Black Star Network Presents: Gov. Tim Walz & Sen. JD Vance Vice Presidential Debate Analysis

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 79

  • @ziply123
    @ziply123 Месяц назад +14

    This was the best post-debate roundtable I've heard, hands down. Sharing this clip far and wide.

    • @Wolfnotsheep1
      @Wolfnotsheep1 Месяц назад

      I would be embarrassed to share something like this. Sorry. They haven't brought up a single proper talking point. Besides.
      Vance came from s*** Don't know.S*** kissing trump's a** s***. This will make upstanding citizens. Look, bad, sorry it's just my opinion

  • @georgettaneal6255
    @georgettaneal6255 Месяц назад +9

    You, my friend Roland Martin, have the best debate analysis. As always, in my Book of Hope, you bring us the best perspective from the best, including you ❤😊

  • @dwaynewilliams7826
    @dwaynewilliams7826 Месяц назад +7

    Haha. I love Dr. Greg Carr! I'm with you brother. I don't claim none of this place either. I live in Chester, VA.

  • @amoijoy573
    @amoijoy573 Месяц назад +1

    I thoroughly enjoyed this conversation. Thank you Roland.

  • @leosu3546
    @leosu3546 Месяц назад +3

    Proverbs 26:24-26
    24 Enemies disguise themselves with their lips,
    but in their hearts they harbor deceit.
    25 Though their speech is charming, do not believe them,
    for seven abominations fill their hearts.
    26 Their malice may be concealed by deception,
    but their wickedness will be exposed in the assembly.

  • @MichelleFord-p7l
    @MichelleFord-p7l Месяц назад +3

    I really enjoy your roundtable discussions like this. Thank you for providing this forum for us. Agree with the panelists, it annoyed me to hear Vance talk about Biden policies being Harris policies, "she's not POTUS yet." Vance is a waste of a Yale law degree, it baffles me! Loved, "No answer is damning." Great point from Dr. Carr regarding the 25th amendment, that's another point to be concerned about, Vance as POTUS cannot happen! Totally agree with Roland on the Tiananmen Square answer, "my dates are off or something and move on." "You're a senator," would've been great! Excellent point from Dr. Santiago Ali, "Who do you feel comfortable with if something happens to POTUS?" I'm with Randi, "J6" was and embarrassment, Trump was/is an embarrassment who does not rise to the dignity of the U.S. Presidency. He's a slug, rumbled mannerisms-why wouldn't he wear better looking suits? He's rich, look dignified. I was embarrassed every time he traveled to another country.

  • @bettyblevins7904
    @bettyblevins7904 Месяц назад +4

    I do love the way Give. Walz looked out at the viewers and talked directly to us. While Vance's eyes constantly darted around and his body language was that of someone untrustworthy.

    • @prudenceelliott1958e
      @prudenceelliott1958e Месяц назад

      Lie walk a broad road and hugs the whole road for himself

    • @compound00
      @compound00 Месяц назад

      @bettyblevins7904 LOL. HE looked right at you and showed you called himself a Liar and a knuckle head. 🤣

    • @WhattheNewTestamentReallySays
      @WhattheNewTestamentReallySays Месяц назад

      Hello Betty, I'm not sure of what you mean. Can you elaborate what you mean about Vance's body language?

  • @bettyblevins7904
    @bettyblevins7904 Месяц назад +1

    Tell people to take their ID when they vote also.

  • @MACRI-zg3qu
    @MACRI-zg3qu Месяц назад +7

    Yessss maaaam👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 preach!!!!@

  • @donnisefonville
    @donnisefonville Месяц назад +5

    Just SMH man I'm sooo Glad I voted early 😊

  • @ethelparis2255
    @ethelparis2255 Месяц назад +8

    i don't think tim Walz did not answer some of the questions directly and I wish he had said more about Obmas presidency upping the economy and trump just benefiting from it and how trump weakend the epa, the cpc and it was a fear because of that that we had no protection from virusus effecting the American people on a large scale

  • @bettyblevins7904
    @bettyblevins7904 Месяц назад +1

    I felt compelled to share trump misdeeds and fraud. I love the post debate discussion and analysis. This analysis brought me back to sanity after the trump craziness and wondering how long will he get away with his bs. Listening to you all helps me decompress and embrace like minded beautiful black sisters and brothers who have got his(trump) number and he won't continue to get away with his grifts.

  • @bettyblevins7904
    @bettyblevins7904 Месяц назад +1

    It's our job also to instruct people about the role of a VP.

  • @stuartsoll3254
    @stuartsoll3254 Месяц назад +2

    Walz did a great job. Im also an old white guy. Yesterday I dropped my ballot in the box. I voted Harris and blue all the way.

  • @roscoes9933
    @roscoes9933 Месяц назад +1

    Okay, so here’s the thing. JD Vance? Yeah, he won-barely. But honestly, some of what he said was like trying to sell you a used car with no wheels. Sure, it might look good, but you’re not going anywhere. Now, Tim Walz? That’s a whole different vibe. I looked at the guy and thought, "This man? He’s not trying to sell me dreams or miracles-just straight-up truth."
    And by the time I was done listening, I was convinced. Him and Kamala? Together, they’d be out there like two highly caffeinated squirrels-buzzing around, getting things done. That’s what leadership is about, right? Honest, hardworking, and maybe just a bit crazy, but in a good way!

  • @Ron-ep3zl
    @Ron-ep3zl Месяц назад +1

    Let's also not forget that Vance said he,unlike Pence, wouldn't have certified the election. One of the reasons Trump picked him besides him writing the front in project 2025.

  • @TeresaNelson-k8e
    @TeresaNelson-k8e Месяц назад +8

    I think Tim answered everything and he did a great job. My God do he supposed to act like Trump? I thought everybody was sick of that. It was time to turn the page. Jeeeezzz

    • @Wolfnotsheep1
      @Wolfnotsheep1 Месяц назад

      Didn't he sign a bill that he wanted female hygiene products in boy's bathroom? Why didn't they ask him that question? And why would anybody support something like this for our young boys? That's supposed to do become grown men

    • @TeresaNelson-k8e
      @TeresaNelson-k8e Месяц назад

      @@Wolfnotsheep1 oh wow I didn’t know that but I’ll look it up for myself I’m not with that

  • @bettyblevins7904
    @bettyblevins7904 Месяц назад

    WOW Roland you guys really are right on point about what I expected out of Walz. However I think Gov Walz had an agenda and I pray he did well.

  • @RaymeerDosa
    @RaymeerDosa Месяц назад +1

    Why ol boy talking about tap dancing look like Gregory Hines

  • @mamiebryant9064
    @mamiebryant9064 Месяц назад +3

    Roland you need to be more gracious to ur guests 😮😮

  • @gloriabazemore4796
    @gloriabazemore4796 Месяц назад +4

    Forgive me, I did not hear her name, but the young lady with the “hoop-earrings” and hair parted down the middle, expressed perfectly my sentiments regarding the debates. Her observation nailed it, for me. Thank you, young lady.

  • @SteveGully-f8j
    @SteveGully-f8j Месяц назад +1

    We all know Vance lied and lies 👺 it's insulting to anyone who has common sense

  • @landebanks5886
    @landebanks5886 Месяц назад

    JD can't sell an upscale used car. What a loser

  • @tommymerritt4267
    @tommymerritt4267 Месяц назад

    Tim Walz should have been firm to Vance

  • @WhattheNewTestamentReallySays
    @WhattheNewTestamentReallySays Месяц назад

    I feel, upon reflection, and in the final analysis, that Walz did the better job and Vance's "mask" slipped off about three time during his guileful charade: (1) When he said Trump saved the ACA. (2) When he got mad about being fact checked. (3) When he would not acknowledge that Biden won the last election. To me it was clear that J.D.Vance was "concealing" himself and the truth the whole while of debate and Tim Walz came across to me as nervous BUT REAL AND TRUTHFUL.

  • @Elizabeth-b1i
    @Elizabeth-b1i Месяц назад +1

    Trumps getting old and JD is getting ready to take the presidential place of Trump. He is all in.❤

  • @Sickniccc
    @Sickniccc Месяц назад +1

    Tim stumbled when they brought up his time in the military in china/asia. He ran around in circles on that question

    • @clark7474
      @clark7474 Месяц назад +2

      Yes, only that one thing. Vance got called out on lie after lie after lie. Vance never answered one question much less state any policies.

    • @Wolfnotsheep1
      @Wolfnotsheep1 Месяц назад

      Excuse me what lie?​@clark7474

  • @NilsaRodriguez-i5c
    @NilsaRodriguez-i5c Месяц назад +3

    I think Tim Walz won the debate he stood by his principal and was not a bully Vance like trump lied throughout the debate who the hell wants a dam liar as vice president I take a good and decent man over a corrupt liar anytime so happy that Kamala Harris chose him as her VP

  • @thelmaridges8984
    @thelmaridges8984 Месяц назад

    Maria

  • @Panaviki123
    @Panaviki123 Месяц назад

    And when He said these Immigrants are taking brown and black people job. He did not say Americans Jobs.??????Black man. 🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

  • @Sickniccc
    @Sickniccc Месяц назад +3

    Tim Walz didn’t do good at all. But Vance is so untrustworthy it’s ridiculous

    • @clark7474
      @clark7474 Месяц назад +4

      Tim Walz did great! He may not have debate style but he had debate substance.

    • @gloriabazemore4796
      @gloriabazemore4796 Месяц назад

      @@clark7474I agree with your conclusion

  • @taedofficial6214
    @taedofficial6214 Месяц назад +4

    It was hard to find a video of a black group speaking on this debate. After the first 15 minutes watching, I realized it’s probably because one, yall are black. 2, potty language! How do we expect candidates and citizens to take this seriously if yall are on here cussing up a storm? 3, everyone is talking all at once! Be PROFESSIONAL! Respect what each other has to say and listen to the complete thought they have! It’s the simple things. It hurts to see this because I was really hoping this would look a LOT more professional, patient and respectful so we can be heard more and taken more seriously! It was hard enough to find this video let alone deal with ignorance of professionalism. Cussing out our candidates is biased and negative in ALL! Let’s do better my people. Let’s show them we can do better and be more practical as smart intelligent individuals! Let’s prove them wrong by being right! They will NOT listen to low grade criticism!

    • @mamiebryant9064
      @mamiebryant9064 Месяц назад +1

      This is a very important election. Walt was NOT lying he misspoke unlike the blatant lies that trump n his clone(j.d.) is doing.

  • @naeemintellectual8203
    @naeemintellectual8203 Месяц назад

    So, who regrets their VP pick?😢😂

  • @romerogrady7195
    @romerogrady7195 Месяц назад +1

    I tell you what I saw .... Waltz, who's a nice guy was taken advantage of and he lost the Debate ! Waltz allowed Vance to catch him with his guards down, and he could never recover. Vance came into the debate acting like Tim buddy, and once Vance got Waltz all soft and cuddly.. he started hammering him with lies and attacks on Kamala ! To be honest, Waltz never recovered from that China question. Tim Waltz is a decent white guy from a corn fields of Nebraska, but he wasn't savvy enough against the crook, and seasoned used car salesman from Ohio. It was like watching the nice kid next door try to out hustle a hustler.... it will never happen !

    • @clark7474
      @clark7474 Месяц назад +1

      So based on all the 🐮💩you just spouted your voting for trump?

  • @ucheuchema1081
    @ucheuchema1081 Месяц назад +3

    "...JD Vance did not answer one question..." said the lady. Well, Tim Waltz did not answer one question. Especially the one to explain his statement that he was in Hong Kong during the Tiananmen square incident. Tim had to be pushed to even address that one. So, this panel appears to lack integrity. I say "A liar cannot condemn a liar for lying".

    • @mdh2796
      @mdh2796 Месяц назад

      No one cares about a blip on the screen regarding their personal travels to Tianamen Square - that has no impact on the US whatsoever. Why didn’t they ask JD about his disrespectful statement of the Haitian immigrants that impacted decent and innocent lives here in the US? Oh yes the media wanted something on Tim and didn’t get it 😂😂😂😂. On the flip side, JD Vance couldn’t even denounced the January 6 insurrection but instead continued to support Trump’s false narrative of him winning the 2020 election, he was weak on healthcare, abortion/reproductive rights, climate change, his attempt to offer us a response on the economy, foreign policy and immigration was very shakey, laced with lies and offered no solutions, just the usually talking point about we can fix it on day 1 but how? Lol - Tim Walz might not have been perfect but he is a decent human being who doesn’t have to pretend who he is, very relatable, decent and authentic. As an independent I know a fake when I see one and Vance was a good reflection of that. The pundits and analysts only do things for news sensationalism and ratings but us the viewing/voting public knows better 🙏🏽💯. Good decent debate and civility is the winner!! This was not a university debate and being smooth with no substance lose for me - the only thing smooth about Vance in this debate was that he is a very slick liar!

  • @ethelparis2255
    @ethelparis2255 Месяц назад +2

    i guess you all did not fact check, but walz saying about the abortion registestrly was not correct, it was fact checked

    • @annocsunamoon
      @annocsunamoon Месяц назад

      The Project 2025 states that Doctors must report on women seeking abortions outside of their states. THAT'S A REGISTRY. IN FACT, there's a youtube of Congress holding hearings on that 900+ page manifesto that quotes the exact page number for those that want to read it. Fact check that.

    • @mccrayjohn5429
      @mccrayjohn5429 Месяц назад +2

      The whole debate was not fact checked what are you

  • @Dan-p5h
    @Dan-p5h Месяц назад +3

    Sounds like a lot of bitter people JD done a good debate

  • @colorofspurge
    @colorofspurge Месяц назад +1

    Vance destroyed Walz. His poise. His prose. His pose.

    • @clark7474
      @clark7474 Месяц назад +5

      Destroying someone on style while being destroyed on substants is not a flex. Take a 💺sir.

    • @colorofspurge
      @colorofspurge Месяц назад

      Nah. I prefer standing. lol. I didn’t hear anything of substance. Which reality show star did you copy that “take a seat” talking point? From a speaking/debate analysis, Vance was “slick” with his words so much so, it looked like Walz wanted to vote for the Trump/Vance ticket. Actually, speaking coherent sentences and staying on message is a flex when the opponent stumbles over his words and thoughts.

    • @veronicamoody3981
      @veronicamoody3981 Месяц назад

      @@clark7474 People today are more concerned and influenced by appearance and facade. We live in a very phony world these days.

  • @donnisefonville
    @donnisefonville Месяц назад

    U can turn a lie to the truth

  • @eddiesaun9690
    @eddiesaun9690 Месяц назад

    Black "beta males" will vote Kamala2024!!!!!