Like rules or where i can find some live M-1 ore other things thanks)
My god. Is this the greatest sport ever created? Also, excellent use of Judo in this fight; the style was created for use in armoured combat after all.
This is awesome. Its really too bad this isn't a more respected and well known sport. I would absolutely LOVE to see more of this reguraly
it's acually the first time i hear about this discipline, in witch countries is held most?
is the fight in this video typical or are there weight categories, different equipement one can use etc etc?
TheRpggamer91 It started in Russia and Ukraine, but with Battle of the Nations, countries all over the world participate. Look it up.
lol wtf am I watching?
+Jack Troughton God damn puns...
*****
*IRON*-ically
Where are de heath and mana flasks?
so the rules?
seams to be if you take them down you're allowed a couple head strikes before they stand you back up... i assume that reflects negatively in the scoring for the guy on the receiving end?
The one guy doing the hip tosses was wrecking it! He's judo throwing his opponent to the ground, then he smashes his pommel into dude's helmet over and over. Epic.
I want to watch this everyday now.
what s the name of the second song ??? please
Is there tko, ko and submission wins in medieval mma?
Wow this is awesome, this shines a small light on what the real warriors of the past would have faced. Scary to imagine what genuine sword fights would have been.
yeah picture a guy swinging around a sharpened 205cm zweilander.
That's thats the stuff of nightmares
It is very interesting to see, that judo throws are very effective. It shows why they are present in jujutsu for sure, meant to be used against a samurai in armor.
I would love to try this.
Отличный бой!
Why is the guy with the round shield only half armored in the legs? Seems like the sort of thing you would't forget. Also the ref might want to wear some armor as well. And why did he call the fight so soon?
TheMegadethMonk He has armor on his upper legs, it's just padding instead of metal, which is lighter. As for the ref, I believe he has some padding as well.
Are the swords blunt and they aren't allowed to stab?
Yeah, stabbing is to lethal, someone could get seriously hurt or die
Im a huuuuge MMA fan, and this should get right in the ranks! this is awesome and I could see some sick combowombo moves be thrown inn here with the propper training!! Make this viral enough and we will se a sword/kickboxing marshal art form spawning :D (sorry if my english is bad)
Ivan Pedersen this video is disgusting no one know how to use their weapons and they look like idiots flailing around against echo other
meamcatnm I said with propper training!!!
how the fuck do you keep track of scoring
the helmets restrict your vision, which is why there isn't a lot of quick strikes to obvious openings.
*Runescape IRL*
+Salim Al-Jabry a pure on 07 old school
Salim Al-Jabry Well, im lvl 73 with 99 magic and 92 ranged, so you decide.
Salim Al-Jabry I love it, i use blowpipe and barrage. sick nasty
go to os
0/10 did not end him rightly.
+i Neko 0/10 no pommel thrown
+Darcksage not even a attempt at a pommel throw
+Preston Sheppard
0/10 not even 30 full seconds spent in the middle of a fight to unscrew pommel
This is awesome!
I don't get why so many people are complaining. It's basically like what is boxing is to fist fighting.
It's a sport.
wow I didn't know this existed. this is my new favorite fight sport.
How do you score this fight? By the number of strikes unblocked? aggression? ring control?
You get points for weapon strikes, takedowns/knockdowns, and disarms.
New York Knights Combat awesome Id like to try this sport sometime Ive done LARP for 20 years and have 30 pro kickboxing/MMA fights and 6 champion belts.
Вай борцуха, вай братуха! XD Я сначала подумал, он его с лука херачить будет, на канат залезет и с ульты, а тот его сбить попытается, по ногам, вот это я понимаю средневековый бой...
I feel that if the fighters were this armored, wouldn't it be more effective to fight with a heavy blunt weapon like a thick hammer or a large mace? One impact shockwave can penetrate the armor and seriously incapacitate
+H Lim Yeah it would be, and that's why they aren't using them. They can blunt the swords so that they're relatively safe, there's no way to make a mace or war hammer less deadly.
Are maces allowed
Holy crap what did I just watch? That was amazing
And is jabbing allowed??
Who would win in a joust: Cain or Tyson?
I can see now why some historical armies had a spike sticking out of the center of their shields. You could attack and defend at the same time.
What are the rules??
One thing can someone explain how you win?
Solo Waggin Points are given for shield and weapon strikes, as well as takedowns.
Why does the ref keep stopping it??
Are they not allowed to thrust?
The Derp Gaming Extravaganza No, it's based on medieval tournament rules, which banned thrusts due to injuries.
Qual o objetivo da luta? :v
i wouldn't want to have to step in as the ref and have no face mask...
+Jon Malahoff are you stupid? people would die, imagine having a stray stab hit you in the eye, its blunt, but it would still do massive damage
That round shield seems to be making a huge difference
Is this a gameplay trailer for the new Chivalry: Medieval Warfare?
i would say this is more realistic to anything we are shown in movies or game of thrones, apart from there being no sharp sowrds or stabbings allowed, the quickness and that feels insane like watching two knights go at it.
where are the pyromancer?
where has this sport been all my life?
Not gonna lie, that actually looks brutal !
haha joe rogan brought me here
SAME
Which episode?
I hope this sport comes to America. I wanna play. lol
so awesome!
why no one use Half-sword in m1
historically correct or not i personally got a whole different perspective on how these fights would have looked liked. i know its not as nice and clean as they make it appear in the movies, but its way more savage than i previously thought.
Whose idea it was?
The ref really should be wearing some form of plexi-glass visor....
Also they should put roundel into play so that when someone scores a take down they can end the fight with their dagger like a TKO in boxing or a submission in MMA. It would make the take down make more sense and allow for an excuse to let the men wrestle a bit more.
Why aren't they actively guarding with those shields? It's pretty idiotic not to.
Where is the footwork?
CITIZENS OF THE IMPERIAL CITY, WELCOME, *TO THE ARENA!*
This is awesome
I feel this would be more realistic if all the fighters kept daggers as well so if you knock down the opponent you can lift his face plate and end him rightly with the dagger.
What do I you mean, the only way to properly end a man rightly is to unscrew your pommel and throw it at him
Jesus those Shields are more terrifying than the swords most times.
Those swords aren't sharp right?
I honestly don't care if this historically wrong, or if they're wearing light or heavy armor. I find this quite interesting. They must be sweating so much I wonder what type of intense training they had to go through to be on the top spot
this is awesome. I hope this becomes an international thing
only swords? no axes, hammers, maces or morning stars?
what if someone falls on a sword?
What is someone falls down the stairs?
They are not sharp.
Giant49warriors What if someone takes an arrow to the knee?
Alex Maltez Get out of here now xD
jesse rissanen Hahahaha
dont want to sound like a dumb ass but are the swords real or fake?
Real, but blunted to they don't stab the shit out of each other
For once, I'm not concerned about historical accuracy. This is awesome.
Where has this been my life?
I really like the winners shield and brigandine colours.
This could be a bit more popular if there were some more historical accuracy and technique. It appears to me as a back and forth clash of swords. Also I don't see much thrusting( or any as a matter of fact) which may be a rule of the sport, but on history was a staple in medieval martial arts. As stated in historical fighting manuals.
FrewghuArmory This is based on tournament rules, not the battlefield. And, as it happens, stabbing in tournaments was outlawed by the Pope due to injuries. I think that happened in the 11th or 12th Century.
This has potential
At 10:26 those vets are like "...look at those newbs LOL"
Me: I'm gonna go to bed early tonight
Also me:
they are stumbling around alot in this one but not all the matches look like this
Interesting...how the hell do they judge?
Hard hit to body=1 point
Takedown = 5 points
Ez pez
love the sportsmanship
Ex boxers?
Ex boxeadores. Guerreros de época no se moverian tanto por la lona, permanecerian mas estaticos, si no se estarian entorpeciendo con otros luchadores en plena batalla.
LA muerte normalmente se obtenia clavando una daga al caballero derribado a traves de alguna comisura de la armadura, normalmente en la cabeza...un ojo, el cuello... Si no a golpes de maza.
Yikes that guy nearly lost an eye in the hug at the end O.O.
I'm pretty sure the guy who walked in with the bow is a ufc reject
Why is this "Medieval"? It looks like a bar brawl with armor.
The guy in the bascinet couldn't breathe real well by the looks of it. So, he was flopping quite a bit. The other guy was more experienced. Also two different fighting styles: fencer vs grappler.
Looks more like wrestling. Whoever can take down better wins. Problem is some of those sword strikes would be fatal in reality and should be counted as such. These battles likely didn't last long because scrapes, bruises, and gashes would combine to make one opponent weaker and that injured opponent would give way to a fatal stab.
This is the greatest thing since the invention of mma!
Do Samurai Vs. Knight!
If you can find anybody trained as a Roman Centurion or Spartan (sadly I don't think there are such people but if there are) do Centurion Vs. Spartan!
Awesomenerd100 There are.Roman swordfighting and Greek swordfighting (as well Byzantine too) , including the use of other weapons such as spears are taught in Italy by some clubs and in Greece by Koryvantes and Academy of Historical European Martial Arts (which is a HEMA Alliance member and member of Meyer Freifechter Guild)
i know its probably illegal but in the fury of battle,it seems pretty easy to accidentaly thrust a sword up under the helmet and kill your opponent pretty quickly
It really depends, but usually an opponent in armour will be wearing a steel bevor (neck guard) or a mail coif (a mail hood that wrapped around the whole head, leaving only the face exposed), which both protect the neck very well. A sword that has an acute enough point could pierce and burst the mail, but definitely not the plate steel bevor.
Blunted swords m8.
why we didnt see this match on WWE???