Well what did you guys expect guts sword isn't really a sword so I'm pretty matching against sword as strong as dragon slayer probably won't have same sound as a normal sword
Josh Hunn The action is good, but as far as animation goes the first thing that I find wrong with it is staging, particularly the way the camera moves. There are so many cuts and there's so much movement I cant even critique the rest of the movement.
Give them credit, they predicted and created post ironic Vine soundeffect memes in 2017, this is clearly a statement on causality and the themes of berserk
Lmao dude there are other studios that can do beautiful stuff as well. Madhouse can't just animate everything the people want XD. Not to mention the artists actually have to have a passion for the thing they want to adapt as well
This scene would have been 11/10 if it was not the horribly low FPS and intensifying shaky cam. All those brilliantly animated fighting moves went to waste.
@@stormcutter59 Everyone likes to hate on things but they can't really think for themselves. Because the general consensus is to hate on the latest iteration of berserk, and esepcially how there tends to be a hate for 3d animation in the 'anime community' most people don't rate individual scenes. Some scenes in the 2016 and 2017 anime are decent and have some nice tempo going for them despite the general 3d animation being far from what could be up to snuff.
@@Arunnejiro I can tell you with 100 percent certainty, I hate this on my own terms. Not because everyone else hates it. Music is good, story is excellent but that isnt from the anime itself, and the voice acting is good too but....that's it. The graphics are an essential piece of the story and without it, the show just looks like a fan animated work of the original material. That's a big problem. Also the anime doesnt allow for more quiet scenes to roll on like the original anime did and to me that's a big problem. It's an adaptation that's flawed already in how it presents the story of Berserk and its executed so poorly it only adds to the issue. It's a bad anime
Wow, this is the most clangtastic fight I have seen in my life. Now excuse me, I have to go to the hospital because my ears and eyes are starting to bleed
Jesus Christ. I went from watching his first duel with Zodd in the 90's adaptation to this. I literally laughed out loud when all the clanging started happening.
God no. Golden Age movies, yes, but the original 97 is so fucking outdated by now... as much as it has some amazing things about it, I couldn't get past the first two episodes because of how dated and bad the art style became over time.
Krûk Blood-Axe Would still watch it beside of this fucking crap... the fact that an anime of this level can’t get a proper animation actually blow my fucking mind, the 1997 was 100 times better than this, at least they knew how to pass the emotion to the character, this anime isn’t only about the fight but the feels... character are so deep with such profound development.
@@ericbernier2340 Agreed, the 97 anime had real heart to it and captured the emotional turmoil of the characters perfectly. The movies that came out looked good but lacked the emotional depth of the series.
id really love to see what the sound effects department was doing for this audio "alright jimmy its a big fight take these frying pans and just go ham on a car"
>yes I understand the animation is terrible >uh huh the sword fights do sound like frying pans smashing together >I’ll agree some of the voice acting was off >yes I will be watching this series again, yes I did enjoy it
Not gonna whine and bitch about the animation. It almost seems like Guts and Zod would been battle brothers in another life the way they both shine and feel alive in combat.
am sorry but to reach that level of skill, my god the speed I think I died when Zodd took the other sword and second how can Griffith new band think they can kill Guts when he been unarmored withstood there attacks and HURT!!!! >.> they never had the chance to fight an armored/ healthy guts.
I think the anime wouldve been watchable if the fucking sound design wasnt so awful. its like one of the interns looked up "metal sound" and chose the first one without listening to it
You do know the Grunbeld fight was basically like the manga right so technically they didn't ruin it unless you want to count for their bad animation than yes but if it's not because the really must have not enjoyed the fight
scrappy :v In The Manga Guts in Berserker armor is practically 0 gravity. Its because his sword swinging so god damn fast it makes his jumping look sooo wierd and he even slightly changes trajectory because the sword when he did that wierd flip thing.
Comparing this to any of the pages in the Beserk manga, the expression, and camera angles, and designing and animation were horrible, e.g. Gut's hatred for Griffith, When two people are literally a feet away from eachother and then some how be next to eachother, animation that looks like 2000 series of Jojo and Dragon ball Z mixed together, etc.
So this is the reboot to one of the legendaries..... This makes my soul hurt..What the fuck is this? Not just the shit CGI but what the fuck is with this rush job of a mess.
"Clang"
El Dr.Peste ikr that sound cracks me up, sounds like a pan lol
El Dr.Peste CLANG
Well what did you guys expect guts sword isn't really a sword so I'm pretty matching against sword as strong as dragon slayer probably won't have same sound as a normal sword
カ"ラ"ン"！
It sounds like he's swinging a metal pipe around. So weird.
man this PS2 Berserk game looks great
PS2 Remastered
Please don't be mean to the game like that
Joke is on you, the fucking PS"game looks better than this. Better directing too.
Incorrect, this is closer to the dreamcast berserk game.
The PS2 Game looks better than this
I'm glad that the art department students got to have a go at making an anime, but I wish they got actual animators to make Berserk.
right? they are the reason why berserk as a decent anime won't ever happen. well, at least we got the manga to be content with.
Josh Hunn The action is good, but as far as animation goes the first thing that I find wrong with it is staging, particularly the way the camera moves. There are so many cuts and there's so much movement I cant even critique the rest of the movement.
Sigh…
Give them credit, they predicted and created post ironic Vine soundeffect memes in 2017, this is clearly a statement on causality and the themes of berserk
When you and your siblings wanna make music with the pots and pans
Brandon Adrien it become "clang"
*SHAKING CAMERA INTENSIFIES*
Ousted *clanging in the background also intensifies*
Just reboot the damn series with Madhouse doing the animation. This is so trash.
What about Studio Deen, who made Fate: Stay night? that anime animation is amazing
PolTheKiller is that a joke?Deen made the worst ever fate adaptation,the actual good version of Fate/Stay night was done by Ufotable.
I spelled wrong sry, i meant to say Ufotable who made Fate stay night ubw
PolTheKiller Nah man, Madhouse is better. Look at OPM, HxH, Hellsing, Hajime no Ippo, Overlord, Summer Wars, etc. Their animation is flawless!
Lmao dude there are other studios that can do beautiful stuff as well. Madhouse can't just animate everything the people want XD. Not to mention the artists actually have to have a passion for the thing they want to adapt as well
The fact that this man KICKED a blade so hard that it went all the way through Zodd is stupid crazy lmao
This fight sounds like someone dropping an entire cupboard's worth of saucepans down a long flight of stairs.
This must make Zodd so happy. As long as he has been alive fights this intense are probably very rare for him.
Clang.
Clang.
Clang.
Struggled Clang.
This scene would have been 11/10 if it was not the horribly low FPS and intensifying shaky cam. All those brilliantly animated fighting moves went to waste.
brilliant? You thought that animation was brilliant? What are your standards dude? In a ditch?
@@stormcutter59 It was great aside from what he said.
@@stormcutter59 Everyone likes to hate on things but they can't really think for themselves. Because the general consensus is to hate on the latest iteration of berserk, and esepcially how there tends to be a hate for 3d animation in the 'anime community' most people don't rate individual scenes. Some scenes in the 2016 and 2017 anime are decent and have some nice tempo going for them despite the general 3d animation being far from what could be up to snuff.
@@Arunnejiro I can tell you with 100 percent certainty, I hate this on my own terms. Not because everyone else hates it. Music is good, story is excellent but that isnt from the anime itself, and the voice acting is good too but....that's it. The graphics are an essential piece of the story and without it, the show just looks like a fan animated work of the original material. That's a big problem. Also the anime doesnt allow for more quiet scenes to roll on like the original anime did and to me that's a big problem. It's an adaptation that's flawed already in how it presents the story of Berserk and its executed so poorly it only adds to the issue. It's a bad anime
The CGI is still kinda shitty and audio sounds like they're slamming frying pans together.
When Zodd says "You survived pass my predictions, this makes me happy boy!" Father & Son moment right there..
よく考えると最初ゾッドになんて歯も立たない存在だったのに打ち合えるようになってるって凄いよなー
Wow, this is the most clangtastic fight I have seen in my life. Now excuse me, I have to go to the hospital because my ears and eyes are starting to bleed
How dare they desecrate this sacred series! Inexcusable! this is blasphemy!
Oh damn it, they should have made the camera shake more, I almost saw something
*C L A N G*
That camera sucks
狂戦士になる前の状態でこれだもんな。
人間なのに人間辞めてる
But I put my grasses on so why is everything wrong
Because you put them on wong
didnt know Akuma was a swordsman
😂😂😂 *loses sword* *gives Guts the Raging Demon*
Zodd had presented before Akuma FYI. If anything, Akuma would be the one whose inspired from Zodd.
Didnt know Ryu was a swordsman
@@SeekGrace Quite the opposite actually as SF came BEFORE berserk
@@illegalalien6542 We're talking about Akuma not Street Fighter.
If I had a dollar for every frame in this video I would owe money
0:04 I love that noise.
Jesus Christ. I went from watching his first duel with Zodd in the 90's adaptation to this. I literally laughed out loud when all the clanging started happening.
This is so crazy this was almost 5 years ago. It feels like only yesterday I was immensely disappointed.
Bring back the '97 animation team/style please
God no. Golden Age movies, yes, but the original 97 is so fucking outdated by now... as much as it has some amazing things about it, I couldn't get past the first two episodes because of how dated and bad the art style became over time.
Krûk Blood-Axe Would still watch it beside of this fucking crap... the fact that an anime of this level can’t get a proper animation actually blow my fucking mind, the 1997 was 100 times better than this, at least they knew how to pass the emotion to the character, this anime isn’t only about the fight but the feels... character are so deep with such profound development.
@@ericbernier2340 Agreed, the 97 anime had real heart to it and captured the emotional turmoil of the characters perfectly. The movies that came out looked good but lacked the emotional depth of the series.
No anime should be visually violated like berserk.
I actually love this fight
「だが、戦える。あいつに辿り着くまでの数えきれない夜が、オレを叩き上げた」
This isn't an anime, it's a screen saver.
No wonder people say CLANG! That's 90 percent of the fucking show!
That first 15 second sequence was actually really good
If it was more polished, this whole fight could’ve had more potential.
I agree.
If zodd was mortal, Guts would have bested him in the first encounter.
Gut is the strongest human in the series =)))
Berserk 2017 in two words: *[Clanging Intensifies]*
*CLANGING INTENSIFIES*
Berserk's version of Ryu v Akuma.
There not choppy, there just oo fast for us too see
reducing tha shaky camera a bit would work and it would be 9/10 :sip:
did someone just go up to the microphone and bang a shit ton of pots and pans
ovv yeah im cucumbering ... nice edit
id really love to see what the sound effects department was doing for this audio "alright jimmy its a big fight take these frying pans and just go ham on a car"
They fight like how Griffith’s fighting is described; quick and nimble.
Yet both Guts and Zodd couldn’t be further from that…
this is just too offensive for the human eye to see
>yes I understand the animation is terrible
>uh huh the sword fights do sound like frying pans smashing together
>I’ll agree some of the voice acting was off
>yes I will be watching this series again, yes I did enjoy it
じゃまだあああああ！
i like the sound effects
the sword clangs sound like a giant frying pan
many earthquakes on those hills
At least no one can say that the sound design isn't at the same level as the animation.
Came for the clang in the comments...wasn't disappointed.
Those were the days when we were playing dark souls on ps3/x360
the anime in cgi isn't bad, they just don't know how to use cgi.
Not gonna whine and bitch about the animation. It almost seems like Guts and Zod would been battle brothers in another life the way they both shine and feel alive in combat.
Bonjour ce serait pour savoir cette scène elle est dans quelle saison de gars avec la saison 1 ou 2 merci
Idk why they just didn't give him a pan.
Worked in Dead Cells.
Their hair is not moving 😂
Have you seen Dragonball Z? The Saiyan has planet-buster durability.
you wanna here a fuckin joke LET STUDIO PERRIOT adapt berserk
First 12 seconds were actually decent.
Guts turned blackclangman
am sorry but to reach that level of skill, my god the speed I think I died when Zodd took the other sword and second how can Griffith new band think they can kill Guts when he been unarmored withstood there attacks and HURT!!!! >.> they never had the chance to fight an armored/ healthy guts.
Did they use the drum parts from st. anger for sound design?
I don't know why but i enjoy this battle
Honestly, the animation isn't bad, its just that the FPS is so damn low here.
Nobody:
Dragonslayer: “CLANG”
C L A N G C L A N G C L A N G! :D
I think the anime wouldve been watchable if the fucking sound design wasnt so awful. its like one of the interns looked up "metal sound" and chose the first one without listening to it
Literalmente es cagar algo legendario
This is the only fight I enjoyed because they ruined the Grunbeld fight 🤦🏽♂️
You do know the Grunbeld fight was basically like the manga right so technically they didn't ruin it unless you want to count for their bad animation than yes but if it's not because the really must have not enjoyed the fight
Xavier Christian
my man they made guts look like he was floating in 0 gravity and gave him more CLANG
Grunbeld said “He shattered my shield”.......while his shield was completely fine attached to his arm.
@@shadowraider5154 Except Guts strikes lost a lot of impact and his "gun" was literally a cylinder that clipped through his hand.
scrappy :v In The Manga Guts in Berserker armor is practically 0 gravity. Its because his sword swinging so god damn fast it makes his jumping look sooo wierd and he even slightly changes trajectory because the sword when he did that wierd flip thing.
Comparing this to any of the pages in the Beserk manga, the expression, and camera angles, and designing and animation were horrible, e.g. Gut's hatred for Griffith, When two people are literally a feet away from eachother and then some how be next to eachother, animation that looks like 2000 series of Jojo and Dragon ball Z mixed together, etc.
not even the shitty animation could ruin this masterpiece of a fight sequence
I liked the part where there was *clang*
What is the theme music called
"HAI C L A N G FORCES" by Susumu Hirasawa
Infiltrators
AAAAHHH SHAKEYCAMMMM
I dont get the hate i liked this so much.
Y’all say this looks bad but when I look at ruby it looks even worse.
This honestly isnt THAT bad. Plenty of C L A N G.
CLANG CLANGGG
Que EP foi esse ?
Guts #1
this fight is crazy as hell, not exactly in a good way..
The fight would have actually been pretty good were it not for the *CLANG* and shaking camera
seriously? 59 seconds of good animation, that's all it would have taken, but they couldn't even do that.....
WHAT DO YOU MEAN THIS WASN'T FROM THE PS2 GAME?
Needs a little more shake n' KLANG.
Fucking frying pan.
Demon slayer animators need to animate next season
Best comedy
Cliiiiangggg
The only thing worse than the animation is the sound effects.
Saber x Barsaka
Stage: UBW
clang, clang, clang
Clang clang CLANG!!!!!
Jesus fuck. You can see Jack shit with whats going on in this scene. No wonder why I've been told this version is bad
Zodd is the real Kirito
What is that sound!?!
*CLANG*
What ps2 game is this?
So this is the reboot to one of the legendaries..... This makes my soul hurt..What the fuck is this? Not just the shit CGI but what the fuck is with this rush job of a mess.
cancer: ANIMATED
CLANG CLANGACLANALA AAMABABNAJAHA!1!1!!111
Clang intensifies