Agreed BO F definitely for me, Korean drama “winter sonata” that started Hallyu “wave and the ost theme song also a hit that translate into various languages.
Taiwan's Meteor Garden and its version of F4 literally started THE wave for most of Asia. The boygroup by Jerry Yan, Vaness, Vic & Ken were so loved. It was insane🫠
Meteor Garden Taiwan is the OG of all versions and it started the Asian drama wave. It open doors to Asian drama series to be aired and dubbed in majority of the countries all around the world.
The Chinese version of "meteor garden" is the best in my opinion. The character development and chemistry between leads was amazing. I was literally crying the whole time while watching and couldn't get over the couple for months. People were obsessed over them dating in real life because their chemistry was so good.
Yes!!! I did not even bother to watch the K-drama version as I thought the FL looks very annoying 😂 I still don't under why people like her as her acting was so stiff
I've seen 4 versions (Thai, Japanese, Korean & Chinese). They were all good, but the K drama and Meteor Garden are a tie for me. I love Dylan Wang. In the K drama, the 2nd male lead (Kim Hyun Joong) is my favorite of all the versions. The Korean version is, IMO, definitely worth watching.
I loved Meteor Garden far more than Boys over Flowers. I also quite liked the Thai version too. I think calling the Korean version of Little Women a ‘remake’ is a bit of a stretch, it bears little resemblance to the original and is more what you’d call a ‘re-imagining’. I’d love to watch the Korean Scarlet Hearts but I can’t get it at all in the UK 😞
Ahhhhm HANA YORI DANGO (japanese version) has always a special place in my heart no matter how many remakes it will have from different country. Tsukasa Domyouji will always be my first love (charcter in a drama)like literally I cried for a whole month because it finally ended. Like everyday I was watching it in our local tv station (gma), it was dubbed in Filipino, I don't have internet access and personal computer that time, so my fangirling was waiting every afternoon to watch the show.. and when it ended I was so devastated. Like I can't move on to their characters. So I bought a dvd which the subtitles were sucked but still watched it anyway. And yeah, I remembered that I always write their names so I wouldn't forget them. *Reminiscing* Those were my teenager days.
Of all the BOF remakes, Hana Yori Dango is topnotch for me and the only version that I’ve rewatched that I lost count already. I just love everything about it. The acting and chemistry is beautiful for me. Makino’s character is not annoying and Tsukasa was portrayed perfectly. And also the other actors that played the F4, they have this balance and not too overacting. Not much kissing scenes too but the chemistry is overflowing. So yeah. That’s the drama for me. From season 1-2 even the movie at the end. MatsuJun and Mao Inoue, they were the power couple of jdrama.
I've actually never understood the hype around the korean adaptation of BOF, for me it's always been and always will be Hana Yori Dango! Maybe it's a generational thing lol? It was one of my first dramas ever along with Gokusen and I was hooked for years!
yes Hana Yori Dango is my favorite adaptation as well 😄 I liked Meteor Garden, but it's a bit draggy. I never watched BoF to completion, I guess I'm just tired of another remake...😅
World of the Married was so amazing, every little detail was important and even the title at the beginning was an easter egg, the dresses the main caracter wore had meaning, the cast was phenomenal, a must watch
Personally, I love the original Brit series though. A lot of the details in the WOTM were the exact same copies of the scenes from Doctor Foster so if you've seen the original series, the adaptation kinda pales in comparison. I wouldn't say the same for the other dramas mentioned in this list though (Boys Over Flowers, Destined to Love You, Mr. Queen, Romance Is a Bonus Book, Wtich's Romance, etc.).
@@lepunksmoothie I've seen the original and it was great, I think the script is just amazing, but not every adaptations of the show are good, the french one was meh for example. Every country ads its spice to it but the korean version was really one of the best imo
Im still not over how 2010s popular drama were downright sexist and misogynist. BOF was the sickest every version even the thai one. Chinese version was still tolerable because of the cast chemistry and still bareable script
SO GLAD TO FIND SOMEONE WHO THINKS THE SAME. BOF WAS TRASH. The obsession for it reminds me of when everyone was obsessed with Twilight (myself included), but then the movies came out and most realized that the writing was terrible! Have people watched BOF since their first watch? The male lead is the hugest jerk and there’s no way I could support him after a few eps in.
When I saw Little Women in the thumbnail I knew you were going to be reaching. First of all when the source material is as iconic as Little Women you are not a remake of another movie but another adaptation of the source material. And that being said calling the k-drama Little Women an adaptation of the original is in itself a reach. Other than the fact they are sisters there is really little else to relate it to the source material. The bad part is that the source material is good enough that a good melodrama could of been done without all the thrills. You telling me we have a story where a wealthy heir is friends with a group of sisters, who is in love with the oldest, while at the same time the youngest is in love with him. Then you throw in a new love interest for the oldest sister. You telling me that doesn't sound like a k-drama.
Click bait! I am sure I was not the only one who clicked on the video ONLY because of the thumbnail and having the same reaction of "huh? how are they the same?". She gets more views, more comments, algorithm continues to push the videos.
Fated to Love You is an all time favorite. I had to re-watch several episodes because I was crying so hard/loudly. Still can not watch it again, years later. Moon Lovers is fantastic. However I still haven't seen the last episode, becuase they broke my heart.
I liked the Taiwanese version of Fated To Love You, the best. The ML in the Korean version ruined it for me. He had a maniacal laugh that was not only off putting but happened way too often and at times that didn't call for laughter. Even the FL made a comment about it in one episode. LOL (or should I write BWAHAHAHAHA?)
Mr Queen is phenomenal. Have heard some great debates about the Female/Male lead. I had to laugh as you can interpret it any way you want. I prefer the original Little Women adaptation with Elizabeth Taylor. I would love to see a Korean take on Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights. A dark tale indeed would be a good Korean remake.
I didn’t know Mr. Queen is a remake. I definitely have to watch the OG. Much as I adore IU, Moon Lovers can’t hold a candle to Bu Bu Jing Xin. It’s really hard to adapt a story from a very distinct time period in China.
I remember watching the Chinese version here on RUclips. It’s funny too but personally I’m a bit disappointed with the ending and prefer the kdrama ending
Life on Mars!! YES! I've been recommending it to everyone who ask me what kdrama to watch. The fact that they can somehow adapt the series to fit into korean culture was BEAUTIFUL! and the twist, the romance subplot everything I cannot recommend this enough
yeah i call bull on this list tbh. there’s no way the korean remakes of jane the virgin and little women are more popular than their original counterparts
Yeah, there's no way anyone in their right mind would say it was more popular. The original is a cult classic that had the rights secured for remakes in multiple countries. There's no comparison.
I don’t see any similarities between Little women of south korea and english except stories of sisters !!!! Even if south korean little women is amazing, the english one is CLASSIC.
Scarlet Heart Ryeo was not well loved in Korea it has a low rating due to the negative mindset ratings of some knets for idols like iu and baekhyun….but it has a massive love & support and got hit internationally and because it success internationally…..international viewers wants a second season
I've seen scarlet heart and mr queen Chinese version and i must say Korean adaptation is amazing. Sadly scarlet heart has no season 2 ( the present time ) . Chinese version has it.
I’m sorry, but always the original version is the best. I’m really sorry but the Korean version of Boys over flower was terrible. Japanese mangas always best in Japanese. Remakes are never that good.
Little Women on the thumbnail is not a remake it was similar in name only. Romance is a bonus book is another that is not a remake it was just another noona romantic drama.
I absolutely loathe Boys Over Flowers and I just don't understand how it became so popular. The acting was atrocious, which is strange because it has a quality cast.
Boys over flower was my first kdrama in 2018 who introduced me to the kdrama world , I have meteor garden and all the other versions but nothing compares to the OG classic boys over flower korean version it's literally the best and I can binge watch it over and over again.
I never meet a person who watch any of “Boys over flowers” versions and says the Korean one was the best or the good idk about other but I mean i life with Meteor Garden and that show always remain the best Japanese Liar game was also good indeed i love the japanese more The only kdrama that actual good from being adapted of j-dorama i watched is 365: repeat the year. They pretty understand but the show is really the best
Sorry, regarding the Chinese remake of 'You Are My Destiny.' The one you shows is 'Perfect and Casual', stard by Wei Zhe Ming and Xu Ruo Han as ML & FL The Chinese remake of 'You Are My Destiny' is stard by Xing Zhao Ling and Liang Jie as ML & FL
1:05 Boys over flowers (generally, not referring to just the Korean version) is forever iconic, to the point that it should be a rule that all asian media watchers have to have at least watched one of the adaptations. Although parts of some of the adaptations are quite questionable, it should be taken as a learning experience lol
My Preference: - Scarlet Heart over Moon Lovers, can't even compare. I did not finish ML. It 'might' be more popular to some bcoz of younger & KOREAN Stars - Hana Yori Dango over BOF - Fated to Love You TW over KR
Boys over flowers (Korea) was bad. Meteor Garden (Taiwan and China) were waaay better. The Taiwanese version is THE REASON why the Korean version was made. The F4 became hugely popular all over Asia and that's why they did the Korean version. Which is really bad. The only great thing about it was the cute guys. If you want to see the most hilarious version, watch the Japanese version. I had stitches from laughing so hard.
Sorry but Chinese Fated to love you said by you an the poster shown starred by Wei Zheming and Xu Ruohan is called Perfect and Casual based on Webnovel "Mr Perfect and Miss Almost" written by Wan Zhi. Please do correct it.....
1. Boys over flowers 2. Romance is a bonus book 3. Life on Mars 4. Moon lover Scarlet heart 5. Mr queen 6. You are my destiny 7. Little women 8. Rich man 9. A witch romance 10. Liar game
The lead actress in Mr Queen was so good. She was playing a male character who's trapped in a woman's body lol so she had to pretend to be a boy who was acting like a girl..
THE K-DRAMA VERSION OF "TAXI DRIVER" ISN'T JUST BASED ON A BESTSELLING WEBTOON, BUT LEE JE HOON'S IMAGE WHILE RIDING A TAXI CAB WITH HIS SUNGLASSES LOOKS LIKE A STRIKING RESEMBLANCE TO ROBERT DE NIRO'S AWARD-WINNING CULT CLASSIC HOLLYWOOD FILM... ESPECIALLY THE TWO LIVE-ACTION K-DRAMAS CALLED "BOYS OVER FLOWERS" & "CITY HUNTER" WAS BASED ON THE TWO BESTSELLING ANIMÉ SERIES, ALSO "LOVE AFFAIRS IN THE AFTERNOON" K-DRAMA REMAKE IS BASED ON THE J-DRAMA "HIRUGAO"! 🚕🔫📺🎬🎥
Are there Asian drama versions of Pride & Prejudice, Persuasion or Sense and Sensibility? I really feel kDrama or Cdrama adaptations of these English classics would be really interesting.
I loved both Meteor Garden and Hana Yori Dango better than the Korean version... Hmm...very interested in watching Go Princess Go, though. I did love Mr. Queen and am curious on the original version...
The chinese version was filmed quite some time ago and had a very low budget compared to the korean remake. I still think it's worth watching just cause of how funny the show is but the korean version is definitely more polished.
Indeed the thai version of boys before flowers, the japanese version which is the first one to be launched, is the best so far aswell in the script with more sense aswell in the acting.
No wonder why scarlet heart ryo was so painful and addictive to watch. With incredible plot twists and a sad open ending.. Chinese books are so great on doing that. Making you cry and beg for more even if it's hurt. Many movies and series are adapted from amazing books. I wish more people can give a try on Chinese dramas.
It's good. Obviously with the 10+ year difference between the original and the K version happening, it means the time shift goes back to the 80s instead of the 70s, and that works really well because they work it around the 88 Seoul Olympics. So they do a good job of making it relevant to Korea. There's even a lot of faithful crossover (they do a straight adaption episode of 'The Warren' - the classic original story, and clothing choices are a great nod). But man, they really, REALLY whiff the ending. Doesn't have anywhere near the same emotional punch - it's just a fundamental difference in storytelling and, for my money, it doesn't work anywhere near as well. YMMV, of course.
@@annetterawlings4549 I might go back and give it another watch one day, just to see if my views change with time, distance and being more able to judge it on it's own as opposed to comparison.
They didn't mention Playful kiss, which was way better than the Taiwanese version Miss n kiss. Nor did they mention criminal minds, which the korean version was excellent. They didn't mention Designated surv8vir, korean version was pretty damned good.
Wait you didn't like the original 2005 Taiwanese adaptation It Started with a Kiss? Ariel Lin and Joe Cheng chemistry was so popular that's why they got a second season.
I appreciate how the mainland chinese version of Hana Yori Dango (can you tell that I stan the Japanese version?) was not even mentioned. Cause they didn't even have permission to do an adaptation. Lol But um yeah, go HanDan!!
Perdón pero no el caso de Liar Game. No estuvo mal la version coreana pero la original tiene esa esencia que de la sentido. Por algo se hicieron dos temporadas y como tres peliculas.
Kdrama Little Women is nothing like Little Women Novel or movie. It just has the same name. Even if it is inspired by the original Little Women it still does not have any similarity except that it is a story of sisters. That's all.
I preferred "My Queen" over "Witches Romance" though the lower budget can be seen in the debut episode. A big thing I liked being covered in the Taiwanese Drama vs. the Korean one was the father putting pressure on the son to commit being that she was older and may want kids. That was completely left off of the Korea one to its detrimit in my opinion.
I'll had designated surviver. I had alreafy watched the american version twice, so I appreciated how in thesoythkorean version they gave it a twist so we would'nt know who the culprit was
IN My memory the remakes were of SK versions was "The Tunnel" (three different countries did it} and one I think twenty years back ,about this woman gets a boyfriend in the mail but he's a Android?? Original was Japanese and from a manga.
Romance is a bonus book might have been great - if the female lead had ever looked as if she liked the male lead. Even in the clips on this compilation you can see that he is all intense and she looks as if she's wondering if the ceiling needs a fresh coat of paint. Also, her disappeared daughter was really weird.
1] Boys Over Flower drama was my 1st Kdrama , it was good & I loved it sm ,but I would say its Thai adaptation really hits different 2] 5:30 fated to love u Chinese version the poster here shown is of drama perfect & casual 3] Rich man &Poor woman k drama was not my cup of tea , the FL looked emotionless , Suho did a good job( its true it did well & became popular only because of him)actually it was really a bad adaptation , I liked the OG version better {MY OPINION } 🙂
I feel this list was incomplete cause you didn't mention naughty kiss.i have seen I believe all versions and they were all wonderful.naughty kiss was my first but fell for love on Tokyo and it started eith a kiss.granted maybe old but was done after boys over flowers so nit sure ehy these weren't mentioned?
I always say,"Boys Over Flowers ",is our gateway drug to getting hooked on Korean dramas...
lol ture
Word!!!
They even had a Indian remake called Kase hai yeh Yaariaan
Agree Boys over flowers was the 1st korean drama I've watched ❤ then Meteor Garden, & now I'm addicted, korean & Chinese drama's are so Good.😍🥰
Agreed BO F definitely for me, Korean drama “winter sonata” that started Hallyu “wave and the ost theme song also a hit that translate into various languages.
Taiwan's Meteor Garden and its version of F4 literally started THE wave for most of Asia. The boygroup by Jerry Yan, Vaness, Vic & Ken were so loved. It was insane🫠
It's my favorite of all the versions! Yummy guys!
Meteor Garden Taiwan is the OG of all versions and it started the Asian drama wave. It open doors to Asian drama series to be aired and dubbed in majority of the countries all around the world.
The Chinese version of "meteor garden" is the best in my opinion. The character development and chemistry between leads was amazing. I was literally crying the whole time while watching and couldn't get over the couple for months. People were obsessed over them dating in real life because their chemistry was so good.
Does it have the same title?
Yesss omg i love this drama. I have watched this probably like 4 times its my comfort drama
@@snowps1yes
Yes!!! I did not even bother to watch the K-drama version as I thought the FL looks very annoying 😂 I still don't under why people like her as her acting was so stiff
I've seen 4 versions (Thai, Japanese, Korean & Chinese). They were all good, but the K drama and Meteor Garden are a tie for me. I love Dylan Wang. In the K drama, the 2nd male lead (Kim Hyun Joong) is my favorite of all the versions. The Korean version is, IMO, definitely worth watching.
I loved Meteor Garden far more than Boys over Flowers. I also quite liked the Thai version too. I think calling the Korean version of Little Women a ‘remake’ is a bit of a stretch, it bears little resemblance to the original and is more what you’d call a ‘re-imagining’. I’d love to watch the Korean Scarlet Hearts but I can’t get it at all in the UK 😞
Try drama cool for Moon Lovers
@@annetterawlings4549 Thanks for the tip Annette but it seems DramaCool is android only, and I’ve got Apple iOS so it won’t let me.
I honestly think the Thai version is the best one
Mr. Queen was top my list ❤ such a masterpiece 😊 Little women and moonlover were also impressive.
Mr. Queen deserves all the love!! It is one of my fav kdramas of all time❤❤❤
Ahhhhm HANA YORI DANGO (japanese version) has always a special place in my heart no matter how many remakes it will have from different country. Tsukasa Domyouji will always be my first love (charcter in a drama)like literally I cried for a whole month because it finally ended. Like everyday I was watching it in our local tv station (gma), it was dubbed in Filipino, I don't have internet access and personal computer that time, so my fangirling was waiting every afternoon to watch the show.. and when it ended I was so devastated. Like I can't move on to their characters. So I bought a dvd which the subtitles were sucked but still watched it anyway. And yeah, I remembered that I always write their names so I wouldn't forget them. *Reminiscing*
Those were my teenager days.
Of all the BOF remakes, Hana Yori Dango is topnotch for me and the only version that I’ve rewatched that I lost count already. I just love everything about it. The acting and chemistry is beautiful for me. Makino’s character is not annoying and Tsukasa was portrayed perfectly. And also the other actors that played the F4, they have this balance and not too overacting. Not much kissing scenes too but the chemistry is overflowing. So yeah. That’s the drama for me. From season 1-2 even the movie at the end. MatsuJun and Mao Inoue, they were the power couple of jdrama.
I've actually never understood the hype around the korean adaptation of BOF, for me it's always been and always will be Hana Yori Dango! Maybe it's a generational thing lol?
It was one of my first dramas ever along with Gokusen and I was hooked for years!
yes Hana Yori Dango is my favorite adaptation as well 😄 I liked Meteor Garden, but it's a bit draggy. I never watched BoF to completion, I guess I'm just tired of another remake...😅
World of the Married was so amazing, every little detail was important and even the title at the beginning was an easter egg, the dresses the main caracter wore had meaning, the cast was phenomenal, a must watch
Personally, I love the original Brit series though. A lot of the details in the WOTM were the exact same copies of the scenes from Doctor Foster so if you've seen the original series, the adaptation kinda pales in comparison. I wouldn't say the same for the other dramas mentioned in this list though (Boys Over Flowers, Destined to Love You, Mr. Queen, Romance Is a Bonus Book, Wtich's Romance, etc.).
@@lepunksmoothie I've seen the original and it was great, I think the script is just amazing, but not every adaptations of the show are good, the french one was meh for example. Every country ads its spice to it but the korean version was really one of the best imo
Im still not over how 2010s popular drama were downright sexist and misogynist. BOF was the sickest every version even the thai one. Chinese version was still tolerable because of the cast chemistry and still bareable script
SO GLAD TO FIND SOMEONE WHO THINKS THE SAME. BOF WAS TRASH.
The obsession for it reminds me of when everyone was obsessed with Twilight (myself included), but then the movies came out and most realized that the writing was terrible! Have people watched BOF since their first watch? The male lead is the hugest jerk and there’s no way I could support him after a few eps in.
@@ashliel.3517 not only the ML other parts were too ridiculous and they added comedy?! nothing of that show is not crap
When I saw Little Women in the thumbnail I knew you were going to be reaching. First of all when the source material is as iconic as Little Women you are not a remake of another movie but another adaptation of the source material. And that being said calling the k-drama Little Women an adaptation of the original is in itself a reach. Other than the fact they are sisters there is really little else to relate it to the source material. The bad part is that the source material is good enough that a good melodrama could of been done without all the thrills. You telling me we have a story where a wealthy heir is friends with a group of sisters, who is in love with the oldest, while at the same time the youngest is in love with him. Then you throw in a new love interest for the oldest sister. You telling me that doesn't sound like a k-drama.
Click bait! I am sure I was not the only one who clicked on the video ONLY because of the thumbnail and having the same reaction of "huh? how are they the same?". She gets more views, more comments, algorithm continues to push the videos.
South Korea's Tempted was also a good version of the classic Dangerous Liaisons which was also adapted by the movie Cruel Intentions.
But was what got me in kdrama
Fated to Love You is an all time favorite. I had to re-watch several episodes because I was crying so hard/loudly. Still can not watch it again, years later. Moon Lovers is fantastic. However I still haven't seen the last episode, becuase they broke my heart.
I liked the Taiwanese version of Fated To Love You, the best. The ML in the Korean version ruined it for me. He had a maniacal laugh that was not only off putting but happened way too often and at times that didn't call for laughter. Even the FL made a comment about it in one episode. LOL (or should I write BWAHAHAHAHA?)
big disservice to jang hyuk saying that fated to love you only succeeded because of jang nara lol
The newest Thailand’s F-4 is THE BEST boys over flowers version.
The best adaptation of Hana Yori Dango is the Japanese one, but Kdrama one is a special version.
I absolutely love little women it's such a great show my mother also enjoyed it ❤
Mr Queen is phenomenal. Have heard some great debates about the Female/Male lead. I had to laugh as you can interpret it any way you want. I prefer the original Little Women adaptation with Elizabeth Taylor. I would love to see a Korean take on Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights. A dark tale indeed would be a good Korean remake.
I didn’t know Mr. Queen is a remake. I definitely have to watch the OG. Much as I adore IU, Moon Lovers can’t hold a candle to Bu Bu Jing Xin. It’s really hard to adapt a story from a very distinct time period in China.
I remember watching the Chinese version here on RUclips. It’s funny too but personally I’m a bit disappointed with the ending and prefer the kdrama ending
Life on Mars!! YES! I've been recommending it to everyone who ask me what kdrama to watch. The fact that they can somehow adapt the series to fit into korean culture was BEAUTIFUL! and the twist, the romance subplot everything I cannot recommend this enough
But MAN did they completely whiff the ending.
So the reason the Korean remake of Life on Mars is more popular is it won an award? The British original was huge when it came out.
yeah i call bull on this list tbh. there’s no way the korean remakes of jane the virgin and little women are more popular than their original counterparts
Yeah, there's no way anyone in their right mind would say it was more popular. The original is a cult classic that had the rights secured for remakes in multiple countries. There's no comparison.
I don’t see any similarities between Little women of south korea and english except stories of sisters !!!!
Even if south korean little women is amazing, the english one is CLASSIC.
Hana Yori Dango manga and the live adaptation Meteor Garden (Taiwan version) was my gateway to Asian dramas.
My favorite drama of all time, you are my destiny #6 Jang Hyuk ❤❤
Scarlet Heart Ryeo was not well loved in Korea it has a low rating due to the negative mindset ratings of some knets for idols like iu and baekhyun….but it has a massive love & support and got hit internationally and because it success internationally…..international viewers wants a second season
Koreans like Good Story Scripts don't Worst Only foreign people like korean drama because Why ..
you are telling me Korean LOM is more popular than British LOM
have you lost your mind
Now Promoting Only Korean drama or kpop With Worst Story Script Who Is Promoting Korean drama or kpop Now..!?
I liked F4 thailand more than any versions❤❤ 2nd would be meteor garden chinese version
I've seen scarlet heart and mr queen Chinese version and i must say Korean adaptation is amazing. Sadly scarlet heart has no season 2 ( the present time ) . Chinese version has it.
And the S2 is very well done - loved it
Fated to love you is superb and Mr Queen its a masterpiece.
Mr Queen was totally addictive.
This is untrue about Korea's Boys Over Flower, Taiwan's Meteor Garden started the F4/HYD craze in Asia, its still more popular then Korea's.
I’m sorry, but always the original version is the best. I’m really sorry but the Korean version of Boys over flower was terrible. Japanese mangas always best in Japanese. Remakes are never that good.
Little Women on the thumbnail is not a remake it was similar in name only. Romance is a bonus book is another that is not a remake it was just another noona romantic drama.
I absolutely loathe Boys Over Flowers and I just don't understand how it became so popular. The acting was atrocious, which is strange because it has a quality cast.
Is there anyone else who loves F4 more than all the other versions?
🙋♀️ 😊
Boys over flower was my first kdrama in 2018 who introduced me to the kdrama world , I have meteor garden and all the other versions but nothing compares to the OG classic boys over flower korean version it's literally the best and I can binge watch it over and over again.
I love Asian dramas, I wish Mexico's novelas would do something different! Its basically the same story with difference faces.
Nothing beats Meteor Garden Taiwan version. That being said, I’m still hoping for Scarlet Heart S2.
Mr. Queen, Little Women.
Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo is my fave out of these ❤❤
Yess, hope that they make a second season!
yk even so much later, they can act like no time was ever skipped. baekhyun and iu still look the same XD
@@celebglam224
I never meet a person who watch any of “Boys over flowers” versions and says the Korean one was the best or the good idk about other but I mean i life with Meteor Garden and that show always remain the best
Japanese Liar game was also good indeed i love the japanese more
The only kdrama that actual good from being adapted of j-dorama i watched is 365: repeat the year. They pretty understand but the show is really the best
Why is Perfect and Casual the poster at 5:30 ? I think they were supposed to put the version with Xing Zhao Lin and Liang Jie
Sorry, regarding the Chinese remake of 'You Are My Destiny.'
The one you shows is 'Perfect and Casual', stard by Wei Zhe Ming and Xu Ruo Han as ML & FL
The Chinese remake of 'You Are My Destiny' is stard by Xing Zhao Ling and Liang Jie as ML & FL
Meteor Garden is classic good❤, Fated to Love you and You are My Destiny are both great❤
1:05 Boys over flowers (generally, not referring to just the Korean version) is forever iconic, to the point that it should be a rule that all asian media watchers have to have at least watched one of the adaptations. Although parts of some of the adaptations are quite questionable, it should be taken as a learning experience lol
My Preference:
- Scarlet Heart over Moon Lovers, can't even compare. I did not finish ML. It 'might' be more popular to some bcoz of younger & KOREAN Stars
- Hana Yori Dango over BOF
- Fated to Love You TW over KR
18 again should be in this list it was so good
Taiwanese meteor garden was better. Esp choice of female lead. Shancai was a lot more convincing and likeable heroine.
I think Moon Lovers was more popular because of the eye candy cast and OST - it certainly was for me anyway 😂
But the original Chinese drama had a bigger impact and bring more emotion for me. Did you watch it?
@@Hanna2801 yes I did - and thoroughly enjoyed it - but as I said the Korean version had more eye candy
Boys over flowers (Korea) was bad. Meteor Garden (Taiwan and China) were waaay better. The Taiwanese version is THE REASON why the Korean version was made. The F4 became hugely popular all over Asia and that's why they did the Korean version. Which is really bad. The only great thing about it was the cute guys. If you want to see the most hilarious version, watch the Japanese version. I had stitches from laughing so hard.
Sorry but Chinese Fated to love you said by you an the poster shown starred by Wei Zheming and Xu Ruohan is called Perfect and Casual based on Webnovel "Mr Perfect and Miss Almost" written by Wan Zhi. Please do correct it.....
1. Boys over flowers
2. Romance is a bonus book
3. Life on Mars
4. Moon lover Scarlet heart
5. Mr queen
6. You are my destiny
7. Little women
8. Rich man
9. A witch romance
10. Liar game
The lead actress in Mr Queen was so good. She was playing a male character who's trapped in a woman's body lol so she had to pretend to be a boy who was acting like a girl..
THE K-DRAMA VERSION OF "TAXI DRIVER" ISN'T JUST BASED ON A BESTSELLING WEBTOON, BUT LEE JE HOON'S IMAGE WHILE RIDING A TAXI CAB WITH HIS SUNGLASSES LOOKS LIKE A STRIKING RESEMBLANCE TO ROBERT DE NIRO'S AWARD-WINNING CULT CLASSIC HOLLYWOOD FILM... ESPECIALLY THE TWO LIVE-ACTION K-DRAMAS CALLED "BOYS OVER FLOWERS" & "CITY HUNTER" WAS BASED ON THE TWO BESTSELLING ANIMÉ SERIES, ALSO "LOVE AFFAIRS IN THE AFTERNOON" K-DRAMA REMAKE IS BASED ON THE J-DRAMA "HIRUGAO"! 🚕🔫📺🎬🎥
Korean version of Boys Over Flowers WAS TRASH so PLEASE DON'T say that it was BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL JAPANESE DRAMA
Are there Asian drama versions of Pride & Prejudice, Persuasion or Sense and Sensibility? I really feel kDrama or Cdrama adaptations of these English classics would be really interesting.
I loved both Meteor Garden and Hana Yori Dango better than the Korean version...
Hmm...very interested in watching Go Princess Go, though. I did love Mr. Queen and am curious on the original version...
The chinese version was filmed quite some time ago and had a very low budget compared to the korean remake. I still think it's worth watching just cause of how funny the show is but the korean version is definitely more polished.
Meteor Garden and Boys over Flowers were my gateway dramas to Asian dramas
Indeed the thai version of boys before flowers, the japanese version which is the first one to be launched, is the best so far aswell in the script with more sense aswell in the acting.
No wonder why scarlet heart ryo was so painful and addictive to watch. With incredible plot twists and a sad open ending.. Chinese books are so great on doing that. Making you cry and beg for more even if it's hurt. Many movies and series are adapted from amazing books. I wish more people can give a try on Chinese dramas.
Nah Hana Yori Dango is definitely the superior version, I couldn't even get past episode 1 of the Korean one.
MR. QUEEN
LITTLE WOMEN
I haven't watched the Korean version of Life on Mars but loved the original - must watch it
It's good. Obviously with the 10+ year difference between the original and the K version happening, it means the time shift goes back to the 80s instead of the 70s, and that works really well because they work it around the 88 Seoul Olympics. So they do a good job of making it relevant to Korea. There's even a lot of faithful crossover (they do a straight adaption episode of 'The Warren' - the classic original story, and clothing choices are a great nod). But man, they really, REALLY whiff the ending. Doesn't have anywhere near the same emotional punch - it's just a fundamental difference in storytelling and, for my money, it doesn't work anywhere near as well. YMMV, of course.
@@KyleS3m3noff I binge watched it straight after posting that comment - loved it but do agree about the ending
@@annetterawlings4549 I might go back and give it another watch one day, just to see if my views change with time, distance and being more able to judge it on it's own as opposed to comparison.
Actually, Meteor Garden is far better than Boys Over Flowers. I can always rewatch MG, but can not do the same for BOF.
They didn't mention Playful kiss, which was way better than the Taiwanese version Miss n kiss. Nor did they mention criminal minds, which the korean version was excellent. They didn't mention Designated surv8vir, korean version was pretty damned good.
Wait you didn't like the original 2005 Taiwanese adaptation It Started with a Kiss? Ariel Lin and Joe Cheng chemistry was so popular that's why they got a second season.
@@fire34fly There's a more recent Taiwanese remake called 'Miss in Kiss', which is what OP is talking about here I guess. ISWAK is better though.
For me, BOF Korean version is on the bottom of my list if I had to rank all of the different versions. Thai version is the best one!
Actually BOF would rate 3rd in my list of remakes for Hana Yori Dango - Meteor Garden (2018) and F4 Thailand (2021) are both better in my opinion
I honestly won't mind season 2 of moon lovers
For me boys over the flower thai is favourite 😊
i LOVE romance is a bonus book
Liar Game is such an underrated show.
The korean remake is maybe more popular, but it's such a downgrade from the original one.
The Poster used for Your are my destiny/ fated to love you 2020 is actually the poster of Perfect and Casual ☠️
Jang Nara and Jang Hyuk's acting made for a most wonderful and touching series 💜
Meteor Garden n Hana Yori Dango are lot much better than Boys over flower
My favorite is scarlet heart
I appreciate how the mainland chinese version of Hana Yori Dango (can you tell that I stan the Japanese version?) was not even mentioned. Cause they didn't even have permission to do an adaptation. Lol But um yeah, go HanDan!!
Perdón pero no el caso de Liar Game. No estuvo mal la version coreana pero la original tiene esa esencia que de la sentido. Por algo se hicieron dos temporadas y como tres peliculas.
What about The World Of The Married???? It was a remake of U.K., Doctor Foster. It was absolutely fantastic.
Wow I didn't know that there was a Korean version of younger
Boys Over Flowers was hyped up because of Lee Minho but IMHO, Meteor Garden is still the best and most popular version.
True 👍
Boys over flowers is a timeless masterpiece
MEteor Garden will always be top!! even till today i still watch it.
Kdrama Little Women is nothing like Little Women Novel or movie. It just has the same name.
Even if it is inspired by the original Little Women it still does not have any similarity except that it is a story of sisters. That's all.
Junpyo ❤ jandi, that's what junpyo wrote in the cable car ❤❤❤
Mr Queen is just 🤌🏻😘 Peghfection
Me Queen was hilarious
Fated to love you was actually the name of the Kdrama version yo.
I preferred "My Queen" over "Witches Romance" though the lower budget can be seen in the debut episode. A big thing I liked being covered in the Taiwanese Drama vs. the Korean one was the father putting pressure on the son to commit being that she was older and may want kids. That was completely left off of the Korea one to its detrimit in my opinion.
The World of the Married. Great adaptation imo.
Beg to differ., Meteor Garden was phenomenal back then.
I'll had designated surviver. I had alreafy watched the american version twice, so I appreciated how in thesoythkorean version they gave it a twist so we would'nt know who the culprit was
WHAT???? romance is a bonus book is a remake of younger???? I had no idea
IN My memory the remakes were of SK versions was "The Tunnel" (three different countries did it} and one I think twenty years back ,about this woman gets a boyfriend in the mail but he's a Android?? Original was Japanese and from a manga.
Romance is a bonus book might have been great - if the female lead had ever looked as if she liked the male lead. Even in the clips on this compilation you can see that he is all intense and she looks as if she's wondering if the ceiling needs a fresh coat of paint. Also, her disappeared daughter was really weird.
Meteor garden Chinese is the best versión for me, and I loved all versions of you are my destiny
For me F4 Thailand was the best ❤
1] Boys Over Flower drama was my 1st Kdrama , it was good & I loved it sm ,but I would say its Thai adaptation really hits different
2] 5:30 fated to love u Chinese version the poster here shown is of drama perfect & casual
3] Rich man &Poor woman k drama was not my cup of tea , the FL looked emotionless , Suho did a good job( its true it did well & became popular only because of him)actually it was really a bad adaptation , I liked the OG version better {MY OPINION } 🙂
I must be the only K Drama fan who disliked Boys Over Flowers. I was more of a Coffees Prince kinda gal
Original Always Original korean drama Not Popular than Original but We Who is Promoting kdrama..😊
..Wdym?
I feel this list was incomplete cause you didn't mention naughty kiss.i have seen I believe all versions and they were all wonderful.naughty kiss was my first but fell for love on Tokyo and it started eith a kiss.granted maybe old but was done after boys over flowers so nit sure ehy these weren't mentioned?