i would like to add, that indonesia's reason to make nusantara is not population centers, as people can and are encourage to migrate to less populated regions. the central location allows for future centralization and more grip and control over our eastern regions that are usually neglected. other than that the name nusantara refers to the austronesian word for archepelego. austronesian people are cousins of melanesians and their peoples are malaysia-philipines and indonesia.maphilindo. infact philipinos and malaysians have a sort of nusantaran idealism to unify like the germania unification. so the nusantara capital is very fitting especially when malaysia philipines and indonesia Wants to UNIFY as Nusantara. with such a unification nusantara would have 100+60-70+270-280M population or 430-450M population. able to compete much more strongly angaist foreign powers. although today, that idea has been put on hold by the three indonesia,philipines and malaysia.
lastly i'll dislike you althoug it was mostly simple calculation fun, if you're ever going to mention to asians israel, make sure to mention palestine too even though it might not be that relevant, for south east asian and those further east asia israel is far more foreign than some split state in the middle east, palestine. if you're wondering why there's like 10 dislike and not 1 is because you mention israel without palestine. israel RARELY if ever makes diplomatic shows in central asia,south asia, south east asia, even less in east asia. while many middle eastern nations publicized palestine which means in asian eyes, israel is more foreign in general.infact some or many think israel is located in europe due to how european they act and how they are part of european football league
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements: Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3% Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4% Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1% Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9% Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86% Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1% Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9% Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3% Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
This video is a serious improvement compared to the Europe video. It is noticeable how you did take into account the advice given in the comments. Keep up the good work. This channel has a lot of potential.
Suggestion: For "tall" countries (like Vietnam, Israel, India) it would be better for you to input the cities from north-south instead of east-west. This makes it easier to see regional trends of these countries when the cities are not all placed yet.
thats why the idea of changing the capital of bangladesh never got succeeded, because all of the country knew that DHAKA is the best place for the capital of BANGLADESH.
@@albertromansky9501 I see. Can I ask why you didn't include Iceland in the Europe video? It's not particularly small, and I think it could have taken a good position in the ranking as it's centralised in the capital
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements: Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3% Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4% Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1% Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9% Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86% Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1% Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9% Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3% Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
My guesses for China (in your europe video) was quite right. I remember I guessed Xi’An, Chengdu, Chongqing and Wuhan. And Which city/settlement was closer to the Mongolian pop. Center
Both Qazaqstans and Indonesia choice make a lot more sense if you understand an additional major function of a capital, namely control over the region. In Qazaqstan case over the more Russian north and in Indonesias case it is to be closer to the more rebellious eastern provinces.
What about Oceania? I mean, it is basically just New Zealand and Australia but maybe you could also add Fiji, Papua New Guinea, and maybe even like Tonga.
It's interesting for me. But I am not sure that it would be interesting to wide audience. If you want, I can give you result about Oceania (just text with numbers)
Delhi is also the capital of the Mughal empire (1530-1540; 1639-1857) and delhi sultanate (1334-1506) also it doesnt come under ethnic lands as the city is a melting pot but nagpur comes under ethnic maratha lands.
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements: Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3% Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4% Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1% Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9% Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86% Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1% Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9% Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3% Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
as a georgian, i dissagree on khashuri being a capital, batumi, kutaisi or just tbilisi are the best options, im not talking like im mad, just saying XD
@albertromansky9501 Headquarter of Hindu Nationalist Group, Parent of Indian Ruling Party BJP. Nagpur is Dangerous of Opposition Party. Indore is best for Indian Capital, Indore Is most Cleanest City in India.
Unfortunately, it is very difficult to take into account all aspects, including political and religious ones. That is why I suggested capitals purely on a geographical basis. Indore is interesting, I will read more about this city
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements: Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3% Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4% Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1% Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9% Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86% Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1% Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9% Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3% Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
Just reminder to Subscribe:
ruclips.net/channel/UCN-kMJaYSkP5dHjSiPSzCAQ
Saw the european capitals a while ago and somehow i didn't subscribe, but it's there now :)
i would like to add, that indonesia's reason to make nusantara is not population centers, as people can and are encourage to migrate to less populated regions. the central location allows for future centralization and more grip and control over our eastern regions that are usually neglected. other than that the name nusantara refers to the austronesian word for archepelego. austronesian people are cousins of melanesians and their peoples are malaysia-philipines and indonesia.maphilindo. infact philipinos and malaysians have a sort of nusantaran idealism to unify like the germania unification. so the nusantara capital is very fitting especially when malaysia philipines and indonesia Wants to UNIFY as Nusantara. with such a unification nusantara would have 100+60-70+270-280M population or 430-450M population. able to compete much more strongly angaist foreign powers. although today, that idea has been put on hold by the three indonesia,philipines and malaysia.
lastly i'll dislike you althoug it was mostly simple calculation fun, if you're ever going to mention to asians israel, make sure to mention palestine too even though it might not be that relevant, for south east asian and those further east asia israel is far more foreign than some split state in the middle east, palestine. if you're wondering why there's like 10 dislike and not 1 is because you mention israel without palestine.
israel RARELY if ever makes diplomatic shows in central asia,south asia, south east asia, even less in east asia. while many middle eastern nations publicized palestine which means in asian eyes, israel is more foreign in general.infact some or many think israel is located in europe due to how european they act and how they are part of european football league
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements:
Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3%
Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4%
Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1%
Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9%
Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86%
Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1%
Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9%
Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3%
Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
video idea: cities that should nerge together
Cool. Noted!
Svitlograd (Lysychansk + Siverskodonetsk + Rubizhne)
@@albertromansky9501Upper Silesia cities or threecity in Poland
This video is a serious improvement compared to the Europe video. It is noticeable how you did take into account the advice given in the comments. Keep up the good work. This channel has a lot of potential.
Wow, thanks!
Suggestion: For "tall" countries (like Vietnam, Israel, India) it would be better for you to input the cities from north-south instead of east-west. This makes it easier to see regional trends of these countries when the cities are not all placed yet.
Good suggestion. You are right 👍
In the case of Malaysia. When Malaysia first became independent, its only the mainlad part. The part on Borneo island were incorporated later.
Yeah, in general, abnormal capital's location explains through the history.
Do Africa nxt please
thats why the idea of changing the capital of bangladesh never got succeeded, because all of the country knew that DHAKA is the best place for the capital of BANGLADESH.
Very nice videos i like the concepts! Keep it up !
Thank you! I'm working on a lot of new ideas
I love these video ideas.
Great vid once again, we need Africa too!
Where was the center of population of the Roman Empire?
Probably somewhere near Rome. But, if we consider the current population, the result will probably be closer to Egypt
Very Good U need more views bro
I love this channel so much!!! Nice video!!
Ideas: centers of population of each continent, redraw the borders so that all capitals are close to population centers
Good idea, thank you!
Great video. I see the amount of work behind this AMD would be very happy to see the Video about the historical capitols^^
Nice video
Also btw, didn't you say you would make a video about the amazon river and other rivers in siberia
Very good video, but what about Brunei? East Timor? Palestine? Bhutan? Maldives?
I decided not to include small countries in the ranking because their Capitals city are essentially the entire population of the country
What about Turkey?
@@albertromansky9501 I see. Can I ask why you didn't include Iceland in the Europe video? It's not particularly small, and I think it could have taken a good position in the ranking as it's centralised in the capital
@@albertromansky9501 What do you consider the cutoff point for 'small'? In my opinion Bhutan, Maldives and maybe East Timor are large enough
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements:
Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3%
Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4%
Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1%
Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9%
Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86%
Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1%
Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9%
Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3%
Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
My guesses for China (in your europe video) was quite right. I remember I guessed Xi’An, Chengdu, Chongqing and Wuhan. And Which city/settlement was closer to the Mongolian pop. Center
btw the city of Qom is pronunciation Ghom (english does not have the sound but sounds like a Gh') not Oam , its Qom
Pretty sure they made a typo in the text to speech site they used
Ull need do africa as well as Australia & the many islands across the seven seas
The UAE must be so mad they didn't make Dubai the capital.
Both Qazaqstans and Indonesia choice make a lot more sense if you understand an additional major function of a capital, namely control over the region. In Qazaqstan case over the more Russian north and in Indonesias case it is to be closer to the more rebellious eastern provinces.
Wow, interesting point of view.
I think that capital should be away from rebellious regions
What about Oceania? I mean, it is basically just New Zealand and Australia but maybe you could also add Fiji, Papua New Guinea, and maybe even like Tonga.
It's interesting for me. But I am not sure that it would be interesting to wide audience. If you want, I can give you result about Oceania (just text with numbers)
@@albertromansky9501 you can
India is indeed runs from Nagpur 😂
( RSS headquarter, Parent organisation of India's ruling political party) for last 10 years
don't forget the geography, even if centralized area is the best, it might be harder to access
Could you please give me some example?
@albertromansky9501 The river flows, where the capital can access global goods by using river stream to cross the areas.
24:02 It would certainly be nice!
What about Quwayt? It seems even more centralized, as well as having a desert or sea buffer in each direction.
Very few settlements except the capital city
British Raj also included Burma (Myanmar)
Only for 10 years. For most of its history the 2 colonies are seperate.
hoi player detected
Please you make a video on centre of African countries population
👀
Delhi is also the capital of the Mughal empire (1530-1540; 1639-1857) and delhi sultanate (1334-1506) also it doesnt come under ethnic lands as the city is a melting pot but nagpur comes under ethnic maratha lands.
Why it is better to have a capital in the center of population instead center of territory?
Why you didnt mention Qatar, Bahrain, Palestine, Kuwait ?
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements:
Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3%
Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4%
Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1%
Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9%
Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86%
Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1%
Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9%
Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3%
Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
too small
i like to point out the pronunciation the city of Tabriz (in iran) it is not Tar-Biz its Tab-Riz *the a in tab is like the a in the word "As"
as a georgian, i dissagree on khashuri being a capital, batumi, kutaisi or just tbilisi are the best options, im not talking like im mad, just saying XD
I mentioned khashuri as the center population. Obviously it doesn't mean that it should be the capital city 🙂
technically most densely populated country is vatican)
"These Cities Would be Better for the Capital"
No they would not.
I am live in Amman
Nagpur is RSS Capital
What is RSS?
@albertromansky9501 Headquarter of Hindu Nationalist Group, Parent of Indian Ruling Party BJP. Nagpur is Dangerous of Opposition Party. Indore is best for Indian Capital, Indore Is most Cleanest City in India.
@@albertromansky9501 Once upon a time India PM Narendra Modi & Their Many BJP Leader Worked for RSS.
@@warishislxlr so it is like if america put the capital in san francisco or something
Unfortunately, it is very difficult to take into account all aspects, including political and religious ones. That is why I suggested capitals purely on a geographical basis. Indore is interesting, I will read more about this city
6:56
It's also the hub of the Coronavirus
Yes, transportation hubs were the first to be affected by the spread of covid
24:00 DO ITTTT
Nagpur? That being the capital of the RSS idealogy? Good joke.
Bro if you really want to make videos about Bharat put the correct map or else don't do the video.
Which one correct map I should use?
Bro u forgot Bahrain Qatar Bhutan Brunei Palestine and Singapore also u didn’t give any alternative capitals for like half of these countries
Countries that were not included in the ranking due to a small area or few number of settlements:
Singapore (Singapore) - 0,78 km, 97,3%
Kuwait (Kuwait City) - 20,7 km, 95,4%
Qatar (Doha) - 6,9 km, 95,1%
Timor Leste (Dili) - 16,65 km, 92,9%
Bhutan (Thimphu) - 36,7 km, 86%
Maldives (Male) - 68,3 km, 84,1%
Bahrain (Manama) - 5,46 km, 82,9%
Brunei (Bandar seri Begawan) - 35,4 km, 66,3%
Palestine (Ramallah) - 46,5 km, 47,1%
good video👍
but you forgot palestine
For Palestine it's naturally Jerusalem
@@gimeinn It is not. As it borders Israel.
I am from Dhaka..😊😊
Jordan cheated the game