The "last colony" in Europe? | Growing up in Gibraltar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 июл 2024
- At the Southern tip of the Spanish peninsula is a piece of land measuring under 7 km2, whose GDP per capita is one of the highest in the world: it's Gibraltar.
Gibraltar is one of Britain's overseas territories, and according to its citizens, it's happy to be one. Commuting to Spain for groceries and restaurants, welcoming thousands of Spaniards coming in for work daily, the lives of those living under the Rock are an extraordinary mix of English and Spanish culture.
We went to the country that Spain defined "the last colony in Europe" to ask a young Spanish person and a young Gibraltarian what it means to grow up under the Rock.
Chapters:
00:00 - 00:56 Intro
00:56 - 1:13 What is Gibraltar?
1:13 - 2:10 What Gibraltarian identity looks like
2:10 - 2:58 Why is Gibraltar British?
2:58 - 3:49 Spain or Britain
3:49 - 4:16 Between wealth and drug trafficking
4:16 - 6:19 Living in Spain, depending on Gibraltar
6:19 - 7:11 More than business
7:11 - 8:01 Francisco Franco and closed borders
8:01 - 9:29 Life after Brexit
#gibraltar #lineadelaconcepcion #monkey
_____________________________________________________________
Young, bold, #European. #ENTR a digital space for open discussion about what really matters, what holds us back and what connects us all. We value differences and celebrate what we have in common- no matter where you are from and what you believe in.
We speak “European” in six languages: English, French, German, Polish, Portuguese and Romanian. ENTR a unique channel made by young journalists from #DW, France Médias Monde and partners all over Europe.
Follow ENTR on Instagram: / en.entr
Devolved lo robado que está fuera del tratado. La zona del aeropuerto está fuera del tratado.
The comment regarding Franco and the border reopening needs clarification. Franco died in 1975. The border was reopen to pedestrians only in 1982 and to motor vehicles in 1985.
Yes, we wanted it to be clear that there's a causal relationship between Franco's death and the border reopening. Thanks for spelling it out!
Even if franco died in 1975 = Between 1975 and 1982 / 1985 spain s politicians still had fascist attitudes against Gibraltar
One can still feel European without one's country being a member of the EU. I live in the UK but still feel European. The EU is not Europe. We travel to Gibraltar regularly and it was interesting to hear views from both sides of the border. It was a very good video. Many thanks!
Thank you for your comment! We're glad you liked the piece!
And one as a European can feel being attached to the EU, while being somehow forced by other European Swiss to live outside the EU, because we believe we are exceptional and the best.
I identify as a Londoner and then English. I have absolutely no negative opinions of the EU. We just identify what we feel we are.
As a born and bread Gibraltarian and after the Brexit Back Stubbing saga we have endured, this is how I feel today, First I feel Gibraltarian, then European and then unfortunately, British because we have no option but too.
@@greengardengreen6666 Some people just don't know when they are well off.
The accent sounds a little welsh
Without wanting to offend anyone, I find it strange for Spain to complain about Gibraltar when we have the same situation with Ceutá and Melilla.
I visited Gibraltar just recently, and realised what a beautiful place it is. Britain in the sun, or so I thought. But it is much more than that. Gibraltarians are unique, both English and Spanish at the same time. I love that combination. It is a relationship made in heaven. I'm returning there next year. Just for a day to remind me of what a wonderful place it is.
It was stolen
@@juanmorales5133 Spain has two territories in Africa. Where they stolen ?
@@derekferguson2328 never because Morocco did not exist,yet.
However Gibraltar is part of Spain.
@@juanmorales5133 not true. also gibraltar was given, not stolen
@@universalsubliminals1174 lee un poco de hiistoria de España.
A small part of Wales in the Med, at least judging by her accent!
Gibraltar has part of UK (oversea territory) for longer than US has been a country. People should respect their choice and their right to be who they want to be.
Sure, Jan.
Viendo lo que hacen los franceses en África,es de interés internacional, poner fin a la esclavitud y el saqueo y el desplazamiento forzado de la población, arriesgando la vida para salir de la miseria que ocasiona los países ocupantes de los territorios africanos
Sure, let's ask the colonizers what they think !
This is a joke, Gibraltar was Spanish until the British did what the British did best, send troops, plant a flag and colonize the bloody place !
Los territorios ocupados del imperio español, Canadá Guyana, Malvinas, Belice, y otras islas del Caribe, no son territorios de ultramar de nadie,son territorios ocupados del imperio español, y no por ganar una guerra,es por el reparto de Napoleón tras el secuestro de toda la familia real española Y los Estados ocupados del imperio español por los colonos yankees también
Los británicos y franceses no conquistaron ningún territorio español, nunca, fueron los Borbones quien regalaron los territorios a los que le nombraron Rey del imperio más grande del mundo, El MERIDIANO ESPAÑOL se extiende De Polo Norte A Polo Sur y al Oeste Del Meridiano Español, y es a perpetuidad. Todo Es Español
A fresh and new view on the complex relationship between the two sides of the frontier. Disappointing to see the overhead shot of Europa point spoiled by the releasing of raw sewage though.
She sounds Welsh to me😂 then again the more I listen it actually wasn't. Definitely took a second to get use to.
Yes, definitely, there’s no mistaking that ghastly accent!
Franco died on 20th November 1975. The border at La Línea remained closed for more than 13 years until it was partially reopened to Spanish and Gibraltarian pedestrians on 15 December 1982, and was fully reopened to motor vehicles on 5 February 1985 in preparation for Spain joining the European Communities in 1986
It was opened beccause otherwise the UK would have vetoed Spain's joining the EU (CEE back then), another forced condition upon Spain as usual. Some countries in this world use their stronger military and nukes to bully the rest.
Franco died in 1975 not in 1985
1985 is the year of the reopening of the border
My question is; although rental prices are very high in Gibraltar, does this also mean it is the same for the natives? Or do many native Gibraltarians live in subsidised and/ or rent controlled accommodation?
It is the same for native people! Gib’s GDP is one of the highest in Europe. The latest data is quite old, from 2016, but back then Gibraltar had a GDP per capita of just under €93k!
Yes there are government subsidized housing for Gibraltarian residents (3 years +) as well as new developments where they can buy apartments half price, with re-sell restricted to residents only. This created two housing markets: local and open, same as in Jersey.
@@enentr GDP per capita is the 2nd highest in the world, next to Qatar.
@@enentr so as a Brit, I need to rent overpriced property for just three years... And then I can buy property at local prices?
@@tariqkhader6196 no vengais a España
That Gibraltarian's girl's views and feelings do not represent most Gibraltarians feelings, The fact is my 13 year old grandsons does not speak spanish and I actually wish he could. I am 67 years old and the views of that woman do not coincide with my experience, been to the UK countless times and never experience what she claims she had.
That's fair, that's why they mention that there's a generational difference! What is your personal experience in terms of identity?
Very good question, Only last night I met with my very old friends of 50 years, One is 100% english man married to a Gibraltarian lady, the other is 100% Scottish man also married to a Gibraltarian Lady who passed away recently, the next is a born Gibraltarian and his brother of Maltese descent, the next was born in Gibraltar of Spanish descent, the next was also born in Gibraltar of Genoese descent and I born in Gibraltar of Portuguese descent from 4 generations back in time, We all feel Gibraltarian even those that where not born here, We are all British and proud of it but we feel most proud to belong to this little community of ours which we will defend to the end, We have no problem with our neibours in fact I love their hospitality, culture and generosity, worked with them in Gibraltar for many years and there is not a bad word I can say about them, great people, One of my grandsons does not speak Spanish and I am trying to convince him to try, my other grandson is half Irish and half Gibraltarian, he also is finding it hard to speak Spanish and I try to teach him in my own way to speak andalucian Spanish which shows on my part that I have nothing against Spain, but when it comes to Madrid I will never trust them, they still carry franco's mentality and still don't understand democracy like we do. I could carry on but i could go on forever.
@@enentr And as to how i was treated in the Uk Iwas born in Gib but my parents emigrated to London when I was 2 years old and started school there, I was never badly treated by anyone in the school, I came back to Gib when I was 7 years old and had a worst time in Gib school than I had in London lol which is why I don't understand that lady's experience but I not saying she is lying, we go through life experiencing different things.
Well actually who cares about the experience of 60 thousand breakaway people ?! Purely anecdotal 😎
@@SuperLuckystrike1 that's really interesting. I'm a Brit who moved to Spain in his 20s. It's really interesting to hear the English and Spanish influences in the way Gibraltarians speak English. I started learning Spanish as a teenager because it's a family language on my mother's side, and I still feel like a European even though I accept that the majority of the UK voted to leave.
Wembley stadium has more seats than Gibraltar's population
She sounds more welsh than gibraltarian
No, she does not. She finishes questions saying, "no", which is Spanish, rather than "yes", which is British.
Yes I’m Welsh and I thought that! She sounds like she’s from the valleys 😂
@@jesusbermudez6775 Agreed. Southern Spanish accent couldn't be more different. Esta gente no tiene ni idea 😜
@@jesusbermudez6775 Yes she absolutely does sound Welsh.
@@Benji567891 Of course not.
I thought she was welsh
Unfortunately sounds Welsh!
Is jumping into a fire worse than jumping into ice-cold water? 🤯
It is
Northern Ireland isn't a colony?
No, as it's controlled by the inhabitants, rather than a country from afar
If Spaniards would like to live and work in Gibraltar, I think they should respect the rights of the local inhabitants and ask themselves why the qualify of life is so much worse on the Spanish side. It seems to me like an abject failure of the Spanish Government, so why would Gibraltar want the same fate?
Lmao being a tax safe haven for corporate gambling casinos and controlling the world's most used waterway is something Spain would've done if they had won the prior seige.
because its a tax haven |wtf
Life quality in Spain is not that much different from the UK. La Linea is not quite like the rest of Spain its way poorer and Gibraltar is not an average UK city, its way richer
@@Ed-ss1uh Why don't they do that in Cadiz?
@@jfarinhote It's rich because it's idependent from Spain, not because it's part of Britain. It just uses Britain for protection.
Are Spanish really calling us colonisers here? When they colonised so many places? It’s called self determination, that’s their coloniser blood trying to claim every island who doesn’t want to join them 😂
I'm from the UK but I've been living in southern Spain for a couple of years now. I've visited Gibraltar easily over a hundred times by now and it's a beautiful place 🇬🇧🇬🇮
Claro como toda España ,pero es tierra española no británica .
@@pedroviriato9356 It "was" Spanish land, until ceded to Britain.
@@CountScarlioniNo se puede ceder territorio ,un territorio pertenece al pueblo ,ningún rey o gobierno puede ceder territorio ,los ingleses entraron ilegalmente y ocuparon por la fuerza Gibraltar ,si luego un " tratado " ," cede " territorio ,viene precedido por un hecho ilegal ,por tanto no es legal esa cesión .
@@pedroviriato9356 Morocco agrees with you about Ceuta and Melilla. Maybe you'll give them back to the African peoples from whom they were stolen! Set an example to the rest of us why not?
@@CountScarlioniNo existían Ceuta y Melilla son ciudades creadas por España y por qué las quiere Marruecos , Melilla también la podría reclamar Argelia ,y aquello era el Rif no Marruecos.
Gibralter es espanyol
Sounds like both her & her partner have spent a considerable amount of their lives in Wales
That's the Gibraltarian accent for you!
Gibraltar🇪🇦🇮🇨
Never been to Gibraltar however I’ve spoken to a few Gibraltarians over the years through work, especially recently, a very friendly and chatty people. My only question is (sorry to be “that guy”), I was under the impression that when Gibraltar was ceded to Britain, many, if not most Gibraltarian families fled Gibraltar into Spain. Most Gibraltarians today (I believe), are descended from various immigrants who were brought in from various parts of Europe (I used to speak to one with a Portuguese surname!). If this is indeed the case, and without wishing to get all controversial, when parliament says, “the people of Gibraltar wish to remain British”, are these really ethnic Gibraltarians we’re talking about, or a population which was planted there by Britain in the first place?
Maybe your looking at the situation with a strictly British eyes/conception. I'm from one of the French overseas in the Caribbean and from my over 20 years of experiencing social Life in Europe (French and UK I'm UK based now) Identity, Citizenship, Culture, Race are very confusing for mainland Europeans. For most people I know they mean exactly the same... For overseas territories all over the world, those concepts are perceived very or sometimes extremely differently. I'm black Caribbean coming from an eclectic ethnical background ( I look let's say black-asian because of my native mixity, I was born in Paris ( some people find me very French..) and I speak English with more of a American-like accent because I grew up in the Caribbean....) I confuse people so much in London, I don't even know where to start 😂😂😂😂 First thing first is sticking to History to understand us. If, you look at Gibraltar from a Mainland perspective, I've never been there but I believe you won't understand it. If you put on your "historian" glasses, things start to make sense. It is the same for a lot of Caribbean cultures, for philipinos, Mauritius, south Americans etc... Some people are confused by philipinos having Spanish names and enjoying South American music while eating Asian food, being Asians and living in Asia. If you know a bit about their History it's completely.... normal
The top 8 most common surnames in Gibralter are Spanish.
Most Gibraltarians have at least some Spanish ancestry.
Hm… What does high taxes do to the economy…?
Who has high taxes?
@@ScorpionSuerteSpain…
@@Jonasvolley They're normal
Wow this is systemic divide how someone can see something their whole life but never get to live it. Been at a disadvantage my whole life I know what it like and so is most people. It living next to the border of advantage the same for Malaysian living next to Singapore. So is Mexican living next to us border. So is life
It’s not colony it’s a overseas territory 🇬🇮🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Yes! Yet the UN keeps Gibraltar among the territories that are still to decolonise - why do you think that is?
El rey de Gibraltar es el Rey de España, no de UK y el imperio español nunca ha entregado la soberanía de ningún territorio, todo sigue bajo soberanía española y tenéis que salir de Gibraltar sólo fue cedido en usufructo
Indeed so. Gibraltar is self governing in all but matters of defence and foreign relations and probably most Gibraltarians are quite happy about that. The future of Gibraltar is a matter only for the people of Gibraltar. For many of them, of course, Franco's regime is still a living memory.
Gibraltar es una recompensa por el primer Borbón que ocupó el trono del imperio español, igual que la Luisana Y Menorca que se recuperó para España, El primer Borbón era nieto del rey de Francia luis catorce,o el rey 👑 Sol y cedió la Luisana sin soberanía de ningún tipo y no podía vender ni traspasar, y Gibraltar me da pereza y además estoy de vacaciones para decir lo mismo Ciao
@@carmen2689 ¿Desconoces el tratado de Utrecht?
Açores is Portugal...
Sory churchill
Portugal is Galiza
Sorry Salazar 🎭
@@spaliverpool71As a portuguese I'm ok with that.
All Galegos I've spoken with would rather have a Portugaliza or Galetugal
We love galiza, I don’t get what you were trying to imply 😂
Olivença é nossa😂
We love galiza, I don’t get what you were trying to imply 😂
Olivença é nossa😂
The Gibraltar girl sounds Welsh 😂
Her accent is part northern british part spanish.
Welsh
No, Welsh actually….no mistaking that awful tone!
The UK should offer Gibraltar to join the union.
Not only Gibraltar they should offer the same to the Americancarribean territories
Yes it's a colony.
Northern Ireland is also a colony.
Jabal-at-Tariq
The woman sounds Welsh
Spanglish
You sound welsh
That’s not a colony but a British territory.
Gibraltar will never be handed back to the Spanish as they could then close off the Mediterranean. They have a 'colony" in Morocco directly opposite Gibraltar so they could close the gap whenever they like. It will never be allowed to be Spanish.
Actually it's 2 enclaves in Northern Morocco. Never say never 👻
Actually, all Morocco should be handed back to Spain.
Those are not colonies, they are integral partes of Spain. Never the UN or any independent country has recognize them as colonies. They have been Spanish since before the Alaouit kingdom existed. Had they been colonies they would have been handed over with the rest of the protectorate.
@@Odiseiopero muchacho qué dices😂
España tenía un protectorado sólo en el norte, y además este SÍ era una colonia.
Ya lo sé. La cuestión es que nuestro interés es ese. Lo árabes a Arabia. El norte de África debe ser reconquistado.@@dans7497
How weird Spanish is fucked up and UK colony is not, 🙂↔️ where did I see this earlier?
Alex, the girl in the video, sounds welsh funnily enough!
We love her accent -- such a cool mix!
@@enentr yes it's amazing
Everything about her couldn't be any more Southern Spanish 😏
As someone who is born and raised in Gibraltar, it is difficult to express our identity with other people and feel like we are understood. We have a melting pot of ethnicities and ancestry that stretches all over Europe and parts of North Africa. I think the majority of us do feel a sense of British pride but first and foremost we are Gibraltarian. To answer some of the statements made in the comments. Gibraltarians, should they wish to further their educational studies, tend to go study in UK universities. Once we are there two of the most common statements or questions asked are, “are you Spanish?” Or “why do you have a welsh accent?”. Our bilingual culture and languages I think contribute to the accent and our vernacular Llanito. Llanito is what we identify ourselves as to our neighbors across the border. The llanito dialect is a mix of Andalusian Spanish laced with British English along with words borrowed from other languages, genoise, Arabic and Maltese to name a few, and to either native English speakers or native Spanish speakers it’s almost unintelligible! I think we appreciate that the majority of our culture and cuisine and lifestyle is an amazing blend of British, Spanish and Mediterranean! We wave the British flag, have British pubs and have a deep affiliation to the British forces and monarchy. Whilst also enjoying tapas, eating food late at night and spending our summers in our beaches or up the coast in Spain. It’s a unique experience to have and one I’m blessed to have and appreciate! Come to Gibraltar and see for yourself!
Gibraltar, if it’s British, should have British taxes and social welfare contributions.
They have self determination so they set their own laws on those things. Same way the UK can't tell the Isle of Man or the Channel Islands how to run their domestic affairs either.
@@CountScarlioni So it's not part of the UK then. Problem solved.
Scotland sets its own taxes and is part of britain. Gibraltars people pay taxes and social insurance and the gibraltar government pay the uk for every patient that needs hospital treatment where there isnt a specialist in gibraltars hospital. Gibraltar is self sufficient and runs itself. 99% of gibraltarians want the link with uk to remain. Its called democracy. Ask most people in la linea what the madrid governments have ever done for them
She sounds very welsh
And how terribly unlucky to sound Welsh!
Is there any apetite in Gibraltar to become an independent nation?
That girl sound Welsh to me! Hmmm..
No mistaking an awful Welsh accent!
We are still part of Europe we just don't belong in the European Union anymore. Seems like a nice young lady but feel she needs to mature a bit more.
We are still European. Leaving the EU didn't stop that.
Absolutely not the last if you call Gibraltar a colony. Many more parts are somewhat contested in Europe, Catalonia, Corsica, etc. Really good video tho!
Its not a colony because its contested. It was literally a Crown Colony. They only changed the name recently when it became less fashionable. And its on the list of NSGTs of the UN Special Comittee on Decolonization.
It is Europe`s last colony.
Catalonia a colony?! For real?! Catalonia was a coloniser. There was still Catalan slave owners in the Carribean until the 1870s....
Catalonia has never existed as an independent state in history. It used to belong to the kingdom of Aragon which joined to the kingdom of Castille by marriage in 1469 forming the kingdom of Spain. Currently is an intengrant part of Spain, one of its 17 autonomous comunities, same as Madrid or Andalusia, in fact it enjoys more privileges than many of them. It is self -governing in most issues except defense, pensions, and foreign affairs. It votes its representatives in both el Congreso and el Senado, so it is far from being a colony. Those in favour of independence are a minority.
La Linea is far nicer
Is not
Around the world there are literally billions of people who would swap with you.
I think you need to understand in modern day Britain what does British mean what ethnic background what’s your religion which part of the UK you come from?, we effectively for 2000 years have been having people from abroad, coming to live, conquering Britain, our DNA is completely mixed, at the moment. It is still overwhelmingly white, but the demographics quite literally change by the year. One example of all the people who live in London 40% were born abroad.🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧
Long Live Gib!
I’m English and I’m still pissed off about Brexit. I totally understand her frustration
The chollo has the days counted ,without papeo,bye bye Britain,the EU is not interested in more tax havens.
if you dont like it clear off to spain
The treaty of Utrecht was signed over 300 years ago. Spain should Get over it and start acting like a democracy. Because of this closed down attitude Spain is no longer a wealthy country and doesn't win Nobel prizes. It's not innovative or influential. It's not even been democracy for very long. The border was deemed to be further in to Spain than it is so Spain needs to give back that extra land. That's the reality. Look at the treaty.
Después de Gibraltar váis a salir de las Malvinas también españolas, y de la Capitanía General de la Guayana española por supuesto, que invadieron los territorios ocupados del imperio español y el continente español forma parte de España desde 1492! de Polo Norte a Polo Sur y al oeste del meridiano español
I looked at the treaty and it says it does not give territorial jurisdiction to the British. So the place is Spanish.
@@jesusbermudez6775cueta and melia has been forced to be occupied by Spanish 😂😂😂😂😂😂
the will of the people in those areas want to be Spanish@@CardiffUlster
Jajajaja dude, what a ton of nonsense.
1-In the democracy Index, Spain is position ED even better than the US, Israel, South Korea or Italy with 8,07 points, should we consider all these countries non democratic?
2-Spain is among the 15% of the richest countries by gdp per capita and among the 7% richest by nominal gdp. And it's IHD is among the top 30. Almost the same as France's. (Also, Spain has a higher life expectancy than the UK and it's Healthcare is considered to be also better... How do they do that? Magic? ).
3-It is true that it is not at the same level as other western European countries in innovations and we have problems, but calling it as if it was a third World country is lying. Yet, Spain is the second in organ transplanting activity only behind the US for example. We can also talk about AVE (the second largest High speed network in the world), countries like Saudi Arabia or Malaysia hired Spanish companish to build their High speed networks. Spain is working with France and Germany in the developement of the SCAF, a 6th gen fighter. Australia hired Navantia to build Spanish-designe F-100 destroyers and their two LHDs. Wow, I thought there was no innovation in Spain XD. Does Zara, Inditex, Iberdrola, Ferrovial, Telefónica, IAG, CASA or Indra ring bells? Nah, definetely there is no innovation in Spain.
Last but not least, the fact that the UK has or has had so many disputes with many countries around the world (Gibraltar, Falklands, North Ireland, Chagos, everything that the british museum does not want to return, all the coups and invasions, even the steriotype of the drunken tourists... we can also add the idea of being incapable or too entitled to learn foreign languages) does not make you think that maybe you are doing something wrong? Or you are too entitled to recognize it?
Labour will give it back soon
Reform
Gibraltar tiene resolución de la ONU para descolonizar desde 1968 , debido a la entrega ( por desgracia) a la Unión Europea se retrasó la descolonización, pero vamos a estar muy encima para que salgan de territorio español los colonos británicos. Ahora la soberanía la tiene el pueblo español y no les va a servir sobornar a nadie
They had a vote and they voted stay British that's democracy
Gibraltar has voted to stay with the UK, which is their human right. In the words of the UN "In the process of decolonisation, there can be no alternative to the principal of self determination". Regardless, gibraltar is more likely to become independent than it is to become spanish
@@littleshep5502 que fastidio, los colonos tienen que volver a su tierra, no votan en territorio nacional español
@@carmen2689 Well, lucky for them, they aren't in Spanish national territory. Gibraltar is a separate nation with its own territory and borders
@@littleshep5502 no, España no entrego la soberanía de ningún territorio, nunca!!!
If Spain was managed like Gibraltar is they would be far more contented.
You need all that tax haven money first 🤡
You compare a town with 35000 inhabitants which is a tax haven with a country of 47 million people. Is like comparing Dublin with France.
exactly@@dans7497he sounds dumb
@@dans7497 Monaco
@@ScorpionSuerte another option
Fueraaa.
It's embarrassing that the city across from Gibraltar has a 35% unemployment rate. Shocking that Gibraltarians don't want to join Spain.
The reason there is a 35% unemployment is precisely its proximity to Gibraltar which prevents any attempt of entrepreneurship there.
@@jonayz8655 That makes no sense. Please explain.
Gibraltar es parte de españa
Gibraltar is part of uk , and last colony is Ceuta and melilla you have to understand that , and if you ask the Spanish who work in Gibraltar they will say to you that Gibraltar it belongs to UK not spain , and viva Marruecos viva Gibraltar.
Ceuta and Melilla aren’t colonies! They’ve been an important part of Spain for over 500 years. Morocco has only existed for 50 years. It is a big difference.
The Utrecht treaty never gave territorial jurisdiction to the British. Gibraltar is Spanish.
Ceuta and Melilla are colonies ….. they are not self sufficient like Gibraltar . Europeans should really ask how a small nation of 34000 is a self governing state except for external foreign affairs …..as for the Canary and Baleárico Islands including 2 small little “enclaves” are all controlled by Madrid and are taxed !
@@jesusfriasambrona9261 neither is Gibraltar if spain wants people to repect Ceuta and Melilla as part of Spain, then Spain should recognise that Gibraltar is an British Overseas Territory because its people wish
@@jesusbermudez6775 then Ceuta is Moroccan, Gibraltar is not spain nor its people are Spanish they are Gibraltarian and British, if they wanted to be part of Spain fine, but they dont ,they want to Remain British what part of that dont you understand?
If you ever want to rejoin the EU, Spain will ask for Gibraltar territory. Forget being part of the EU forever.........
Btw: spain is behavin' as a very good partner bein' so much patient with the border controls...........thats what a real democracy does
Spain should return Olivenza to Portugal and Ceuta and Melilla to Morocco.
@@joserodrigues46 ceuta and melilla were spanish cities before morocco was a even a country.....
@@manuelfg2902 That's a typical Spanish myth. Morocco has always existed as a unified country with the name "Morocco" or any other. With regards Gibraltar, it is to their inhabitants the decision to be independent, British or Spanish. Spain cannot claim any devolution by force.
@@joserodrigues46 in that case, its also ceuta and melilla inhabitants decision, isn't it?
@@manuelfg2902 Right, so I don't understand the old narrative of Spanish politicians claiming rights to Gibraltar. I think Spain always feels uneasy about any referendum, contrary to other democratic European nations.
Gibraltar is not colony. Catalonia is colony. Free Catalonia
Gibraltar is British territory 🇬🇧❤️🇬🇮
Gibraltar is not a country. It is Spanish territory occupied by the UK.
Thank the Borboness and their immeasurable lust for power and greed.
In your dreams. The madrid government would ruin the place and the 15000 jobs that keep people in spain employed in gibraltar would be lost guaranteed
Is a part of Spain.
Gibraltar is not a country.
Should be Spanish
The UK should give Gibraltar to Morocco before Spain, because Spain has Ceuta and a couple other enclaves in Morocco
The mental gymnastics Spanish go through to pretend Ceuta & Melilla are totally dissimilar to Gibraltar.
n the past the Spanish govt has deliberately not used the UN or ICC as a means of applying pressure as it would undermine their position in Ceuta & Melilla
😂😂😂 for sure!
Ceuta used to be Portuguese first. Why not giving it to Argentina instead? 🤠
@@spaliverpool71 I'm surprised Argentina hasn't claimed Gibraltar (yet)!
@@nickbrown6457 And they could also swap Gibraltarian monkeys 🐒 for Falkland penguins 🐧
Gibraltar isn't the 'last colony' in Europe - Scotland is still and English colony!
Scotland isn't a colony
@@littleshep5502 Define Scotland. What is it?
@@ianmacrae2710 Scotland is a component country, one of four that make up the united kingdom
@@ianmacrae2710 England doesn't have a central government. Scotland cannot leave the UK without permission, with this being controlled by the UK gov. The only country which can is northern Ireland as part of the good Friday agreements.
And no, Scotland isn't, and has never been, a colony
@@littleshep5502 I’m not sure if you realise, but you have just accepted that Scotland is a colony.
The sovereign, independent country of Scotland entered into a supposedly ‘voluntary’ economic and political union with another country (there is nothing in the Treaty of Union that made it a territorial union) but you are now saying that Scotland cannot leave that ‘voluntary’ union other than with someone else’s permission. All that is required to leave a ‘voluntary’ union is to notify the other party that you are leaving. If you require anyone’s permission, it is no longer a ‘voluntary’ union and you have become a colony.
Of course England has a central government, it is called Westminster and if you don’t think it’s England’s government you can’t count. It pretty much admits to being such by the fact there is a Secretary of State for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland but no Secretary of State for England.
In 1706, Daniel Defoe (and English spy) said, ‘The Scots will be allowed to send to Westminster, a handful of men who will make no weight whatever. They will be allowed to sit there for form’s sake to be laughed at.’ And so it has proved to be.
It’s interesting you say, ‘Scotland cannot leave the UK without permission, with this being controlled by the UK gov’. The English Government defined the UK with the United Nations as ‘A Union of two countries, a principality, and a province’. Furthermore it said, Scotland Wales and Northern Ireland were self-governing and could leave the UK anytime they wished. Of course they said this because they knew if they didn’t, under the United Nation’s decolonisation statutes, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland would clearly be defined as colonies. But know you are telling me this was a lie and Scotland can only leave the 'union' with England’s permission.
Interestingly, there is a civil liberation movement in Scotland in the process of preparing to take a case to the United Nations to trigger their decolonisation statutes.
Put another way. Imagine you had a business that I wanted to take it over so I said, ‘How about we amalgamate our businesses?’ and you replied, ‘No, I don’t want to’. So I put a gun against your head, and say, ‘What about know?’ (Remember that at the time of the signing of the Treaty of Union the English had their Army amassed in Ulster and on the Scottish border and their Navy stationed in the Firth of Forth outside of Edinburgh and the English Chancellor of the day famously said, ‘It is union or war’).
So you sign up to the deal (so as not to lose your head) and in the new enterprise you get 45 shares and I get 486 (the split of representatives in the first parliament formed after the supposed union) then I put a proposal to the Board of Directors (which is you and me) that you can only leave with the Board of Directors’ permission (i.e. the equivalent of the constitution is reserved). We take a vote and lo and behold the proposal pass with 486 votes for and 45 against. Then many years from then you say, ‘This isn’t working for me, I want to leave’, to which I reply, ‘You can shut the F up and get back to your desk, I’ll tell you when you’re leaving and it ain’t going to be anytime soon!’
If you ever had any illusion you were in a partnership it has been dispelled and if you were a country you are what is commonly known as a colony.
I wish the Dutch had taken it,would have been much more beautiful,because the Dutch have taste and the building would be elegant 🇲🇦
Yes!
Like Surinam?
Just like the inner cities in uk then
If you live in Gibraltar but prefer to be Spanish then the solution is easy. Nobody is forcing you to stay.
Places like Gibraltar belongs to Spain. Like Liechtenstein, Luxemburg and Monte Carlo these places ought not to exist. In the case of monte Carlo people dont pay taxes at the cost of the normaal european taxpayer. Tax evasion between Spain and Britian in Gibraltar is common as well. Unfortunately the rich buy Politicians and therefore these taxhavens exist
😂 Monaco, as a separate country, predates the French Republic. Just like Belgium and the Netherlands are separate countries with distinct histories, Monaco has the right to decide who to take however much tax money they wish to (or not). Monaco is not part of the EU, why on earth would they owe taxes to Europeans?! 😂
You make no sense, most aren’t apart of the eu and only have agreements with the eu, from your logic Switzerland wouldn’t be independent??
Are you going to give us Olivença????
Gibraltar does not belong to Spain. You need to get your facts right.
You sound a true democrat then, where you believe people have no right to run their own affairs, unless their your own