"A Elbereth Gilthoniel," when he calls on Varda to guard him in the face of horror. As the Valaquenta says, "Varda hears more clearly than all other ears the sound of voices that cry from east to west, from the hills and the valleys, and from the dark places that Melkor has made upon Earth."
It’s only a tiny mention, but the Gaffer said in the pub that Bilbo taught Sam to read and I enjoy that every time I read it. I like the mental image of Bilbo patiently and kindly watching Sam practice his letters in a sunny room in Bag End.
Sam is the true hero along side Frodo. I love how you pointed out that he is a metaphor for all our lives and how that simple goodness can bring about great influence for good. “ we are all part of a great story…”
Could mention that Samwise, fastidiously and selflessly, took Galadriel's precious soil and placed one grain under every planting, rather than make his own garden better than all others. To my joy, that proved his heart was evermore grand and worthy of the love of Rosie and his fellow Hobbits.
@@gmansard641 he did?🤔 I don't remember that. He may very well have said it though. I loved how shy he was with Rosey though. It made for a wonderful moment when he returned and his confidence was through the roof.
Even overlooking that the "Sam is the real hero" view is often very dismissive of Frodo's more esoteric struggle with the Ring for an entire year (and that it was Frodo's pity for Gollum, pity that Sam did not share for most of their travels, which ultimately enabled the destruction of the Ring), I don't know if I'd say there _is_ one "real hero" of Lord of the Rings. The downfall of Sauron was brought about by fellowships, brotherhoods, and friendships between individuals and between kindreds alike. The Battle of Pelennor Fields was not won by Aragorn's arrival alone, but also the faithfulness of the Rohirrim to aid Gondor against all odds when they could easily have stayed home to lick their wounds; and furthermore, by Eowyn and Merry's shared courage and devotion to Theoden, which allowed them to deal death to the undying Captain of Mordor's forces. And only thanks to that victory were the remnants able to march towards battle unwinnable by strength of arms at the Black Gate, so that Frodo and Sam might pass to the mountain unhindered, a journey which also only succeeded because they were able to spur each other on when neither could have ever endured the trip alone. The conflict in Lord of the Rings is a conflict of Camaraderie against Dominance; of those who stand against impossible odds together, despite differing backgrounds and a few grudges from far-off times, against one who would make all things his own and sends others to fight for him by fear and threats. There is no one true hero, responsible in the end for the final triumph, but many heroes who (though perhaps in greater and lesser measures) brought victory by a vast web of mighty works.
Small correction: Sam was by the window at Bag End on purpose, not by accident. He, Merry, Pippin, and Fatty Bolger were all suspicious and worried about Frodo, and Sam was there specifically for the purpose of eavesdropping to get more info for the "Conspirators", as they called themselves.
Yes, I wish this video had included that bit. I think it speaks to Sam's protective feelings towards Frodo that he went along with it, even though he seemed so mortified by his involvement once the truth was out.
Tolkien himself said that Samwise is the true hero of LotR !!! In addition, HE said that the story doesn't really start until Sam was pulled through the window & doesn't end until Sam is home.
Tolkien called Samwise Gamgee "the chief hero" of The Lord of the Rings, going so far as to refer to the modest Hobbit as "far superior to" himself. Sam's grace, kindness, and undeniable heroism are ultimately responsible for the elimination of Sauron's presence from Middle-earth. But I didn't need Tolkien to confirm the most important character in the book and movies for me.
Unlike Peregrine and every other character in the books and movie besides Frodo, he doesnt experience one moment of comfort, being around friends, or, in your face hope, safety, and, love besides what Sam is able to provide for he and Frodo both after they leave the fellowship and commence their lonely journey. Everyone had important parts to play of that there is no doubt. Sam is the unflinching heart of the entire story and without him Middle Earth falls.
Yes Sam is the the true hero, where Frodo failed he stood fast. I read somwhere, cannot recall where, that J R R Tolkien modelled Sam after his batman in WW1. A batman was an officers servant soldier in the british army, who when thd officer retired/sent in his paper followed him as a trusted servan and sometimes friend as a valet, footman, bodyguard or butler.
Frodo did not fail. He lived with the terrible temptation and and the unspeakable mental and physical torture of living with the ring. No one else could have done it. All the Wise and the mighty knew that only Frodo could take the Ring to Mordor. He accepted the duty in spite of his fear and his overwhelming desire to stay in Rivendell with Bilbo. Sam was Frodo's heroic helper but he carried the Ring only briefly
Unpopular opinion: Sam was compelled by Gandalf at the beginning of the story to stay with frodo until the quest was completed. Not to disagree that Sam was a faithful and loyal companion but to explain how Gandalf's magic strengthened that loyalty to the degree he would do things like leave the shire, wade into a river knowing he couldn't swim, and stay with the fellowship knowing that the shire, his father, and his lady friend were in danger. None of this diminishes his bearing of the ring and wishing for clear skies and sunshine, breaking the magic darness of sauron and giving the rest of Gondir and the realm of men to make a stand.
@@cindyknudson2715 Um... I'm willing to debate but Gandalf is quite literally a god. Being from a higher plane of existence, has magic powers, falls and resurrects more powerful. There's an argument and then there's just denial.
No I do not agree that Sam is the true hero of the Lord of the Rings. For all the events that play out so many different characters played their part. As Gandalf said even Gollum had his role to play, that ended in the ultimate destruction of the Ring. So definitely too complex of a story for any one person to be the true hero.
Both Frodo and Sam of course are the heroes. It is hard to say who is more heroic or compare them. However, Sam has always been my favourite stays true to his values always stand for what’s right and protected Frodo when he was incapacitated or injured. Plus, Sam gets the girl at the end! :-) :)
When I read the book as a kid I thought Frodo, Aragon, Gandalf, Legolas and Gimli were all the biggest heroes. After reading the book as an adult it occurred to me that Sam was in fact the true hero. He cried a lot and was unsure of himself but he preserved out of loyalty and love when stronger men would have turned back.
Tolkien was known for bringing in comparisons of religion to his works. I believe that while Sam wasn't necessarily a Jesus type figure, he was a perfect example of the passage of greatest love and sacrifice. And staying true no matter the situation or temptation, very much like Job. He's a shining example in my opinion of what it means to do good for the world and ask little in return.
I agree that Sam is a hero and it is tough when in comparison to the others in the fellowship that he was the true hero but when one thinks on it I can see it. He saw and spoke on things comprehending them in their truist form with no ego to become problematic especially when later tempted by the ring. Sam's voice and support to frodo was a great blessing keeping the focus on hope and the good as frodo interiorly fought the ring. Sam did carry the ring and was able to give it back to frodo says something about his interior strength and his humility in "knowing his place" in the bigger picture. I liked that he became a good family man and leader and sharing his gift from galadriel with the shire lands. It made me laugh when the hobbits leaving bree with aragorn and the pony bill in tow (I forget the nasty characters name) was sticking his head over a hedge I believe making a stupid comment when Sam eating an apple threw the apple hitting the creep square in the head shutting him up as the group kept walking.
Yes! If I recall Gandalf put an enchantment on Bill to help him find his way home. He came back to the Prancing Pony, and Barliman took care of him until the Hobbits returned. Bill lived out his life in the Shire with Sam.
Perhaps i didnt understand it in that video but what does "the gaffer" actually mean? In german we call someone a "gaffer" who's starring at women or at an accident without helping. But it seems thats not the cade here right?
after watching the movies for the first time it always bothered me that Sam calls Frodo, Mr. Frodo. In the movie you get the feeling they are acquaintances since the drink together at the bar, and Sam is Bilbo's gardener. but by the end of the movie they are much closer companions than that and he still says Mr. Frodo while Merry and Pipin just call him Frodo But in the Books it makes it clear that they are all actually friends. It just so happens that Sam works for Bilbo, but they all spend a lot of time together and know eachother as friends, AND still Sam calls him Mr. Frodo. I dunno that just seems strange to me, none of my friends address me as "Mr." as if I am their employer. If I could change one thing it would be that
Calling Frodo Mr and Master was an acknowledgement that he respected Frodo, and that socially, Frodo was above him. Tolkien grew up in an England that was very class conscious, and his writing reflects that. I liken Frodo and Sam's relationship similar to the American South. Younger people are taught to call their elders Miss or Mr as a sign of respect. And after all, Frodo is around 20 or so years older than Sam.
I don’t believe Frodo would be alive to see Sam again. He was already 50 to start the journey. If same was the mayor 7 times for 7 years each that’s another 49 years. So Frodo would be well over 100 by time Sam got there. The undying lands do not mean immortality. Bilbo only lived to be around 115 at most. It seems very unlikely that Sam would see Frodo again.
@@ryanellis9325 yes I did forget the 17 years between bilbo leaving and Frodo leaving. I’ve watched a video by Tolkien untangled on here that discusses 10 misconceptions of middle earth where he discusses it much more intellectually then I can.
Sam Gamgee wasn't working under the window at Bag End when Gandalf was talking about the ring by chance!! He had been spying on Frodo as he was the chief investigator of the Hobbits Conspiracy!!
Hobbits have a longer lifespan than middle men, and commonly live to 100. The Appendices mention that Merry was "still hale" at 102 when he and Pippin left the Shire to visit Eomer and then travel to Gondor to live out the remaining years of their lives. Frodo would have been about 114 by the time Sam arrived in the West, which is certainly old even by Hobbit standards. However, he's living in a land free of disease, and assuming he's friends with Elrond, he has a world-class healer to help him reach his maximum lifespan. All this is to say, their time together would have been limited, but I think Sam and Frodo were reunited.
"If I could grow apples like these, I would call myself a gardener." Hey! And can I put forward that it is pronounced Gam-GEE, not Gam-Jee. Since the movies, the dmg has been done, but still.
I really wanted to watch the whole thing, but that drone is so annoying, I can't. I already know all this stuff, I thought this would be fun. Sorry I wasted time on this.
While great in the films, Sam's quality shone greater in the books. Never faltered in his loyalty to Frodo and possessed great resistance to the Rings corruption. When he was the ringbearer, The Ring being very potent now that it was near Mordor tried to seduce him of visions of power and glory and Sam was able to overcome it due to his humility and wanting a simple life as a gardner
Yes, there's the amazing moment at the Tower of Cirith Ungol that Sam just hands the ring back, no hesitation, no struggle. After Gandalf went on and on about how difficult it is to just relinquish any of the Rings.
I really liked the movies. Not so much The Hobbit, the dwarves looked foolish in the movies post LOR. AND all the movies as movies do bend the book version.
I love Sam, the choices of Master Samwise is one of my favourite chapters. I just hope that in their love for Sam people don’t under appreciate Frodo. Both were exceptional hobbits and there was a good reason Sam idolised Frodo!
They were both the hero of the journey; Sam could'nt have taken the ring his will was not strong enough but he had the strenght to carry Frodo ,and Frodo was in the end so exhausted by his wounds and the terrible power of malice of the ring that Sam was needed to help him. Frodo's task was not to destroy the ring but to bring it to Mount Doom where it could be destroyed. And he did this; Frodo was the brain and the heart and Sam was the legs and the heart.
I agree that Sam is one of the heroes. Like any team, each member of the Fellowship gave something. Sam is right up there at the top along with the other Hobbits.
Frodo could not have done his job without Sam, Frodo was lucky to have him as a friend. 😘🇦🇺 yes and the above quote of Sams was one of a hero. He had faith when all others lost it.
Great Choice for a Video Guy's.... spotlighting The " True Hero's" favorite Hobbit.... Bill the Pony Is The Hero behind the curtain per say.... He is after all held in the Highest Esteem by Shadowfax and The Mearas' ....without Bill's Steadfast Soul.... Samwise would Most definitely had a harder go of it... 🫏🐎🫏 !!!
I’ve always found the question of “who was the true hero of LOTR” to be a tautology. There is no single hero. To me, it has always been about the enduring spirit of humanity when faced against impossible evil (humanity being a multiracial term here). That said, Sam is tied with Aragorn for my favorite character and the line/scene where he carries Frodo near the end is one of the most poignant in all of cinema and in all of the legendarium.
Without Sam all would have been lost if the orcs of Cirith Ungol took Frodo's body and discovered the ring. Though I wonder how events would've played out if Merry or Aragorn went with instead.
Yes yes yes, Sam is the Hero of the story. Many times Frodo would have been lost or killed without Sam. And some battles Sam had to fight for Frodo, and what about when Sam carried Frodo up that last hill? Of course Samwise Gamgee is the Hero of the story. Without Sam there is no Frodo and no story.
I didn't come up with this but saw it posted on Facebook but I thought it was humorously appropriate. "Samwise had to travel to the other side of the known world and face the strongest and most powerful evil that world had in order to have enough courage to propose to a woman who already liked him.
I'll watch this video when I'm done at work, but I'm re-reading the books right now . . . and Sam is kind of a huge jerk. At one point, Tolkien says that Samwise is an optimistic hobbit by nature, but he really isn't. It *feels* like Smeagol possibly could've turned a new leaf, except for Sam constantly being mean to him. He really is quite rude! I feel more and more pity for Gollum this time around. He's allegedly a "bad guy," but he's been corrupted by an incredibly powerful supernatural artifact for his entire presence in the narrative. He deserves better than what he got.
Samwise "The Brave" Gamgee is, by far, my favorite character in LOTR, and yes he is the true hero of the story. His deeds after the LOTR tale, are almost as impressive as his deeds during the war. Replanting and regrowing The Shire, being elected The Mayor of Michel Delving seven times, marrying Rosie Cotton. raising thirteen children, and finally, going to The Undying Lands to reunite with Frodo, Bilbo and Gandalf. A good life.
A big deal was made of how Samwise mourned parting with Bill the pony, but no mention was made of how they were reunited on the journey back to the Shire. As to the final question, Samwise is clearly not the hero of LotR - it doesn't even have a single hero, really. Frodo and Aragorn are the two chief protagonists, but neither is the hero of the entire story. Samwise is my favourite character and he does embody everyman heroism, however, the bravery of ordinary men thrust into horrifying situations, such as Tolkien saw for himself on the battlefields of WWI - which as the author would be keen to point out, does not make him an allegory for anything, it's simply an observation on human nature...
In any real story there is always two that are heroes. There is the man who is destined to do something great and remarkable, and the loyal man who makes the first mans destiny possible to fulfill. Both Sam and Frodo are the hero, neither could've done anything without the other.
"There's Some Good In The World, Mr. Frodo. And It's Worth Fighting For."
What’s your favourite Samwise Gamgee quote??
"I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you!"
"Boil 'em, mash 'em, stick 'em in a stew"
"Please don't turn me into anything... unnatural"
"A Elbereth Gilthoniel," when he calls on Varda to guard him in the face of horror. As the Valaquenta says, "Varda hears more clearly than all other ears the sound of voices that cry from east to west, from the hills and the valleys, and from the dark places that Melkor has made upon Earth."
"Theirs some good in this world, Mr Frodo. And its worth fighting for."
It’s only a tiny mention, but the Gaffer said in the pub that Bilbo taught Sam to read and I enjoy that every time I read it. I like the mental image of Bilbo patiently and kindly watching Sam practice his letters in a sunny room in Bag End.
Sam is the true hero along side Frodo. I love how you pointed out that he is a metaphor for all our lives and how that simple goodness can bring about great influence for good. “ we are all part of a great story…”
I really feel that the fellowship are all the heroes. They were like a machine, all doing things necessary to the mission.
Could mention that Samwise, fastidiously and selflessly, took Galadriel's precious soil and placed one grain under every planting, rather than make his own garden better than all others. To my joy, that proved his heart was evermore grand and worthy of the love of Rosie and his fellow Hobbits.
They did.
One of my favorite moments, when Galadriel passes through the Shire and notes to him "I see that you used my gift well."
Sam can teach us all to enjoy the simplest things in life, like a garden. It's not much but it's peaceful and fullfilling.
@@jasonmaclean719 Yes, that moment in Mordor when Sam says how much he'd appreciate "half a mug" of beer.
@@gmansard641 he did?🤔 I don't remember that. He may very well have said it though. I loved how shy he was with Rosey though. It made for a wonderful moment when he returned and his confidence was through the roof.
Even overlooking that the "Sam is the real hero" view is often very dismissive of Frodo's more esoteric struggle with the Ring for an entire year (and that it was Frodo's pity for Gollum, pity that Sam did not share for most of their travels, which ultimately enabled the destruction of the Ring), I don't know if I'd say there _is_ one "real hero" of Lord of the Rings.
The downfall of Sauron was brought about by fellowships, brotherhoods, and friendships between individuals and between kindreds alike. The Battle of Pelennor Fields was not won by Aragorn's arrival alone, but also the faithfulness of the Rohirrim to aid Gondor against all odds when they could easily have stayed home to lick their wounds; and furthermore, by Eowyn and Merry's shared courage and devotion to Theoden, which allowed them to deal death to the undying Captain of Mordor's forces.
And only thanks to that victory were the remnants able to march towards battle unwinnable by strength of arms at the Black Gate, so that Frodo and Sam might pass to the mountain unhindered, a journey which also only succeeded because they were able to spur each other on when neither could have ever endured the trip alone.
The conflict in Lord of the Rings is a conflict of Camaraderie against Dominance; of those who stand against impossible odds together, despite differing backgrounds and a few grudges from far-off times, against one who would make all things his own and sends others to fight for him by fear and threats.
There is no one true hero, responsible in the end for the final triumph, but many heroes who (though perhaps in greater and lesser measures) brought victory by a vast web of mighty works.
Sam wasn't a hero. He was THE hero. When I need to be brave Sam's is the image that I hold in my head.
Actually Tolkien considered him as such. That's why the story ends when he says 'I'm back'.
Small correction: Sam was by the window at Bag End on purpose, not by accident. He, Merry, Pippin, and Fatty Bolger were all suspicious and worried about Frodo, and Sam was there specifically for the purpose of eavesdropping to get more info for the "Conspirators", as they called themselves.
Yes, I wish this video had included that bit. I think it speaks to Sam's protective feelings towards Frodo that he went along with it, even though he seemed so mortified by his involvement once the truth was out.
Sam is one of the true heroes as the destruction of the one ring would never happened without his dedication, courage, and bravery!!
The entire Fellowship were the heroes; none of them could've done it without each other.
Sam definitely came in clutch, though.
Tolkien himself said that Samwise is the true hero of LotR !!! In addition, HE said that the story doesn't really start until Sam was pulled through the window & doesn't end until Sam is home.
Peregrin Took... Forced the confrontation with the Balrog.
Convinced Treebeard to move against Saruman.
Summoned Rohan.
Saved Faramir.
Tolkien called Samwise Gamgee "the chief hero" of The Lord of the Rings, going so far as to refer to the modest Hobbit as "far superior to" himself. Sam's grace, kindness, and undeniable heroism are ultimately responsible for the elimination of Sauron's presence from Middle-earth. But I didn't need Tolkien to confirm the most important character in the book and movies for me.
Unlike Peregrine and every other character in the books and movie besides Frodo, he doesnt experience one moment of comfort, being around friends, or, in your face hope, safety, and, love besides what Sam is able to provide for he and Frodo both after they leave the fellowship and commence their lonely journey. Everyone had important parts to play of that there is no doubt. Sam is the unflinching heart of the entire story and without him Middle Earth falls.
Yes, Sam is the true hero of the Lord of the Rings
Yes Sam is the the true hero, where Frodo failed he stood fast. I read somwhere, cannot recall where, that J R R Tolkien modelled Sam after his batman in WW1. A batman was an officers servant soldier in the british army, who when thd officer retired/sent in his paper followed him as a trusted servan and sometimes friend as a valet, footman, bodyguard or butler.
Frodo did not fail. He lived with the terrible temptation and and the unspeakable mental and physical torture of living with the ring. No one else could have done it. All the Wise and the mighty knew that only Frodo could take the Ring to Mordor. He accepted the duty in spite of his fear and his overwhelming desire to stay in Rivendell with Bilbo. Sam was Frodo's heroic helper but he carried the Ring only briefly
"I am glad you are here with me. Here at the end of all things, Sam"
Plenty of heroes in the LOTR… but Sam is definitely top tier.
This was amazing. Absolutely didn't cried. Thank you ❤
Without Sam
Frodo would have not made it to the end… He promised to be with Frodo and he intended to keep his promise 🥹
I like to think that Yavanna blessed Sam and protected him.
Varda was certainly looking out for him when he fought Shelob.
Yes, I think Varda was Frodo’s guardian and Yavanna was Sam’s guardian.
I love how this feels like a documentary
We all need a Sam on our life journey 😊😊
Sam was the hero. Tolkien knew how war rages a person. I am certain that he met many people like Samwise in the Trenches of WWI.
Back again, needed a happier tale than now.
I'm pretty sure that Sam's eavesdropping wasn't coincidental, it was part of his keeping an eye on Frodo as one of the conspirators.
I have to write an essay on Sam and your content gave me so much information lol
When Bilbo gives his birthday speech, he lists off all the hobbit families in attendance. However, he never mentions the Gamgees
Had the hardest flashback at the PO-TAE-TOES
Unpopular opinion: Sam was compelled by Gandalf at the beginning of the story to stay with frodo until the quest was completed.
Not to disagree that Sam was a faithful and loyal companion but to explain how Gandalf's magic strengthened that loyalty to the degree he would do things like leave the shire, wade into a river knowing he couldn't swim, and stay with the fellowship knowing that the shire, his father, and his lady friend were in danger.
None of this diminishes his bearing of the ring and wishing for clear skies and sunshine, breaking the magic darness of sauron and giving the rest of Gondir and the realm of men to make a stand.
Gandalf is not a god. He didn't put a spell on Sam, either.
He gave Sam a mission, a purpose, and Samwise made a promise to fulfill it.
@@cindyknudson2715 Um... I'm willing to debate but Gandalf is quite literally a god.
Being from a higher plane of existence, has magic powers, falls and resurrects more powerful.
There's an argument and then there's just denial.
No I do not agree that Sam is the true hero of the Lord of the Rings. For all the events that play out so many different characters played their part. As Gandalf said even Gollum had his role to play, that ended in the ultimate destruction of the Ring. So definitely too complex of a story for any one person to be the true hero.
Both Frodo and Sam of course are the heroes. It is hard to say who is more heroic or compare them. However, Sam has always been my favourite stays true to his values always stand for what’s right and protected Frodo when he was incapacitated or injured. Plus, Sam gets the girl at the end! :-) :)
My favorite character from the movies! Samwise the Brave.
Sam is definitely the true hero of the tale!
My wife still thinks we named our second son after her father, whose name also happens to be Sam....
Sam Wise is one of the truest and best friends of all time.
When I read the book as a kid I thought Frodo, Aragon, Gandalf, Legolas and Gimli were all the biggest heroes. After reading the book as an adult it occurred to me that Sam was in fact the true hero. He cried a lot and was unsure of himself but he preserved out of loyalty and love when stronger men would have turned back.
As a Gardener, to whom did Sam delegate responsibility to tend the various gardens entrusted to or possessed by Mr Samwise, in his long absences?
With 13 children I totally expect that some of them inherited their fathers love of gardening and received good training from the best
Samwise the brave is indeed the true hero of The Lord of the Rings
i realy gotta rewatch lord of the rings
Read it instead!
@@alfamalenor do both.
Tolkien was known for bringing in comparisons of religion to his works. I believe that while Sam wasn't necessarily a Jesus type figure, he was a perfect example of the passage of greatest love and sacrifice. And staying true no matter the situation or temptation, very much like Job. He's a shining example in my opinion of what it means to do good for the world and ask little in return.
I agree that Sam is a hero and it is tough when in comparison to the others in the fellowship that he was the true hero but when one thinks on it I can see it. He saw and spoke on things comprehending them in their truist form with no ego to become problematic especially when later tempted by the ring. Sam's voice and support to frodo was a great blessing keeping the focus on hope and the good as frodo interiorly fought the ring. Sam did carry the ring and was able to give it back to frodo says something about his interior strength and his humility in "knowing his place" in the bigger picture. I liked that he became a good family man and leader and sharing his gift from galadriel with the shire lands. It made me laugh when the hobbits leaving bree with aragorn and the pony bill in tow (I forget the nasty characters name) was sticking his head over a hedge I believe making a stupid comment when Sam eating an apple threw the apple hitting the creep square in the head shutting him up as the group kept walking.
Sam is my hero!
I agree that Sam was the real hero because Frodo wouldn't have gotten as far as he did without Sam.
YES to your question.
The real hero of the story!
What an absolute chad.
Was always curious to know if Sam was ever reunited with Bill the pony. Please tell me that happened, lol.
Yes! If I recall Gandalf put an enchantment on Bill to help him find his way home. He came back to the Prancing Pony, and Barliman took care of him until the Hobbits returned.
Bill lived out his life in the Shire with Sam.
@@katherinegraham3803 Oh, that is just perfect. Thank you!
The books explain this.
In the book Bill the pony takes a kick at one of the evil men who infiltrated the Shire. Have a look to see exactly who it was, it's quite fitting.
Fatty is truly an un-sung hero.
Sam is the true hero
It was Sam who defeated Saruman?? WHAT?? I must now read the books. I MUST NOW READ THE BOOKS
I believe Sam's fathers name is Hamfast.
Perhaps i didnt understand it in that video but what does "the gaffer" actually mean? In german we call someone a "gaffer" who's starring at women or at an accident without helping. But it seems thats not the cade here right?
There some good in world for you Mr froda from Sam
PLEASEEE DO GALADRIELLL
after watching the movies for the first time it always bothered me that Sam calls Frodo, Mr. Frodo.
In the movie you get the feeling they are acquaintances since the drink together at the bar, and Sam is Bilbo's gardener. but by the end of the movie they are much closer companions than that and he still says Mr. Frodo while Merry and Pipin just call him Frodo
But in the Books it makes it clear that they are all actually friends. It just so happens that Sam works for Bilbo, but they all spend a lot of time together and know eachother as friends, AND still Sam calls him Mr. Frodo. I dunno that just seems strange to me, none of my friends address me as "Mr."
as if I am their employer.
If I could change one thing it would be that
Calling Frodo Mr and Master was an acknowledgement that he respected Frodo, and that socially, Frodo was above him. Tolkien grew up in an England that was very class conscious, and his writing reflects that. I liken Frodo and Sam's relationship similar to the American South. Younger people are taught to call their elders Miss or Mr as a sign of respect. And after all, Frodo is around 20 or so years older than Sam.
Yes, Sam IS the true protagonist of the story.
Frodo is basically his whiny wife he must carry and praise.
I don’t believe Frodo would be alive to see Sam again. He was already 50 to start the journey. If same was the mayor 7 times for 7 years each that’s another 49 years. So Frodo would be well over 100 by time Sam got there. The undying lands do not mean immortality. Bilbo only lived to be around 115 at most. It seems very unlikely that Sam would see Frodo again.
Bilbo was 128 when he went to the undying lands.
@@ryanellis9325 yes I did forget the 17 years between bilbo leaving and Frodo leaving. I’ve watched a video by Tolkien untangled on here that discusses 10 misconceptions of middle earth where he discusses it much more intellectually then I can.
Sam Gamgee wasn't working under the window at Bag End when Gandalf was talking about the ring by chance!! He had been spying on Frodo as he was the chief investigator of the Hobbits Conspiracy!!
Hobbits have a longer lifespan than middle men, and commonly live to 100. The Appendices mention that Merry was "still hale" at 102 when he and Pippin left the Shire to visit Eomer and then travel to Gondor to live out the remaining years of their lives.
Frodo would have been about 114 by the time Sam arrived in the West, which is certainly old even by Hobbit standards. However, he's living in a land free of disease, and assuming he's friends with Elrond, he has a world-class healer to help him reach his maximum lifespan.
All this is to say, their time together would have been limited, but I think Sam and Frodo were reunited.
@@katherinegraham3803 if Tolkien was alive and I could ask one question it would be this. I want to know so badly if they actually reunited or not
"If I could grow apples like these, I would call myself a gardener."
Hey! And can I put forward that it is pronounced Gam-GEE, not Gam-Jee. Since the movies, the dmg has been done, but still.
How did Sam got the ring from Frodo is my question
Read the books
Yes, Samwise was the hero.
Rosie wants Sam to invade her Hobbit hole.
Video 274
👏👏👏👏
😍😍😍😍💕💕💕👌
I really wanted to watch the whole thing, but that drone is so annoying, I can't. I already know all this stuff, I thought this would be fun. Sorry I wasted time on this.
Frodo is the true hero of the story. Sam is definitely a hero, but Frodo is the central hero
Actually, Tolkien himself said that Sam was the real hero and the books were really about him.
Samwise the Brave! I want to hear more about him!
Samwise the Brave indeed 😁
Frodo- 'He wouldn't have got far without Sam.'
While great in the films, Sam's quality shone greater in the books. Never faltered in his loyalty to Frodo and possessed great resistance to the Rings corruption. When he was the ringbearer, The Ring being very potent now that it was near Mordor tried to seduce him of visions of power and glory and Sam was able to overcome it due to his humility and wanting a simple life as a gardner
Yes, there's the amazing moment at the Tower of Cirith Ungol that Sam just hands the ring back, no hesitation, no struggle. After Gandalf went on and on about how difficult it is to just relinquish any of the Rings.
I really liked the movies. Not so much The Hobbit, the dwarves looked foolish in the movies post LOR. AND all the movies as movies do bend the book version.
I love Sam, the choices of Master Samwise is one of my favourite chapters. I just hope that in their love for Sam people don’t under appreciate Frodo. Both were exceptional hobbits and there was a good reason Sam idolised Frodo!
They were both the hero of the journey; Sam could'nt have taken the ring his will was not strong enough but he had the strenght to carry Frodo ,and Frodo was in the end so exhausted by his wounds and the terrible power of malice of the ring that Sam was needed to help him. Frodo's task was not to destroy the ring but to bring it to Mount Doom where it could be destroyed. And he did this; Frodo was the brain and the heart and Sam was the legs and the heart.
Sam was the true hero, bravery, loyalty and humility all in one
Sam's character is simple but so rare, he's what we all need in a friend
Thank you for this video.
I’ve shown my partner and now she truly appreciates why I named by dog Sam, he’s loyal too.
I agree that Sam is one of the heroes. Like any team, each member of the Fellowship gave something. Sam is right up there at the top along with the other Hobbits.
Frodo could not have done his job without Sam, Frodo was lucky to have him as a friend. 😘🇦🇺 yes and the above quote of Sams was one of a hero. He had faith when all others lost it.
Great Choice for a Video Guy's.... spotlighting The " True Hero's" favorite Hobbit.... Bill the Pony Is The Hero behind the curtain per say.... He is after all held in the Highest Esteem by Shadowfax and The Mearas' ....without Bill's Steadfast Soul.... Samwise would Most definitely had a harder go of it... 🫏🐎🫏 !!!
Thanks for the video. Yes Sam is the hero in LOTR without Sam Frodo wouldn't have got very far 😊
I’ve always found the question of “who was the true hero of LOTR” to be a tautology. There is no single hero. To me, it has always been about the enduring spirit of humanity when faced against impossible evil (humanity being a multiracial term here).
That said, Sam is tied with Aragorn for my favorite character and the line/scene where he carries Frodo near the end is one of the most poignant in all of cinema and in all of the legendarium.
Without Sam all would have been lost if the orcs of Cirith Ungol took Frodo's body and discovered the ring. Though I wonder how events would've played out if Merry or Aragorn went with instead.
Yes yes yes, Sam is the Hero of the story. Many times Frodo would have been lost or killed without Sam. And some battles Sam had to fight for Frodo, and what about when Sam carried Frodo up that last hill? Of course Samwise Gamgee is the Hero of the story. Without Sam there is no Frodo and no story.
I didn't come up with this but saw it posted on Facebook but I thought it was humorously appropriate.
"Samwise had to travel to the other side of the known world and face the strongest and most powerful
evil that world had in order to have enough courage to propose to a woman who already liked him.
I love how The Broken Sword makes videos where the words are spoken in such a way that reminisces how Tolkien would speak in the books
0:29 🎉😮🎉 the Light would be more effective against Shelob had Samwise held the vial by its neck... "but"...
I'll watch this video when I'm done at work, but I'm re-reading the books right now . . . and Sam is kind of a huge jerk. At one point, Tolkien says that Samwise is an optimistic hobbit by nature, but he really isn't. It *feels* like Smeagol possibly could've turned a new leaf, except for Sam constantly being mean to him. He really is quite rude! I feel more and more pity for Gollum this time around. He's allegedly a "bad guy," but he's been corrupted by an incredibly powerful supernatural artifact for his entire presence in the narrative. He deserves better than what he got.
Smeagol was a creep long before he possessed the ring.
5:45 to 5:54
6:18
6:53
7:43
8:51
9:36 to 9:37
11:48 to 11:52
17:26 ❣❣
19:19
19:24 to 19:39
22:31 to 22:38
24:53 to 25:09
Whats taters..eh. what's taters.. precious?
You know.. po-ta-toes..😂
Boil 'em, mash 'em, stick 'em in a stew.
You never brought up the seed of the Mallorn tree that was in the box with the soil. You just talked about the soil.
Good spot! 🤦♂️😂
@@TheBrokenSword 😁
Samwise "The Brave" Gamgee is, by far, my favorite character in LOTR, and yes he is the true hero of the story. His deeds after the LOTR tale, are almost as impressive as his deeds during the war. Replanting and regrowing The Shire, being elected The Mayor of Michel Delving seven times, marrying Rosie Cotton. raising thirteen children, and finally, going to The Undying Lands to reunite with Frodo, Bilbo and Gandalf. A good life.
A big deal was made of how Samwise mourned parting with Bill the pony, but no mention was made of how they were reunited on the journey back to the Shire. As to the final question, Samwise is clearly not the hero of LotR - it doesn't even have a single hero, really. Frodo and Aragorn are the two chief protagonists, but neither is the hero of the entire story. Samwise is my favourite character and he does embody everyman heroism, however, the bravery of ordinary men thrust into horrifying situations, such as Tolkien saw for himself on the battlefields of WWI - which as the author would be keen to point out, does not make him an allegory for anything, it's simply an observation on human nature...
Been a fan of Astin for the longest. I believe this was a perfect character fit. I have the Rudy movie on DVD and will usually watch after the rings.
In any real story there is always two that are heroes. There is the man who is destined to do something great and remarkable, and the loyal man who makes the first mans destiny possible to fulfill. Both Sam and Frodo are the hero, neither could've done anything without the other.
they loved not just plants, but all things that were green and growing.
so..... plants.
Sam One of the Heroes. He's among Aragorn, Gandalf and Frodo
Samwise Gamgee is the true hero of this legendarium.
Sam shares with Frodo in savings Middle Earth
Sam!!!!
The hero's of the Lord of the Rings is both Sam and Frodo.
Without Sam, the quest would have failed!
Sam is the real hero of tLotR.
Truly the greatest hero of the entire tail.
PLEASE DO FULL STORY OF GALADRIEL PLEASEEE