Hello, just a note. Elecgear is just the packager of this product. The stick module brand in this video is Favor Union. These are a quite good hall effect stick modules (different in several areas with the Ginful v5, but both as good as the other) . K-Silver makes TMR stick module replacements for common controllers, like PS5, PS4, Xbox and Nintendo, and they are as good as the Gulikit TMR ones (but the GuliKit product comes with some stick module caps with metal rings, which are quite good minimizing friction and providing a smoother movement of the stick)
Hi, thank you for the information! I agree that the product is a decent one. I like its build quality and the play of the stick which is very similar to the ALPS one. It's interesting to try the K-Silver/GuliKit TMR stick modules!
@@stevensv4864 I don't know if you are asking about stick modules or controllers. I will talk about my preferences and about objective data. My preference is K-Silver modules and Gamesir controllers. I am just used to Gamesir, I have Gamesir G7 SE, several T4 Kaleid, both are 1000Hz Hall Effect modules and Cyclone 2 with TMR modules. My daily main controller is Gamesir T4 Kaleid, at 1000Hz polling rate, it uses K-Silver Hall Effect modules. (I like it notably more over the G7 SE) I have tested Cyclone 2, which for me it feels as good as T4 Kaleid. Objectively Cyclone 2 is better than T4 Kaleid as it has some clear advantages in terms of resolution and quicker response modules than the T4 Kaleid hall effect modules, but T4 Kaleid and its modules are so good that noticing a clear, real use, improvement is difficult. Cyclone 2 has some advantages also in its PC companion app, is more configurable (specifically you can create your own response curve for the sticks), but as I am doing some modifications to my controllers, I have not found the time to do it to the Cyclone 2 to use it as my daily controller. Other objectively good modules and controllers. I also have - Dualsense with Ginful V5 hall effect modules. This combo is very interesting if you play on a PS5, as I have noticed that the PS5 console does some work with the data it receives form the Dualsense controller. It is something that a PS4 Pro or a PC does not do. It operates with the input it receives from the Dualsense controller and makes it smoother. more stable and better to use. I have been offered a Dualsense with TMR modules (both Gulikit and K-SIlver) but have not tried yet. I will in the coming months. - Gulikit TMR module kit for Dualsense: It is very good, the modules are good (as good as the K-Silver ones) but the advantage are the stick caps this kit offers, they are a good addition to the TMR modules, it smoothes notably the performance of the sticks. So the kit is a very good addition to a Dualsense. - Guilikit KK3 Max: It is a very good controller. Hall Effect modules (GuliKit obviously), good ones. I am not using it daily as I am very used to my T4 Kaleid controllers. - FlyDigi Apex 4: It is a very good controller. Hall Effect modules (K-Silver), good ones. I am not using it daily as I am very used to my T4 Kaleid controllers. I am also experimenting with: Alpakka Controller. It is gyro only open source controller. Hall Effect Keyboards. Controllers I am interested in trying. BigBig Won Blitz 2 TMR Beitong Asura 2 Pro Beitong Zeus 2 Horipad for Steam (and its Gyro functions) and some other. In summary: The most fundamental thing a controller must have to be able to play at a high level an FPS game, (I play Apex Legends) is the ability to remove dead zones for the sticks. If a controller is not able to do that, you cannot play fast action aiming games at a high level.
@@InterstellarLord ty for very detailed anws!. But something i dont think its ápex 4 has ksilver hall, i think its self made one. Man im team gamesir also maybe bc i dont have budget for try other brand but g7 se and cyclone 2 are awesome, my g7 se has 1 year + and everything fine and i dont keep cyclone 2 bc It doesnt fit so good in my hands, im selling It and Will wait g7 pro for buyingit
@@stevensv4864 You are rigjt, Apex 4 has those custom, tension-adjustable stick modules. I forgot because Vader 3 Pro has K- Silver ones. Cyclone 2 is of the very top controllers right now, I think you could give it another opportunity.
1本目の動画から拝見させていただいてましたが、まさかここまでコントローラーマニアな動画になっていくとは、、、注目しておいて良かったです！ これからも更新楽しみにしております。 くれぐれも無理のないペースでお願いします！
ありがとうございます！
私も楽しめる範囲でアップしていきますので、引き続きよろしくお願いします！！笑
お疲れ様です！
難しい内容だけど、わかりやすいしめっっっちゃためになる！！
今後メーカーがここに焦点を当ててくれると熱いですね。
ありがとうございます！
ほんとにそうですねー！！
デフォルトでは低感度でも良いので設定でリニア化できると熱いと思います。
前回の動画でもコメントしましたが、ホールエフェクト最大の売りであるドリフトの低減を感じさせるためにわざと低感度なカーブにしていると思っていましたがある意味では仕様なんですね！
ただし、ユーザー目線でいえば操作性のための一手間はほしいなという印象でしたが、、、。
少なくともソフト側で設定できるカーブは本来のリニアの操作性を再現できるプリセットなどは全機種標準装備で入れておいてほしいですね！
全くもってそのとおりだと思います！
リニアじゃないのは仕方ないので、リニアにするプリセットが欲しいですね。
一番良い解決方法だと思うので、メーカーさんには検討して欲しいです！！
初めてコメントいたします。
ホールエフェクトについて大変分かりやすい解説でした！
非常に勉強になりました。
コメントありがとうございます！
良かったです！！
ただのコントローラーマニアかと思ったらただの天才か
ただのコントローラーマニアが頑張った甲斐がありました、ありがとうございます笑
Hello, just a note.
Elecgear is just the packager of this product.
The stick module brand in this video is Favor Union. These are a quite good hall effect stick modules (different in several areas with the Ginful v5, but both as good as the other) .
K-Silver makes TMR stick module replacements for common controllers, like PS5, PS4, Xbox and Nintendo, and they are as good as the Gulikit TMR ones (but the GuliKit product comes with some stick module caps with metal rings, which are quite good minimizing friction and providing a smoother movement of the stick)
Hi, thank you for the information!
I agree that the product is a decent one.
I like its build quality and the play of the stick which is very similar to the ALPS one.
It's interesting to try the K-Silver/GuliKit TMR stick modules!
hey inter wich are the best tmr and hall u have tried?
@@stevensv4864 I don't know if you are asking about stick modules or controllers. I will talk about my preferences and about objective data.
My preference is K-Silver modules and Gamesir controllers. I am just used to Gamesir, I have Gamesir G7 SE, several T4 Kaleid, both are 1000Hz Hall Effect modules and Cyclone 2 with TMR modules.
My daily main controller is Gamesir T4 Kaleid, at 1000Hz polling rate, it uses K-Silver Hall Effect modules. (I like it notably more over the G7 SE)
I have tested Cyclone 2, which for me it feels as good as T4 Kaleid. Objectively Cyclone 2 is better than T4 Kaleid as it has some clear advantages in terms of resolution and quicker response modules than the T4 Kaleid hall effect modules, but T4 Kaleid and its modules are so good that noticing a clear, real use, improvement is difficult. Cyclone 2 has some advantages also in its PC companion app, is more configurable (specifically you can create your own response curve for the sticks), but as I am doing some modifications to my controllers, I have not found the time to do it to the Cyclone 2 to use it as my daily controller.
Other objectively good modules and controllers. I also have
- Dualsense with Ginful V5 hall effect modules. This combo is very interesting if you play on a PS5, as I have noticed that the PS5 console does some work with the data it receives form the Dualsense controller. It is something that a PS4 Pro or a PC does not do. It operates with the input it receives from the Dualsense controller and makes it smoother. more stable and better to use. I have been offered a Dualsense with TMR modules (both Gulikit and K-SIlver) but have not tried yet. I will in the coming months.
- Gulikit TMR module kit for Dualsense: It is very good, the modules are good (as good as the K-Silver ones) but the advantage are the stick caps this kit offers, they are a good addition to the TMR modules, it smoothes notably the performance of the sticks. So the kit is a very good addition to a Dualsense.
- Guilikit KK3 Max: It is a very good controller. Hall Effect modules (GuliKit obviously), good ones. I am not using it daily as I am very used to my T4 Kaleid controllers.
- FlyDigi Apex 4: It is a very good controller. Hall Effect modules (K-Silver), good ones. I am not using it daily as I am very used to my T4 Kaleid controllers.
I am also experimenting with:
Alpakka Controller. It is gyro only open source controller.
Hall Effect Keyboards.
Controllers I am interested in trying.
BigBig Won Blitz 2 TMR
Beitong Asura 2 Pro
Beitong Zeus 2
Horipad for Steam (and its Gyro functions)
and some other.
In summary: The most fundamental thing a controller must have to be able to play at a high level an FPS game, (I play Apex Legends) is the ability to remove dead zones for the sticks. If a controller is not able to do that, you cannot play fast action aiming games at a high level.
@@InterstellarLord ty for very detailed anws!. But something i dont think its ápex 4 has ksilver hall, i think its self made one. Man im team gamesir also maybe bc i dont have budget for try other brand but g7 se and cyclone 2 are awesome, my g7 se has 1 year + and everything fine and i dont keep cyclone 2 bc It doesnt fit so good in my hands, im selling It and Will wait g7 pro for buyingit
@@stevensv4864 You are rigjt, Apex 4 has those custom, tension-adjustable stick modules. I forgot because Vader 3 Pro has K- Silver ones.
Cyclone 2 is of the very top controllers right now, I think you could give it another opportunity.