NingNing is far more technical than Winter. Better technique, whole register chest support and tonal skill. Her vibrato is her strength and she have the best low register in the entire 4th gen. Since she's one of the two vocalist who can carry support down to G3 consistently and F#3 at best.
@@Riize-q9m isn’t it the same? I mean, technical skill is required for live singing. You are dancing and singing at the same time. At that moment it comes down to technique and chest support to maintain your tone and breathing.
It's about stability of vocal not techniques. And its good to acknowledge winter for her live stable vocal. And why your ass is burning that ningning isn't mentioned 😂😂. Why you ningning fans are so selfish please grow up man try to acknowledge other member also.
not get good training? literally everyone except for wonhee trained for like 4 years each. Yall love to make excuses for ur precious idols just accept that they aint good and move on geez
@@wintvibes stop i am not even trying to defend my idols. i do not eve stan illit . and you need to accept the fact that it is more of the company fault that they debuted these girls who needs more training and now the members are facing extreme backlash. you need to know the difference between hating and criticizing and also the difference between presenting opinion and blindly defending the idol🙄
@dronecamera0017 not you saying you're presenting your own opinion but also at the same time be like "yOu nEEd tO aCcEpT tHe fAcT tHaT iT iS tHe cOmpAny'S fAuLt" lmao 💀
@@wintvibes look it's very easy to understand and the thing is that i don't stan illit but still hating on the girls is unfair as it is not in their hand that when they will debut. It's all in the hands of company so we should call out to HYBE for debuting a group that is not prepared yet!
I feel like I’ll it is sorta like le serrafim from debut because le serrafim was criticized when they first debuted because the vocal tone was to low for them so they struggled as well as ill it not saying all of them but especially Moka and Iroha they have low parts that may be to hard for them because they haven’t had enough vocal training
How can illit be that bad if they can't sings they better do rap but can't do anything so they better get hate they deserve it. How do they pass the audition?
When it's moka or illit who literally debuted the past Month it's so horrible and they Talentless but when it is Shuhua who debuted from 6 years and she Literally the same horror as 1 mouth debuted she slayed well Just know that the fault is not in them in you
the fact that u said moka was the worst live vocalist means that u don’t even know illit😂, moka is a very good live performer when hybe puts it in her range. the worst would be iroha because she cannot hold her notes all the way though. even then illit are still very good vocalists.
She was having fun and imo, she DOES have the potential to be better, but it's sad her company doesn't give her enough training to develop her vocal cords properly, that "boyyy" part was so painful to hear because it's so wobbly, she's the weakest in the group (no surprises, it's usually J-Kpop idols that are the weakest in the group due to their inability to support and avoid nasality)
tbh seeing moka vocals i started to question her performances in ru next, cuz in r u next she have pretty good vocals and even when she dance hard, the vocal still insane, did r u next use autotune for most contestant in r u next
Miyeon solo stans / akgaes are dxmb. First, ask the professionals what Live Vocals and Live (Performance) Stability mean. (uneducated clowns) Witnesses of the sect of 'Support'... (Lmao) And yes, Soyeon is one of the best vocalists in the group. Better than Yuqi & Minnie.
the thing with illit is that they need songs in a comfortable vocal range and style. in the beginning it seemed they were all struggling to sing live
Frr I hate these type of people it's not their fault that hybe doesn't give them song ACC to their vocal range
It's not even that hard even a person who can't sing can be stable while standing💀
@@Wintereggspayes I can sing this song even without vocal lesson
@@Arigon07can you speak Korean?
No you don’t!😊
@@Wintereggspafr keep making excuses for them
*aespa an all rounder group* 🛐
Soyeon being the main rapper with best vocals just proves she's an all rounder!!
@Ryunaselibest live vocals then no big deal?
@RyunaseliSHE IS CARRYING CUBE ENTERTAINMENT.....NO DOUBT
@@atulrajkonwar4846LOUDER ‼️‼️
Okay but shuhua still slayed
edit: have y'all heard 5th gen encore stages ? why are y'all so mad
not really she was ok
@@ventaliqShe slayed
well no……
she cant even do her job properly
ur standards are low..
I feel bad for them some of them did not get enough training 😢
Wintah's voice is so soothing to listen! I love her vocals and voice tone🤍💟
Aespa elite 💫
While our EVERGLOW slaying their live vocal in this Zombie era😘
Onda improved a lot!!
minju’s singing>>>>>
NingNing is far more technical than Winter. Better technique, whole register chest support and tonal skill. Her vibrato is her strength and she have the best low register in the entire 4th gen. Since she's one of the two vocalist who can carry support down to G3 consistently and F#3 at best.
It's about best live vocalist not technically wise
It's acc to the stability of the idol
@@Riize-q9m isn’t it the same? I mean, technical skill is required for live singing. You are dancing and singing at the same time. At that moment it comes down to technique and chest support to maintain your tone and breathing.
It's about stability of vocal not techniques. And its good to acknowledge winter for her live stable vocal. And why your ass is burning that ningning isn't mentioned 😂😂. Why you ningning fans are so selfish please grow up man try to acknowledge other member also.
@@Riize-q9m That's the same thing though? If ningning sings live technically better than she sings live better.
Everyone in G-Idle sings well, in fact. Shuhua's vocal is usually better than it was in the video showed.
Soyeon being main Rapper, still slay as all rounder 💚 A real Super Lady
Queen is back to slay again!!
Gidle all have the best vocals . Don't hate one my fav group and my bias . She slayed.
How tf is she hating?
@@Lucindamagami she said she's the worst vocalist can't u tell 🙄
AESPA MY GURLS 🔛🔝
Caught you in a minute ❤
BRO SHUHUA SLAYED!!!💗☠️☠️☠️
the others had to help her
I feel bad for moka, and of course illit..... Why to hate the group? It's although their company's fault! Illit doesn't deserve this forced hate..
ningning is main vocalist.......
We know. But it is about who has most stable live vocal. And ofc everyone knows that winter has the best live vocal.
guys i request do not hate on illit members , criticize the company as it is not the girls fault if they did not good training
not get good training? literally everyone except for wonhee trained for like 4 years each. Yall love to make excuses for ur precious idols just accept that they aint good and move on geez
@@wintvibes stop i am not even trying to defend my idols. i do not eve stan illit . and you need to accept the fact that it is more of the company fault that they debuted these girls who needs more training and now the members are facing extreme backlash. you need to know the difference between hating and criticizing and also the difference between presenting opinion and blindly defending the idol🙄
@dronecamera0017 not you saying you're presenting your own opinion but also at the same time be like "yOu nEEd tO aCcEpT tHe fAcT tHaT iT iS tHe cOmpAny'S fAuLt" lmao 💀
@@wintvibes look it's very easy to understand and the thing is that i don't stan illit but still hating on the girls is unfair as it is not in their hand that when they will debut. It's all in the hands of company so we should call out to HYBE for debuting a group that is not prepared yet!
@@wintvibes 4 years training.. For what exactly?
aespa❤❤❤❤❤🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🤟🤟🤟🤟
Unrelated but whats the title of the song in the intro?
midas touch by kiss of life!
Aespa 100% is ningning. She has the most stable and gorgeous tone. Just watch the savage encore and you’ll see…❤️❤️
I feel like I’ll it is sorta like le serrafim from debut because le serrafim was criticized when they first debuted because the vocal tone was to low for them so they struggled as well as ill it not saying all of them but especially Moka and Iroha they have low parts that may be to hard for them because they haven’t had enough vocal training
aespa the best 4th gen group
You could take any random kid off the street and they'd sound better than Moka, it's really important to stress that idol ≠ singer
aespa vocal Queens ❤
aespa all rounders
Magnetic is just not in Moka’s range, she sang “When we disco” with Jyp and sounded so much better
Ningning is the better Live Vocal tied with Winter
First
Pin?
feel bad for moka Hybe is annoying
Shuhua still slayed it proves how gidle is multi-talented gg
How can illit be that bad if they can't sings they better do rap but can't do anything so they better get hate they deserve it. How do they pass the audition?
Slaypa
which is the first group and song?
group: Kiss Of Life
song: Midas Touch
You mean the intro?
@@starbald3895 yeh
Boy 🐑🐑🐑
when i saw you put ningning's fancam for worst, i panicked
All are good
oh my god. gen 5 kpop. illit :)))) vocal.
AESPA. >>> 🧚✨💅🫶
The reason some of them don’t have a good voice is Becuase they didn’t get enough training 😢
When it's moka or illit who literally debuted the past Month it's so horrible and they Talentless
but when it is Shuhua who debuted from 6 years and she Literally the same horror as 1 mouth debuted she slayed well Just know that the fault is not in them in you
the fact that u said moka was the worst live vocalist means that u don’t even know illit😂, moka is a very good live performer when hybe puts it in her range. the worst would be iroha because she cannot hold her notes all the way though. even then illit are still very good vocalists.
Moka is not bad, the parts that are given her doesn’t suit her vocal range, but she is the least best in her group.
Moka is in the top2 weakest vocalists of her group
She was having fun and imo, she DOES have the potential to be better, but it's sad her company doesn't give her enough training to develop her vocal cords properly, that "boyyy" part was so painful to hear because it's so wobbly, she's the weakest in the group (no surprises, it's usually J-Kpop idols that are the weakest in the group due to their inability to support and avoid nasality)
in illit, yunah is best
best live vocalist aespa is ningning
Moka improved
i am still wondering how is it possible that shuhua has debuted. SHE JUST CAN’T SING WTF. it is like a random girl starting singing for fun
moka is js kpop's worst live vocalist (opinion.)
To be fair, Shuhua's training time was very short. She couldn't even speak Korean well when she debuted.
OK but it's 6 years now 🙂
+ the same as moka but the defense is that moka debuted 1 month ago so please stop making excuses
@@hadjer0.0the thing is moka can still sing tho but the other one can't
@@offgun5708 the thing is they jest want to hate no matter what but when it's their fav it's OK
*g idle soyeon?? No, it's miyeon.*
"live"
@@elfy2006 *I know live, but Miyeon is better than Soyeon at singing live. Listen to her singing in Super Lady and Fate.*
@@LOBIRORY Both are good
@@LOBIRORYtwo songs, *TWO SONGS* . Most of the time IT IS Soyeon.
@@LOBIRORYSoyeon is the one who is the most stable and clearly heard live in Gidle
tbh seeing moka vocals i started to question her performances in ru next, cuz in r u next she have pretty good vocals and even when she dance hard, the vocal still insane, did r u next use autotune for most contestant in r u next
Miyeon solo stans / akgaes are dxmb. First, ask the professionals what Live Vocals and Live (Performance) Stability mean. (uneducated clowns) Witnesses of the sect of 'Support'... (Lmao) And yes, Soyeon is one of the best vocalists in the group. Better than Yuqi & Minnie.
The fact Shu wasn’t even bad either
You guys really are tone deaf
@@offgun5708 it’s ok to be hater, we know you couldn’t do anywhere near as good 🫶
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
In Illit all are worst
Moka the worst vocal
Jisoo worst BP
Wtf?
in gidle the best is yuqi
in aespa winter is the worst
Hahaha you means winter has best live vocal. Thank you.❤