Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
WHITE BALANCE: Important or Overrated?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 авг 2024
- Discussing the importance of setting white balance and testing the flexibility of changing white balance in post on Raw, JPG, 8-bit video & 10-bit log.
👍 Thanks for watching! Please like, comment, & subscribe.
Affordable Grey Card on Amazon: geni.us/3faMR
=============================
Table of Contents:
=============================
0:00 - Intro
0:40 - Common Misconceptions about White Balance
1:07 - Changing White Balance on Raw Photos & Video
2:08 - Using the White Balance Dropper in Lightroom/Premiere
2:32 - Raw Photo Results (5500K, 2500K, & 10,000K)
3:25 - Conclusion #1: Can Raw White Balance be Changed in Post?
3:37 - Why I Wear a Grey Shoelace on My Wrist
4:53 - JPEG Results - Extreme White Balance Adjustment
6:14 - Does Exposure Matter for Correcting White Balance?
6:27 - Why Warming an Image Increases Brightness
6:53 - Conclusion #2: Can You Change JPG White Balance in Post?
7:19 - White Balance Method 1: Custom WB in Camera (Best)
7:42 - Method 2: Use a Different Neutral Grey Object in the Scene
7:59 - Method 3: Eyeball It or Set White Balance to Lights
8:40 - Method 4: Just Put Your White Balance on a Middling Kelvin
9:00 - Method 5: Auto White Balance - Why It's the Worst
9:25 - Locking the Auto White Balance Helps
9:57 - When Auto White Balance Is Okay to Use
10:14 - 8-bit Video Results (H.264 MP4 - Standard Profile)
11:38 - Conclusion #3: Can 8-bit Video White Balance be Changed?
11:52 - 10-bit Log Video Results - Any Better?
13:03 - Conclusion #4 & Final Thoughts on White Balance
=============================
Gear I Use to Make Videos:
=============================
kit.co/GeraldU...
=============================
Best Deals for Camera Gear
=============================
Gear Focus Marketplace: geni.us/gearfo...
Amazon Top Deals: amzn.to/3d9tdT4
B&H Deal Zone: bhpho.to/2SCDrnj
=============================
Music:
=============================
I use Artlist for my background music needs. Use this link to get two extra months when signing up: bit.ly/2TV5sYT
=============================
Follow Me:
=============================
Twitter: / geraldundone
Instagram: / geraldundone
Discord: / discord
=============================
Patreon & PayPal:
=============================
If you wish to support the channel monetarily, you can use my Patreon page here: / geraldundone
Or directly via PayPal here: www.paypal.me/...
This is appreciated, but unnecessary, and no content will ever be behind a paywall.
=============================
Affiliate Links:
=============================
Some of the links in my video descriptions are affiliate links, which means at no extra cost to you, I will make a small commission if you click them and make a qualifying purchase. If you have a different purchase in mind, you can also use these storewide links below.
🛒 Amazon: geni.us/1m1G32
🛒 B&H Photo: bhpho.to/2MYRKBE
=============================
Recommended Channel Tools:
=============================
💬 Closed captioning provided by ONEXTRA: onextra.ca
🚩 If you're a fellow RUclipsr, I highly recommend you try TubeBuddy. It's helped my channel immensely: www.tubebuddy....
=============================
#whitebalance #photography #editing
Now we are all getting gray shoe laces on our arm....You gotta start selling those
I am wondering if anyone makes an 18% grey watchband...search time.
Merch! Yes!
yeah he should totally start selling these
Yes, sell em, i'd rather buy them from you as im sure most of your viewers like to support what you do.
Converse: (cough)I think I can help a lil
I bet X-Rite is going to start selling $85 grey shoelaces.
👍😜
C$100, naturally. And no free shipping either.
and thats by inch you know ;)
it's amazing they can sell that nothingness for so much. it's good to be the standard in the industry.
uesjd c y
I imagine a future standard gray rubber wristband product which is stain resistant. Killer content, Gerald. No fluff. Quick, clear delivery. Very helpful.
Thanks, John! Much appreciated. 😃👍
Hey Gerald , you should sell "neutral grey wristbands for video" ;-) - where is the "buy" button???
One of the misconceptions is the belief that the WB set on gray card is what you want. Of course, totally incorrect WB usually looks ugly (unless that's the intention). But the truth is that if you take two raw files from different cameras of the same scene and set WB on the same gray card, you will get different color results nevertheless.
WB is not what makes the colors pleasing or not. My Nikon Z6ii is set at White AWB, as well as my Sony A7iii. Both result in different colors. But I usually don't care that Nikon's AWB is wrong, because the colors still come out great. I rarely ever change Nikon WB in LR. With Sony, it's a different story. The colors often don't seem right, and fixing WB usually improves that, but even after the fix, the colors from Sony raw files are still lacking.
Bottom line, don't sweat WB, get the right camera.
@@USGrant21st Also, it depend on the Kelvin of the light, morning light would not make the same grey as the evening one.
Finally learning some more from youtube. I was done watching tutorials / explanation vids since all youtubers are just repeating each other with newbie instructions. You're bringing it to a whole new level! Thanks for that
Ah, there's the original "what is happening" I've been missing. Also, my husband's shoelaces about to get "undone".
Clever. Very clever.
"What is up everybody!" 😂 sound familiar ?
I haven't seen any content as high quality as yours ever. Never felt the need to skip some parts of your video to get to the actual content. very helpful. Thanks a lot :)
Helpful, practical question, answered! Thanks Gerald!
Cheers, Curtis! 😃🙏
I stumbled upon one of your videos recently and I just kept watching more. The value and knowledge in your content is delivered in an easy to digest way for guys like me who want to get into videography but can’t afford the proper education for it. Thank you so much.
Dude. The Shoelace is BRILLIANT. I ALWAYS try to get custom white balance in camera with a gray card before I start recording. It has been way easier since then.
Ha. Thanks! And agreed, way easier. 👍
Sometimes I feel guilty watching your channel. Like I snuck into a school and I'm watching for free. Always such awesome information. Thank you so much for sharing so much all the time.
somebody should think of 18% grey lens caps
That's a great idea! I love it.
The expodisc claims to be 18% transparent. Won't fit on your lens though without some tinkering and quite expensive for a lens cap. A white reflective object also has the advantage of giving you the ability to set a good whitebalance under dimmer light than the grey card or anything transparent at 18%.
Reminds me of the grey Pentax Teleconverters that look photoshopped in pictures :) www.pentaxforums.com/lensreviews/Pentax-Rear-Teleconverter-A-2x-L.html
Gerald Undone Old panasonic dv camera had a semi transparent white cap precisely for that purpose. Hate seting white balance on dslrs; so much easier with a dedicated set button on a video camera. The A7SII has to be in photo mode to actually set it.
@@mondotv4216 these can be used for whitebalance but not for exposure. I also don't understand why dslr's dont use the easier camcorder method to set custom white balance. Actually, on the gh5 it works very simmilar to camcorders.
Beware people, this channel is dangerously addictive.
I LOVE how you always address all possible upcoming questions what people will be asking in comments, and answering them beforehand :D thats experience!
Haha. Thanks! I try. 😃
Brilliant intro. Glad its back!
Ha. Thanks. Cheers, Caleb. 😃👍
and we're back~ :))
Man at some point someone needs to create the RUclips DSLR video channels' squad where they all hangout at a round table and make different cameras fight to the death!
Another great job. The shoelace idea is so simple it's genius. I often misplace or forget my gray card and then I end up scanning for something that is close to neutral. Keep up the great work presenting useful and meaningful information.
Thanks, Phil. I do the same thing. 😜
Another great video, Gerald. Your explanations are, as always, accurate and very well-considered. For professional real estate and architectural photography, accurate WB is absolutely key, as we're usually using mixed lighting, ambient and flash. I've learned a number of tricks in post to deal with color contamination in PS, but having accurate references in-frame, especially for a sequence of frames, as one does for RE, Arch or product, is a big help to minimize shot-to-shot variance and having maximal color consistency through all the images in your assignment/shoot. As we used to say in Six Sigma, customers don't feel _averages,_ they feel _variation._ Cheers, Stephen
Thanks, Stephen! Always love your comments. Great points as usual. Cheers!
My kids are upset because I took their laces, all of them. Don't they understand I have goals?????
*Benjamin's arm is covered from wrist to elbow in a rainbow of shoelaces* - IT'S FOR SCIENCE!
Gerald Undone 😂😂😂
Hihihi
Ben Arnoux The 2nd best reason to have kids, (so you can steal the stuff back that you bought..)
You're a beacon of evidence based reason in an ocean of regurgitated nonsense. Thank you.
Thanks a lot, Michael! I really appreciate that. 😃👍
My thoughts exactly!
Michael, evidently you are not a “current day hard left Democrat “!😉. Lol. Yea I agree with you, facts and reason are getting harder and harder to find these days.
Right on - Custom WB + correct exposure in the camera is the best way to go for image quality and for production speed.
I think you produce easily the most useful videos around the RUclips. I’m grateful. And I’m not hater when I say that I’m tired of life coaching etc even when the videos are about movie making. I like entertainment also but learning makes me more happy. Like Aristoteles said way back that people are in their most happiest state when they learn and they can use the skills with others. Thanks dude.
Don’t mean to say there’s anything wrong at all that RUclipsrs speaks about their life. I’m just tired 😴 - I don’t mean anything negative. But the happy moment what I fell w/ this video was huge for me.
Much appreciated. I enjoy being useful, so thanks for saying so. I agree with you about learning. Happy to help! Cheers 😃🙏
Haha, LOL, thanx for featuring me! I'm happy real Gerald is back! =)
Dude I think Grey “UNDONE” wristbands are a great useful merch idea
What is the song that plays after you subliminally planted seeds of doubt in our minds by potentially saying n'aright at the end leaving us to wonder which dimensional Gerald we are watching?
Hahahaha. Oh that song... 😜 It's called Brenner by Falls.
You have the Peter Gregg whitey balance card. What more do you want from us haha?
Haha Duuudeeee, nice to see you here !
@@geraldundone Thanks ;)
I like your take on different things, you're quickly becoming my favorite youtuber.
Flattered and thankful. Appreciate that! 😃🙏
All this time and I was trying to white balance picking white surfaces... DOH! Johny come lately here, but this has changed my world! Thanks for the video!
I like the approach of showing how it was tested so it can be verified. Good job.
Yes of course, but still the fact he saw himself forced to do it is kinda dumb, because whotebalamcing a shot before you shoot is crucial. There is a rule that says: never doin post, what you can do during production. Andwhite balancing is a camera operators first job to do.
Thanks man! Finally someone who is checking his information before teaching others.
I started watching one of your videos. Before I knew it I was bingeing. So clear, so straight forward, so damned good. Thank you for the excellent nerdy stuff, best resource I have found to date.
Thanks so much for saying that, Jonathan. That's very encouraging. Cheers!
Gerald Undone Still bingeing!
That shoelace thing. Genius.
I’ve just discovered you for the HLG3 stuff, and I turned into the notification squad. Thanks a lot for sharing those really great nuggets of knowledge. Please keep doing what you’re doing!
Thanks a lot! That's awesome to hear. Happy to have a new subscriber. Look forward to future comments! 😃🙏
Wow, another 8000 subs in 2019 so far. Good job, you must be very excited.
Thanks! It's pretty amazing, yeah. Very grateful. 😃🙏
@@geraldundone Good luck for the coming year. :D
He deserves milion+ that knowledge!
always good hearing an echo of your own thoughts/opinions
Best man explained the technicality of videography on the entire RUclips.
I'm just learning about editing for action cam footage and barely know anything but you do a good job of being informative, clear and not overloading people.
Thanks for saying so. I'm happy to hear that!
3rd video I've watched from you back to back and I gotta say your content is gold!
This is awesome - thank you for the deeper dive on this subject.
Regarding the shoelace: I was 100% convinced that it served as an indicator as to whether we've come undone yet.
super super informative! thanks for taking the time to explain and share.
The intro itself deserves a like! Great info and video thank you 🙏
WoWeeii, great tip with the shoelace. Thank you sir, this will save much of my time in edit since i forget about WB over 30% of my shoots!
Great test & demonstration! Bravo as always!
Thank you very much! 😃👍
Thanks for this. I just ordered a18% grey card last night for getting better exposure in my z6 n-log footage but this video really shows I need to be making WB more a priority as well.
That's a solid investment. 👍
I came across your RUclips videos because of my upcoming trip to Alaska to hopefully photograph the Aurora Borealis... I'm fairly new at this hobby maybe 2-3weeks into it and I'm trying to learn as much as possible about night photography etc.
Ok, that shoelace idea is absolutely great!
Honestly, I get home , crack open a beer and see what you have to say . Love it
Thanks for doing so! Happy you're liking the content. Cheers!
Great video, thanks! I think many of us kind of now the difference between raw and .jpg when it comes to white balance, BUT i enjoyed and find it very useful to see practical examples of the limitations 8 bit and 10 bit log has.
Also, well presented!!!
Great video! The same applies to 16 bit TIFF by the way (as you sort of implied). I tested this a while ago, and while the results are better than with 8 bit JPEGs, drastic WB changes still are very destructive. Nowhere close to what's possible with RAW.
Good note, Lukas. Thanks for that! 👍
This is the only content I'd pay for man!
Solid advice from Gerald. It is crucial to have a grey card free of illuminant metamerism. I find recording a white balance from the light falling on the subject at base ISO with an exposure at the mid grey point of the histogram works best. I have learnt that white balance works best in camera at the time of making the picture. Although I work outdoors with natural light, I am aware that most indoor domestic lighting has an unequal spectral distribution of colours, and it may be necessary to make recordings from a grey card in different areas within a scene.
I wear a white lokai band on my wrist, never even thought of using it for this situation , thank you! 🙏🏻🙌🏼
My first year I used the white card and dropper. Now I manual custom white balance also everything. It just seems to work better for me and I find that i have more flexibility to get the white balance and style at times that i want. Just me Like always G man great work.
Thanks so much Gérald ! Like always .. you re the maestro 😉😎📺
Excellent video. Learned a lot. I have never hit the "bell" for any other RUclipsrs as I am on here enough as to not need notifications.
You earned my first "bell" click! Lol you da man thanks for all you do for this community!
Wow! Well I'm flattered. I appreciate it. Looking forward to future comments. Cheers! 😃🙏
Thanks, Gerald. Been living in fear of tackling white balance for...well, forever. Yes, tutorials abound, but I like yours.
Great demonstration and explanation of the WB. And that trick with the shoe lace is cool. I use a grey cat for custom WB for indoor shots.
Well-behaved cat. 😜
Mate, these videos of yours are really first-rate. I've watched a few now and the amount of really solid, evidence-backed information you get into them is admirable - and it's all so clearly presented too. I'm trying to bring myself up from next-to-nothing to reasonably adept video all-rounder in a hurry (expanding an audio-recording business and wanting to hit the ground running) and I feel I've found a proper goldmine of information. Many, many thanks -and I'll visit your Patreon and make my thanks more concrete shortly: if we were on the same continent I would consider buying you a big box of beers or something but this'll have to do!
Hi Gerald Undone, This is great tips. I have been using Auto White Balance until I watch this video. Loved it. I hit the red bell and go
What a great idea, the shoelace is brilliant alternative to a card. I have a gray cloth type velcro Apple watch band that I'm going to start wearing more often on shoots; thanks for sharing!
Excellent info! Thanks for taking the time to do these tests and share the results. I usually like to stylize my WB a little, but it definitely helps to start out with an accurate setting whenever possible. I recently did some run and gun, outdoor vlog-style shooting with AWB, and I noticed it shifting throughout the takes. Next time, I'm locking the WB down first.
Cheers! Yeah, I like to stylize it as well. White balance for vlogging is tough because of the changing environments. Understandable.
Gerald sort of talked about it, but it is absolutely critical if you are shooting video with more than one camera that you have the white balance on a manual setting, and make sure it is the same on each camera (at least, assuming the setting is pretty much equivalent between the cameras).
If you mess it up anyway (you can guess how I know/have ended up investigating this) you may have some success with something like the RE:Match plugin from Revision FX. As Gerald mentioned in the video though, you'll be kicking yourself for it - and after trying to deal with it once, you'll make sure you never make that mistake again.
Something I'm going to try after seeing the shoelace trick, is buying a gray band for my watch. Seems like it would look better than the shoelace, and probably still work.
I really like the fact that you have your own style making videos.
Good job!
Thanks for saying that. Appreciate it!
I always feel smarter after getting undone!
Me filming for 5 years with auto white balance: *interesting* 🤔
Can we just spare a second to think about how amazing and revolutionary JPEG was at the time in the early 90s, and how much of its foundation still lives on in modern video codecs?
Shoelaces undone! Gerald, You are a genius.
I did hit the like button 3 times, the second i heard that (weirdly cool) "what is happening?" now I can go back and actually watch the video !
Excellent WB solution, love it. Made the back of my biz card a white/black/gray card. Always with me.
This is very helpful. I printed a color chart to just test on gopro and yi 4k with different WB to see how well camera captures the colors and also to match both of these camera. I did certain test and it gives me new starting point. Getting correct skin tones was a huge issue in auto WB. Thank you so much for this, well presented and informative.
How about dyeing your hair to all RGB 128?🤣🤣 Just kidding that was very helpful video, Gerald!
Awesome as usual.
My opinion on why you might get better results with the shoe lace is because it's not as reflective as the card.
Good work.
Keep'm comin'
That's quite possible, yeah. Thanks for the kind words! Appreciate the comment. 😃👍
Thanks! ... coming from video/TV (analogue era), I haven't had any difficulties to understand the need of and how to set white balance ... But after shooting digital stills (RAW) (and now video on both DSLR and mirrorless). I have become lazy. The white balance is pretty good. But, you helped me to clarify the importance of setting it proper while shooting video! I need to pull myself in the collar and start set the white balance!!! And also while shooting RAW, just to make it easier in post ... when you have a batch to process. :) Thanks!!!
Appreciate this comment. Thanks for sharing your experience and use case. Cheers! 😃👍
Damn the shoelace trick 🤯🤯 I never noticed, and it's so clever - not to mention, bracelets are fucking great to begin with.
Haha. Thanks! And I definitely agree with your last point! 😃👍
Gerald, thank you sincerely for making this video. This information was extremely beneficial! One of the most overlooked objectives indeed. Oh, and the shoe lace concept...INGENIUS 😉
Thanks, Greg! Really appreciate that. Thanks for saying so. 😃🙏
Hi, in my opinion, if you use the eyedropper to do the white balance of a JPG you will have a better result if you click on any part of the image with 128 of luminosity using "Curves" with the "GRAY" eyedropper.
Great explanation again. If you live in a sunny place your wrist lase could change collor thanks to the sun.
I just figured out I never replied that question you put so much effort into! 🤣
Well, what's happening is that we have again to deal with a video that outstanding that my vocabulary could go to jail for not being able to make it a favor! 🙏
For me, white balance remains something I didn't go into that much, & I would find it kind of stressful to miss it on the go... Now I realize even + why I need to master it & obviously these videos happen to be 1 of the best support for that matter! Thx 👌
Thanks for the really kind words! Always appreciated. I'm glad these videos are useful. 😃👍
Great video, Gerald. I just shot a two-day event at a hotel, and had to deal with tungsten, incandescent, as well as sunlight - all in the same massive boardroom. I set custom WB with my gray card ahead of time, so the shots vary when I moved around the room. I shoot RAW, so I was able to make them look consistent enough when viewed within a collection of 170 photos. Fortunately, I'm the only one who seems to notice that the room has different tint.
I've been there! I sympathize. You're probably just more sensitive because you've been staring at them. Mixed light is tough, but it sounds like you approached it as best as you could without covering windows and turning off lights.
So a quick thing with the log footage. Please try this and see the difference for yourself! Add an adjustment layer and have it over top of the log footage. Apply your lut there, and then white balance the video clip from its Lumitri color(do this with the adjustment layer hidden or at least that’s what I usually do to start). Lumitri places the technical lut before anything, and if I remember right Lumitri is all 8 bit processing.This applies to highlight and shadow retention as well! Ever since we started processing this way in lumitri we saw a massive improvement in what a log video can do even when shot 8bit. It’s obviously not going to be as good as raw but the outcome will definitely be better than the log example shown in this video.
@Gerald Undone
Short: White balance color picker should be done on the white card and the gray card is for exposure.
Long: I love the explanation and though I agree with most of it, the one point I don't agree with is vital for the accuracy of the test. I remembered an old-school film instructor telling me about the black/gray/white card. Gray is to measure the exposure of your shot for skin tones (as in 18% gray card). Your custom white balance should be done on the white card. Though the gray card might work sometimes, it is not completely accurate.
As I replicated this test I did two sets of files, one with a color picker on gray and one set on the white card. You can definitely see the difference, especially on the 2,500 K sample as the process does not overcompensate with red on the white card as it does with the gray.
Thank you for doing this test as it challenged me to do my own and settle this for me once and for all.
You know who else shoots RAW? Polin...Jared Polin. :D
Still the best technical explanations of photo/video on the 'Tube. Great vid, Gerald!
Haha. Yeah, I think I read that somewhere--might have been on a shirt or something. 😜
And thanks, Jason! Much appreciated.
This was really good. I consider myself advanced on settings but I have repeatedly made WB mistakes (and have always used auto for video) great stuff man!
Thanks for saying that. I'm glad it's useful. 😃👍
On my camera I think to have noticed that setting my whitebalance correctly in camera will also help with reducing noise in my footage. I suspect the built in noise reduction works best when all color channels are properly balanced.
I shoot real estate stills as a contractor. My settings are prescribed and include using auto white balance and jpeg images (which is surprising). I shoot in ambient light only, bracketed shots so that my client can merge them into an HDR shot in post. I always look at the final images that they post on their website, and I have to say that I am amazed at how uniform they are able to get the white balance throughout the house with their WB adjustments. My point - of course it is better to shoot RAW when you know you will be adjusting exposure and WB in post, but in some environments (like houses with mostly neutral colors) you can make WB adjustments and still get pretty good - even professional - results even with jpegs. And sure, absolutely, white balance is usually very important to get right.
Yeah, that seems totally reasonable. Thanks for sharing. 😃👍
Ordering a white balance card today and I will learn how to set it in camera!
Nice. Good stuff! 👍
Be sure to get a good one! Independent tests here: www.leeminglutpro.com/whitebalance.html
Every video you make is fire G, give this man a medal!!!
Nice explanation, however I agree with that comment that you should white balance a log footage before applying any other correction. My tests showed much better results that way, although I work in Resolve. And the power a log format is that you can go deeper for better results, if you want. For example you can linearize it, transform the color space into a cone response domain (like Bradford), perform chromatic adaptation there, and transform color space back, and apply the linear to log conversion.
If you shoot bRAW or cDNG on BMD cameras. Doing WB in he raw tab is better than using the eye dropper or the values below(now above in v17) the primary wheels.
What changes is he clipping is no longer full white (or full grey), when highlight recovery is on or off.
As always, Gerald - great stuff, thanks!
You only get this super explanation at this channel. Thanks gerald
Really great video, super helpful! Love that grey wrist band and grey card on the shelf. Timeless content Gerald
Awesome indepth tutorials. Grateful ❤️
This is a good video. I try to always do a custom white balance, but sometimes when I'm running and gunning I forget. Then I'm kicking myself in post.
Excellent ! 11:30 to 11:38 - your reaction - priceless ! LOL
This was amazing. love the way you went through this process. Very clear, concise, and helpful for the newb that i am. subscribed!
You can also use white balance creatively by boosting or favoring a particular temperature in camera, say during sunset or sunrise or blue hour.
Definitely. Indoors too. If you only have a tungsten and daylight, but you want a blue light. Balancing to tungsten will make the daylight bluer and vice versa. And this still supports that you should be thinking about white balance while shooting. Great point! 👍
It's a pity one can't use grey thoughts to set AWB, 'cause that's what some people always have with them.
This was great! Very informative. Thank you.
You can also try changing the temperature in log 10 bit before converting to rec 709. I think there'll be a difference.
Wow, that is way more important to set in camera than I thought. I never want to use auto again, either!
Wish I found you before, great to hear someone that sounds like they know what they're talking about on these subjects, my reddit experts are divided on this