Naw, these were worked with using the actors probably. Yueh was described as having purple lips like 20 times in the book and an AI would have factored that.
Baron Harkonnnen was not bald, the Harkonnen had black hair. Gaius Helen Mohiam was skinny with hawk nose picturing a witch. Halleck had an inkvine scar on his cheek. Hawat had thin ruby-red lips due to sapho juice consumption. Paul Atreidis was 15 yo and the book specifically said that he was even small for his age. A child. I see that the author was not really into the book detail at all.
I like the movie verisons by far, except Chani. Zendaya is not pretty enough for MC. Rebecca Fergusson as Jessica, Javier Bardem as Stilgar, Timothee as Paul, Oscar as Leto I, Stellan Skarsgård as Baron, Charlotte Rampling as Reverend mother. No casting could be better. Specially Timothee, Javier Bardem and Rebecca's performance was just phenomenal. It could not be better than this. Absolute perfection
I don't know who put the description into the AI but those images are not accurate to the book. All the Harkonnen have red hair and are not bald. Paul and Jessica have Auburn hair. Gaius Helen Mohiam is supposed to be old but doesn't look old as the Bene Gesserit control their aging. Dr. Yeuh and Thufir are supposed to have orange stained lips from all the spice they eat, same goes for all the Fremen characters. Stilgar is supposed to have lines in his mustache from constantly having his nostril breathing tube pressing down on his face. He is also supposed to be darker skinned. Whereas Chani is supposed to be lighter skinned than Stilgar and is not supposed to have Auburn hair.
@@workingmamma5342 No, his hair color is talked about when he finds out who his grandfather is on his mother's side. If you have watched the new film, they actually give Paul and Jessica that touch of red to their hair.
@@LiamborninDC Paul had black hair, of that, I am sure. And an oval face, like Jessica's. The most complete physical description was made in the very first chapter, when he met Mohiam. Black hair. Green eyes and oval face (like his mom), long, narrow nose. Small built for his age.
@@LiamborninDC The filmmaker has creative liberties. When Paul finds out who his grandfather is, the color of his hair is not mentioned. Only his mother's.
Buzzfeed did a list too and made everyone basically black with a crap load of freckles. The casting was top notch but my only gripe was the north vs south tribes thing (the Freman were and unified people) and Paul and Chani's relationship was much different in the book. Chani stood by Paul in every decision Paul made, she even supported Paul marrying Irulan for political gain. Zendaya was more of a pouting 10 year old child that threw tantrums all the time.
Correct me if I am wrong, but there are a lot of things here that are just not true. Kynes has blonde hair. Gurney has a gigantic scar on his face. Yueh has purple lips, and his hair is held in a ring. I do like how old Thufir looks, in the books characters remark on how old and battered he looks. I also like the dark skin on Leto I.
According to Frank Herbert's story, the Harkonnens have red hair by descent, and the planetologist Pardot Kynes is a man, not a woman. In the Dune book, the Atreides house are nobles full of luxuries like the kings of England and the Harkonnens are ruthless beings and enjoy killing, the latest Dune movie is well run but has many flaws
That's great! I love this book series, and I do recommend you read the entire saga, even the prequels and sequels, that were written by the son of the author. Many people don't like them, but I personally do, and they were written based on material the author left before dying.
Beware, there is a HUGE difference between books by Frank and Brian (his son). I read the 3 prequels by Brian, and to the date, it was the worst experience I had with sci-fi books. If I could, I'd ask for a refund. I was even afraid to go to the Dune book itself because of that experience. Gladly, Frank is a real sci-fi author and great writer overall.
@@SamuelHenriqueGermano I seem to have a little interest in Dune. So I feel like just reading the first three books which they call “The Great Dune Trilogy” is good enough for me. I don’t usually read very many books. I appreciate your recommendation though.
I'm totally OK with how DV and David Lynch reinterpreted some of the characters' appearances. The real shame lies in the SyFy Original miniseries. The only good casting choice in the entire production was Ian McNeice as the Baron. That's it and that's all. And those stupid hats.
Forçaram demais na Chani, em? No livro é dito explicitamente que ela tem os cabelos claros e a pele bem clara, que sua forma se assemelha a de um anjo, com cabelos curtos, na altura pouco acima dos ombros.
Liet Kynes was a white skin man?! xD BRUH! They could at least leave him as a guy. AT LEAST. Why won't fascist DEI make their own NEW stories with original diverse characters instead of 'changing' everything what was already written and known?
In the Dune universe this video would be banned after the Butlerian revolt. "Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of the human mind ". AI is a crime against humanity 😂
Bonjour .quel magnifique travail. Quelle déception que cette dernière adaptation cinéma de dune. Tout est fade et il n y as aucune originalité. Encore une fois votre travail est superbes .cordialement pg
к сожалению на нейросеть влияют, кадры , изображения и иллюстрации из фильмов о Дюне распространенные в интернете , так что генерируемые картины искажены ранним представлением
The casting they ended with was good, but some of my dream casting would be: Leto: Viggo Mortenson Thufir: Jim Carter Gurney: Will Patton Duncan: Aidan Turner Emperor: Charles Dance
@@richlisola1 Yes, I got that. Just wonder why they are both redheads, since they come from different places and families and have different backgrounds
@@arlequinacontostavlos2100 Well, let’s see. The Known Universe is a big place, expect redheads to exist in many places. And contrary to some beliefs. Not all redheads are related.
@@richlisola1 Really? Wow... Regardless, it's still weird that two main charactets not related whatsoever are redheads, since in books, many characters are very different from each other (when not realated), so people when reading can really imagine them apart
Jajaja nooo, a Gurney le hacen falta como 500 cicatrices más, Jessica no tenía el rostro TAAN enjuto y afilado, de hecho señalan que su rostro tenía un curvatura sensual que conservó incluso siendo una mujer madura y que heredara de su padre..., ahí les falló bastante. Paul se ve desproporcionadoxd
I really like that dennis made all the harkonnen bald and hairless. Make it soo much easier to differentiate different characters and races.
Yeah, the harkonenns being bald just makes them a lot more sinister looking than that goofy af red hair of previous adaptations.
Yes, but is wrong
I’m not a fan because it makes them look too alien
Timothy Chalamet was great casting. He looks like what the book describes, and he has acting talent.
I was thinking about Tamino Amir as Paul tho
No. All actors total misscast. Book novel is too hard to make a movie.
Well, IIRC Paul Atreides was described as "short for his age"
Paul was supposed to be much younger when he arrived in Arakkis. there's a reason why they referred to him as a child
I still like Kyle MacLachlan more. Nothing against Timothy Chalamet, he's a good actor, but I just thought Kyle MacLachlan was more charismatic.
Naw, these were worked with using the actors probably. Yueh was described as having purple lips like 20 times in the book and an AI would have factored that.
Baron Harkonnnen was not bald, the Harkonnen had black hair.
Gaius Helen Mohiam was skinny with hawk nose picturing a witch.
Halleck had an inkvine scar on his cheek.
Hawat had thin ruby-red lips due to sapho juice consumption.
Paul Atreidis was 15 yo and the book specifically said that he was even small for his age. A child.
I see that the author was not really into the book detail at all.
Nope. The Baron had red hair, likeJessica (his daughter!). Jessica did not have such a narrow face. She had an oval face, with green eyes.
Only Feyd had black hair.
@@sectorgovernor Correct.
No harkonnen red hair
Yes, and Kynes is a middle-aged redhead man not a "Keanu Reeves-like" guy.
I think I actually like most of the movie characters better 😂. They did an amazing job with that movie, it was beautiful
Except for Liet Kynes being race and gender swapped. That was stupid and woke (is that redundant?).
@@sparkyblazeup1 Yeah for sure. Really unnecessary pandering, thankfully the actress still did a really good job
Herbert chose the characters’ looks for a reason, I saw no good reason to change them
@@sparkyblazeup1Chani was race swapped too
No Princess Irulan, Feyd-Rautha or Alia, but we have Shadout Mapes. Interesting choice.
I like the movie verisons by far, except Chani. Zendaya is not pretty enough for MC. Rebecca Fergusson as Jessica, Javier Bardem as Stilgar, Timothee as Paul, Oscar as Leto I, Stellan Skarsgård as Baron, Charlotte Rampling as Reverend mother. No casting could be better. Specially Timothee, Javier Bardem and Rebecca's performance was just phenomenal. It could not be better than this. Absolute perfection
Jessica in the books has round face, so I don't know what description AI used
The Atreides seems having grown on a planet with a (slightly) lighter gravity than Earth, they 're all tall and slim!
Jessica looks like a mean 2nd grade teacher and I always imagined Gurney looking like Elton John.
Where is Gurney's inkvine scar.?
Where's Gurney's inkvine scar?
List is Chani’s father Imagine that Denis
Wow, AI missed the mark on all of them! It's just wrong.
Liet was a joke
Why’d they have to do Kynes dirty like that
She was good
What was good about her exactly?
in the book he had unique voice, motivation and gravity.
None of that existed in the movie.
@@Akhypotter13she was false, and represented nothing of the real character. More racist pandering.
I don't know who put the description into the AI but those images are not accurate to the book.
All the Harkonnen have red hair and are not bald.
Paul and Jessica have Auburn hair.
Gaius Helen Mohiam is supposed to be old but doesn't look old as the Bene Gesserit control their aging.
Dr. Yeuh and Thufir are supposed to have orange stained lips from all the spice they eat, same goes for all the Fremen characters.
Stilgar is supposed to have lines in his mustache from constantly having his nostril breathing tube pressing down on his face. He is also supposed to be darker skinned.
Whereas Chani is supposed to be lighter skinned than Stilgar and is not supposed to have Auburn hair.
I believe Paul had black hair, like Duke Leto.
@@workingmamma5342 No, his hair color is talked about when he finds out who his grandfather is on his mother's side.
If you have watched the new film, they actually give Paul and Jessica that touch of red to their hair.
@@LiamborninDC Paul had black hair, of that, I am sure. And an oval face, like Jessica's. The most complete physical description was made in the very first chapter, when he met Mohiam. Black hair. Green eyes and oval face (like his mom), long, narrow nose. Small built for his age.
@@LiamborninDC The filmmaker has creative liberties. When Paul finds out who his grandfather is, the color of his hair is not mentioned. Only his mother's.
What? The Baron and Rabban had the same type of hair. I don't remember being bald in the novel...
Buzzfeed did a list too and made everyone basically black with a crap load of freckles. The casting was top notch but my only gripe was the north vs south tribes thing (the Freman were and unified people) and Paul and Chani's relationship was much different in the book. Chani stood by Paul in every decision Paul made, she even supported Paul marrying Irulan for political gain. Zendaya was more of a pouting 10 year old child that threw tantrums all the time.
I don't know if Rabban 's hair or hair colour is mentioned in Dune, however in the Brian Herbert books, he had short red hair.
Honestly Brian Herbert’s books come off as fan fiction
Correct me if I am wrong, but there are a lot of things here that are just not true. Kynes has blonde hair. Gurney has a gigantic scar on his face. Yueh has purple lips, and his hair is held in a ring. I do like how old Thufir looks, in the books characters remark on how old and battered he looks. I also like the dark skin on Leto I.
According to Frank Herbert's story, the Harkonnens have red hair by descent, and the planetologist Pardot Kynes is a man, not a woman. In the Dune book, the Atreides house are nobles full of luxuries like the kings of England and the Harkonnens are ruthless beings and enjoy killing, the latest Dune movie is well run but has many flaws
Kynes is also, ummm White.
I think that Pauls father definitly look better with a stronger beard
What the heck! dr wellington look like john wick ? The look is uncanny.
Good. I just finished reading the book. I plan to rewatch Part One before seeing Part Two and then start to read Dune: Messiah and Children of Dune.
That's great! I love this book series, and I do recommend you read the entire saga, even the prequels and sequels, that were written by the son of the author. Many people don't like them, but I personally do, and they were written based on material the author left before dying.
Beware, there is a HUGE difference between books by Frank and Brian (his son). I read the 3 prequels by Brian, and to the date, it was the worst experience I had with sci-fi books. If I could, I'd ask for a refund. I was even afraid to go to the Dune book itself because of that experience. Gladly, Frank is a real sci-fi author and great writer overall.
@@SamuelHenriqueGermano I seem to have a little interest in Dune. So I feel like just reading the first three books which they call “The Great Dune Trilogy” is good enough for me. I don’t usually read very many books. I appreciate your recommendation though.
I'm totally OK with how DV and David Lynch reinterpreted some of the characters' appearances.
The real shame lies in the SyFy Original miniseries. The only good casting choice in the entire production was Ian McNeice as the Baron. That's it and that's all. And those stupid hats.
Forçaram demais na Chani, em? No livro é dito explicitamente que ela tem os cabelos claros e a pele bem clara, que sua forma se assemelha a de um anjo, com cabelos curtos, na altura pouco acima dos ombros.
Thank you
Liet Kynes was a white skin man?! xD
BRUH! They could at least leave him as a guy. AT LEAST.
Why won't fascist DEI make their own NEW stories with original diverse characters instead of 'changing' everything what was already written and known?
They are soooo fantasy accurate!! Love it!
Gostei da escolha do elenco.
Piter looks like a dishonored character
Lowkey accurate tbh, except Liet's token actor.
Chani was nothing like her book counterpart
AI seems to have a preference for elongated faces in most cases.
In the Dune universe this video would be banned after the Butlerian revolt.
"Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of the human mind ".
AI is a crime against humanity 😂
Thufir hawat give me this uncle iroh vibe
These are pretty much all wildly inaccurate to the book descriptions.
Zendia or whatever her name is spelled is easily the worst actor
She’s worse than Kristin Stewart ever was. Pouty and off putting at all times.
Wait, the AI didn’t catch Gurney’s grapevine scar on his cheek!?
Gaius Helen Mohiam well dennis depiction looks better more mysterious
Bonjour .quel magnifique travail. Quelle déception que cette dernière adaptation cinéma de dune. Tout est fade et il n y as aucune originalité. Encore une fois votre travail est superbes .cordialement pg
beautufil, but not accurate
Стиль камбалы😁
к сожалению на нейросеть влияют, кадры , изображения и иллюстрации из фильмов о Дюне распространенные в интернете , так что генерируемые картины искажены ранним представлением
The casting they ended with was good, but some of my dream casting would be:
Leto: Viggo Mortenson
Thufir: Jim Carter
Gurney: Will Patton
Duncan: Aidan Turner
Emperor: Charles Dance
Why are all the women redheads? I don't get it
Chani and Jessica were redheads. Read the book
@@richlisola1 Yes, I got that. Just wonder why they are both redheads, since they come from different places and families and have different backgrounds
@@arlequinacontostavlos2100 Well, let’s see. The Known Universe is a big place, expect redheads to exist in many places.
And contrary to some beliefs. Not all redheads are related.
@@richlisola1 Really? Wow... Regardless, it's still weird that two main charactets not related whatsoever are redheads, since in books, many characters are very different from each other (when not realated), so people when reading can really imagine them apart
Jajaja nooo, a Gurney le hacen falta como 500 cicatrices más, Jessica no tenía el rostro TAAN enjuto y afilado, de hecho señalan que su rostro tenía un curvatura sensual que conservó incluso siendo una mujer madura y que heredara de su padre..., ahí les falló bastante. Paul se ve desproporcionadoxd
Woke hollywood.
Good
Honestly the casting was amazing. Liet got the diversity treatment but the character was still intact i feel.
Liet Kynes was like Lawrence of Arabia, if PT Lawrence were part Arab. He was a man and Chani’s father-What part of that was gotten right?
Bull shi! Liet Kynes from book was a blonde!
heavy black washing and diversity quotas in this movie lol
I like to call it mud smearing-Nothing got washed, none of this was clean.