Just to be super clear; I am NOT concerned with the fact that Blackpink is getting criticism because they shouldn't be immune to it. What I have a problem with is the nature of the criticism I've been seeing online and the selective double standard the group faces as well as the general frustration aimed at the members themselves. If Blackpink as a group doesn't offer enough in your opinion, you have every right to not support or follow the group.
@@xxheart_breakerxx8732 blackpink and YG didnt promote themselves "the biggest gg" actually YG promote BP saying they will be the next 2n1. the media, and the public did that, bc their popularity, recods, and fanbase Teddy says in their documemtary that they never though they will be that BIG INTERNATIONALLY, sorry for my english
Blackpink is quite inconsistent, but they are great performing for big crowds, it really brings out their full capabilities at the time. People can and should criticize them, but their mistakes are many times more noticed than their overall quality.
It so frustrating how people dont know the difference between having backtrack and lip-sync or confuse skipping line for lip-sync. They just attack artist they dont like. I was watching Rihana's recent performance and I was disappointed at how some people were calling it lip-sync because she skipped parts.
Lip sync = mic off 100% The fact that they sing along with the back tack is because when they motivate or connect with people. The song will be able to continue to run and not be missed. I couldn't understand when I heard them sing. There were 2 vocal lines. Why did people still dare to say lip sync?
It's so sad that all The members would make an amazing performance for a two hours stage and the only thing that goes viral is a 5 seconds clip of jennie standing in the opposite direction of the other members or something
I recently saw them live during this tour in New Jersey and all 4 of them were amazing! Honestly, not a single complaint that I can think of. From a singer’s perspective, they were all giving 100%, sounded great and they were just so entertaining to watch. We really need to show idols grace and shouldn’t put them on an unattainable, unrealistic “god” pedestal. They’re humans like us at the end of the day.
I saw blackpink in their IN YOUR AREA tour (Barcelona) in 2019, in THE SHOW in 2021 and more recently BORN PINK world tour (Paris) in 2022. I have been stanning them since 2017 and words can't express how proud Im am of them for constantly improving, especially their vocals. In 2019 they weren't very stable but still singed live then at the show they were moe stable and confident. The biggest change was in their more recent tour. They were all very stable both at singing and rapping LIVE. People are just so used to listening pre recorded tracks on 4th gen kpop and think that their faves are singing live while somehow magically doing back flips and intense coreographies that they can't recognise what live vocals sound like.
The problem is not that they are getting criticised. The problem is that they are getting shamed for things that are actually normal. Jennie is getting called names just because she decided to perform with a bralette and a jacket. People are pointing out how she shouldn't wear such clothes and how she is negatively influencing children in the concert. First of all she is an adult and can make decisions on her own, and she knows what she is doing. Secondly the album Born Pink clearly has a explicit label and the tour being named after the album I'm 100% sure no parent who wants "good influence" on their children will bring them to such concert. And they are also getting called out names because they are twerking. LIKE C'MON! It's recognised as a dance form (?) You can't slutshame someone for this. I mean is that the best people can do? Being misogynistic and calling someone something that they aren't. The reality is hate for blackpink sells better than anything on the internet. They saw that the ticket price was high and that they made mistakes for their Seoul concert, they got on blackpink's back and started hating them for every little thing. Heck even their encore part of the concert is getting hate for not being "perfect". And yes I am not justifying their mistakes I'm just pointing out the hate they are getting disguised as criticism from people who just get on a hate train without knowing what's going on.
FR, they are acting as if their faves are amazing too. Blackpink's stage presence is better than a lot of groups. I always am amazed when seeing blackpink perform. They were inconsistent but I feel those people paid too much attention to dancing. This is a concert not a music show or dance competition.
I think the only problem with their performances is inconsistency,the chemistry between the members is fluctuating or should I say the energy levels and cohesiveness between them seem to be variating time to time and that makes them seem like they have more sp individually than as a group collectively.
What sets BP apart from other groups is their individuality. And BP is considered a group with individual fans. They weren't like a group. It's like 4 singers performing together at a concert.
I’ve heard so many bad things about this tour, but omfg this makes me so confused. It seems like they are singing live for the whole thing and it’s obvious when they aren’t singing and letting the backtrack cover a part. I’m not a huge fan but imo the fact I can tell they are obviously singing live is so much more important than perfect choreography. With Mamamoo being my favorite group because of the consistent live vocals especially from my bias Solar, this makes me love Blackpink a lot more and respect them so much more than I did before.
im tired of seeing haters criticising them when they haven't even attended their concert. I saw them live, and i have one thing to say, i had the best experience of my life. the concert was alot better than i expected
maybe it's because im a fan, but i just love their way of performing. idk i just prefer when the artist engage with the audience and hype them, something that is quite rare in kpop. yes, they could be a little more synchronized and stuff, but honestly that's not something that really matters TO ME. i wish they came to my country 😭😭😭😭
I personally don't expect music show type of synchronization on tours; I've always perceived tours as a chance for connecting with the audience and prioritizing having a good time overall. Where are you from btw? They didn't come to my country but I was thinking about seeing them in Berlin
@@samuel-ge9ut Man I really have a great pity for Brazilians because I know that a lot of South Americans are loving them so much yet the only one that confirmed is in Mexico. Hope you guys get it soon man
also something that I've been noticing is how these stage presence discussions are always about WOMEN, like I've never seen a scandal like this about men ONCE
Literally. Twice, (G)I-dle, Blackpink etc. get extreme amounts of criticism and hate on their stage presence when so many boy groups give the bare minimum or below, but get praised just because they’re attractive.
@@yeyosilver7067 Like what? At my concert, blackpink were phenomenal. Such a fun show, mics were on, they were having fun and enjoying themselves while putting on a great performance.
Kpop is toxic and the primary entertainment are fanwars. I'd rather enjoy the music, videos, and performances and stay away from much of the discourse and the comments. It's gross. Good thing there are channels like this who keep it about what matters.
What frustrates me with all the hate directed at Jennie’s stage stumbles is that in their documentary they literally said that Jennie gets motion sickness and also struggles with fatigue, which of course will get triggered when you’re having to whip your hair and spin around on stage. And even if she just tripped, why can’t people understand we all make mistakes? It doesn’t ruin the performance, if anything it makes it more human and personal for the blinks watching.
i will never get how so called “haters” have the time to interact with a group they dont even seem to like. thank you so much for making this. the hate got to an extent where i couldn’t escape it. people may argue that blackpink is seen as this overly good and overrated phenomenon when it’s just their haters viewing them that way and this proves my argument looking at current reactions to certain lacking stages. if they didn’t place them on the high standards they wouldn’t be mad about them lacking. kpop stans are delusional.
@@deathgodtheking2651 exactly, people will make up any excuse they can instead of just admitting that they deserve to be where they are because of their hard work
I tried my best to get tickets but it was sold out in minutes... But whenever I ask someone who attended the concert they say I won't regret as it's the best decision I have ever made . Girls were powerful, fun and enjoyable. Their rap , sing were louder than the back track.
thank you for making this vid. I've seen many hateful comments calling BP overconfident, or lazy, or saying that their popularity is getting to their heads. I never watch the girls live, but I did see their full concerts on RUclips and I never see that. These ppl just love to hate girls without proper context and its very frustrating as a blink. And whenever I tried to stand up for the girls, they always say I have low standards, blind or something like that (pretty ironic). I bet their Coachella performance is gonna be dragged harder than their bornpink tour no matter outstanding the show is.
I went to Berlin show and I had time of my life, one of my favorite memories. The girls sounded great, the band was so good, the dancers ate, the crowd was hype. These kind of mistakes could be posted about every tour, every group but BP as the biggest gg will always be given impossible standards to match.
I got so hyped just from watching the live stream. I can't even imagine how high on endorphins the people ACTUALLY ATTENDING were. I was screaming the entire time. My mom yelled at me to shut up. It was the best.
I appreciate your video and your perspective on the tour. I also do believe that it’s not all hate and some of it is constructive criticism while the rest is just downright rude. I do still believe that this tour and especially how long and abruptly it started was not the best move. Considering the fact it’s been 2 years since they performed together and even a little over 2 years since they performed together infront of a live audience and it shows. But it’s not the girls fault. I blame YGE more than I do the girls bc the fact that they’re being used just for their brand and fanbase and not in a good way. And it’s bc of that they get a lot of hate and labeled as influencers who can sing. YGE doesn’t care ab the fact they actually put years into this and this is dream. They’re just following where the money is which absolutely sucks for the girls bc I do believe they’re starting to lose their passion for music (at YGE at least) bc of the decisions being made. I wish them the best though SN: Does Jennie’s black jacket say B*tch on the back of it??.. I want to buy it now lol
Saw them in Chicago with my bestie and I will keep saying that THEY KILLED IT!! The concert was SO hype, the dancing was excellent, the live singing was really good especially considering the choreo, and all four girls' stage presence was incredible. To top it off there were some lovely moments of connection with the crowd and with each other that let their personalities shine. I was glued to the concert the whole time and there weren't any mistakes that people had been complaining about, and while I'm not an expert on k-pop I have experience performing on stage. I was VERY impressed with their abilities and energy, and also had so much fun my arm was destroyed from shaking my lightstick constantly!! Everything I could want from a Blackpink concert. I truly don't understand why bp haters get so much attention online because the girls do nothing to deserve it!
blackpink got hate in 2019 for being too in sync and they screw up once for their seoul concert (they even apologized the next day) but kpop fans made it seem as if their entire tour was like that and discredited their hard work. yg made a statement abt how the girlies were working hard to shoot shut down, prepare for inkigayo and prepare for tour. everything was rushed and pushed out last minute and its obvious mistakes were bound to happen. i just don't get why they got crucified and people made it seem as if they're ALWAYS like that. if that's the case i highly doubt blackpink would be where they are today.
If they sync, they won't have time to connect people. It cannot do both at the same time. Yes, in 2019 people complained because they seemed to ignore the fans when performing. And this year when they care about the fans who come to see them. People who don't go to concerts complain that they don't sync. lol
Blackpink isn't even in my top 5 fav girl groups, but the moment a friend shared one of the compilations of the "bad moments" of their tour I was like "good, they have many shows with a strong set list, they should manage their energy properly, expecting perfection from idols is dumb" and I stand by that. If they were to perform every single song with a lot of energy, they would probably faint in the middle of the concert, I want idols to be healthy and making sure they don't exhaust themselves is a crucial part of that. *Just to clarify, I like them and I would consider myself a blink, they are just pretty low in my stan list lol
I am one yr late but thank you for this video! I have been a BLACKPINK and Jennie defender since they debuted. out of all the members, Jennie has gotten most hate. when they debuted she got hated for "trying to outshine" other members with her energy and SP, then when she mellowed down she got accused of "being lazy". compared to other girl groups, BLACKPINK is doing so well in performing live, stage presence, and all other whole package. I saw them live in Vegas, I admit the first section during intro they weren't really singing 100% live BUT the rest of the concert they sang almost mostly live and did amazing! seeing them live made me love them even more.
I honestly get the criticism about the Born Pink tour. For the prices that they are charging the tour is very underwhelming. There are no props on stage and to put it bluntly the members are just dancing like they were in a music show. I would even argue that there is more effort being put into music shows rather than into their concert stages. The pinks also lipsynced a lot during the concert and the background music was very loud compared to their low mics. Also their enegry was kinda mid and I hate to jump on that bandwagon but Jennie was really lackluster and often gave the impression like she wasnt really into it. What I really enjoyed tho was the engery of the crowd. It was epic! As a frequent concert attender all in all I have to say that Blackpink sadly is one of the weaker acts I watched and the crowd really is the most enjoyable thing about the experience. Maybe it was just like this at my show and others were better. I think its very apparent that the pinks sadly are very inconsitent when it comes to performances.
@@deathgodtheking2651 Hmmm I personally don't think they were that great but that's just my opinion. I'm sure there are a lot of people who did enjoy their performance :3
As an ex-blink who unstanned after the tour, there are a some things I have to say : 1. The vocals were inarguably the best part of the tour. Especially in the current era of kpop where live vocals are exceptionally rare, it was truly satisfying to see "the biggest gg in the world" absolutely kill with their vocals. Rose was the obvious standout in this area. 2. I thought we as kpop stans had accepted the fact that Lisa isn't an impressive vocalist and is an average rapper. But she is an AMAZING dancer. Not only that, she actually shows improvement in her dancing capabilities and never have I seen that girl miss. So, it would make sense for her solo stage to be more dance focused than anything else, wouldn't it? Throughout the entirety of this year-long tour she has been consistent. And getting sick / having off days on tours are unavoidable. But she hasn't let any of it show in her performances. That's a true professional performer. And I hope ppl (by that I mean their own fandom's solo stans) will stop using her solo stage as an excuse to bring her down knowing that she was delivering vocals during group songs. And here's to hoping she gives herself music that is actually good now that she's on her own. fck them tiktok monstrosities. 3. Jisoo's cover of liar was 100x better than her actual solo performance(s). It sometimes makes me wonder if their mid music impacts their stage presence but getting back to the point: Jisoo seems stagnant to me. I'm not a professional by any means but jisoo dances and sings the exact same way she's been doing since the last tour. Her vocals are definitely better than her dance. Which is confusing to me because she had more than two years b/w tours to improve but okay. 4. I've been listening to what you have to say and take in any nuance you offer regarding each member. And while I do mostly agree with everything you have said up to this point, here is where i wholeheartedly disagree. Before I start, I wanna say that you can actually call someone out without degrading / dehumanising them and let's leave the partying out of this since it's not anyone's business but hers. Jennie has been given the benefit of the doubt countless times by fans including me. But if there's one thing i've noticed watching not just bp but also many other ggs and bgs, there's a stark difference between trying and not trying, and jennie is more often than not NOT TRYING. The woman looks bored on stage period. And the clip you inserted about her "happy face" basically implying that she has an rbf isn't an excuse since we do have the first tour to compare to where she genuinely looks happy to be there without an ear to ear smile (not to mention countless other idols with rbfs whose performance capabilities have never come into question due to having one). Having off days is fine. But as a performing artist who charges as much as Beyonce to come see you, the sheer number of off days you take at the expense of fans who pay hard earned money to see you (ppl even go into debt to see their faves at least once in their life, not to mention the expenses ppl pay to come watch a group from abroad since their country never falls on tour lists) brings to question not only your professionalism but also your morality. Every single fan in every single country deserves to see jennie perform with the same energy she gives at coachella or at her own concert in la at any day. I'm obviously not talking about the times she was genuinely sick. EVEN THEN I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. Until that podcast with dua lipa.... The only thing I'm gonna say is that she came off as highly hypocritical and untruthful. It seemed like a bad excuse for something she knew she did wrong but didn't have the guts to admit or at the very least say she'll try to do better. It made me lose the little respect I had for her and I turned away from the group as a whole. As a person you are entitled to your opinion, but this is mine. Ig it makes me frustrated since I've loved jennie and bp as my female ults from a very young age. I still do hold a soft spot for the group (for the other 3 members at the very least) which is why I clicked on this video. It's been a while and a lot has changed so I wanted to look at everything from a fresh mindset. The conclusion I reached was that this tour was a true mess, even looking back at it now. It was either the best or the worst which is pretty extreme.
I Really get your point, This blackpink tour is not as bad as people says, but really call my attention that your analysis to little mix last tour you were a lot more critical compare to this analysis and I think that's not fair. I like your yt channel because you're honest and critical, but in this case you justify so many things that you didn't in little mix video. In BP video you say they are not robot, they are human and makes mistakes but in little mix video you talk about they're making so much mistakes but never consider and talk about that two members gave birth 5 months before the tour. You used to talk about the positive and negative things in your analysis, but here I just see the positive side. The reality is that blackpink in this tour are so inconsistent, one day they have a lot of energy and the other day lack completely of it.
Unless you attended every single concert during their ongoing tour, you can't say they lack energy in every other performance. Judging the concert through 3 second clips doesn't make any sense. And this is from a 2/3 hour concert. If I were a hateful person, I could do the exact same thing to any performer. And I wouldn't even be angry if THEY WERE inconsistent. Or any artist on tour. Blackpink has been touring since last year, and I think a lot of people forget just how much of a toll tours take on someone. My point is that we should have some grace for every artist. Whether it's Blackpink or anyone else.
Thank you for the comment! This video is different than the strict review format of my Little Mix video. This video was made in response to mean-spirited, condescending, rude comments I've observed online, which wasn't the case for Little Mix. Confetti Tour was an unfortunate case. Why even going on tour 5 months after giving birth if it allegedly puts health and safety of the members at risk and having them perform a similar show to those they had performed in the past? The whole concept of the show was working against Perrie and Leigh-Anne; I'd pay money just for them to go on stage and sing their hearts out while sitting or standing still with some nostalgic footage in the background. I wouldn't say a word. But instead we got questionable tacky outfits, poorly executed choreography, energetic chaos and quite a lot of lipsync. I totally get your point and why you may feel like that; please know I'm still very much fond of Little Mix and I am looking forward to members' solo debuts!
@@aintnootherfan The lip-sync, poorly executed choreography and the lack of energy I see it in this black ink tour too but I understand your point that this is a different concept video and that’s why you didn’t mention it. Thank you for answered.
@@penguin_0172 I didn’t have to attend to every single concert I just watched the fans videos from different dates and I notice the inconsistency but overall I don’t think it’s a bad tour just that I noticed that this tour was put together so fast with not enough preparation and the girls are not mentally prepare to performance every night.
Thank you for this. Everyone wants k-pop idols to be seen as humans and not robots except when it comes to Blackpink. They forget that even they can't do half of what Blackpink does.
I don’t know if they were brought to success thanks to their company but in the end they sing, if they become successful it’s not even their fault lol If people buy their music you can’t really do anything about it xD
well you can't deny the fact that due to them coming from YG and 2en1 being their senior made them instantly popular even before debut, if blackpink where from a small company without an already well established name and fanbase they wouldn't be half successful as they're now, like look at gidle they're doing everything and are in my humble opinion better than blackpink yet they aren't half as popular because they come from a small company
@@NA22427Cube is a big company, compared to actual small companies. They've had popular groups before, they're just ULTRA SHITTY when it comes to managing their groups. Gidle could've been bigger if it were not for Cube mistreating them and not capitalizing on opportunities. Big Hit has proven that if you manage your group well and market it cleverly, the size of your company don't matter. Look at Momoland, they were on a meteoric rise, but their shitty company couldn't handle it and f*cked up, so they had meteoric downfall. Everglow was getting popular along with Gidle, but now I don't hear from any of them from their company.
@@NA22427 Hate to burst your bubble, but this is showbiz. As a public figure, the type of company you're associated with DOES matter (in a way). While you could argue that K-pop acts like (G)I-DLE have better chances of showcasing/utilizing their talents, that still doesn't change the fact that companies like Cube Ent generally suck at promoting and capitalizing on their popular artists (judging by their history)! Just like Pledis/SVT (especially before the HYBE acquisition), Cube is lucky to have (G)I-DLE on their roster.
I saw them live in 2019 and with just a handful of songs they pulled of a brilliant tour and also debut at Coachella. I seen them again in London for the two nights they were here and they were phenomenal. I don't know why people are lying other than they can say and do what ever on line and get away with it. I have booked tickets for Coachella and Hyde park this year. Haters are going to hate and nothing will stop them.
Of course they owe their fans a lot . They would not be where they were if not for fans. It the fans who watch their songs , stream them , buy their merch put up with hate for them the least they can do is give their best . No one is asking for a super performance but at least show that you trying. Without a fanbase they would be now where . So pipo criticism is not to put them down but to wake them up cause kpop is competitive. It like a parent correcting a kid. Fans are not pipo to treat like garbage, they are pipo to be grateful for
Is it just me or do we all just want Jisoo's solo album to have a Latin influence? Her voice goes so well with the Latin sound. As a Latino, she made me proud by singing that song. Even if it is all in English, it fit well with her voice.
FINALLY ,THANK YOU .A reasonable human being. 5% of the comments I see online is pure criticism/feedback , while the other 95% try so had to bring them down. Spreading lies as "they are not doing their jobs!!!" and suddenly feeling sooo sorry
What’s even funnier is that they still use the same 5 second clip just to prove a point. I mean out of all the cities they been too haters still use their performance in Korea to shit on them
@@deathgodtheking2651 even the concert in Korea wasn't even half as bad as they make it to be. When knetz that kpoopies claim to be the most toxic people on earth are not complaining about the concert, why tf are their butts burning lol
I think K pop standards are so intense, it boggles my mind that people post a few seconds or even a minute of a mistake when the concerts are two hours. Its not a special stage, or a performance of couple of songs, its multiple shows in a week sometimes, of course there will be errors to some level. I saw them in Vegas and had an amazing time, they were so fun and charismatic, and they sounded great, even though it was one of their last shows.
With BP it's very strange cause they seem to improve but not as fast as some other groups and people are expecting a lot more since they debuted in 2016. I'm not a stan myself but I have to say that if some groups that have been in the industry for less than them have improved much more than BP then what's the problem? I don't think people want them to be perfect (it'd be stupid anyway) but the more time flies the more demanding people will become with them. However, I must say people are not easy with these poor girls and I'm not even going to talk about insane threats and insults they received. May God help them!
You know, it's not even their fault. They have to basically restart every single comeback. Like imagine not doing something for like 2 years and people expect you to be the best on your first day back.. and I think the reason rosé and Lisa have did so good in the born pink tour is because they had their solos.
Guys,The girls just want to see and invited the fellow blinks,share some moment with them,have fun,dance and sing together. Just it. Not promising thats concert will be a perfect perform,but they're promise it will be one of best memories u can keep in your life, in positive way or negative way. Its up to you.
all of the mistakes highlighted made me think've they were doing a terrible job, and they seemed to be kinda messy actually in the beginning of the tour from the clips used - I'm from Brazil, so not a chance I'd go see them live. but they improved their show, Rose is giving good vocals also. they apparently lip sometimes, but the live instances aren't credited because people hate Blackpink, I'm not even a fan of them. but the criticism is too much. I'm ashamed, but I did believe most criticism that, even if it happened, those videos made people think the whole tour was Jennie falling and other mistakes.
They seem good to me. They are just having fun. I wish I could have joined a girl group in high school or college. It is about self expression, fun, dancing, and letting the people on stage " Wow" you. Overall, they have fun, stage presence, that is strong, their choregraphy is good, through they use playback a lot. Lip syncing is minimal. It seems like a " fun" show. 15 or 16 year old me would have had their albums and gone instead of the Spice Girls.
Honestly, i don't have a problem with constructive criticism, but i feel like most of it is just blatant hate with blackpink. Like, saying they lipsync is crazy to me, it's so obvious that they sing live every single concert. Also, one of the things that infuriated me the most is the hate Jennie got for losing her balance. What the fuck was that? I don't even consider that a mistake, she just.. lost her balance, it's not like she messed up the move or forgot it or something. Same thing with Jisoo's situation when singing Shut Down. My girl sounded so good the whole time and people had an issue with the last line she sung and it wasn't even that bad. Kpop stans are not used to live vocals and it shows. They just try to find reasons to hate on them. It saddens me to see that they don't see BP as people, but as the punching bag of kpop.
The main reason why BP is getting criticised is due to blinks being hypocrites themselves, kpop stans being ignorant on complex issues, an inability to separate their bias from their 'criticism', and their unwillingness to try experience new things. That said, Bp has just one great performer the rest are in different stages of mediocre. But blinks are too delusional and xenophobic to give the girl her flowers. Its ironic that most of the people who lash out at lisa's stage were blinks, blinks who wanted to even the playing field on the hate the other members got. Lisa's stage reminds me of Beyonce's single ladies amongst other great performers and it was executed flawlessly. But blinks rather disparaged it in other to reduce the hate the other members are getting. Y'all really need to know what lip sync is atp
?? Don't get me wrong but you just sound like an akgae (which means toxic solo stan.) And yeah right, it's always those stupid, stupid Blinks being delulu and....xenophobic towards Lisa? Where did that come from? Well alright.
First of all who goes to concert and tries to nitpick "oh she's one beat late" "oh she lipsync that part" "oh her choreo is wrong" Like bruh!! It aint a competition show hahaha IT'S A CONCERT!!! The BP enjoys the show same as fans. You go there like party with them. They go there to enjoy a party with you. IT SHOULD BE LIKE THAT! YES they are inconsistent as a fan I see it but that doesn't mean I didn't enjoy the show.
They are the best for me, even my wife who wasn't a fan of them but after we watch their show in chicago day 1 concert she became a fan. Even if they made few mistakes on other shows I'm still here for them and also their personalities are another thing that draws me in to stan them. Btw I'm 47 years old guy and been a blink since 2019.
It’s such a drain on the Blink experience to constantly defend BP and try to prove their already undeniable talent to people who purposefully ignore and twist the truth to encourage others to jump on the hate train, and who shame them for massive global achievements they’d die for their own faves to achieve. It’s like they don’t understand that BP reaching these heights is paving the way for other kpop artists to follow, not taking away from anyone. They’ll only ever acknowledge a member’s skills so they can trash talk the other members or Blinks themselves for neglecting the member they claim to like (which isn’t even happening). And while other groups have gone from hated to loved over time, for BP it’s the opposite: the more success they experience, the more hate they receive. It’s almost impossible to find a comment section under any Blackpink video that isn’t full of vitriol (maybe except their MVs), even when the video itself is praising the group. Just look around here
Though there have been some videos going around that have left some people questioning if the members have enough time to practice together for the tour, they tend to be few and far between. And with a K-Pop girl group as popular as BLACKPINK, it isn’t surprising to see them getting unfairly hated on just for being successful
if any other group did a little twerk or tripped on stage nobody would bat an eye, people would even call it cute, but with blackpink it’s completely different
I feel like Kpop stans, especially those of 4th gen forget how live vocals sound (and also dancing while singing live) due to the massive amount of lip-synced/pre recorded "live" stages and super hard choreographies which are never meant to be performed while singing live
Hello, at first I thought I was going to have to educate you.... Thank You. I, have in my life, have worked with the music and live performance industry. I have seen more concerts than I can remember. Well, maybe I should say attended more concerts, because when working in the back, you don't get to see, but still hear and know how things work. BlackPink, is one of the best, most chaotic, concert series I have ever seen. It reminds me of David Bowie. He would put everything he could into his show because his fans paid good money to be entertained. BP is very entertaining. Things people do not know. They run over two miles for each performance. Once they leave the stage, it is RUN to get to your next spot. If they are stage front, they are running stooped over under the stage to get in place for their cue. They run from the stage to the back to do their change outs. They only have the three to five minutes to do it and most of the time it is getting changed and people fussing over them just to run back so they are on their mark when the light go back on. Thankfully they have showed some of this on the BPM videos. I have talked about the so called lip-syncing vs backing track. People need to learn the difference. Because no one can dance like Lisa and still sing in tune. It is impossible. So, she lets the backing track do the work while she is doing her dance breaks. Besides that, they are live mic, all the time. And yes, if you do not like BP, don't watch them. There is plenty of good music out there to enjoy. As for their concerts suck. When a concert sucks, the artist will be reprimanded by their labels and concerts will be canceled due to "personal reasons, Health Issues or other reasons." This series, no matter the critics opinions, is adding even more shows, selling out places K-pop has never been before. K-pop should be thanking them for the exposure, but instead they are trying to tear them down. There is an industry reason for that. But this post is already getting long. BP does things at their concerts I had never seen before with their preshow and post show fan interactions. I'm used to get them to the stage and get them out fast. Not let them stop and talk to the fans. Now here is where most people will call me a die hard Blink... Nope, that's my wife. While my BP bias is Jisoo, my K-pop bias is the one and only IU! And I was a hardcore Sulli Stan, ergo why I comment on so many of these videos. That kind of behavior needs to STOP!
I always mad to see something pop up in my recommendation for "unpopular shitty opinion about BP" Like dude the content creators are just straight rude and accused bp outta nowhere from just a second clip of videos and not even the whole concert. The fact that they always pin point the bad one clip for five minutes is ridiculous when their concert is 2 hours straight. Even the comments section... Gosh my my head dizzy and full of negativity 😵 like woah a lot of haters or so called fake blinks trying so hard to downgrade the girls. It's so contradict when most people who are attended their concert said was great and the girls know how to hype up the crowds but the hate is just rubbish lol.
Sometimes I feel that they are a little inconsistent but they have so much fun during their performances, they sing well (they're not the greatest vocalist in the world, but their vocals are pretty consistet most of the times) and make mistakes in a choreography and in songs as well it's normal because they're human. Being a BLACKPINK hater is a trend i believe, because you may not like them but the hate these girls receives is out of this world. Guys if you don't like them it's okay, don't listen their music.
blackpink never claimed to be the best at singing, dancing, or even rapping. the love for the girls and their fun music is what keeps them so popular. people who love them and their music will enjoy their concerts regardless of any mistakes
I ABSOLUTELY love your point of view and absolutely agree with your whole video. I am a blink since 2019 and I realized all the things you pointed and commented about during the video.
This video is different than the strict review format of my Little Mix video. This video was made in response to mean-spirited, condescending, rude comments I've observed online, which wasn't the case for Little Mix. Confetti Tour was an unfortunate case. Why even go on tour 5 months after giving birth if it allegedly puts health and safety of the members at risk and having them perform a similar show to those they had performed in the past? The whole concept of the show was working against Perrie and Leigh-Anne; I'd pay money just for them to go on stage and sing their hearts out while sitting or standing still with some nostalgic footage in the background. I wouldn't say a word. But instead we got questionable tacky outfits, poorly executed choreography, energetic chaos and quite a lot of lipsync. I totally get your point and why you may feel like that; please know I'm still very much fond of Little Mix and I am looking forward to members' solo debuts!
@@aintnootherfan BLACKPINK making more mistakes despite them being on a hiatus have time to practice giving us nothing the backtrack is louder than their vocals but you still find excuses for them meanwhile those women despite giving birth still trying hard to give a show and all you did is dragging them to hell I'm not even surprised how you always biased when it comes to Blackpink I'm not trying to say that Blackpink deserve hate but atleast you should try to be fair
@@euphoria7019 loud backtrack? in comparison to most kpop groups blackpinks backtrack is quite. they made one mistake in their seoul concert and weirdos took it and made it seem as if the entire tour was like that. their comeback and tour were rushed and it was pretty obvious they didn't have much time to smoothen it out hence is why their first concerts the only one consisting of mistakes. you make excuses for little mix and want them to be humanized whilst neglecting to take into account blackpinks situation. both groups don't deserve lashings but it happens.
@@-xxx9170 this is about BLACKPINK and little mix you can't read? and i can't even believe that you're comparing women who just gave birth to 2 years hiatus group especially Jennie who didn't have and performances or solo release 💀
@@euphoria7019 where did i compare little mix giving birth to blackpink? are you having comprehension issues? i simply said you can humanize your girlies without belittling blackpink in the process. i even said both groups don't deserve lashings yet you took it as an attack. weirdo
When I studied abroad in Korea, I went to the Seoul concert day 2, and I can understand where some of the criticism videos came from. I personally think YG rushed the tour, especially after all the promotions for shows they made the girls do. It felt like they were both over whelmed to perform in front of such large crowds again after so long from Covid and exhausted from born pink promotions that led to more inconsistencies in the earlier parts of the tour. As someone who was also blessed enough to be at Coachella weekend 1 in 2019, I can't say the born pink concert was better; but it wasn't anywhere near as much of a shit show as the criticism videos make it seem. I very much enjoyed my time even though some mistakes were obvious or parts were lacking, and if I could go back I would do it again. As the tour has gone on, the girls do seem to be getting much more comfortable and happy on stage which is always great to see! The only thing I genuinely disliked is YG's management of it; of all the K-pop concerts I attended during my time abroad, blackpink's was both the most expensive (sat in the upper section) and the shortest. I wish they performed all of the songs from the album or didn't cut some of them short (it's a sin we don't have a single live "The Happiest Girl" performance yet). I also wished Jennie performed a mix of "Solo" and her new song to match Rose and Lisa and hope Jisoo will perform a mix of her solos once they're released! Along with that, the way they handled the merchandise line was horrible, I waited in line for an hour before the concert but still had to leave early just to make the concert on time and of course they were sold out of almost everything after the concert, still got a cute hat tho : )
After the disbandment of 2NE1 and the prolonged hiatus of BigBang, YG fans were left craving for content. The release of a couple of their songs, combined with allegations of YG using phone farms to boost their songs on RUclips, prompted RUclips itself to release a statement acknowledging that their MVs may have been artificially inflated with paid views. Despite the controversy, these tactics contributed to their sustained popularity. This was one of the reasons for their big boom. i cant see any other reason for them to be that popular. they are just RUclips famous.
Thanks for making this. It was hidden by the way not on my front page so it might be suppressed. Anyway I went to the LA show and it was incredible. All the hate about the your is cap
I remember watching some video criticizing Bacpink on tour and then I saw Mamamoo performance when they got silly and I instantly though if this was Blackping they would get so much hate. I definitely think thre's a double standard. For some reason people want Blackpink girls to be perfect all the time. For me it's artificial, concert is not a music video. I rather see some mistakes and goofines on stage.
In my opinion, Blackpink set the tone of the tour with their first concert. This was practically the "death senteces" for the tour and it will haunt the group. After the concert, there were already many rumors on the Internet about it. From they don't want to play anymore to YG didn't give them time to prepare. And that has also certainly unsettled a few fans. I've read several times that many were unsure whether it will be good, because one has heard a lot of negative things and Videos and whatever narrative was put out. And then the ticket prices also play a point. They are not exactly cheap and there was certainly one or the other the idea that Blackpink is not interested in the fans and only wants money. And of course, the haters have settled there like leeches, no question, is simply attack surface. It's like any other performance, if the open show is bad, the rest will not be well received. And Blackpinks is not an exception from it. And yes the girls have apologized and that was also right of them. They stand by the fact that it did not go well and not everyone does that. But YG should have looked at it, these mistakes could have been avoided or at least not be visible to the normal viewer. It's not the first time they've done this. There should work like professionals who know how to plan and support such things.
Unfortunately, I have to disagree with you on this one. I went to the Vegas concert in Aug, which cost me money for the flight, hotel, and the concert ticket. Rose was the only one that tried to interact with the audience in the first half of the concert. Jennie had several really obvious mistakes and always had a face showing “I don’t want to be here”. Jisoo did great in her solo. The concert was filled with extremely loud video because their lack of live singing, and around 20-30 min was the interaction with the VIP audience because they didn’t have enough songs produced. I also went to Beyoncé concert this summer and had a completely different experience 😂 Although idols aren’t really artists, and they have a shorter career, BP and YG should deliver more in order to make them match their hype. Many 3 and 4 gen groups are amazing but they earn way less money because they don’t have all the corporate resources. I disagree with personal attacks or bad languages but for audience who pay money out of their own pocket, they have a word to say.
All of bp fans who went to concert actually enjoyed the show ( myself included) I have went to many other kpop group concerts but bp and skz are the only groups that i have enjoyed. They are so energetic and seeing them happily dancing, singing makes me feel like I m dancing with them on stage. Idk which concert u went, but in the concert where I went none of them Lypsynced. All of them sang live and that too with decent technique. I love these girls and haters are just blind and deaf atp.
i have zero issues with them and their tour i actually like them as people very much but i've noticed maybe i just dont like their singing voices that much 🤔
as a ex blink 1 i dont agree with it first you said the bad clips are from first few tour but if they practice rather than photoshoot they never gotten this hate and dont give me yg to blame yes yg dont give them comeback but they can still practice on their own like in 2 years yes 3 of them doing solo project but like other groups can balance what they do it why cant they
And now they are much better. compared to the first stage Bro, no matter how much you practice, when you're practicing there isn't a full stadium watching you.that they disappeared for 2 years Just let them adjust. and you look at the paris fair They're back the way they were.
so much to be said, but will leave it short (ish)... Great video totally agree on most parts and well formulated (thats the wrong word my tired mind tells me, but well explained... English is a 2nd language)... anyways I did see them live and it was amazingly raw, a pure expression of art, yes it was at times (very few) flawed, but always very real, you got a real sense of who they were as individuals, so will explain that as it is also the flaws kinda. Jennie: her passion on individual lines sell them so well, hard to explain but it felt like someone receiving a breakthrough in therapy but live in front of thousands cheering for it, I walked away with the thought that she was meant to be on stage, letting her healing be shared to us. Jisoo: hard to explain, but at the concert I was sometimes playing the fun game "finding Jisoo (I missed some cute moments with other members because of it) Jisoo seemed of somewhere else than the rest on stage having fun interacting, so the members were doing choreo on the front platform of the catwalk, Jisoo was at main side stage doing poses and singing to individual fans that caught her eye, she seemed to have the most FUN on stage and it was infectious to watch her. Lisa: she was born to be in the performance center, she captivated to the point that even at a distance you could clearly see her expressions while she did insanely pretty (but kinda shouldn't be pretty... if I or anyone else tried) dance moves or flourishes (where they let down the mic to do a thing and let the backtrack take over, we call it a flourish in the industry, or flourish tracking for the type of backtrack used, because it is very clear to hear when it kicks in, and it means that you should pay extra attention), she was amazing to watch. Rosé: she is a mindbogglingly talented vocalist.... just that... would be enough... but she adds such flair and talent to her performance that it leaves you wanting more... all in all my main grief was me having only two eyes, because wherever I found enjoinment I missed out somewhere else.... but think that is on me, they are hated on for being to damn good... and that is it.... can they be better?.. probably and surely they will, because they put in a lot of effort to become better.. are they peaking?.. nope.... have they peaked the industry?.. yes, but they will take it further and lift the industry with them
FINALLY!👍👌👍👌👍 The people who spend their entire existence trying to deny Blackpink's talent, success and popularity, are not fans of BLACKPINK! They are trolls, very stupid ones too! They hid behind their fake social media names and Avatars, hurling insults at people/groups like Blackpink because it's all they can do to make them feel better about themselves! I've been following Blackpink since they debuted and literally watched them grow from amazingly talented young girls to mature, amazingly talented young Women! Over the last 7 years, they have only gotten better & more confident! They are now genuine roll models for all the up and coming Kpop girl groups.
Well I was thinking that they're just bored to perform in front of their own people cause they killed it in overseas. This issue only emerged after their performance in Korea. Well to be fair Lisa's a Thai. Rose is an Australian. Only Jennie and Jisoo were Korean. But Jennie doesn't seem interested to be in Korea anymore. Am I wrong?
Well, they certainly are not Milli Vanilli if you know what I mean. And they are making $3 million per show I have no complaints. They deserve their rewards for working hard. Will they stick around after Born Pink? Who knows.
i understand that alot of the "criticism" is not genuine and is most definitely harmful to society overall. but i actually think most of it is pretty fair. because there's just so many issues with this group, with the girls and with the company. blackpink themselves are the toxic space that further feeds on toxicity coming in. people are loud about them even though they don't like them because it's interesting and it's frustrating. it's not just the inconsistencies, the weird personas and unprofessional actions or the shady tactics. as a group blackpink are extremely mediocre. people always call out mediocrity. i know it looks like people pick at everything but that's often just the consequences of someone not being good enough at anything. like blackpink don't give enough of a good performance to have watchers be fine with lipping but they also don't sing well enough consistently for their to not be any reasons not to critiscise and dislike live concerts and stages. in comparison to everyone around them..... they just stick out like a swollen, pussy thumb. people expect the best of the best if you're that praised and successful. especially if you're from a minority group that's impact is currently a huge topic. alsoooooo the racism and ignorance!!!!! both their company and the girls are horrible. and honestly come across as airheads. it's creepy and yet another reason to not like or fall for the hollow brand that is blackpink. there's just so much surrounding them and it can't all be blamed on yge. blackpink aren't dolls. they're grown women who've made these choices just as much as their label and staff. they wouldn't get this much flack if fans and non fans could see that the girls cared but were being held back. in fact that's been an excuse for years. it just doesn't work because it's not true. well it might be in some ways and mostly just for lisa since she's the only performer with that kind of energy and that's why she's the most liked. people see that she has some kind of passion. i have to say jennie and rose have disappointed me so much. they were so exciting to me but they're just so boring. they're not artists. jisoo is either just boring enough or too boring. but she has some good moments here and there. it's far too obvious that she isn't into music and also just how far behind she is skill wise and talent wise. i did used to praise her for working hard to keep up but it's not enough anymore. her improvements are so slow and sloppy. blackpink is a decade of training that apparently doesn't exist.
It's seems like you have a deep personal problem to them lol, I mean I can't judge people by the video only because we never know them personally behind the scenes. But so far from what I see them in social media and the video from fans ask them to take a sign, I think they are pretty good and chill and doesn't have that "star syndrome" Aura, they seem to know how to put themselves without being fake.
@@Dina-zb2cvpeople expect blackpink to be like other groups which there not every group has different styles of music I don’t know why people want them to be like others
@@deathgodtheking2651 because blackpink is a "k-pop" Star not a global girl group from America or Europe. So people will expect them to maintain that "saint and innocent child like" Persona like typical kpop idol. So when you see blackpink having fun with the western artist or going to the party/club with them it feels like out of the box and people will think they're a being a bad girl and will tarnish their reputation when in fact they just being socialized as a normal human being.
@@deathgodtheking2651 maybe because of their face? I know they are a mature woman in their mid 20's but because they have such a young pretty feminine face people will expect them to act cute lol.
Yo las vi en Barcelona y aluciné, el tour es altamente profesional, ellas estuvieron espectaculares, mantuvieron la energía en todo momento, hubo buena cohesión entre los fans y ellas, la presencia escénica, el carisma y sus voces on top como siempre
Only a narcissist would object to constructive criticism. And, people who view a product or service, such as a pop music group, have a right to criticize the content.
Constructive criticism offers feedback and is given by people with an understanding in that field. No kpop fan has achieved that level to call their criticism constructive especially when they are both ignorant and lack basic etiquette
@@ariastarn1289 Pretty ironic when you come off as a “solo stan” (despite SOME valid points). I would’ve been totally on board with you IF it weren’t for the “akgae” crap. Even your so-called “compliments” are fairly backhanded. 👈🙃 (This is coming from someone who biases nearly ALL the BLACKPINK members, including Lisa.)
Boy i love your channel a Lot but You sugarcoat BP in your channel The girls are clearly not Bad but you're way more critical with other groups (femenine or masculine)
the first keyword that shows up when i google born pink tour is "mess" just how many haters do they have online that even the korean media had to respond
Ok, let’s make something clear they aren’t close to be the best performers and sometimes they can be really bad ( I think the only one who is consistent is Lisa) but they don’t deserve the hate they receive, whoever I want to point out that the amount of criticism they receive is also due to the overhype their fans have created, as I said they are regular performers, but you always can see they fans acting like they are the best thing in the world ( rose being the vocalist, Lisa being the best dancer) things that are clearly not true so people expect a lot to them just to see them being meh
People have to understand that this is life, not heaven or so-called ideal world we all want to see because we don't always get what we want. I understand that the biggest weakness of Blackpink is inconsistency but apart of that, they slay at a lot of moments which already entertain us a lot and give us a lot of interactions with in concert based on what i see from some fans who are watching Born Pink. They are not perfect, but I still enjoy them. They've been in such a hell of busy schedules and it took a toll of them mentally and physically which I understood, and in that phase, I really can't ask or demand too much from them.
Literally! Even as a longtime geek (music or otherwise), I've always found stan culture pretty absurd. The more you engage with a piece of media, the bigger the entitlement (and it shows). Even within the K-pop sphere, certain fans be bitter/salty when their fave artists succeed and promote internationally. It's like saying you don't want Beyoncé and Michael Jackson to do the same (despite their MASSIVE global influences).
It's that hennie and jisso forgot the choreo like 4 or 4 times they have like 13 Ichoreos that's it groups like twice have 50 choreos and regular comebacks taking so many breaks and u still didn't improve and forget the choreo like wtf it's clear for jisso and jennie the passion is not there and they r influencers having 36 songs in 7 years is crazy like what the he'll they r influencers now
Well Jisoo and Jennie are not in twice are they? This kind of mentality is weird. Because you'd be the same person that would cry wolf if your parents compared your weakness to the strengths of some other random person
@@ariastarn1289 wow u want to play that game u imagine taking 2 years of u r jobbb to develop skills and coming back worse barley any improvement it's not that hard and they r performing only like 8 particular song if u can remember that then the passion I gone and can't vlame it on the gotta blame it on yg not giving them good music and regular comebacks cause clearly during their debut era and the album was actually really impressive
@@Justbechill1548 you know what, I actually agree with you. Before I thought it was a case of nerves,but they are not improving, they are regressing. I can't defend them anymore.
@@ariastarn1289 exactly cause blinks r constantly defending them they don't improve if u let them gey hate they will actually do good cause rosè and jennie r also me of the best performers I have ever seen but they r so inconsistent like rosè was the only member I could look at during Coachella and the album and jennie during aylt d4 and album they have talent Lisa is the only one putting in effort the others might be better talen wise but she worked harder than them and it shows if jennie and rosè put effort in the could be one of the best in kpop
the hypocrisy kpop fans serve when it comes to bp is so insane. Bp is an internationally acclaimed group, that doesn’t mean they have to be the best in all the categories, they don’t own anyone an explanation as to why they are famous, subjecting them to hate is not even a new development they have been a target by everyone in K-pop since 2018. The most recent addition to their bandwagon hate train is the slut shaming, it really is so painful to watch, think about millions of people name calling you on internet, objectifying you, and yet you still have to go on the stage in front of the very same people and do the same show you got ridiculed for, who would be happy who wouldn’t be depressed. I blame YG for such poor management of Blackpink they really should not resign with them.
Just to be super clear; I am NOT concerned with the fact that Blackpink is getting criticism because they shouldn't be immune to it.
What I have a problem with is the nature of the criticism I've been seeing online and the selective double standard the group faces as well as the general frustration aimed at the members themselves.
If Blackpink as a group doesn't offer enough in your opinion, you have every right to not support or follow the group.
THANK YOU!!, criticism ruins career not only BLACKPINK, criticism can affect everybody even not so popular people.
@@xsctar_kpopyou missed the point
@@xxheart_breakerxx8732 agreed
@@xxheart_breakerxx8732 blackpink and YG didnt promote themselves "the biggest gg" actually YG promote BP saying they will be the next 2n1. the media, and the public did that, bc their popularity, recods, and fanbase
Teddy says in their documemtary that they never though they will be that BIG INTERNATIONALLY, sorry for my english
Blackpink is quite inconsistent, but they are great performing for big crowds, it really brings out their full capabilities at the time. People can and should criticize them, but their mistakes are many times more noticed than their overall quality.
It so frustrating how people dont know the difference between having backtrack and lip-sync or confuse skipping line for lip-sync. They just attack artist they dont like. I was watching Rihana's recent performance and I was disappointed at how some people were calling it lip-sync because she skipped parts.
Lip sync = mic off 100% The fact that they sing along with the back tack is because when they motivate or connect with people. The song will be able to continue to run and not be missed. I couldn't understand when I heard them sing. There were 2 vocal lines. Why did people still dare to say lip sync?
@@parkpark6976 I wonder what runs in these peoples mind too.
It's so sad that all The members would make an amazing performance for a two hours stage and the only thing that goes viral is a 5 seconds clip of jennie standing in the opposite direction of the other members or something
So trueee
I recently saw them live during this tour in New Jersey and all 4 of them were amazing! Honestly, not a single complaint that I can think of. From a singer’s perspective, they were all giving 100%, sounded great and they were just so entertaining to watch. We really need to show idols grace and shouldn’t put them on an unattainable, unrealistic “god” pedestal. They’re humans like us at the end of the day.
I'm so glad you've had a great experience!
im so jealouss
I saw blackpink in their IN YOUR AREA tour (Barcelona) in 2019, in THE SHOW in 2021 and more recently BORN PINK world tour (Paris) in 2022. I have been stanning them since 2017 and words can't express how proud Im am of them for constantly improving, especially their vocals. In 2019 they weren't very stable but still singed live then at the show they were moe stable and confident. The biggest change was in their more recent tour. They were all very stable both at singing and rapping LIVE. People are just so used to listening pre recorded tracks on 4th gen kpop and think that their faves are singing live while somehow magically doing back flips and intense coreographies that they can't recognise what live vocals sound like.
U ate with this comment
@@slaysan Thank You😘😘😘
Ate and left no crumbs, slay! ❤
The problem is not that they are getting criticised. The problem is that they are getting shamed for things that are actually normal.
Jennie is getting called names just because she decided to perform with a bralette and a jacket. People are pointing out how she shouldn't wear such clothes and how she is negatively influencing children in the concert. First of all she is an adult and can make decisions on her own, and she knows what she is doing. Secondly the album Born Pink clearly has a explicit label and the tour being named after the album I'm 100% sure no parent who wants "good influence" on their children will bring them to such concert.
And they are also getting called out names because they are twerking. LIKE C'MON! It's recognised as a dance form (?) You can't slutshame someone for this. I mean is that the best people can do? Being misogynistic and calling someone something that they aren't.
The reality is hate for blackpink sells better than anything on the internet. They saw that the ticket price was high and that they made mistakes for their Seoul concert, they got on blackpink's back and started hating them for every little thing. Heck even their encore part of the concert is getting hate for not being "perfect".
And yes I am not justifying their mistakes I'm just pointing out the hate they are getting disguised as criticism from people who just get on a hate train without knowing what's going on.
FR, they are acting as if their faves are amazing too. Blackpink's stage presence is better than a lot of groups. I always am amazed when seeing blackpink perform. They were inconsistent but I feel those people paid too much attention to dancing. This is a concert not a music show or dance competition.
True. And thats point so funny. The way haters loving them better than blinks them self ❤
I think the only problem with their performances is inconsistency,the chemistry between the members is fluctuating or should I say the energy levels and cohesiveness between them seem to be variating time to time and that makes them seem like they have more sp individually than as a group collectively.
What sets BP apart from other groups is their individuality. And BP is considered a group with individual fans. They weren't like a group. It's like 4 singers performing together at a concert.
Yea tbh rosé and Lisa always give their best, so they match up but Jennie is the one that throws them off a lot..
I’ve heard so many bad things about this tour, but omfg this makes me so confused. It seems like they are singing live for the whole thing and it’s obvious when they aren’t singing and letting the backtrack cover a part. I’m not a huge fan but imo the fact I can tell they are obviously singing live is so much more important than perfect choreography. With Mamamoo being my favorite group because of the consistent live vocals especially from my bias Solar, this makes me love Blackpink a lot more and respect them so much more than I did before.
im tired of seeing haters criticising them when they haven't even attended their concert. I saw them live, and i have one thing to say, i had the best experience of my life. the concert was alot better than i expected
I mean why would haters attend their concerts?
Concerts are expensive man and I sure wouldn't attend a concert by an artist I hate. Even if it's free.
@@yukiiyamanaka so why tf are they giving reviews as if they actually attended?
@@Unknown-uh6cqbecause there obsessed with them and lowkey a fan they just don’t wanna admit it
@yukiyamanaka6365 and why tf would they even share their opinion on the concert when they weren't even there? 💀
@@edoardosopracolle9155 cause they tryna be apart of the crowd they see other people shit on them
maybe it's because im a fan, but i just love their way of performing. idk i just prefer when the artist engage with the audience and hype them, something that is quite rare in kpop. yes, they could be a little more synchronized and stuff, but honestly that's not something that really matters TO ME. i wish they came to my country 😭😭😭😭
I personally don't expect music show type of synchronization on tours; I've always perceived tours as a chance for connecting with the audience and prioritizing having a good time overall.
Where are you from btw? They didn't come to my country but I was thinking about seeing them in Berlin
@@aintnootherfan i'm from brazil, there's been some rumors that they're negociating some stadiums here, but there's nothing confirmed yet 😭
@@samuel-ge9ut Man I really have a great pity for Brazilians because I know that a lot of South Americans are loving them so much yet the only one that confirmed is in Mexico. Hope you guys get it soon man
@@gurunhitam3414Not only them, there's a looooot of artists that could come to Brazil too, please, I've never asked for anything 😢
also something that I've been noticing is how these stage presence discussions are always about WOMEN, like I've never seen a scandal like this about men ONCE
PERIODT
Literally. Twice, (G)I-dle, Blackpink etc. get extreme amounts of criticism and hate on their stage presence when so many boy groups give the bare minimum or below, but get praised just because they’re attractive.
Name me an extremely famous male group that toured with pathetic acts like this
@@yeyosilver7067 Like what? At my concert, blackpink were phenomenal. Such a fun show, mics were on, they were having fun and enjoying themselves while putting on a great performance.
@@chuuedup_ Wow how impressive, fans defending mediocrity lol
Names, please
Kpop is toxic and the primary entertainment are fanwars. I'd rather enjoy the music, videos, and performances and stay away from much of the discourse and the comments. It's gross. Good thing there are channels like this who keep it about what matters.
Omg thank thank you; kpop can get overwhelming sooo quickly
What frustrates me with all the hate directed at Jennie’s stage stumbles is that in their documentary they literally said that Jennie gets motion sickness and also struggles with fatigue, which of course will get triggered when you’re having to whip your hair and spin around on stage. And even if she just tripped, why can’t people understand we all make mistakes? It doesn’t ruin the performance, if anything it makes it more human and personal for the blinks watching.
It's not really the motion sickness. It's more that shes physically built weaker than the other members.
Exactly she wearing heels and dancing I would trip
i will never get how so called “haters” have the time to interact with a group they dont even seem to like. thank you so much for making this. the hate got to an extent where i couldn’t escape it. people may argue that blackpink is seen as this overly good and overrated phenomenon when it’s just their haters viewing them that way and this proves my argument looking at current reactions to certain lacking stages. if they didn’t place them on the high standards they wouldn’t be mad about them lacking. kpop stans are delusional.
They can’t even win awards without haters saying they paid for it or YG paid I see that every time they win
@@deathgodtheking2651 exactly, people will make up any excuse they can instead of just admitting that they deserve to be where they are because of their hard work
@@deathgodtheking2651 hell I even saw someone say that BP slept with YG so he could pay for their awards, like- come on now 🤦♀️
@@Velvet62211 every time there’re the most stream on Spotify people say they slept with jermey or thanks jermey
@@Velvet62211 what’s funny is they blackpink “flopped” but they still winning awards and doing numbers
I tried my best to get tickets but it was sold out in minutes... But whenever I ask someone who attended the concert they say I won't regret as it's the best decision I have ever made . Girls were powerful, fun and enjoyable. Their rap , sing were louder than the back track.
tbh as someone who went to the tour I thought they did great but I think everyone is entitled to their own opinion
thank you for making this vid. I've seen many hateful comments calling BP overconfident, or lazy, or saying that their popularity is getting to their heads. I never watch the girls live, but I did see their full concerts on RUclips and I never see that. These ppl just love to hate girls without proper context and its very frustrating as a blink. And whenever I tried to stand up for the girls, they always say I have low standards, blind or something like that (pretty ironic). I bet their Coachella performance is gonna be dragged harder than their bornpink tour no matter outstanding the show is.
I went to Berlin show and I had time of my life, one of my favorite memories. The girls sounded great, the band was so good, the dancers ate, the crowd was hype. These kind of mistakes could be posted about every tour, every group but BP as the biggest gg will always be given impossible standards to match.
I was at concert and my personal opinion that they are good . And Jennie is really dominant performer
I got so hyped just from watching the live stream. I can't even imagine how high on endorphins the people ACTUALLY ATTENDING were. I was screaming the entire time. My mom yelled at me to shut up. It was the best.
I appreciate your video and your perspective on the tour. I also do believe that it’s not all hate and some of it is constructive criticism while the rest is just downright rude. I do still believe that this tour and especially how long and abruptly it started was not the best move. Considering the fact it’s been 2 years since they performed together and even a little over 2 years since they performed together infront of a live audience and it shows. But it’s not the girls fault. I blame YGE more than I do the girls bc the fact that they’re being used just for their brand and fanbase and not in a good way. And it’s bc of that they get a lot of hate and labeled as influencers who can sing. YGE doesn’t care ab the fact they actually put years into this and this is dream. They’re just following where the money is which absolutely sucks for the girls bc I do believe they’re starting to lose their passion for music (at YGE at least) bc of the decisions being made. I wish them the best though
SN: Does Jennie’s black jacket say B*tch on the back of it??.. I want to buy it now lol
Saw them in Chicago with my bestie and I will keep saying that THEY KILLED IT!! The concert was SO hype, the dancing was excellent, the live singing was really good especially considering the choreo, and all four girls' stage presence was incredible. To top it off there were some lovely moments of connection with the crowd and with each other that let their personalities shine. I was glued to the concert the whole time and there weren't any mistakes that people had been complaining about, and while I'm not an expert on k-pop I have experience performing on stage. I was VERY impressed with their abilities and energy, and also had so much fun my arm was destroyed from shaking my lightstick constantly!! Everything I could want from a Blackpink concert. I truly don't understand why bp haters get so much attention online because the girls do nothing to deserve it!
blackpink got hate in 2019 for being too in sync and they screw up once for their seoul concert (they even apologized the next day) but kpop fans made it seem as if their entire tour was like that and discredited their hard work. yg made a statement abt how the girlies were working hard to shoot shut down, prepare for inkigayo and prepare for tour. everything was rushed and pushed out last minute and its obvious mistakes were bound to happen. i just don't get why they got crucified and people made it seem as if they're ALWAYS like that. if that's the case i highly doubt blackpink would be where they are today.
If they sync, they won't have time to connect people. It cannot do both at the same time. Yes, in 2019 people complained because they seemed to ignore the fans when performing. And this year when they care about the fans who come to see them. People who don't go to concerts complain that they don't sync. lol
Saw them live and they where awesome
I'm glad!
Its so sad that these type of video don't get much views but those videos where it only shows Blackpink bad clips and only hating on them.
Hopefully the yt algorithm will do its thing with this one too! But a lot of the times negative 'controversial' messages get more attention
@@aintnootherfan you are right. People only see negative and love to watch it.
Blackpink isn't even in my top 5 fav girl groups, but the moment a friend shared one of the compilations of the "bad moments" of their tour I was like "good, they have many shows with a strong set list, they should manage their energy properly, expecting perfection from idols is dumb" and I stand by that. If they were to perform every single song with a lot of energy, they would probably faint in the middle of the concert, I want idols to be healthy and making sure they don't exhaust themselves is a crucial part of that.
*Just to clarify, I like them and I would consider myself a blink, they are just pretty low in my stan list lol
I am one yr late but thank you for this video! I have been a BLACKPINK and Jennie defender since they debuted. out of all the members, Jennie has gotten most hate. when they debuted she got hated for "trying to outshine" other members with her energy and SP, then when she mellowed down she got accused of "being lazy". compared to other girl groups, BLACKPINK is doing so well in performing live, stage presence, and all other whole package. I saw them live in Vegas, I admit the first section during intro they weren't really singing 100% live BUT the rest of the concert they sang almost mostly live and did amazing! seeing them live made me love them even more.
This was much needed
I honestly get the criticism about the Born Pink tour. For the prices that they are charging the tour is very underwhelming. There are no props on stage and to put it bluntly the members are just dancing like they were in a music show. I would even argue that there is more effort being put into music shows rather than into their concert stages. The pinks also lipsynced a lot during the concert and the background music was very loud compared to their low mics. Also their enegry was kinda mid and I hate to jump on that bandwagon but Jennie was really lackluster and often gave the impression like she wasnt really into it. What I really enjoyed tho was the engery of the crowd. It was epic! As a frequent concert attender all in all I have to say that Blackpink sadly is one of the weaker acts I watched and the crowd really is the most enjoyable thing about the experience. Maybe it was just like this at my show and others were better. I think its very apparent that the pinks sadly are very inconsitent when it comes to performances.
What show was yours?
@@deathgodtheking2651 first night Berlin
@@annimaus5890Oh,I wasn’t there but I thought they were great from what I’ve seen
@@deathgodtheking2651 Hmmm I personally don't think they were that great but that's just my opinion. I'm sure there are a lot of people who did enjoy their performance :3
@@annimaus5890 i just have to ask you this….when Lisa said everyone silences how quiet was it
As an ex-blink who unstanned after the tour, there are a some things I have to say :
1. The vocals were inarguably the best part of the tour. Especially in the current era of kpop where live vocals are exceptionally rare, it was truly satisfying to see "the biggest gg in the world" absolutely kill with their vocals. Rose was the obvious standout in this area.
2. I thought we as kpop stans had accepted the fact that Lisa isn't an impressive vocalist and is an average rapper. But she is an AMAZING dancer. Not only that, she actually shows improvement in her dancing capabilities and never have I seen that girl miss. So, it would make sense for her solo stage to be more dance focused than anything else, wouldn't it? Throughout the entirety of this year-long tour she has been consistent. And getting sick / having off days on tours are unavoidable. But she hasn't let any of it show in her performances. That's a true professional performer. And I hope ppl (by that I mean their own fandom's solo stans) will stop using her solo stage as an excuse to bring her down knowing that she was delivering vocals during group songs. And here's to hoping she gives herself music that is actually good now that she's on her own. fck them tiktok monstrosities.
3. Jisoo's cover of liar was 100x better than her actual solo performance(s). It sometimes makes me wonder if their mid music impacts their stage presence but getting back to the point: Jisoo seems stagnant to me. I'm not a professional by any means but jisoo dances and sings the exact same way she's been doing since the last tour. Her vocals are definitely better than her dance. Which is confusing to me because she had more than two years b/w tours to improve but okay.
4. I've been listening to what you have to say and take in any nuance you offer regarding each member. And while I do mostly agree with everything you have said up to this point, here is where i wholeheartedly disagree. Before I start, I wanna say that you can actually call someone out without degrading / dehumanising them and let's leave the partying out of this since it's not anyone's business but hers. Jennie has been given the benefit of the doubt countless times by fans including me. But if there's one thing i've noticed watching not just bp but also many other ggs and bgs, there's a stark difference between trying and not trying, and jennie is more often than not NOT TRYING. The woman looks bored on stage period. And the clip you inserted about her "happy face" basically implying that she has an rbf isn't an excuse since we do have the first tour to compare to where she genuinely looks happy to be there without an ear to ear smile (not to mention countless other idols with rbfs whose performance capabilities have never come into question due to having one). Having off days is fine. But as a performing artist who charges as much as Beyonce to come see you, the sheer number of off days you take at the expense of fans who pay hard earned money to see you (ppl even go into debt to see their faves at least once in their life, not to mention the expenses ppl pay to come watch a group from abroad since their country never falls on tour lists) brings to question not only your professionalism but also your morality. Every single fan in every single country deserves to see jennie perform with the same energy she gives at coachella or at her own concert in la at any day. I'm obviously not talking about the times she was genuinely sick. EVEN THEN I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. Until that podcast with dua lipa.... The only thing I'm gonna say is that she came off as highly hypocritical and untruthful. It seemed like a bad excuse for something she knew she did wrong but didn't have the guts to admit or at the very least say she'll try to do better. It made me lose the little respect I had for her and I turned away from the group as a whole. As a person you are entitled to your opinion, but this is mine.
Ig it makes me frustrated since I've loved jennie and bp as my female ults from a very young age. I still do hold a soft spot for the group (for the other 3 members at the very least) which is why I clicked on this video. It's been a while and a lot has changed so I wanted to look at everything from a fresh mindset. The conclusion I reached was that this tour was a true mess, even looking back at it now. It was either the best or the worst which is pretty extreme.
I Really get your point, This blackpink tour is not as bad as people says, but really call my attention that your analysis to little mix last tour you were a lot more critical compare to this analysis and I think that's not fair. I like your yt channel because you're honest and critical, but in this case you justify so many things that you didn't in little mix video. In BP video you say they are not robot, they are human and makes mistakes but in little mix video you talk about they're making so much mistakes but never consider and talk about that two members gave birth 5 months before the tour. You used to talk about the positive and negative things in your analysis, but here I just see the positive side. The reality is that blackpink in this tour are so inconsistent, one day they have a lot of energy and the other day lack completely of it.
Unless you attended every single concert during their ongoing tour, you can't say they lack energy in every other performance. Judging the concert through 3 second clips doesn't make any sense. And this is from a 2/3 hour concert. If I were a hateful person, I could do the exact same thing to any performer.
And I wouldn't even be angry if THEY WERE inconsistent. Or any artist on tour. Blackpink has been touring since last year, and I think a lot of people forget just how much of a toll tours take on someone. My point is that we should have some grace for every artist. Whether it's Blackpink or anyone else.
Thank you for the comment!
This video is different than the strict review format of my Little Mix video. This video was made in response to mean-spirited, condescending, rude comments I've observed online, which wasn't the case for Little Mix.
Confetti Tour was an unfortunate case. Why even going on tour 5 months after giving birth if it allegedly puts health and safety of the members at risk and having them perform a similar show to those they had performed in the past?
The whole concept of the show was working against Perrie and Leigh-Anne; I'd pay money just for them to go on stage and sing their hearts out while sitting or standing still with some nostalgic footage in the background. I wouldn't say a word.
But instead we got questionable tacky outfits, poorly executed choreography, energetic chaos and quite a lot of lipsync.
I totally get your point and why you may feel like that; please know I'm still very much fond of Little Mix and I am looking forward to members' solo debuts!
@@aintnootherfan The lip-sync, poorly executed choreography and the lack of energy I see it in this black ink tour too but I understand your point that this is a different concept video and that’s why you didn’t mention it. Thank you for answered.
@@penguin_0172 I didn’t have to attend to every single concert I just watched the fans videos from different dates and I notice the inconsistency but overall I don’t think it’s a bad tour just that I noticed that this tour was put together so fast with not enough preparation and the girls are not mentally prepare to performance every night.
@@ronaldcastillo9646 he seems either biased or scared of the fans lol
Thank you for this. Everyone wants k-pop idols to be seen as humans and not robots except when it comes to Blackpink. They forget that even they can't do half of what Blackpink does.
I don’t know if they were brought to success thanks to their company but in the end they sing, if they become successful it’s not even their fault lol
If people buy their music you can’t really do anything about it xD
well you can't deny the fact that due to them coming from YG and 2en1 being their senior made them instantly popular even before debut, if blackpink where from a small company without an already well established name and fanbase they wouldn't be half successful as they're now, like look at gidle they're doing everything and are in my humble opinion better than blackpink yet they aren't half as popular because they come from a small company
@@NA22427 yeah I think that the company knows how to
@@NA22427 Cube it's not a "small company" they're more in the mid tier side, but agree with everything else.
@@NA22427Cube is a big company, compared to actual small companies. They've had popular groups before, they're just ULTRA SHITTY when it comes to managing their groups. Gidle could've been bigger if it were not for Cube mistreating them and not capitalizing on opportunities. Big Hit has proven that if you manage your group well and market it cleverly, the size of your company don't matter. Look at Momoland, they were on a meteoric rise, but their shitty company couldn't handle it and f*cked up, so they had meteoric downfall. Everglow was getting popular along with Gidle, but now I don't hear from any of them from their company.
@@NA22427 Hate to burst your bubble, but this is showbiz. As a public figure, the type of company you're associated with DOES matter (in a way). While you could argue that K-pop acts like (G)I-DLE have better chances of showcasing/utilizing their talents, that still doesn't change the fact that companies like Cube Ent generally suck at promoting and capitalizing on their popular artists (judging by their history)! Just like Pledis/SVT (especially before the HYBE acquisition), Cube is lucky to have (G)I-DLE on their roster.
I saw them live in 2019 and with just a handful of songs they pulled of a brilliant tour and also debut at Coachella. I seen them again in London for the two nights they were here and they were phenomenal. I don't know why people are lying other than they can say and do what ever on line and get away with it. I have booked tickets for Coachella and Hyde park this year.
Haters are going to hate and nothing will stop them.
Of course they owe their fans a lot . They would not be where they were if not for fans. It the fans who watch their songs , stream them , buy their merch put up with hate for them the least they can do is give their best . No one is asking for a super performance but at least show that you trying. Without a fanbase they would be now where . So pipo criticism is not to put them down but to wake them up cause kpop is competitive. It like a parent correcting a kid. Fans are not pipo to treat like garbage, they are pipo to be grateful for
Is it just me or do we all just want Jisoo's solo album to have a Latin influence? Her voice goes so well with the Latin sound. As a Latino, she made me proud by singing that song. Even if it is all in English, it fit well with her voice.
People would drag her for “making fun of culture”
0:47 Wow, you won't even say 2ne1......
FINALLY ,THANK YOU .A reasonable human being. 5% of the comments I see online is pure criticism/feedback , while the other 95% try so had to bring them down. Spreading lies as "they are not doing their jobs!!!" and suddenly feeling sooo sorry
What’s even funnier is that they still use the same 5 second clip just to prove a point. I mean out of all the cities they been too haters still use their performance in Korea to shit on them
@@deathgodtheking2651 even the concert in Korea wasn't even half as bad as they make it to be. When knetz that kpoopies claim to be the most toxic people on earth are not complaining about the concert, why tf are their butts burning lol
Heavy on the last sentence!!!
I saw them live in November of 2022 in Atlanta, and at Coachella- and they were AMAZING! 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
I think K pop standards are so intense, it boggles my mind that people post a few seconds or even a minute of a mistake when the concerts are two hours. Its not a special stage, or a performance of couple of songs, its multiple shows in a week sometimes, of course there will be errors to some level. I saw them in Vegas and had an amazing time, they were so fun and charismatic, and they sounded great, even though it was one of their last shows.
With BP it's very strange cause they seem to improve but not as fast as some other groups and people are expecting a lot more since they debuted in 2016. I'm not a stan myself but I have to say that if some groups that have been in the industry for less than them have improved much more than BP then what's the problem? I don't think people want them to be perfect (it'd be stupid anyway) but the more time flies the more demanding people will become with them. However, I must say people are not easy with these poor girls and I'm not even going to talk about insane threats and insults they received. May God help them!
You know, it's not even their fault. They have to basically restart every single comeback. Like imagine not doing something for like 2 years and people expect you to be the best on your first day back.. and I think the reason rosé and Lisa have did so good in the born pink tour is because they had their solos.
Guys,The girls just want to see and invited the fellow blinks,share some moment with them,have fun,dance and sing together. Just it.
Not promising thats concert will be a perfect perform,but they're promise it will be one of best memories u can keep in your life, in positive way or negative way. Its up to you.
all of the mistakes highlighted made me think've they were doing a terrible job, and they seemed to be kinda messy actually in the beginning of the tour from the clips used - I'm from Brazil, so not a chance I'd go see them live.
but they improved their show, Rose is giving good vocals also. they apparently lip sometimes, but the live instances aren't credited because people hate Blackpink, I'm not even a fan of them. but the criticism is too much. I'm ashamed, but I did believe most criticism that, even if it happened, those videos made people think the whole tour was Jennie falling and other mistakes.
They seem good to me. They are just having fun. I wish I could have joined a girl group in high school or college. It is about self expression, fun, dancing, and letting the people on stage " Wow" you. Overall, they have fun, stage presence, that is strong, their choregraphy is good, through they use playback a lot. Lip syncing is minimal. It seems like a " fun" show. 15 or 16 year old me would have had their albums and gone instead of the Spice Girls.
Honestly, i don't have a problem with constructive criticism, but i feel like most of it is just blatant hate with blackpink. Like, saying they lipsync is crazy to me, it's so obvious that they sing live every single concert. Also, one of the things that infuriated me the most is the hate Jennie got for losing her balance. What the fuck was that? I don't even consider that a mistake, she just.. lost her balance, it's not like she messed up the move or forgot it or something. Same thing with Jisoo's situation when singing Shut Down. My girl sounded so good the whole time and people had an issue with the last line she sung and it wasn't even that bad. Kpop stans are not used to live vocals and it shows. They just try to find reasons to hate on them. It saddens me to see that they don't see BP as people, but as the punching bag of kpop.
The main reason why BP is getting criticised is due to blinks being hypocrites themselves, kpop stans being ignorant on complex issues, an inability to separate their bias from their 'criticism', and their unwillingness to try experience new things.
That said, Bp has just one great performer the rest are in different stages of mediocre. But blinks are too delusional and xenophobic to give the girl her flowers.
Its ironic that most of the people who lash out at lisa's stage were blinks, blinks who wanted to even the playing field on the hate the other members got.
Lisa's stage reminds me of Beyonce's single ladies amongst other great performers and it was executed flawlessly. But blinks rather disparaged it in other to reduce the hate the other members are getting.
Y'all really need to know what lip sync is atp
?? Don't get me wrong but you just sound like an akgae (which means toxic solo stan.) And yeah right, it's always those stupid, stupid Blinks being delulu and....xenophobic towards Lisa? Where did that come from? Well alright.
First of all who goes to concert and tries to nitpick "oh she's one beat late" "oh she lipsync that part" "oh her choreo is wrong" Like bruh!! It aint a competition show hahaha IT'S A CONCERT!!!
The BP enjoys the show same as fans. You go there like party with them. They go there to enjoy a party with you. IT SHOULD BE LIKE THAT! YES they are inconsistent as a fan I see it but that doesn't mean I didn't enjoy the show.
This is exactly the video we needed. It is an excellent video! Thank you for this much needed video!
omg thank you!
They are the best for me, even my wife who wasn't a fan of them but after we watch their show in chicago day 1 concert she became a fan. Even if they made few mistakes on other shows I'm still here for them and also their personalities are another thing that draws me in to stan them. Btw I'm 47 years old guy and been a blink since 2019.
It’s such a drain on the Blink experience to constantly defend BP and try to prove their already undeniable talent to people who purposefully ignore and twist the truth to encourage others to jump on the hate train, and who shame them for massive global achievements they’d die for their own faves to achieve. It’s like they don’t understand that BP reaching these heights is paving the way for other kpop artists to follow, not taking away from anyone. They’ll only ever acknowledge a member’s skills so they can trash talk the other members or Blinks themselves for neglecting the member they claim to like (which isn’t even happening). And while other groups have gone from hated to loved over time, for BP it’s the opposite: the more success they experience, the more hate they receive. It’s almost impossible to find a comment section under any Blackpink video that isn’t full of vitriol (maybe except their MVs), even when the video itself is praising the group. Just look around here
Though there have been some videos going around that have left some people questioning if the members have enough time to practice together for the tour, they tend to be few and far between. And with a K-Pop girl group as popular as BLACKPINK, it isn’t surprising to see them getting unfairly hated on just for being successful
if any other group did a little twerk or tripped on stage nobody would bat an eye, people would even call it cute, but with blackpink it’s completely different
I feel like Kpop stans, especially those of 4th gen forget how live vocals sound (and also dancing while singing live) due to the massive amount of lip-synced/pre recorded "live" stages and super hard choreographies which are never meant to be performed while singing live
Plus, they don't let Jennie eat as much as she likely needs to. 😣
Hello, at first I thought I was going to have to educate you.... Thank You. I, have in my life, have worked with the music and live performance industry. I have seen more concerts than I can remember. Well, maybe I should say attended more concerts, because when working in the back, you don't get to see, but still hear and know how things work. BlackPink, is one of the best, most chaotic, concert series I have ever seen. It reminds me of David Bowie. He would put everything he could into his show because his fans paid good money to be entertained. BP is very entertaining.
Things people do not know. They run over two miles for each performance. Once they leave the stage, it is RUN to get to your next spot. If they are stage front, they are running stooped over under the stage to get in place for their cue. They run from the stage to the back to do their change outs. They only have the three to five minutes to do it and most of the time it is getting changed and people fussing over them just to run back so they are on their mark when the light go back on. Thankfully they have showed some of this on the BPM videos. I have talked about the so called lip-syncing vs backing track. People need to learn the difference. Because no one can dance like Lisa and still sing in tune. It is impossible. So, she lets the backing track do the work while she is doing her dance breaks. Besides that, they are live mic, all the time. And yes, if you do not like BP, don't watch them. There is plenty of good music out there to enjoy.
As for their concerts suck. When a concert sucks, the artist will be reprimanded by their labels and concerts will be canceled due to "personal reasons, Health Issues or other reasons." This series, no matter the critics opinions, is adding even more shows, selling out places K-pop has never been before. K-pop should be thanking them for the exposure, but instead they are trying to tear them down. There is an industry reason for that. But this post is already getting long. BP does things at their concerts I had never seen before with their preshow and post show fan interactions. I'm used to get them to the stage and get them out fast. Not let them stop and talk to the fans. Now here is where most people will call me a die hard Blink... Nope, that's my wife. While my BP bias is Jisoo, my K-pop bias is the one and only IU! And I was a hardcore Sulli Stan, ergo why I comment on so many of these videos. That kind of behavior needs to STOP!
I always mad to see something pop up in my recommendation for "unpopular shitty opinion about BP" Like dude the content creators are just straight rude and accused bp outta nowhere from just a second clip of videos and not even the whole concert. The fact that they always pin point the bad one clip for five minutes is ridiculous when their concert is 2 hours straight. Even the comments section... Gosh my my head dizzy and full of negativity 😵 like woah a lot of haters or so called fake blinks trying so hard to downgrade the girls. It's so contradict when most people who are attended their concert said was great and the girls know how to hype up the crowds but the hate is just rubbish lol.
Sometimes I feel that they are a little inconsistent but they have so much fun during their performances, they sing well (they're not the greatest vocalist in the world, but their vocals are pretty consistet most of the times) and make mistakes in a choreography and in songs as well it's normal because they're human. Being a BLACKPINK hater is a trend i believe, because you may not like them but the hate these girls receives is out of this world. Guys if you don't like them it's okay, don't listen their music.
blackpink never claimed to be the best at singing, dancing, or even rapping. the love for the girls and their fun music is what keeps them so popular. people who love them and their music will enjoy their concerts regardless of any mistakes
As if K-pop standards couldn't be more ridiculously high. 🙄 Seriously, we need to cut these celebs some slack and let them be human from time to time.
I ABSOLUTELY love your point of view and absolutely agree with your whole video. I am a blink since 2019 and I realized all the things you pointed and commented about during the video.
I can't believe this is the same person who did a review of little mix last tour 💀
This video is different than the strict review format of my Little Mix video. This video was made in response to mean-spirited, condescending, rude comments I've observed online, which wasn't the case for Little Mix.
Confetti Tour was an unfortunate case. Why even go on tour 5 months after giving birth if it allegedly puts health and safety of the members at risk and having them perform a similar show to those they had performed in the past?
The whole concept of the show was working against Perrie and Leigh-Anne; I'd pay money just for them to go on stage and sing their hearts out while sitting or standing still with some nostalgic footage in the background. I wouldn't say a word.
But instead we got questionable tacky outfits, poorly executed choreography, energetic chaos and quite a lot of lipsync.
I totally get your point and why you may feel like that; please know I'm still very much fond of Little Mix and I am looking forward to members' solo debuts!
@@aintnootherfan BLACKPINK making more mistakes despite them being on a hiatus have time to practice giving us nothing the backtrack is louder than their vocals but you still find excuses for them meanwhile those women despite giving birth still trying hard to give a show and all you did is dragging them to hell I'm not even surprised how you always biased when it comes to Blackpink I'm not trying to say that Blackpink deserve hate but atleast you should try to be fair
@@euphoria7019 loud backtrack? in comparison to most kpop groups blackpinks backtrack is quite. they made one mistake in their seoul concert and weirdos took it and made it seem as if the entire tour was like that. their comeback and tour were rushed and it was pretty obvious they didn't have much time to smoothen it out hence is why their first concerts the only one consisting of mistakes. you make excuses for little mix and want them to be humanized whilst neglecting to take into account blackpinks situation. both groups don't deserve lashings but it happens.
@@-xxx9170 this is about BLACKPINK and little mix you can't read? and i can't even believe that you're comparing women who just gave birth to 2 years hiatus group especially Jennie who didn't have and performances or solo release 💀
@@euphoria7019 where did i compare little mix giving birth to blackpink? are you having comprehension issues? i simply said you can humanize your girlies without belittling blackpink in the process. i even said both groups don't deserve lashings yet you took it as an attack. weirdo
I'll be seeing them at Hyde Park and I can't bloody wait!
When I studied abroad in Korea, I went to the Seoul concert day 2, and I can understand where some of the criticism videos came from. I personally think YG rushed the tour, especially after all the promotions for shows they made the girls do. It felt like they were both over whelmed to perform in front of such large crowds again after so long from Covid and exhausted from born pink promotions that led to more inconsistencies in the earlier parts of the tour. As someone who was also blessed enough to be at Coachella weekend 1 in 2019, I can't say the born pink concert was better; but it wasn't anywhere near as much of a shit show as the criticism videos make it seem. I very much enjoyed my time even though some mistakes were obvious or parts were lacking, and if I could go back I would do it again. As the tour has gone on, the girls do seem to be getting much more comfortable and happy on stage which is always great to see!
The only thing I genuinely disliked is YG's management of it; of all the K-pop concerts I attended during my time abroad, blackpink's was both the most expensive (sat in the upper section) and the shortest. I wish they performed all of the songs from the album or didn't cut some of them short (it's a sin we don't have a single live "The Happiest Girl" performance yet). I also wished Jennie performed a mix of "Solo" and her new song to match Rose and Lisa and hope Jisoo will perform a mix of her solos once they're released! Along with that, the way they handled the merchandise line was horrible, I waited in line for an hour before the concert but still had to leave early just to make the concert on time and of course they were sold out of almost everything after the concert, still got a cute hat tho : )
After the disbandment of 2NE1 and the prolonged hiatus of BigBang, YG fans were left craving for content. The release of a couple of their songs, combined with allegations of YG using phone farms to boost their songs on RUclips, prompted RUclips itself to release a statement acknowledging that their MVs may have been artificially inflated with paid views. Despite the controversy, these tactics contributed to their sustained popularity. This was one of the reasons for their big boom.
i cant see any other reason for them to be that popular. they are just RUclips famous.
Yesssss 👏🏽
Love ❤️ this video ‼️
Excellent Job as always Monsieur 💯🪄
Thank you!!
thank you so much for this video and defending the girls (with proof!)
Thanks for making this. It was hidden by the way not on my front page so it might be suppressed. Anyway I went to the LA show and it was incredible. All the hate about the your is cap
I remember watching some video criticizing Bacpink on tour and then I saw Mamamoo performance when they got silly and I instantly though if this was Blackping they would get so much hate. I definitely think thre's a double standard. For some reason people want Blackpink girls to be perfect all the time. For me it's artificial, concert is not a music video. I rather see some mistakes and goofines on stage.
great video as per usual 💓💓💓
ps : still waiting for you to get into sunmi, i hope i’ll be able to see her on your channel 😊
In my opinion, Blackpink set the tone of the tour with their first concert.
This was practically the "death senteces" for the tour and it will haunt the group.
After the concert, there were already many rumors on the Internet about it. From they don't want to play anymore to YG didn't give them time to prepare.
And that has also certainly unsettled a few fans. I've read several times that many were unsure whether it will be good, because one has heard a lot of negative things and Videos and whatever narrative was put out.
And then the ticket prices also play a point. They are not exactly cheap and there was certainly one or the other the idea that Blackpink is not interested in the fans and only wants money. And of course, the haters have settled there like leeches, no question, is simply attack surface.
It's like any other performance, if the open show is bad, the rest will not be well received. And Blackpinks is not an exception from it.
And yes the girls have apologized and that was also right of them. They stand by the fact that it did not go well and not everyone does that.
But YG should have looked at it,
these mistakes could have been avoided or at least not be visible to the normal viewer.
It's not the first time they've done this. There should work like professionals who know how to plan and support such things.
Unfortunately, I have to disagree with you on this one. I went to the Vegas concert in Aug, which cost me money for the flight, hotel, and the concert ticket. Rose was the only one that tried to interact with the audience in the first half of the concert. Jennie had several really obvious mistakes and always had a face showing “I don’t want to be here”. Jisoo did great in her solo. The concert was filled with extremely loud video because their lack of live singing, and around 20-30 min was the interaction with the VIP audience because they didn’t have enough songs produced.
I also went to Beyoncé concert this summer and had a completely different experience 😂
Although idols aren’t really artists, and they have a shorter career, BP and YG should deliver more in order to make them match their hype. Many 3 and 4 gen groups are amazing but they earn way less money because they don’t have all the corporate resources.
I disagree with personal attacks or bad languages but for audience who pay money out of their own pocket, they have a word to say.
All of bp fans who went to concert actually enjoyed the show ( myself included)
I have went to many other kpop group concerts but bp and skz are the only groups that i have enjoyed.
They are so energetic and seeing them happily dancing, singing makes me feel like I m dancing with them on stage.
Idk which concert u went, but in the concert where I went none of them Lypsynced. All of them sang live and that too with decent technique.
I love these girls and haters are just blind and deaf atp.
i have zero issues with them and their tour i actually like them as people very much but i've noticed maybe i just dont like their singing voices that much 🤔
wow that was such an interesting video... thank you
as a ex blink 1 i dont agree with it first you said the bad clips are from first few tour but if they practice rather than photoshoot they never gotten this hate and dont give me yg to blame yes yg dont give them comeback but they can still practice on their own like in 2 years yes 3 of them doing solo project but like other groups can balance what they do it why cant they
And now they are much better. compared to the first stage Bro, no matter how much you practice, when you're practicing there isn't a full stadium watching you.that they disappeared for 2 years Just let them adjust. and you look at the paris fair They're back the way they were.
The criticism I saw did not say THEY were lazy. But that their PERFORMANCES were.
It is dude, some kpop folks still brought up that old scandal lol
Some people hated the tour because they were sold out unlike their favs' tours.
so much to be said, but will leave it short (ish)...
Great video totally agree on most parts and well formulated (thats the wrong word my tired mind tells me, but well explained... English is a 2nd language)... anyways
I did see them live and it was amazingly raw, a pure expression of art, yes it was at times (very few) flawed, but always very real, you got a real sense of who they were as individuals, so will explain that as it is also the flaws kinda.
Jennie: her passion on individual lines sell them so well, hard to explain but it felt like someone receiving a breakthrough in therapy but live in front of thousands cheering for it, I walked away with the thought that she was meant to be on stage, letting her healing be shared to us.
Jisoo: hard to explain, but at the concert I was sometimes playing the fun game "finding Jisoo (I missed some cute moments with other members because of it) Jisoo seemed of somewhere else than the rest on stage having fun interacting, so the members were doing choreo on the front platform of the catwalk, Jisoo was at main side stage doing poses and singing to individual fans that caught her eye, she seemed to have the most FUN on stage and it was infectious to watch her.
Lisa: she was born to be in the performance center, she captivated to the point that even at a distance you could clearly see her expressions while she did insanely pretty (but kinda shouldn't be pretty... if I or anyone else tried) dance moves or flourishes (where they let down the mic to do a thing and let the backtrack take over, we call it a flourish in the industry, or flourish tracking for the type of backtrack used, because it is very clear to hear when it kicks in, and it means that you should pay extra attention), she was amazing to watch.
Rosé: she is a mindbogglingly talented vocalist.... just that... would be enough... but she adds such flair and talent to her performance that it leaves you wanting more...
all in all my main grief was me having only two eyes, because wherever I found enjoinment I missed out somewhere else.... but think that is on me, they are hated on for being to damn good... and that is it.... can they be better?.. probably and surely they will, because they put in a lot of effort to become better.. are they peaking?.. nope.... have they peaked the industry?.. yes, but they will take it further and lift the industry with them
FINALLY!👍👌👍👌👍
The people who spend their entire existence trying to deny Blackpink's talent, success and popularity, are not fans of BLACKPINK! They are trolls, very stupid ones too! They hid behind their fake social media names and Avatars, hurling insults at people/groups like Blackpink because it's all they can do to make them feel better about themselves! I've been following Blackpink since they debuted and literally watched them grow from amazingly talented young girls to mature, amazingly talented young Women! Over the last 7 years, they have only gotten better & more confident! They are now genuine roll models for all the up and coming Kpop girl groups.
They are awesome singers in good human being
Well I was thinking that they're just bored to perform in front of their own people cause they killed it in overseas. This issue only emerged after their performance in Korea. Well to be fair Lisa's a Thai. Rose is an Australian. Only Jennie and Jisoo were Korean. But Jennie doesn't seem interested to be in Korea anymore. Am I wrong?
i feel like she's not interested to be a Korean idol anymore and is leaning more to be part of Hollywood
@@NA22427lmao she told you so
@@baffah3991 i said feel for a reason, learn to read!!
@@NA22427 u learn to spread love instead of hate.
Finally,someone said this!! Thank you,thank you so much💗💗💗💗🖤
Well, they certainly are not Milli Vanilli if you know what I mean. And they are making $3 million per show I have no complaints. They deserve their rewards for working hard. Will they stick around after Born Pink? Who knows.
i understand that alot of the "criticism" is not genuine and is most definitely harmful to society overall. but i actually think most of it is pretty fair. because there's just so many issues with this group, with the girls and with the company. blackpink themselves are the toxic space that further feeds on toxicity coming in.
people are loud about them even though they don't like them because it's interesting and it's frustrating. it's not just the inconsistencies, the weird personas and unprofessional actions or the shady tactics. as a group blackpink are extremely mediocre. people always call out mediocrity.
i know it looks like people pick at everything but that's often just the consequences of someone not being good enough at anything. like blackpink don't give enough of a good performance to have watchers be fine with lipping but they also don't sing well enough consistently for their to not be any reasons not to critiscise and dislike live concerts and stages.
in comparison to everyone around them..... they just stick out like a swollen, pussy thumb. people expect the best of the best if you're that praised and successful. especially if you're from a minority group that's impact is currently a huge topic.
alsoooooo the racism and ignorance!!!!! both their company and the girls are horrible. and honestly come across as airheads. it's creepy and yet another reason to not like or fall for the hollow brand that is blackpink. there's just so much surrounding them and it can't all be blamed on yge. blackpink aren't dolls. they're grown women who've made these choices just as much as their label and staff. they wouldn't get this much flack if fans and non fans could see that the girls cared but were being held back. in fact that's been an excuse for years. it just doesn't work because it's not true. well it might be in some ways and mostly just for lisa since she's the only performer with that kind of energy and that's why she's the most liked. people see that she has some kind of passion.
i have to say jennie and rose have disappointed me so much. they were so exciting to me but they're just so boring. they're not artists.
jisoo is either just boring enough or too boring. but she has some good moments here and there. it's far too obvious that she isn't into music and also just how far behind she is skill wise and talent wise. i did used to praise her for working hard to keep up but it's not enough anymore. her improvements are so slow and sloppy.
blackpink is a decade of training that apparently doesn't exist.
It's seems like you have a deep personal problem to them lol, I mean I can't judge people by the video only because we never know them personally behind the scenes. But so far from what I see them in social media and the video from fans ask them to take a sign, I think they are pretty good and chill and doesn't have that "star syndrome" Aura, they seem to know how to put themselves without being fake.
@@Dina-zb2cvpeople expect blackpink to be like other groups which there not every group has different styles of music I don’t know why people want them to be like others
@@deathgodtheking2651 because blackpink is a "k-pop" Star not a global girl group from America or Europe. So people will expect them to maintain that "saint and innocent child like" Persona like typical kpop idol. So when you see blackpink having fun with the western artist or going to the party/club with them it feels like out of the box and people will think they're a being a bad girl and will tarnish their reputation when in fact they just being socialized as a normal human being.
@@Dina-zb2cv people always say act your age but when blackpink does it’s a problem like I don’t know why people want them to be girly girly or cutesy
@@deathgodtheking2651 maybe because of their face? I know they are a mature woman in their mid 20's but because they have such a young pretty feminine face people will expect them to act cute lol.
Yo las vi en Barcelona y aluciné, el tour es altamente profesional, ellas estuvieron espectaculares, mantuvieron la energía en todo momento, hubo buena cohesión entre los fans y ellas, la presencia escénica, el carisma y sus voces on top como siempre
dont feel too bad for BP cause they love their haters more than their fans
Why do you think that? (Genuine question)
Only a narcissist would object to constructive criticism. And, people who view a product or service, such as a pop music group, have a right to criticize the content.
Constructive criticism offers feedback and is given by people with an understanding in that field. No kpop fan has achieved that level to call their criticism constructive especially when they are both ignorant and lack basic etiquette
@@ariastarn1289 Pretty ironic when you come off as a “solo stan” (despite SOME valid points). I would’ve been totally on board with you IF it weren’t for the “akgae” crap. Even your so-called “compliments” are fairly backhanded. 👈🙃
(This is coming from someone who biases nearly ALL the BLACKPINK members, including Lisa.)
Boy i love your channel a Lot but You sugarcoat BP in your channel
The girls are clearly not Bad but you're way more critical with other groups (femenine or masculine)
Yep. Hes overly biased, another white knight trying to shield them
When you pay a fortune for a pathetic show, you shouldn't expect a wave of praise
the first keyword that shows up when i google born pink tour is "mess" just how many haters do they have online that even the korean media had to respond
I was in their Concert and it was AMAZING
Ok, let’s make something clear they aren’t close to be the best performers and sometimes they can be really bad ( I think the only one who is consistent is Lisa) but they don’t deserve the hate they receive, whoever I want to point out that the amount of criticism they receive is also due to the overhype their fans have created, as I said they are regular performers, but you always can see they fans acting like they are the best thing in the world ( rose being the vocalist, Lisa being the best dancer) things that are clearly not true so people expect a lot to them just to see them being meh
People have to understand that this is life, not heaven or so-called ideal world we all want to see because we don't always get what we want. I understand that the biggest weakness of Blackpink is inconsistency but apart of that, they slay at a lot of moments which already entertain us a lot and give us a lot of interactions with in concert based on what i see from some fans who are watching Born Pink. They are not perfect, but I still enjoy them. They've been in such a hell of busy schedules and it took a toll of them mentally and physically which I understood, and in that phase, I really can't ask or demand too much from them.
Literally! Even as a longtime geek (music or otherwise), I've always found stan culture pretty absurd. The more you engage with a piece of media, the bigger the entitlement (and it shows). Even within the K-pop sphere, certain fans be bitter/salty when their fave artists succeed and promote internationally. It's like saying you don't want Beyoncé and Michael Jackson to do the same (despite their MASSIVE global influences).
It's that hennie and jisso forgot the choreo like 4 or 4 times they have like 13 Ichoreos that's it groups like twice have 50 choreos and regular comebacks taking so many breaks and u still didn't improve and forget the choreo like wtf it's clear for jisso and jennie the passion is not there and they r influencers having 36 songs in 7 years is crazy like what the he'll they r influencers now
Well Jisoo and Jennie are not in twice are they? This kind of mentality is weird. Because you'd be the same person that would cry wolf if your parents compared your weakness to the strengths of some other random person
@@ariastarn1289 wow u want to play that game u imagine taking 2 years of u r jobbb to develop skills and coming back worse barley any improvement it's not that hard and they r performing only like 8 particular song if u can remember that then the passion I gone and can't vlame it on the gotta blame it on yg not giving them good music and regular comebacks cause clearly during their debut era and the album was actually really impressive
@@Justbechill1548 you know what, I actually agree with you. Before I thought it was a case of nerves,but they are not improving, they are regressing. I can't defend them anymore.
@@ariastarn1289 exactly cause blinks r constantly defending them they don't improve if u let them gey hate they will actually do good cause rosè and jennie r also me of the best performers I have ever seen but they r so inconsistent like rosè was the only member I could look at during Coachella and the album and jennie during aylt d4 and album they have talent
Lisa is the only one putting in effort the others might be better talen wise but she worked harder than them and it shows if jennie and rosè put effort in the could be one of the best in kpop
Jisoo was pretty gud@@Justbechill1548
You expect authentic music from a big successful group. Not to copy from other songs.
😢 17:23 maybe jennie could perform if she didn't party too much in the us
Outrageous weird sarcastic and heavily shamefull
#apologizetojennie
Jisoo was the best in the to7r
Haters, they will criticize things that they have no capacity of even attempting to do 🤷🏼♀️
bts is the most hated group by the general public, but blackpink is the most hated group by the whole kpop community.
Yep; that's the trajectory of being some of the world's most popular acts. (I'm saying this as someone who ults BLACKPINK and BTS.)
Thank youuuu
the hypocrisy kpop fans serve when it comes to bp is so insane.
Bp is an internationally acclaimed group, that doesn’t mean they have to be the best in all the categories, they don’t own anyone an explanation as to why they are famous, subjecting them to hate is not even a new development they have been a target by everyone in K-pop since 2018.
The most recent addition to their bandwagon hate train is the slut shaming, it really is so painful to watch, think about millions of people name calling you on internet, objectifying you, and yet you still have to go on the stage in front of the very same people and do the same show you got ridiculed for, who would be happy who wouldn’t be depressed.
I blame YG for such poor management of Blackpink they really should not resign with them.
this channel is so heavily biased...