Hey guys, thank you so much for all your comments! 😊 Here are your suggestions: Digital Man Turn The Page Subdivisions Anthem Chemistry Marathon Vital Signs The Analog Kid Circumstances Fly By Night Limelight Working Man Red Lenses Prime Mover Middletown Dreams Bastille Day Malignant Narcissism The Trees Where‘s My Thing Leave That Thing Alone Show Don‘t Tell The Enemy Within La Villa Strangiato Spirit Of Radio Camera Eye Cheers, Julia 💛
Well, I have seen Rush many times.... first starting in Atlanta during the Grace Under Pressure tour.. the best was each. Always the upmost experts and craftsmen. Love this band forever. RIP Neil.
I've seen video where he's singing, playing bass with right hand, keyboards with left and playing bass pedals with his feet all at the same time... I can't even rub my stomach and pat my head...@@drury2d8
Geddy Lee is bass god in his own right but the fact that he sings while playing all that just elevates him to another level of musician. Oh his keyboard skills are not too shabby either. Legend.
Agreed - I can sing, I can play bass, I can even play rhythm guitar whilst singing. But I cannot play bass and sing at the same time. I end up slurring my speech and my fingers get confused as my brain is trying to wrestle with two completely different rhythms and melodies. Geddy Lee (and the few other people who are good at simultaneous bass and singing) are either wired differently or somehow train their brains to do multi-thread processing!
Never got to see them but always on my bucket list. However, my band did open for Permanent Waves, a tribute band in Toronto. They're awesome. Check them out on Facebook.
@@ThomannsGuitarsBasses No big deal, but it is funny how something small like that grabs your brain. Love the video, great choices of bass lines - and awesome playing as always. I was fortunate to see Rush live back on the '81 'Moving Pictures' tour in Boston (was 15 at the time), great mix of new and old stuff. Geddy Lee was a big influence on me as a young bass player.
80's Rush was my very first Rush experience! A friend of mine had given me a bag with some of his LP's to check out, in '89, and one of them was 'Grace Under Pressure'; I was instantly hooked 🙂
All of Power Windows is a joy for me to listen to, and my favorite albums are their final two. It really is a shame that their middle works get buried so often
I’m from Ontario, Canada, believe it or not they played at my high school in 1972, I’ve seen them 8 times, starting with the, All the Worlds a Stage tour, when they were still playing the Oshawa Civic Auditorium, up to the Moving Pictures tour. One of my all time favourite bands! Great video Julia!
My high school as well even earlier than 1972. And a yearbook has RUSH bass player Jeff Jones before Geddy replaced him. Geddy went to Newtonbrook; I went to Downsview Secondary School - the next neighbourhood high school south west of Newtonbrook. ie. they weren't mega superstars then; more like another of the teen/bar bands in suburban Toronto.
I believe it. Do you happen to remember any songs they played in 1972? Unfortunately, we have pre-1974 live recordings or even setlists which I've always found strange
Glad to see a Clockwork Angels tune getting some love. That album deserves more attention and credit. In his memoir, Geddy personally ranked CWA as another one of Rush's apotheoses, right next to 2112, Moving Picture, and Power Windows. I recently revisited the album and fell in love with basically every song all over again. CWA, as Geddy described in his book, was really the peak of Rush's return to their heavy rock sound that had started with Counterparts. I have to agree with the bass God himself! Btw I am 27 years old. Young people still love this band!!! Long live Rush.
Amazing part about Rush, they figured out how to play all their songs as recorded on the albums in a live setting without adding touring musicians, so they are up there playing their usual instruments, Geddy has a pedal synth so he’s playing 2 instruments at once AND singing (and standing on one foot), and all three of them had gear to trigger samplers to add in anything they couldn’t play without having 8 arms and legs.
There was no band I looked forward to seeing live more than Rush. I was a little late to the game getting into their music and didn't see them live until the Presto tour in 1991. After that, I saw them with my brother every time they played in Philadelphia until their final tour, the R40 tour, in 2015. Geddy's vocal range dropped over the years, but their musicianship never wavered one bit. Absolute fucking legends.
I tried playing Tom Sawyer. I thought I had it until I got to the fast part and I really don't have it. I noticed Julia stopped just before that part though
@@Welcome2TheInternet I think she did a fantastic job - and this is coming from someone that plays Rush. Cameras are cheap - if you think you can do it better, put up or shut up.
It's a little tougher for him live what with singing and all but from his recordings the dude is a seriously tight player and his technique is certainly a big part of his sound. If you used a pick or don't have really good fingering technique it would never sound right. Not with that type of progressive rock so bass driven and percussive/melodic. Julia does indeed seem to have it.
"Leave That Thing Alone" for me is the perfect tune for learning and playing. And it also features one of Lee's trademark techniques, playing with one finger in a way of alternative picking.
Another song that heavily uses that technique is Animate. Damn near the whole song is played with that technique. Back when I first got into Rush, I tried learning Caravan, and found myself using a similar technique on the main riff before I even knew about it. Just felt right I guess
Ged has written many memorable bass lines over the years but my personal favorite remains Closer to the Heart. Beautifully melodic and flowing and is just about the most perfect bass line to fit a song.
This is surreal: Last week, after Geddy was nominated "the greatest bassist of all time" in the MusicRadar poll, I scanned the Thomann website and YT for a channel email address to send in a suggestion that this could be a good excuse to do a top-5 on Rush. Thanks for doing it anyway! I would've suggested "Turn The Page", the verse bassline is really cool and at least you wouldn't need to sing on top of it... The verse of "Alien shore" is also great. As for me, I've used "Distant Early Warning" for warm-up... a lot. :-)
Middletown Dreams is a fantastic bassline. Glad to see Halo Effect and the latest album get some love. The Garden is one of the best songs Rush have ever produced in my opinion.
Thanks a bunch for highlighting this bass-god. You did very well. His attack is awesome, his lines are a dream. I’m from ‘67 and grew up with them and stuck with them. Got into bassplaying because of Geddy. Once you go Rush, you never go back!
Thank you so much for performing such incredible bass lines... Besides those 5 songs, I also love: 1) Finding my way 2) 2112 (especially the final part) 3) Natural Science 4) New World Man 5) Earthshine 6) Anthem And of course: 7) Working Man 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Never got to see them but always on my bucket list. However, my band did open for Permanent Waves, a tribute band in Toronto. They're awesome. Check them out on Facebook.
Many years ago when I was only playing guitar, I saw an incredible guitarist in the now defunct Carnavon Castle, Camden Town, and after the show told him I was going home to dig a hole in the garden to bury my guitar - I felt so inadequate. After watching several of Julia's videos looks like I need to get my spade out again! But seriously, I'm hanging in there on both instruments, and this is a great tribute to Rush from a motivational player who comes across so well on screen. Thanks a lot.
For me, Geddy is a sort of "Bass-God." I tried yesterday, to play Hemipheres again, for the fist time in years... OMG that is pure art. To mention 5 Rush songs is difficult... The power of Geddy is in the virtuosity of composing certain parts, like for example the piece in "show , don't tell" it is so melodic. And "Hemipheres" of course, The power of bass in La Vila , Free Will, @mikko rinne mentioned Turn the page. Open secrets, and than I forget 100 or more ;-) . And yes, now days there are a lot of great great bass players, but if Geddy play's , you know immediatly it's him.
I'm a fan of the bass lines from Grand designs from Power Windows, Digital Man from Signals, Kid Gloves and After image from Grace Under Pressure and all of the other bass lines Geddy played!
"YYZ" and "The Big Money" are great picks. I would also have included "Digital Man", "Prime Mover" and "Where's My Thing" in my top 5 with "Fly By Night" as honorable mention.
Julie, I can't argue with any of your selections. However... First and foremost, for all you youngsters out there, any RUSH baseline is a GREAT RUSH baseline. One, often overlooked, most melodic baselines from Geddy is Primer Mover. The Hold Your Fire album, although almost and afterthought in their collection, just doesn't get the respect it deserves.
When i was 14 years old i bought my first Rush album: A Farewell To Kings and i am a fan ever since. I like how Geddy plays in the titelsong of the album particularly after 3 minutes in the song there's an instrumental part and guitarsolo with amazing basswork. Another one of my favorites is in Freewill, Also after 3 minutes and before and under the guitar solo in a 6/8 beat, very nice!
1) solo break in La Villa Strangiato. 2) playing throughout Circumstances 3) Freewill-solo break 4) YYZ 5) and, weirdly “Fly by Night” beautiful example of his melodic capabilities
Geddy was always composed and playing the bass while hitting his vocals perfectly, Alex was walking around putting out more sound than thought possible from a single guitar and Neil was surrounded by the biggest drum kit ever, it was like a massive nest. I didn’t like all Rush songs, but I loved a handful and enjoyed their tour where they opened for The Scorpions.
Spirit of Radio, Subdivisions… Julia, thanks for your take on this pioneer musician who brought such amazing textures to Rush, with that great bass work, AND vocals that were unmatched AND keys… what a talent! And we get to listen to Geddy forever. A thrill.
1. Red Lenses 2. Spirit of Radio 3. The Trees 4. Marathon 5. Big Money The fact that he switched between keyboards and bass while singing the whole time in the middle of a song without missing a beat was just incredible!
Hi from Brasil! The instrumental part of "Freewill"... not just the bass: drums and guitar "attack" with EVERYTHING, getting the MOST out of your instruments!
I often watch the concert video of RUSH playing YYZ in a stadium in Brasil. You are obviously fanatical fans of them judging from that video. It's great to watch.
I was in a Guitar Center once and there was a kid playing some Rush lines on a bass he'd picked up. I went up and told him, do not underestimate how hard that right hand is hitting. It's a movement that drives past the string, but catching enough of it to slam strings into frets much of the time. Once you start playing like that, it's hard to play "normal." "The Big Money" is also one of my favorites to play. The line in the verses of "Turn The Page" is similar but a bit busier; I can't imagine being able to play that and sing the melody at the same time.
Thank you!!! It’s hard to say who was the most talented in that band. All 3 brilliant. Your renditions were flawless and really took me back there. Thank you.
@RDog4484 - Yes, 'Marathon' would be in my list also! Lots of fun to play, too! It's also my 15-year-old Son's favourite Rush song, and he had first thought Geddy was actually "slappin' da bass" 😊
Ms. Hofer... that was bang-ON!!! (yep, THREE exclamation marks) I'll drop some love in the hat for "The Analog Kid" off of Signals. Great work, as always!
Slappa 'da bass! The first Rush song I ever learned is The Spirit of Radio. I love the groove and walking bass line that's played with the solo. Great list!
Wow! Julia well done. You definitely have the talent to play some of Mr. Lee's best bass lines. Not a small task by any means. I have been a big fan off yours for awhile but now I am a bigger fan. You really nailed Geddy's style and tone. Brava. I think my favorite along with the ones you have already chosen is "Leave that thing alone" It looks to me like Geddy likes playing it as well the way he really digs in with his right hand and uses a flamenco style to play it.
That was fun! Thanks. Been a fan since I saw them over the New Year's holiday '74-'75 on the Fly By Night tour. And don't feel bad about not playing Big Money with a fingernail. That's a Geddy speciality. He closed a car door on his hand when he was a teenager and injured that finger. The nail on that finger now grows much thicker than his other nails. A natural pick!
I saw Yes live at Madison Square Garden when a kid. It was before I started playing bass but IIRC he was using a pick which I believe contributes a lot to his sound. Here nor there the bass sounded great so I use both fingering and pick if needed for sound. It was easier for me being I also play regular guitar.
Geddy is the world leader in playing complex bass lines and singing challenging melodies at the same time. Most of it is done in odd time signatures... even early songs like Anthem... I don't know how he does it.
Show Dont Tell is one of the grooviest bass breaks ever!!! Also Power Windows had many great lines. Especially on Grand Designs, Middletown Dreams and Emotion Detector!! Sometimes forgotten because of the heavy keyboards!!
I started playing bass because of Geddy. In addition to this whole list (Red Barchetta is my all time favorite song) I'd say "Leave that thing alone" off Counterparts is pretty cool. The song almost sounds like Lurch didn't showup that day so they just sample tracked guitar and let Geddy do all the work. Fun to play too!
I learned them in the early 80s. I even wrote rush like songs. My fav band at the time. I had a 74’ black fender jazz bass and played in a hs rock band. Wild to see all these young people love it just as much!! Cool
I love "Limelight" myself. It's my go-to for testing playability on a bass and it usually turns a few heads when you're playing it on a jazz with a some distortion. Everything off Moving Pictures is killer and is fun to play.
Hey guys, thank you so much for all your comments! 😊
Here are your suggestions:
Digital Man
Turn The Page
Subdivisions
Anthem
Chemistry
Marathon
Vital Signs
The Analog Kid
Circumstances
Fly By Night
Limelight
Working Man
Red Lenses
Prime Mover
Middletown Dreams
Bastille Day
Malignant Narcissism
The Trees
Where‘s My Thing
Leave That Thing Alone
Show Don‘t Tell
The Enemy Within
La Villa Strangiato
Spirit Of Radio
Camera Eye
Cheers, Julia 💛
I really like the bass line off of "Heart of the Sunrise".
Pls ..."Bravado"
Let me add another vote for "The Analog Kid."
Hemispheres
Xanadu
Cygnus X-1
@@michaelbyrd7883 Yes.
What’s most amazing, to me, is that Geddy played these complicated bass riffs while singing melodies that were completely dissimilar. Truly a talent.
Well, I have seen Rush many times.... first starting in Atlanta during the Grace Under Pressure tour.. the best was each. Always the upmost experts and craftsmen. Love this band forever. RIP Neil.
you forgot the synth
I've seen video where he's singing, playing bass with right hand, keyboards with left and playing bass pedals with his feet all at the same time... I can't even rub my stomach and pat my head...@@drury2d8
No doubt about it!!!
Practice makes perfect.
Geddy Lee is bass god in his own right but the fact that he sings while playing all that just elevates him to another level of musician. Oh his keyboard skills are not too shabby either. Legend.
Agreed - I can sing, I can play bass, I can even play rhythm guitar whilst singing. But I cannot play bass and sing at the same time. I end up slurring my speech and my fingers get confused as my brain is trying to wrestle with two completely different rhythms and melodies.
Geddy Lee (and the few other people who are good at simultaneous bass and singing) are either wired differently or somehow train their brains to do multi-thread processing!
Geddy Lee is from another planet, because for doing those bass lines while singing, playing bass pedals and alternating with keyboards is unique OMG 😮
You forgot his foot work on the Moog Taurus pedals.
Yes, a great bass player, but a disgusting singer.
Never got to see them but always on my bucket list. However, my band did open for Permanent Waves, a tribute band in Toronto. They're awesome. Check them out on Facebook.
Geddy's Bass solo that blends into Alex's solo on FREEWILL is amazing.
Bingo
Digital Man is one of my favorite Geddy bass lines. That opening is killer
Tom Sawyer was on Moving Pictures. 1981, not '76
That was my first thought "oh dear, I am old but not quite THAT old" :D
yeah I caught that immediately and I was sure I bought that in 1980 same as back in black scared my mom quite a bit
Thank you... I was there the day it came out, waiting to buy the album at my local record store, it was most definitely in 1981.
Hey guys, you are totally right! I am sorry, my bad! // Cheers, Julia
@@ThomannsGuitarsBasses No big deal, but it is funny how something small like that grabs your brain. Love the video, great choices of bass lines - and awesome playing as always. I was fortunate to see Rush live back on the '81 'Moving Pictures' tour in Boston (was 15 at the time), great mix of new and old stuff. Geddy Lee was a big influence on me as a young bass player.
I've always been amazed at how Geddy could play those bass lines and sing at the same time. Monster talent.
And the taurus pedals too.
Everybody disregards the 80s Rush songs when they do these lists. I'm glad you picked Big Money to be included here.
80's Rush was my very first Rush experience! A friend of mine had given me a bag with some of his LP's to check out, in '89, and one of them was 'Grace Under Pressure'; I was instantly hooked 🙂
That and Marathon
All of Power Windows is a joy for me to listen to, and my favorite albums are their final two. It really is a shame that their middle works get buried so often
I love 80’s Rush! Power Windows is an album I have loved for more than 35 years! I fell in love with it when it first came out in 85.
Those three Canadian gents are three of the most amazing musicians ever to grace rock ‘n’ roll
I’m from Ontario, Canada, believe it or not they played at my high school in 1972, I’ve seen them 8 times, starting with the, All the Worlds a Stage tour, when they were still playing the Oshawa Civic Auditorium, up to the Moving Pictures tour. One of my all time favourite bands! Great video Julia!
My high school as well even earlier than 1972. And a yearbook has RUSH bass player Jeff Jones before Geddy replaced him. Geddy went to Newtonbrook; I went to Downsview Secondary School - the next neighbourhood high school south west of Newtonbrook. ie. they weren't mega superstars then; more like another of the teen/bar bands in suburban Toronto.
Cooll!!!!!!!
I believe it. Do you happen to remember any songs they played in 1972? Unfortunately, we have pre-1974 live recordings or even setlists which I've always found strange
I thought ATWAS was at Massey?
Was that Laura Secord Secondary?
Glad to see a Clockwork Angels tune getting some love. That album deserves more attention and credit. In his memoir, Geddy personally ranked CWA as another one of Rush's apotheoses, right next to 2112, Moving Picture, and Power Windows. I recently revisited the album and fell in love with basically every song all over again. CWA, as Geddy described in his book, was really the peak of Rush's return to their heavy rock sound that had started with Counterparts. I have to agree with the bass God himself! Btw I am 27 years old. Young people still love this band!!! Long live Rush.
Amazing part about Rush, they figured out how to play all their songs as recorded on the albums in a live setting without adding touring musicians, so they are up there playing their usual instruments, Geddy has a pedal synth so he’s playing 2 instruments at once AND singing (and standing on one foot), and all three of them had gear to trigger samplers to add in anything they couldn’t play without having 8 arms and legs.
Having played in a Rush tribute, I can testify to the extreme difficulty of staying upright while trying to wrangle all the technology needed!
There was no band I looked forward to seeing live more than Rush. I was a little late to the game getting into their music and didn't see them live until the Presto tour in 1991. After that, I saw them with my brother every time they played in Philadelphia until their final tour, the R40 tour, in 2015. Geddy's vocal range dropped over the years, but their musicianship never wavered one bit. Absolute fucking legends.
yep. Multi-faceted multi-talented trio
Except clockwork angels
F10! F10!
Favorite bass line: The short bass break in La Villa Strangiato
same
Incredible criatividade and performance... I agree!
Funky one
La Villa Strangiato is their masterpiece of the masterpieces.
Excactly, that was my way down that rabbit hole and made me pick up the bass guitar. So, thank you Geddy!
There’s no hiding when you’re playing Rush. You either have it or you don’t.
Julia has it apparently. Well done.
I tried playing Tom Sawyer. I thought I had it until I got to the fast part and I really don't have it. I noticed Julia stopped just before that part though
No, she doesn't. Hitting the right notes and "getting it" are 2 different things.
@@Welcome2TheInternet I think she did a fantastic job - and this is coming from someone that plays Rush.
Cameras are cheap - if you think you can do it better, put up or shut up.
@@Welcome2TheInternet I believe she has it. She didn’t go into the whole song but she seems seasoned enough and I don’t even watch this channel
It's a little tougher for him live what with singing and all but from his recordings the dude is a seriously tight player and his technique is certainly a big part of his sound. If you used a pick or don't have really good fingering technique it would never sound right. Not with that type of progressive rock so bass driven and percussive/melodic. Julia does indeed seem to have it.
"Leave That Thing Alone" for me is the perfect tune for learning and playing. And it also features one of Lee's trademark techniques, playing with one finger in a way of alternative picking.
His technique has never been truly copied (that I’ve seen), the only person I’ve seen employ a similar technique is Brian Beller.
Another song that heavily uses that technique is Animate. Damn near the whole song is played with that technique.
Back when I first got into Rush, I tried learning Caravan, and found myself using a similar technique on the main riff before I even knew about it. Just felt right I guess
Agreed!!!!👍👍👍
The counting right after the first part of the intro to YYZ… it always feels great! 🤘🏽😁
I was always amazed by the fact that Geddy is able to sing with a perfect pitch while playing some complex lines. Indeed a rare breed.
Awesome job and impressed you included YYZ-lots of bassists avoid it. Freewill on the whole, but especially the bass break supporting the solo. ❤️
I approve!
Ged has written many memorable bass lines over the years but my personal favorite remains Closer to the Heart. Beautifully melodic and flowing and is just about the most perfect bass line to fit a song.
This is surreal: Last week, after Geddy was nominated "the greatest bassist of all time" in the MusicRadar poll, I scanned the Thomann website and YT for a channel email address to send in a suggestion that this could be a good excuse to do a top-5 on Rush. Thanks for doing it anyway! I would've suggested "Turn The Page", the verse bassline is really cool and at least you wouldn't need to sing on top of it... The verse of "Alien shore" is also great. As for me, I've used "Distant Early Warning" for warm-up... a lot. :-)
Yes! Turn the Page! Exactly! It's a crazy complex bass line.
I too have been playing along to 'Distant Early Warning' a lot; Good fun! 🙂
Can't get enough of Julia's bass face! 🔥❤
As a drummer who's covered a lot of Rush songs, you helped me "hear" Tom Sawyer anew. Your tone and rhythm are splendid!
Geddy Lee? YAAAAASSSSS. Favorite bass line... too many to choose from.
My favourite is Show Don’t Tell, especially the bass solo.
that’s a good one 👍🏻
Yes! People sleep on that solo! Underrated solo!
That solo is hard,...especially the harmonics part
Show Don't Tell! Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Dave Stieb's walk up song in 1990. He and Geddy are good friends.
I love the bass in "Free Will."
my top choice
@@davidlajaunie6009 Mine too indeed ...
One of my favorite Rush baseline if from "The Enemy Within".
Great one!
Absolutely. The fact that he could sing while playing this is amazing!
Mine, too. Such an underrated song!
might have been lifted from this song (4;30) ruclips.net/video/Dy4HA3vUv2c/видео.html
I just commented the same thing! :D
I've been a fan of Rush for years.... and now I'm a fan of Julia. Keep up the great work!
🤮
My fav, “Camera Eye” bass line
My favorite Geddy Lee bass part, hands down, is Xanadu. That intro that moves into the walking line is so fun to play.
Middletown Dreams is a fantastic bassline. Glad to see Halo Effect and the latest album get some love. The Garden is one of the best songs Rush have ever produced in my opinion.
My favorite baseline(s): La Villa Strangiato...for sure! So jazzy, so varied, it grabs you again every time
Working Man was always my fav power bass song by Rush. Pure energy all the way thru!
Its a good day when the Goddess of the Bass drops a new video.
Especially when it's Geddy Lee bass lines!
Thanks a bunch for highlighting this bass-god. You did very well. His attack is awesome, his lines are a dream. I’m from ‘67 and grew up with them and stuck with them. Got into bassplaying because of Geddy. Once you go Rush, you never go back!
Thank you so much for performing such incredible bass lines... Besides those 5 songs, I also love:
1) Finding my way
2) 2112 (especially the final part)
3) Natural Science
4) New World Man
5) Earthshine
6) Anthem
And of course: 7) Working Man 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Never got to see them but always on my bucket list. However, my band did open for Permanent Waves, a tribute band in Toronto. They're awesome. Check them out on Facebook.
Another great bass video. I love watching bassists who love their instrument honor other bassists who love the bass like Lee.
All his basslines are good , Circumstances and The Trees come to mind as favorites
Many years ago when I was only playing guitar, I saw an incredible guitarist in the now defunct Carnavon Castle, Camden Town, and after the show told him I was going home to dig a hole in the garden to bury my guitar - I felt so inadequate. After watching several of Julia's videos looks like I need to get my spade out again! But seriously, I'm hanging in there on both instruments, and this is a great tribute to Rush from a motivational player who comes across so well on screen. Thanks a lot.
For me, Geddy is a sort of "Bass-God." I tried yesterday, to play Hemipheres again, for the fist time in years... OMG that is pure art. To mention 5 Rush songs is difficult... The power of Geddy is in the virtuosity of composing certain parts, like for example the piece in "show , don't tell" it is so melodic. And "Hemipheres" of course, The power of bass in La Vila , Free Will, @mikko rinne mentioned Turn the page. Open secrets, and than I forget 100 or more ;-) . And yes, now days there are a lot of great great bass players, but if Geddy play's , you know immediatly it's him.
The best bassist and keyboard player as well as lead singer and great choice Julia 🤘🤘🤘😎😎
My favourite Rush bass line is „Spirit of Radio“. A real monster 👹!
Energía pura!!!
Thank you....my favorite... Circumstances
I'm a fan of the bass lines from Grand designs from Power Windows, Digital Man from Signals, Kid Gloves and After image from Grace Under Pressure and all of the other bass lines Geddy played!
Jacobs Ladder, The Trees, Freewill, Entre Nous, Different Strings, La Villa Strangiatto, so many awsome bass lines...
"YYZ" and "The Big Money" are great picks. I would also have included "Digital Man", "Prime Mover" and "Where's My Thing" in my top 5 with "Fly By Night" as honorable mention.
I’d also include Vital Signs, I started listening to that song a couple weeks ago and it’s so much fun to play
dude Prime mover is so underrated its criminal!
@@andrewpappas9311 - I too love playing along to 'Vital Signs' 🙂
Prime mover is so overlooked and underrated, it’s nice to finally see someone mention it .
Julie, I can't argue with any of your selections. However...
First and foremost, for all you youngsters out there, any RUSH baseline is a GREAT RUSH baseline.
One, often overlooked, most melodic baselines from Geddy is Primer Mover. The Hold Your Fire album, although almost and afterthought in their collection, just doesn't get the respect it deserves.
When i was 14 years old i bought my first Rush album: A Farewell To Kings and i am a fan ever since. I like how Geddy plays in the titelsong of the album particularly after 3 minutes in the song there's an instrumental part and guitarsolo with amazing basswork. Another one of my favorites is in Freewill, Also after 3 minutes and before and under the guitar solo in a 6/8 beat, very nice!
1) solo break in La Villa Strangiato. 2) playing throughout Circumstances 3) Freewill-solo break 4) YYZ 5) and, weirdly “Fly by Night” beautiful example of his melodic capabilities
Although already mentioned, 'Digital Man' is the top one for me.
Geddy was always composed and playing the bass while hitting his vocals perfectly, Alex was walking around putting out more sound than thought possible from a single guitar and Neil was surrounded by the biggest drum kit ever, it was like a massive nest. I didn’t like all Rush songs, but I loved a handful and enjoyed their tour where they opened for The Scorpions.
Favorite Rush bass line?
Impossible to answer, however I still can't play Circumstances and sing at the same time!!!
Great job once again Julia!
Only one to catch that...awesome. seen Geddy rip Circumstances live and he killed it like it was nothing...truly amazing
Spirit of Radio, Subdivisions… Julia, thanks for your take on this pioneer musician who brought such amazing textures to Rush, with that great bass work, AND vocals that were unmatched AND keys… what a talent! And we get to listen to Geddy forever. A thrill.
Favorite Geddy baselines; The Enemy Within, Digital Man, Analog Kid and New World Man to name a few. A good sampling of funky, fast and fun !!!
Those are all amazing!! Couldn't agree with you more
1. Red Lenses
2. Spirit of Radio
3. The Trees
4. Marathon
5. Big Money
The fact that he switched between keyboards and bass while singing the whole time in the middle of a song without missing a beat was just incredible!
I think we are the only two who picked Red Lenses...haha
Hi from Brasil! The instrumental part of "Freewill"... not just the bass: drums and guitar "attack" with EVERYTHING, getting the MOST out of your instruments!
I often watch the concert video of RUSH playing YYZ in a stadium in Brasil. You are obviously fanatical fans of them judging from that video. It's great to watch.
@@charlieross-BRM This live version is amazing! ruclips.net/video/ZiYGR9S0FIU/видео.html
I was in a Guitar Center once and there was a kid playing some Rush lines on a bass he'd picked up. I went up and told him, do not underestimate how hard that right hand is hitting. It's a movement that drives past the string, but catching enough of it to slam strings into frets much of the time. Once you start playing like that, it's hard to play "normal."
"The Big Money" is also one of my favorites to play. The line in the verses of "Turn The Page" is similar but a bit busier; I can't imagine being able to play that and sing the melody at the same time.
I love how when shit gets real, Julia's upper lip gets stiff and then crawls into the Billy Idol style smirk.
Thank you!!! It’s hard to say who was the most talented in that band. All 3 brilliant. Your renditions were flawless and really took me back there. Thank you.
Rush? Instant like :-)
Did the same 🤣🤣🤣
Well done
Heh, same here! ;-)
right!!!
Grande
Nice! Good choice of Rush songs and nicely played, Julia. Thank you.
Nice to see Big Money get some love. Such an underrated song. Digital Man would make my top 5.
Love this huge respect: Geddy's right hand technique is phenomenal. YYZ still challenges me after 40 years of playing.
Surprised Marathon wasn’t on here. That’s a snappy bass line!
Very snappy,.....that was during Geddy's poppin' funk Wal days
@RDog4484 - Yes, 'Marathon' would be in my list also! Lots of fun to play, too! It's also my 15-year-old Son's favourite Rush song, and he had first thought Geddy was actually "slappin' da bass" 😊
Definitely in my top 5
Yeah how does he play and sing that choppy bass line?😳
@@paultringali4099 - Yes, mind-blowing! 😀
One my all time favorites: Marathon
Geddy Lee is such an amazing bassist!
Speaking of Clovkwork Angels, I really like the bass line of "The Garden".
Geddy is the best ever, and I could not possibly love this video more. Well done, Julia! Thank you.
3:35 haha, bass face on! Brilliant!
Ms. Hofer... that was bang-ON!!! (yep, THREE exclamation marks) I'll drop some love in the hat for "The Analog Kid" off of Signals. Great work, as always!
Slappa 'da bass! The first Rush song I ever learned is The Spirit of Radio. I love the groove and walking bass line that's played with the solo. Great list!
Wow! Julia well done. You definitely have the talent to play some of Mr. Lee's best bass lines. Not a small task by any means. I have been a big fan off yours for awhile but now I am a bigger fan. You really nailed Geddy's style and tone. Brava. I think my favorite along with the ones you have already chosen is "Leave that thing alone" It looks to me like Geddy likes playing it as well the way he really digs in with his right hand and uses a flamenco style to play it.
My favorite Rush basslines:
Spirit of Radio
Tom Sawyer
Freewill
2112 (especially Overture and Temples of Syrinx)
Working Man
Holy sh*t Julia, I love the new look! Rush is one of my all time favourite bands. Rock on.
Fly by Night, Closer To The Heart, and Limelight
Cygnus X-1, Prime Mover, Grand Designs, Vital Signs... So many amazing bass lines, tough job to pick one!
You need to check out Tim Starace from the group YYNOT, you may love his playing!!
Tim is awesome!
Tim is the best Rush tribute bassist I've ever seen.
Awesome job Julia, Geddy is often imitated but never duplicated. You my dear are a cut above
3 out of 5 from Moving Pictures. No wonder that's my favorite Rush album --and they have not shortage of great ones.
That was fun! Thanks. Been a fan since I saw them over the New Year's holiday '74-'75 on the Fly By Night tour. And don't feel bad about not playing Big Money with a fingernail. That's a Geddy speciality. He closed a car door on his hand when he was a teenager and injured that finger. The nail on that finger now grows much thicker than his other nails. A natural pick!
Fantastic! You should do Yes bass lines too, Chris Squire was Geddy Lee his big bass inspiration.
I saw Yes live at Madison Square Garden when a kid. It was before I started playing bass but IIRC he was using a pick which I believe contributes a lot to his sound. Here nor there the bass sounded great so I use both fingering and pick if needed for sound. It was easier for me being I also play regular guitar.
John Entwistle also
Chris Squire is probably my favorite bass player.
Agreed!
Yah, Yah, but this is not about Chris Squire.
Geddy is the world leader in playing complex bass lines and singing challenging melodies at the same time. Most of it is done in odd time signatures... even early songs like Anthem... I don't know how he does it.
The bass on Vital signs is a great one to try. You did very well:)
Show Dont Tell is one of the grooviest bass breaks ever!!! Also Power Windows had many great lines. Especially on Grand Designs, Middletown Dreams and Emotion Detector!! Sometimes forgotten because of the heavy keyboards!!
It is hard to choose because there are so many, but one of my favorites is "Vital Signs."
Julia, you suprised me, I think your interpretation is so far the best I've ever heard from Rush. The Big Money - how cool is that?! Amazing!
Please note, Tom Sawyer was from 1981 not 1976. Thank you.
She knows, & apologized in an earlier comment above.
If I had my eyes closed, it would've thought it was Geddy Lee playing this - especially YYZ - well done!
ANYTHING off of Hemispheres would be dope.
YES!
Sweet video, amazing songs, amazing bass playing! Rock on Julia!
Back in studio 🤘🏽😃 what a Rush that must have been, I hope Pineapple isn’t lonely.
Or did you do an awesome renovation of your apartment??
Mmm I’d like to try playing guitar Working Man in that Lewitt booth!
I started playing bass because of Geddy. In addition to this whole list (Red Barchetta is my all time favorite song) I'd say "Leave that thing alone" off Counterparts is pretty cool. The song almost sounds like Lurch didn't showup that day so they just sample tracked guitar and let Geddy do all the work. Fun to play too!
Malignant Narcissism is probably my favorite Rush instrumental, would love to hear you take that bass line on.
I learned them in the early 80s. I even wrote rush like songs. My fav band at the time. I had a 74’ black fender jazz bass and played in a hs rock band. Wild to see all these young people love it just as much!! Cool
I love Big Money. The band made a lot of political jabs and this is one.
Your playing is sublime.
I always wondered how he could sing over that busy bass line. So complicated and he makes it look so easy.
Great playing Julia! I’ve listened to Rush on and off for many years.. their tunes have real staying power.
There's so many but: Alien Shore, Grand Designs, How It Is, Chain Lightning, and The Body Electric, all have underrated bass lines.
Great video, Julia! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
my fav bass line is from "Roll the Bones"
Her facial expressions when she plays are great and you can really tell she enjoys those killer basslines. Well played!
I agree I love her expressions , so honest
My favorite Rush baseline would be Red Lenses.
I love "Limelight" myself. It's my go-to for testing playability on a bass and it usually turns a few heads when you're playing it on a jazz with a some distortion.
Everything off Moving Pictures is killer and is fun to play.