Stihl MS150TC vs Echo CS 2511TES
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 май 2020
- We tested the Stihl MS150TC vs the Echo CS-2511TES the we picked out of the market from pro users.
MS150TC with original chain PM3 (1/4 1.1/0.043) 1.0kW, 2.6kg
CS-2511TES with original chain A4S (1/4 1.1/0.043) 1.11kW, 2.3kg
Fuel: Aspen 2 (for both machines)
Chain oil: Aspen Bio chain
Log/wood: 10x10cm Douglas (Pseudotsuga menziesii) coming from the same tree, same piece that was cut half way.
Before the test we warmed up the engines during 5 minutes (sequence:5sec. WOT/5sec idling) and we cut 2 cookies each.
Nice I just bought the 2511 echo 👍
As the owner of a new MS151TC, this is just sad. But I knew it could happen. The problem clearly is caused by the Echo gloves used with the Stihl saw 🙂 The Stihl must have more conservative "defaults" including RPMs in the wood, chain, sprocket. Also, I'm sick of seeing Stihl bend over for the EPA.
It would be interesting to see someone do a review of both saws with mods, chains, sprockets optimized for material removal on each engine. They would need to be chosen so that the expected product life is still met.
Should have alternated sides while cutting as many pieces of wood, even on the same tree vary in density. Also, not sure if this is covered in the video or description but type of chain also makes a significant difference.
I realize this video is just a quick demonstration of initial saw performance, but really you need to wait to come up with any type of conclusion until any saw has been used numerous times. The type of load you put on it, and how the carburetor is set (especially the high speed adjuster) are a couple reasons. Don't get me wrong, there certainly is value to these videos and I actually enjoy watching them when researching a product I might be interested in.
Thanks for the tip. I will try in the next one
Cheers JMOT
Привет. Подскади что лучше для себя взять штиль194 или ехо2511- ценник в них одинаковый? Питю немного 3-5 дней в год но иногда попадается дерево 50- 60см
The 194 wakes up really nice with a muffler mod and timing advance, I love my 2511t with a muffler mod but I tend to bring my 194 up for removals
Hangisi daha iyi sizce birinden cevap istiyorum
J'ai une autre question:
Je recherche actuellement une tronçonneuse pour des travaux en forêt en Afrique.
J'ai acheté deux " Stihl 08S " pour l'abattage ( je prends des ancienne car ils sont facilement dépanner sur place).
Et je j'aimerai acheter deux autres ancienne machine pour la découpe des branches d'arbres.
Quelle tronçonneuse me conseillerais- tu? (en stihl ou autre mais des anciennes machines)
Merci
Buy a new Husqvarna 395xp with a square filter cover
For the next process put on a 372xp triangular filter cover on. Tie the chainsaw on a rope & tow it without the guidebar behind your vehicle to break it in. Remove from process & restore with original components.
There's your second hand chainsaw (with scratch marks) to get across the border. ✔
Echo every time .starts easier n cuts quicker ...Why pay more for less for a stihl ...Thanks for the video
Daniel Roberts the echo shits on the 150 but you do have to drill a 1/2 inch hole through the muffler on the echo coz they are chocked up bad,make sure to go through both plates as there are two layers of metal to get through before it’s drilled properly,drill it where the plastic muffler cover opening is about an inch below original existing outlet hole.then retune the saw and they fly it will seriously eat a 150 iv used both the stihl and the echo both with muffler mods and the echo still kicked it’s ass .
This is great advice. My 2511 really woke up after the muffler mod.
I feel like that still can do better was it a brand new chain?I think it looked a little dull could’ve bit down on her a little more I feel like the guy with the echo was more an aggressive cut give the stihl another chance maybe full chisel chain see what might happen
Both were tuned according the manufacturer's standards and had a brand new 1/4 chain
Follow me for more interesting videos: ruclips.net/channel/UCik4HBvaaP8NtnfKTzgJVRQ
awesome video jan
Always echo always Japan! I own three echo and I love them
Seeing is believing !...
Las cadenas no se como estarán pero la palanca para arrancar en frío la tenía en posición de trabajo la stihl
😮😮😮😮😮🙈👏👏👏
What about weight I'm looking to buy one of these saws but I love how lightness of the stihl
The Echo is lighter. about 300grams
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining I bought the 2511t and honestly regret it should've went with 151 stihl I brought it up in the tree with me 2x and both times had to have my groundees send up my stihl 194t to get the job done
@@luluschannel9862 be interested to use a 151 after having used a poorly maintained 150t for years. 150 was trash compared to an echo 2511
@@luluschannel9862 B.S. put yur harley t shirt 😅🤣
echo budama testeresi sınıfında 1 ci motor Türkiye’de 300 dolar gibi bence fiyat performans açısındanda 1 numara
İyimi gerçekten toprağım stilden iyimi
The chainsaw e echo It might be the best tool in the world. It is very light and the chain takes many turns.
How/why is the 150(or even 151t, to be fair) such an under-performer to the 2511t? The 201t & 355t are identical specs and identical performance (+/- a few %'s in eitehr direction), I love my 355t and coveted the 2511t (that I now have) but when the time came to replace my 25cc climbsaw a few weeks ago I found myself trying *hard* to choose the 151t, I have never bought a new Stihl powerhead (untrue I got a 193 but returned it a day later) and was really trying to justify it especially with the 2511's going up to nearly $500 in my area, but just couldn't justify it no matter how I tried (and that would be true if they were the same price, even w/ the inflation of 2511 MSRP it's still below a 151t..)
Well, I think it's the result of some good Japanese Engineering.
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining Can't argue that, there's always tons of exceptions but there's certain peculiarities to german, and japanese, hardware- seems like it almost applies as nicely to BMW's&Lexus as Stihl&Echo ;D (have always preferred japanese automobiles myself! My echos have never given me problem, 1st & foremost I'm a climber & need things to start in-tree when they're cold, it can take 30min to setup a cut if it's a big limb over a house, if the saw is finicky I'd delay a job over it but my echo's - 355t w/ 18" and now 2511t w/ 12" - are all I need, and even now am never using the 355t just 2511t and then rear-handles from there!)
@@facelesspsycho8252 I certainly HATE how many 25cc units come w/ 3/8LP but you can easily upgrade that, you cannot upgrade the 150's power-output with that same level of ease...apples-to-apples, if you consider getting both, porting both, and seeing to it they both have picco chains, the 2511 still wins :/
I did genuinely want to get the 151 for my replacement 25cc, realllly tried to convince myself!
La differenza sta nell'affilatura...
Give me the echos over Any of newer stihls
Stihl more robust, but echo kicks arse!
esa comparacion pienso que esta manipulada. Esa prueba puede y tiene mucha importancia el afilado de la cadena. ademas se nota claramente .
Hola, Como mencioné en un comentario anterior, las cadenas de ambas máquinas eran nuevas. Ambos con una cadena de 1/4 1,1 / 0,043.
Test with active 39.39 ;)
Both sound cap IMHO. Be nice if they were both tuned for best performance while still standard. Also be nice if chains were optimally sharpened - or organise some bar / chain setup that can be swapped between the two. ...
Both were adjusted according the manufacturers data and had both a brand new 1/4 chain on it.
Echo shampin🎉🎉
É meglio che metti una catena nuova alla stihl ms 150 perche io possiedo entrambe le motoseghe e non c'è tutta questa differenza ha ha ha affila la catena poi vedi che taglia anche la stihl
They were both equiped with a new chain. Both had a 1/4 1.1/0.043 the Stihl with a stihl chain and the Echo with the A4S
Salut,
on m'a proposé une Ms 150 avec moteur serré à 50€. Est que ça vaut le coup de prendre ou pas?
Merci
Non, une cylindre coute 200-300 euro, donc si vous payez un peu plus vous avez une nouvelle machine.
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining
Merci beaucoup pour cette réponse
Moi je prends
Laisse tomber style je préfère acheter des déco c'est moins lourd
The Echo WOn
I knew this was filmed in the UK the second i heard the wood pigeons ahaha
Not in the UK Rory. :)
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining fuck. Europe at least?!
Yes
La echo sembra più veloce, ma entrambe le motoseghe avevano la catena nuova? Il tizio indossa guanti Echo, magari non è un video neutrale 🤷♂️
Non sono affidabili i tagli, be' sicuramente bisogna vedere come e se è affilata la catena della sthil....
Il suffit juste que la chaîne de la Stihl ai été trop tendue ce qui me semble être le cas et voilà le résultat...😅
Looks like the Echo kicked Stihls ass as usual
Maybe stihl perform better if they wear a harley davidson shirt while using it 😅🤣😅
Echo super shill in start
Sybil isn't properly tuned
Sorry sthil
Echo echo echo
Echo ALL day
I've got my 150t n two echos n my 150 pisses all over the echos
Sad to hear, a good machine always start with good maintenance and a good dealer who knows how to tune a saw. :) Do you run it on 1/4 chain (the Echo)?
No way that trash or any trash stihl are better than echo. Echos are reliable. Stihls are meant to be used for a few years and thrown away.
I have 4 echos 2 is cs2511t and 3 Stihl ms250, 194t and 170 that cs2511t kicks ass with Stihl chain, It’s my edc saw!
WRONG simon
Cs 2511etc le top com machine
ECHO CS 2511 TESC NO CS 2511 TES
A dislike for being BIAS
I don't understand why, but okay.
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining just a troll. I was boring. You ok😂
@@JanMaesOutdoorTraining i subscribed😘
Echo JAPON
haha my 150 shit on both them saws" did mess with the muffler n lean the fuel" its a little screamer now they looked blunt"
keep dreaming
Na mate the echo with simple muffler mod and retune is a faster cutting and better saw than 150 dog box shit heaps
Onu gecsen echo ya kimse kafa tutamaz
Echo new chain , stihl old chain
Stihl👎
the stihl last longer