They have so much genuineness in their voice. Even though they were nervous, they sang so beautifully. I always say this but I am truly proud that I stan them❤
TXT's live vocals have always been beautiful, and now it's almost 4 years later and their vocal quality and tone has improved even more. Maybe some people still don't like them, but that's ok because TXT are still going to shine and fans and the general public who acknowledge them are the ones who really matter. Keep shining TXT
@@felixthegreat7998 Their Japanese EPs are great too! I'd definitely recommend The Dream Chapter Magic or The Chaos Chapter Freeze or repackage Fight or Escape if you're thinking of starting a K album collection. Though I love all their releases
I LOVE HYUKA AND TAEHYUN'S VOICEEEEE THEY ARE SO ANGELIC 😍😍😍 AND THEIR HARMONY THEY NAILED IT! THE MOMENT IT STRUCK IN MY EARS I FEEL IM IN HEAVEN GO TXTTTT
Sometimes during their live performances haters keep on saying that they are lip syncing but in fact these boys are just singing in perfect harmony hitting those notes.
*To new MOAs in the future who are watching it now.* This was a long time ago and they have been working so hard. So much things has happened since then and they have been through a lot too. If you are new i can guarantee you that its worth it to stan them. They are so kind, helpful, loving, caring, talented, amazing and so much more. They can make me happy no matter what, they are my inspiration and they help me through everything. They have taught me so much things. They have taught me to be positive, never give up, how to be happy and so much more things. Im so sorry im terrible at expressing my feelings. But please never leave them because they deserve everything.
Every time I listen to this performance I want to cry. How far you all have come and it's only been 2.5 years! Can't wait to continue this journey with you!
진짜 다 좋은데 이렇게 담담한 노래에 범규 목소리랑 수빈이 목소리가 위로해주는 것 같아 진짜 좋은거같아요...ㅠㅠ
막내즈가 메인 파트고 연준이도 음색이 좋아서 잘 모를 수 있는데 범규 수빈 목소리 진짜 좋아요,,, 이 노래에선 잘 나온듯 ㅜ
For those who says TXT can't sing live, y'all now can choke. 🤧
Agree 😂 I'm so sick on haters keep calling them untalented who can't singing, slap them hard with this video.
For those who say ANYTHING about what TXT "can't do" can choke. TXT pure talent.
PREACH
Ik that they can sing but the music have auto tune
@@eggmcmuffin7417 no
They sound exactly like the studio version these boys are super talented
Hiiii ,I LOVE ur videoss
Ава супер 😂😊
omg luv ur vids
They sound better than then the studio version
Wow I love your vids. Especially WAENG
음색 다들 오지는데 수빈이 음색 저세상 음색이다 진짜 세상에
저게 근데 진짜 레알 아무것도 없는
라이브라는 게 레전드......
지금까지도 돌려보러 오게 되는 노래.....
그니까요 음색이 와아.... 진짜 미쳤죠.............
ㅇㅈ
세상에
라이브라는게 미쳤다고요 툽부심 차오른당ㅎㅎ
와 진짜 음원이랑 다른게 뭐야..음원 재생이랑 같이 부르는것도 아니고 피아노를 바탕으로 부르는데 음원이랑 똑같아 진짜 미쳤다..데뷔 한지 한 10년은 된것 같은 실력..
태현이 음색 미쳤어....진짜 반했어ㅠㅠ
YES, THEY'RE FREAKING SINGING LIVE AND I'M JUST GONNA SIT HERE EATING WATERMELON
do you know wAtErmELoN? .... SAME!!!! AHHH
@@anacabell8112 lmao hahaha😂
🍉
hahahah oh boi, your dp is so cute! Beomgyu 😂😂😂
YOU WERE THERE!? LUCKYYYY I WAS BUSY AT THE OTHER SIDE OF THE WORLD DON'T MIND ME
YEONJUN WAS SOOOO PROUD OF THE MEMBERS, YOI CAN SEE OT IN THE VIDEO💜💜💜
I agree
라이브 미친거 아님 진심?
최연준 특유의 음색 개사랑해..❤❤
Rookie of the year🙌
Yeeeeeessss
Yeaahh global shookies
generation*
GLOBAL SHOOKIE!!
Yes they did
Nap of a star really hits a spot in my heart
Same
나도 라이브로 듣고 싶어
Keep 태현ing Keep on grooming 저도 제발
Finally a video where we dont need subs that much 😂
angelic 12h
Lol
They have so much genuineness in their voice. Even though they were nervous, they sang so beautifully. I always say this but I am truly proud that I stan them❤
I can hear soobin's voice, he was like so nervous😆
He's the shyest baby of them all 🥺
애들 음색 미쳤고 너무 이쁘다 진차ㅠㅠㅠ
TAEHYUN IS SOOOO GOOD IN BEING A 2ND VOICE, SO IT WAS HIM ALL ALONG 🔥🔥🔥
부럽다 야발 나도 저기 있었으면 죽엇다 이미 사랑해 휴닝카이...
와 범규 음색이 와.......
이 영상에서 애기들이 부르는 노래를 들으니깐 머리속으로 힘들게 연습하는 모습이 상상된다 우리 투바투 사랑해❤️ 내일도 함께하자💖💖
the harmonization at 1:46 is so pretty i could cry
txt can sing live , they are from big hit where artists there are full of talents.
휴닝아 눈물 나온다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠ 목소리
음색 실화냐 가슴이 웅장해진다
수빈 ටㅏ 음색 미친다...
모아들이 큰 무댜 꼭 올려줄게 그때까지 아무일 없이 무대 열심히 하고 화이팅 !!
뭐야 연준이는 영어도 잘하네 ...
Taehyun clear voice!😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍Really love it!
Yeonjun, the rapper of the group did that high note 😊
MeKey JD he’s not the rapper. There’s no fixed positions lol
@@bruh-ok5ks well he looks like the main rapper as he usually raps for the group, their positions are actually obvious💀
@@gyw9185 yea but there are instances that he sings too, and sometimes the "vocalists" rap to, esp in cover songs
they have no fixed positions bc theyre all rounders
gy w they all rap, dance, and sing so he is a rapper, but there is no main anything
연준아.. 영어바름 치인다애기야ㅠㅠ 노래도 잘하고 영어도 잘하고 춤도 잘추고 랩도 잘하고 잘생기고 귀엽고 벌레도 안무서워하고 다리도길고 어깨도 예쁘게 넓고 못하는게뭐야?
이쁘다ㅜㅜㅜㅜ이상황이 너무 이뻐ㅜㅜ
TXT's live vocals have always been beautiful, and now it's almost 4 years later and their vocal quality and tone has improved even more. Maybe some people still don't like them, but that's ok because TXT are still going to shine and fans and the general public who acknowledge them are the ones who really matter. Keep shining TXT
I still don’t have any of there albums sadly but I do have one of there Japan eps
@@felixthegreat7998 Their Japanese EPs are great too!
I'd definitely recommend The Dream Chapter Magic or The Chaos Chapter Freeze or repackage Fight or Escape if you're thinking of starting a K album collection. Though I love all their releases
수빈이 목소리 내귀를녹이네 녹여...
딱히 누가 돋보이게 잘하는 것도 아니고 그냥 팀 자체가 다 잘해서 튀는 목소리 하나 없이 좋은 노래가 만들어지는 듯..짱바투 합시다 여러분🌝🌚
Their voice is so beautiful I'm crying such an angelic voice..😭😭😭💛 #4monthswithTXT 🎉
TAEHYUNs vocal....omg so good..💖
와 진짜 미쳤다... 다시 들어도 라이브인게 믿기지 않는다.. 사랑해 얘들아...❤️
rewatching this made me so emotional, I've been with them since 2019 and now they really have come so far, so proud of them^^
최수빈 최연준 최범규 강태현 후닝카이 사랑해
'후'가아니라'휴'입니당
@@moaaa7777 go, girl!
am i the only one who appreciates soobin’s voice 🥺
JT Hyunjin I loooove his voice too!!!!🥰🥰🥰🥰
Soobin is my bias!!💯
After 1 yr n a half they r beast now
Imagine singing on d spot on streets with a unknown pianist
The pianist played so well! TXT has beautiful vocals!! My heart feels so full listening to them! 💙💛
Taehyun's voice makes me happy 😍
nap of a star just became even more emotional than it already was
so truuueee 😭😭😭 I always cry when I hear this song 😭
HUENINGKAI'S VOICE IS SO BEAUTIFUL
BigHit with 12 talented boys😭😭😭
I love TXT (BTS too,of course)
11???
Isn't 12? 😂
I forget one member: Park Jimin😁😂
@@Валерия-ю6л2ь oh well I think it's just weird to call him one of the boys..😂
Rochelle Gardiola he's also from bighit tho and if it's bc of age it's not like bts aren't men already too...
OMG. Our baby TXT voice so sweet. They basically Vocal Kings. Their voice complete with each other. So beautiful 😍
I LOVE HYUKA AND TAEHYUN'S VOICEEEEE THEY ARE SO ANGELIC 😍😍😍 AND THEIR HARMONY THEY NAILED IT! THE MOMENT IT STRUCK IN MY EARS I FEEL IM IN HEAVEN GO TXTTTT
인이어도 없이 엠알만 틀어놓고 불렀는데 진짜 라이브 잘한다..
음색 미쳤다 다들
this performance makes me cry 😭 they were so little
Fr tho I can’t they we’re just kids here
범규 목소리 💕
아니 지금보니까 못보겠다 진짜… 이 천사아기들 어쩌면 좋아 진짜 눈물 나올듯 지금도 잘하고 있어 사랑해
I want a live version like this released as a single. Omg, their live vocals sound better than the album version!
TXT IS ROOKIE OF THE YEAR🙏😊🌝💜
애들 너무 어리다..풋풋해서 더 예쁘다 뭔가 아련하고ㅠ
Beomgyu's voice makes me want to cry at the beginning! This is such a great showcase of their vocals.
Their voices are so awesome...
I wanna see them in person...
💜💜💜💜💜
와 라이브 지린다 우와우와우와우와
아니 애들 어떻게 저렇게 잘 불러 ? 미쳤다 진짜 왁
저거 데뷔 초 아니였어..? 어쩜 데뷔 초도 저렇게 노래를 잘 하냐.. 애들아 사랑해 음색 진짜 오진다 지금 너희밖에 안 보여❤
Wow I love txt so much, the Huening Kai's voice is sooo soooo beautiful, i love it
Sometimes during their live performances haters keep on saying that they are lip syncing but in fact these boys are just singing in perfect harmony hitting those notes.
I really love Soobin voice 😭 I feel his emotions.
they have such unique voices I'm so happy I saw them in Dallas 😭💖
Agustin Garcia luckyyy :(( im from Houston but my parents never let me go
와 범규 음색 미쳤나봐 세상에 대박이야 진짜
Wow, that vocals! That live!
Soobin voice is no joke I swear
세상에마상에 라이브라는 게 놀랍다 음색 미쳤네
피아노만 깔았는데 말이 돼냐 미쳣나봐 …
진짜 그냥 듣기만 해도 어느새 눈물 흘리고 있는 나를 봄...
노래도 잘해 투바투
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
De verdad que es IMPRESIONANTE EL TALENTO de los chicos. Me dejan sin palabras Y ESTO ERA EN SU ERA DEBUT. MUCHO TALENTO, DEMASIADO TALENTO
I love soobin's voice ❤❤❤
Soobiniee ikrrrr
*To new MOAs in the future who are watching it now.*
This was a long time ago and they have been working so hard. So much things has happened since then and they have been through a lot too.
If you are new i can guarantee you that its worth it to stan them. They are so kind, helpful, loving, caring, talented, amazing and so much more. They can make me happy no matter what, they are my inspiration and they help me through everything. They have taught me so much things. They have taught me to be positive, never give up, how to be happy and so much more things. Im so sorry im terrible at expressing my feelings. But please never leave them because they deserve everything.
휴닝이 음색 진짜 넘 이뻐
미쳤죠? 네 미쳤죠
Their voice is so beautiful just like their faces❤️💜😍
Taehyun has the best vocals omg
전원 다 실력이 너무 좋아서 이렇게 라이브도 가능하구나 너무 멋있다
아가들 진짜 많이 컸잖아ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
?나만 노래깔려있는 줄 알았나? 댓글보고 첨아랏어요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄹㅇ 엄청난실력에 입이 땅으로 고꾸라지겠다
They’re great kids, they’ll be on a different level if they kept taking care of each other. Keep up the hard work, we love you!
Their voice is really beautifull. Yeonjun's vocal 😍😍❤
뭐지 왜 눈물나냐
얘들아 사랑해
Taehyunn angelic voice
라이브...... 진짜 미친 거 아니냐고 화음 뭐야
아줘나눈물난다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 힘들게 잘달려왔구나..
Their voices are so beautiful💕 Haters can choke😉
Choi Beomgyu so handsome 😍
Respect to all the peoples here,they even wave their hands for them,they are so pure😊😊😊
수빈아 잊지 못해 또 왔다 내 댓이 베댓이 되어있는데 그만큼 너 음색이 좋다는 거니까 늘 자신감 가지고 살아갔으면 좋겠다 물론 태현이, 휴닝이, 연준이, 범규도
Soobin’s voice😭
Their voices are so pure I can’t-
Every time I listen to this performance I want to cry. How far you all have come and it's only been 2.5 years! Can't wait to continue this journey with you!
데뷔초때는 라이브 힘들텐데... 이정도면 ㄹㅇ 잘하는거다....
All of them really can sing, those boy are very talented
Why are those spectators look like a proud Moms and Dads ??? 😭😭
I really like you as an idol and role model