Why are metals so stretchy? (2^13 sub special)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 май 2024
- It's play button time, and today it's made from copper foil - a surprisingly stretchable material. You wouldn't think that crystalline materials like metals could deform without destroying the atomic pattern that gives them their strength and electronic properties, but with the help of a crystal defect called a dislocation, it's super easy. Dislocations are agents of plastic deformation, traveling through crystals and enabling malleability and ductility in soft metals like copper, making them great raw materials! I hope you enjoy this dive into the materials science of plastic strain, and if this is your first video here, be sure to subscribe for more!
Thanks to all my OG subscribers, and welcome to the new ones! And a big thanks to Steve Mould for sending some of his awesome fans my way. / steventhebrave
Corrections and Clarifications:
- "Plastic deformation" is a term that means a permanent change in shape, even in metals, we call it plastic.
- There are also grain boundary considerations in polycrystalline materials that I don't address at all - mostly it shows up in tension, because bubble rafts aren't ACTUALLY very ductile.
- More to add when I get convinced I'm wrong!
Check out the other social media for updates and ramblings:
/ alphaphoenixchannel
/ alpha__phoenix
#Materials #Physics #Crystals
The original bubble model video from 1952 narrated by Bragg himself - a real hidden gem of matsci history.
• Experiments with the B...
GIFs:
short: gfycat.com/contentinsignifica...
long: gfycat.com/compassionatewavyb...
Music in this video:
I Dunno by grapes is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
ccmixter.org/files/grapes/16626
The UNKILLABLE Snake AI (Entire 30x30 game)
Hestu tune from Nintendo
Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 
Наука
Bro. When you pulled out the bubbles it all made sense. That was nutsss
Here’s your first reply, i guess.
fr, i was mind blown.
This demo is so cool. Awesome video.
Thanks Grady! This one was a lot of fun. I wasn't lying when I said it was one of my favorite matsci demos - I'm flabbergasted it isn't in every 101 class.
Hmm funny seeing you here
A wild engineer appears!
Noice
@@AlphaPhoenixChannel It was in mine! Actually it was before my Materials 101, it was in Engineering 102, which every engineering student goes through before specialising further. I love the demo, it's so versatile and a surprisingly accurate analogue! We used different sized bubbles to simulate interstitial and substitutional impurities (kind of, interstitial doesn't work as much in 2d). We outlined grain boundaries, and observed dislocations not passing grain boundaries. All in all, a fun lab class.
Steve Mould has a video doing a similar thing with ball bearings getting vibrated and simulating the annealing process.
Sir, I am a commercial electrician. I bend aluminum tubing for a living. I don't think the information you've given me will benefit me at all in my career but you can be damn sure I'm going to think of this lesson everyday at work. And I will be telling my apprentices about dislocation to try and seem cool
Steve Mould brought me here. Did not disappoint. Highly recommend. Watched all your videos~
+1
Me to ✌️ great channel
Same!
Thanks! I'm so excited to get to share fun projects with more people!
Same here, from Australia. Good luck with the Nobel prize in the next year :)
The carpet example was brilliant. Your channel is awesome.
Glad it made it clear - thanks for the comment!
And it all ripples into effect with the object, or thing, that is causing that specific ripple. I.e., volume of the object, force applied, etc.
I'm came from Steve Mould's channel, and i just want to say that this is one of those few channels on RUclips where the host knows enough about a subject to talk about in in depth, but in a very easy-to-understand way! Please keep up the good work!
Thanks! That’s what I strive for - hopefully it’s informative and fun!
i've seen this demonstration with little metal beads, but never with bubbles. it's pretty amazing how you set it up to make all the bubbles the same size
Yeah the metal beads are awesome for showing how repulsion between atoms causes spontaneous ordering (crystallization) but they aren't sticky enough to easily get motion behavior like dislocations gliding effortlessly through. I wasn't lying when I said my jaw hit the floor when I first saw Bragg's lecture video using bubbles. It's so ludicrously cool.
Also don't look too close at some of the shots if you think all of my bubbles were successfully the exact same size lol.......... It's actually pretty fun to see what crystal defects you get when you do have different sizes - you can get weird sized bubbles stuck to dislocations (or dislocations stuck to weird sized bubbles) because they relieve some of the strain associated with having an extra half-plane of atoms wedged in the crystal.
@@AlphaPhoenixChannel It's worthy of a second channel content of exactly how you did it.
AlphaPhoenix
that's really interesting, and probably why many metals are doped or alloyed to get a better material. just a few % carbon and you have steel instead of iron.
Oh absolutely! You get all your dislocations pinned to impurities, and suddenly the material acts a LOT harder.
"7:55 wants to know your location"
I've just graduated from a materials science degree and I've got to say you managed to explain dislocations better than any of my lecturers ever did, good job
I've been wondering for years... why is it that everything we learn in school is always so badly explained compared what you can find on youtube?
There are SOOO MANY topics I've learned on RUclips in 20-100 minutes VS MONTHS in school. what is going on?
@@zovisapphire tower of babyl.. book of enoch/fallen template. As God spread us out with the flood to punish a tower meant to get to the heavens we don't know what Is going on in the kitchen/is in the next cubicle... we specialize..
It's sort of like what God did but more of an embracing and hijacking what he did.. to remake and own it. No self sustain, no Renaissance men, no geniuses, no polymaths.... everyone must focus on a tree so they don't see the forest...
Power and abdication of personal sovereignty. Point at a manufactured target to point at with a bought foam finger to point with. Thatsbthe power. Now go point. You get power go point.. find a witch to burn
Track Indo-European languages theology philosophy religion and semiotics...
What's the neurology and fractal nature of pareto distribution and matthew principal with a side of imposter peter dunning kruger syndrome
“Because hexagon, is the bestagon!”
@Hand Grabbing Fruits it has already been declared, but you may declare it again.
But only in 2d or where third dimension doesent matter. Because perfect hexagons cant form non flat object
@@O5MO take a bunch of pentagons, give a few of them an extra side. Now you have 3D shapes.
Ahh, fellow members of the order
Well my dad is a gon
For comparison, PewDiePie is now in the 2^26 button. This chanel is highly underrated, I've been here since the 2^10 button and I feel proud of it like a dad (even if I did nothing). Keep it coming!
Thanks so much! Glad you like the channel. Long-time supporters give me the motivation to make more videos - it isn’t nothing!
This channel reminds me of Applied Science, where videos aren't frequent but they're very good. Oh and holy crap the bubble model for crystal structures is brilliant
I think they could do a really interesting collaboration project.
Ben from Applied Science mentioned this channel on his Twitter a few days ago. It's how I found it, and I'm fascinated!
Yep, I'ḿ here because of Steve... but man, how glad I am he mentioned your channel.
This video has to be on my top 5 all time favorite YT videos!
Keep up the great work.
Wow thanks!
When Steve Mould shouted you out, and after watching one of your videos, I was certain that I was watching a channel that already must have had millions of subscribers, but when I saw your sub count I was literally shocked! I do not know how you have not hit it big yet, but heres to you doing so!
8 years of engineering school. Never has this ever been explained so well. Excellent job.
I wonder if the atoms zipping around is partially the reason for why metal gets hot when bent
Friction in itself yes
the atoms aren't zipping around, the dislocations between the atoms are
@@MalcolmCooks yes but the atoms are similarly moving to fill the gaps left by dislocations, which is why the dislocation itself moves
@@MalcolmCooks that's like saying the bottle isn't holding the water, the empty space is.
@@Lunibruniful given that atoms are mostly empty space, that's actually true, too.
I'm one of the steve mould people, ive watched a ton of your videos now and you've quickly become one of my fav channels. Such amazingly interesting stuff demonstrated so well
Welcome! thanks for that endorsement! I don't put out a LOT of videos, and I think that hurts me on youtube, but it means I only publish stuff I really find interesting. These dislocations here are a topic very near and dear to my heart. Dislocations are everywhere, but they really suck in electronic devices...
@@AlphaPhoenixChannel Quality over quantity matters with the type of subject matter you cover. Keep doing you, your subscribers subbed for a reason.
On a side note, I'm also here from Steve's video.
What I am loving in particular about the bubble demo versus the the steel ball demo, is that the bubbles have some give (like atomic bonds) so I feel that the resulting effect is more analogous to a crystal structure. Now if only we could think of a way to extend this model to build intuition about heat treatment of carbon steel...
Very intresting because your complaint was the same as what Bragg noted in his original experiment (Bragg Raft Bubble is a good search term) - he also wanted to know hat happened when heat was applied.
Came from the Steve Mould video and after watching one video I immediately watched every single other video on your channel. Literally all of them! Amazing content, you're a great educator and clearly one of the RUclips greats in your field. So glad I found the channel 👍👍
somehow, in the 2 or 3 years i've been watching your videos, i missed this one. those bubbles, as you put them through "tension" and "compression"...that was incredible. talk about a picture being worth a thousand words. something can maintain overall rigidity while experiencing deformation -- we know that's true, but seeing it happen, man just those concepts, rigid as they may be in our heads, are malleable too. thank you for this.
RUclips homepage actually brought me to your channel and I’ve watched everything you have now. You have a fantastic talent of explaining extremely complicated subjects so simply and eloquently. Keep on producing!
Underrated channel. Interesting science bits from someone who actually knows what he is talking about. Beware of the fakes!
I only left the 2^13 comment two days ago... and he delivers! Can't wait to see this channel more.
I took a couple hour nap this afternoon before posting... producing a 14 minute video in 3 days isn't something I'd recommend, but it WAS a lot of fun!
@@AlphaPhoenixChannel I came back to this video once I had finished my engineering course. I wish I had remembered it earlier, the subject on metal structure and half-planes would have been so much easier!
Wonderful demonstration of plastic deformation. Thanks Steve mould for bringing me here😍
As always, one of the best presentations, topics and presenters on RUclips.
I cannot express how much I appreciate you explaining in a few minutes what so many years in an educational system (outdated by decades and centuries) was unable to teach to this extent.
Please keep up the wonderful work
I’m studying to be an architect and this has bothered me for YEARS. Thank you!
I came via Steve mould. Thanks to Steve for directing me to you and thanks to you for making very interesting viddies!
That demo is AMAZING!!! I couldn’t believe it worked so well I thought their would be a bunch of popping when moving them around, and the contrast was excellent every detail was there!
That's exactly how the Statue of Liberty's exterior was created. "Chasing and Repoussé." The "chasing" is the carving and chiseling of details on the front and "repousse" is the hammering 🔨 of the basic form from the back. We usually use a bowl of pitch wax to hold the peice of metal... but any surface with give could work. That bubble demonstration is mind blowing! It literally behaves exactly 💯 like atoms under magnification 🤯 Wow 👏 love your enthusiasm. I totally get it. 👍
Great video and explanation. As a lay person, you explain complicated things very intuitively, and your passion just shines through. Love it.
I love when content creators help each other out. I’m sure I would have found you eventually but glad Steve mentioned you so I could start watching your videos sooner.
I’ve been binging all your videos, you use the best examples I’ve seen across all of RUclips! It’s so intuitive, absolutely love the stuff you’ve made. Seeing your process (including the ‘failures’) teaches so much
Steve fella here, just wanted to thank you for the videos. They are all very entertaining and informative. Looking forward to the water crystal!
Holy crap. This is literally the best physics material science video I have ever seen! Thank you!
Your passion for science really shows in your videos
Thumbs up from me!
Good luck as i see a bright future !
im a senior manufacturing engineering student. Did not know of your channel but after getting far enough to see that you are making a 2^13 subscriber play button im subbed haha. Love this demonstration and MAN would it have saved me some grief in material science class. Keep being cool!
This is my first post on youtube in almost 10 years. Just found your channel. I'm enthralled by your energy and positive vibe, in which you really explain the topics of your videos methologically and entertaining. Please keep up the good work, you made my day.
New subscriber here! My jaw dropped too the whole time watching those dislocations ripple through the bubbles. I could watch that all day! >>> Suggestion for the next play button: Sintered powdered metal!... Because it sounds really cool.
This is an awesome demonstration! Great video :^D
On of my absolute favorites, and to explain dislocations, a topic very near and dear to my heart because of my lab work! Such fun!
You are great, new favorite science communicator. Only thing holding your channel back is video quality, all of your cameras (or something in your editing chain) is making your content look like it's from like 2015.
Hey Brian, new fan here😁.....!
I came here from Steve's video.
You're amazing....♥️
Oh hell yes I am making one of those bubble bath things. My niece is gonna freak out when she sees the ripples.
Please make a follow up video on how this relates to elastic deformation, plastic deformation and metal fatigue. Different things must be going on with the crystal structure in those 3 instances ...
Godspeed my dude, you make some great content and the enthusiasm and energy you show through these videos is amazing. Thank you so much!
Have a happy 2^13! GREAT video, thanks!
Feel like your channel is going to be huge. Got in at the 8.5k floor, on and up boyo!
Great job explaining this demo, and dislocations in general!
Tiny nitpick because you seem to enjoy corrections: I believe the 2D bubble lattice would just be "hexagonal" since the hexagonal lattice is necessarily close-packed in 2 dimensions.
Why is it necessarly close packed
Oh my god, that bubble raft demo is so beautiful and just ... perfect. Thank you so much for presenting this! It's helped explain so well, the rest of the video is really great too! Gratz on the subscribers, I'm subbing right now too!
Yours is my newest favorite channel; the sky is the limit as you branch out into related topics. Fascinating, thank you!
Scientists: metal shouldn't bend
*Me who just bent my spoon while eating*
Uri Geller wants to know your location.
"last time we used an electron microscope to build a play button out of individual atoms, so let's poke at some foil now" :D
And visualize the atoms with bubbles.
Tbh I am glad the Steve shouted you out. I wouldnt have discovered this passionate dude that provides great content, keep on doing great!
My 9 & 6 year old sat through this entire video.
Just another reason to love your content. Not sure how I haven't come across this one before though.
Achievement unlocked: watched the video about 2^13 subs when the video had 2^8 views
PoWeRsOfTwO!!!!! yeah I spend too much time with computer numbers...
hexagons.. are the bestagons
One of the best videos on youtube. I noticed this kind of deformation when bending soft aluminium tubes as a kid- suuper trippy to look at up close.
that carpet analogy with ripples was one of the best teaching moments i've ever seen
Most underrated channel I ever came across,
What makes this demonstration even better than steel balls is the adhesive behaviour between the bubbles.
The dynamic deformation was the most accurate one I have ever seen in a model! Great video
You're definitely going places dude, your titles and thumbnails are interesting and enticing, and the actual video manages to keep that enticement throughout. Love the stuff!
After seeing shoutout from Steve Mould I immediately became hooked on your postings
Great job, thank you
That bubble experiment is such a good illustrative example. Thank you for sharing that with us!
Any time Gianni!
First time I have ever commented about a video in my life, but I love learning and the way you broke it down with comparisons, visuals,and reasoning was strength up.. gangsta.
This, is the best video on RUclips. It made so much sense and was so satisfying to watch those ripples.
I absolutely love this demo and it’s one of the best and one of the easiest to understand that I’ve ever watched.
I've found a new favorite science channel. Very easy to follow and comprehend if you have the basic ideas down and it's fun to watch :)
Your channel is great! I extend my motivation to you to keep making awesome videos! I joined because of Steve's shoutout and it was a great find :)
I studied material science as an undergrad, and this video explains the concept of dislocations better than anything else ive ever encountered. I cant believe i havent seen this bubble raft demonstration before. Simply spectacular
Glad you like it! I also can't believe this isn't in every single materials 101 class
I'm a big fan of Steve Mould too! I'm soooo happy YT suggested your channel to me!! I LOVE YOUR CHAN!!!
Oh wait did you just subscribe in the last week and not come direct from Steve Mould? That would be some kinda big hint “the algorithm” was helping out!
Thanks for the comment - glad you’re here!
That's so cool! You can literally see the hole in the material propagate through, it makes so much more sense now.
Nice video man.
this is just easily one of the best science videos on the internet period.
The compression and tension demo with the bubbles is so cool! I feel enlightened. Thank you!
This guy is so cool. I would normally be bored with stuff like this but he speaks about it with what I'm interpreting as a lot of passion, it's a super interesting watch.
This blew my mind. Thank you for making such high-quality content freely available on the internet for anyone to enjoy.
That bubble demo is an amazing tool for getting your head around the idea. Thanks for bringing it to everyone's attention.
I'm here via the algorithm.
Love your energy and enthusiasm when discussing these concepts! Great use of visual examples.
Gosh, that visual representation using the bubbles is brilliant. Thank you so much for sharing this!
Not directly from Steve Mould, just coincidentally ended up here at the same time it seems lol. Loving the videos! Suggestion for 2^14-some sort of lithography technique? Maybe it's vaguely redundant with 2^12, but it'd also be cool to see AFM images of the result.
Wow. They need to show this video before the dislocation lecture in engineering material science. Such a huge improvement to my intuition of this.
That carpet demonstration was really great. I was having a hard time imagining what you meant by ripple until then.
2:00 Takes me back to my junior high school days (early 1960s) when I embossed the heads of two Irish Setters in copper. We filed the back with wax, tacked them to very nice small pieces of wood using copper tacks, and framed them.
This channel deserves far more subs. Really cool demo, and well-explained.
your channel is amazing man.. keep it up..u tend to explain things dif than other and that makes it amazing!!
8:40 The small gaps shooting along through the bubble raft has to be the coolest part of the entire demonstration. They just zip along. I wonder if their speeds can be predicted from physical principles.
This is fantastic!
I work as a blacksmith in a museum, I do this all day every day! It always amazes me when people ask very basic questions and the answers are very complicated or very recently understood science, like “why does the metal glow when it’s hot?” Or “how does the chimney draw air so well?” OR “how does the metal change shape?”. I’ve yet to find a good succinct explanation for solid state welding, that one’s tough.
I saw this video two years ago, but now after making one year of material engineering I'm really impressed by the simulation and I'm sending the video to my teacher
That really is a great demo. Seeing all the dislocations zip through the raft is really neat. It's funny how great demos can make such an impression. One I loved from school was using a tilted sandbox to model river erosion. Seeing the right demo (or better getting to play with it yourself) can really make the concepts make so much sense.
This is literally the best explanation of dislocation on metal I have ever seen. Really capture what every textbook on material trying to convey
As a educator myself, I really loved the practical demonstrations along with crisp explanation.
first time seeing this demo and it looks amazing the visual effect is mind blowing very nice done!!
You asked for suggestions for your next button. I read about a way to etch patterns that reflect wavelengths of light. This was used to “paint” an image instead of using dyes. 🙂
welcome to the new subs, perhaps now that you've brought up crystal structure; you could grow a play button shaped crystal for the next one
I’m surprised that I don’t see stuff this good on RUclips let alone a whole channel that makes cool demos like this one. Keep up the cool content!!!
the bubble hexagon plain looks so dope, physics is like a wizardry, so many complex stuff, all made out of particles that obey very simple rule set
I really like how you show that science isn't always perfect, actually that it can be annoying and a bit messy some times!
Great work!
randomly came up on my recommended
I think I just found the best and most underrated science RUclipsr, this was so interesting to watch!
Amazing video! What a fantastic demonstration of the second week of Metallurgy 201! So glad I found your channel!
I came here from the gerrymandering video, which I liked and commented a request for you to gerrymander Texas, then RUclips impressed me with your impressions video, which I also liked and commented on, and then RUclips sent me here. Now I'm addicted to your channel and you have a new subscriber
I've never seen such a good demonstration of this! Awesome, thanks a lot!
I randomly came across your video on detecting leaks in vacuum chambers and liked the video. So I decided to subscribe. This is the second video of yours I've watched, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The bubble raft demo was, IMO, top notch. Keep up the good work.
The bubble demonstration is beautiful, how I went through so much school around engineering and machines and never heard of this particular demonstration is beyond me.