My Response to Four Muslim Apologists
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Abdullah Sameer responding to 4 Muslim apologists by the names Farid, Yusuf Ponders, Emin and Asadullah in a video titled "Muslims react to viral ex-muslim video" where they react to my first upload that I made on why I left Islam back in 2016. Topics discussed include Dhul Qarnayn, Gog and Magog
🎬 Subscribe to my RUclips Channel: bit.ly/2HvOPhm
🎁 Support me at abdullahsameer.... 🍺
References
My original video: • Leaving Islam After Pr...
Their video: • Muslim's React To Abdu...
[1] sunnah.com/ibn...
[2] / 1235951126568108032
Other interesting videos:
► The great sacrifice of Eid • The great sacrifice of...
► Hajj, where people go to die • Hajj, where people go ...
► What you need to know before converting to Islam • What you need to know ...
► Debunking "Islam is a Feminist Religion" • Debunking "Islam is a ...
My articles:
► Debunking “The One True Islam” Fallacy / the-one-true-islam-fal...
► Muhammad’s false prophecies / muhammads-false-prophe...
Follow me at:
► Twitter: / abdullahadam
► Facebook: / abdullah.sameer.71
The original video they responded to now has 1.3 million views which I can't even believe myself. Some of them were polite, and some like Asadullah were downright condescending and even made fun of my voice/accent. I just ignored his foolishness though.
I'm proud to say that even after 4 years I still stand by my original arguments I made in that video and wouldn't change a thing. Maybe I would clarify or emphasize a couple of points, but really I am happy with what I said. This is really the first serious rebuttal I've received so far. I think early on I was too small so they just ignored me and hoped nobody would watch my content or I would just drop out, but that didn't happen. This channel is getting noticed. Let's keep hitting them where they feel it the most. Thank you for your support!
Yours
Abdullah Sameer
mobile.twitter.com/ProjectAndalus/status/1237009607832281089
So what is your logic of the biblical GOG AND MAGOG ? Why bash Islam only ?
1.3 million views doesn't mean all viewers agree with the points they made 👌🏻 there's always bound to be a few that will go on to watch your vids later and change their opinions after hearing what you have to say
I’ll be watching soon!
ä brother jihad doesn’t mean to kill innocent people it means strive to struggle . Unfortunately even in Quran it’s misinterpreted . Islam is a victim of miss interpretation of words like jihad and Martyrdom etc ...
It's very important we do our best to help create a positive, healthy & friendly dialogue that avoids making our discussions personal. All sides have been guilty of adding unnecessary needle and ad hominem. Ex-Muslims and Muslims often attack the individual rather than stick to the topic. I realise it's human nature because our egos can make us react badly, particularly when it relates to sensitive subjects like religion, but we must try to control our egos and be as humble as possible and not react to unkind remarks or personal insinuations. Always try to show empathy and understanding and strenuously avoid any temptation to add unnecessary needle.
Perhaps it's because I'm a Christian and tend to watch videos produced by Christians, ex-Muslims, or atheists, but my experience has been that Muslims resort to name-calling, ad hominem attacks, and vulgarity far more often than their Christian/ex-Muslim/atheist counterparts. Islam has hadiths that call for vulgar and insulting attacks against those who insult or blaspheme Muhammad, but Christianity does not endorse such behavior. Perhaps this could be a good area for a study of debate techniques among religious apologists.
Well said, and you have a great channel.
@Hassan. Narrow - minded Abrahamic religions as espoused by fully salaried preachers does contribute to pride, self righteousness and egoism.
@@ponygirl6258 Sure we do. Of course David wood, Sam Shamoun, all the folks from Jihad watch like Robert spencer, the likes of Christian Prince, Apostate Prophet, etc etc etc all belong to the Muslim community right? People who never make content inviting and teaching others about Christianity but only mocking Islam and the Muslims on the daily. You pony girl are jealous and obsessive over the amount of academics the Muslim community produces while you and your ilk have only david wood and his like to fall back on while leaving more credible and established with qualifications academics like James white in the dustbin cuz he and his kind refuse to mock Islam. You a Christian are watching and supporting atheists for the mere fact they go against Muslims how pathetic. This is a clear example of evil constantly uniting against truth. I mean the audacity to have someone like david wood as their champion but claim instead we are the people who mock and ridicule like really...the hypocrisy and double standards are mind boggling smh.
pony girl ruclips.net/video/maGo6eC9Z2Y/видео.html
Abdullah Bhai, I was also forced by my Pakistani and Indian Muslim friend to convert to Islam In Australia. I rejected to convert and end up loosing all friends. I am happy about it now.
Good on you bro, always supporting you.
Who needs friends like that??
Of people treat their "friends" like that, how are they real friends?
I'm glad you dodged that bullet!
Stay strong. Like Hinduism says, SATYAM , truth is god. This is enough- no other prophets or books are required.
Sanatana dharma allows many different paths, there is no force or coercion anywhere. Pick one and be strong
I am a new convert to Islam & you are throwing fake story to get likes! Hehe!
@@danielanderson2716 yes,My brother! Welcome to Islam ..Assalaam-o-alaikum :D
This was my problem. I started to think like: “OK, if I believe that there is some giant wall made from steel somewhere on Earth and 99 billion people are behind that wall, then how can I say that some stories people (non-muslims) believe aren’t fairytales? Then I literally believe in something so unreal, much more unreal than trinity or 12 shia Imams-demigods
@TrustMeImAScientist1 nah, all religions are fairytales
How is the trinity even remotely related to the idea that there may be people living under the radar of modern civilization? Take for instance the North Sentinel islands, they have never contacted modern humans. You must have not watched the entire podcast by the muslims responding. There are many explanations and possibilities about yagog and magog's existence such as the fact that they may be a small population while hiding and could exponentially grow in number when they escape. Another explanation is that they are numerous in terms of the population at the time of their release. I have no idea where you got the idea that there are 99 billion behind a wall, that is definitely the reality of the situation. There are many many different interpretations about this issue and you can choose yourself what you want to believe about it. I don't see how this is an issue...
i am a Muslim , ask me questions
Recently they found a wall made of metal on the border of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan
The story of Zul Qarnian is also interpreted to be metaphorical!! After so many years they still have no clue who the man is! And there are no candidates for this title! 12 imams are not demi gods lol! You are ignorant and uneducated about these topics! Your assumptions therefore sound more idiotic than logical!
x muslim from Bangladesh , keep up the good work . love ur videos
Lol, you probably didn't know your religion well enough. A lot of Bangladeshis mix culture with religion!
Ex Muslim here too
It is too ironic.
The Quran claiming Alexander as a servant of Allah, when he was actually a Pagan and arguably the founder of Western Civilization, Islam's nemesis.
Not to mention, a bi-sexual and claimed divinity through Amon-Ra. Allah clearly didn't know who Alexander really was.
Lel something you all made up, no where in the quran you will find that Alexander is mentioned
in anyway or form.
In fact if you look through all the tafaseer you won't find even a single mention of Alexander
Imbeciles....
@@abdurahmanyaqub, it's said that the figure of dhul quarnain was inspired in Alexander the great. I have heard this more than once and I am not even a Muslim.
@@bellycurious lul so by hearing it spread among your circle of idiots make it automatically true? first time i have heard of that...
You know i grew up in a Muslim country among Muslim scholars traveled to Muslim lands to different teachers... and not one and i mean it, not once the mention or even know who Alexander is... in fact Arabs them self didn't really know him so your argument would better off stay in your lying deceiving mouth
@@abdurahmanyaqub It doesn't help with the koran being conveniently vague (as usual) on the subject. For argument's sake it isn't Alexander. Who else could it be? Cyrus? Darius? It doesn't really make it any better or any different if it were either of them. Even your own scholars aren't entirely sure who this person is.
Abdullah Sameer is a great human being and has deep understanding. His explanations of the matter is superb.
Dr LYN CHRISTIAN PRINCE AS BEN VERY FUNNY
ruclips.net/video/8mQcgZilg4Y/видео.html
HOW2WIN FROM CP? ROFL PART 1
ruclips.net/video/3CDq2dMdGKM/видео.html
10 WAY CP IS DODGY
ruclips.net/video/maGo6eC9Z2Y/видео.html
@@ISLAMICPREACHERAPOLOGIST I wwonder in what why sameer is a great human? the boy just get schooled and further humiliates himself by responding back. you know talking to a brick wall wot get you anywhere anyway.
@@sparrow3491 He is a great human because he is doing in his own way necessary work that puts his life at risk. It's not about being correct all the time, it's about being honest and brave.
Thanks for this anti-response! I'm now a better Muslim because of this video :)
Mee too.. it proves that quran is the absolute truth.. 😊
@@MuhammadAbdillah111 no
This giant wall either exists or it doesn't. It's that simple.
@A if its on the surface of the earth we should be able to see it
it doesn't exist. very simple indeed.
@A there's this totally other true book called lord of the rings that was revealed to the great prophet jrr tolkien pbuh. check it out.
@A so if i claim there is a teapot orbiting Jupiter and you say no there's not, the burden is on you to prove there's not, and not on me to prove there is? muslim logic.
CHRISTIAN PRINCE AS BEN VERY FUNNY
ruclips.net/video/8mQcgZilg4Y/видео.html
HOW2WIN FROM CP? ROFL PART 1
ruclips.net/video/3CDq2dMdGKM/видео.html
10 WAY CP IS DODGY
ruclips.net/video/maGo6eC9Z2Y/видео.html
Rabbis asked about Dhul Qarnayn, and it's well-known fact that Alexander the Great was an important person in the old Jewish culture, a "virtuous pagan" that helped Jews.
That's Cyprus you idiot not Alexander
"...you can see how mental gymnastics gets upgraded to *Mental Olympics* ..."
I'm going to use this in my conversations whenever i get the chance from now on.. without giving you credit of course 😁
this is what mental illness looks like
you can have a friendly neighborhood ex muslim
but you can't have a muslim one.
@Bostaan Naam I never seen an atheist who convert back to islam but i've seen a lot of ex muslims.
@@fraddi lol
As an ex Ismaili then ex Sunni Muslim: thank you. Question: do you sometimes remember yourself as a Muslim and can understand why are these Muslim apologist are defending Islam like they are! To see prove of your perfect faith being wrong so many times and constraining yourself everyday to not doubt Islam is a very blinding and hard thing to have on oneself.
You have deluded yourself
Where the evidence came from? Sameer? 😂😂😂 You must be joking.. I don't believe liars..
@@Yusufalsylheti Islam is 100% false, complete 7th century invention.
@@FriendwithNoName7 nice joke
The idea Muhammad couldn't possibly have known about a few things in the Talmud is absurd. He spent years in Medina. Are we to suppose that no Arabian Jews knew so much as a few stories in the Talmud, bearing in mind that the Talmud originally was oral tradition!
Muhammad had a jewish teacher and had contact with jewish tribe numerous of time.
@@nickjohn2051 Yep, though many Muslim apologists that know this make their brains switch off when this point is expedient.
Funny enough, you find accusations against Mohammad in the Quran itself. This clearly shows that the people of the time knew he was a fraud.
@@houseofsofia6650 exacely
@@houseofsofia6650 The biggest event that showed he was fraud is during isra' and micraj as Muhammad claimed he travelled all the way to jerusalem and flew on flying donkey to space all in one night. Numerous "sahaba" apostate immediately after hearing the story. Another one when Muhammad claimed he had dream of marrying aisha at 6 years old.
Farid keeps talking about the "proofs of Islam" but he never mentions what exactly they are. I would like to know what these proofs are
Farid, as always lacks elaboration.
Nobody knows...
He’s literally made a 15min video on it 😂😂😂
ruclips.net/video/k7Bzk7Wtl8Q/видео.html
@Zatchooze NautA request which is probably impossible- Ignore biases before watching! ruclips.net/video/uwSxSemmdDE/видео.html
The fact that they are not bothered by the dhul qarnayn issues shows that they don't understand that the Quran has severe plagiarism issues
Friendly neighborhood ex-muslim! Love it! Truth Teller!
Orgasm Donor ex Muslims get attacked by anti Muslim bigots in the west beacuse they can easily be mistaken to be Muslims
"Disclaimer: None of this is correct, we're just wildly speculating."
😂😂
So glad you're replying to this, I was watching it and imagining what you might say. Have fun with this drivel. 😊👍
He can make response videos but he won't respond to the points🤣 watch this: ruclips.net/video/QA5tgC9DXO8/видео.html
If God is prepared to talk about Yajuj and Majuj despite there being no evidence at the time or fourteen hundred years on, why not also talk about dinosaurs, the giant Moas of New Zealand, platypus's and penguins. If Islam is true I think that might have saved a good many souls from hell over the past few hundred years had it been mentioned.
@@WeAreGhuraba You ignored the point I made at the end "If Islam is true I think that ('that' being mention of the animals unknown of at the time) might have saved a good many souls from hell over the past few hundred years had it been mentioned). Of course, it wouldn't have to be the things I mentioned specifically, they were merely examples. I for one think that if the Koran spoke of them, or something equally unlikely to be known of, it would have prevented a great many people from leaving Islam and roasting in hell forever who otherwise would have left. Don't you?
I think saying something that might convince a doubter and prevent them burning in agony forever is rather relevant.
@@WeAreGhuraba Not sure what your first point has to do with anything. I became an atheist ten years ago. Does that affect the argument one way or another? I've never been a Muslim and its difficult to say what I personally would have made of them in light of all the nonsense passages. However, I'm sure it would have helped a huge number of those many people who desperately wanted Islam to be true, but the lack of evidence left them feeling compelled to leave. Another thing in answer to your question is this; I've seen a huge number of Muslims giddy with excitement about the amazing proof their religion is true and this so called evidence was much much shoddier that the example I gave. While it may not have convinced everyone, it would probably have convinced many millions and thereby spared them a fate worse than the holocaust.
@@WeAreGhuraba
But the thing is abiut your answer to Stopscammingman:
Let's say for examples sake that if you were wrong abiut islam, and it actually wasnt from God or not the best source and would not help you........would you even want to know? Would you have faith that Truth is always good no matter what it turns out to be, and you could find something better?
I think the very basis of the claims of islam are very flawed, and this is an example, which other things claiming to be God's Truth don't have.
Lets compare with some other source that *_also_* claims to have discovered God's Truth &/or even teach people how to discover it for themselves:
www.divinetruth.com & related RUclips Channels, inc an FAQ.
Now you may think it is bullshit because it conflicts with the claims of Mohammed & the claims of the book you believe is from God. Fair enough, that's what anyone in your postion would say. I even did, but i wasnt a Muslim (although I did consider islam when seeking for Truth).
BUT BUT BUT this Divine Truth DOES meet exactly the criteria that Stopsacmmingman brings up, which the Mo & the qur'an do not:
God would definately predict that people would question the validity of the voice Mo claimed he had in his head, which claimed to be from God, and the book that was written after his death based on this belief.
There are many competing claims.
God would obviously realize that anyone seeking truth would *_put different claims to the test._*
Divine Truth does actually give a LOT of factual and useful info that - if it turns out to be true when put to the test - that would show it it true or false.
And there is much more criteria that it meets, that religions that originate as voices in people's heads (such as islam) do not.
@@WeAreGhuraba
So I put to you that it is actually a fair and reasonble argument.
I don't think it is the central reasons why I'm personally quite sure that islam is a waste of time IF someone is seeking truth about life or God, but it is still one.
I've wasted a lot of time in my life, and I can relate to the painful recognition of that.
Btw - we are not necessarily seeking the same thing.
If you get what you want in islam, I'm not going to change you.
But this is not a muslim channel, so raising such questions & being trithful about then is very valid.
Cheers
@@WeAreGhuraba
And the question is not about waiting for angels. It was back then and is today: "Mohammed, how do I know we can trust you, or trust the voice in your head?
Because that was the source of islam.
Or "Why would I have faith in some soure claiming to be God's Truth, how would it benefit humans and how would I put it to the test?"
That is for anything claiming to be God's Truth, including the ones you didn't know about. Islam does not meet them, but other sources do.
In science this is called a theory being "falsifiable".
And surely if God exists (which I think ia very likely true)......then do you really think he/she is more irrational or evil or deceptive than even humans? I do not.
Cleverly done.
The stuff you are putting out is a complete joke. It doesn't even have
the semblance of being professional or a scholarly critique.
Funniest thing to me is how you all are making those claims, while back in reality, none of you can even properly refute anything he says. So the last ditch effort in a desperate attempt to sound smart you resort to ad hominem. Pretty weak and pathetic if you ask me.
5:25 indeed muslims are made to believe from early age qoran is never wrong, islam is perec, mohamed was perfect, so they want to fit everything into that dogma.
Your blinded by the liar people , he a child molester, died on the grave, while Jesus still alive on heaven
@@nolardogeral1861 why did abraham sleep with his sister (Genesis 20:12) ?
Great stuff as always Abdullah. Amazing 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
Of course it is if you don't want to listen to the other side of the truth:ruclips.net/video/QA5tgC9DXO8/видео.html
I left Islam last year. I just want to say thanks to you guys. You are very brave.
Keep telling the truth about this cult, you are a brave man
Forgive these four "apologists" ! They appear to have invested too much in Islam and the Quran to even consider that they could be mistaken or deluded ! All they can do now is to somehow defend the indefensible. Not everybody is like you, Abdullah Sameer (and many other ex-muslims) who thought it was never too late to call spade a spade and bravely confront the facts.
Saleem Raza CHRISTIAN PRINCE AS BEN VERY FUNNY
ruclips.net/video/8mQcgZilg4Y/видео.html
HOW2WIN FROM CP? ROFL PART 1
ruclips.net/video/3CDq2dMdGKM/видео.html
10 WAY CP IS DODGY
ruclips.net/video/maGo6eC9Z2Y/видео.html
Well .... the same thing goes for sameer right? He apparently made alot of attention as an ex muslim and invested alot of time in that so he probably wont think he is wrong.
I have one argument to finish you, actually person, Mohammed Hijab.
mimi - golden shower - hijab, we love him
Let's thank these geniuses for giving you the exposure and also for helping you and your channel's growth.
Applied modes of reasoning and techniques of persuasion are the best videos on this channel.
9:50 So Sahih Hadiths are weak now? That would be good news
Muslims now pick and choose which hadith suits their agenda irrespective of authenticity.
Hadiths has always been cancerous to Islam ... but made legal by Saudi driven Wahhabi fundamentalists.
Just because one institution claims that it is sahih doesn't make it sahih. There are not only sahih hadiths in the 6 Sunnan books. Don't talk about hadith if your knwoledge is based off a couple Ex-Muslim YT clips
@@thenotoriousm0e852 frrr bruh they think they understand a whole science based off of an ex Muslim RUclips with no credentials in Islam smh
As a muslim i defend your right to be an apostate.
If you believe there is nothing wrong in being a disbeliever and an apostate then you probably aren't a Muslim yourself.
عبد الله there is nothing wrong - Mullah’s tells you that it’s wrong , not Islam.
Today’s Islam is all about Mullah vs Allah
@@aleefmohammed244 Did Allah say the disbelievers and apostates will go to Jahannam or the Mullahs? If you believe it is permissible for a person to be a disbeliever then make no mistake you would be a disbeliever yourself.
عبد الله there is no compulsion in religion and anyone is free to believe what they believe. God is the best of judges so there is no such thing that heaven is reserved only for Muslims.
@@aleefmohammed244 Then you disbelieve in the Quran saying that the disbelievers are in Hell?
Mr. Abdullah Sameer i respect ur decision regarding leaving islam... But ur perception about islam is very low.... Pls don't think quran in that perception... U r an intelligent and knowledgeable man... Pls study furthur about this history, science in other perception many scientist and historians reverts to isalm... So, study furthur Mr. Abdullah sameer...don't judge too early...
Those historians and sientists were decieved
Brother Abdullah Sameer may peace and blessings be with you 💞💕🇦🇺
Yes
Believing in gog and magog alive for thousands of years is crazy.
Love u abdullah ,lot of love to u and fullest support to u always.
First of all, brother Sameer, you are an incredible and amazing person. I respect your perceptive, way of thinking, way of speaking, and ideas. You allowed me to open my eyes and to think freely. Doubt and curiosity totally had been in myself for a very long time. These kind of video, always got the best answers. I hope to see your next upcoming video. I wish you the very best and hope for your well-being. I will support you in anyway that's possible.
They discussing with each others.. You know if you discuss something with the fact that everyone was based on the argument that was from the same source (quran & hadith), same idea, same interpretation, same perspective, you arent going anywhere.. your knowledge wont develop and even sometimes went backwards. religion is like that, "unaltered words form God", "unaltered laws of religion", hence no changes had been made. no space for growing, no space for change, no space allowed for betterness, all of these will not allowed our nature as human being to contemplate more from others, to learn, to grow.. all that were grew are what? multiples babies and wifes, child-marriage, more veil for women?? come one, even music arent allowed in islam, paintings of people or animal, limit the ikhtilat so there is no zina, and much more to say...
Gog and Magog remind me of those aliens that attacked wakanda in Avengers infinity war.
So a reason to leave Islam is because you don’t believe in the unseen? Isn’t that pivotal to belief?
why did you ignore 90% of their replies???? are u scared to admit you’re wrong
well done Abdullah Sameer you are the modern time 111
Abdullah it is a mystery to me that these nevertheless developed people continue to believe in this nonsense you are my example. 👍👍👍💕
Jerome Syed I think more people in the world don't believe it.
@@fatimaachy5764 like believers in amazigh nationalism
Speech is very important and so is the terminology we used to describe other people and the continuation of those terms.
I think most atheists know a lot about religion and have been involved in them. They can then use logic and reason. If you have an open mind then you can be flexible and acknowledge that you might be wrong on some things. But most religious apologetics are rigid and defensive so it's hard to reason things out with them
@. ok
@. what is your opinion about them
@. ok
As someone who agrees with Sameer to a large extent, I have to disagree with you a bit.
There are plenty rigid atheists out there too.
Many of them are presuppositionalists and absolutely refuse to budge.
@. Refuse to budge on the complexity of the Universe and Human brain came from nothing ?
Excellent advice for all skeptics Abdullah! Thank you!
Just one and simple question to Muslims:
What sort of evidence they would accept to admin that islam is false ???
John Baljian EXCUSE ME GOG MAGOG IN BIBLE TOO
I wonder why it is difficult to admit the obvious.
Matthew Imuetinyan cognitive dissonance...they can see the flaws in other scripture but not in their own
@@tanjavankessel9842 imagine thinking the word of God has flaws lmao
That guy bottom right is Thunderf00t's nemesis. I remember him from back in the day.
As always, great video. Abdullah taking down 4 Muslim apologists singlehandedly as per Quran 2:249 "How many a small company has overcome a large company by permission of Allah. And Allah is with the patient." Subhanallah!
If you believe that Muhammad flew on a winged horse to another dimension with 0 tangible evidence, then the sky is not the limit to how absurd your beliefs can get.
Lol, thank you Mohamed
Abdullah Sameer My pleasure. 😃👍🏻
Probably it was about the Alexander the great. The Mog and Magog story.
Thanks bro for information ,man your smile is amazing be happy n spread truth,
Do not interact with the outsiders, stay in the loop, the echo-chamber, don't you like finally belonging in a tight-knit community where all share the same major activities and world-view as yours. Do not engage with outsiders because they might actually convince you otherwise.
I've seen multiple other communities which basically functioned like that and that definitely raised more red than green flags, if any.
Despite my initial bias towards Islam being the truth and the only salvation I can't just pretend that I don't see and recognize a pattern here.
You, sir, you are doing too, like another christian apologists, the work of the True God... You are saving souls...
👎:ruclips.net/video/QA5tgC9DXO8/видео.html
Loved your content...😁
My friend read Ezekiel 38 it talks about The same story about Gog And Magog. Also Hebrew have it mentioned.
Read Ezekiel 38-39 my friend carefully.
And since when was the BIBLE was the quran criterion...oh yeah...muhammad acquired the BIBLE to the followers if they have any doubts.
How many of you guys see the insecurity fear in these 4 dudes eyes?
Atheism on the other hand is completely irrational it cannot be demonstrated in reality, it contradicts any sort logical thing it's a load of nonsense
@@damxcv Actually atheism is far more rational than any theism.
Theism: Just blindly accept what some superstitious savages wrote centuries back and believe that while having Z E R O evidence to back it up.
Atheism: Continues to inquire into the truth and are WILLING to accept it if some actual solid evidence is presented.
It's much better to ADMIT we DON'T know something and strive to figure it out, instead of PRETENDING like we DO know it, and KILL those who dare question our predetermined answers.
Let this 4 guys to debate Abdullah so we can learn more
Great video. Made it till the end. They're apologistic arguments were bad and pathetic as always.
Yet Abdullah doesn't even have much subscribers. Look at the number of subscribers in any of their channels
@@lovehate2994 Lol, numbers don't prove anything! Abdullah Sameer audience: Non Muslims who are SEARCHING for faults in Islam! (Quite huge)
Muslim apologists audience: Muslims (excludes many who don't know of him and just can't be bothered hearing responses to PATHETIC CLAIMS. The response videos are actually directed more towards non muslims who believe his nonsense but obviously if you want to stay Ignorant then there is nothing they can do!
@@lovehate2994 Abdullah Sameer makes a claim (which is a lot easier) then Muslims apologists have to go through even more time to explain the misunderstandings and lastly this Abdullah Sameer isn't even literate in islamic studies!
Abdullah Sameer - Ibn Warraq, also a former Muslim, and an author of 19 books, wrote his first book, Why I Am Not a Muslim, sourcing from his comprehensively extensive knowledge of Islamic history. A compelling, fascinating read, one learns of two streams of Islam, both from two stages of Muhammad's life, in early Mecca, and later Medina. Both Muslim and non-Muslim scholars agree, that this created two Qu'rans. The Mecca Qu'ran and the later, abrogated Qu'ran, the Medina Qu'ran. Learning this clarified the perplexing statements of the two opposing streams, claiming to be following the prophet. As a Yehudi Torah kabbalist grandmother, I deeply appreciste your courage, and unfliching stand for the truth. Blessings..
Good video. Aisha saw right through Muhammad's charade when she stated: "Your Lord hastens to grant you wishes."
And despite seeing through this apparent charade, continued to eulogize, remember with great fondness and become one of the greatest scholars in Islamic tradition.
@@HZ_LionsDen Well she was a child when he started his child abuse on her disguised as marriage . Most likely the poor girl suffered from what we now know today as Stockholm Syndrome ." Stockholm syndrome is a psychological response. It occurs when hostages or abuse victims bond with their captors or abusers. This psychological connection develops over the course of the days, weeks, months, or even years of captivity or abuse.
With this syndrome, hostages or abuse victims may come to sympathize with their captives. This is the opposite of the fear, terror, and disdain that might be expected from the victims in these situations.
Over the course of time, some victims do come to develop positive feelings toward their captors. They may even begin to feel as if they share common goals and causes. The victim may begin to develop negative feelings toward the police or authorities. They may resent anyone who may be trying to help them escape from the dangerous situation they’re in."
@@Unknown-yd2vn 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 She wasn't kept hostage. Also it is recorded how he would treat her! Stockholm syndrome! Really?🤦🤦🤦🤦 As well as that you forgot that girls would get married off younger back then!
This!!!!!! She knew she knew she knew
great vid really enjoyed the alexander references thank you
They are already shaken & therefore comforting themselves as the truth pricks aggressively
Shake by what?
@@diorz38 shaken not shake by the thruth that reveals fabrication throughout their literature & coverups
@@jayesjjani2278 fabrication? Coverup? Mhmm are you sure that's islam?
For farid, The truth alone is dayif !
Everything other than the truth is sahih
Fifi has no answers
@@pinpoint3770 he does! Answer to all your question is "it's dayif"
@@AndysMusicPod u r a liar.
Farid did not say this hadith was dayif.
grow up kid.
@@Servant_0f_Allah. Of course he did 😂😂
Maybe you should grow up and get your own internet service and watch his videos 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Abdullah sameer dont let these 4 take on your case. Because belive me. These 4 will ruin you. Belive!!! 🤣😂
all u ex muslims dont effect islam, Allah replaces u with better people. Islam is the fastest growing religion, 2 billions muslims and counting. we shall find out what the truth is after death when the angel of death comes to take our souls. not long left till we find out.
I like this background better than the other green screen one :)
More Original and laid back :)
This guy be like : It's complicated therefore it must be wrong
belief in krishna is also complicated why dont ubelieve in it?
@@whydontyoustfu because it doesn't make sense
@@primeminister1040 ahh invisible billions of alien creature somewhere hidden on earth makes sense right😂
@@whydontyoustfu alien creatures?
@@primeminister1040 gog magog
If the story were true about gog and Magog, the Greek historian would have written about it. It's obvious that the Quran is all fabules.
fascinating stuff thanks.
Sameer you are an awesome and gracious chap. It takes gut to be consistent to your beliefs unlike the turkeys you are responding to!
Suddenly you have become one of my favorite ex-Muslims... :)
2:23 EPIC COMPELLING DRAW ZOOM-IN 🤣🤣🤣
As you may have noticed, the folk who made the vid are now in botched damage control mode.
I asked Farid if bukhari hadith number 3175 is authentic ,no response . What a smart move not to answer.
Never stop making content !!! 👏🏽
Islam is very, very EVIL.
We all know that . STAY AWAY FROM ISLAM !
My friend, you are dynamite!!!
Mannnn ...the level of mental Gymnastics😂😂😂
"Asadullah was so rude and he made fun of my accent" 😭😭😭 wah wah
And they say, "None will enter Paradise except one who is a Jew or a Christian." That is [merely] their wishful thinking, Say, "Produce your proof, if you should be truthful."Q 2:111
Its funny cause all the guys refuted you
Trymetrds
He has a shoe in his head, his only argument is calling these polite men ‘apologists’
They're gonna flag this pls report to RUclips for any issue
Flag it how? I was respectful throughout
@@AbdullahSameerVideos I meant copyright infringement
@dimmy dunk wt u mean
I'm curious, when they pray 5x/day what do they say in the prayers?
Google it
Its a bunch of supplications and then lots of Quran
Ex Muslim here too.
Islam if just like a brain problem
I flunk in Islam on day 1.
Where is angel Gabriela?
Abdullah, you're a nice genuine guy. Keep your head up and expose the lies of Islam
You need a lot more views dude, you are posting some good content, straight facts
Trying to make blue orange doesn't make it orange. It will always be blue. The Qur'an is book of fables to relegated to stone age book.
wait so if we defend islam, and the quran then we’re ignorant??? how does that make sense there are reasonable explanations to your fabrications and silly points lmao, stop forcing your views down peoples throats
they aren't your beliefs, your parents and their parents handed them down. you would think differently if you weren't brought up with them
No gog and Magog is not a big a problem for Islam . The evidence for Islam is different . One story nobody understands cannot disprove Islam.
For the story of Gog and Magog one delivered historcial evidence coming from this region is the median wall (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_Wall) located between Tigris and Euphrates. Then Dhul Quarnain would be Nebuchadnezzar II.
I think the Hadith was Sahih according to Dar-us-Salaam Publications as opposed to Ibn Majah. Just a side note. Excellent points as usual.
False . It’s only Yusuf Ali’s opinion that Dhul Qarnayn was Alexander the Great . Most tafsirs say it’s Cyrus the great of Persia
haha best man ... walking dead or lord of rings xD
Predictions are so subconcious and unaware that you are not aware of until the shock comes in. Heck making predictions is the existence.
Thank you for this video.
6:41 'this is all speculation' are you saying the quran is not as clear as it states?
is on the thumbnail "Apostate Prophet" ?
Farid Responds got responded. Farid try to expose but got exposed.
I would like to listen your criticism about bhagwat Geeta.
@Nym GRACE it's not big book,he can read it in 1 week..you don't need to be Hindu to criticize bhagwat Geeta.
Farid is barbage. Rest of them, I need to check.
Andalus is the one, who worked in Malaysia in security/intelligence field???
Andalus in sec intel? Ahahhahahaha. I literally lived there and pdrm (the police department) never ever got a clue who he is. Heck even pdrm special branch that consist of multiracial team catching the ISIS mole and islamic terrorist way covert than him. He just have a delusion of grandeur.
i see you found him intimidating
@@nickjohn2051 Yea sure buddy, you some random nobody that isn't providing receipts for the claims you're giving. He worked as a civilian contractor of some sorts. Not really a big deal and he never made it out as such you insecure beta male.
@Kate M.H. Ok Maam
@@WeAreGhuraba >civilian contractor that no one know where he works?
>Even PDRM special branch has no clue who the fuck he is
>face like soy boy
>Bald
>Still doing Phd on useless paper on philosophy and theology that have no impact on citation index, and usefullness on the world.
>his fan can only resort to name calling his opponent "beta male" even though, most Muslim man typically are among the oldest to lose virginity.
No, it's Stephen King's The Dome ✔