I literally just watched them play it live from 2007, and this one in 2019 and they perform it just as well. Really incredible for a band. His voice handles the song just as well, not easy to do
Chad's voice has held up remarkably well throughout the years! This song is one that's not that easy to sing either. He's singing in his higher register for the whole tune, and night after night.
I don't really understand why people hated them. These children are hating them just because it's a meme or it's trending. Nickelback is such a great band. The vocalist had one of the most unique voices in the industry.
I watched the recorded video and then this. I thought to myself, "nicely done". I love this song. Everything about it - the vocals - hard but not screaming, the lyric - emotional, but not sappy, the simplicity of the melody - easy to sing along to, the bass follows a simple root-5-root pattern, and extremely effective. Even a new bass/guitar player can quickly learn this song. Just a great song.
@@getgle Photograph is definitely lip synched. They use the same recording from the Live At Sturgis show. The rest of the Rock In Rio concert was performed live but they've been using this recording for Photograph for a while now. Probably to save Chads voice. Still one of the best live acts to this day though!
Ok. So I've analyzed this performance and the one from "Live At Sturgis". This concert is basically live but in this particular song he used playback vocals from Sturgis. I don't know why he did it, given that the overall performance from this concert was far more than good enough. But yeah, saying his voice hasn't changed a bit is a little lie. It's a shame, because I loved the "sturgis" concert with all my heart
I've noticed it too. I don't hate them but maybe he can't sing as high as his voice before or maybe his voice is not rough like before So that's why they chose to lip sync it
Y’all do know he had vocal surgery a couple years ago. They had to cancel the last part of their tour cause Chad’s vocals were shot to sh!t. He tried to stick it out and eventually had to have surgery
Fuck this man is awesome...somehow there are still some of them that make good make real music... Those who are singing along in the crowd are real music lovers... They appreciate his work... Because thwy truly know music is that.. No lip sync no auto tune. Gave the best
So many people shit on this band, but they are actually one of the few bands today that sounds exactly like their records
Jealousy
exactly they are awesome
i agree buddy
he is obviously singing with the playback track lol. But thats actually not bad if you ask me
Chad had a really bad attitude that greatly contributed to the hate. Hopefully hes more humble now. Regardless, the band's success cannot be denied.
his voice is so unique. its almost like he naturally stacks his vocals!
Thinking the same. He's always had an almost "doubled" sounding vocal. Chester Bennington had a similar vibe.
He got a distortion effector in his throat
human vocoder type beat
Amazing how he still sounds the same live more than 10 years later
I literally just watched them play it live from 2007, and this one in 2019 and they perform it just as well. Really incredible for a band. His voice handles the song just as well, not easy to do
This song is 16+ years old!
@@the_minimalistic_adventure no way now i feel super old! 😂
The Vocals are playback. They use a record from a live show 2005 or 2006, it's exactly the same on every show until today.
@@alexanderrohlfing I'm sure theres a vocal track playing along to fill out the space, but are you suggesting its straight up lip synching?
Chad is one the few vocalist who sounds like on the radio when he sings. This is pure talent right here ladies and gentlemen.
This guy can sing. I can't reach the tones in this song.
Man he still sounds the same! Insane!
15 years later, they still don't know what is on Joey's head
A hockey trophy
Chad's voice has held up remarkably well throughout the years! This song is one that's not that easy to sing either. He's singing in his higher register for the whole tune, and night after night.
backingtrack from 2007 live in sturgis^^
I like Nickelback music, because it is simple and direct, without fanfare or complications.
I don't really understand why people hated them. These children are hating them just because it's a meme or it's trending. Nickelback is such a great band. The vocalist had one of the most unique voices in the industry.
I watched the recorded video and then this. I thought to myself, "nicely done". I love this song. Everything about it - the vocals - hard but not screaming, the lyric - emotional, but not sappy, the simplicity of the melody - easy to sing along to, the bass follows a simple root-5-root pattern, and extremely effective. Even a new bass/guitar player can quickly learn this song. Just a great song.
Oh yeah still alive nickelback i wish your voice is never grow old💪👍
Wow , the Crowd is Loving it!
Such a moving song. And you can see from the audience that they really get this song, when they sing along
never liked the band, but never understood the hatred. People at this concert seem to enjoy a lot.
His vocals gets me all the time...wow 👏 😮
Idk why people hate this band they’re insanely good!!!!
Must be awesome to be an artist and have like 50K people singing along to your song
So much talent such a solid performance!!
Never tired listening to this nickleback is the best rockstar for me
One of my favorite best band ever❤💪
i love this song
NICKELBACK S *"*CLASSIC *"*"
Good performance as always
I love this song and this band ,..keep safe..we love's you
INCREDIBLE
Awesome✨👏
It's so perfect to the recording that RUclips read it as "music in video"
WOW.... Its so good to hear
I love everything that these guys do.
Empezando el día con esta canción :) !!!
Danm vocal love it
Nickelback the best everywhere ❤❤❤❤🤟🤟🤟🤟
They may have been overrated back in the day, but they’re underrated nowadays!
Chills.
Love,nickleback from.ph
Damn! I wish i had this voice .
DAM! Still sounds GREAT!!
Wow😀😀😀❤❤❤
Holy fuck, Chad nailed it !
God, how I miss a live concert...
They r still great band 🤘
what a banger!
❤
Nice crowd
ชอบคับ
คนไทยมาไงเนี่ย นึกว่ามีผมชอบคนเดียวละ😃
This band is fucking awesome.
Rock N Roll
Wow, the guy looks like a different person now he's older. The voice on the guy is fuckin awesome! Nickelback are amazing.
🤘
mizo!!
Why does he sound like his 2005 self in photograph, but every other song, he sound a little soft.
Photograph is lip synced, I think it's to match up with the video perfectly.
@@SiLoMixMaster It's not, you can cleary hear it's different.
I was wondering the same thing.
@@getgle Photograph is definitely lip synched. They use the same recording from the Live At Sturgis show. The rest of the Rock In Rio concert was performed live but they've been using this recording for Photograph for a while now. Probably to save Chads voice. Still one of the best live acts to this day though!
😍
Hey🌹, all love and how are you doing today?
"Look at this Instagram, Eggs Benedict side of ham"
I can’t believe he had the same vocals for this long
Sounds like the recorded. So fuckin love his voice
Damn, from a drummer's perspective... Daniel Adair's overhead mics must be off or acting up/glitching, you can barely hear his cymbals in this AT ALL.
Rock in Rio doesn’t have the best sound mixes
Sounds like playback great band amazing vocals
Ok. So I've analyzed this performance and the one from "Live At Sturgis". This concert is basically live but in this particular song he used playback vocals from Sturgis. I don't know why he did it, given that the overall performance from this concert was far more than good enough. But yeah, saying his voice hasn't changed a bit is a little lie. It's a shame, because I loved the "sturgis" concert with all my heart
I've noticed it too.
I don't hate them but maybe he can't sing as high as his voice before or maybe his voice is not rough like before
So that's why they chose to lip sync it
Y’all do know he had vocal surgery a couple years ago. They had to cancel the last part of their tour cause Chad’s vocals were shot to sh!t. He tried to stick it out and eventually had to have surgery
how the fuck does this man still sound like he did 20 years ago...OMG
until today we dont know what’s on Joey’s head
Fuck this man is awesome...somehow there are still some of them that make good make real music... Those who are singing along in the crowd are real music lovers... They appreciate his work... Because thwy truly know music is that.. No lip sync no auto tune. Gave the best
Daughtry vs nickelback..im choice nickelback👍
He's got the lyrics on a screen? I've never seen that before, anyone know why?
It's just part of the equipment lol tons of musicians have that, it's usually on a small screen so you don't really notice it
koolaidman519 it’s really just a backup just incase. where did you see this?
B C M @1:10
It's so the band has a method to assist them with the lyrics to the songs. Lots, I mean LOTS, of artists do that. They just don't show it.
@@Laga98 Because its karaoke.
เป็นคนที่ร้องสดได้เทพและเหมือนเทปที่สุดคนนึงของโลกนี้
I'm looking for a rythem guitarist who knows
👍👍👍❤️🇷🇺
Jonah Hill is a fan of nickelback
12 years voice still the same
I clicked thinking this was def leppard photograph. Oops fl
And to think people call this bad...it's literally not, at all
They are very talented , love them ..but they need to grow their hair lo
The only thing that has changed it their hair.
lofi hiphop
Sad that this is a half lip sync
Minha tristeza por ver o Chad tendo que apelar pro playback é gigante... 😢
No hace playback i think
Wow people actually pay money to see nickelback 😂
I love Nickelback but it's a shame this performance is lip synched :(
Я.за.бывшый.состав.группы.почему
Great crowd, but check out any random person singing and it's clear they don't know all the words. Perhaps because they're main language is Spanish???
As expected of his name... He really is a Chad.
Tho... he doesnt looks like Nicholas Cage anymore with his new hair. Sad... LoL
I like him better a brunette
..
Playback unfortunately. Pretty sure it’s the vocals from the live track on the All the Right Reasons bonus track version
Dawson Wehage no but any real nickelback fan can tell that the vocals are from a much older performance (06/07 era)
WTF? 😂😂😂😂😂
why do people give this band so much shit?
The main voice is on playback I believe.
Clearly NOT.
Anyone with a brain can tell he's actually singing. It's not playback lol.
My bad with the wording, but he's had surgery on his vocal cards and sometimes he tries not to strain his voice
it is playback and i dont know why do u abuse someone bcs of a different opinion. here's prove ruclips.net/video/5m237V82hbs/видео.html
@@greatestofalltime7_ It's 100% lip synced
Pnung malabo n kau ng jowa mo
I know that Chad can sing live but in this case the voice is lip sync'ed
sorry to burst everyones bubble but unfortunately he is miming the whole song. They mime all their live shows and its so lame