Jonathan Haidt on the Rise of The Anxious Generation (Part 2)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 янв 2025

Комментарии • 23

  • @Intelligence-Squared
    @Intelligence-Squared  Месяц назад

    The full version of this video is available to watch for our Members (Gold level) here: ruclips.net/video/Pg_jijdUxuY/видео.html

  • @Jamminn555
    @Jamminn555 Месяц назад +9

    Wonderful insights from Jonathan Haidt. Generally well moderated but she continually interrupts, diverts, makes jokes, starts making interruptive and jumping-in noises that rush him into ending his answer, which he does many times quite politely, or otherwise interrupts him JUST when there were other insights or deeper thoughts that include a breath or pause from Jonathan. No need for injecting when you have such an engaging guest. An informative and wonderful session overall.

    • @agaperion
      @agaperion Месяц назад +1

      Well moderated? Not even a little bit.

    • @ncritchlow1
      @ncritchlow1 10 дней назад

      @@agaperionshe was terrible!

  • @news24net
    @news24net 23 дня назад +4

    I agree Sarah Montague is a bit clueless on this issue, she should have done a bit more prep. Thanks Jonathan for raising awareness and speaking out on this modern social ill.

  • @Cheyne4Chelsea
    @Cheyne4Chelsea Месяц назад +7

    My lord this moderator is insufferable. She clearly has no conception of the topic being discussed. She keeps acting as if this is about taking all of society back 50 years
    LISTEN. The case he's making is quite precise. Childhood development has always included risk taking. The development of children SUFFERS without them being able to learn from risk taking
    Phones and technology in general are not central to the thesis. They are merely what has replaced traditional outdoor play and associated risk taking. (There are all sorts of other issues with ever present technology/connectivity, and these largely apply to adults as well. Separate issue[s])

    • @Guy-Lewis
      @Guy-Lewis Месяц назад

      "Phones and technology in general are not central to the thesis. They are merely what has replaced traditional outdoor play and associated risk taking." You contradict yourself.

    • @Cheyne4Chelsea
      @Cheyne4Chelsea Месяц назад +1

      @Guy-Lewis if I had you'd cite the contradiction. My guess is that you don't understand the differentiation between "central" and "relevant"
      As he has been explaining for years, and as I explained, the CENTRAL issue is the lack of independent outdoor play and associated, graduated risk taking. If this had been replaced by fully supervised itineraries (as it has with certain children with helicopter parents) orv Anthony else rather than screens the problem would still be the problem

    • @Guy-Lewis
      @Guy-Lewis Месяц назад

      @@Cheyne4Chelsea Although you presumably know that correlation is is not causation, you appear to be oblivious to the relationship between cause and effect.

    • @Cheyne4Chelsea
      @Cheyne4Chelsea Месяц назад +1

      @@Guy-Lewis you're clearly trying to impress with terms you don't understand. Again, explain where I've made a mistake. And now u also ask you to explain what correlation I've confused with causation. Be specific. I'm obviously very dumb

  • @London_miss234
    @London_miss234 Месяц назад +3

    Play and be productive in a healthy way.

  • @sinsinsinat5377
    @sinsinsinat5377 Месяц назад +4

    The interviewer seems very intense and counter argues out of stubbornness

  • @Randomcharacters285
    @Randomcharacters285 20 дней назад +3

    The moderator is so obnoxious, what’s the point of having someone on if your not going to listen to them

  • @BrickTamlandOfficial
    @BrickTamlandOfficial 8 дней назад +1

    I think it is way too easy to scapegoat whatever technology we have now. Its harder to acknowledge that even back in the day and now, parents are worked to the bone and society expects them to go home and create some kind of structure for their kid that they can rely on and expect from us adults. Low paying jobs and exhaustion is the issue.
    Another issue is that there is not enough structure built into social media sites when you sign up. There should be an understanding of how we can use social media in healthy ways and avoid toxic screen usage levels.

  • @TheNextFreud
    @TheNextFreud Месяц назад

    My perception is that the #1 obstacle is adults not generally being on "the same team" anymore

  • @marcchampagnephilosopher
    @marcchampagnephilosopher 9 дней назад

    He is a psychologist, so he has to constantly find facts to argue "Do X." As a philosopher, I can simply say: "Who cares whether or not large amounts of people are doing ABC. Join me in doing X instead of ABC. Your happiness will be the proof that it is the wise choice."

  • @murrayjsm1
    @murrayjsm1 Месяц назад

    You cut the video off!
    Can you post the rest of it?
    I’m not Gen Z, my attention span is longer, lol.

  • @JamesDrawings
    @JamesDrawings Месяц назад

    👏!

  • @angies.7689
    @angies.7689 Месяц назад +2

    Please, let’s hear more from toxic do-nothing moderate corporate centrists. How utterly fascinating.

  • @Commonsense-u1h
    @Commonsense-u1h Месяц назад

    Haidt is an interesting social scientist, however he's wrong that things have only got better. Lots of communities got really screwed by neoliberalism.
    He's right though about Gen Z and Alpha and he's right that Conservatives and Liberals need to understand him better.

    • @Guy-Lewis
      @Guy-Lewis Месяц назад +1

      As I recall, he said that things were improving *until 2013*
      So, gradual improvement followed by what I'd call reversed bigotry.