The problem is not the quality of the pianos. The problem is Stu. I've never heard anything he played sound bad. He could tap on a shoebox and you'd say... wow, I wanna buy that!
Do you think this is a hidden advertisement for musical instruments? But don't you need to be a professional to make the most accurate review possible? I would be happy to meet a professional like Stu in person! The point is not how colorfully you describe everything. For example, I hear how “plastic” sounds float in the sound of some instruments, while some sound so juicy that I can’t even believe that this is not a real acoustic piano! (and this takes into account the fact that the sound example comes to us through RUclips, and not through a lossless recording!)
I have a small complaint. I did a lot of research before buying a Roland FP-30X for its capabilities as an acoustic piano emulator. The Casio Privia PX-S1100 is at exactly the same price point as the Roland FP-30X and the Yamaha P-225. All three listed for $699 at the store where I bought the Roland. The Roland FP-30X and the Yamaha P-225 should be on this list along with the Casio Privia PX-S1100.
Thanks for writing in! It is important to note that the price gaps between various models vary quite a bit in different markets. Here in Canada, the price gap between the PXS1100 and FP30X/P225 is quite pronounced. However, they are still excellent value buys regardless, which is a testament to their quality. :)
I own the px s3000. I mostly use it as a midi keyboard as i dont rate its onboard piano sounds at all. If you compare it to other keyboards in the price range there are others with a better piano tone. I watched a blind test online of pro player trying many keyboards and he expressed the same feeling about the piano sounds on the Casio. Personally, I wouldnt buy Casio again, my next will be Roland or Kawai.
That is totally fair! Naturally, if you're mainly using the piano as a MIDI controller, that definitely changes the discussion in terms of features and priorities when buying.
@MerriamPianos Yes, I didn't intend to solely use it as a midi keyboard in the beginning, infact, quite the opposite. But because I was disappointed with the piano sounds on the 3000, I 99% just use it now as a midi controller, which I have to say is good in that respect for me. However, I'm looking to buy something like Kawai next. But I'm unsure whether to go the vpc-1 midi controller only or an mp7se or even an fp90x or 60x. I really want the best of both worlds. Where, if I just want to sit down and play without booting up a PC for midi samples, I can just turn on the keyboard and have a piano tone i enjoy. Or if I want to play samples on another occasion, I have a keyboard that is good for that too. Maybe Stu could do a review on that in the future. A great piano keyboard that has great feel, good onboard sounds and also makes a great midi controller for piano. Best of both worlds. 😉👍
Yes, Love my Kawai ES920 sounds! Great quick Wide Choices Review ! Thank you. And.......after this board I definitely stick with Kawai Piano in near future....(701, 901..??)
Stu does the piano buying community a great service with his roundups and comparisons. Logically, there wasn't time to explain all the advantages of each model, so I was left wondering why the Casio GP-510 was chosen over the GP-310. I really liked seeing the PX-1100 get a good appraisal, and also the Roland FP-60X and F-701. These worthy instruments have been a bit underrated in other reviews and threads I was a little surprised that the RD-88 didn't get mentioned. Stu's last review of it was fairly glowing, and I was impressed when I tried it. The RD-88 is astonishingly cheap for such a versatile stage piano, and is highly portable as 88-key pianos go. If I needed a new 88-key gigging piano I would buy it straight away. My second choice would be the FP-60X. I view the latter as ideal for playing solo/duo in hotels, restaurants and small garden parties (and maybe it's nicer to practise on) but less ideal for band gigs. The ES920 is a great alternative to the FP-60X, but (and this is very subjective) I prefer Roland actions and sounds. It's sad that Yamaha has nothing in this semi-pro plastic action portable piano category now, not really replacing the P-255 with anything similar. I've purchased five portable Yamahas during 35 years, but the way things are going, the brand of my next portable or stage piano is more likely to be Roland.
Thanks so much for the kind words and for sharing your insights! We definitely try to be as thorough as possible given that there are so many amazing models out there that don't always get a spotlight on them. :)
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12 Some do, but often they are in the wrong part of the hotel, or not working too well. On one occasion when I used a hotel piano, the poor client paid nearly as much for the piano use as for me. It's lovely when it all works out. During a recent trip to Scotland I saw a nice village hotel which seemed to have a baby grand, and I was invited to try it. It turned out to be a P-125 in a custom-made cabinet. Amplification was separate. The cabinet, purchased from the Continent, cost 4000 pounds, or maybe euros. I was dismayed for the hotel, but I guess it was still cheaper than buying a digital baby grand. There is an obvious market for a simple, durable, digital piano with a fake baby grand cabinet, circa 3000 dollars. The requirement is not being met by manufacturers. Even if it can't be an ebony finish at that price, a cheap shell must be possible.
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12I replied, and strangely it disappeared. More succintly now, some hotels have acoustic pianos, but often they are inaccessible or unplayable. Digital pianos get broken even more quickly. A basic digital piano, esthetically good from all angles, is badly needed by the smaller hotels and restaurants. It doesn't need lots of extras, or to cost a fortune, but it needs to withstand a few knocks.
I'm in a real bind at the moment and ready to drop my money. Kawai CA701 vs the new Roland LX6? Problem is in my country the price of the kawai is the same as the LX5, the LX6 is £600 more. I'm still hoping for a DP603 or HP upgrade since their size is a little more compact. I'm in love with the lines of the 603 but its very old in the digital era.
Hi! Brent here! The CA701 is very impressive. I have not played the LX6 model yet, but, based on the specs and what I have heard, I am quite excited to do so as it looks to be an amazing instrument too! My suggestion would be to compare them in person to get a sense as to which one you connect with more.
@@MerriamPianos Yes, I played the CA701 and CA501 and loved the action of the 701 over the 501. I also tried the roland LX 706 which is incredibly cheap atm. i'm not sure about the LX bulk and relatively low power output on the old LX. I felt the PH50 action felt better than the CA501 but different maybe not better per se than the CA701 but the 701 has those really long balanced keys that felt incredibly light deep in to the the keys. I'm hoping to try the new LX6 in the coming weeks as I've heard the action on the LX6 and 9 has been upgraded. Thanks for your input.
I tried out the LX706 action recently and was quite disappointed after hearing such high praise. It doesn't compare to the grand feel of my MP11SE, which has apparently only been improved on successive versions. Honestly felt like a toy action in comparison. Definitely interested in the new sounds of the LX models though.
With the roland fp60x. You mention why you would get it over the fp90x . But what makes it stand out to justify the extra cost over its little brother the fp30x?
Stu has touched on this before in previous videos and the top-facing speakers have a big impact on the quality of the sonic experience. I also know that Stu is a big fan of the PHA4 action. ;)
The controls and speakers on the 60X are much better. It also has more voices without going into app. Seems it has everything the 90X has except wood keys, full modelling, and quite such powerful speakers. But full modelling is still controversial.
I got a Roland FP-30X about four weeks ago. I am using it purely as an acoustic piano emulator. I chose it for that purpose and for that purpose it is superb. I am not schooled enough to assess it for other purposes, but I think as a gig keyboard or for emulating other keyboard instruments, it might not be the best. Much depends on who is playing it though. I know there are people who use the FP-30X for all sorts of purposes, and the same for other instruments. I put the FP-30X at the top of the entry level price point along with the Yamaha P-225 and the Casio Privia SX-1100. The extra cost of an FP-60X would be justified if you were using the extra features you would be paying for if you bought one. The heavy action of the Rolands is not for everyone. I reached the intermediate beginner stage a long time ago and that is where I am picking things up right now. I have learned, many of the traditional piano exercises (such as Hanon) are designed for the purposes of developing hand strength in the student. I already have big and strong hands and strength in all of my fingers. I don't think playing identical sequences in both hands is good training and I am already reconfiguring the exercises so that I am not playing the left and right hands in parallel. Exercises are good though. People should treat playing them correctly as an end in itself, not as a means to an end.
What about the Roland LX-6/LX-9? I 100% agree with your views on the: Kawai KDP120 Kawai ES920 Yamaha P-525 Yamaha CLP-725 (however now the P-525 is better value!)
Some of this comes down to the subjectivity and preferences of the player of course. I would say that the KDP120 is definitely a contender as well. I haven't personally tried the LX6 and LX9 models yet, but I am quite excited to!
Nice video, but there are a few typos in your Chapters. prs1100 -> pxs1100, prs6000 -> pxs6000, Kawaii CN 2011 -> Kawai CN 201, Kawaii ES920 -> Kawai ES920, Yamaha CA701 -> Kawai CA701, Roland F71 -> Roland F701, Yamaha CC888 -> Yamaha CK88
roland rp 701 for 1140euros or roland fp 60x with 3 pedal stand for 1350 euros. which would be the better choice? usage only at home=will stay at the same place.
I'm quite surprise FP E-50 didn't included into the list. So its not one of the best digital piano deal for now considering the value it offer within the price range?
Of course, there are going to be a few pianos that we weren't able to squeeze into the video, but the FP-E50 is definitely a piano that greatly outperforms its price tag. :)
Me too... My FP-E50 arrived a day ago. Was a pain bringing it up 3 flights of stairs. (A feat given that I'm on the wrong side of 50...) The stand for it should be arriving on the 26th. Much better playing experience than the FP 30X. So many tones... May never get to the cloud... If I do it will be to download a boatload of synth sounds. So... I got this awesome piano sitting in front of my TV for a couple. Makes using the remote a little goofy... Like the comment below, Stu as always very informative.
Congrats on your FP-E50! It is an amazing, fully-loaded instrument as you've discovered. Plus, it is not just all bells and whistles. The core piano experience is wonderful. You'll be thrilled with it! :)
Thanks for tuning in! It really depends on the budget and the preferred form of the piano (i.e. portable versus console design). For us, the Kawai KDP120 has been the most popular digital piano choice for beginners. However, for those that are okay with a more streamlined piano or a portable piano, the Roland FP10 is a really attractive offering too. :)
Had the Roland stuff and was fine. For the money, the DGX-670 is incredible. I abhor built in speakers, but through cans it's amazing. The added style section can make for some serious compositions. Love your playing - kinda like Bobby Lyle! One more thing. I still LMAO when you demoed a keyboard and the drums kicked unexpectedly. You cracked up. More bloopers please!
Thanks so much for tuning in! I will be sure to pass on your kind words to Stu. Sometimes the onboard speakers leave a little to be desired, but the headphone experience can be top notch. Haha I'll pass on the note to our production team. Maybe more bloopers are needed on the channel. ;)
I got a Roland FP-30X from a retail store for $630 US just four weeks ago (3-2024). That was with an available 10 percent discount not everyone would qualify for. The same store was selling the Yamaha P-225 for the same price. $700 US list price for either instrument.
Hi! Brent here! Thanks for the suggestion! I will pass it along to our production team. I'm sure they will do their best to tackle that comparison for you. With that said, we are not Korg dealers so it may be difficult to include the C1 Air model. But, we do get pianos come through our inventory on trade, so it is not impossible. :)
Hi! Brent from Merriam Music here! We are not Korg dealers at this time and I personally don't have a lot of experience with that particular model. With that said, I will pass on the suggestion to our production team in case they are able to tackle that model in an upcoming review/comparison. :)
We are not Korg dealers, so it is difficult to tackle reviews/comparisons on their models. With that said, we do get pianos come in on trade, so we will do our best to tackle pertinent Korg models for you if possible.
@MerriamPianos thanks fore the reply, and sorry for the late reply. Regarding about the Z stand question no I haven't because when I got my digital piano the store only had X type stands🎹🎶
As an owner of a Montage and a MODX+ (not 88 key versions though), MODX+ is an amazing and very deep synth with also great (and infinitely tweakable) pianos. But bear in mind MODX+8 uses the GHS keybed that (for me) is distinctly inferior to Rolands PHA4. So I would probably agree that if piano is the priority, I would go for fantom 08 that Stu suggests. These two instruments are quite different in other areas too, but they both have strengths and weaknesses that in the end you will have judge for your use case. But since (understandably) most piano players pay a lot of attention to the action, I would probably go for the fantom. Even though I would marginally prefer Yamaha's piano sounds.
@@sonic2000gr I had five Roland digital pianos with PHA-4 action and all developed some problems after 3-4 months. I has been always some increase in action noise (clicking) but the most recent Roland digital piano had an issue with increased downweight of some white keys. Here are my measurements: Nov 22 2023 Feb 21, 2024 Middle C (C4) - 67g 75.2g C7 - 53g 55g C6 - 59g 70g C2 - ~66g ~78g C3 - 65.5g 78g I will not tolerate such heavy action. Yamaha C7 that I also practice on needs only 48g to move C4 Michael
@@mfurman A friend recently got an FP10 and is complaining about PHA4 weight. On the FP30X (of another friend) I've seen no such issue. That is strange.
It comes down to a matter of personal musical preference and context of use. There is no single "one size fits all" piano in each price category. For instance, some players will gravitate towards a warm tone, while others will connect with a bright tone.
You got X. Time to learn why Z. I got a Z-stand out of the gate and I'm on my first keyboard at age 70+. The price difference is not particularly significant. I paid $74 US for a Z stand and a decent X stand would have cost at least around $50 US.
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12 I got a Liquid Stands Z-stand. I'm using my keyboard (Roland FP-30X) purely for acoustic piano emulation. With the Z-stand, I was able to adjust the height of the keyboard to exactly 29-1/2 inches above the floor. That's the supposed standard height.
The problem is not the quality of the pianos. The problem is Stu. I've never heard anything he played sound bad. He could tap on a shoebox and you'd say... wow, I wanna buy that!
Haha I hear you on that front! I will certainly share your incredibly kind words with Stu on your behalf! I know he appreciates them. :)
Do you think this is a hidden advertisement for musical instruments? But don't you need to be a professional to make the most accurate review possible? I would be happy to meet a professional like Stu in person! The point is not how colorfully you describe everything. For example, I hear how “plastic” sounds float in the sound of some instruments, while some sound so juicy that I can’t even believe that this is not a real acoustic piano! (and this takes into account the fact that the sound example comes to us through RUclips, and not through a lossless recording!)
I have a small complaint. I did a lot of research before buying a Roland FP-30X for its capabilities as an acoustic piano emulator. The Casio Privia PX-S1100 is at exactly the same price point as the Roland FP-30X and the Yamaha P-225. All three listed for $699 at the store where I bought the Roland.
The Roland FP-30X and the Yamaha P-225 should be on this list along with the Casio Privia PX-S1100.
Thanks for writing in! It is important to note that the price gaps between various models vary quite a bit in different markets. Here in Canada, the price gap between the PXS1100 and FP30X/P225 is quite pronounced. However, they are still excellent value buys regardless, which is a testament to their quality. :)
I just ordered a FP-E50. I’m super excited to get my hands on it. Stu as always very informative.
Hi! Brent here! Congrats on your FP-E50! It is an awesome piano. You will be thrilled with what it has to offer!
@@MerriamPianos it took me a long time to decide but this channel was a great help to my decision. I haven’t felt more confident in my purchase.
My digital piano's rival. LOL! Injoy, and happy music making🎹🎶
Me too.@@Shogunai87
I own the px s3000. I mostly use it as a midi keyboard as i dont rate its onboard piano sounds at all. If you compare it to other keyboards in the price range there are others with a better piano tone.
I watched a blind test online of pro player trying many keyboards and he expressed the same feeling about the piano sounds on the Casio. Personally, I wouldnt buy Casio again, my next will be Roland or Kawai.
That is totally fair! Naturally, if you're mainly using the piano as a MIDI controller, that definitely changes the discussion in terms of features and priorities when buying.
@MerriamPianos Yes, I didn't intend to solely use it as a midi keyboard in the beginning, infact, quite the opposite. But because I was disappointed with the piano sounds on the 3000, I 99% just use it now as a midi controller, which I have to say is good in that respect for me.
However, I'm looking to buy something like Kawai next. But I'm unsure whether to go the vpc-1 midi controller only or an mp7se or even an fp90x or 60x.
I really want the best of both worlds. Where, if I just want to sit down and play without booting up a PC for midi samples, I can just turn on the keyboard and have a piano tone i enjoy. Or if I want to play samples on another occasion, I have a keyboard that is good for that too. Maybe Stu could do a review on that in the future. A great piano keyboard that has great feel, good onboard sounds and also makes a great midi controller for piano. Best of both worlds. 😉👍
Good to hear a recommendation for the underrated FP60X.
The FP60X still holds up as an excellent choice given its wonderful touch and sonic experience via the top-facing speakers. :)
Yes, Love my Kawai ES920 sounds! Great quick Wide Choices Review ! Thank you.
And.......after this board I definitely stick with Kawai Piano in near future....(701, 901..??)
That is awesome to hear! Thanks for tuning in - we're glad you enjoyed it! :)
6:14 Love it!😜@@MerriamPianos
Great complete review ! Thank you !
Thank you kindly! :)
Stu does the piano buying community a great service with his roundups and comparisons.
Logically, there wasn't time to explain all the advantages of each model, so I was left wondering why the Casio GP-510 was chosen over the GP-310. I really liked seeing the PX-1100 get a good appraisal, and also the Roland FP-60X and F-701. These worthy instruments have been a bit underrated in other reviews and threads
I was a little surprised that the RD-88 didn't get mentioned. Stu's last review of it was fairly glowing, and I was impressed when I tried it. The RD-88 is astonishingly cheap for such a versatile stage piano, and is highly portable as 88-key pianos go. If I needed a new 88-key gigging piano I would buy it straight away. My second choice would be the FP-60X. I view the latter as ideal for playing solo/duo in hotels, restaurants and small garden parties (and maybe it's nicer to practise on) but less ideal for band gigs.
The ES920 is a great alternative to the FP-60X, but (and this is very subjective) I prefer Roland actions and sounds. It's sad that Yamaha has nothing in this semi-pro plastic action portable piano category now, not really replacing the P-255 with anything similar. I've purchased five portable Yamahas during 35 years, but the way things are going, the brand of my next portable or stage piano is more likely to be Roland.
Thanks so much for the kind words and for sharing your insights! We definitely try to be as thorough as possible given that there are so many amazing models out there that don't always get a spotlight on them. :)
If I may ask do the hotels you play in have pianos in them?🎶
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12 Some do, but often they are in the wrong part of the hotel, or not working too well. On one occasion when I used a hotel piano, the poor client paid nearly as much for the piano use as for me. It's lovely when it all works out.
During a recent trip to Scotland I saw a nice village hotel which seemed to have a baby grand, and I was invited to try it. It turned out to be a P-125 in a custom-made cabinet. Amplification was separate. The cabinet, purchased from the Continent, cost 4000 pounds, or maybe euros. I was dismayed for the hotel, but I guess it was still cheaper than buying a digital baby grand.
There is an obvious market for a simple, durable, digital piano with a fake baby grand cabinet, circa 3000 dollars. The requirement is not being met by manufacturers. Even if it can't be an ebony finish at that price, a cheap shell must be possible.
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12I replied, and strangely it disappeared. More succintly now, some hotels have acoustic pianos, but often they are inaccessible or unplayable. Digital pianos get broken even more quickly.
A basic digital piano, esthetically good from all angles, is badly needed by the smaller hotels and restaurants. It doesn't need lots of extras, or to cost a fortune, but it needs to withstand a few knocks.
I'm in a real bind at the moment and ready to drop my money. Kawai CA701 vs the new Roland LX6? Problem is in my country the price of the kawai is the same as the LX5, the LX6 is £600 more. I'm still hoping for a DP603 or HP upgrade since their size is a little more compact. I'm in love with the lines of the 603 but its very old in the digital era.
Hi! Brent here! The CA701 is very impressive. I have not played the LX6 model yet, but, based on the specs and what I have heard, I am quite excited to do so as it looks to be an amazing instrument too! My suggestion would be to compare them in person to get a sense as to which one you connect with more.
@@MerriamPianos Yes, I played the CA701 and CA501 and loved the action of the 701 over the 501. I also tried the roland LX 706 which is incredibly cheap atm. i'm not sure about the LX bulk and relatively low power output on the old LX. I felt the PH50 action felt better than the CA501 but different maybe not better per se than the CA701 but the 701 has those really long balanced keys that felt incredibly light deep in to the the keys. I'm hoping to try the new LX6 in the coming weeks as I've heard the action on the LX6 and 9 has been upgraded. Thanks for your input.
I tried out the LX706 action recently and was quite disappointed after hearing such high praise. It doesn't compare to the grand feel of my MP11SE, which has apparently only been improved on successive versions. Honestly felt like a toy action in comparison.
Definitely interested in the new sounds of the LX models though.
Cn29 for $1,299 is pretty great for someone wanting a cabinet style piano with more room to grow than most people would ever need
Absolutely! That is a fantastic deal for a fantastic piano! :)
With the roland fp60x. You mention why you would get it over the fp90x . But what makes it stand out to justify the extra cost over its little brother the fp30x?
Watch a previous review and you will find the answer. 😉
Stu has touched on this before in previous videos and the top-facing speakers have a big impact on the quality of the sonic experience. I also know that Stu is a big fan of the PHA4 action. ;)
The controls and speakers on the 60X are much better. It also has more voices without going into app. Seems it has everything the 90X has except wood keys, full modelling, and quite such powerful speakers. But full modelling is still controversial.
I got a Roland FP-30X about four weeks ago. I am using it purely as an acoustic piano emulator. I chose it for that purpose and for that purpose it is superb. I am not schooled enough to assess it for other purposes, but I think as a gig keyboard or for emulating other keyboard instruments, it might not be the best.
Much depends on who is playing it though. I know there are people who use the FP-30X for all sorts of purposes, and the same for other instruments. I put the FP-30X at the top of the entry level price point along with the Yamaha P-225 and the Casio Privia SX-1100. The extra cost of an FP-60X would be justified if you were using the extra features you would be paying for if you bought one.
The heavy action of the Rolands is not for everyone. I reached the intermediate beginner stage a long time ago and that is where I am picking things up right now. I have learned, many of the traditional piano exercises (such as Hanon) are designed for the purposes of developing hand strength in the student. I already have big and strong hands and strength in all of my fingers. I don't think playing identical sequences in both hands is good training and I am already reconfiguring the exercises so that I am not playing the left and right hands in parallel. Exercises are good though. People should treat playing them correctly as an end in itself, not as a means to an end.
What about the Roland LX-6/LX-9?
I 100% agree with your views on the:
Kawai KDP120
Kawai ES920
Yamaha P-525
Yamaha CLP-725 (however now the P-525 is better value!)
Some of this comes down to the subjectivity and preferences of the player of course. I would say that the KDP120 is definitely a contender as well. I haven't personally tried the LX6 and LX9 models yet, but I am quite excited to!
@@MerriamPianos I mentioned the KDP120?
Nice video,
but there are a few typos in your Chapters. prs1100 -> pxs1100, prs6000 -> pxs6000, Kawaii CN 2011 -> Kawai CN 201, Kawaii ES920 -> Kawai ES920, Yamaha CA701 -> Kawai CA701, Roland F71 -> Roland F701, Yamaha CC888 -> Yamaha CK88
Thank you kindly! And thanks for catching those. We appreciate it. :)
The Ck88 seems to be really good. A review of this guy with Stu would be awesome!
Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle that for you. :)
roland rp 701 for 1140euros or roland fp 60x with 3 pedal stand for 1350 euros.
which would be the better choice? usage only at home=will stay at the same place.
I would give a slight edge to the RP701 for the aesthetic quality, but they are both quite comparable and offer an excellent musical experience. :)
CA701
Edit sorry missunderstud the comment. Nevermind what I said.
Edit they both have 701 in the name🎹🎶
I'm quite surprise FP E-50 didn't included into the list. So its not one of the best digital piano deal for now considering the value it offer within the price range?
Of course, there are going to be a few pianos that we weren't able to squeeze into the video, but the FP-E50 is definitely a piano that greatly outperforms its price tag. :)
Those appear to be Adam Audio studio monitors in the background. I must say that you have exquisite tastes.
Thank you kindly! I believe you are correct. :)
does px s 1100 have"hundred of sounds"?
I heard that too.
Every now and then there are a few slip ups. The PXS1100 has 17 tones. I believe Stu meant that the PXS3100 has hundreds of tones (700 to be exact).
4:33 you say its triplesensor control but in the picture it says dual sensor. did i misunerstood what you said?
Thanks for the correction! The graphic is incorrect.
Me too... My FP-E50 arrived a day ago. Was a pain bringing it up 3 flights of stairs. (A feat given that I'm on the wrong side of 50...) The stand for it should be arriving on the 26th. Much better playing experience than the FP 30X. So many tones... May never get to the cloud... If I do it will be to download a boatload of synth sounds. So... I got this awesome piano sitting in front of my TV for a couple. Makes using the remote a little goofy... Like the comment below, Stu as always very informative.
Congrats on your FP-E50! It is an amazing, fully-loaded instrument as you've discovered. Plus, it is not just all bells and whistles. The core piano experience is wonderful. You'll be thrilled with it! :)
Would the new Roland RD-08 make this list if it were not so new?
I would say absolutely! What Roland has packed into the RD-08 for its price point is quite crazy!
You mention that the Casio PXS1100 has hundreds of sounds, but I can only find something like 18 sounds on mine. Am I missing something?
I believe Stu meant to say the PXS3100. The PXS1100 is more streamlined in terms of its tone offerings.
Wow you play great!!! So for a beginner what piano do you recommend the most out of all the ones your named in this video?
Thanks for tuning in! It really depends on the budget and the preferred form of the piano (i.e. portable versus console design). For us, the Kawai KDP120 has been the most popular digital piano choice for beginners. However, for those that are okay with a more streamlined piano or a portable piano, the Roland FP10 is a really attractive offering too. :)
@@MerriamPianos Ok and thank you for your reply
Please make a review of the NI Komplete S88 MK3 with its included piano instruments
Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle that review for you. :)
Great video! Please do a full review of the Yamaha CK88!! Thanks :)
Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle that review for you if possible. :)
Had the Roland stuff and was fine. For the money, the DGX-670 is incredible. I abhor built in speakers, but through cans it's amazing. The added style section can make for some serious compositions. Love your playing - kinda like Bobby Lyle! One more thing. I still LMAO when you demoed a keyboard and the drums kicked unexpectedly. You cracked up. More bloopers please!
Thanks so much for tuning in! I will be sure to pass on your kind words to Stu. Sometimes the onboard speakers leave a little to be desired, but the headphone experience can be top notch. Haha I'll pass on the note to our production team. Maybe more bloopers are needed on the channel. ;)
I don't even know what's going on anymore... the FP30X is over 1K?
60X for 2K? Holy Jesus...
The prices have seen some fluctuation over recent years.
@@MerriamPianos if you call doubling "fluctuation" then sure...
Where is that? It's still like $700 in the USA for the Roland FP-30x
I got a Roland FP-30X from a retail store for $630 US just four weeks ago (3-2024). That was with an available 10 percent discount not everyone would qualify for. The same store was selling the Yamaha P-225 for the same price. $700 US list price for either instrument.
Roland RP30 vs KORG C1Air vsKAWAI KDP75 vs CASIO PX770?
Hi! Brent here! Thanks for the suggestion! I will pass it along to our production team. I'm sure they will do their best to tackle that comparison for you. With that said, we are not Korg dealers so it may be difficult to include the C1 Air model. But, we do get pianos come through our inventory on trade, so it is not impossible. :)
Just bought a Kawai Cn29 for $1299! I hope that it’s worth it, I just started learning to play
That sounds like a fantastic price for a fantastic piano! Best of luck with your piano journey. :)
Best wishes for your finger.. hope it's doing well
I will be sure to pass on the well wishes to Stu! Thanks!
In Europe DGX-670 and FP-E50 have almost the same price. Just saying.
The price points and price gaps do vary a bit from market to market of course. Thanks for sharing! :)
olá pessoal. Com o lançamento do roland go keys 3 e 5. Precisamos de uma comparação com o Casio CTs500 e 1000. Abraços do Brasil.
We will do our best to tackle those reviews/comparisons for you! Thanks for the suggestion! :)
What are your thoughts about the Korg SV2 S!??
Hi! Brent from Merriam Music here! We are not Korg dealers at this time and I personally don't have a lot of experience with that particular model. With that said, I will pass on the suggestion to our production team in case they are able to tackle that model in an upcoming review/comparison. :)
@@MerriamPianos it would be great!
I love what you are Doing!
Keep up with the good work mate!
4:25 by YDP series you mean the YDP185?🎹🎶
The YDP145 and YDP165 models are the ones that directly compete with the KDP120. :)
Why avoiding KORG products? Why not giving any attention at all?
We are not Korg dealers, so it is difficult to tackle reviews/comparisons on their models. With that said, we do get pianos come in on trade, so we will do our best to tackle pertinent Korg models for you if possible.
What about the middle finger?
Stu's middle finger did sustain an injury, but he is on the road to recovery! :)
@MerriamPianos thanks fore the reply, and sorry for the late reply. Regarding about the Z stand question no I haven't because when I got my digital piano the store only had X type stands🎹🎶
You are very welcome! Ah I understand. I definitely think a Z stand would be very worthwhile to look into. :)
Modx+ review sir I'm planning to buy that just want confirmation from you
We will do our best to tackle that if we can. :)
As an owner of a Montage and a MODX+ (not 88 key versions though), MODX+ is an amazing and very deep synth with also great (and infinitely tweakable) pianos. But bear in mind MODX+8 uses the GHS keybed that (for me) is distinctly inferior to Rolands PHA4. So I would probably agree that if piano is the priority, I would go for fantom 08 that Stu suggests. These two instruments are quite different in other areas too, but they both have strengths and weaknesses that in the end you will have judge for your use case. But since (understandably) most piano players pay a lot of attention to the action, I would probably go for the fantom. Even though I would marginally prefer Yamaha's piano sounds.
@@sonic2000gr I had five Roland digital pianos with PHA-4 action and all developed some problems after 3-4 months. I has been always some increase in action noise (clicking) but the most recent Roland digital piano had an issue with increased downweight of some white keys.
Here are my measurements:
Nov 22 2023 Feb 21, 2024
Middle C (C4) - 67g 75.2g
C7 - 53g 55g
C6 - 59g 70g
C2 - ~66g ~78g
C3 - 65.5g 78g
I will not tolerate such heavy action. Yamaha C7 that I also practice on needs only 48g to move C4
Michael
@@mfurman A friend recently got an FP10 and is complaining about PHA4 weight. On the FP30X (of another friend) I've seen no such issue. That is strange.
@@sonic2000gr I prefer the GHS over the PHA4 anyday. To each they're own🎹🎶
Ehmmm but what about KORG?
It is a matter of personal preference at the end of the day. Every player will have their own tone/touch preferences. :)
@@MerriamPianos I agree, but you have mentioned a Casio, Yamaha, Kawai and Roland. But you never seem to add anything from Korg, are they bad???
Hey I don't care about the brand. I hoped you'd have a best pick for each price range. I'm dissapointed.
It comes down to a matter of personal musical preference and context of use. There is no single "one size fits all" piano in each price category. For instance, some players will gravitate towards a warm tone, while others will connect with a bright tone.
Come on Roland, bring that new updated
RD-2000 STAGE PIANO to market porfavor:)
We have not received notice from Roland on an update as of this time, but we will definitely keep you posted. :)
Love my DGX670. The speakers, and sound are amazing. Now if my X stand would just stop dancing. LOL🎹🎶
I changed to a Z stand. Much more stable.
Glad to hear it! Have you tried a heavier duty Z style stand?
You got X. Time to learn why Z. I got a Z-stand out of the gate and I'm on my first keyboard at age 70+. The price difference is not particularly significant. I paid $74 US for a Z stand and a decent X stand would have cost at least around $50 US.
@@anonymike8280 oh X why Z good one haha. Yeah the store where I got my digital piano did not hav any in stock, and I was in a rush🎹🎶
@@MERCEDES-BENZS600GUARD_V12 I got a Liquid Stands Z-stand. I'm using my keyboard (Roland FP-30X) purely for acoustic piano emulation. With the Z-stand, I was able to adjust the height of the keyboard to exactly 29-1/2 inches above the floor. That's the supposed standard height.
Pleas get rid of the sound effects, It is not a PC game.
I will forward the feedback to our production team.
Thank you for the feedback. I will forward the suggestion to our production team.