Does it deserve the hype? | Glen Scotia Victoriana 54.2%

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
  • I'm doing a rereview of a single malt scotch whisky from the Glen Scotia distillery in Campbeltown today. This is the cask strength Victoriana. It's recently won quite a prestigious award, so I figured now is a good time to look at it again. I'll taste it and give you my thoughts. Cheers!
    Link to the OSWA website: www.oswa.co.uk/
    Link to the 2022 OSWA Awars: • The Online Scotch Whis...
    Support through Patreon: / gwhisky
    Support through PayPal: gwhiskytw@gmail.com
    IG: @gwhiskytw
    Business/Contact info: gwhiskytw@gmail.com
    Scores:
    0-75 - Crap
    75-79 - For cocktails & people you don't like
    80-82 - Not bad
    83-85 - Getting good here
    86-89 - Delicious
    90-94 - Awesome
    95-100 - Cowabunga Dudes
    Music: freemusicarchi...

Комментарии • 146

  • @zhartaunik
    @zhartaunik 4 месяца назад +1

    Yesterday, I was offered a bottle of whiskey to buy. I had previously tasted some cheaper versions of Glen Scotia, so I was a bit hesitant to pay around $100 for a bottle without an age statement. The only reassuring factor was its cask strength (or something close to it). At least it wasn't 43% or even 46%. However, when I got home and tasted it, I was extremely surprised. The flavor is absolutely awesome-full-bodied, sweet, but not overly so. I am extremely happy with the purchase.

  • @ItalNico
    @ItalNico Год назад +4

    Great review. I picked up a bottle of the 54.2% almost a year ago and had a few drams which I enjoyed but hadn't touched it in a good 6-7 months. I had one last night side by side with a Kilkerran 12 and have to say the GSV was the winner hands down. Now that my palate has expanded from drinking a lot of CS and IB whisky I have a lot more appreciation for what this malt brings to the table. The sherry and bourbon influence and how they work so well together is remarkable and this is quite a damn good malt for the price. I was a bit surprised that it won whisky of the year (Ledaig 18 was my choice) but it is available and affordable so I was happy with the results. It's also a good reminder not to turn our noses up to NAS whiskies - there are some good ones out there that shouldn't be ignored in my opinion.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      Well said! It really is special stuff. Btw... your choice for whisky of the year is 💯. 😉

  • @shawndaly8450
    @shawndaly8450 7 месяцев назад

    Just picked one up for 100$, I love campbeltown whisky’s! Can’t wait to crack this one. Good work, cheers

  • @carlmartinlinder
    @carlmartinlinder Год назад +4

    For me, #1 Victoriana 54,2%. #2 51,5% #3 15-year #4 18-y #5 Double Cask (not mentioning the special or festival releases or Single Casks)

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      Yeah that's fair. Seems a lot of people have different takes on this line. 🥃

  • @Koby616
    @Koby616 4 месяца назад

    Just about to pick up my 1st victoriana tomorrow 😊 thanks for the review ❤

  • @WhiskyLoversSociety
    @WhiskyLoversSociety Год назад +2

    Was sad that they did not win last year..... Redemption Love this one. Great review.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Yeah it's well deserved! 🥃

  • @80Tamiya
    @80Tamiya Год назад +1

    thx again for the review Geoff. I get flavours and an experience from this that I do not get from anything else in the whisky world. It is special stuff 👌

  • @buffdogg
    @buffdogg Год назад

    I got a bottle of this and after the first dram went back and bought every bottle I could. One of if not the best Scotch I've ever had.

  • @allanwhittle3041
    @allanwhittle3041 Год назад +2

    Usual great review Mr G
    All the usual range Glen Scotia’s are worth a try , except I don’t care for the strange bottlings in Bordeaux casks etc
    But I’ll say it again 🤣IMO The Duty free 16 year old Ltr is the pick of the bunch

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Hah I still haven't picked it up. Seems like special stuff. Don't worry, I haven't forgotten! 🥃

    • @allanwhittle3041
      @allanwhittle3041 Год назад +2

      @@Gwhisky The question ...Is Victoriana worth the hype ?...Much as its def good , No.....I personally don't think it is worth the hype or the award , again , broken record but i prefer the 16 (also to the 15 and 18 ) and in all honesty ( i know you don't agree on this view ) i reckon the Double Cask is shockingly good value and a less challenging , i agree with the guy who still has a half full bott of Vic , i just hardly ever , wait for it ....Reach for it !!!( i do love that phrase it tells you all ya need to know about what ya really really like !!)

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      @@allanwhittle3041 Hah that's fair. For a whisky that I scored 88, I can't say I reach for it too often myself. "Reachability" is a big thing! 🥃

  • @paulkukiel3725
    @paulkukiel3725 Год назад +1

    Great review, Geoff. Certainly one of my favourites I’ve sampled over this past year.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      Cheers Paul! 🥃

  • @gareth630
    @gareth630 Год назад +1

    I voted for this last year haha. Love the stuff and a regular in the stash, got a bottle of the peated 8 yr Campletown festival release this year and it was a belter.
    Top stuff mate 🙂

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      That 8 year old is excellent! Cheers Gareth! 🥃

  • @welshtoro3256
    @welshtoro3256 Год назад +12

    I don't wish to be critical of the OSWAS (I voted) but, I have to say, I don't think it's everything it's cracked out to be. Too many categories had highly predictable nominations and it was really like an online community echo chamber. I really appreciate the effort of Roy and Ralfy but I think the format needs to change if it's going to keep me interested next year. Springbank, for example, will win best distillery next year and in perpetuity. They aren't necessarily the best distillery at all but the ludicrous and uncritical hype that surrounds them, amplified by short supply, make it a certainty. Deanston had a couple of nominations too - Deanston! Arran 10 was also utterly predictable. Ditto: If Victoriana is the best whisky out there the moon is made of cheese.
    It could be me of course. I think I'm moving further and further away from mainstream opinion about whisky matters. I first tried Victoriana at a Tasting a number of years ago. I think it had just launched. It was okay but I wasn't that impressed. To this day I'm still irritated that it doesn't have an age statement. We have a right to know what we're paying for when a bottle costs £75. It was all part of the NAS craze which was designed to sell us younger whisky for old prices. "It's what's in the bottle that matters" - Yeah. I do think I need to give this another go and it's been kind of on my radar for a while. The 18 has increased in price and costs more than £100 now so that's probably a thing of the past.
    Cheers Geoff. Great review as always. WT

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +6

      Don't take this the wrong way, WT, but I think you're being a bit cynical here. By nature the OSWAs are going to drift towards the centre of what most whisky lovers appreciate-such is the nature of a democratic voting system. If you're there looking for obscure or non-mainstream whiskies then of course it's not going to deliver. No reason we can't celebrate the whiskies that are high quality, widely available, and well presented.
      My first experience with the Victoriana wasn't a very positive one, either. I've had two bottles since and I thoroughly enjoy it now. No guarantees that that'll be the case for you, but I think it warrants a revisit. Agree that a stated age would be nice. Cheers buddy. 🥃

    • @welshtoro3256
      @welshtoro3256 Год назад +8

      @@Gwhisky I appreciate that I do come off a bit cynical in that comment and I was aware of that when I posted. I really don't want to be but there's a lot to be cynical about. 18 year old whisky is becoming more and more expensive and increasingly hard to justify. We've had conversations about 12 year old whisky being overpriced. I'm finding it harder and harder to keep a cool head when there is so much BS coming from the corporate ownership of distilleries these days. Most of my interest is coming from Independent bottles now. Those single cask bottles are far easier to find than anything from Springbank distillery. I love Springbank but they can hardly be called a people's distillery when people can't buy it. They are not available and I don't think they should be on the OSWAs list until they are. Cynicism to one side, I do enjoy the OSWAs but I think there's room for improvement as it develops and I'm sure that will be the case.

    • @andrewbutler7681
      @andrewbutler7681 Год назад +2

      You're not the only cynical one: I did vote again this year, but didn't bother watching the results 'show'. Having now looked up the winners, I'm not surprised, but I'm becoming more and more convinced that I am not part of the target audience...

    • @marclambert8596
      @marclambert8596 Год назад +4

      I agree with most of ur frustration and def wld like to see them do smthg about repeat winners. I think the Ralfy & Roy “integrity” movement is important but at the same time I am getting very tired of the preaching to the choir and the self-justifying statistical analysis. If that continues much longer I will start to tune out but am hoping everyone just leaves the preaching to lower than rant levels and rewards the integrity bottlings with positive reviews instead of focusing on the releases that lack said integrity.

    • @maltontiger3144
      @maltontiger3144 Год назад +3

      Interesting thoughts. I think for the most Roy and Ralfy have done an amazing job and you will never please everyone. I think potentially opening up the categories to 10 or 12 optioms might please more people. It was very predictable that Arran 10 won again which makes it seem like its in a league of its own winning two years running. I would have take any of the other options over the Arran 10 to be honest.

  • @Balkonwhisky
    @Balkonwhisky Год назад +1

    Nice Video from you, again.
    I like Glen Scotia very much, especially their Peated Expressions.
    Sad that the 10yo Peated is discontinued, it was really good Stuff for the Fair Price.
    Thanks for Sharing your Opinion.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching! Have you tried the latest peated 8 year old? Really good! 🥃

    • @Balkonwhisky
      @Balkonwhisky Год назад

      @@Gwhisky Not yet. Its still closed in my "to Open" Area.😅
      His/Her/Its (🤣😂) Time will come 🤗

  • @Nikolay_Nikolov
    @Nikolay_Nikolov Год назад +2

    Hey, Geoff! Perfect timing with the review😀
    My vote at the OSWAs went for the AnCnoc 18 and for people's choice I picked Port Charlotte 10. Still, I don't mind Voctoriana winning as I love Glen Scotia. Also, its sister distillery Loch Lomond goes steadily up and up in by book too.
    Unfortunately Glen Scotia is overpriced in Bulgaria, but I managed to buy a couple of bottles of Victoriana in 2021 on special sale at roughly 55 euros. I'd very much like to try the 18 yo, but man that price... around 128 euros. Glen Scotia is imported in Bulgaria by the same company that imports Laphroaig and Kavalan and all these brands are blatantly overpiced here. Coincidence? I doubt it...
    I'm looking forward for that review of the 8 yo festival bottle. I got a bottle not long ago for ~69 euros. Tough price, but I just couldn't resist.
    Cheers!

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      The AnCnoc and PC10 are solid picks! Yeah I was a bit surprised when Victoriana took it. Shows what I know. I was happy to see it myself. Wouldn't have been my pick but it absolutely makes sense. It's beautiful stuff, not too pricey, and seriously unique. These whisky people know what they're talking about!
      The Loch Lomond is a brand I'm slowly getting into. I've got the 18, tried the 12, and I'll be trying "The Open" soon. It's interesting stuff and very well priced!
      The 8 year old Scotia is good. I'll be reviewing it in the next couple weeks if all goes to plan. Cheers buddy! 🥃

  • @lightplays2181
    @lightplays2181 Год назад +1

    Hi Geoff ! It' super , today morning Georgian whisky clubs member made rewiev in this whisky and give him high point and said Victoriana best then 12 y.o.Glen Scotia .

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Wow! Yeah it's a really good one. Glad you guys enjoyed it! 🥃

    • @lightplays2181
      @lightplays2181 Год назад +1

      @@Gwhisky Cheers !

  • @PezrulezHaakon
    @PezrulezHaakon Год назад +1

    One of my absolute favourite non peated whisky 😋

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      It's fantastic! 🥃

  • @Dan-hn1lx
    @Dan-hn1lx Год назад

    This is one of my favorites!!! Glen Scotia hits the spot

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      It's excellent! 🥃

  • @cliffnorman178
    @cliffnorman178 Год назад +2

    Thanks very much for your review. It was great. However I personally believe that this version of Victoriana deserves at least a score of 90/91.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Totally fair! 🥃

  • @thewhiskyenthusiast
    @thewhiskyenthusiast Год назад

    Always a fan of the Victoriana!

  • @Du57yx91630n5
    @Du57yx91630n5 Год назад +1

    so far the 51.5% Victoriana has been my only Glen Scotia. it's been open since January of last year and it has been temperamental a couple of times even when pouring it as seldom as I do. one time it even gave me a scare because tasted like it had corked, but bounced back a few weeks later. I have no doubt that this bottle didnt instantly become $150 retail when the award was announced and in that regard I dont appreciate awards because it only highlights something with genuinely intrinsic value as "in demand" aka kiss it goodbye. The tasting notes for me have been very consistent over time; rich cheesecake on slightly charred Graham cracker crust topped with a fresh fruit salad(my first taste literally made me visualize strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, apple and kiwi adorned atop a cheesecake). I fall in love with Victoriana everytime. I dont hate the new packaging which is a pleasant surprise to me.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Love those tasting notes. And I do think there was a difference between the older batches and the newer ones. I don't get quite as much of a cheese note in these newer ones, although some people still seem to pick up on it. And yes, the new packaging is actually pretty nice! 🥃

    • @Du57yx91630n5
      @Du57yx91630n5 Год назад

      @@Gwhisky So far my experience with Campbeltown is only the Victoriana, Springbank 15, Kilkerran 12 and Kilkerran Peat in Progress Batch 5. Victoriana is the cheesiest of those with Kilkerran PiP really being the only other one that has the lactic richness I associate with cheese and it's way more like a custard or creme brulee compared to Vic.
      In reference to the newer batches; I've noticed less of a focus on "the funk" aspect when looking at reviews of Campbeltown releases as of late in general. Do you think maybe they are neutering new whisky to be more "consumer friendly"? It would be a damn shame if they were and totally negating the desire to seek for them as it should be their calling card in my opinion.

    • @Du57yx91630n5
      @Du57yx91630n5 Год назад

      I poured my KK12 to double check and it does have a bit of coconut cream pie with a dusting of lemon zest thing about it between the nose and palate. So I suppose SB15 is the least of the bunch under all that sherry and smoke.

  • @maltontiger3144
    @maltontiger3144 Год назад +1

    Great timing ! I have to admit I've found this bottle.. challenging Admittedly it's the 51.5% bottle I've got but it's been sat in my Italian collection for 18 months and I still have half a bottle left. I was slightly perplexed how it won at the OSWAs with all the great competition in that category. Maybe I've got a bad batch! Generally I love Glen Scotia and particularly the 15 and 18. Cheers Geoff

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      There might be batch issues. I didn't like my first bottle at all, and I believe that was the 51.5% release. Or it might simply be a matter of taste. Agree on the 18... probably my favourite affordable offering from their line. Cheers Ramiz! 🥃

    • @bbdj2779
      @bbdj2779 Год назад

      I must have a bottle from the same batch. My partially finished bottle has been getting dusty the back of the shelf. Many better offerings out there.

  • @beatroot_red
    @beatroot_red Год назад

    Great whisky at an affordable price and an absolute staple. I love the funk and the chees-like notes in there. A Glen Scotia was one of my first bottles I bought and I have been a bit of a fan boy ever since.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      High praise... but deserved! 🥃

  • @peathead4450
    @peathead4450 Год назад

    Honest review Geoff. Thanks.
    'Nough said.
    Slàinte mhath

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Hah cheers Peathead. As always, thanks for watching! 🥃

  • @alehhandro1
    @alehhandro1 Год назад +1

    I haven’t tried Victoriana, never seen it in the liquor stores in the area where I live now and lived before I moved. I have experienced the Double Oak, the 15 and 25 year olds (didn’t have to pay for the 25 y.o., god bless friends!). I do like all of them but to my taste I think the Double Oak is the best value for money.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Not my favourite, but it's good and affordable. Really solid bang-for-buck! 🥃

  • @sambrewster8556
    @sambrewster8556 Год назад

    Had a bottle of this for some time. It's not one that I've raced through but I agree that it keeps getting better as the bottle goes down.
    For me there are big tropical notes up front and then those undercurrents of tobacco and leather. A product of the combination of ages in the bottle I suspect.
    Definitely one that has taken a while to get to grips with but a quality product.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      I had to get to know it myself. Didn't enjoy pretty much the entirety of my first bottle! 🥃

  • @trapperkcmo3460
    @trapperkcmo3460 Год назад +1

    ive had adjectivy stuff before. its good, i'll grant ya.

  • @garycooper3363
    @garycooper3363 Год назад

    Thanks for the review. First tried Victoriana 2020 and instantly enjoyed it for basically the same reasons you do. I do think that initial bottle was slightly better than the most current version but that’s subjective as my taste has evolved or certainly changed over time. Still highly rated, however that first bottle was £55 whereas the last was £73 so it’s periscope up like everything else these days! Also bought the double rum finish NAS bottling and really enjoying that although it’s not cask strength, but a respectable 46 abv at under £50.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      I'd never heard of that rum finished bottling. Just looked it up. Could be good! And yes, the price of this seems to have gone up here as well, along with the price of everything else. Cheers Gary. 🥃

    • @garycooper3363
      @garycooper3363 Год назад

      @@Gwhisky cheers mate. 🥃🥃

  • @WhiskyLock
    @WhiskyLock Год назад

    Great review and observations. While I do think that Victoriana received slightly more praise than it deserves at the OSWAs, it's still a solid offering. And I do prefer it to the 18. Cheers 🥃

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Wasn't what I voted for, but like you I think it's good stuff. The people have spoken! 🥃

  • @henrieliot8740
    @henrieliot8740 Год назад

    Tried this one and GS 18. Prefer 18yo as well. Once again personal preference. I would love to see natural colour Glen Scotia 15yo. I believe they add E150.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Yeah Glen Scotia is inconsistent with specs. I'd love to see them go 100% natural on all their products. 🥃

  • @jarrettmcgregor1001
    @jarrettmcgregor1001 Год назад

    I need to buy a bottle of this quick smart. I've drunken 3 bottles.of this however 3 or 4 years ago. Was my favorite whisky then, I'm sure it will be again.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      It's still good stuff, I'm sure you'll still love it. Cheers Jarrett! 🥃

  • @mahmoudali1848
    @mahmoudali1848 Год назад

    I'm torn about whether to get a bottle of the Victoriana and the comments here doesn't help. In my market it costs all of C$130 while the Kilkerran 12 is C$100. I'm not sure I want tl pay the premium for an "award winner" whisky. These days I've been trying to aquire unusual malts and have been successful in finding independent bottlings of Auchroisk, Fettercairn, Blair Athol, Mannochmore, and blends like Orchard House that contain Clynelish, Linkwood, and Benrinnes. Just the other day I found a cask strength Glenlossie for C$82 and am seriously thinking of getting a second bottle of it instead of a Victoriana which costs an extra C$50.
    In any case I enjoyed your video and also the OSWA. If anything it spurred me on to buying my first ever bourbon, the Wild Turkey Rare Breed, of course the fact that it was on sale for C$50 played no small role.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      That's pretty pricey for Victoriana. Personally I like the Kilkerran 12 more. 🥃

  • @furuyashinichi3211
    @furuyashinichi3211 Год назад +1

    こんなにウイスキーを飲みたくなる動画もない!^_^
    ウイスキーを買ってしまうのは問題だがw

  • @tombryan1
    @tombryan1 Год назад

    Interesting take on it. I have to look into this Distillery. I know you are a fan of Edradour, have you tried the 22 year Oloroso high proof red canister? Superb. I think it's right in your lane.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Oof. The older ones tend to be a bit out of my budget. Sounds fantastic, though! 🥃

  • @ConnahJay
    @ConnahJay Год назад

    I have a bottle of SpringBank 12 100% ex-bourbon and I prefer my bottle of Victoriana 54.2%

  • @MrChristopherMolloy
    @MrChristopherMolloy Год назад

    Dollar for dollar, I think Victoriana is the very best whisky being bottled in Scotland today, and that's at any age or at any price.
    It's at the pinnacle of my high-value whiskies in 2022; a group which also includes Craigellachie 13, Port Charlotte 10, Glenmorangie 14, and Laphroaig 10 CS.
    Or if I was on a very tight budget and still wanted a solid cross section of Scotch profiles: Loch Lomond 12 (complex), Glencadam 10 (standard), Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair (Sherried), and Ardbeg 5 (peated).

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Can't argue with that. You like it more than I do, but it's definitely a standout when it comes to flavour and value. Damn good stuff.

    • @MrChristopherMolloy
      @MrChristopherMolloy Год назад

      @@Gwhisky Do you have an opinion on the best Scotch being bottled today?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      @@MrChristopherMolloy The BEST? Man I wouldn't even know where to start!

    • @MrChristopherMolloy
      @MrChristopherMolloy Год назад

      @@Gwhisky ...and there's a new video. 😉

  • @peterc3822
    @peterc3822 Год назад

    Malt activist made a good point about potentially people associating Victoriana with the 51.5% bottling and not the 54.2% bottling potentially. He also felt the 54.2% was not as good.
    I haven't tried it but I have a 54.8% Batch 001 on the way to see how that compares also. Cheers!

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      Yeah I saw his videos on the the modern version and the mini he had of the older one. While I like the newer one more than he does, he and I both seem to agree that the older lower-abv stuff was better. I don't know much about the 54.8% version, but I'm sure it's delicious. Most of my bottles of Victoriana have been good. Cheers! 🥃

  • @yoursinsincerely39
    @yoursinsincerely39 Год назад +1

    You hypester you...
    Definitely top of the GS range for me. 18 comes a close second. I was extremely underwhelmed by their "award winning" 25. It was a disappointment.
    The Victoriana shines as a unique dram. I suspect they have vatted some older whiskies in here. I get the lovely, dry tannic note that we can associate with older maturation. So yes, very "adjective-y". Ha!
    Haven't had their peated 8 PX cask. On my radar.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Agree! I haven't reviewed the 8 yet but I've got it on the go and it's fantastic. Its actually quite close the Victoriana in a lot of ways, but with a nice peaty kick and some sherry notes. The PX doesn't overwhelm and it isn't too sweet. You might enjoy it! 🥃

  • @sidberns1373
    @sidberns1373 Год назад +1

    Just catching up that this won, can’t believe it, the bottle I had I ended up tipping the last bit down the sink. Wanted to like it after all the hype but it was just rough and unpleasant.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      A few people have reacted negatively to this one. I felt similarly about my first bottle. Not sure if it's a batch thing or a taste thing, but hey it won't be for everyone. Cheers Sid. 🥃

    • @nohandle257
      @nohandle257 Год назад

      Add more water.

    • @bbdj2779
      @bbdj2779 Год назад +1

      I felt exactly the same as you. I enjoy almost all of my whisky at CS, and rarely have trouble with a “challenging whisky”. It took consuming 2/3 of this bottle, and sitting on the shelf for well over a year before it became tamed enough to be drinkable without drowning it in water. It was an inferno of heat on the back of the throat. One of the most unpleasant CS whisky experiences I’ve had. Not surprised to hear that some had dumped it. I nearly did. Buyers regret with this one.

  • @allenbt11
    @allenbt11 Год назад +1

    In my market the Glen Scotia 15 YO (Bourbon w/ an Oloroso Finish) is significantly cheaper. I realize you are giving up some proof (51-56% v. 46%) and the 15 YO is a finish, v. the Victoriana's Ex-Bourbon & PX Sherry matured blend, but head to head what's your preference?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      I much prefer the Victoriana. I have never really connected with the 15 in the way a lot of other seem to. Solid, but definitely not my favourite from the line. Cheers Allen! 🥃

  • @b.benjamineriksson6030
    @b.benjamineriksson6030 Год назад

    Should I buy the Victoriana or the Glen Scotia Single Malt Festival Edition 2023?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      I've not tried the 2023 release, so unfortunately I can't comment. 🥃

  • @jackhammer8439
    @jackhammer8439 Год назад

    Gosh. Got my bu-annual scotch shipment in today. Including the Victoriana.
    I don’t really even know what to say. So much going on with it. I can see myself growing to love it but almost too much to digest in one sitting. It’s so bizarre and interesting. Which in and of itself I love.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      It's one that usually opens up and gets better as the bottle sits. Cheers! 🥃

    • @jackhammer8439
      @jackhammer8439 Год назад

      @@Gwhiskyoh yeah I can see me liking this one more and more as the bottle goes down and I have time to unpack it. Thanks for the suggestion!

  • @martywong822
    @martywong822 Год назад +1

    I understand all the uniqueness that you are talking about, but about the mustiness and some leather note, those are quite challenging. I leave my half bottle on the shelf untouched for half a year and see if my taste may change to appreciate it again in the future. For now, not connected with this one.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      That's fair. Just because it's popular doesn't mean it's for everyone. 🥃

  • @heartbroken522
    @heartbroken522 Год назад

    It already got an award😂

  • @annamcmahan6993
    @annamcmahan6993 Год назад

    I don't regret buying it, but probably will opt for something else next time. There's a LOT of alcohol in the nose, albeit it got better after breathing a while. It is spicy and interesting, but... price range, one could buy other whisky and bourbon that can offer more.
    UPDATE: After a couple days of breathing it became better. Water makes the alcohol feels stronger and the aroma thinner, so I'd take it straight.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Mine took a while to open up as well. It was at its best after well over a month of being popped. Glad to hear you're starting to warm up to it. Cheers Anna! 🥃

  • @jeffmill999
    @jeffmill999 Год назад

    Grabbed the older 51.5% for $59us..no tax last one on shelf...give it a try...Clynelish 14 for $39us no shit...last one and the elusive Glenfarclas 15.. 46%.....next store tomorrow..
    Johnny has unicorns...

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      Great whiskies at great prices. Johnny's the man! 🥃

  • @heartbroken522
    @heartbroken522 Год назад

    Geln Scotia 15 n Victoriana 51.5% old version both have a warm glue water note which I don't like, never get another GS since…

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Sorry to hear you don't like it.

  • @scnullois
    @scnullois Год назад +1

    LOL bro, are you experimenting with a new editing technique? It is weird. Please go back to previous with no talk-overs! Otherwise a good review. I have a 2020 bottling and it is just from memory but I am going to revisit it soon because of you

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Just trying to tighten up the videos with less and make them more concise. I think your 2020 should be the 54.2% strength. Either way you can't go wrong with this one, newer or older. Cheers.

  • @xiamengbaby
    @xiamengbaby Год назад

    How much are people paying for this to decide if it's a good value? It's $100 (US) or more by me.

  • @DonnerPassWhisky
    @DonnerPassWhisky Год назад

    Got one of these a year or more ago. It's good but didn't really connect with it. Kind of reminds me of what Laphroig has done with Lore. An engineered Whisky made with different age casks. Cheers

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      I find that to be the case with the 15, but not this one. Cheers Tim! 🥃

  • @EuropaWill
    @EuropaWill Год назад

    Nice review G. I have this on order since I'm curious what the hubbub is all about. Does it taste any less or more mature than the 15? How would you compare the Victoriana with the Loch Lomond 18?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      It tastes about as mature as the 15. The Victoriana isn't quite as "dirty" as the Loch Lomond 18, but it's got a bit more weight and texture. Very different whiskies and both extremely unique. 🥃

  • @aframs-cctaf-rams-cct6424
    @aframs-cctaf-rams-cct6424 Год назад +1

    Gummy bear finish

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Hah I'll check for that. 🥃

  • @rafaelnardiiii
    @rafaelnardiiii Год назад

    Didn’t you get any of the PX casks used in this whisky?

  • @saevar69
    @saevar69 Год назад

    got my bottle ...for christmas

  • @hanggo24
    @hanggo24 Год назад

    Did oswa pick up the 51.5% version not this bottling (54.2)?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      No the 54.2% bottle won it.

  • @vimalrajkappil
    @vimalrajkappil Год назад

    How's glen scotia campbeltown 1832 ??

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Haven't had it. I hear it's good.

  • @jeffmill999
    @jeffmill999 Год назад +1

    Going on a whisky safari tomorrow...turns out my hotel is one block from the store that has Victoriana...I wanted to tell you I was killing a Deanston 12 the other night and I got your soapy note...laughed my balls off... 2023...whisky..not women...

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Hah so I'm not crazy! It's there! 🥃

    • @jeffmill999
      @jeffmill999 Год назад

      @@Gwhisky i found it 2 times..not a bad dish soap...go buy more...

  • @catnapgee5357
    @catnapgee5357 Год назад

    I personally think Glen Scotia 15 is much better

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Fair enough! 🥃

  • @tomtomtommyism
    @tomtomtommyism Год назад +1

    ah ah, when I saw the title I thought "88" ... that's what I reckon it'll be / what I would score...bingo 😀!
    "Macerated strawberries with balsamic vinegar and pepper" would be my pretentious tasting notes 😉

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      Hah love those tasting notes! Glad to hear we're on the same page. Great minds or something... 🥃🥃🥃

    • @tomtomtommyism
      @tomtomtommyism Год назад +2

      @@Gwhisky great video as usual, will catch up with everything at some point!
      suggestion : a google spreadsheet doc with your whiskies/score/ link to the videos ?

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +1

      @@tomtomtommyism Yeah but my scores are always changing. It's a good idea and you're not the first to ask for it....

    • @tomtomtommyism
      @tomtomtommyism Год назад +1

      @@Gwhisky you could put a "original score" and "update/mind changed" columns

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад +2

      @@tomtomtommyism I'd definitely need an "updated score" category. 🥃

  • @nohandle257
    @nohandle257 Год назад

    Brand new to your channel. Subscribed. Really enjoy the obvious honesty and humor. Which does not really go with your ... shall we say 'antiseptic' presentation. Sorry. Too white, to minimalistic and if I had just looked and not actually stopped and listened ... I would have passed. That said, I believe you. There's no 'flannel' here. Straight forward and to the point. And most of all I appreciate your pace, though still a bit frantic for me is still much more subdued compared to some of your compatriots who literally make me want to click off inside of 20 seconds. I'll be back.

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      Well I appreciate your bluntness. As it happens, I'm in the midst of planning out a new set with new equipment. With any luck the channel will have a more professional look within the coming few weeks. Welcome to the channel, Reed! Glad you're enjoying the content. 🥃

    • @nohandle257
      @nohandle257 Год назад

      @@Gwhisky Oh Good. Somewhere between First Phil and ralfy I hope. 😁 First Phil must be a professional video editor. I can't imagine how much time and effort he puts into his videos. Doubt his efforts could possibly have a big cost/benefit ratio to the positive. 🤔 ralfy on the other hand ....

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  Год назад

      @@nohandle257 Hah yeah Phil's a video guy. And you're right his edits are amazing. My setup will likely just be a few shelves in the background and some slicker lighting. Also, you might have noticed my 4k resolution doesn't actually look 4k. All of that will be fixed soon (hopefully). Cheers.

  • @markanderson8677
    @markanderson8677 11 месяцев назад

    88 is to low . . . 94

    • @Gwhisky
      @Gwhisky  11 месяцев назад

      Generous, but glad you're loving it! 🥃

  • @daveandrews5485
    @daveandrews5485 Год назад +1

    I voted, but not for this. Too adjectivey!

  • @bbdj2779
    @bbdj2779 Год назад

    Overhyped whisky of the year.