It doesn't matter. His accuracy, deep ball ability and smartness is what makes him way better. It doesn't matter the defense he plays, a good placed ball is a good placed ball, its not like he had hours to throw the ball in the pocket or anything.
Please start giving the eagles defense their just do. Cowboys defense still sucks and eagles is much improved that makes anything either QB does judgemental.
Jigolopuff And he danced over those defenses the way you would expect an elite Quarterback to. We beat those teams by a combined 34 points and it should've been more if not for the 4-5 key drops by Celek,Matthews and Agholor.
+That1boi Don't sit up here and compare the bears or Browns defense to a playoff team in Washington or the significantly upgraded New York defense. Two far superior teams, anyone who watches football knows that. The Eagles better be 2-0 playing those shit teams. By the way if Terrance Williams wasn't an idiot there's a good chance Dallas would be 2-0.
+Hakurei Oni you're gonna sit here and honestly say the redskins aren't better than the Browns or Bears? I'm just gonna end the comment right here because that's completely asinine. And by the way, dak should've had two touchdowns but Cole and dez dropped them, how is that his fault? His stats are superior to wentz and Carson has played terrible teams while dak played the early division leader and last years division champ. Say what you want, the division was awful, but the redskins still won it, something the Bears and Browns haven't done in however long.
Why is this even a question? Imagine Wentz behind that Dallas O line and with those receivers??? He would look like that next Tom Brady... Wentz is leap years ahead of Dak Prescott
Passes of 15 yards+ Dak: 5 Wentz: 16 Touchdowns Dak: 0 Wentz: 3 Interceptions Dak: 0 Wentz: 0 Numbers don't lie dak has been a game Manager imo an wentz had no oline or #1 WR Give him dez Elliot witten best oline in the NFL he would be 10x better then he already been
I get that it makes a debate better when the two disagree, but if you have to say "I'm right" and "you know I'm right" every time you debate, then you begin to lose credibility.
Only reason Dak isn't airing it out more is because the Cowboys playcalling is conservative AF. They're trying to keep the ship afloat until Romo comes back where they believe they can make a run in the playoffs like they did in 2014. Eagles aren't really playing for much at this point in time, so they're much more willing to let their rookie QB air it out. Don't forget that Dak had multiple long TD passes in the pre-season, so it's not like he lacks the ability.
I was unsure until i read your comment. I think your assessment is more than likely correct. Im a Dallas fan but i didnt just side with Dak i really thought about it and still was unsure. I dnt like the idea of waiting on Romo though.I was hoping he get hurt early so Dak and get more reps early before the playoffs.Now your ruining my hopes of Dak staying in.
+jgyrwa Dakota and D. Mcnabb will have a great deal in common... Jerry wanted Paxton Lynch but got Prescott instead see where a top Secret Qb takes the Cowboys.. Lynch maybe too fragile for the NFL like Mariota
eagles airnt playing for much? boy you better take off them glasses because the eagles are playing for the playoffs. if wentz had the offense line and weapons that day had this wouldn't be a question. 3Passing Td to 000000Td why is this a question?
Alex Lopez I hear you. My point is that the Cowboys are quite literally in "this is it. All or nothing." mode. They can't let Dak take huge risks because they want to return the car to Romo in the best shape possible, you know what I mean? As for the Eagles and the playoffs, I know they also want the best for the team, but I mean *every* team wants to make the playoffs. If they don't make it this year, then it really doesn't matter as much compared to a team like the Dallas, because the Eagles have a young franchise QB who they know is going to take some time. Whereas with Dallas, this might literally be the last year they even have a shot to be a legit playoff team, Romo might be done after this year. It's 2 different philosophies. The Eagles are in: "Hey this Wentz kid is pretty good and we have a good defense, so let's see what we can do this year, because we're only going to get better." Whereas Dallas is in: "We can't fuck this year up, because it's most likely going to be our last shot for several years." All I mean.
u are exaclty right play calling is conservative asf and dak has thrown plenty of deep ball touchdowns and yea it might have been pre-season but everybody does not seem to relize that he played against starting defense's in the pre season and not to mention he played in a very difficult confrence in college which is the SEC and he took a sorry ass school to #1 in the nation at one point
i didnt see dak once pressured in the pocket he hasn't even got a scratch on him on the other hand you got carson wentz completing a pass while a defender is in his face carson wentz has been nore pressured nd has thrown more amazing than dak and dak facing two tough teams really? giants defense was in last last year and redskins are a tough team this year really the redskins are just as trash as browns gtfo
All i see everytime i watch him is having a lot of time in the pocket with the best oline in front of him rewatch both their games abd see who had more pressure on them while completing passes i didnt see dak once get hit hard come on now carson wentz had a tougher time in the pocket while completing throws while defenders were literally tackling him hard
Skip is right. C'mon, the eagles played the browns then the bears, the cowboys played the giants then the redskins. Dak has better stats. Nuff said. Wins mean nothing because you need a team.
Prescott has had a whole preseason to prepare while Wentz was named the starter 8 days before the season began. Considering all circumstances Wentz has been more impressive.
wins mean nothing? really they why play if wins don't mean anything. the cowboys played the giants and redskins not elite teams by any means...wentz has better but its close
I will go with Dak Prescott he played against 3 tough defensive teams. The Hawks in pre-season, New York Giants, and Washington Redskins. Two of the teams which are in they division, also losing by only 1 point against New York Giants. Although they only scored one touchdown against the New York Giants. Only thing Dak need to work on is switching up plays in the redzone.
The Giants are an ok team. He lost to an ok team. It doesn't matter whether it was his fault or not he still lost. The Redskins suck and he beat them in a close game.
everyone is talking about wentz being 2-0 and not mentioning the fact that they only gave up 10 pts to cleveland and 14 to Chicago. Dak has kept the opposing offense off the field and the Dallas D still can't stop anyone. Carson does look to be the better pure passer but as a whole I'm going to have to say Dak.
cowboys had all the pieces in 2014 to make a run, they were lucky to win their first round with bad officiating against the lions and it came back to them in green bay so to that point, when has eli even remotely had someone close to a 2,000 yard rusher to rely on?
I haven't paid much attention to Dak, but the only thing I'd argue Dak has over Wentz from a QB stand point is maybe mobility, but even that's up for debate. Also up for debate is if the Redskins and Giants are really THAT much better than the Browns or Bears, because from what I've seen, none of them are playoff caliber teams. Here's what I see: WENTZ: 2-0. DAK: 1-1. WENTZ: No star receivers. DAK: Has Dez Bryant. WENTZ: O-line not the greatest. DAK: Best O-line in the league. WENTZ: 3 TD passes (no turnovers). DAK: 0 TD passes (no turnovers). Also, I'd like to note I haven't seen Carson make a single stupid pass yet. The only bad decision I've seen from Wentz is not protecting himself on a scramble. Granted, I haven't paid attention to Prescott play, so I don't know how we'll he looked on the field and how smart he was with the football, but Wentz was practically flawless. Skip says he's not bias, but I have to call bullshit.
Wentz will make mistakes, I understand that, but we here in Philly now have a franchise QB who will lead us to playoff victory's and that's all I want. I want a chance, a shot a hope for a ring. just hope. thank you football gods for blessing us with Kid Carson
Lol, he plays the Browns and bears both top 5 worst defenses in the league and now you are talking about him winning games in the playoffs!?!?!!? You are deluded boy
Let's see how he comes out against the steelers this week, boys gonna look shook. Dak has already played winning teams and handled them to the same degree as wentz if not better. Also, if you watched football at all you'd know dark had two passes dropped that would been TDs week 1. One of them was to your boy dez Bryant.....
Yah. A rookie receiver doing well is seen every year. A rookie QB doing this good is a completely different ball game. If Wentz even has just a good season and Sterling has a breakout season, Wents will still win ROTY.
This has to be Wentz, hes transitioned into the NFL from the FCS, albeit half a preseason game, just like that. Hes audibling nearly every play, like a new peyton manning, thats all my comparison is.......calm down. Sure hes overthrown a few balls and underthrew a big one last night to Agholor, but hes also delivering pinpoint passes that have been dropped, like J Maths, for sure TD if he actually caught the ball. He also needs to learn to slide and make sure he gets outta bounds, cause some of those hits he was taking, for literally nothing, was making me hold my breath. Yes his first two games were against the browns and bears, but I seem to remember, people doubting him before the browns game and even more before the bears game. The guy literally doesnt go anywhere without the playbook to study it, every halftime hes got it right in his hand, I mean you cant teach that stuff, hes got an amazing demeanor............Ill leave it at that, yes I am an Eagles fan.
I don't get what the point of this argument is? Like who cares? Both are playing well for rookies let's talk end of season who had the better year. It's only been two weeks
Wentz played against a T E R R I B L E defense game 1 Plays against a bottom level defense. Dak game 1-Plays against a supposedly top 10 defense No ints. Dak game 2-against a decent defense on ROAD AND DIVISION RIVAL throws dots. Dak all the way.
The skins and Giants stink too! The Giants and Redskins are bottom 10 defensively. And without a QB, the Cowboys offense is much better than the Eagles. Not throwing a single TD pass against these bums with an offense as good as the Cowboys is pathetic for even a below average QB.
Dak should have had 2 TDs against the Giants why are people blaming him Dez had the ball and dropped it & so did cole Beasley that's not his fault he did his job
Not even trying to be biased here, but wentz looks like the better qb. He is calling audibles and throwing the ball down the field with a shitty online and average at best receivers. Dak looks ok not even great to be honest. He is really just dink and dunking passes. There is a reason why wentz went 2 and dak in the 4th round. Might not matter in the future but right now it def looks like it.
The eagles have one of the best Olines Wtf are you talking about? You don't even know your own team LMAO. You guys have a top 10 Oline with peters and Johnson
No we do not have one of the best onlines . Lane Johnson seems to struggle without his peds and Jason Peter's is old and lost a step. Our line is far from one of the best. Did you watch the game last night ? Penalty all over the place.
we'll just wait and see when my boys play you I think dak is better he has no interceptions and already has a game winning drive under his belt this offense is for romo but will soon change
Dak isn't dink and do king you goof, watch the games instead of talking shit, Wentz played 2 of the worst defenses in the entire league while Dak played 2 pretty good defensive sides that are also divisional opponents
Wentz is better.. end of story.. cowboys could be 0-2.. and Dak is playing too conservatively and didnt show much.... Eagles won convincingly and has less weapons around. Carson reminds me of young Brady with legs.. I see huge upside but still early so we will see..
Lol at young Brady, and they say Cowboys fans are delusional. Your boy has played against the Browns and the Bears....its early for this talk but you're running with it as if he's played against elite defenses.
eazy, did you see when wentz EMBARRASSED the steelers who supposedly hv/had a top notch D? ...... not sure how you can even form the words you did. How is it "delusional" for fans to think he's a potential Brady? What argument do you hv?
I'm a cowboy fan, but right now Wentz has the wins and the TD passes. we'll see during the season and at the end but Wentz is in the lead. love me some Dak though
they're both playing pro football players and are both doing well, but until Dak gets some TD passes and more wins, Wentz is objectively in the lead. i think Dak is awesome and will take the lead, but it's still early
Dak should have had 2 TDs against the Giants why are people blaming him Dez had the ball and dropped it & so did cole Beasley that's not his fault he did his job
Dak is where it's ak. Dak is a 4th rounder that nobody saw coming, Wentz was hyped up 1st round, a 2nd overall selection. Dak stayed in college for the full 4 years, while Wentz played 3 and was redshirted. Wentz had an easy game against the Browns as Dak played against two divisional rivals which is big in my eyes. Dak also broke an NFL rookie record of no turnovers in a debut. Dak all the way!
iTz_BBoy7 Dak has a higher QB rating then Wentz. It's only a matter of time that Dak will get his touchdown passes from the likes Dez Bryant and Jason Witten. The only way to resolve whose better, is by the first game that they face each other. Remember Dak is 4th rounder with nothing to lose while Wentz is the 2nd overall draft pick with a lot of hype. The 'Boy's didn't overpay to draft their quarterback unlike what the Eagles paid to gwt Wentz.
And if you've paid attention to the pre season leading up to the regular season you'd know and realize all those picks the eagles gave up to get wentz the eagles got back. You wanna know who else has a high "qbr"? it's tony romo how many playoff wins does tony romo have? I mean surely qbratings get wins(sarcasm). Like sharpe said that's all that matters in the end is the win and cowboy fans seems to care more about a qbr than an actual win? really that is a joke!
Also to add the cowboys have more talent than the eagles but you guys cant get at least one touchdown reception from qb to wr in 2 games really? dez bryant hasn't caught anything in 2 games dak has noooo touchdowns but a high qbr?
iTz_BBoy7 The Dallas coaching staff hasn't opened up the play book for Dak. Garret and Staff have to feed Dak more plays to open up the Offense. Give it time because Dak has a lot of time on his side to explode as a fine game-breaking quarterback Dak has a higher QB rating because that stat is based on pass completion percentage, yards, tds, and interceptions, all the criteria Dak has meet with the exception of touchdowns
Wentz actually throws it down the field. Has way less weapons than Dak. Does he have any turnovers? He actually has touchdowns. I think they'll both be solid though.
The Cleveland Browns and Chicago Bears will be lucky to win 6 games this year. Carson looks like the better passer but Dak is better overall and has played tougher opponents
Based off what I seen so far in two games its pretty close but Dak has play tougher competition so I'd give him the edge and he looks to have the higher ceiling. Also look at how they both performed in college, but you can't go wrong with either.
And also the cowboys haven't really let Dak open it up yet as far as the plays and letting him throw harder passes which everyone knows he's capable its just the cowboys coaching staff playing conservative safe ball.
Cowboys have a potential top 10 offense while the Eagles have ass receivers and mediocre running backs. Wentz making them better. Dak playing with great players on the other hand.
Skip does nothing but contradict himself. In an argument he just had in reference to Rodgers vs Brady, he clearly made a point to say QBR was meaningless, a "made up stat". Yet now, when it's Prescott vs Wentz, he does nothing but lean on it. Dude pisses me off.
Wentz all day. Prescott throws twenty 5 yd passes to Beasley. Padding stats. Wentz throws deep balls in the basket. If not for dropped passes... I'll wait
If Garret would open up the playbook lil more then Dak would throw deeper more but Dak has thrown a few passes that was over 10 yrds its not Dak's fault garret is too conservative
Wentz has had to face zero adversity in his first two games and like they said played the 2 worst teams in football. We'll see who he is against the Steelers this week. Dak clearly has the advantage right now. Also Dak almost threw for 300 yards against Washington and Carson threw for 190 yards against the sad Bears D.
Have to go wentz even though dak is putting up numbers he hasn't even thrown one td pass. What makes their game so different is that Wentz is calling audibles, picking up the blitz, getting passing tds(even with the sorry recievers). Dak is good but his game needs alot of work reading the plays, and his passes aren't that accurate. But Daks mobility is great.
This is exactly what I see. People think we are being biased but it's the truth. Wentz is a really smart kid. Straight A student 4.0 gpa. And is an athlete. This is why I'm more impressed with Wentz. Either way it's to early to know what these qbs are gonna turn out to be. Cowboys really got lucky with dak. Because they didn't even know he was gonna what he is. Eagles did what they had to do. Can't blame them, and they got their picks back for the Wentz trade.
Carson is very intelligent he got a 4.0 in college he is a brainiac dork with those glasses but who cares he plays the game tough. He is more intelligent than Dak who got into a parking lot fight with drunks before being drafted. look it up on youtube Dak fights.
Dallas has better receivers right now. if you add up all those drops from week one that were put on the jersey numbers and then those two drop last game for big yardage trust me Carson is better like 100 plus yrds better. Dak still hasnt passed for touchdown and the only time it comes close is when he throws a jump ball for Dez Bryant that dosent take skill or accuracy. two bread basket throws by carson week one and two drops that were perfectly thrown week two. please.
+Mooreville Middle school ... Does anyone in our division have a front 7 like us? .... That's all I need to win this division. Cowboys defense is garbage, giants defense is still being built up & the redskins defense is about as good as the cowboys defense.The best Defense will win this division.
I like Carson Wenz....he has poise and is able to audible. The problem with Wenz is he is reckless with his body. I like both but from what i seen from Wenz is impressive.
+Sidney Williams the eagles has a defense the cowboys dont dak prove he can lead his team in the 4 quarter if wasnt for sorry as williams we will be 2 and 0 wentz aint did that yet as far as play calling the cowboys want let dak throw it down field he can as we all seen in preseaso he can throw the deep ball so dak is better
Wentz has yet to play a quality CB or pass rush. Wentz also played the Browns and Bears, two of the worst teams in the league. Dak had TD, but were dropped.
Carson has had several "would-be" TDs that were dropped. Skip said, "Carson has no pressure at all," which is just ridiculous. Skip hates the Eagles and LOVES the Cowboys, he should not have any say in discussions about the NFC East, because he can't keep his fanboy down.
Gabriel if you watched the game yesterday Wentz actually had so much pressure and took so many hard hits and still completed tough passes so he actually has faced good pass rushers
Dez would've dropped Carson's touchdown passes just like he dropped Dak's in week one. If you gave Wentz Jason Garrett as a coach as well, he would be playing much more conservative like Dak is.
Both these QB'S are going to be good. I had thought Dak Prescott was the Best QB coming into the draft yet he didn't get picked until the 4th round. I think Dak will be the Best QB in that division about a year or two from now. but I agree with Tony Romo being inserted back as starter once he is healthy.
Dak should have 2 TD passes on the books. It's not Dak's fault that he didn't have any passing TD's in week 1 against the Giants. 2 of our receivers DROPPED 2 TD passes! Dak can throw a pass to a receiver, but he can't make them catch it.
jdac22 if that is the case then Carson should of had 4 TD's last night..... There both good but Carson is more accurate right now Dak has thrown a lot of balls short
Lol "1-1." Yeah, so I guess Carson Wentz is better than the likes of Cam Newton and Aaron Rodgers now. Give me a break. Copy and paste Dak Prescott into the Eagles and let him play CLEVELAND and CHICAGO and tell me he wouldn't match Wentz's stats. Not to mention the Cowboys' overly conservative play calling.
I'm an Eagles fan and I think Pittsburgh will win myself, but you're avoiding the question. Dak is a game manager, Carson has all of the intangibles necessary to win games with a work ethic to boot.
Alright then, well here's my answer. If Wentz does what he's done against the Browns and Bears against the Steelers, who's arguably the best team in the league right now, then fine, I'll say that Wentz is superior. But as of now, I don't feel he's earned that title yet.
Dynamic_ And I'll be completely honest as well: I'm not going to crown Wentz the next Favre because of his toughness, the next Peyton because of his ability to read the defense or the next Romo because almost every pass has been a perfect strike. The potential to become one of them is there. I don't see that in Dak's play.
Both Dak And Carson are gonna have great careers in the nfl i think we can all agree on that. I have to give the edge to Dak Prescott. It's because he was a fourth round pick. Carson wentz was the second overall pick so he has huge expectations on his shoulders.
These guys are my favorite sports analysts. They don't talk out of their ass, and actually support their words with facts. unlike some people over at ESPN...
Dak is not a run first QB. In 4 games he has ran it 12 times and Wentz in 3 games has ran it 9 times. Dak played against way better players in college but had way better stats. Wentz has only played 3 games and people act like he is the best rookie they ever seen. People forget including pre season Dak has played 9 games with no interception and playing at an elite caliber. Not to mention the QB for the Dallas Cowboys is one of the most high profile stressful position in any sport and he is handling it like a champ many can not handle the role. Its a reason why Beasley is a top receiver this year so far. People need to stop using Dez as an excuse of why Dak is playing good because every other receiver has more catches then Dez. Dak is beating Wentz in almost every stat. Dak has a higher Completion % , in 4 games he has 1,012 passing yards. Wentz has 769 in 3 games so he would have to pass for over 243 yards against the lions to beat Dak. Dak QBR is 86.6 and Wentz is 68.9. Dak Avg. 7.73 yards per catch and Wentz Avg. 7.54. Dak has more rushing yards, yards per carry, and rushing TDs. The only reason he has not had more passing yards is because we run the ball in the touchdown more, plus over 15 pass was either drops in the TD, the TD was called back, or the receiver got tackle less the 5 yards from the goal. Wentz is simply playing at a level you would expect a 1st round draft pick to play at. I mean who can't do dump passes and screens to people like Sproles as he get 20+ yards after the catch. Eagles has one of the best tight ends in football and nobody on the offense is a scrub so they obviously have weapons. Eagles line is real good in fact they have protected Wentz better then the Cowboys line. Dak has been pressured 16% of the time and Wentz 8.1%. Dallas line run block really good but there pass blocking is slightly above average I can name plenty teams with better pass blocking like the EAGLES, Patriots, Green Bay, Saints, Falcons, Denver, Raiders, Bengals, Giants. Dak is playing above what would be expected of a 4th round draft pick. Wentz was a 1st round pick that knew he would have the starting job. Dak came in as a 3rd possible 4th string and had no ideal he would start until the first game of the season. Wentz is good but I give Dak the slight edge.
Talk about degree of difficulty....dak plays with the best o line in football with dez at receiver and elliot at running back while Wentz plays with patchwork o line butterfinger receivers and Ryan mathews
Are people really predicating who is better based on TD passes? Dumbest things I've ever heard considering Dak should have two touchdown passes. Hard to say who is better right now. I think Wentz has a stronger arm but Dak is more accurate. Two weeks won't determine anything. Let's see how they are playing 4 weeks from now.
As a Dallas fan, Wentz is far ahead of Dak as a QB. Dak's success has been more about the Cowboys coaching staff putting him in the best position to be the ultimate. At the beginning of this season I said that the Cowboys don't need Dak to win games. They just need him to not lose them. He's done just that. He's the future but they've shown that he's got more developing to do than Wentz. His collectiveness is off the charts but he's not the passer or the field general that Wentz is. His deep ball isn't quite there and his back shoulder needs work. Wentz is already checking in and out of plays and getting them right. Wentz is the smartest young QB in the league. Dak is a pure playmaker.
Dak got one of the best WR in the game, a HoF TE, the best offensive line in football, & a top 5 pick at RB who's backups is a former 1000yd rusher. Not to take anything away from what dak is doing cuz I actually like him more, but Carson Wentz is pretty much carrying that offense so I gotta go with Carson Wentz. But its still too early we'll see how things are going a couple weeks down
It's harder to make this argument knowing the coaching Dak has to deal with. Conservative playcalling. Coaching has a lot to do with it. I'd take Dak because he seems more mobile. Also remember the coaching dictates types of plays in the red zone. The Cowboys have never been short on talent. They've been short on coaching. Whether it be QB coaching, WR coaching, etc
What? They drafted Quincy and then took Dak. What you smoking. I don't like Garrett or Jerry, but they are far from being racist. 2 out of 5 of their best players are black.
Tod Wilkinson Sounds like you're the racist not me. I am not racist against QB's. it's funny how no one seems to care that 90% of all NBA players are black, or how great WR and RB are all black. Please take your BS with you.
Love this show!! Shannon is funny as heck.. On pointe with comments. Skip has come out of a shell since he got the show. Very interesting and Delightful to watch.... They do go at it tho...
i would imagine wentz being the better qb right now for crying out loud he is a first round pick 😂. its expected from him. you gotta give dak more praise however cause nobody including me wouldve ever thought that he would be that good since the day he got drafted. and lets see how wentz will play when he faces tougher opponents
How does completion percentage equal accuracy? When a receiver drops passes and the percentage goes down how does that mean accuracy? Dak has better receivers doesnt mean more accurate.. Bomb is anything that drops in over shoulder.
Dak is playing behind one of the best offensive lines in football, throwing to a receiving core that is much better than the Eagles'.
Also throwing against better defenses..... Browns and bears are both top 5 worst defenses in the league
Dak has played 2 tough division teams and Wentz has played 2 bad teams
It doesn't matter. His accuracy, deep ball ability and smartness is what makes him way better. It doesn't matter the defense he plays, a good placed ball is a good placed ball, its not like he had hours to throw the ball in the pocket or anything.
Please start giving the eagles defense their just do. Cowboys defense still sucks and eagles is much improved that makes anything either QB does judgemental.
Jigolopuff And he danced over those defenses the way you would expect an elite Quarterback to. We beat those teams by a combined 34 points and it should've been more if not for the 4-5 key drops by Celek,Matthews and Agholor.
ESPN about to sue Skip and Fox for using the Qbr stat
Laughing my ass off
+SuperJuice (Mgg) it's lmao
how about your lazy ass actually spell out your words
ESPN are run by a bunch of dick suckers
+Cryptic 90 so is fox
It is impossible by now, to argue which one is the better QB. Wayyyyy too early
yeah but you know people are going to do it anyways, we won't really know till like week 7 or 10...
You mean a couple of years
AjaxForever Well yeah, but I was talking more about this season and how they both end up doing just this year
Ow okay yes, in this season it will take us at least till week 7 or 10 or so. They need time. RGIII was great in his first season too. So..
Not a cowboys fan and I agree that its too early to decide but at least right now I'm siding with Dak.
Hell nah. Wentz has less options and is making it look easy. Hell nah skip
no huddle offence, change plays, read option. i totally agree with u
They played two god awful teams. Let them play some real teams and then we'll see
Not like the cowboys played any amazing defenses either.
+That1boi Don't sit up here and compare the bears or Browns defense to a playoff team in Washington or the significantly upgraded New York defense. Two far superior teams, anyone who watches football knows that. The Eagles better be 2-0 playing those shit teams. By the way if Terrance Williams wasn't an idiot there's a good chance Dallas would be 2-0.
+Hakurei Oni you're gonna sit here and honestly say the redskins aren't better than the Browns or Bears? I'm just gonna end the comment right here because that's completely asinine. And by the way, dak should've had two touchdowns but Cole and dez dropped them, how is that his fault? His stats are superior to wentz and Carson has played terrible teams while dak played the early division leader and last years division champ. Say what you want, the division was awful, but the redskins still won it, something the Bears and Browns haven't done in however long.
Why is this even a question? Imagine Wentz behind that Dallas O line and with those receivers??? He would look like that next Tom Brady... Wentz is leap years ahead of Dak Prescott
your dumb take this L
You're*. Go fuck yourself.
lies ....smh
and Dak has Dez
+#88 god what L wantz is 2-0 the cowgirls are the ones who took an L. Hence 1-1. Now smart guy I rather win then have a better stat.
Passes of 15 yards+
Dak: 5
Wentz: 16
Touchdowns
Dak: 0
Wentz: 3
Interceptions
Dak: 0
Wentz: 0
Numbers don't lie dak has been a game Manager imo an wentz had no oline or #1 WR
Give him dez Elliot witten best oline in the NFL he would be 10x better then he already been
Yep. Only stat that's better is yards.
Cowboys run the ball and faced better Ds.
dak had a touchdown last game and he has to play with the worst defense in the league
and the Giants and Redskins are better than the Cleveland browns and Bears
Trash defenses with little film.
it's impossible for skip to be objective. he thinks t.o. doesn't belong in the hall.
k
It's 2016 man and some of y'all still take that clown serious lol
How does he keep his job as a sports "analyst" if he is basically subjective about everything
+dave mccabe because he is polarizing.
I get that it makes a debate better when the two disagree, but if you have to say "I'm right" and "you know I'm right" every time you debate, then you begin to lose credibility.
How many teeth does Shannon Sharpe have in his head? Homie got the smile of a Titan from Attack on Titan.
it's called brushing and flossing lol
that's cold man 😂😂😂
it's called taking care of your teeth maybe you should do it
veneers
Only reason Dak isn't airing it out more is because the Cowboys playcalling is conservative AF. They're trying to keep the ship afloat until Romo comes back where they believe they can make a run in the playoffs like they did in 2014. Eagles aren't really playing for much at this point in time, so they're much more willing to let their rookie QB air it out. Don't forget that Dak had multiple long TD passes in the pre-season, so it's not like he lacks the ability.
I was unsure until i read your comment. I think your assessment is more than likely correct. Im a Dallas fan but i didnt just side with Dak i really thought about it and still was unsure. I dnt like the idea of waiting on Romo though.I was hoping he get hurt early so Dak and get more reps early before the playoffs.Now your ruining my hopes of Dak staying in.
+jgyrwa Dakota and D. Mcnabb will have a great deal in common... Jerry wanted Paxton Lynch but got Prescott instead see where a top Secret Qb takes the Cowboys.. Lynch maybe too fragile for the NFL like Mariota
eagles airnt playing for much? boy you better take off them glasses because the eagles are playing for the playoffs. if wentz had the offense line and weapons that day had this wouldn't be a question. 3Passing Td to 000000Td why is this a question?
Alex Lopez I hear you. My point is that the Cowboys are quite literally in "this is it. All or nothing." mode. They can't let Dak take huge risks because they want to return the car to Romo in the best shape possible, you know what I mean? As for the Eagles and the playoffs, I know they also want the best for the team, but I mean *every* team wants to make the playoffs. If they don't make it this year, then it really doesn't matter as much compared to a team like the Dallas, because the Eagles have a young franchise QB who they know is going to take some time.
Whereas with Dallas, this might literally be the last year they even have a shot to be a legit playoff team, Romo might be done after this year. It's 2 different philosophies.
The Eagles are in: "Hey this Wentz kid is pretty good and we have a good defense, so let's see what we can do this year, because we're only going to get better."
Whereas Dallas is in: "We can't fuck this year up, because it's most likely going to be our last shot for several years."
All I mean.
u are exaclty right play calling is conservative asf and dak has thrown plenty of deep ball touchdowns and yea it might have been pre-season but everybody does not seem to relize that he played against starting defense's in the pre season and not to mention he played in a very difficult confrence in college which is the SEC and he took a sorry ass school to #1 in the nation at one point
You gotta love the special chemistry that Skip and Shanon share!
Shannon: how many touchdowns did Dak throw?
Skip....none
LMFAO
Well Dak has 2 pretty tough games while Carson had 2 pretty easy games so I think Dak had a better first 2 week
i didnt see dak once pressured in the pocket he hasn't even got a scratch on him on the other hand you got carson wentz completing a pass while a defender is in his face carson wentz has been nore pressured nd has thrown more amazing than dak and dak facing two tough teams really? giants defense was in last last year and redskins are a tough team this year really the redskins are just as trash as browns gtfo
No pressure? What games were you watching? Prescott was sacked 4 times in the Redskins game, twice as much as his counterpart Kirk Cousins.
All i see everytime i watch him is having a lot of time in the pocket with the best oline in front of him rewatch both their games abd see who had more pressure on them while completing passes i didnt see dak once get hit hard come on now carson wentz had a tougher time in the pocket while completing throws while defenders were literally tackling him hard
watch the highlights again and watch his passes under pressure. Dak will have 4 TD's against the Bears.
And oh ya does dak even have a td throw
I knew Skip would say Dak before the video even started... He never disappoints 💀
"numbers don't lie"...exactly! Prescott QBR 76, Wentz QBR 63
Eagles faced 2 worst teams in NFL, Cowboys 2 division rivals. Hands down...DAK!
As a cowboys fan I hope both Wents and Dak live up to the hype. Excited for the possible future for both teams. Bring back the NFC Beast!!!
Wentz*
Wentz is better and it's not even close. He's doing more with a lot less around him.
playing terrible teams
doing more against the browns and bears....right
My high school team is better than the Browns by a lot enough said
not even close?
maybe not in skin color. but everything else I'd consider debatable
Dallas Cowboys are gonna win the east. Next year the whole thing. Football is finally back America
Wentz no doubt. Prescott has a wall to protect him and Wentz has less options.
These 2 are funny together😂 great chemistry
Skip is right. C'mon, the eagles played the browns then the bears, the cowboys played the giants then the redskins. Dak has better stats. Nuff said. Wins mean nothing because you need a team.
Prescott has had a whole preseason to prepare while Wentz was named the starter 8 days before the season began. Considering all circumstances Wentz has been more impressive.
+KingRedbull yes he's been more impressive but dak has been better.
how does Dak have better stats, neither has an interception but Wentz has 3 passing TD's to Dak's single rushing. Wentz also has a higher rating
wins mean nothing? really they why play if wins don't mean anything. the cowboys played the giants and redskins not elite teams by any means...wentz has better but its close
Bruh u said winning means nothing you can't expect anyone to respect ur opinion on that
I will go with Dak Prescott he played against 3 tough defensive teams. The Hawks in pre-season, New York Giants, and Washington Redskins. Two of the teams which are in they division, also losing by only 1 point against New York Giants. Although they only scored one touchdown against the New York Giants. Only thing Dak need to work on is switching up plays in the redzone.
Finally someone else with common sense. Exactly
The Giants are an ok team. He lost to an ok team. It doesn't matter whether it was his fault or not he still lost. The Redskins suck and he beat them in a close game.
everyone is talking about wentz being 2-0 and not mentioning the fact that they only gave up 10 pts to cleveland and 14 to Chicago. Dak has kept the opposing offense off the field and the Dallas D still can't stop anyone. Carson does look to be the better pure passer but as a whole I'm going to have to say Dak.
They're still 2-0 vs the Browns and Bears combined 0-4
new rivalry in da east like Romo and Eli going at it for over 10 yrs
Yeah but Eli got two rings... Romo????
When was last time cowboys had a good defense though?
cowboys had all the pieces in 2014 to make a run, they were lucky to win their first round with bad officiating against the lions and it came back to them in green bay
so to that point, when has eli even remotely had someone close to a 2,000 yard rusher to rely on?
I'd rather have a great defense & pass rush then a great running back
I haven't paid much attention to Dak, but the only thing I'd argue Dak has over Wentz from a QB stand point is maybe mobility, but even that's up for debate. Also up for debate is if the Redskins and Giants are really THAT much better than the Browns or Bears, because from what I've seen, none of them are playoff caliber teams. Here's what I see:
WENTZ: 2-0. DAK: 1-1.
WENTZ: No star receivers. DAK: Has Dez Bryant.
WENTZ: O-line not the greatest. DAK: Best O-line in the league.
WENTZ: 3 TD passes (no turnovers). DAK: 0 TD passes (no turnovers).
Also, I'd like to note I haven't seen Carson make a single stupid pass yet. The only bad decision I've seen from Wentz is not protecting himself on a scramble. Granted, I haven't paid attention to Prescott play, so I don't know how we'll he looked on the field and how smart he was with the football, but Wentz was practically flawless. Skip says he's not bias, but I have to call bullshit.
9:20 Stop Skip!!! lol man had me rolling
wentz is better than presscott
Wentz will make mistakes, I understand that, but we here in Philly now have a franchise QB who will lead us to playoff victory's and that's all I want. I want a chance, a shot a hope for a ring. just hope. thank you football gods for blessing us with Kid Carson
Lol, he plays the Browns and bears both top 5 worst defenses in the league and now you are talking about him winning games in the playoffs!?!?!!? You are deluded boy
Frederik Brandt he can only beat whose in front of him. Stop nitpicking, hater
Frederik Brandt Dak can't even get throw a TD pass when he has Dez..... He's pure trash
Let's see how he comes out against the steelers this week, boys gonna look shook. Dak has already played winning teams and handled them to the same degree as wentz if not better. Also, if you watched football at all you'd know dark had two passes dropped that would been TDs week 1. One of them was to your boy dez Bryant.....
he played against two shitty teams and you think you found a diamond get real
Skip is a homer and Wentz will win rookie of the year
You are clearly the homer if you think Wentz is winning any award you dumbo, you can't call other people biased if you yourself is....
Nope Sterling Shepard will win rookie of year.
A receiver will never beat a qb for rookie of the year. Wentz will win it and he deserves to win it.
Yah. A rookie receiver doing well is seen every year. A rookie QB doing this good is a completely different ball game. If Wentz even has just a good season and Sterling has a breakout season, Wents will still win ROTY.
Here's the truth. If Wentz goes the whole season and takes the Eagles to the playoffs, not only is he OROTY but he'll be MVP as well
This has to be Wentz, hes transitioned into the NFL from the FCS, albeit half a preseason game, just like that. Hes audibling nearly every play, like a new peyton manning, thats all my comparison is.......calm down. Sure hes overthrown a few balls and underthrew a big one last night to Agholor, but hes also delivering pinpoint passes that have been dropped, like J Maths, for sure TD if he actually caught the ball. He also needs to learn to slide and make sure he gets outta bounds, cause some of those hits he was taking, for literally nothing, was making me hold my breath. Yes his first two games were against the browns and bears, but I seem to remember, people doubting him before the browns game and even more before the bears game. The guy literally doesnt go anywhere without the playbook to study it, every halftime hes got it right in his hand, I mean you cant teach that stuff, hes got an amazing demeanor............Ill leave it at that, yes I am an Eagles fan.
I don't get what the point of this argument is? Like who cares? Both are playing well for rookies let's talk end of season who had the better year. It's only been two weeks
Wentz played against a T E R R I B L E defense game 1
Plays against a bottom level defense.
Dak game 1-Plays against a supposedly top 10 defense No ints.
Dak game 2-against a decent defense on ROAD AND DIVISION RIVAL throws dots.
Dak all the way.
Dak has much better receivers than the Eagles.
The skins and Giants stink too!
The Giants and Redskins are bottom 10 defensively. And without a QB, the Cowboys offense is much better than the Eagles. Not throwing a single TD pass against these bums with an offense as good as the Cowboys is pathetic for even a below average QB.
Dak should have had 2 TDs against the Giants why are people blaming him Dez had the ball and dropped it & so did cole Beasley that's not his fault he did his job
ITS J 02 Wow you are so dumb
No question now DAK, Wentz has been exposed twice now
Short answer: Wentz
I'll answer when they play each other...... 2 times !
Not even trying to be biased here, but wentz looks like the better qb. He is calling audibles and throwing the ball down the field with a shitty online and average at best receivers. Dak looks ok not even great to be honest. He is really just dink and dunking passes. There is a reason why wentz went 2 and dak in the 4th round. Might not matter in the future but right now it def looks like it.
The eagles have one of the best Olines Wtf are you talking about? You don't even know your own team LMAO. You guys have a top 10 Oline with peters and Johnson
One of the best oline??? Not even close we have great tackles and one is old... the middle of the line is average
No we do not have one of the best onlines . Lane Johnson seems to struggle without his peds and Jason Peter's is old and lost a step. Our line is far from one of the best. Did you watch the game last night ? Penalty all over the place.
we'll just wait and see when my boys play you I think dak is better he has no interceptions and already has a game winning drive under his belt this offense is for romo but will soon change
Dak isn't dink and do king you goof, watch the games instead of talking shit, Wentz played 2 of the worst defenses in the entire league while Dak played 2 pretty good defensive sides that are also divisional opponents
Wentz is better.. end of story.. cowboys could be 0-2.. and Dak is playing too conservatively and didnt show much.... Eagles won convincingly and has less weapons around. Carson reminds me of young Brady with legs.. I see huge upside but still early so we will see..
The Browns and the Bears? come on, dont count that
I agree with you.I don't care who he plays.The browns almost beat a playoff experience Baltimore and the bears were actually favored vs Philly
Prescott is a better qb. the Dallas defense needs work
Lol at young Brady, and they say Cowboys fans are delusional. Your boy has played against the Browns and the Bears....its early for this talk but you're running with it as if he's played against elite defenses.
eazy, did you see when wentz EMBARRASSED the steelers who supposedly hv/had a top notch D? ...... not sure how you can even form the words you did. How is it "delusional" for fans to think he's a potential Brady? What argument do you hv?
I'm a cowboy fan, but right now Wentz has the wins and the TD passes. we'll see during the season and at the end but Wentz is in the lead. love me some Dak though
Look who wentz has been playing though
they're both playing pro football players and are both doing well, but until Dak gets some TD passes and more wins, Wentz is objectively in the lead. i think Dak is awesome and will take the lead, but it's still early
won by 15 or more point both games, cowboys won by 4 points total and playing two teams in the worst division in the league so the this L
Dak should have had 2 TDs against the Giants why are people blaming him Dez had the ball and dropped it & so did cole Beasley that's not his fault he did his job
Then he shouldn't be blamed for those neither he did his job
Dak doesn't even have a passing td yet
Dak is where it's ak. Dak is a 4th rounder that nobody saw coming, Wentz was hyped up 1st round, a 2nd overall selection. Dak stayed in college for the full 4 years, while Wentz played 3 and was redshirted. Wentz had an easy game against the Browns as Dak played against two divisional rivals which is big in my eyes. Dak also broke an NFL rookie record of no turnovers in a debut. Dak all the way!
Wanna know something funny? Wentz hasn't created a turnover either and wentz has more touchdowns than dak.. soo what's the poor excuse for that?
iTz_BBoy7 Dak has a higher QB rating then Wentz. It's only a matter of time that Dak will get his touchdown passes from the likes Dez Bryant and Jason Witten. The only way to resolve whose better, is by the first game that they face each other. Remember Dak is 4th rounder with nothing to lose while Wentz is the 2nd overall draft pick with a lot of hype. The 'Boy's didn't overpay to draft their quarterback unlike what the Eagles paid to gwt Wentz.
And if you've paid attention to the pre season leading up to the regular season you'd know and realize all those picks the eagles gave up to get wentz the eagles got back. You wanna know who else has a high "qbr"? it's tony romo how many playoff wins does tony romo have? I mean surely qbratings get wins(sarcasm). Like sharpe said that's all that matters in the end is the win and cowboy fans seems to care more about a qbr than an actual win? really that is a joke!
Also to add the cowboys have more talent than the eagles but you guys cant get at least one touchdown reception from qb to wr in 2 games really? dez bryant hasn't caught anything in 2 games dak has noooo touchdowns but a high qbr?
iTz_BBoy7 The Dallas coaching staff hasn't opened up the play book for Dak. Garret and Staff have to feed Dak more plays to open up the Offense. Give it time because Dak has a lot of time on his side to explode as a fine game-breaking quarterback Dak has a higher QB rating because that stat is based on pass completion percentage, yards, tds, and interceptions, all the criteria Dak has meet with the exception of touchdowns
Wentz actually throws it down the field. Has way less weapons than Dak. Does he have any turnovers? He actually has touchdowns. I think they'll both be solid though.
DAK
The Cleveland Browns and Chicago Bears will be lucky to win 6 games this year. Carson looks like the better passer but Dak is better overall and has played tougher opponents
Dak has 0 tds lol
wouldve but doesnt... even with a top 3 receiver
TheLakerFan 24 Rushing
+Bossrah We really gon act like dez didn't play like trash first game and there were like 3 potential scoring drops against the redskins
he's russell wilson rookie year just a game manager
Dak reminds me of Mcnabb
Based off what I seen so far in two games its pretty close but Dak has play tougher competition so I'd give him the edge and he looks to have the higher ceiling. Also look at how they both performed in college, but you can't go wrong with either.
And also the cowboys haven't really let Dak open it up yet as far as the plays and letting him throw harder passes which everyone knows he's capable its just the cowboys coaching staff playing conservative safe ball.
Cowboys have a potential top 10 offense while the Eagles have ass receivers and mediocre running backs. Wentz making them better. Dak playing with great players on the other hand.
Skip does nothing but contradict himself. In an argument he just had in reference to Rodgers vs Brady, he clearly made a point to say QBR was meaningless, a "made up stat". Yet now, when it's Prescott vs Wentz, he does nothing but lean on it. Dude pisses me off.
As objective as I can be, even though I'm a Cowgirl hater, I gotta take Dak
I hate both teams. I hate Eagles even more. But Wentz is more impressive to me.
Wentz audibles and has control of the full playbook... He is easily better
+Cruzan26 Browns and bears...
Dak has a bigger dick so he is better.
Dak reads defenses, and changes plays from the line of scrimmage and knows the playbook like the back of his hand. Yup. I'll take Dak >wentz
"Oh, so you like people being PC huh..."
Shannon is fucking killing me dude 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
This is better than First Take. Too over-dramatic on that show
Wentz all day. Prescott throws twenty 5 yd passes to Beasley. Padding stats. Wentz throws deep balls in the basket. If not for dropped passes... I'll wait
Dak has thrown the ball 5 times over 15yds in 75 attempts. Get serious Skip.
Right? He's just been throwing little baby passes that are safe
+Tod Wilkinson you can't argue with stats idiot.
If Garret would open up the playbook lil more then Dak would throw deeper more but Dak has thrown a few passes that was over 10 yrds its not Dak's fault garret is too conservative
Wentz has had to face zero adversity in his first two games and like they said played the 2 worst teams in football. We'll see who he is against the Steelers this week. Dak clearly has the advantage right now.
Also Dak almost threw for 300 yards against Washington and Carson threw for 190 yards against the sad Bears D.
Have to go wentz even though dak is putting up numbers he hasn't even thrown one td pass. What makes their game so different is that Wentz is calling audibles, picking up the blitz, getting passing tds(even with the sorry recievers). Dak is good but his game needs alot of work reading the plays, and his passes aren't that accurate. But Daks mobility is great.
This is exactly what I see. People think we are being biased but it's the truth. Wentz is a really smart kid. Straight A student 4.0 gpa. And is an athlete. This is why I'm more impressed with Wentz. Either way it's to early to know what these qbs are gonna turn out to be. Cowboys really got lucky with dak. Because they didn't even know he was gonna what he is. Eagles did what they had to do. Can't blame them, and they got their picks back for the Wentz trade.
Carson is very intelligent he got a 4.0 in college he is a brainiac dork with those glasses but who cares he plays the game tough. He is more intelligent than Dak who got into a parking lot fight with drunks before being drafted. look it up on youtube Dak fights.
so because you get into a fight your not intelligent?
How is Dak not accurate when he's been more accurate than Carson Wentz?
Dallas has better receivers right now. if you add up all those drops from week one that were put on the jersey numbers and then those two drop last game for big yardage trust me Carson is better like 100 plus yrds better. Dak still hasnt passed for touchdown and the only time it comes close is when he throws a jump ball for Dez Bryant that dosent take skill or accuracy. two bread basket throws by carson week one and two drops that were perfectly thrown week two. please.
eagles are winning the NFC East..Hands down..best D in division..best special teams in the east ...and a top 5 front 4.
L O L
hahahaha
Yes they have played the two worst teams so you gonna go ahead a make a guess there winning the NFC EAST..wow
+Mooreville Middle school ... Does anyone in our division have a front 7 like us? .... That's all I need to win this division. Cowboys defense is garbage, giants defense is still being built up & the redskins defense is about as good as the cowboys defense.The best Defense will win this division.
Mooreville Middle school who is ur team?
Dak has more options compared to wentz foh
I like Carson Wenz....he has poise and is able to audible. The problem with Wenz is he is reckless with his body. I like both but from what i seen from Wenz is impressive.
I would like to see dak make a throwing touchdown.
Throwing? Passing would be the correct term but ok.
Yea my bad
+Sidney Williams the eagles has a defense the cowboys dont dak prove he can lead his team in the 4 quarter if wasnt for sorry as williams we will be 2 and 0 wentz aint did that yet as far as play calling the cowboys want let dak throw it down field he can as we all seen in preseaso he can throw the deep ball so dak is better
+Andrew Alexander w
+Andrew Alexander 1 TD
I'm a cowboys fan and even I'll admit wentz been better! Sunday will be the real test for him tho
Wentz all day
It's no doubt that it's Wentz.
Played bad teams but if you give wentz that Cowboys o line and dez Bryant he'd probably have like 8 TDs right now
Wentz has yet to play a quality CB or pass rush. Wentz also played the Browns and Bears, two of the worst teams in the league. Dak had TD, but were dropped.
Carson has had several "would-be" TDs that were dropped. Skip said, "Carson has no pressure at all," which is just ridiculous. Skip hates the Eagles and LOVES the Cowboys, he should not have any say in discussions about the NFC East, because he can't keep his fanboy down.
Gabriel Joe Haden isn't an elite cornerback? Im pretty sure Haden is an elite Cornerback and Wentz played against Haden and Wentz Destroyed Haden
Gabriel if you watched the game yesterday Wentz actually had so much pressure and took so many hard hits and still completed tough passes so he actually has faced good pass rushers
Dez would've dropped Carson's touchdown passes just like he dropped Dak's in week one. If you gave Wentz Jason Garrett as a coach as well, he would be playing much more conservative like Dak is.
Both these QB'S are going to be good. I had thought Dak Prescott was the Best QB coming into the draft yet he didn't get picked until the 4th round. I think Dak will be the Best QB in that division about a year or two from now. but I agree with Tony Romo being inserted back as starter once he is healthy.
IT'S BEEN 2 GAMES GIVE ME A DAMN BREAK FROM ALL THIS COWBOYS TALK HOLY SHIT
Wentz >>> Dak 🏋️♀️😉🏈💯🤘
The Cowboys will need a new Coach to get the best out of Dak. A QB whisperer. Jason G is not that guy.
Garrett isn't a QB whisperer ? LMAO What do you think his first coaching job was ?
pretty sure Jason garret used to be a qb lol
With Shanons closing statements he inadvertently strengthened Skips Tebow argument lol.
Well now he's beaten the Steelers so it's unarguable now lol
Dax is running that offence smoothly, he has also brought the running demention to it,as the season goes on he will go down the feild more.
Wentz graded best QB in first 2 weeks. Dak not even in top ten. case closed.
Shannon set Skip up with that lottery analogy.lol
LMAO
Dak Prescott does NOT even have a TD (Throwing) in we are in week 3 now
its only been two
If your team is scoring why does it matter. He has a rushing TD against Washington.
Dak should have 2 TD passes on the books. It's not Dak's fault that he didn't have any passing TD's in week 1 against the Giants. 2 of our receivers DROPPED 2 TD passes! Dak can throw a pass to a receiver, but he can't make them catch it.
jdac22 if that is the case then Carson should of had 4 TD's last night.....
There both good but Carson is more accurate right now Dak has thrown a lot of balls short
Carson Wentz is not more accurate. Dak has a higher completion percentage.
I am seeing a big trend here... the more the season goes on, the more dak's play keeps getting better while wentz' is trailing off.
I'm a Dallas fan and I say wentz looks better.
I'll take Dak Wentz
This dude skip is trippin again... give him his medication
L
Lol when skip says let's be objective I just laugh and grab popcorn
DAK>Wentz
So much better than first take now. Love this show and Shannon is made for this with Skip
Dak should of been 2-0 tho? Redskins gave them that game...more like 0-2 😂😂😂😂😂😂
thank you kirk cousins missed like 3 touchdowns passes the cowboys got lucky
Eg Davis....I don't understand the play calling on the 4 yard line...you got Matt Jones but they decide to pass...straight dumb!
They still had the lead before Dak led the game winning drive so...
Wentz had way easier opponents but Dak does have better offensive weapons and that o line
Lol "1-1." Yeah, so I guess Carson Wentz is better than the likes of Cam Newton and Aaron Rodgers now. Give me a break. Copy and paste Dak Prescott into the Eagles and let him play CLEVELAND and CHICAGO and tell me he wouldn't match Wentz's stats. Not to mention the Cowboys' overly conservative play calling.
Okay. IF the Eagles beat Pittsburgh tomorrow, will you still be making excuses?
No, because they won't beat Pittsburgh tomorrow. Simple.
I'm an Eagles fan and I think Pittsburgh will win myself, but you're avoiding the question. Dak is a game manager, Carson has all of the intangibles necessary to win games with a work ethic to boot.
Alright then, well here's my answer. If Wentz does what he's done against the Browns and Bears against the Steelers, who's arguably the best team in the league right now, then fine, I'll say that Wentz is superior. But as of now, I don't feel he's earned that title yet.
Dynamic_ And I'll be completely honest as well: I'm not going to crown Wentz the next Favre because of his toughness, the next Peyton because of his ability to read the defense or the next Romo because almost every pass has been a perfect strike. The potential to become one of them is there. I don't see that in Dak's play.
Both Dak And Carson are gonna have great careers in the nfl i think we can all agree on that. I have to give the edge to Dak Prescott. It's because he was a fourth round pick. Carson wentz was the second overall pick so he has huge expectations on his shoulders.
Wentz impressed me yesterday against my team Steelers
skips face when Shannon asked him how many td 's has dak thrown for in two games PRICELESS
These guys are my favorite sports analysts. They don't talk out of their ass, and actually support their words with facts. unlike some people over at ESPN...
Dak is not a run first QB. In 4 games he has ran it 12 times and Wentz in 3 games has ran it 9 times. Dak played against way better players in college but had way better stats. Wentz has only played 3 games and people act like he is the best rookie they ever seen. People forget including pre season Dak has played 9 games with no interception and playing at an elite caliber. Not to mention the QB for the Dallas Cowboys is one of the most high profile stressful position in any sport and he is handling it like a champ many can not handle the role. Its a reason why Beasley is a top receiver this year so far. People need to stop using Dez as an excuse of why Dak is playing good because every other receiver has more catches then Dez. Dak is beating Wentz in almost every stat. Dak has a higher Completion % , in 4 games he has 1,012 passing yards. Wentz has 769 in 3 games so he would have to pass for over 243 yards against the lions to beat Dak. Dak QBR is 86.6 and Wentz is 68.9. Dak Avg. 7.73 yards per catch and Wentz Avg. 7.54. Dak has more rushing yards, yards per carry, and rushing TDs. The only reason he has not had more passing yards is because we run the ball in the touchdown more, plus over 15 pass was either drops in the TD, the TD was called back, or the receiver got tackle less the 5 yards from the goal. Wentz is simply playing at a level you would expect a 1st round draft pick to play at. I mean who can't do dump passes and screens to people like Sproles as he get 20+ yards after the catch. Eagles has one of the best tight ends in football and nobody on the offense is a scrub so they obviously have weapons. Eagles line is real good in fact they have protected Wentz better then the Cowboys line. Dak has been pressured 16% of the time and Wentz 8.1%. Dallas line run block really good but there pass blocking is slightly above average I can name plenty teams with better pass blocking like the EAGLES, Patriots, Green Bay, Saints, Falcons, Denver, Raiders, Bengals, Giants. Dak is playing above what would be expected of a 4th round draft pick. Wentz was a 1st round pick that knew he would have the starting job. Dak came in as a 3rd possible 4th string and had no ideal he would start until the first game of the season. Wentz is good but I give Dak the slight edge.
Talk about degree of difficulty....dak plays with the best o line in football with dez at receiver and elliot at running back while Wentz plays with patchwork o line butterfinger receivers and Ryan mathews
It's Tuesday. Just got that Madden weekly update. My Eagles on 🔥🔥🔥 I might call out tomorrow
Are people really predicating who is better based on TD passes? Dumbest things I've ever heard considering Dak should have two touchdown passes. Hard to say who is better right now. I think Wentz has a stronger arm but Dak is more accurate. Two weeks won't determine anything. Let's see how they are playing 4 weeks from now.
As a Dallas fan, Wentz is far ahead of Dak as a QB. Dak's success has been more about the Cowboys coaching staff putting him in the best position to be the ultimate. At the beginning of this season I said that the Cowboys don't need Dak to win games. They just need him to not lose them. He's done just that. He's the future but they've shown that he's got more developing to do than Wentz. His collectiveness is off the charts but he's not the passer or the field general that Wentz is. His deep ball isn't quite there and his back shoulder needs work. Wentz is already checking in and out of plays and getting them right. Wentz is the smartest young QB in the league. Dak is a pure playmaker.
Dak got one of the best WR in the game, a HoF TE, the best offensive line in football, & a top 5 pick at RB who's backups is a former 1000yd rusher. Not to take anything away from what dak is doing cuz I actually like him more, but Carson Wentz is pretty much carrying that offense so I gotta go with Carson Wentz. But its still too early we'll see how things are going a couple weeks down
It's harder to make this argument knowing the coaching Dak has to deal with. Conservative playcalling. Coaching has a lot to do with it. I'd take Dak because he seems more mobile. Also remember the coaching dictates types of plays in the red zone. The Cowboys have never been short on talent. They've been short on coaching. Whether it be QB coaching, WR coaching, etc
Tod, Romo is a Mexican this has nothing to do with race.
What? They drafted Quincy and then took Dak. What you smoking. I don't like Garrett or Jerry, but they are far from being racist. 2 out of 5 of their best players are black.
Tod Wilkinson Yeah cool, especially since my brother and sister are black.
Tod Wilkinson Sounds like you're the racist not me. I am not racist against QB's. it's funny how no one seems to care that 90% of all NBA players are black, or how great WR and RB are all black. Please take your BS with you.
Both guys are the next generation of QBs for these teams, there is no reason to debate 'who is better' this early in their careers...
Skip is on major drugs.... Carson Wentz is clearly the best running QB over prescott
First time I agree with Skip
Love this show!! Shannon is funny as heck.. On pointe with comments. Skip has come out of a shell since he got the show. Very interesting and Delightful to watch.... They do go at it tho...
i would imagine wentz being the better qb right now for crying out loud he is a first round pick 😂. its expected from him. you gotta give dak more praise however cause nobody including me wouldve ever thought that he would be that good since the day he got drafted. and lets see how wentz will play when he faces tougher opponents
How does completion percentage equal accuracy? When a receiver drops passes and the percentage goes down how does that mean accuracy? Dak has better receivers doesnt mean more accurate.. Bomb is anything that drops in over shoulder.
lmao Jerry Jones impersonation on point
I straight up love this show man
as an eagles fan i think both qbs are gonna be great. both wentz and dak look like they've been doing this in the nfl for awhile
Respect both their point of views