Uni-Byte 0060 - FG 100 DDS Function Generator: NO! JUST NO!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025

Комментарии • 88

  • @sorcererstan
    @sorcererstan Год назад +11

    I just re-checked mine that I got several years ago and it's actually very nice waveforms all around, up to the max specs. Must have gotten lucky.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      You may have gotten your before the attack of the clones!

    • @muppetpaster
      @muppetpaster Год назад

      Same here...ordered one 2 weeks ago after seeing this, just to have a laugh...Have to say I'm powering it with 12 Volts.....
      And hey...What'd you expect of this, being just south of 10 dollars...I actually paid 7 Euro's.

    • @electromagix
      @electromagix 7 месяцев назад

      me too a lucky one. got a unit with awesome performance

  • @Chuckmefarley
    @Chuckmefarley Год назад +2

    I don't think I need a AWG for what I do just yet and I do have the little XR2206 kit in case I need to make a speaker beep. The local online retailer had this one for sale with one review that was terrible so I was really looking forward to your input. Also looking forward to see if changing the opamp works, I had a clone DSO150 oscilloscope go magic smoke on me and after ordering new ICL7660 (I think) IC's I managed to get it working fairly ok after that.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      The little XR2206, despite having issues of it's own, is head and shoulders better than this. I think I'm going to use NE5532 replacements. Others seem to have had luck with them. Good going on the DSO150!

  • @trcwm
    @trcwm Год назад +2

    Great video! anxiously awaiting the follow-up.

  • @wnekuu
    @wnekuu Месяц назад +1

    I just got mine. At 10kHz all the waveforms are beautiful, at 100kHz sin becomes maybe a little bit too triangular but still looks like sin, square is rounded a bit but still looks more or less like square. Faaar better results that you have, so I must have been lucky with good unit

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Месяц назад

      Go see the video where I fix this one. You should be able to get a really good sin wave up to 400kHz.

    • @wnekuu
      @wnekuu Месяц назад

      @uni-byte ah I don't have a need for that :) tbh for now I bought it for one project for university where I need as slow sin as possible, and for private projects it's one of those things that better to have and not need than need and not have :)

  • @franciscoferreira-eh1yu
    @franciscoferreira-eh1yu 26 дней назад +1

    The pwm able pin of arduino does not do all that ? If if does, it is possible to use one as frequency genarator ?

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  25 дней назад

      They do not use PWM, they use DDS (Direct Digital Synthesis). 8 I/O lines feed an R-2R ladder type DAC then the output from that is filtered. This is a frequency generator.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  25 дней назад

      You might also want to view my videos #0071 and #0139.

    • @franciscoferreira-eh1yu
      @franciscoferreira-eh1yu 25 дней назад

      @@uni-byte Thank you for the answer. The 0071 I was already watched. The 0139 is being really useful. Just to see if I get the concept right: (long message ahead warring) If I make a a 16 r2r resistor ladder, and connect it to 8 digital Arduino ports, turn on port D12, turn off port D12, and do the same till port D4, turn all ports off and repeat, assuming there is no capacitance in the circuit, I would got a wave similar to what you showed in the video ? That would also be a crude DDS ? (not sure if I was clear enough, English is not my first language)

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  25 дней назад

      @@franciscoferreira-eh1yu You would use 8 I/O bits all on a single port in the MCU and treat is as a parallel port. You would have to store whatever waveform you want to reproduce in the MCU memory as a table, then read the 8-bit (0-255) values from the table and send the value to the 8-bit I/O port at one time. You would not manipulate each bit separately.

    • @franciscoferreira-eh1yu
      @franciscoferreira-eh1yu 25 дней назад +1

      @@uni-byte thank you

  • @jcbu55
    @jcbu55 Год назад +2

    Can the device be used as a sound generator? Thanks for the reply.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      If you get a working one it will generate audio frequencies.

    • @jcbu55
      @jcbu55 Год назад +1

      @@uni-byte I got mine now and it works great. 👍

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      @@jcbu55 Good to hear!

  • @shaunmorrissey7313
    @shaunmorrissey7313 Год назад +3

    I have one of these and I have to say mine behaves completely differently, I opened mine up and the construction is quite a bit deferent and the op-amps used are TL082C. Seems I have been lucky with my purchase.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      Nice! Do you remember the vendor you got it from?

    • @shaunmorrissey7313
      @shaunmorrissey7313 Год назад

      @@uni-byte Hi, looking back I bought mine on the 6th of October 2021 from an ebay seller base in the UK. I didn't think I had it that long.

  • @ivolol
    @ivolol Год назад +2

    I saw a russian? video of a guy who had ordered a DIY 0-30V PSU board. Whole board worked fine [eventually], except... they had included dud opamps in the kit. So many problems on first start. And when he substituted some others he had on hand... also dud 'cus they'd be ordered from ali. He eventually made his own 'opamp tester' circuit (verify very basic comparator functionality) to find a portion of working ones out of what he had on hand, and finally the whole kit worked perfectly.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      The whole counterfeit chip thing seems to be getting out of control. For me, I tend to buy more for reputable outlets like DigiKey more these days. I do have some eBayer's I've used for years that have yet to pass me a counterfeit chip, but they usually don't have everything I need.

  • @markharrisllb
    @markharrisllb Год назад +2

    I bought one of these when I first had my Hantek 6022BL. Even though I was extremely new at the time I realised it wasn’t helping my progression. Sadly I think the market will be mainly the very naive like myself and it does negatively impact on our experience and journey into learning electronics. Even sadder is that there are several RUclips videos praising them at the price.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      Yeah, things like this can be a real drawback to someone just getting their feet wet. Like buying a budding musician a $300 trombone. More likely to make them hate playing rather than excel at it.

  • @theDaftman
    @theDaftman 3 месяца назад +2

    well i have 2 of these, i use them for SSB setup, nothing wrong with mine at all, you must have got yourself a dad one.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  3 месяца назад

      Yes, I certainly did. I had to replace the op-amps to get it working. They were fakes. You should look at the follow up video. the link to that is in the description. Look for "We fix the FG 100 DDS:"

    • @theDaftman
      @theDaftman 3 месяца назад +1

      @@uni-byte Ok ill go back and look at that. thanks for all your time needed to edit and up load.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  3 месяца назад

      @@theDaftman You're welcome. Thanks for watching!

  • @8thsinner
    @8thsinner 5 месяцев назад +1

    I had been looking at this to make my way into the pemf field just to experiment, Don't really know what i'm doing but if this is so crap, what other options are there in the pulsed signal offerings?
    My budget isn't crazy but could stretch for more than this unit goes for by a little.
    Is there even such a thing as a cheap, two channel adjustable voltage pulse generator that works and won't require an expensive oscilliscope to experiment with?
    I won't likely be going into the high kilahertz ranges, solfegios and such are mainly under 1000hz...

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  5 месяцев назад +1

      The FeelTech FY-3200S has a fairly goo reputation and can be had for under $100.

    • @8thsinner
      @8thsinner 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@uni-byte I've been looking at a few now.
      CDEK SDS1102X
      UNI-T UTG962E
      OWON DGE2070
      A little more cost, and i'm leading towards the first cdek, but combined pulsed generator and oscilloscope in one seems good, but I don't know what I might be missing.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  5 месяцев назад +1

      @@8thsinner I thought the CDEK SDS1102X was an oscilloscope? I have heard good things about the UNI-T and the Owon. I'm not sure what Owon's support is like but I do know UNI-T do not support their products very well.

    • @8thsinner
      @8thsinner 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@uni-byte Oscilliscope and generator...so it says at least, but I don't know, is it better to have both functions separate?
      I'm also not sure of the differences between wave generator and pulse...
      mm...help...lol

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  5 месяцев назад +1

      @@8thsinner I know very little abut the CDEK, but I do think it's better to have your scope and FG as separate instruments.
      Any good function generator will generate bot waves and pulses. Both the Owon and the UNI-T will do this. They will produce any waveform you like.

  • @tomigalik4052
    @tomigalik4052 Год назад +1

    How many max amper can it produce in output?

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      The original op amps are capable of about 10-15 mA. The ones I put in can do maybe twice that. So, not much. It really is a high impedance output and NOT a 50 ohm output like hey suggest in the information sheet.

    • @muppetpaster
      @muppetpaster Год назад

      Sure.....Amps output....😂😂😂 Funny man...

  • @alasdair4161
    @alasdair4161 11 месяцев назад +1

    I made the mistake of building the kit version of the FG-085, and it is even worse. The FW has more bugs than a beehive.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  11 месяцев назад

      I wasn't even aware of that model. Is it just the FW?

  • @paulhall9713
    @paulhall9713 9 месяцев назад +1

    At about 15:00 I nearly choked to death.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  9 месяцев назад

      LOL! Thanks!

  • @TonyCasneuf-l8l
    @TonyCasneuf-l8l Год назад +1

    Thanks for your video, the one i've bought doesn't even generate waves only bulbs coming out 😂

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      Sorry to hear that. If you can check the output of the DAC to see if it's okay then maybe an op-amp replacement might get it going.

  • @aquinamedia4508
    @aquinamedia4508 Год назад +1

    Many thanks for the educational and buyer beware content!
    Could be an interesting follow-up video on swapping the op-amps.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      Yes, it will be revealing for sure.

  • @ovalwingnut
    @ovalwingnut Год назад +1

    GR8T Infotainment. Thank you.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад +1

      Glad you liked it!

  • @davidv1289
    @davidv1289 Год назад +3

    Thank you for sharing - sorry, but I have to admit I had a good laugh at the waveforms - glad to hear you got your money back. Replacing the opamps would be interesting and the "clip and clean" method would probably be best in this situation - less chance of board damage. Regards, David

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      You and me both! Yup, the "clip and clean" method looks best to me too.

  • @mrv4757
    @mrv4757 10 месяцев назад +1

    Well, the review seems to be missing a suggestion on a good generator within the same price range. The video is interesting anyway, so thanks for sharing.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  10 месяцев назад +2

      Problem is, there is nothing else in the price range. If you get one of these that works properly, or you have the skills to get it working (see the follow up video #0071) it's pretty good for the money. The next level up and your into the $75 range. But you do get a lot more in that range.

    • @wnekuu
      @wnekuu Месяц назад +1

      ​@@uni-bytewow I bought nine for like maybe 12 usd from China lol, if I would have to pay 75 or 100 usd I would just add a little bit more and buy one from Siglent connected to my scope, but as I mentioned in other comment mine seems to be good one, and for what I need it for I wouldn't spend more anyway, but good to know there weren't any alternatives anyway

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Месяц назад +1

      @@wnekuu Not in that price range anyway.

  • @jlippencott1
    @jlippencott1 7 месяцев назад +1

    One would think they don’t do any testing with such a reject rate.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  7 месяцев назад

      There was so much wrong with this I'd have to agree. I'd go a step further and say there is no quality control of any kind.

  • @jeanyluisa8483
    @jeanyluisa8483 8 месяцев назад +1

    Those cheap function generators are sold by countless resellers. Even though they all look the same, they have different firmware versions and and some different hardware components.
    Thats why the many tests of this generator on RUclips show so different results.
    I bought one of them about 3 years ago and its as lousy as the one in this video. I bought another one 2 month ago. That one works fine, the sigals it generates are ok and it even has some more waveforms than the old one.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  8 месяцев назад

      This one was repairable. See the link in the description "We fix the FG 100 DDS".👍

    • @jeanyluisa8483
      @jeanyluisa8483 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@uni-byte Oh yes, now when you point me o that video - I have seen that video some time ago and ordered some N5532 to fix it. Problem is just, that I have no experience with soldering those tiny smd parts. My soldering skills are already bad enough at bigger parts. So fixing it is one of many projects for "later", when I am in the mood to try it. As I wrote I already have a new one of those FG 100 DDS and it works fine.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  8 месяцев назад

      @@jeanyluisa8483 Sounds good!

  • @mdelabo
    @mdelabo 11 месяцев назад +1

    It strange on your oscillo
    Mine wark very good!

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  11 месяцев назад

      Yeah, it looks like some are good, others not so much. Watch the follow up video. We fix the problem.

  • @stargazer30721
    @stargazer30721 Год назад +1

    We bought one of these at work because it was inexpensive and if was damaged in the field it would be ok. Had all of the same issues our tech says. Buyer beware!

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      Thanks for the additional info. It does seem the majority of them these days are tiny boat anchors.

  • @icollided
    @icollided Год назад +1

    Thank you for saving me $25

  • @Lk-Snow1
    @Lk-Snow1 Месяц назад +1

    Can i find treasure use this?

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Месяц назад +1

      You want to make a metal detector out of this? I don't quite understand.

    • @Lk-Snow1
      @Lk-Snow1 Месяц назад +1

      @@uni-byte i want make longrange gold detector..help me sir

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Месяц назад +1

      @@Lk-Snow1 Everybody would like a long range gold detector. While you would certainly need a tunable oscillator to make high sensitivity and high discrimination metal detector, you will need a lot more than just the oscillator. I cannot cover that in the comments section of RUclips. Good metal detectors are not cheap - for a host of reasons.

    • @Lk-Snow1
      @Lk-Snow1 Месяц назад +1

      @@uni-byte Thank you🙏

    • @Lk-Snow1
      @Lk-Snow1 Месяц назад +1

      @@uni-byte someone make gold detector use dds function generator or other frequency generator. i don't know is it fake or true

  • @oldskeptic1513
    @oldskeptic1513 Год назад +1

    ... once upon a time there was an expression, you only get what you pay for ... I do not think I'm the first to say, you've got a faulty unit as well ...

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      I ended up fixing it and it turns out to be quite nice. See this video: ruclips.net/video/XWJOChu1ZMc/видео.html

    • @oldskeptic1513
      @oldskeptic1513 Год назад

      @@uni-byte ... thanks, I shall ...

  • @johnwest7993
    @johnwest7993 Год назад +1

    In my professional opinion, 'All broke ting'.

  • @dishepullisais2434
    @dishepullisais2434 Год назад +1

    05:00

  • @TRONMAGNUM2099
    @TRONMAGNUM2099 Год назад +1

    I was dying laughing watching this. Pure garbage there. You could do just as good maybe better with a 555 and a breadboard.

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      A 555 would be a dream in comparison to this in it's original state. After replacing the op-amps with real ones it turns out to be quite good: ruclips.net/video/XWJOChu1ZMc/видео.html

  • @SendyTheEndless
    @SendyTheEndless Год назад +1

    More like.... DYSfunction Generator : >

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  Год назад

      LOL! Just about sums it up.

  • @kd5yut
    @kd5yut 11 месяцев назад +1

    what do you expect from chinese junk? spend a little money and get a good one

    • @uni-byte
      @uni-byte  11 месяцев назад +1

      Thanks for your comment. The point of getting this was for review as a part of the beginner's electronics tool kit I am developing. It may come as a surprise to some people, but there are some beginners that do not have the money to spend on a $600 function generator, or at least do not want to spend that kind of money (+$600 for a scope, +600 for a power supply, +++$$$) on a hobby they may abandon for one reason or another. That's they idea behind the beginner's tool kit. To put together a set of useful instruments and tools at a reasonable cost. These were once pretty good little generators, but doing this review we found out that that the market is being supplied with counterfeit components.

  • @gordselectronicshobby3853
    @gordselectronicshobby3853 Год назад

    The one I have works very well. You must have a problem with yours.