The original ver of this twinkle was edited because sm (apparantly, they put seohyun's voice from tts to cover jessica while singing) but bc people want to hear sica's voice, the uploaded probably edited this out from a fancam (with sica's voice). Sooo, therefore, it kinda seems off and unnatural. But atleast we can all hear them with their true voices :))
Lets appreciate Sunny's angelic voice at 0:53 and 2:21. She's slaying it. Lets not point who's bad or can't. ☺️☺️ Instead lets just appreciate these beautiful ladies
5 SOSHI Of SONE SNSD 4ever yeah they matured and bec of all those issues they tend to be more careful now i think look what happen to ty before announcing baekyeon dating issue she became too careful bec she think she may dissapoint sones in the future on what she will going to do. Thats what i see ...
With the issue of jessica coming back this 2022 I am missing her presence with her 8 sisters, I want them to be together again even just a day to see them being happy altogether again because that's what could have happened though
Its weird how seohyun sounds so off when she sings snsd songs, like she's struggling so much but when i saw her sing in masked singer i was soo blown away.
+Steffany Han this is a complete shit, the original dvd version has her voice clearly, so the person who edited this did it just to start fanwar. Do you actually think they would mute a part of a song, this is ridiculous
Jessica's deserves some solo or sub-unit in her group since then. But I am happy now because she's free and figured out what happened. Recently she signed a new company label 'Coridel' accdng. to the company the solo album is preparing to be release soon. Cant wait
Jessica's part was covered by Seohyun. Maybe, cause the original sound is not Jessica's voice. I was wondering why you did this version, so I went back to listen it again. I founded that that voice was not Jessica's voice. Thank u !!
The sub-unit was supposedly a Quartet (Taeyeon, Jessica, Tiffany, Seohyun). Divas of SNSD. But I guess the reason Jessica was included was due to her schedules/other commitments such as drama/acting for tv series during that year 2012.
As of TTS, you cannot say that Sica did not want be part of it when SM or sub group members mentioned that other 6 members were all busy at that time.. SM would never say that Jessica wanted to be part of sub group and we believed she should not.. SM did prepared for Jessica and Krystal's sister group, I remembered they did even do some demo recording... if Sica was not kicked out from SNSD, they would definitely launch season 2 of Sica & Krystal and their first single or mini album... So do you really think Jessica would leave SNSD by herself (when they had finished shooting of Catch Me If you can JP ver. (you can find it on RUclips and there will be another new sub group with her sis....)
Prove that none SNSD bullying Jessica is 1:50 when Jessica sing Seohyun come and joke around with her and after they hug joona still call Jessica like normal taeyeon never do that bc Jessica is her friend Sunny will never do it cuz she's Jessica friend same with the other
KPOP IS LIFE People are still believing that snsd kicked out/bullied sica? That was old drama that’s not even true at all. The girls have long said that if you are not snsd, you’ll never know how they feel about each other. Friendship of more than 8 years is not easily broken with a simple quarrel or disagreement. SM made her leave the group and the company, not snsd. Even if snsd wanted her to stay, she couldn’t. SM has and always will be the decision maker and their artists have no rights to control their management.
@@JS-wj1cs true.. I really don't understand until now already 2021 people still believe to that theory that makes no sense at all.. But still jessica departure is really mysterious cause no one really knows what happened except sm, snsd members and music industry people..
TBH, I think Jessica's voice sounded better than Seohyun's when she sang her part. I really wished they made it a 4 girl group or that Jessica wasn't too busy with Legally Blonde. T.T Jessica's angelic voice~
+Brielle Ong Nahh, actually TaeTiSeo said in a show that the TaeTiSeo unit even came out in the first place is because in 2012, other Soshi members wanted to act and do other things but TaeTiSeo are the only members that wanted to sing so a Soshi unit was made. Other members had their schedules packed with other activities that year like Jessica who was acting in a KBS drama.
+Nur Qamarina Oh, what I saw in the post was that after Jess was done filming she'd be in a sub unit but someone didn't want her in and asked for Seohyun to be in it instead.Interview?They might be lying though.I don't have a link but maybe you can search it.
+Brielle Ong lol that is not non of taeyeon's business. If Tae kickad out Sica the members Would hate her and leave the group, cuz they maybe think some day she maybe want to kick out you or something and if they didn't leave the group IT would be ver AKWARD betwen them
Guys listen this person removed sica's part so everybody could hear it. If you listen to the actual version you can hear that it is actually seohyun's audio over sica's voice.
I was reading the comments while watching the performance and fuck, why some sones can't just enjoy the song and not fighting for who is better than who? gosh
The law reason makes no sense as Jessica was still under SM at the time this was released. It's more like SM just being the usual bitches that they are.
I think why it was removed is because sometimes for concerts they voice/sing over the clip so the track is more clear because you can get a lot of noise(not just the fans) from concert recordings. It's so it's more clear and smooth. ??
oh! I almost forgot because they do the re-recording for this Jessica may have either left or been away. Or they already decided something and she did not get put into a booth BUT usually a lot of this is done waaaaaaaay in advanced to the release date though. Who knows?
what the fuck SM TOWN? she has a great voice! why are they removing /editing it?! is it because she was kicked out or leave? o'comon why so rude? this is, is her part of her best memory in her life the Ot9 ver. of twinkle! 💣
It was originally like that... JTS (Jessica, Tiffany and Seohyun), but idk why they debuted as TTS (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun). You can hear JTS Oppa Nappa
Golden Star Number 1 I think she was trying to say Jessica instead of Tiffany (Taeyon, Jessica, Seohyun) but then if that happened their voice ranges would be too alike idk why people hate TTS trio, I think their voice ranges fit more than TJS honestly
Jimin's tears I know he/she meant Jess instead of Tiffany, what i said is just curiosity because people dont know that it was originally JTS. Some people say Jess doesnt fit TTS songs, but if Jesa were picked instead of Tae, the songs obviously wouldnt be the same, remember that the person who picks the song for the group, picks the song according to their voices, or simply, Tiffany and Seo would just have different lines in the songs :p personally i am Still curious about JTS... :( or TaeSica subunity (that obviously would have never been planed)
![[STAR ZOOM IN] TaeTiSeo 'Twinkle' Outstanding 160426 EP.74](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/F5qjproKfrs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[STAR ZOOM IN] TaeTiSeo 'Twinkle' Outstanding 160426 EP.74](/img/tr.png)
![소녀시대-태티서(Girl's Generation-TTS)-Cater 2 U [유희열의 스케치북]20141003](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FJKCCrA7O-w/mqdefault.jpg)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[FANCAM] OT9 TWINKLE!! + Ending @ GG Tour in Singapore 2013](/img/1.gif)
When sunny sung that one part it literally gave me chills 😍
Andrea Otti yet people doubts about her debut😒😒
Same😍
1:44 my angel's voice
1:56 that hug of maknae to her unnie, seosic moment.. i love it
Even Sunny can slay this song alone
sunny's voice is underrated. 'even sunny' is so demeaning towards her.
@@TechNerdNetwork ikr. idk why she's in the vocal line but never gets enough line. Even Sooyoung, who has a soft smooth voice.
E
@@TechNerdNetwork lol “demeaning”. I wonder if u will think “demeaning” if i say she cant sing this song alone
I love Sunny but no she wouldnt slay this song alone.
The original ver of this twinkle was edited because sm (apparantly, they put seohyun's voice from tts to cover jessica while singing) but bc people want to hear sica's voice, the uploaded probably edited this out from a fancam (with sica's voice). Sooo, therefore, it kinda seems off and unnatural. But atleast we can all hear them with their true voices :))
*uploader
+난 멀티 팬덤 입니다 I did edit her voice from a fancam into the song
tayswift 13
sssparks fly SM do that too, Jess sing live ,but SM Put Lipsync.. Bcs SM want to Keep Jess image as Main Vocal
Lets appreciate Sunny's angelic voice at 0:53 and 2:21. She's slaying it. Lets not point who's bad or can't. ☺️☺️ Instead lets just appreciate these beautiful ladies
SM is so stupid. We can SEE Jessica, what's the point of removing her voice...?
They will need to pay more
Stupid SM, she's IN the video, why remove her audio 😂😂😂
what do you mean?
sorry I cannot understand
+劉瑞琳 SM removed Jessica's voice from the OT9 version of Twinkle, but it still shows her singing it
+magicmike191v2 when was the ot9 version published?
+劉瑞琳 the OT9 version was filmed in 2013, the dvd was released in late 2014
+magicmike191v2 but why her voice isn't in it
love sica's voice
Give Sunny a fucking solo right tf now that was amazing
sunny voice so greaatt
They look more energetic and happier than now 😢
true.....
Maybe because thhey are matured now
5 SOSHI Of SONE SNSD 4ever yeah they matured and bec of all those issues they tend to be more careful now i think look what happen to ty before announcing baekyeon dating issue she became too careful bec she think she may dissapoint sones in the future on what she will going to do. Thats what i see ...
My girl Sunny killin' it!
MissSaintG Sunn 💗💗
Omg I love Sica, I want full version of Sica sing Twinkle
YEAHHH😭😭
With the issue of jessica coming back this 2022 I am missing her presence with her 8 sisters, I want them to be together again even just a day to see them being happy altogether again because that's what could have happened though
2024 i am here
I love Sunny’s voice.❤️
Suny's voice so amazing it's very beautiful
JESSICA NO.1. I LOVE JESSICA
Sunny sings so well !!!!!!!!!!!
sunny's voice 😍😍
It shows how Taeyeon is having fun singing Twinkle with all the members!
Sunny was amazing！
taeyeon hella killed this! she seems so baddass and happy in this performance...her voice is so effortless
2021 is nearly over and yet im still watching ot9. Just simply regret I was too small in 2013 that I couldn't afford to go to their concert ever once.
The Sunny part is the best
Slay Sunny that's our girl 😍😍😍
The people in that concert are so god damn lucky THEY GOT TO HEAR IT
Sunny slayed
sunny sound really great here😍😍.. i fcking really need her solo😣😣
xolovesme _ ofc SM should.! she have a nice voice
Tayeon really gave me goosebumps with her high notes.. Aww miss Sica
Sunny snatched my wig on this part 0:54
O MG SUNNY VOICE HERE!!!!
Never thought Twinkle would sound good when sung by Girls' Generation
Their voices is so good to hear~
Its weird how seohyun sounds so off when she sings snsd songs, like she's struggling so much but when i saw her sing in masked singer i was soo blown away.
ahhhhhh.... we miss this moments reaaly ... !!
the way sunny and jessica slayed this song THEY SHOW SM THE VOCAL LINE IS FIVE NOT 3
jessica was always main vocal wdym
When Sunny did Tiffany part
It's really nonsense taking out Jessi's voice because she's on the video. Sometimes SM really sucks. Btw, great editing skills tho! :-)
Jaxx Ongpauco ikr! Hate it whenever they take out Jessica's voice! No one can replace her
Yeah that’s very low to do stupid SM just because she left doesn’t mean that they can do that !
They can't put her voice in twinkle live because when she left, the song is not part of their prior agreement voice usage ☺️
sunny and jess should be on the song !!! 😊
Sunny and Sooyoung really sounds great in this song
Sooyoung's voice is so good
Rewatching this and remembering why Sunny is their 3rd or 4th top vocal only behind the TTS members, what a group of vocal legends.
they are all happy here .......
Miss Sunny's voice is so magnificent😘😻😍 she deserves her solo.
is no one gonna talk about how cute maknae and jessica play together at 1:50 onwards
Jessica Voice Edited by fans..thanks who maked this video.i say thnk u so much.
I Like this version of twinkle better cause I can enjoy watching our nine girls together
Me gusta la voz en esta cancion de Sunny y Sooyoung
:)
This always makes me smile 😊
SM sucks.. Is it right to remove Jessica's audio while she's singing? -____-
+Steffany Han yes :D
isn't Jessica one of them too? why they removed her?
+SuhailiMalik Because SM entertainment's directors are a bunch of assholes..
its true
+Steffany Han this is a complete shit, the original dvd version has her voice clearly, so the person who edited this did it just to start fanwar. Do you actually think they would mute a part of a song, this is ridiculous
0:06 / 0:09 / 1:19 / 1:45 / 1:56 / 2:03 / 2:14 / 2:19 / 2:50 / 3:15 it's cute seeing sica had fun on the stage!
2018, and I'm still crying. I miss OT9.
Jessica's deserves some solo or sub-unit in her group since then. But I am happy now because she's free and figured out what happened. Recently she signed a new company label 'Coridel' accdng. to the company the solo album is preparing to be release soon. Cant wait
thank you for your effort in editting this video
Thank you!!
Omg i really need this version thx
Miss them being like this together :' hope can see them all together like this again :'
Jessica's part was covered by Seohyun. Maybe, cause the original sound is not Jessica's voice. I was wondering why you did this version, so I went back to listen it again. I founded that that voice was not Jessica's voice. Thank u !!
does sooyoung not look JUST like aoa's jimin @ 0:37? jesus
I see it
Omg it did happened 😂😂
Ew hell no
Sooyoung is not a bullier 😒
sooyoung honey im so so sorry
Heeeyyyeeaah Geudaeye twinkle nareul bwa!! Oooowowwwooo
The best part :D i love this part so much
Sm is so dumb like we can SEE Jessica, what's the point pretending she didn't participate? Like they could erase her or something, oh my goodness.
Appreciate your effort so much!!!!
thanks
Taeyeon was at her happiest during this concert tour unlike now... You can feel her sadness last gg concert tour as 8 members.
The sub-unit was supposedly a Quartet (Taeyeon, Jessica, Tiffany, Seohyun). Divas of SNSD.
But I guess the reason Jessica was included was due to her schedules/other commitments such as drama/acting for tv series during that year 2012.
Y por la subunidad q iba hacer cn Krystal
omg taeyeon's high note!! slayeon as always~
DAMN SUNNY KILLED ME
MISS OT9 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
they all did great esp taeyeon and seohyun 👏💓 seo wasn't shouting her high notes anymore
I really miss this era :(
makes me really sad. but thank you for the video. no wonder icouldnt hear her. they removed it
I love them so much. TaeTiSeo, Sica, Sunny, Sooyoung, Yuri too can slays this song. Uhhh 💖💖💖💖
As of TTS, you cannot say that Sica did not want be part of it when SM or sub group members mentioned that other 6 members were all busy at that time.. SM would never say that Jessica wanted to be part of sub group and we believed she should not..
SM did prepared for Jessica and Krystal's sister group, I remembered they did even do some demo recording... if Sica was not kicked out from SNSD, they would definitely launch season 2 of Sica & Krystal and their first single or mini album... So do you really think Jessica would leave SNSD by herself (when they had finished shooting of Catch Me If you can JP ver. (you can find it on RUclips and there will be another new sub group with her sis....)
Prove that none SNSD bullying Jessica is 1:50 when Jessica sing Seohyun come and joke around with her and after they hug joona still call Jessica like normal taeyeon never do that bc Jessica is her friend Sunny will never do it cuz she's Jessica friend same with the other
KPOP IS LIFE
People are still believing that snsd kicked out/bullied sica? That was old drama that’s not even true at all. The girls have long said that if you are not snsd, you’ll never know how they feel about each other. Friendship of more than 8 years is not easily broken with a simple quarrel or disagreement. SM made her leave the group and the company, not snsd. Even if snsd wanted her to stay, she couldn’t. SM has and always will be the decision maker and their artists have no rights to control their management.
@@JS-wj1cs true.. I really don't understand until now already 2021 people still believe to that theory that makes no sense at all.. But still jessica departure is really mysterious cause no one really knows what happened except sm, snsd members and music industry people..
TBH, I think Jessica's voice sounded better than Seohyun's when she sang her part. I really wished they made it a 4 girl group or that Jessica wasn't too busy with Legally Blonde. T.T Jessica's angelic voice~
Actually it was originally TaeTiJess or TaeTiSica but then idk but they said Tae didn't want her in.Can't find a different one.
+Brielle Ong Nahh, actually TaeTiSeo said in a show that the TaeTiSeo unit even came out in the first place is because in 2012, other Soshi members wanted to act and do other things but TaeTiSeo are the only members that wanted to sing so a Soshi unit was made. Other members had their schedules packed with other activities that year like Jessica who was acting in a KBS drama.
+Nur Qamarina Oh, what I saw in the post was that after Jess was done filming she'd be in a sub unit but someone didn't want her in and asked for Seohyun to be in it instead.Interview?They might be lying though.I don't have a link but maybe you can search it.
+Brielle Ong As if. Dont be so naive and believe anything. SM decided who's in a unit, the members don't have any say in it.
+Brielle Ong lol that is not non of taeyeon's business. If Tae kickad out Sica the members Would hate her and leave the group, cuz they maybe think some day she maybe want to kick out you or something and if they didn't leave the group IT would be ver AKWARD betwen them
I miss them especially JESSICA💕😭👏👑
Miss the old eras when the girls were all together and close
Guys listen this person removed sica's part so everybody could hear it. If you listen to the actual version you can hear that it is actually seohyun's audio over sica's voice.
Sica with baby seo .. so cute .. 😄😄
I was reading the comments while watching the performance and fuck, why some sones can't just enjoy the song and not fighting for who is better than who? gosh
ot9 is a miracle
I do not know why SM took her voice away since we can still see her singing the part but it could be for law reason not sure
The law reason makes no sense as Jessica was still under SM at the time this was released. It's more like SM just being the usual bitches that they are.
Imagine if the subunit debuted as TJTS instead, the full vocal power
sunny tho
I think why it was removed is because sometimes for concerts they voice/sing over the clip so the track is more clear because you can get a lot of noise(not just the fans) from concert recordings. It's so it's more clear and smooth. ??
oh! I almost forgot because they do the re-recording for this Jessica may have either left or been away. Or they already decided something and she did not get put into a booth BUT usually a lot of this is done waaaaaaaay in advanced to the release date though. Who knows?
She was actually singing here, though. Why did they do this? Because SM are bitches. Simple as that. Look up the company's sordid history.
cuteness overload..
Jessica 😢
2:52 so badasss❤️❤️❤️
twinkle is a good song for our ot9
😇😇 waaaaaaaa. Youre awesome Jessica !
I miss them😢😢
thanks!!
You're welcome
ค่ายsm ชอบทำให้แฟนคลับร้องไห้อยู่ เราเป็นหนึ่งในนั้นด้วย T.T
I don't remember which video I watched, SM had use Seohyun voice to cover Jessica voice, that make me feel so bad
I can’t believe sm removed jessicas vocals ugh
what the fuck SM TOWN? she has a great voice! why are they removing /editing it?! is it because she was kicked out or leave? o'comon why so rude? this is, is her part of her best memory in her life the Ot9 ver. of twinkle! 💣
it's so sad that yoona didn't have a single line
I miss my baby girls ughhhh 😢
1:56 Why am I crying? T_T
I want TJS more than TTS.
It was originally like that... JTS (Jessica, Tiffany and Seohyun), but idk why they debuted as TTS (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun). You can hear JTS Oppa Nappa
Golden Star Number 1 I think she was trying to say Jessica instead of Tiffany (Taeyon, Jessica, Seohyun)
but then if that happened their voice ranges would be too alike
idk why people hate TTS trio, I think their voice ranges fit more than TJS honestly
Jimin's tears I know he/she meant Jess instead of Tiffany, what i said is just curiosity because people dont know that it was originally JTS. Some people say Jess doesnt fit TTS songs, but if Jesa were picked instead of Tae, the songs obviously wouldnt be the same, remember that the person who picks the song for the group, picks the song according to their voices, or simply, Tiffany and Seo would just have different lines in the songs :p personally i am Still curious about JTS... :( or TaeSica subunity (that obviously would have never been planed)
oh hahaha, oops my bad. And yes I am curious about JTS too D: so sad they didn't get to have another song...
No jessica have a sub group along with krystal so she replaced by seohyun