What If Russia Won The Crimean War?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- Watch next: "Every Significant Mongol Successor State; How The Mongols Fell in 1857"
• Every Significant Mong... -~-
#possiblehistory #alternatehistory #alternatehistoryofeurope #Russia #europe
The Crimean War was a very important war of the 19th century. It saw France under Napoleon III stand up to Russia's claims over churches in the Ottoman empire. From this it grew into a larger conflict, where Britain, France, Sardinia-Piedmont and the Ottomans faced off against Russia. The coalition of the Western powers came out victorious, but what if this changed? If Russia won the war, would they have taken the entire Balkans, paving the way for global domination?
If you like the content please like, comment and subscribe, it helps smaller channels like mine to get noticed!
If you want to support the channel you can go to my Patreon or become a member! You will get early access to video's and will be allowed to suggest priority video subjects!
/ possiblehistory
/ @possiblehistory
www.buymeacoff...
Possible Extra's a channel where we do not necessarily history related stuff, like podcasts and more!
/ @theobserverph
Gaming Channel:
/ @deletedchannel1010
Feel free to follow or join our social media platforms:
/ possiblehistory
/ possiblehistor1
/ discord
/ possible_history0
Most of our music by Beta Records. He's great, check him out!
Link: goo.gl/peHHCX
A lot of other music by Kevin McLoad. The Copyrightfree Music Creator
/ kevinmacleodarchive
Thank you all for watching! To support the content leave a like and a comment on the video, interaction really helps boost the video performance. For more weekly alternate history content, consider subscribing to the channel!
Did you forget about Sardinia's involvement in the Crimean War?
I love your alternative history videos, please make more.
Brilliant video, cant wait for our collaboration this week!
I have a suggestion: What if the German Empire had never been a colonizer? Bismarck strongly opposed colonialism for his whole life because colonies were expensive and undefendable (history proved right both) but for diplomatic and internal reasons he allowed it. I would like to hear more about Africa in general though.
@@DieJacke The map has more blue and red on it (France and Britain).
You’re single-handedly saving the alternate history community.
What does he do different?
@@guardianevan8406 he doing alt history not geo politics like other channels
@@guardianevan8406 He isn't a fascist like Z and -zvalid or whoever- Zvallid.
@@guardianevan8406 he actually does alternate history
@@concept5631 Zvallid? The guy who made the "How Germany could've won WW1." video?
Here's an underrated POD: what if Italy had unified as a federal state in 1848, rather than as an unitary state in 1861?
This would need the Pope to be kinda leader of it. Sardinia and Two Sicilies were the most significant powers among Italian states, and last one was heavy influenced by the Pope.
Maybe co- Rule of Charles Albert and Pii 9?
@@alexzero3736 That's what quite a few thinkers actually wanted, back then. And it was the Pope's sudden change of heart that sunk the whole thing. An even more niche POD would be for the brief alliance between the Duke of Modena and revolutionary Ciro Menotti to endure, in the 1830s. There was a whole, hare-brained scheme to put the former on the Italian throne after a series of revolts engineered by the latter.
You might even see the weird thing of federal Italy getting pointers and inspiration from the United States who got it from Rome.
Each Italian state would have conflicting laws and much more local like the Holy Roman Empire or modern US states.
Could see pope in an alt modern-day being basically a more politically stronger British monarch, think like most president in Europe or USA vice president.
He is much more as a face and tourism and soft power like British monarch.
Yeah you might see him flex it once a lifetime but popeman likely wouldn't.
See USA vice president being a tiebreaker vote being relevant.
@@JB-bb1bh One of the main theorists of 19th century Italian federalism, Carlo Cattaneo, had Switzerland and the United States in mind - in fact, he moved to Switzerland later on in his life - so it's likely that a federal Italy would've resembled something in between them, except there would've been quite a lot of variety in the forms of government of the individual states, with monarchies and republics under the same flag.
Oh yes, I really want to see that! I'm not really sure why such a diverse country with many urban centers and languages ended up as unitary.
I like how you actually make realistic scenarios instead of just making ludicrous claims about how something ridiculous could have definitely happened, and when you do make an unrealistic scenario for fun, you make it clear that it is unrealistic.
It would be nice if other such channels would do that. I actually had one reply to me in a comment saying that the scenario in their video wasn't supposed to be serious, but never once in the video did they even imply that.
One thing which wasn't mentioned is Greek participation in the war. Greece, a newly established kingdom, with large claims on Ottoman territory, was unsatisfied with the British position of supporting the territorial integrity of the Ottoman Empire. As soon as the Crimean War started, armed insurrections began in Thessaly, Epirus and parts of Macedonia, with support from Greece. The revolts saw success, however attacking the Ottoman Empire meant that Greece was indirectly on the side of the Russians. Britain initially offered Greece the Ionian islands and small adjustments in the borderline in Thessaly to stop supporting the rebels, however Greece declined, and the British fleet blockaded Athens, landing troops in Pireas. This also led to a plague outbreak. Greece backed down due to pressure from the British and the eventual Russian defeat meant that they were in no position to bargain. However, if Russia won thanks to Greek help, that would probably mean that concessions would be made to Greece as well
No comments? That's sad
What if the Spanish fleet wasn’t destroyed by the storm?
Easy, it wasn’t. The Spanish fleet was routed and THEN hit by a storm.
That's a good one because it was Iberian union times. The ramifications are amazing
Now here's my suggestion for an alternate history I haven't seen done anywhere. Alexander III, father of Nicholas II, both of whom were conservative, had an older brother who was the original heir to the throne called Nikolai Aleksandrovich. Nikolai, as far as I know, was much more liberally-minded than Alexander, and may have been a reformer just like his father, Alexander II. Unfortunately, he died when he got sick with meningitis on a trip around Italy. If he were to survive, would Russia perhaps be quicker to reform and fare better in the end?
Now that's an obscure but big scenario. I like the concept.
No
I like that idea. Maybe Imperial Russia would've survived if he did.
This is one of my favorite channels on RUclips, you’re bringing a fresh take on the alternate history community and I love it. Keep up the great work!
You gotta love possible History they are the best alternate history channel not only good storytelling but great map visuals as well.
Suggestion what if USA and Russian Empire stayed allies or officially became allies becoming great friends?
ah yes, posable history
@@glxyzera7532 sorry about that dang autocorrect at it again
@@stargazer-elite lmao dw
How are you 20 hours ago even though the video is only 18 hours ago
@@puzanfish7705 because yoy didn,t refresh the oage most likely
The video of "what if there wasn't a long peace after napoleon" and this video should be paired together. Great video as always!
Отдельное уважение защитникам Севастополя и Петропавловска ✊
Я с тобой согласен, подобное мнение вкладывал под канал ПослеЗавтра, так там на меня набросились, что аж противно стало
И всем защитникам отечества со всех уголков мира
In a few year I think he could be one of the most subscribed alt history
True
Great to see the much more sophisticated approach of your channel! I had already given up alternative history since it often was like: "If country x would have won that one battle, half of the world would forever be under its control." You are a good contrast to this ignorance!
2:37 was the biggest jumpscare I've had in months. Much kudos for making sense of Europe's historical fear!
Europe's historical fear is imperialistic wishes of Germany, Britain and France.
It is a Western fear tgis good bring peace to eastern europe finaly
Good job possible History! Sorry I cant always text in the comments but good job! ❤
You make great alternate history videos. The crimean war is often ignored, i am thankful you didnt ignore it.
Thank you for the realistic alternate history man!!!
well this is much more tame than mr z's scenario thats for sure. with him it made russia into the superpower of the world...this is more..realistic..damn im REALLY liking this channel!
What if Russian Empire didn't send troops to help Austria fight Hungarian uprising? Also, What if Austria let Hungary go ( Let's say Austrian Emperor accepted the Crown of Germany in Frankrurt)
Favorite moment of my Saturday's: PH releases a video
What if Charles V gave Netherlands to his brother Ferdinand instead of his son Philip? Spain lost a lot of men and resources trying fight constant Protestant rebellions in the Netherlands. Without the Spanish Netherlands Spain could've concentrated instead on the Mediterranean area conquering territories in North Africa and perhaps liberating Greece from the Ottomans much earlier.
I've discovered your chanel just days ago, and I must say that I realy enjoy your work ! I feel like it is much more tamed and researched than other alternate history youtube creators (*cough misterZ *cough) and I hope you keep on the good work !
also, if I can give some idea !
What if Moism replaced confuscianism during the unification of China
What if the Majapahit empire unified
What if the technocratic party won the 1936 americain elections
What if the socialists plan of continental strike at the begining of ww1 had been respected
Mohist China is an interesting abstract alternate history timeline.
Possible History be like: This video is a fucking banger. Drop it.
I agree with this scenario, but it's not enough to stop at that last map. *The interesting things would start to appear after WWI* - would the Bolsheviks fight to incorporate Romania and Bulgaria into Soviet Russia?
Would Turkey have stayed neutral in WW2?
*Would Germany have invaded the USSR in WW2 without the Romanian oil fields covering the fuel demand of the Wehrmacht?*
*Would Stalin abandon the prospects of expanding to the Turkish Straits* (promised to the Russian Empire in *1915* according to *Constantinople Convention* but withdrawn from the negotiation table after the regime change in Russia) *like in our timeline?* This last question relies on the previous one, i.e. 'Would Turkey have stayed neutral in WW2?'.
What if France won the Italian Wars.
It’s a cool and tame scenario to think over, really nice.
For something way more radical in terms of consequences I wonder what would’ve happened if the Novgorod with its republic-psudeo government united Russia instead of the Muscovites
Kinda sad this video didn't really do anything, but really enjoy your priorities on keeping it grounded and respect for realism in AH.
Think there are a lot of German-centric AH that are extremely decisive in either direction like:
What if Friedrich III didn't die and remained German Kaiser for a normal lifespan?
What if France won the Franco-Prussian War?
What if Prussia lost the Seven Years War?
Very unique approach to this POD
Good job!
Если бы мы выиграли Крымскую войну, то Балканы бы намного раньше освободились от турецкого гнёта
Если бы Англия и Франция не "помирились" против единого "врага", то РИ легко бы победила ОИ( флот уже уничтожили). РИ забрала бы проливы и освободила балканы( скорее всего, там бы сидели наши люди у власти)
This was a pretty good video, and a good watch and very well researched as well.
Hey man. I'm also a Dutch RUclipsr (~1200 subs) with a huge interest (and minor) in history, and love for alternate history. Love your work! Let me know if you want to do a collab. We could play a Paradox game or just do a livestream answering alternate-history questions from the chat. If not, that's fine, I'll certainly stay subscribed!
Congrats, you just gained 1 more subscriber !
Me too, just found. YOU GUYS RULE
Great video 👍
Tbf about your last point, this is entertainment. Obviously they’ll go for more out there scenarios/results since it’s fun
Interesting but turning a pyrrhic loss into a pyrrhic victory is most likely going to have minor changes.
But a interesting video nonetheless
What if Britian, France and Austria sought to keep the balance of power by partitioning the ottomans (so power grows somewhat evenly), as they think direct rule of ex-ottoman territory is a better buffer to overagressive Russian expansion and intervene on Russia's side resulting in a massive winn agaisnt the ottomans but a long drawn out peace deal.
I think this is a potential option, after all the partition of poland had already happened twice, britian and France were imperialist themselves and the ottomans were already seen as very weak.
But if nothing else is a fun scenario to try and guess the post-partision borders and diplomacy.
What if Sweden won the great northern war.
Thanks a lot for making this video. I have been asking for this scenario for a long time. 👍
can you do what if germany was united by both prussia and austria under a diarchy of both of them
Found out your channel a few days ago and after binge watching a ton of your vids I just want to say, keep up the amazing work!
Nice and realistic. Keep it up!
It would be interesting to look indept at the wars of secesion in hispanic america and to make alternate history scenarios about it "what if the vicerroyalty of peru repulsed the independentists" "what if the spanish monarchy fled to the americas" are some good ideas
What if the Sith Empire won the great hyperspace war
Idk if he would do any fantasy/scifi althist, but the biggest result of that is no Nathema Ritual or Second Sith Empire under Vitiate. The Sith Empire is a major power, but still nowhere near as strong as the Republic now that they lost the element of surprise. The only real benefactors here are the Sith species, since they aren't genocided at the end of the war by the Republic. Naga Sadow continues to rule until he dies naturally like Marka Ragnos, continuing the Sith Golden Age for another century or so. After his death Vitiate might be strong enough to take power, but he is much less powerful with no Nathema Ritual and would at least partially be kept in check by the Sith Council.
My suggestions for an Alternate History Video
What if the Albany Plan of Union Succeeded?
or
What if Canada and the rest of British North America (West Florida, Caribbean islands, Etc.) joined the American Revolution.
I love this channels videos!
Next two videos if the ottomans won the siege of Vienna 1683 and the siege of Vienna 1529.
I have been researching this topic, and for most of the people who talked about Crimean War it was seen as like "If Russia won it would be a global superpower!!". But, well, as described here, it wasn't really truth. Anyway, i have seen an opinion that if Russia won Crimean War, than it would modernize even worse than our own timeline. Anyway, good work, really liked it.
What if Central Powers focused first in Russia?
What makes this event actually interesting is that Russian influence on the Balkans, basically prevents WW1 from ever happening.
A more influential and powerful Russia in the Balkans would have no need to cause unrest. And the Austrians wouldn't be able to expand past Croatia into Bosnia and Serbia.
Meaning the Balkans would've become Proxy Vassals of Austria and Russia here. Meaning the territories would be more homogeneously divided, prevent cultural and civil unrest.
Also most of the Slavs in the Balkans preferred to be under Russian influence than Austrian Influence. Specially because this Austria is not yet Austria-Hungary, meaning it hasn't even considered reforming their government.
Loved the video, but I have one issue, as Russia wins the Crimean war could it have made Russian population less angry and therefore stopping the Assasination of Alexander and modernising and liberalising Russia further where Alexander III wouldnt be able to undo everything that his father did.
Alexander II was never killed due to the Crimean War loss, or anything related to it. He was killed for being too careful in his reforms.
I think the biggest change in this timeline is that Romania never forms or it does very late,even tho a lot of people deny, Romania was somewhat of a big player in the region later.
really have to agree with your statement that one event does not necessarily mean a make-or-break scenario for large powers
Great videos mate, one on the best channels for alt history on YT
Maybe Russia can left most Balkan to Austria for exchange of Constantinople in Russia. Once this city under its control it’s impossible for them lose it out. They are willing to do everything for this holy city of orthodox.
What if Germany Romania Italy Russia attacked declared war on Austria when Austria declared war on Serbia in World War 1
What if tsar simeon qonquerd Eastern Rome Byzantium
What if the first crusade was focust on Spain
What if the Rashidun caliphate qonquerd Eastern Rome Byzantium in the First Arab invasion
Or what if the Fourth Crusade was focused on Spain?
0:08 is it me or do I see no no Germany
Don’t now what you are talking about, the orange border is just the German Confederation
Germany only came after Prussia one the Franco Prussian war
Before WW1
I genuinely love your channel, keep up the great work
As a history person, your RUclips channel is always the best❤
The blessed timeline 🙏
Sure.........
Great Video ! What are you using to make the maps used in your content ?
Great video man, unfortunely I think it might get nuked by the algorithm for mentioning Russia :P
My therapist: Four eyed Austria is not real don't worry about it
Four eyed Austria: 4:15
Good video bro, but you didn't touch on what would happen to Alaska?
In my wildest dreams this alternate timeline sees Romania erased and Hungary never loosing Transylvania.
Meanwhile while playing Victoria II as Russia I allied America and dragged them into almost all of my wars against the Ottomans.
Needless to say the Crimean War went down pretty...differently.
Great video!
Love your stuff dude, keep it up
great vid
Cool vid bro
HAHAHA THAT MAP IN 11:59
Great realistic video
Could you do a what if alexander the great reincarnated in 1920 and became greek king so he could fight ín the greco turkish war and ww2. It would be cool to see how he would reform the greek society and economy. What I mean by this is alexander is born into the greek royal family in 1900 and becomes greek king in 1920
If this Alexander had the same education and environment in his youth as other early 20th century Greek royals he might not have made decisions very different from the actual Greek monarchs of that time period.
What if the Byzantine empire survived til the modern day
I love the eyes Austria-Hungary has in the thumbnails
If Russia won that war it does not reformed, not abolished serfdom, not begin industrialisation and not reformed army. So to 1870-1890 it would lost Turkish wars and cannot annex Buhara and Kokand too . And finally Japan freely occupy Far East Russian territory.
Russians already crushed the Ottomans in the Caucus front winning every battle there, the only Ottoman commander to even slightly deliver setbacks to the Russians was Omar Pasha who fought in present day Romania.
Why would Dobrudja be cut in half?
We will find the answer soon
I have an idea this could be done in 1 or 2 videos or a series the idea is what if you took an extremely great ruler and made them incompetent and on the other side take an incompetent or average ruler and make them as prolific as alexander the great, napoleon or Aurelian
Can you make a video about the Handmaid’s Tale ?
the one big change I can see from this alternative timeline is the possibility of moldovia not being landlocked
Nice job
How or if WW1 comes about here might be changed if the independent Balkan states are essentially Russian satellites. Austria-Hungary would have to think a bit more carefully about the dangers of Russian intervention with a much longer prospective frontline opening up immediately in the east. Russia aligned Bulgaria would also mean a lack of Bulgaria in the Central Powers, so in theory you could see Serbia holdout longer and continue to be a pain for Austria if the war does otherwise break out in the same fashion and see the same alliances form. It's not a huge change in the dynamics of the war, but it may make the Balkans a bit more difficult for the Central Powers to deal with on account of the lack of Bulgaria on their side. Allied Bulgaria would also create a threat for the Ottomans, in terms of its potential to seize what remained of their European lands and push right up to the straights, threatening to shell Constantinople.
Man Russia sure does look evil in that thumbnail
love this vid
I like that most of the time you have a map on screen.
Good Video
Hello,
My passion project for the past 8 months was making a scenario where Russia won the Crimean war. You may have even seen my map as it's the first thing that pops up when you search "what if Russia won the Crimean war" in google. An outdated version made 5 months ago, but still. As time passes, and the more I learn about the conflict, the less dramatic I make it. Here is the first map I made, 7 months ago, and here is one from 2 weeks ago (IMPORTANT: both are set in 1930, not right after): (edit, I give up, i cant post the link. Ive been trying for half an hour using alt accounts, but I cannot link to imgur. I think it goes to spam... just know that one features a world similar to mr.z and one more similar to this timeline but still a lot different)
(Keep in mind that, while the point of divergence is the Crimean war, the timeline is realistic in that the butterfly effect is present, meaning things like almost no person conceived after 1853 is born, as different sperm would fertilize different eggs. One tiny change and a different person is born, thus radically changing the timeline. This is not a timeline where I make the most realistic possible scenario, this is just a thought experiment of what could have happened)
As you can see first one was very inspired by MrZ. And I agree now with you that he made it way too big of a deal. Plus I too now agree that Austria would not remain an ally of Russia as I originally thought. However, I think you went the other extreme and changed too little. I understand what you are saying, but an event such as this would change some things quite a bit. You only briefly talked about the effects such a defeat would have on Britain and France after such a brutal war. Napoleon III just came to power, sent young men to die horrifically, and, lost. Why would frenchmen stand for that, and then be sent to Italy for some vanity project (as they may perceive it). Britain too, which believed itself to be the pinnacle of civilization, just lost to eastern slavs after investing so much. In my timeline Brits end up helping the CSA, to help the economy, regain prestige, and stick it to the Russians who were sympathetic to the USA. Now, I am not saying that is too likely to happen, it's a bit of a far cry and relies on the butterfly effect, but still, it's a possibility. What I am saying is that such a defeat would have an effect, even if not a very drastic one.
I really like what you are trying to say here, to not make every scenario a dramatic change-all. However, I don't agree with this scenario too much, especially the long-term effects. Still, if you or anyone disagree with what I said, feel free to reply. I changed my scenario before after some feedback from others so it can happen again! :>
Eh, I think itd be a bigger cost for the Russians. The Ottoman army had been reorganized and modernized under the rule of Abdulmecid I. Only the budget really held it back. In the Crimean War, the Ottomans largely held off the Russians on their own, only loss really being a bit of land in the Caucasus in the later part of the war. They were pushing into Bucharest as well before the Austrians forced a Russian withdrawal.
If it wasn't for the French and the British, The Ottomans would ceased to exist earlier. The Russians dominated the Ottoman Army both in the Sea and land, your "empire" would've collapsed and replaced with another Middle Eastern Caliphate
,
Not in the Crimean War or really after tbh. The war of 76-78 was lost due to the political instability of the Sublime Porte. 3 Sultans had come and gone in 1 single year. Also, "your empire" I am not Turkish. The Crimean War saw the Ottomans defeat and hold back the Russians and even push into Russian-occupied Wallachia. France and Britain were a factor in the Empire's survival of course. I think it is unfair to write off the entire Ottoman army just because of that
Finally I can enjoy alt history without having to worry about the channel having horrific takes.
What if the first crusade Failed
What if the first Arab invasion failed
What if the sassanid Empire survived
Fun fact sardina joined on ottoman side in the crimean war aswell
What if nadir shah never went insane and never blinded his son
What if WWII ended in a stalemate?
At what point? There a lot of points of interest in WW2.
@@alexzero3736 1944, they pushed Hitler back but aren’t able to cross into Germany, Poland is a puppet as with Czechia, Hungary gets Transylvania, southern Italy is free but northern Italy becomes a German puppet, france loses Alsace Lorain and Benelux becomes a German puppet as with Denmark, that’s about what I had in mind although 1944 is the point of departure I would say WWII in this timeline may end in 1946 or 47
@@turquoisemaster6000 that's unreal... Even if USSR could not push further, USA and it's allies won't accept such kind of submission. Atomic bomb would be thrown on Berlin...and other cities would be destroyed like they did with Essen.
Here’s an idea I don’t see a lot of people talking about: what if Taft won the 1912 election instead of Roosevelt, or Wilson, I would like someone to talk about it, however, it isn’t the most realistic scenario. I wonder how he would view World War I.
excelent!
Do. what if Bulgaria took Thessaloniki before the Greeks in the Balkan war
What if Martin Luther was killed just following the diet of Worms?
What if this war lasts a year longer and the Indian Mutiny breaks out?
What if the Kingdom of the visigoths survived
What if the Islamic invasion of Spain failed