honestly, who really cares if its accurate. You can guess based of what the survivors told us but you will never and i mean NEVER actually know what happened so who really cares if its accurate. Its all about honoring the men women and children who lost their lives in this terrible disaster
Hi CruisingWay, i have a question: what are your thoughts on the new lights out theory where lights go out in layers/sections? I agree with it as it explains numerous accounts. Great video as always, keep up the good work :)
the only issue with this is that th glass dome probably broke almost as soon as water came on top of it. Due to the water pressure being too much against the thin fragile class of the dome.
@@SQUAREHEADSAM1912 Hi, I have a few questions about how you believe the sinking went: 1. Which direction and how deep do you think the first 2 funnels fell? 2. When do you think the 4th funnel fell or broke off the stern? 3. How do you believe the listing throughout the sinking went? 4. Do you think the double bottom held on post breakup? 5. How many sections do you believe Titanic broke into? 6. When do you believe each boat left? 7. Which time do you believe each deck began to flood / water reached on the outside? 8. Do you believe the lights went out in sections throughout the sinking? I believe they did as several witnesses testified. 9. When do you believe the plunge began, forward funnels falling and break? Which position do you believe the ship was in when the break occurred? 10. Do you believe the starboard boats were all swung out one after eachother or one boat being swung out, then as loading / lowering begins, the next boat swung out? I tend to believe the second option (Maybe also with some port boats such as 10) as it matches what Witnesses describe.
Amazing theory! But in my opinion, the positions of the passengers, especially after the breakup, are not realistic; the velocity of the collapsibles being pushed after the collapse of the first funnel were not realistic either. But I agree with the timestamps. Thanks for the animation!
"Something in the very bowels of the Titanic exploded and millions of sparks shot up to the sky....This red spurt was fan-shaped as it went up, but the sparks descended in every direction in the shape of a fountain of fire" "For a few moments we could see everything that was happening, for, as the vessel sank, millions and millions of sparks flew up and lit everything around us." "I saw the ship in a sort of red glare" "The ship seemed to be surrounded with a glare and stood out of the night as though she were on fire." “Smoke and sparks were rushing out of her funnel. There must have been an explosion, but we heard none. We only saw the big stream of sparks."
Too bad you weren't consistent with timing the text on the screen. Sometimes I could read it 2-3 times. Other times I barely had enough time to read one line. Spending more time pausing the video than the video length itself to read really took away from everything.
@@IloveCruiseShips1912 Just a few things. People are shown loaded into Collapsible 'A' on the starboard side, with it floating in the water. Actually, it was upside down, jammed beneath a funnel cable stay, and still had ropes attached to the davits before the water washed up suddenly in a wave. That wave is what Col. Gracie used to jump up to the officer's quarters roof; this video says that he did it while the deck was still dry there. And the video shows lots of people in the water forward before the ship's first plunge. Nobody was there at that time; they all got washed forward to there by the ship's first plunge and bow rise, which the video hasn't shown yet. It also says that Harold Bride was helping with and went beneath Collapsible 'B', but it was actually 'A' on the starboard side. And the ship didn't break at 24 degrees; it broke earlier than that (down around 15 degrees), and then again at a high angle (45 degrees or more). So this video repeats all of the inaccuracies of all of the other single-break theories. But there is a lot that is good about the video, like the timing for when Joughin hears the first breaking sounds.
Amazing how the camera angles, sounds and red lighting make this so much more terrifying than the movies do
This brought across the terror more than the movie.
This is the most TERRIFYING Titanic sinking video I’ve ever seen. Incredible job with the cinematography!!
the stern literally took its sweet time to rise and sink -
This was like one of the best Titanic animations I've ever seen!! Keep up the good work!
If this is accurate or not I don't know, but it's extremely good. It's big and violent. Excellent work. 👍👍👍
the most realistic i ever saw. Much better than Honor and Glory. It looks more real, more alive.
Nah
HOLY CRAP THIS IS ABSOLUTELY STUNNING. 1912/10
10/10 dude. Feels VERY alive with the little people and angles. Keep up the fabulous work!🫡
wtf this shit was straight up cinematic this is definitely the best animation of the final plunge i have seen
7:34 funny scream
one of the best final plunges i've ever seen
I really enjoyed this video about the sinking of the RMS Titanic. Really well done ❤
Absolutely amazing! 10/10 animation.
Jeez wa leeze the breakup noise is intense but overall infinity out of 10
Might be the most accurate depiction of the final plunge yet. Not just accurate but also immersive.
honestly, who really cares if its accurate. You can guess based of what the survivors told us but you will never and i mean NEVER actually know what happened so who really cares if its accurate. Its all about honoring the men women and children who lost their lives in this terrible disaster
@@billy_bob149 accuracy is still important
@@MatteoRamaccioni84 how so
@@billy_bob149 so we can get a clearer view of what those souls went through
4:51 Where is this breakdown noise coming from and why is she sobbing and shivering?
Why is she crying? 4:51
Hi CruisingWay, i have a question: what are your thoughts on the new lights out theory where lights go out in layers/sections? I agree with it as it explains numerous accounts.
Great video as always, keep up the good work :)
the only issue with this is that th glass dome probably broke almost as soon as water came on top of it. Due to the water pressure being too much against the thin fragile class of the dome.
I see you're not the only one who thinks it was Wilde who killed himself and not Murdoch
Amazing work!
Titanic Atcherley sank at 2.20am after the ship broke in half.
2:20 is an approximation. Watches show between 2:20 and 2:30
at the beginning of the video I heard autumn hymn do you know where you got that from as I have been looking for that?
That Man: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH! 7:36
I too personally believe that actually time of sinking was at 2:22am
2:20 am.
@@amanifaraj8718 … that’s just a rough approximation
@@SQUAREHEADSAM1912
Hi, I have a few questions about how you believe the sinking went:
1. Which direction and how deep do you think the first 2 funnels fell?
2. When do you think the 4th funnel fell or broke off the stern?
3. How do you believe the listing throughout the sinking went?
4. Do you think the double bottom held on post breakup?
5. How many sections do you believe Titanic broke into?
6. When do you believe each boat left?
7. Which time do you believe each deck began to flood / water reached on the outside?
8. Do you believe the lights went out in sections throughout the sinking? I believe they did as several witnesses testified.
9. When do you believe the plunge began, forward funnels falling and break? Which position do you believe the ship was in when the break occurred?
10. Do you believe the starboard boats were all swung out one after eachother or one boat being swung out, then as loading / lowering begins, the next boat swung out? I tend to believe the second option (Maybe also with some port boats such as 10) as it matches what Witnesses describe.
Amazing theory! But in my opinion, the positions of the passengers, especially after the breakup, are not realistic; the velocity of the collapsibles being pushed after the collapse of the first funnel were not realistic either. But I agree with the timestamps. Thanks for the animation!
Brazy, 112/10, Amazing
Well the entire engines didn't fall out. Only the first cylinders of them did.
Other than that, great work!
Turn collapsible B right side up don’t leave it! 0:22
Sparks are coming out of the Funnel!!!!!!?????? 2:26
"Something in the very bowels of the Titanic exploded and millions of sparks shot up to the sky....This red spurt was fan-shaped as it went up, but the sparks descended in every direction in the shape of a fountain of fire" "For a few moments we could see everything that was happening, for, as the vessel sank, millions and millions of sparks flew up and lit everything around us." "I saw the ship in a sort of red glare" "The ship seemed to be surrounded with a glare and stood out of the night as though she were on fire." “Smoke and sparks were rushing out of her funnel. There must have been an explosion, but we heard none. We only saw the big stream of sparks."
I also believe that the boilers in boiler room 2 imploded, but whether it was before or after the break-up I don't know.
A photo of the #2 boiler room shows that those boilers have not imploded.
God Almighty
Amazing Animation, but where does the time 2.22 come from?
2:20 is an approximation. Watches show between 2:20 and 2:30
Too bad you weren't consistent with timing the text on the screen. Sometimes I could read it 2-3 times. Other times I barely had enough time to read one line. Spending more time pausing the video than the video length itself to read really took away from everything.
Boat a and boat b pushed by funnel one’s collapse by 50 meters?? That’s too far.
I’ve always heard about 50 feet. Not to forget some of those on boat B said they were surrounded by people in every direction.
7:40
Sub worthy!
Not very accurate, but awesome computer work.
Please can you explain how it is innacurate?
@@IloveCruiseShips1912 Just a few things. People are shown loaded into Collapsible 'A' on the starboard side, with it floating in the water. Actually, it was upside down, jammed beneath a funnel cable stay, and still had ropes attached to the davits before the water washed up suddenly in a wave. That wave is what Col. Gracie used to jump up to the officer's quarters roof; this video says that he did it while the deck was still dry there. And the video shows lots of people in the water forward before the ship's first plunge. Nobody was there at that time; they all got washed forward to there by the ship's first plunge and bow rise, which the video hasn't shown yet. It also says that Harold Bride was helping with and went beneath Collapsible 'B', but it was actually 'A' on the starboard side. And the ship didn't break at 24 degrees; it broke earlier than that (down around 15 degrees), and then again at a high angle (45 degrees or more). So this video repeats all of the inaccuracies of all of the other single-break theories. But there is a lot that is good about the video, like the timing for when Joughin hears the first breaking sounds.