For someone who has no experience in makeup whatsoever, this is really helpful! I know a lot of people are complaining how you talk too much, but for me at least, it helped me since this is basically my introduction to makeup. So thank you!
does anyone else have the issue of the eye that's on the same side as their dominant hand (e.g. right) coming out perfectly and the other (left) coming out shit :(
I know that this is going to be hard to believe, but I'm 52 and I was quite "tomboyish" through most of my life. No one really ever taught me how to put on makeup and I'm using liquid eyeliner for the first time ever. Oh, btw...I live in a tent and don't have the best lighting or the best mirror. I can tell that you have a lot of patience and you did a wonderful job on this tutorial. When you started talking about making the wing and pretending that your bottom lash line continues...well, I got that! Great explanation! Wish me luck! And thank you again! 😀
I am 72 and watching this tutorial for the first , one of my nieces , said to me last week, “come on try to used some eyeliner “ , I will let you know ladies
Thank you for this! I'm brand spanking new to liquid liner at the ripe old age of 32. 😂 I haven't practiced yet, but I think I'll be able to thanks to this! PS: as a newbie, I thoroughly appreciate the detailed explanations on how exactly to execute. After all, says plainly in the title "for beginners!" So nevermind those who said you "talk to much," it was perfect.
I've never, ever in my life been able to successfully do wings and it's frustrating because basically every other woman in the world knows how to as if they were born with all the knowledge of womanhood haha this makes me want to try again
I’ve been wearing makeup for so long but it’s just to school so no one actually cares but now we are in quarantine so I’m just trying to master what I can😂😂
I just found you (five years later than most) but I think you are an excellent teacher. I am an older woman (61) and for years I never thought I could draw a good cat eye as I always got discouraged. Well, things are changing and I'm taking much better care of myself--entering a new chapter in my life. And yes, that includes a damn good cat eye! So far I am doing pretty good as per your tips, thank you!!!
I love the hack of looking down so you don’t have to pull on your eye. I’ve been doing my own makeup for years and have had it done professionally countless times and had never heard that trick before.
Thank you for the tip about looking down. It was a key tip for me and I've watched a bunch of tutorials on wingedvliner but this is the first time I've heard that.
Thank you! I have watched several other tutorials for the "winged" look and yours explained it in more detail (but not to much detail) on where to start and why. You spoke slow enough but not to slow and kept it simple and made it seem easy! Now off to practice!!!
Best beginner's eyeliner tutorial, ever!!! Thank you so much. I got it! Still working on doing my left eye, but I have the concept. Thanks again!! 😁🤗👍🏽
Nice. I do almost the same, i used to copy all the good vloggers, starting from the wing then working to the inner eye. It was hard for me so i quit doing eyeliners and just put shadows. Then just recently ive been doing liners again & realized it was so much easier to start in the middle of the eyelid then put the wing later on, & trying to put liner first before eyeshadow so i can erase if it didnt go well, then foundation.
You are so pretty! I love your personality. I usually don't watch makeup videos bc the people doing them are divas. I will be going back and watching all your videos! This was the most comprehensive tutorial! I loved the lower lash continuing up tip
I cannot stress this enough this video is a blessing I watched it once and my eyeliner was 1000000 times better, it’s still not perfect considering this is one of my first decent eyeliner application but it’s definitely presentable
Omgosh Thank You!!! I've watched 9 zillion tutorials with Zero success.. Duh me... Your explanation and demonstration was so precise that I finally Got it😇. You are a timeless Beauty❤
Joanna, thanks so much! It's been difficult to find a good tutorial for winged eyeliner that isn't super thick or overdone. Also helps that you have a fair skin tone similar to mine. Great tutorial!
Great explanation, thank you!!! I've never been much into make up and am trying to learn some tips and tricks to make myself look more put together. Eyeliner has been a struggle so I really appreciate you taking the time to talk us through the process. Well done!
I've always struggled with doing winged eyeliner, but I think that this technique might work! Thank you so much! I hope I can get it somewhat decent for my first time! BTW, you're really pretty!
Joanna, this is the first time I've seen a video of yours from the "past". I subscribed to you last year sometime I think. It's crazy how much things change. I love your makeup style now and it's pretty here too! U can rock anything, is what I'm saying! ❤️ 😘
this is amazing!!!! thank you so much, I've always struggled with this but thanks to your tutorial I got it first try! a lot of useful info and very clear instructions!!!! I love you!
omg i have been searching for the best tutorial for making my wings n i tried this method and it came out perfect i am excited thank you so much keep up the good work :)
You have beautiful eyes, i was able to observe you with eyeliner on & off & you really have the most beutiful lash line. But i still loved your video , it was easy to follow & the results where gorgous. Thank you⚡❤
Wow! I was not expecting this to be so informative. I get so lost just watching people do their eyeliner, like I know how to put it on, but this explained how to make it look good. 😆 Thank you so much for this.
Looking forward to get my makeup table so I can try this a lot. Having problems with the liner. It does not look good and it looks kinda shiny ( I like the matte look) and it often breaks up. Any tips on what I can do? Would really appreciate it. I’m a beginner in makeup.
All is fine and well until you hit 30 and need to hold your skin creases out to draw the line 😭😂 been doing winged liner since the 90s. Love the look always have
For someone who has no experience in makeup whatsoever, this is really helpful! I know a lot of people are complaining how you talk too much, but for me at least, it helped me since this is basically my introduction to makeup. So thank you!
Galuh Widhiatmoyo same!!
Religious indian songs
Indian religious songs
Fam same I’m 13 I’m can’t do literally anything
2-D 👅
does anyone else have the issue of the eye that's on the same side as their dominant hand (e.g. right) coming out perfectly and the other (left) coming out shit :(
Yes !
nope. It's the other way around for me. my non dominant side is perfect, the dominant sucks
yes m sad
claudia ME AF
claudia mee always
This was the easiest and ONLY tutorial that worked for me. THANK YOU!
My problem is I always make 2 perfect wings that look totally different... either angle or width or length 🙄🙄🙄
For me it's either get to perfect ones that aren't identical, or have one be amazing and have the other look like a five year old did it...
Same here
Omg the same thing happens to me
🙋me too 😂😢🤔
Same😭
I know that this is going to be hard to believe, but I'm 52 and I was quite "tomboyish" through most of my life. No one really ever taught me how to put on makeup and I'm using liquid eyeliner for the first time ever. Oh, btw...I live in a tent and don't have the best lighting or the best mirror. I can tell that you have a lot of patience and you did a wonderful job on this tutorial. When you started talking about making the wing and pretending that your bottom lash line continues...well, I got that! Great explanation! Wish me luck! And thank you again! 😀
Cindy Beatty I’m about to be 52 too. Lol. Just bought some liquid today.. how’d you do? Practice makes perfect! : ) I’m excited 😊
I am 72 and watching this tutorial for the first , one of my nieces , said to me last week, “come on try to used some eyeliner “ , I will let you know ladies
The first tutorial which worked for me! I have been trying for years and have severe hooded eyes - no tut worked but this!!! Thank you so much ❤
this is the best winged liner video I've ever watched! thank you!
your eyes are so pretty! I love the little splash of brown in the left eye
Thank you for this! I'm brand spanking new to liquid liner at the ripe old age of 32. 😂 I haven't practiced yet, but I think I'll be able to thanks to this! PS: as a newbie, I thoroughly appreciate the detailed explanations on how exactly to execute. After all, says plainly in the title "for beginners!" So nevermind those who said you "talk to much," it was perfect.
The color of your eyes is STUNNING!
I've never, ever in my life been able to successfully do wings and it's frustrating because basically every other woman in the world knows how to as if they were born with all the knowledge of womanhood haha this makes me want to try again
Lady
You have company 😭😭😭
I’ve been wearing makeup for so long but it’s just to school so no one actually cares but now we are in quarantine so I’m just trying to master what I can😂😂
It’s easier for me to start with a small wing and build on it
This!!!!
Omg this is great to read I said to my sister should have been dude because I am so crap at make up, When I do eye make up I look like Alice Cooper 😂
Tutorial starts at 3:30 🙄 just get to the point okay
drew thank you , you are life saver😂
drew thanku 😂
Thank you😂
Thanksss☺️☺️
I AGREE
I just found you (five years later than most) but I think you are an excellent teacher. I am an older woman (61) and for years I never thought I could draw a good cat eye as I always got discouraged. Well, things are changing and I'm taking much better care of myself--entering a new chapter in my life. And yes, that includes a damn good cat eye! So far I am doing pretty good as per your tips, thank you!!!
Girl, don't listen to people saying you talk to much. This is perfect! Thanks so much. Going to try this tomorrow!
This is the best wing eyeliner tutorial I have seen so far... and it was made 4 yrs ago!! Great Job Joanna!! You Rock!!
This is the only video I’ve seen that does what I do. Perfect.
I HAVE SEEN MILLIONS OF VIDEOS but this is the most helpful video..thanks a ton
I’ve never heard it explained like this before
This is so much easier to understand
I love the hack of looking down so you don’t have to pull on your eye. I’ve been doing my own makeup for years and have had it done professionally countless times and had never heard that trick before.
You do this the best and perfect. Also, you have beautiful eyes. Thank you for sharing this information.
Thank you for the tip about looking down. It was a key tip for me and I've watched a bunch of tutorials on wingedvliner but this is the first time I've heard that.
Thank you! I have watched several other tutorials for the "winged" look and yours explained it in more detail (but not to much detail) on where to start and why. You spoke slow enough but not to slow and kept it simple and made it seem easy! Now off to practice!!!
I know this video is super old, but it still helped me learn how to do this TODAY! thank you!!
after watching tons of youtube tutorials for this, i finally found a video that actually works for me!
Best beginner's eyeliner tutorial, ever!!! Thank you so much. I got it! Still working on doing my left eye, but I have the concept. Thanks again!! 😁🤗👍🏽
I love the color in your right eye it's a amber spot in the right corner!!!!
Nice. I do almost the same, i used to copy all the good vloggers, starting from the wing then working to the inner eye. It was hard for me so i quit doing eyeliners and just put shadows. Then just recently ive been doing liners again & realized it was so much easier to start in the middle of the eyelid then put the wing later on, & trying to put liner first before eyeshadow so i can erase if it didnt go well, then foundation.
Pleez tell us about this eyeshadow look.. it looks gorgeous
OMG I've been struggling with liner for forever and I can finally do it because of this video!
As a beginner, I must say these are super easy steps to follow
Worked like a charm love how you kept the liner so thin! Thank you doll ♥️
You are so pretty! I love your personality. I usually don't watch makeup videos bc the people doing them are divas. I will be going back and watching all your videos! This was the most comprehensive tutorial! I loved the lower lash continuing up tip
I love your eyeshadow make up. It looks very simple but classy. Might use for everyday as well.
i actually just did it, because i have so much truly doing a wing. Thank u kindly
This video was so helpful! I was never able to make wings before. I watched it once and have pretty respectable wings on my face! Thank you!!
I cannot stress this enough this video is a blessing I watched it once and my eyeliner was 1000000 times better, it’s still not perfect considering this is one of my first decent eyeliner application but it’s definitely presentable
Omgosh Thank You!!! I've watched 9 zillion tutorials with Zero success.. Duh me... Your explanation and demonstration was so precise that I finally Got it😇. You are a timeless Beauty❤
This was so helpful, the fact that you talked everything you did helped me a lot, as I'm just starting to do makeup. Thank you!!
Thank you for sharing perfect cat eye technique I really like that it is on conservative side and not too much
"Just tell them you've been crying all day" 😂
Thanks tho, you're so pretty too!
Ohmygosh one of your eyes is partially green and I love it. It's very pretty
Joanna, thanks so much! It's been difficult to find a good tutorial for winged eyeliner that isn't super thick or overdone. Also helps that you have a fair skin tone similar to mine. Great tutorial!
YES! That helped A LOT you explained it so well. I also love how blue your eyes are.
The BEST tip I ever read and I’ve been trying to find an easy way for my liner. Thank you!!
This is the most helpful winged eyeliner video I’ve seen. Thanks!
Her eye color is beautiful!
I love your eye color!! And your makeup is so pretty how you do it I clicked on this video because it's a more natural look and I love it!
Beautiful eye color 🌱 🌊
Great explanation, thank you!!! I've never been much into make up and am trying to learn some tips and tricks to make myself look more put together. Eyeliner has been a struggle so I really appreciate you taking the time to talk us through the process. Well done!
Woman! You made that sooo easy. Thank you!!!!
Ur eyes n winged eyeliner are so mesmerising..awesome.👌❤
I have been doing make up for years and eyeliner has always been my struggle and this has helped me so much thank you !
I've always struggled with doing winged eyeliner, but I think that this technique might work! Thank you so much! I hope I can get it somewhat decent for my first time! BTW, you're really pretty!
Omg I've watched so many of these and the way you just explained it, like was so simple but absolutely solved every issue I've had! Subbed!
Joanna, this is the first time I've seen a video of yours from the "past". I subscribed to you last year sometime I think. It's crazy how much things change. I love your makeup style now and it's pretty here too! U can rock anything, is what I'm saying! ❤️ 😘
Thank you for this tutorial, I'm a total beginner and I found your method very approachable and easy to follow!
Very nice applying ! Your eyes are very beautiful!
Vest tutorial on youtube. You are very humble 😍😘😘
Amazing winked eyeliner applied. Your eyes are very beautiful
Great tips, thanks so much for sharing! It’s hard for me to do the winged eyeliner, but you make it look so easy.
This is a great video, Joanna. Thanks for making it.
So easy.
What's the best liquid eyeliner and yet, affordable? Thanks. I like the video so much by the way.
Thank you for the video, very helpful. Do you have a tutorial for this eyeshadow look? It’s amazingly beautiful.
You are an Amazing teacher 👩🏫 ♥️
This video was excellent and super easy to follow 🥰
this is amazing!!!! thank you so much, I've always struggled with this but thanks to your tutorial I got it first try! a lot of useful info and very clear instructions!!!! I love you!
thank you so much! I have been struggling with getting the perfect winged eyeliner and you just gave me every tip I needed to achieve it!
Excellent video! Thank you!
I found this video to be very useful. Thank you.
Thank you, the tips are very useful
Awesome. Got it right for the first time ever.
Your eyes are magical, I am fascinated
Awesome video and instructions!!!
OMG Best & Easiest Tutorial 🙌🏽🙌🏽
Awesome video.. Great explain for beginner..
omg i have been searching for the best tutorial for making my wings n i tried this method and it came out perfect i am excited thank you so much keep up the good work :)
You have beautiful eyes, i was able to observe you with eyeliner on & off & you really have the most beutiful lash line. But i still loved your video , it was easy to follow & the results where gorgous. Thank you⚡❤
This is so perfect, thank you very much ❤❤
Omg I just did my first ever perfect winged liner thank you 🥰
You make this so easy. Great video
She's so pretty!!
All those negative comments...those gals are jealous! You are absolutely beautiful and it is an excellent tutorial.
Wow! I was not expecting this to be so informative. I get so lost just watching people do their eyeliner, like I know how to put it on, but this explained how to make it look good. 😆 Thank you so much for this.
You have the most amazing eyes. very unique
Thank u 4 the video. I learned more from ur 1 video than I did 7 of the others!
Wow! One of the best tutorials I've seen! Great job
I just started using makeup and find this video very useful hopefully I can some day do my liner just like yours ! 🤧💕
Great tutorial Joanna very well done.
The best winged liner video!!! ❤️
Could you maybe measure it with the liner like ya did amd put a dot there on each side? To help go.by?
This is AMAZING!! So helpful! Should definitely have more views - thank you Joanna you rock :)
Question: Do you put on eyeshadow before or after eyeliner?
Before so the eyeliner doesnt seem drowned out by the eyeshadow.
Wow your make up is so pretty in this video x
Looking forward to get my makeup table so I can try this a lot. Having problems with the liner. It does not look good and it looks kinda shiny ( I like the matte look) and it often breaks up. Any tips on what I can do? Would really appreciate it. I’m a beginner in makeup.
thank you on the tip about pulling the eye. I still have some practice but ill get there, ill try not to pull my eye lid anymore.
her lip color is so to die for. what color is that?
its an Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Lipstick in the shade Pure Hollywood
Who knew 7 years after this video was uploaded you’ed be saving a girl for a wedding, THANK YOU
All is fine and well until you hit 30 and need to hold your skin creases out to draw the line 😭😂 been doing winged liner since the 90s. Love the look always have
Omg girl YESSS 😩 I FEEL YOU!
I'm 18 and relate to this! i got naturally wrinkly eyelids
30?Seriously? You must have some seriously messed up diet and genes then. Speak for yourself i suggest.
i just learnet how to apply eyeliner.. thanks a lot seriously 🖤
Thanks for the tutorial, 👍