Advice for using Manim | Grant Sanderson and Lex Fridman

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 61

  • @BrianAmedee
    @BrianAmedee 4 года назад +357

    This requires a dual skills; ability to educate an idea well (not easy), and ability to code/edit a video. We appreciate all who can do this!

    • @IQLabs
      @IQLabs 3 года назад +5

      You're doing a fantastic job my friend! I love your Manim videos.

    • @BrianAmedee
      @BrianAmedee 3 года назад +2

      @@IQLabs Thank you!

    • @JVerde853
      @JVerde853 3 года назад

      Powerhouse of the cell

    • @mosalethoba5267
      @mosalethoba5267 2 года назад

      You're gud with ur craft my guy

  • @naeemulhoque1777
    @naeemulhoque1777 2 года назад +129

    Some Other Software Grant mentioned-
    1. Desmos
    2. Grapher
    3. GeoGebra
    4. Mathematica

  • @StarFury2
    @StarFury2 2 года назад +19

    I'm surprised how flexible and easy to use manim is, especially if you tried to code some of it's abilities from scratch. What an awesome person Grant is to make this tool available to anyone as open source.

    • @yashnarvariya4725
      @yashnarvariya4725 2 года назад

      Please tell me how to learn it

    • @StarFury2
      @StarFury2 2 года назад

      @@yashnarvariya4725 Follow manim documentation online, they do explain things in details. Also RUclips has many tutorials to get you started.

    • @yashnarvariya4725
      @yashnarvariya4725 2 года назад

      @@StarFury2 thanks for reply
      I started learning python for manim mainly.
      I want to create some basic equation animation only by manim.
      Can you tell me how long will it take me to get their or i need to learn any other things like latex?

    • @StarFury2
      @StarFury2 2 года назад

      @@yashnarvariya4725 It depends on your motivation and time invested. I started learning python 1 year ago for similar reasons - making physics animations and apps for my classes. After a month or two, you could get comfortable working with python basics and start making some manims of your own. OOP stuff will take more time to click in. Latex is a huge typsetting framework, but for manim you only need simple math commands.
      Don't expect fast production of manim animations though. A good few minutes long animation can take days of work to complete. However, if you are a teacher like me, or a student or an academic, learning python and latex is great investment in a long run.

    • @yashnarvariya4725
      @yashnarvariya4725 2 года назад

      @@StarFury2 your advice means a lot to me.currently I am in my second year of undergraduate course in engineering,
      I like to teach physics that's why I though manim would be useful thing.but from your advice it looks a big task cause I have college assignment and all.
      But still I wouldn't lose hope on manim but do you recommend any other better alternative whose learning curve is not so steep and I can do some base typewriting animation effect in it as well

  • @Gameboygenius
    @Gameboygenius 2 года назад +38

    Steps for using Manim correctly:
    1) Make sure Manim is actually the right tool for your project.

  • @fathanff1564
    @fathanff1564 Год назад +45

    Ahmad Bazzi has to be on the show

  • @pavelperina7629
    @pavelperina7629 2 года назад +17

    I've just started experimenting with manim. Not because geogebra is bad, but it's different and sometimes ... actually many times, it's advantage to have option to multiply coordinates of 8 points by matrix at once. There were cases where I even wrote a code in C++ generating series of SVG images or gnuplot graphs and then doing batch conversion to PNG. Not for educational purposes, but for debugging of some computer graphics (geometry) or image processing related algorithms. But now I want to do some presentation and adding math in TeX is useful.

    • @yashnarvariya4725
      @yashnarvariya4725 2 года назад

      Hey.
      I want to create mainly equations videos only using manim. For that do i need to learn latex. And please tell me how you are learning manim
      Because i kinda find it hard.

  • @levi2234
    @levi2234 3 года назад +5

    This is a great tip. I onece made an uni presentation. Which ended up being more of a presentation in manim was cumbersome. Mainly use manim for computational animations is the best way to use it.

  • @tes_la
    @tes_la 4 года назад +21

    Thank you so much for such a great explanation.

  • @mattkriese7170
    @mattkriese7170 Год назад +7

    Awesome. This seems like a great place to further expand my learning of python and mathematics. I’ve been looking for a more creative project for combining the two. Thrilled that this is open source and can’t wait to give it a try.
    Cheers!

  • @abhinavbhardwaj5517
    @abhinavbhardwaj5517 2 года назад +4

    I use manim bcs it allows me to practice programming and do creative maths at the same time .and also improves my problem solving

  • @donegal79
    @donegal79 2 года назад +5

    the first question finishes after 1:21.

  • @dakyion
    @dakyion 4 года назад +85

    I wish someone can make it an extension for visual studio! That would be great!

    • @technodruid
      @technodruid 3 года назад +14

      Why don't you?

    • @NicolaiWeitkemper
      @NicolaiWeitkemper 3 года назад +9

      Huh, so what should it do that manim as a CLI doesn't?

    • @MrKrypton36
      @MrKrypton36 2 года назад +3

      because you don't need to, just install it with conda and allow vs code access

    • @mladizivko
      @mladizivko Год назад +1

      why tho? it is a package for python

    • @ElectroNeutrino
      @ElectroNeutrino Год назад

      @@mladizivko Visual Studio is a really common IDE for python work.

  • @NamasenITN
    @NamasenITN 2 года назад +19

    The video starts at 2:18

  • @DamoCovey
    @DamoCovey 28 дней назад +1

    Grant, you rock. That is all.

  • @deplant5998
    @deplant5998 3 года назад +9

    Elon, Bill please give this man some money!!

  • @agrajyadav2951
    @agrajyadav2951 Год назад +4

    bruh look at those biceps damn

  • @acceloratajengold
    @acceloratajengold 4 года назад +35

    Very cool, I also love trying to animate Möbius strips in interesting ways. This is fascinating I will for sure be having a play around with Manim 🤖♾

    • @acceloratajengold
      @acceloratajengold 4 года назад +8

      @M T I don't know. Does it have to be useful? I just like the way it looks and the way you can apply animation dynamics in 3D design.

    • @mortazakhedri1583
      @mortazakhedri1583 4 года назад

      @@acceloratajengold when you made the mobius strip could you put an vector in it and find it’s eigen value?

    • @ashutoshtiwari8225
      @ashutoshtiwari8225 3 года назад +2

      Then be sure to invert it and recreate the scene from endgame.

  • @ArtamisBot
    @ArtamisBot 2 года назад

    I need to implement manim into my automation software...

  • @andrazandjelic3511
    @andrazandjelic3511 2 года назад +11

    The toughest thing about manim for now is downloading it😅

    • @DisDatK9
      @DisDatK9 2 года назад +1

      Getting it to successfully run from CMD (which is the only means to do it I’m pretty sure,) definitely took me a bit. I also am not the biggest fan of having to process in high quality to ensure there aren’t any weird visual bugs which automatically save to a folder, so inevitably I end up having to constantly delete the huge amount of data that my attempts are saved as. I couldn’t find anything in the functionality to quickly delete the work-in-progress videos, and I wish I had the knowledge to be able to make it.

    • @pavelperina7629
      @pavelperina7629 2 года назад +1

      Nah, installing 25 extensions for LaTeX

    • @andrazandjelic3511
      @andrazandjelic3511 2 года назад

      @@pavelperina7629 that part was simple for me to be honest... Took some time but at the end it worked

    • @mladizivko
      @mladizivko Год назад

      @@DisDatK9 you could add some python lines to delete the previous file. put it on top of your file generation functions, so it always deletes the previous one, before adding a new one.

    • @snesmocha
      @snesmocha Год назад

      This took me 10 minutes 💀

  • @LitCast
    @LitCast 3 месяца назад +2

    "constrained by the graphical environment" fellow linux user i see ;)

  • @5caioc
    @5caioc 2 месяца назад +1

    This guy sounds a lot like that dude from 3Blue1Brown

  • @soundaryalahari3802
    @soundaryalahari3802 Год назад +4

    Well now with GPT-4 assisting you, using Manim isn’t difficult anymore… used GPT-4’s assistance to create these videos to visualise multiplication tables for my 6year old kid with just a couple of hour of effort, without any prior experience: ruclips.net/p/PLUlbJLpeMpINh42KYO7Z2pJzyoyUXsqui

    • @mladizivko
      @mladizivko Год назад +1

      Damn, good job! Did you ever program in Python before?

    • @soundaryalahari3802
      @soundaryalahari3802 Год назад +1

      Thanks! Coded in python a lot… but had no prior experience in using manim…

  • @frosty8655
    @frosty8655 4 года назад +27

    Why does he wear space x shirt ? Is he working for them ?

    • @Magmatic91
      @Magmatic91 4 года назад +34

      No I think he's just a fan.

    • @randy52000
      @randy52000 4 года назад +28

      Every engineer/math person is a spacex man when musk calls

    • @zrmsraggot
      @zrmsraggot 3 года назад +37

      Are you a rolling stone

    • @egoworks5611
      @egoworks5611 3 года назад

      @@randy52000 HAHHAHA

    • @CrazyFanaticMan
      @CrazyFanaticMan 2 года назад

      @@zrmsraggot 🤣🤣

  • @pol165
    @pol165 3 года назад

    888 likes xd

  • @IshanBanerjee
    @IshanBanerjee 2 года назад +4

    Don't know why, but after knowing about Manim, I don't feel like using desmos Or geogebra 🥲