Abhijit Iyer-Mitra: was there a secret Taliban-Ghani deal before Afghanistan's collapse ?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024

Комментарии • 323

  • @abstubeindia6979
    @abstubeindia6979 3 года назад +179

    Muslims everywhere are same they support sharia at the same time want to enjoy in liberal countries like India but keep fighting for sharia implementation. When Pakistan was formed the Muslims who supported its formation didn't go to Pakistan but stayed in liberal India

    • @chambipuranik2
      @chambipuranik2 3 года назад +3

      Very good channel.

    • @dxtnt2186
      @dxtnt2186 3 года назад +4

      Liberal countries ‘like India’ 😂😂

    • @dharmaandus6682
      @dharmaandus6682 3 года назад +2

      You are absolutely right.

    • @pappuchin3733
      @pappuchin3733 3 года назад +28

      It is liberal. It’s the country where Indian temples are desecrated, a Hindu guy named Ramalingam was murdered by 20 Muslim men for opposing their conversion campaign but not reported in media, but if someone accidentally stepped on a muslim guy’s feet it will be in CNN.

    • @dannycbe949
      @dannycbe949 3 года назад +1

      Taliban don't follow Sharia.
      The have the Pashtunwali Code

  • @soujanyamuralidhar5265
    @soujanyamuralidhar5265 3 года назад +52

    🤣🤣Abhijit's statement is hilarious about Arundhati Roy as PM,🤪🤪

  • @ansjaiswaal1553
    @ansjaiswaal1553 3 года назад +12

    This way of explanation open our eyes . great work Citti and Abhijeet Sir .

  • @arvindawasthi8222
    @arvindawasthi8222 3 года назад +63

    America did it deliberately no one mis calculated. American job is over and they left. They are business guys do not have any emotional relation with others.

    • @sunnymitra6372
      @sunnymitra6372 3 года назад +4

      Nope.......you are Wrong. Taliban was supposed to come to power after August when American Troops left.......what happened was a Total Miscalculation because now lots of things have gone wrong. Americans haven't left completely and Taliban has come to Power so swiftly that it's unbelievable.

    • @user-ge3je1oi8r
      @user-ge3je1oi8r 3 года назад +2

      @Arvind - yes, looks like.

    • @zil1832
      @zil1832 3 года назад +1

      @@sunnymitra6372 actually americans, the bidens simply doesnt care. Their fickle mind change with every administration. They intervene when they want to intervene and mess things up for others.
      Whats their stake? None! They have atlantic on the east pacific in the west; canada in the north, mexico in the south. They have no worries.
      Jo hag diya hai, wo India ko samhalna pdega ab.

    • @achuthankuttymenon4996
      @achuthankuttymenon4996 3 года назад +1

      @@sunnymitra6372 There was no resistance from Afghan Armed forces and hence it was a cake walk for Taliban and they reached Kabul at breakneck speed.

    • @cosmopessoa1556
      @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад

      Afghan Pres /Taliban deal that put a spike in the American deal. And what is wrong with a secret deal, instead of going into a brutal war, Afghans killing Afghans Foreigners getting rich on Arms supplies while Afghans bleed. Afghans giving away their mineral rights to pay for these equipment, pay foreigners for protection while The Afghans bleed financially and physically. That cycle could go on for eternity
      Should the local security fail Paying the Europeans security,(installing their forces back into Afghanistan) to protect the collateral they acquired, Brilliant move by the president if he was able to make that deal. It would mean they understood the Europeans game plan very well.

  • @av3942
    @av3942 3 года назад +35

    Welcome to the world of sharia. When will the world learn ?

    • @davydeuce
      @davydeuce 3 года назад

      Don’t declare it!! Besides-we are moving into a new AGE and with it the breaking down of old forms. The religions that came out of the Iron Age are fast crumbling. And this is all happening because the collective consciousness of our species is expanding beyond the old forms that enslaved us.

    • @nikhilprem7998
      @nikhilprem7998 3 года назад +1

      @@davydeuce only for particular set of nations, but more and more nations are joining in as time passes, but the main issue to be addressed is the population inequality and the fertility rate imbalance, specially in more backward countries, India is exception since we are developing nation not exporting terror.

  • @bijeshesthaphanose497
    @bijeshesthaphanose497 3 года назад +9

    It's time for Afghani brothers & sisters to unite and stand for them self.
    it's Time for AFGANI REVOLUTION.

  • @user-ge3je1oi8r
    @user-ge3je1oi8r 3 года назад +71

    India should allow only minorities (Hindus, Sikhs, all Sanatan Dharma communities) from Afghanistan to come to India. All Muslim countries can take the muslims. All Christian countries can take Christians from Afghanistan.

    • @vvarrunn
      @vvarrunn 3 года назад +5

      turkey and bangladesh have banned refugees from afghanistan :P

    • @Kem____paalty16
      @Kem____paalty16 3 года назад

      Yes ur right

    • @loki8096
      @loki8096 3 года назад +2

      Do you think india only belong to hindus and sikh??? Don't be a bigotry, are they not humans? Moron.

    • @THUGPUTIN
      @THUGPUTIN 3 года назад +16

      @@loki8096 Your pathetic..
      Muslims have turkey, pak, Egypt, Iran, Algeria, Indonesia, Iraq, Saudi, afghan, Morocco, Sudan, Tunisia, Bangla, Syria, Libya, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Jordan, Tajikistan, Qatar, Yemen, Mauritania, Kuwait and Chad..
      Hindu have Nepal and india as majority.. Educate yourself.. If an hindu can't say india belongs to hindu where does he belong to? Loser..
      If you have balls go to pak or Afghan or any of these countries and say do you think this country belong to Muslim/islam only"? You won't be alive to talk about humanity..
      It's not about being humans its about these countries not welcoming their own.. Why should india do that? So that one day Hindus become minority? Are u high? How does these refugees contribute to unemployment in india? I don't know if your an Indian or not.. If your an Indian please educate yourself why india has more population problem.. It's due to illegal refugees that india is failing to handle and now you want legal refugees..

    • @loki8096
      @loki8096 3 года назад +3

      @@THUGPUTIN don't try to outsmart with your little logic because majority belong to hindus you mean the country should belong to the specific religion?? Which brings me to the conclusion that this world should belong to the specific majority religion. Forgot about other countries, India is so diverse south is not like north, west is not like east, so how do you come to the conclusion that india belongs only to hindu?? So basically minorities should be separated?? You don't make sense. Those country which you mentioned are all religions country so you don't compare that to india.

  • @realhulk7034
    @realhulk7034 3 года назад +12

    I love @SALEH Amarullah ……he has the balls and grit of a true Afghan ❤️❤️❤️❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫

    • @Nuamsi
      @Nuamsi 3 года назад

      Amrullah Saleh has No Balls, Hamid Karzai is a Brave Person. He is still in Kabul, Afghanistan, While Amrullah Saleh is hiding in North Eastern Province.

  • @btmoradia
    @btmoradia 3 года назад +21

    Let them have Islam in full form..

  • @joeybenra
    @joeybenra 3 года назад +24

    NO HANDSHAKES WITH “Talibani” MONSTERS …. Never , Ever !!

  • @darkhumor6088
    @darkhumor6088 3 года назад +22

    At all we must not take Afghani Muslim as refugee and add on another refugee crisis like rohingya..
    lets start a campaign....

    • @macherie300
      @macherie300 3 года назад

      Unfortunately there are some liberal Hindus who don't understand and still want to look big hearted

  • @simmisekhar1950
    @simmisekhar1950 3 года назад +11

    American forces stayed there long enough , if Afghan forces didn’t learn in 20 yrs , then no one is responsible for there chaos but them themselves. Take the example of your own house , if you fight in your house n can’t control your own life n family , who do you think that will manage your life , your neighbor. Same goes with Afghanistan.

    • @sunitacharupalli176
      @sunitacharupalli176 3 года назад

      Simmi, I half agree with your point. My point is what for US army staying in Afghan for 20 years and spoon feeding on their live hood. How can you expect from them to stand on their own feet and fight. So whose fault is this and dumping whole Afghan insane, just asking.

    • @cosmopessoa1556
      @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад

      If some one set up a scenario for you and your family to split and fight and kill each other , while they sell you the equipment to do it Would you ? or quietly go and figure a way to ovoid that killing. ? ANSWER THAT !!!

  • @saffron1977
    @saffron1977 3 года назад +19

    West is shocked as they had planned to create civil war behind them , that didn't happen , they are shedding crocodile tears for Afghans stuck there , their real tears are for them selves as Afghans instead of fighting themselves will come after them sooner then later also they thaught they are bullymasters but realised that they have been themselves bullied badly and also militarily humiliated .

    • @AmazonWebService98
      @AmazonWebService98 3 года назад

      civil war will still have to start, there's already unhappiness inside the faction. due to the brutalness

    • @EILF7842
      @EILF7842 2 года назад

      civil war is inevitable. just wait

  • @rajneeshsharma9049
    @rajneeshsharma9049 3 года назад +48

    Americans epitomize "power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely"

    • @indiacrazyfacts2574
      @indiacrazyfacts2574 3 года назад

      No so-called refugees

    • @Abhishekaditya91
      @Abhishekaditya91 3 года назад +1

      bhai... come out of this mind set. this is 21st century. US has full r8ghts to withdraw and full rights to attack. Its us Indians who cry on everything, taking inspiration from the most stupid person gandhi. Learn something from Krishna, Learn from Chanakya, Learn from Chhatrapati ...to implement Saam, Daam, Dand, Bhed to protect, safegaurd your national interest. Arghanistan is no beauty...its the same land that attacked Indians for centuries. Yes it was in past, but for today atleast learn to put emotions aside and work professionally. US understands this skill...they if needed will sit on chair with Taliban too, because for them Taliban is also another party now. Unlike India, which will sit and cry 'vasudhaiv Kutumbakam' drama. Afghans are pastoral society...you cant teach them human rights, gandhian thinking and drama. Learn to take your interests on top... learn to promote India cause. Kashmir is at stake right n9w. India should have started talking to Taliban by now. Because they ruling Afghan land now. Else Pakistan will use opportunity.

    • @zil1832
      @zil1832 3 года назад

      @@Abhishekaditya91 no need to defend Americans. They are the one who installed ashraf ghani? Who told them to do so? Without us help, taliban wouldnt have been able to topple the Najibullah govt in the first place.

    • @Abhishekaditya91
      @Abhishekaditya91 3 года назад

      @@zil1832 You guys take pride of being Afghan who dont fall back and yet everytime a foreign party plays with you. Do onething, sort your internal matters first. Learn to fight for your own sovreignity and integrity before blaming others.

    • @zil1832
      @zil1832 3 года назад

      Abe ❤️de mein Bhartiya hun🙄🙄. Question is: Are you an American chamcha?

  • @digitalkittycat4274
    @digitalkittycat4274 3 года назад +8

    Why Ghani has to resign when he decided to flee? Who is going to consider his resignation?

  • @subhashzadoo
    @subhashzadoo 3 года назад +10

    Dear, it is shame of UN BODIES, raising issues of human rights. Human have dropped their head in shame by leaving innocent Afghans in uncontrollable environment and to the mercy it Taliban Terrorism. Mahadev Bless Us All!

  • @manabendra62
    @manabendra62 3 года назад +28

    Good one on Arundhuti Roy.

  • @CK-pc8bq
    @CK-pc8bq 3 года назад +17

    Bring uniform civil code as soon as possible in India.

  • @BSWM
    @BSWM 3 года назад +17

    This was orchestrated and planned years ago.

  • @RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA
    @RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA 3 года назад +11

    ARUNDHATHI ROY PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA ? WOW WODERFUL BEGINING SHOT BY ABHIJITH,

    • @berghoff2593
      @berghoff2593 3 года назад

      Why not Barkha as president!

  • @jaihind9290
    @jaihind9290 3 года назад +2

    Wow abhijit has tons of knowledge about Afghanistan situation

  • @Maverick_19
    @Maverick_19 3 года назад +2

    Best observation ever. Amazingly explained. Great video guys.

  • @sundipsomawar3965
    @sundipsomawar3965 3 года назад +3

    अभिजीत तूम बेहतरीन हो।
    लगे रहो।

  • @pramodkulkarni3747
    @pramodkulkarni3747 3 года назад +4

    Good Abhijit. How can I help India and my Indians?

  • @digitalkittycat4274
    @digitalkittycat4274 3 года назад +23

    Finally American's got a joker president.

    • @archiboldwindsor7447
      @archiboldwindsor7447 3 года назад

      All of them USA dummed down education 1938, their grandchildren peasants , super dumb

    • @scm50able
      @scm50able 3 года назад

      Digital kitty cat, No , Afghanisthan had a JOKER PRESIDENT. He is the one who escaped from the country leaving its citizens to become pray to the vicious Talibans . America had sacrificed money and lives for Afghans for 20 years. Americans had enough. They don’t want to sacrifice their lives anymore for the spineless Afghans. They want others to die for them . It won’t happen anymore. Enough is enough. If you want you can go and fight taliban. Okay.

  • @carrad123456
    @carrad123456 3 года назад +9

    When 3 lakh army of Afghanistan didn't fight with modern US arms , the 60-80K men of Taliban. It means those 3 lakh have same beliefs same core concept, soft corner for Taliban.
    Now who are these who are running from Afghanistan ( apart from other nationals and Afghan hindus and Afghan Sikhs) ??
    They look Afghani why they are not fighting ?? And what are their core beliefs, as they flee they need to ask themselves who are they ? What are their values.
    As women and children are not visible in pics let Afganistan ask themselves let their security ask themselves what they stand for ?

    • @pigstyoppositcowshed
      @pigstyoppositcowshed 3 года назад

      300000 ONLY ON PAYROLL BUT 100000 ON MANPOWER. CORRUPTED PIGS 🐖

  • @lataasopa8612
    @lataasopa8612 3 года назад +4

    Very well covered the issue that needs be known

  • @mehulshah4077
    @mehulshah4077 3 года назад +1

    I was waiting for Abhijit on SM. He was telling truth about the Taliban and their ground support long term ago

  • @MSCH1954
    @MSCH1954 3 года назад

    Absolutely agreed.

  • @pacificviews2796
    @pacificviews2796 3 года назад +1

    Good conversation , studied and experienced views. Good communication skills by anchor and the subject matter expert

  • @omnamahshivaya4384
    @omnamahshivaya4384 3 года назад

    Abhijit ji in his lecture brings out the most perfect picture of Afghanistan and the reality of present happenings.

  • @kunaldahale1908
    @kunaldahale1908 3 года назад +5

    Afghani youtuber is claiming that Americans took away weapons of security guards of president ghani. Ghani hasn't resigned but taken away somewhere.

  • @vyoshen4563
    @vyoshen4563 3 года назад +6

    It doesnt go well if USA says it stands with Georgia or Ukrain for human rights/freedom philosophy.

  • @ajsingh9668
    @ajsingh9668 3 года назад +1

    We must do what ever we can to help the northern alliance its indias last hope in Afghanistan ... Vande Mataram 🙏🏽🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @akmishraaable
    @akmishraaable 3 года назад +2

    Let us wait for some more surprises!

  • @Baluph
    @Baluph 3 года назад +3

    Good Job, Sharan Shetty.

  • @javiersaenz3685
    @javiersaenz3685 3 года назад +2

    The comparison of the fleeing Afghan President with Arundhati Roy is despicable.

    • @alaypatel6050
      @alaypatel6050 3 года назад +2

      Who is discipable. Ghani or roy ?

    • @swapnilsuman6426
      @swapnilsuman6426 3 года назад +1

      @@alaypatel6050well, it's a matter of huge debate

    • @user-ge3je1oi8r
      @user-ge3je1oi8r 3 года назад

      @@swapnilsuman6426 😂😂😂😂

  • @jadoogarz4973
    @jadoogarz4973 3 года назад +1

    Ashraf Ghani was a patriot and an honest person, I don't think he looted the country in the last moment of his life, I mean he is about 72yrs old. What does he need in his life

    • @cosmopessoa1556
      @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад

      Like the direction of you thoughts
      If some one set up a scenario for you and your family to split and fight and kill each other , while they sell you the equipment to do it Would you ? or quietly go and figure a way to ovoid that trap

  • @karthikvs9897
    @karthikvs9897 3 года назад +2

    Now what are the chances of UNSC intervening. just a reminder NaMo is heading it.

  • @ashokkaul3165
    @ashokkaul3165 3 года назад +4

    It is a multi level failure of American “intelligence” - in all aspects of what the term implies. The Taliban now own an Air Force and, with Pakistani assistance can paradrop mujahideen at places beyond Afghanistan borders.
    And if they so choose they could extract recognition from a dithering India by holding hostage those Indians who are unable to get out of the country in time, and by making a living hell for the unfortunate Hindus and Sikhs who remain in that benighted country.

    • @sanjayvaidya4925
      @sanjayvaidya4925 3 года назад

      Last flight left 30 min the taliban crawled in. Chill.

    • @homosapien5140
      @homosapien5140 3 года назад

      They only some aircrafts were left, up to 50 military aircraft were flown tp Uzbekistan & Tajikistan before Taliban took over kabul.

  • @123sudeepshiram
    @123sudeepshiram 3 года назад +3

    Thats what within a week fall of govt trained army falling down

  • @anmolmadaan562
    @anmolmadaan562 3 года назад +8

    Its always pleasure to listen Her Royal Highness the Archbitchess Of Mylapore.

  • @adarshguptak
    @adarshguptak 3 года назад

    I don't even want to hear Arundirty Roy and Prime minister in the same sentence

  • @86gotham
    @86gotham 3 года назад +1

    After one year of the Taliban takeover; Pakistan and China will train the Talibani fighters and send them to India as some sort of a proxy war. The other option is that the Taliban, Pakistan and China will directly attack India in a two pronged attack strategy. Either ways, India has to step up its defence budget within this critical next one year.

  • @pappuchin3733
    @pappuchin3733 3 года назад +1

    Let’s not ignore the contribution of Pakistan in all this. They trained and provided sanctuary to Taliban from the attack of US Military. This was admitted by one of the US vets stationed in Afghanistan.

    • @cosmopessoa1556
      @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад

      Not quite right ,you have to start with the American funded mujahidin who destroyed afghan families . these Afghans migrated to Pakistan for shelter where their children were fed and educated in Saudi Arabia Funded madrassas, they became you Afghan Taliban's who went back into Afghanistan and cleared out the the mujahidin who had previously abused their parents so badly in the past

  • @HindustanNewsStudio
    @HindustanNewsStudio 3 года назад

    Good work citti media

  • @Nuamsi
    @Nuamsi 3 года назад

    Amrullah Saleh is in Afghanistan Hiding, While Hamid Karzai is in Kabul living in Personal Residency. Actions of Hamid Karzai is a Brave Person.

  • @cosmopessoa1556
    @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад +1

    And what is wrong with a secret deal, instead of going into a brutal war, Afghans killing Afghans Foreigners getting rich on Arms supplies. Afghans giving away their mineral rights to pay for these equipment, pay foreigners for protection while The Afghans bleed financially and physically. That cycle could go on for eternity also Paying the Europeans for security, against the other side they would be funding, Brilliant move by the president if he was able to make that deal. It would mean they understood the Europeans game plan very well.

  • @mailnitish7
    @mailnitish7 3 года назад +1

    Arundhati Roy as PM of india. It doesn't works that way.

  • @vipulchaturvedi996
    @vipulchaturvedi996 3 года назад +3

    Strategic depth will reverse now with unification of Greater Afghanistan incorporating Khyber Pakhtunkhwa .

    • @mudassarali3292
      @mudassarali3292 3 года назад

      Lol

    • @vipulchaturvedi996
      @vipulchaturvedi996 3 года назад

      @@mudassarali3292
      Keep Lol ing
      TTP is already excercising for years Talibaan s strategic depth in Pakistan

  • @prasadpopuri9019
    @prasadpopuri9019 3 года назад +1

    Western Christian nations have no business to interfere in internal affairs of any country. They have no business to impose their ideas on any peoples. USA have met humiliating defeat in Vietnam, Iraq and now Afghanistan. If Afghans donot like Taliban, Afghans themselves fight.

  • @malliksharma
    @malliksharma 3 года назад +1

    Most probably so - Ghani can take his money and luxurious products out of country and live in comfort but should leave power 'peacefully' to Taliban - the DEAL!

  • @Abhishek-ef2er
    @Abhishek-ef2er 3 года назад +1

    Is it possible that America wants to use taliban against China in xingiang, therefore they have played with two edged sword? IDK they might be.

  • @cityofjoy8830
    @cityofjoy8830 3 года назад

    Earlier Abhijit was saying taliban can never occupy 🇦🇫.

  • @anthonytibbings4047
    @anthonytibbings4047 3 года назад +4

    This was planned way earlier. And no doubt this was no brain child of Ghani but was obviously choreographed by russia and pak.

    • @thrinethran2885
      @thrinethran2885 3 года назад

      None from the former regime were directly part of the American negotiations. It is unlikely that they will or can be manipulated by others : In fact China Russia and Pak have conflicting interests.

  • @simmisekhar1950
    @simmisekhar1950 3 года назад +1

    Only people of that country n the leaders of the country should be blamed. No country will permanently take the responsibility of any other country. America did its own job, spent money , infrastructure, troops training etcs. But the extremely corrupt leaders of the country led the country to chaos.

  • @dhruv2340
    @dhruv2340 3 года назад

    Very nice analysis 👌

  • @rudhisundar
    @rudhisundar 3 года назад +1

    This guy had said that Taliban cannot take over Kabul so easily, it will take long for them!

    • @locomotive43
      @locomotive43 3 года назад +3

      He accepted that on twitter..
      But we need to not believe everything that these analyst... They use their media presence and clout for their own professional advancement

    • @PallavaKingdom
      @PallavaKingdom 3 года назад +8

      Bro he is analyst not god ..he make predictions ...based on points

    • @mrgyani
      @mrgyani 3 года назад +2

      He already answered that - it seems there was some deal with the taliban, there was virtually no fight. Armymen were asked to abandon posts, surrender.
      There are afghan armymen who are tweeting about this in detail. There are governors who are tweeting about this.
      This is how taliban won bloodless, without any fight.
      He stands by his prediction - that afghan army had the capacity to fight them for at least 6 months.

  • @swarnasreevikranth778
    @swarnasreevikranth778 3 года назад +1

    Those young Afghan’s who were running after airplane fear that the new taliban regime will force them to take up jihad. Hence trying to leave the country as soon as possible.

  • @simmisekhar1950
    @simmisekhar1950 3 года назад +3

    America can’t be blamed, it came there , accomplished it’s job, can’t secure Afghanistan for ever, corrupt Afghan forces n the leaders should be blamed for the chaos.

  • @sukhbirnaidu4360
    @sukhbirnaidu4360 3 года назад

    Interesting

  • @subhashpattoor440
    @subhashpattoor440 3 года назад

    It is sure,a deal was reached between Ghani &Taliban.Ghani was a corrupt, treacherous ruler,army officers simply handed over provinces,abandoned weapons.

  • @ayubshaikh9156
    @ayubshaikh9156 3 года назад +1

    Wait and watch………. Very wise , logical conclusion……
    He has a good grasp of Afghan psysche……

  • @rizwansyed7714
    @rizwansyed7714 3 года назад

    CIA,RAW,NDS,MOSSAD AND CHINESE AGENCIES were in Afghanistan for their influence while ISI and talibans were fighting for their existence and survival.. thats the reason that ISI and talibams won while others lost...

  • @RaviDe3371
    @RaviDe3371 3 года назад

    2020 BC mind sets rule returns to power. Sad for the creative progressive and 21st century mindsets of Afghanistan, who could have spearheaded the country's move to modernity.

  • @macherie300
    @macherie300 3 года назад

    I wish arundati roy was prime minister of Afghanistan

  • @kaushikb16
    @kaushikb16 3 года назад +2

    Insightful. Thanks

  • @samirsrivastava1047
    @samirsrivastava1047 3 года назад

    Arundhati Roy analogy is too good.

  • @vipulchaturvedi996
    @vipulchaturvedi996 3 года назад +1

    Ghani avoided the bloodbath in Afghanistan he should not be berated for it.
    Had he taken an opposite decision Taliban would still take-over.
    It is more farsighted.
    Expect a united Afghanistan now.

    • @aditid25
      @aditid25 3 года назад +1

      Agree with you if ghani govt had resisted Pakistan would have got a free hand in Afghanistan in the name of "helping"

    • @mrgyani
      @mrgyani 3 года назад +1

      I think so too. He would have been captured and killed.. I don't blame him for leaving.

    • @vipulchaturvedi996
      @vipulchaturvedi996 3 года назад +1

      @@aditid25
      Also if the outgoing and in coming elements integrate, which they will, astrong Afghanistan will repudiate and claim Khyber Pakhtunkhwa separated by artificial Durand line.
      Taliban has no love for Pak considering the way they have sold them and cooperated In past with US to obliterate them.
      Those celebrating in Pakistan will soon have tragedy of great magnitude falling on their heads.

    • @aditid25
      @aditid25 3 года назад

      @@vipulchaturvedi996 agree... The Taliban today are seeking world recognition as a legitimate regime... Which I think is going to happen gradually if they co-operate...

  • @tumpakoli
    @tumpakoli 3 года назад

    100% true.

  • @geetindo3593
    @geetindo3593 3 года назад +2

    Arundhati roy😂😂

  • @manoharpatil6795
    @manoharpatil6795 3 года назад

    Abhijit ji what is the future of Indian muslim will they join Taliban with activities like raising funds and recruiting youths to take active part in wars.
    Regards.

  • @arnipskumar3245
    @arnipskumar3245 3 года назад

    Hope India takes precautions and end up taking refugees like in Bangladesh 🙏

  • @saumyajitbhaduri1083
    @saumyajitbhaduri1083 3 года назад

    AIM seems to have high profile contacts in every country. Banao isko Foreign minister 🙏🏽🤣

  • @dhanlad9649
    @dhanlad9649 3 года назад +1

    Secret Us and taliban deal

  • @PrakashSingh-lt1kz
    @PrakashSingh-lt1kz 3 года назад +2

    It’s strange that talibani captured Afghanistan without much resistance by Afgan army.Governors invited taliban militias to takeover the state.

  • @ranganathaniyengar6555
    @ranganathaniyengar6555 3 года назад

    Taliban should not misuse ISLAM for their own wrong rules and regulations. Not to trouble the innocent woman, children's,and man .if they misuse finish the suvvar shaitan's once for all by American politicians. They created Taliban. Now their job to finish them. CIA to take care of the Afghanistan people. Allah oh Akbar.

  • @shivaghuge6585
    @shivaghuge6585 3 года назад +2

    Now Bharat is surrounded by Islam and Hindus are sandwiched (Taliban, Pakistan,Bangladesh, Maldives) and in State (Kashmir, Kerala, West Bengal and Assam).

  • @bigmac4417
    @bigmac4417 3 года назад +1

    What has A. Roy to do with it?

    • @vammukittu
      @vammukittu 3 года назад

      Haha hi Arundhati ji, 😂 found your youtube alt I guess

  • @bholebaba5664
    @bholebaba5664 3 года назад

    Didn't Abhijit say that Taliban won't takeover Afghanistan...😑😑😑

  • @gim.deepakreddy2598
    @gim.deepakreddy2598 3 года назад

    Congratulations to Taliban and its supporters.
    Way to go.
    Next target must be to Liberate Uyghurs in China, rid Pakistan of the corrupt and impure, stake claim to Iran, to relive the old glorious Caliphate days, then central Asia and on👍.
    👌👌👌👌👌
    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @divyachengappa6650
    @divyachengappa6650 3 года назад +1

    Very good discussion and views

  • @musicmania1959
    @musicmania1959 3 года назад

    The women and children have enjoyed freedom for 20 years. How can they accept barbarians now. AM needs to make a reality check.

  • @Charanms
    @Charanms 3 года назад

    Amrualla Saleh is the only hope for Afghanistan. A solid guy who knows what he is talking about because he has fought and seen it first. hand the Talibans during 1990s along with his mentor and leader Ahmad shah massoud.

  • @prasadrn5896
    @prasadrn5896 3 года назад

    Looking back, your video seem to be the closest to what is unraveling.

  • @577Pradeep
    @577Pradeep 3 года назад

    Looks scary.. We need patriotic leader in 2024 again not farex eating baby...Please vote for leader who is patriotic towards country.. lets sleep peacefully & eat 3x meals.Vote wisely.

  • @drkarangupta4752
    @drkarangupta4752 3 года назад

    Even if the taliban become unified and allow pak to extract..where will the money come from to invest...khud ke khane ke toh paise nhi hain aur invest karenge

  • @anilchaudhary448
    @anilchaudhary448 3 года назад

    Why India should worry about Afghanistan future. Support Saleh and waste more money for afghan cause. Just stay away from Afghanistan and let Afghan come out and fight for their country . Then only real Afghanistan will emerge

  • @a.kkumar260
    @a.kkumar260 3 года назад

    No strong " all country united outfit " work for humanity,is the main issue.....😪
    Humans taken over by animals in some forests.....😯

  • @venkris5226
    @venkris5226 3 года назад

    Af-pak is a part of Bharat. Only when Islam is driven out of South Asia can we see peace in the region. Afgans leaving should be asked to quit Islam and come back to Dharma - their original way of life. 🙏

  • @kumarsiva5843
    @kumarsiva5843 3 года назад +2

    This is your theory but you have no facts to back it..

  • @bhaswatiroychoudhury5515
    @bhaswatiroychoudhury5515 3 года назад

    Abhijit Iyer Mitra 😃 I thought only women use 2 surnames, father’s and husband’s......but men?

  • @sameer15787
    @sameer15787 3 года назад

    Hindustan is for Hindus and I think India should be Semi-Secular.. except for Muslims all other religions should have voting rights and right to be in government.. Muslims have already got country based on their religion . And that is Pakistan... so now India is for Hindus and other religions living in peace

  • @bharatpandit4796
    @bharatpandit4796 3 года назад

    Ahmedshah Masoodi and Najibullah’s are the most popular posters being sold in the streets of Kabul.

  • @sfarooq2540
    @sfarooq2540 3 года назад

    As Pakistanis I agree with some stuff but some stuff is superficial... Yes Pakistan will like Indian interest to be zero in Afghanis which already did. Yes Pakistan doesn't have full control of Taliban. No Pakistan is not interested in Afghanistan minerals or any resources... Yes Pakistan is concerned about TTP but almost all border is fenced now.

  • @BSWM
    @BSWM 3 года назад

    Why is India in talks with the Taliban.

  • @somdarpo6178
    @somdarpo6178 3 года назад

    no fight, no blood shed in this war?...sold out all war leaders and politicians? how much was paid and whom..which country paid to take over afghan army...wondering

    • @cosmopessoa1556
      @cosmopessoa1556 3 года назад

      Afghans came together ,to stop killing themselves, while other people get rich on the arms they used to kill Afghans. Smart very smart. Now they will have to find another killing field some place else. I think it would be nice to have the Chinese and the Indians go at it, but the Chinese are too smart to fall for that move. Africa looks about ready, but they don't yet have the volume to generate a good money making war.

  • @kondraswapnil
    @kondraswapnil 3 года назад

    Abhijeet talks about someone like he live with that person,no need to say anything personally provide your analysis as we are interested only in that.

  • @mg9854
    @mg9854 3 года назад +2

    More than 74% people following Islam in India believe that Sharia should also be implemented here! So it's just a matter of time if we also see such scenes here in India...

    • @indianallways5720
      @indianallways5720 3 года назад +3

      It will happen when the Khangress rule comes. Khangress and the Italian lady are hand in glove to topple NDA and make India another muslim nation😙😙

    • @mrgyani
      @mrgyani 3 года назад +1

      The recent pew survey says otherwise. The no of Ms who are not 100% sure about religion is double that of Hindus..
      I don't understand why Indian RW is hell bent on generalizing and stereotyping every Indian M.

    • @darkprince2490
      @darkprince2490 3 года назад +2

      @@mrgyani pew survey is by americans and through american lens. indians have a long civilizational memory which says not to trust the words of any adherent of cult islam.

    • @vammukittu
      @vammukittu 3 года назад

      @@darkprince2490 this!

  • @y4ip2288
    @y4ip2288 3 года назад +1

    Nice analysis 🙏🏻