I watched both musicals and i loved them both. I miss Yuya as Sebastian, but the actor they got for him was amazing! I will say the acting was different but the music and voices of everyone was amazing to watch
// Anime Otaku // it used to be on RUclips. That's where I watched all the musicals but now they are no longer on there. The musical that this is from is pretty easy to follow. If you have read the manga or watched the show. Its the Jack the Ripper case turned into a musical. Why did they take it off...!? T^T
This song is the reason why I fell in love with Kuromyu and it's still my favorite song out of all the songs in the musical! (Though Campania main them comes in second!)
youtube take down the 2014 ver.. i miss it, and even though its a raw.. i wish they upload it again. 2014 ver is more cool than 2015.. (idk. pls dont kill me, since i really do like the 2014 becuz of the harmony off everyone. not like that 2015 is a bit over...
Hasta que el algoritmo de RUclips funciona a mi favor :v y pensar que apenas voy a ver este vídeo comparativo de los musicales de kuroshitsuji después de 4 años xD Me preguntó si la autora Yana asistirá a los musicales (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.)
The dancing is beautiful and well done, the echoing is annoying a tad, the acting is amazing, the singing great. Only thing wrong with it is the echoing.
Yes, most clips were taken down a couple months ago and I think they're still on top of new uploads. It's a miracle this one survived as it is. (The reason it's still here, may be because of it's double audio...)
GRELL!!!!!! Sorry i love grell so much. i mean how could u not love a red-headed, flamboyant, chainsaw wielding, green eyed grim reaper? HES LEGIT SEX ON A STICK so back it up y'all. he's mine
マダムの完成度高いよな
これは本当に泣ける……
この時代が1番好き。
人生で初めて観に行ったミュージカルがこの作品で本当に良かった。
どっちも本当に素敵で切なくて号泣不可避…
個人的には、
2014 ver.の舞台装置やアンサンブルさんの動きが好きだけど
2015 ver.はマダムに対するグレルの反応が違って、何とも上手く表現できないんだけども、、、マダムへの愛情みたいなもの?が垣間見えるような気がして何度も見ちゃう。8:45 と 9:01 の目線とか。自分で殺してはいるんだけど、グレルがマダムの死をその後も引きずる分には思い入れがあった感じが表現されてる気がして…
グレル役の人凄い……
めっちゃ分かります😢
The way she perfectly hit that final note and switched it to a desperate scream, TALENTED QUEEN
声はズレていても歌はほぼいっしょってすごいな!
なんか、良い意味で演出っぽい。
両方ともあかねさんなんだけどマダムが二人いるみたい✨
レディレッド好き…
かっこよすぎるしこれ生で見たら絶対泣く
マダムレッド毎回子宮あたりを押さえるのが悲しい
2015の生執事観に行った時このシーンマジ泣きした。
2015年のマダムレッドの歌い方が哀愁ましてますね...
同時再生すると「シエル シエル 愛しい子」の2回目のシエルでハモるんだね…(;_;)
マダムレッドと姉さんの録音の声は一緒なんだね、
かっこいいなぁー
この方のマダム大好き😭マジ泣きした、、、、
2014年を動画で見て2015年生で見たけど、マジで鳥肌立ったし泣けた
聞くたびに泣きたくなる
2015の方がグレルさんがマダムに対しての愛情を感じられる
悲しそうな顔してたりとかしてめっちゃよき
2015の方が、グレルがマダムレッドに愛情がある気がする。
個人的に2014の方が好き😘AKANEさん見た目も声も、全部マダムレットにそっくりでクオリティ高くて、もう本物ですか!大好き♡♡♡♡
クロミュじゃない。生執事
激しく同意!黒ミュとかクロミュって言われると「違う!」ってこだわってしまいます。生執事です!!
ああ、そう、実は生執事ですね。英語では生執事がいつも「クロミュ」と呼んでいるんだから、なんか日本語でもそういう呼び方が使ってしまいました。でも日本語では、やっぱ「生執事」使う方がいいですね
公式が生執事推奨してますからね……
Her vocals are so beautiful--- I'm in love
14年最高だよな…。今年初めてミュージカル見に行くけど…このクオリティかな
2014も2015も観に行ったけどほんとにこのシーンは泣ける…
再再演して欲しいけど、当時のキャストが素晴らしかったからなのもあるし、寄宿学校編でもキャスト変わってるし、今やるとなるとまた総入れ替えだろうから、このクオリティに持っていくのは難しいのかもしれない…🥲
シエルも好きだけどマダム・レッドも好きになったこの動画を見て
この人のマダムレッド本当に良く再現されてる…感情が伝わってきて感動して号泣してしまいました!!(´;ω;`)
どっちも素敵
I wish they hadn't took the video's down I really love these types of musical :'(
Dezi Nana
Same like I’m actually really sad I never got a chance to watch them
初めて見ました。泣いた。
I watched both musicals and i loved them both. I miss Yuya as Sebastian, but the actor they got for him was amazing! I will say the acting was different but the music and voices of everyone was amazing to watch
andrea padilla Omg! iam too late but where did you watch it, I only watch behind the scenes did it have subtitles?? plsss reply ^_^
// Anime Otaku // it used to be on RUclips. That's where I watched all the musicals but now they are no longer on there. The musical that this is from is pretty easy to follow. If you have read the manga or watched the show. Its the Jack the Ripper case turned into a musical. Why did they take it off...!? T^T
Luna Padilla
Stupid question but is there an English sub on the dvd
i love this song so much and it makes me cry everytime i hear it. its so beautiful
カメラワークと演出は2015だけどアンサンブルは2014だな〜
This song is the reason why I fell in love with Kuromyu and it's still my favorite song out of all the songs in the musical! (Though Campania main them comes in second!)
Chills the entire time, this was stunning to watch
This song shows the pain and insanity of Madame Red, how Lady Red is called in German.^^
Yay ein Deutscher Fan😍
生執事見ていてミスキャストに合ったことほとんどないな
もともと素晴らしいけど2015は鳥肌モノや…
1年でよりマダムレッドになってる
グレル・マダムの演技、歌込みで2015の方が好きだけど、映し方撮り方は2014の方がすき……
無理……泣く
I wish they would really release instrumental tracks for all of their musicals.
久しぶりにまた見たけど、また泣いた😢⤵⤵ 見るたびにうるうるする(´・ω・`)
凄い演技力だと思う✨
ほんと大好き
I love how Grell killed her to shut up. xD
I know why she was killed, but Grell had enough of it.
Yeah I know...
She wouldn’t kill her nephew
oh wow you just unlocked a memory i didn't know i had wtf
再再演してくだしあ・・・
2014の方が好き。赤いライト使ってるのがいい。アンサンブルのセリフもうまい
何回見てもこのシーンは泣けます(ó﹏ò。)↷↷
2014の方が好きです(*´˘`*)
4分1秒あたりの「火事だー!!!」が岡本信彦たんの声に聞こえた
く く そうなんだー!!知らなかったです!!わざわざありがとうございます😭😭
5年越しから失礼します!コメントが消えていてわからないのですが、なんていっていたのですか!?気になるので教えていただきたいです🙇♀️
youtube take down the 2014 ver.. i miss it, and even though its a raw.. i wish they upload it again. 2014 ver is more cool than 2015.. (idk. pls dont kill me, since i really do like the 2014 becuz of the harmony off everyone. not like that 2015 is a bit over...
RuKoiN iKoRu
Now all versions are gone and it’s all I want
これは切なすぎる(T^T)
great video but the echo is killing it
It’s not an echo it’s a comparison of 2014 & 2015 of the same musical it’s to show you what they did differently
リコリスは彼岸花のこと。
I love Akane Liv 💗💗💗💗
Can't wait for Joker cinematic record in naohs ark musical
Hasta que el algoritmo de RUclips funciona a mi favor :v y pensar que apenas voy a ver este vídeo comparativo de los musicales de kuroshitsuji después de 4 años xD
Me preguntó si la autora Yana asistirá a los musicales (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.)
あの人→あなた
良いね
Helpless/Satisfied in a nutshell
ทั้งๆที่ฉันเสียทุกอย่างแล้ว ทำไมต้องกลับมาด้วย....
2014年は演技の表現
2015年は歌い方がうまい気がする
一個人的痛苦
The dancing is beautiful and well done, the echoing is annoying a tad, the acting is amazing, the singing great.
Only thing wrong with it is the echoing.
Le Boring its not an echo they're comparing the 2 musicals 2014 and 2015
I LOVE YOU
Where did you find 2014 version?
Somewhere... I really don't remember where. ^^ I'm sorry I can't be of any help to you.
Amaris Okay, thanks anyway.
you can find on torrents subbed :)
Oooo, where did you find 2015 version 😍
Somewhere on tumblr
I cry ##
wish it was just one audio why cant I find another clip with one scene and one audio D: waaaah did youtube take them down
Yes, most clips were taken down a couple months ago and I think they're still on top of new uploads. It's a miracle this one survived as it is. (The reason it's still here, may be because of it's double audio...)
blaaah XD they dont want us to enjoy anything
I have the dvd of kuroshitsuji musical 1 and 2 and can't find the scene.
Is it in the 3 ;-; ? Does it exist somewhere? (Dvd?)
Late reply but, yet... this is the 3rd musical (or 4th & 5th, depending on how you count) . It's available on DVD and Blu-Ray (try CDJapan)
Ann... i love u so much
美しい!しかし、2 つのビデオのうち 1 つから音声を削除した方が良かったので、均等になっていたでしょう。
GRELL!!!!!! Sorry i love grell so much. i mean how could u not love a red-headed, flamboyant, chainsaw wielding, green eyed grim reaper? HES LEGIT SEX ON A STICK so back it up y'all. he's mine
She doesn't like being called he, you already lose ;)
うぅ…😢
Madame red;-; el 2014
黒ミュと生執事の違いがわからないㅠㅠ
ちょん ちょん 同じだけど公式でミュージカル黒執事のことを生執事と呼んでいます
耳がぶぅあんぶぅあんする~_(+Д+_`)
I like 2014 much better
2015. It's more powerful
2014 was better in my opinion. ;v;
I like the 2014's better